17 ms·
Amazon will stop selling Nest smart home devices
- IntronExon 9y agoThat something of such dubious “value” would be subject to this kind of competition between giants is shocking to me. Maybe I’m just a paranoiac, but given the choice of Amazon, or Google having mics/cameras in my home, I would choose neither. I can’t think of a company I would trust to do that, and yet even people sensitive to privacy concerns on one hand seem blinded by the most petty convenience offered by these devices. The stakes are huge. Both Amazon and Google are building out a new voice-powered operating system that can control everything in your life — from your lights to your garage door to the music and video you stream. That’s... terrifying.
- freedomben 9y agoI tend to agree. I've been a huge privacy and OSS advocate for years, and still consider myself to be so. Yet, over the holidays, based on ravings from friends and family, I picked up some Google Homes on sale and have been loving them for the convenience they offer me and my family. That said, I am deeply concerned about where we are headed in the future. I have a natural distrust of all organizations that grows exponentially with the size of that organization. I don't want to make a choice between the lesser of evils. Yet, as we get deeper and deeper into the pervasiveness of technology, I see a real inability to participate that comes as a result of abstaining. Historically OSS has been late to the party, but at least they show up. I have a hard time seeing open source projects keeping up. I had high hopes in mycroft but it never materialized. I'm not too invested in Google Home to bail, so my soul may still be redeemable. I am nervous about our future options tho.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoYou have a voice powered operating system in your pocket with any modern cell phone. Sure, you can trigger it off using a software switch but do you really trust that? Apparently enough people trust it that they keep buying the latest phone models year after year. Anyone who is terrified by this technological shift should at least be cognizant that you are already basically recorded in some way whenever you go out in public in any major city. This is just the next shift.
- IntronExon 9y agoI can’t control anything beyond my home, but that’s an ancient fact of life. I can monitor what’s being sent and received by my phone or computers, but Alexa or whatever Google has? This is more than the “next shift” and I can feel the water getting too hot for this frog.
- singularity2001 9y agowhat is the difference between your computer's https traffic and Alexas? you can record both and decipher neither (unless you're very clever)
- CaptSpify 9y agoThe difference is that I have near total control of my computer's https traffic, whereas I don't have hardy any control over Alexa's.
- justboxing 9y ago> That’s... terrifying. Agreed. But we seem to be in a minority considering how popular these devices are, measured in terms of the millions of such units sold[1]. I guess they are taping into the 'human beings are inherently lazy' thing. [1] Source: > A year ago, Gigaom said Nest was selling 40,000-50,000 thermostats per month. Devitt estimates Nest is selling 100,000 thermostats per month now. http://www.businessinsider.com/nest-revenue-2014-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/nest-revenue-2014-1
- criddell 9y ago> That’s... terrifying. In what ways? How do you think people will be harmed?
- cookiecaper 9y ago"Alexa, why doesn't my daddy agree with Emperor of Mankind, His Excellency Jeff Bezos?" Next day, daddy doesn't come home from work, kid never sees him again. An intentionally extreme example, but this type of thing is certainly within the realm of possibility, and gradually making small encroachments.
- dpark 9y ago> this type of thing is certainly within the realm of possibility In your scenario, Bezos is an evil worldwide overlord who murders non-supporters casually. And yet somehow the real problem is an Echo on the kitchen counter. Just... what the fuck? “Realm of possibility” means something very different to you than to me.
- cookiecaper 9y agoOverlords who casually murder non-supporters is not far-fetched by any stretch, such regimes have risen dozens of times just in the last 100 years. These overlords haven't quite reached "worldwide" status yet, but use your imagination. A device that instantaneously and irrevocably transmits anything spoken to it to HQ, and then automatically transcribes it and makes it available for analysis, is absolutely a dangerous tool for censorship and repression. The fact that it looks nice on your counter and also spits out weather reports doesn't automatically invalidate those risks. These BigCos already compose complex, fairly accurate estimations of our interests and beliefs based on the data they read out of our emails, search history, and yes, voice commands. This data is used to make advertising decisions, but there's no reason that the same data can't be applied to "pre-moderate" the opinions of those who've expressed "dangerous views" in private, or worse. It just hasn't been used that way yet (to our knowledge, though it wouldn't surprise me to learn that Facebook or Google are already punishing/down-ranking accounts that express sentiments they dislike). Inviting these companies into your house to sit in every room and listen for "wake words", and then send up snippets of audio to HQ, should not be dismissed as a casual thing, even if the tradeoff is considered acceptable by some.
- oceanghost 9y agoYou're not paranoid-- its common sense. We have ABSOLUTELY no control over these devices we're inviting into our homes. We are voluntarily paying for a surveillance apparatus that can be turned against us at any moment. Even if you believe Apple/Google/Amazons intentions are honorable-- these devices will be attacked by every intelligence agency. It is an act of insanity to but this stuff.
- dpark 9y ago> We have ABSOLUTELY no control over these devices we're inviting into our homes This is rather alarmist since I control both the power and internet supply to any smart devices I bring into my home. I have much less control over my phone than my Echo.
- IntronExon 9y agoI can root my phone and monitor outgoing traffic. If I unplug my smart speaker it’s a brick with zero functionality. I have a range of options with my phone, I have binary options with an Echo or similar device.
- dpark 9y agoYou can root your phone and believe you’re monitoring outgoing traffic. Your phone hardware could easily be surreptitiously sending data over 4G and you would likely be unable to verify. Also why do you imagine that an echo is fundamentally unable to be rooted?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Someone1234 9y agoThis is creating an edge in the market where independent merchants and services can operate and their independence is their virtue. For an example, Google has Chromecast/YouTube, Amazon has Amazon Fire/Prime Video, and they're less and less interoperable year upon year. This war creates an edge that Roku can squeeze into, which has support for every major vendor except Apple. I find myself using Target and Walmart's websites more than ever before, not due to some moralistic protest, but simply because they're now more competitive and have products Amazon don't stock (like Google Home Mini for one example). I find it interesting from a business perspective that Amazon chooses to push out competition, whereas most major retailers stock both own brand and branded products side by side, and profit no matter what the consumer selects. I wonder when Alibaba US and EU will open. If Alibaba will sell anything and Amazon is protectionist, I can see that being Alibaba's edge.
- 908087 9y agoYou're also probably a lot more likely to receive products that aren't counterfeit when ordering from Target/etc. I've pretty much completely stopped using Amazon for that reason. It's just not worth the risk.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chibg10 9y agoI see this come up fairly often, and it baffles me each time. I've probