9 ms·
OpenTable Fires Employee for Making Fake Reserve Bookings
- dev_throw 9y agoSeeing this from another perspective, shouldn't Reserve's engineering team have been able to pre-empt this kind of attack? If they could do a postmortem and determine the requests came from a single range of IP's (assumption), they could have foreseen it. Or if they had set up alerting around frequency of reservations, they would seen an outsized number of requests which they could further look into. These are pretty easy to set up, so I'm surprised they're so naïve about this kind of vector.
- shaki-dora 9y agoHN should really stop meddling with headlines until they find people who don’t replace “reservations” with “reserve bookings”.
- danso 9y agoFWIW I submitted it under the original title, "OpenTable Infuriates Restaurants With Fake Reservations Scheme", but I'm guessing it was changed to clarify that in the article, blame has so far only been assigned to an individual employee, and only the company Reserve was targeted.
- notsofastbuddy 9y agoSeems fine to me when "Reserve" is, as in this case, a proper noun.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoReally? Reservations is what EVERYBODY calls it. I've made thousands of reservations in my life. I had no clue what a "reserve bookings" is. You can figure it out from context... but why go out of our way to make things so difficult to understand.
- dragonwriter 9y agoTitle case (which is itself an abomination before the Lord and a destroyer of communication) is the problem here. It is not “fake reserve bookings” but “fake Reserve bookings” (that is, in longer form, “fake bookings on Reserve”.) As GP pointed out reserve is a proper, not common, noun in this use.
- ricardobeat 9y agoIn case it’s not clear: “Reserve” is the name of the company affected.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThey didn't replace “reservations” with “reserve bookings”, but with “Reserve bookings”; unfortunately, title case obliterates the distinction.
- grzm 9y agoActual article title: "OpenTable Infuriates Restaurants With Fake Reservations Scheme"
- matt_wulfeck 9y ago> We extend our sincerest apologies to the restaurants in Chicago that were impacted by the disgraceful, unsanctioned activity of a lone OpenTable employee. I have a hard time believing he/she just thought of such scheme without silent knowledge, approval, and/or encouragement of others.
- dawnerd 9y agoQuotas/commissions will do that to sales people.
- avip 9y agoWells Fargo method. We don't know anything, we just set up a system to encourage fraud and close our eyes.
- Zanni 9y agoI believe OpenTable when they say it was a rogue employee, but I was hoping to see some mention in their apology of looking at their incentive system.
- ckocagil 9y agoWhy do you believe them without any evidence to (or against) their claims? For all we know there could be a direct verbal request from a manager.
- Zanni 9y agoI believe them because that's my default position, and I don't see enough evidence to believe otherwise. A poorly-incentivized rogue employee sounds perfectly plausible. But I don't think something like that happens without some culpability on the companies part (poor incentives, lack of oversight), which is why I'd like to see them take responsibility for that.
- jenscow 9y ago
- gumby 9y ago> We extend our sincerest apologies to the restaurants in Chicago that were impacted by the disgraceful, unsanctioned activity of a lone OpenTable employee. What about apologizing to Reserve?
- calt 9y agoThat can be done internally. No open letter required
- trhway 9y ago>Reserve’s security team conducted an investigation and brought that evidence to OpenTable and started a dialogue between the two rivals. OpenTable confirmed that it fired the employee in question lesson to the youngsters - never do anything smelly/unethical (dont even mention criminal) without manager approval in writing. Otherwise at the first sign of trouble you'll be made to take one for the team as it seems to have happened in this and countless other cases. I mean even in normal situation, whenever some details of feature, project, etc. are discussed and decided/assigned in some informal way, i find it is very useful to send a summary note so the manager/PM/etc wouldn't come later with the very different version of what happened.
- Joakal 9y agoThey will be verbal about it. If you request it in writing or email their own request to them, you will be fired or 'burned'. Source: Worked in finance. Most inappropriate requests was verbalised. They not only came from management but from other members of team (ie, bullying). I had a coworker get really angry at me when I 'confirmed the task' to her and cc'd my manager for a task she was offloading to me that wasn't related to my department.
- abcd_f 9y ago> I 'confirmed the task' to her and cc'd my manager That's exactly the way to handle gratuitous or fishy tasks - creates a paper trail and discourages any further attempts of the same kind. It may get you fired though :)
- luk32 9y agoBeing fired at will is still better than being fired for a documented reason. It boils down to risk management =P
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoBut this seems like a really toxic place to work. I routinely send a short summary of key points whenever we have a talk with someone that impacts our work/course of action. If not needed, I try to stay polite and relatively informal "Hi Steve, here's a short summary of what we talked about in the morning as my memory tends to fail me these days. If I got something wrong, please correct me." If someone gets back angry at me after receiving such an e-mail, I don't want to work in such a place.
- erikb 9y agoRead this and ctrl-f "cat's paw" or "execution failure": https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2011/10/14/the-gervais-principle-v-heads-i-win-tails-you-lose/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2011/10/14/the-gervais-principle-... I love how many of the Gervais Principle examples are actually something you can see in real life. Also hating it though. I wish we would live in a better world.
- Balgair 9y agoAgain and again, I come back to the Gervais Principal as The best literature for understanding the corporate environment. Thanks for the refresher!
- blauditore 9y agoI'm wondering how they found out it was someone from OpenTable. Detecting someone using multiple fake accounts (maybe from the same IP) is one thing, but how to track its origin? Did they use approximate location of the IP and saw it's close to OpenTable offices?
- hidenotslide 9y agoProbably because the cancels were followed up by aggressive sales calls that mentioned the issue. A quote from the article: "The no-shows were accompanied by an OpenTable inquiry about Tavern’s 'sagging sales,' with a renewed attempt to convince them to switch."
- tobyhinloopen 9y agoSo they were too aggressive. They should have used fake bookings much less and increase them much more slowly, and don't show with "hey, wanna switch?" right after.
- inetknght 9y agoShould have? You realize you're arguing for something that's morally reprehensible and legally questionable (fake bookings) in the context of something else whose morality is dubious at best (how should OpenTable know about sagging sales in the first place if they're not already affiliated with OpenTable?)
- berbec 9y agoDidn't Uber used to do this to Lyft et al whenever they show up in a new town?
- guelo 9y agoNo. Uber didn't use to have lone rogue sales people that were immediately fired when the company learned about it.
- chris_wot 9y agoYeah, but this could break some restaraunts. OpenTable should be compensating those restaraunts affected, at the very least. And this is different in that it didn’t just affect OpenTable’s rivals, affected the third party business directly.
- vamsipk 9y agoIf it was not sanctioned by OpenTable, why should they compensate? If a government employee does this, should the government compensate?
- eridius 9y agoIt was not sanctioned by them, but they're still responsible for the actions of their employee.
- matte_black 9y agoWhat if it was a customer trolling a restaurant they didn’t like?
- astura 9y agoThen the employer doesn't compensate in this case.
- 9y ago
- geofft 9y ago> Wesner and Reserve CEO Greg Hong said this was the only time they’ve ever tracked such behavior, which they don’t believe is criminal in nature. Isn't this a reasonably straightforward CFAA violation? (I'd agree with "we don't believe it ought to be criminal.")
- gpm 9y agoI don't think so, TOS violations are probably not CFAA violations [0]. It does sound like tortious interference (civil law that would allow recovering damages). I'm rather of the opinion that it should be criminal, this sort of action does real harm to society and is the exact sort of thing criminal laws should target. [0] I'm not aware of any cases that found that they were. Here is a case that found that they weren't: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Drew https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Drew (not a lawyer)
- icebraining 9y agoThe recent Nosal cases seem relevant, since they were specifically about an employee violating the internal computer policy, and the government arguing that violated the CFAA. After some rounds and a divided court, the Ninth Circuit reviewed it en banc and decided against the government: https://www.wilmerhale.com/pages/publicationsandnewsdetail.aspx?NewsPubId=91348 https://www.wilmerhale.com/pages/publicationsandnewsdetail.a... The SCOTUS refused to hear the appeal, but since the Ninth has jurisdiction over California, it seems fairly secure. But IANAL either.
- Someone1234 9y agoThe Computer Fraud and Abuse Act is such a broad and poorly written law that even common behavior can be called a CFAA violation, such as breaking terms of service. It was created during the enduing moral panic after the movie Wargames was released (1983 release, 1984 law). The House Committee Report about the bill literally references the movie. Here's the Wikipedia page on it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Fraud_and_Abuse_Act#C...
- cozzyd 9y agoWell, that explains why the restaurant I took my wife to on Randolph St had a surprising number of empty tables on Valentine's Day.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- petee 9y agoThis is one aspect not addressed in the article; just because tables were falsely reserved, doesn't mean they were actually responsible for the lack of business - if no customers were going to show up anyway. No real way to ever gauge that though.
- Double_a_92 9y ago> if no customers were going to show up anyway They didn't show up because they couldn't get a reservation (because it was already booked out fraudulently).
- petee 9y agoThe point already made in my post was that there is no way of us knowing that many, or even a few customers actually called and couldn't get a table. Evidence is anecdotal.
- Double_a_92 9y agoYes but even if you call you won't get a table. The restaurant doesn't know that most bookings will never show up. I guess I probably didn't get your point...
- cozzyd 9y agoI've been to the same restaurant on other nights and it's always been packed, so it was quite suspicious that it was so empty on what should be an even busier night...
- itronitron 9y agoSo there are four different start-ups that focus on making restaurant reservations... I had no idea it was so difficult to call a restaurant and make a reservation, I guess the person would need access to a phone in order to make the call.
- Benjamin_Dobell 9y ago... and have to: - Repeat my incredibly common, single syllable, three letter name for the umpteenth time just for them to still get it wrong. - Ask for a high-chair and ask them to please write that down somewhere, only to arrive and find they didn't do so and there's no longer any available. - Have staff mess up the time and/or number of people I've booked for, all because they can't hear over the kitchen noise? Yeah, I'll just fill out a few fields and hit submit, thanks.
- ghaff 9y agoI tend to be pretty far in into the "Seriously, you need an app for that?" camp. But using OpenTable is so easy compared to poorly designed restaurant web sites, busy signals/no answer, language barriers especially when traveling, etc. To say nothing of the fact that, you can immediately see if your desired slot is available and maybe check a couple other places before making a decision.
- eganist 9y agoIt's pretty awful. Hold times, the potential for multitasking staff to forget to log a RSVP, determining how to best allocate tables... Not only is online reservation a necessary component, it's just one piece of a multi-component automation solution to the many problems that arise from a desire to efficiently and effectively seat and serve as many people at once as possible. I recognize your comment is in jest, but I appreciate you making it. This challenge is rarely understood.
- GCA10 9y agoIn our household, we make a fair number of restaurant reservations at 11:30 p.m. . . . and some more at 9 a.m. (Two-career couple; hard to align schedules, etc.) Online services like Open Table don't mind this at all. By contrast, restaurants are not eager to keep staff by the phone at those hours, just in case we call.
- hw 9y ago"Reserve’s software engineers noticed a spike in prospective fraudulent activity on the afternoon of February 14" Interesting that they would be monitoring for fraudulent reservations. Are fraudulent reservation 'wars' between these companies pretty common that they would be tracking such behavior? Also, if this isn't criminal, is DDoSing a SaaS competitor not criminal then, since they are pretty similar?
- GCA10 9y agoI don't know about the restaurant business, but I've been told by people in the flower trade that the long-stemmed rose business right before Feb. 14 is full of antics, deceptions, broken promises, dummy orders, etc. that are absolutely terrifying if you're new to the game. So much money to be made so fast. It tends to attract . . . operators.
- dpflan 9y agoDo you know of good sources, articles, documentaries, etc exploring this or these events that attract “operators”?
- patrickyeon 9y agoNPR's Planet Money did an episode on the Valentine's Day rose craziness. I don't recall it being about particularly offside tactics, but it's from three years ago. https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/02/13/386005044/episode-603-a-rose-on-any-other-day https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/02/13/386005044/epis...
- GCA10 9y agoIt would make for a fine bit of investigative reporting. Wish I had an article to recommend. My source is a medium prominent tech executive who tried to disrupt the Valentine's Day flower business (with its high mark-ups). His plan was to set up his own, lower-priced regional alternative -- which would bring in planeloads of flowers from Central America, right on time. Things did not work out the way he had hoped. Everything went sideways the first year. He tried again, and the second year was catastrophically worse. There was no third year.
- tacostakohashi 9y agoOops, it's the good old-fashioned principal agent problem. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal–agent_problem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal–agent_problem
- dwyerm 9y agoI suspect there are some restaurants who are just now finding out what that mandatory binding arbitration and class action waiver clause in Opentable's terms[1] really means, today. On the other hand, there's an Opentable lawyer who is getting an extra martini at lunch today for saving the company by including that text. [1] https://www.opentable.com/legal/terms-and-conditions https://www.opentable.com/legal/terms-and-conditions
- Blackthorn 9y agoThe affected restaurants don't use OpenTable.
- TallGuyShort 9y ago> which they don’t believe is criminal in nature With all the silly things people want to regulate, I'm always baffled how intentionally deceiving people with the intent to cause harm isn't just plain illegal, and your only recourse is civil court. It seems to me it would cover a lot of situations that people try to fix with very specific (and thus loophole-y and high-overhead) regulations.
- scott00 9y agoMy non-lawyer opinion: I would be shocked if a motivated Illinois Assistant State's Attorney couldn't turn this into a criminal conviction. The definition of wire fraud in Illinois (720 ILCS 5/17-24) is "A person commits wire fraud when he or she... devises... a scheme or artifice to defraud or to obtain money or property by means of false pretenses, representations, or promises" and as part of that scheme communicates using a wire or radio waves. Basically, if you lie in connection with a financial transaction and use a telephone or the internet, you've committed wire fraud. The state doesn't prosecute many wire fraud cases as far as I know, but nearly every white collar federal case includes a wire fraud charge, because basically anything nefarious is wire fraud in addition to whatever else it may be. Of course, just because a prosecutor _could_ prosecute someone for a crime doesn't mean they will or should. And I think Reserve's lawyers have probably come to the conclusion that the State's Attorney probably has better things to do with her staff's time than prosecute this case.
- nkkollaw 9y ago> ...and the employee was terminated immediately. Jesus! C-can they do that?
- lowbloodsugar 9y agoIt seems a great many people believe that everyone else, and particularly, everyone in management, is unethical; the system is corrupt, all management is corrupt, and the only way to advance is to sacrifice one's values. I used to believe this too. To the ethical people out there, I'd like to say that there is a battle and we haven't lost yet. It sure looks that way, given the behavior of the government, large corporations, even NGOs. But its a battle. And the first front in the battle is mindshare. If ethical people believe that everything is corrupt and hopeless, then the unethical people have won. Consider this: the rogue employee at OpenTable could genuinely be a rogue employee. They might even be a nominal ethical employee who perceived behavior around them as unethical, or who believed that the only way to success given their performance targets was to behave unethically. They may have believed that the only explanation for the performance targets were that OpenTable wanted them to act unethically, when in fact they were just impossible targets set by an aggressive, but ethical manager. I'm sorry to say that ethical behavior is something we have to fight for continuously. We don't get to create a constitution a few hundred years ago and call it done. But it doesn't help if we declare, as I used to, that the government has been "rooted", and the US is just an unethical cesspit now. Get involved. Demand ethical behavior. Call out moral hazards. Talk about ethics.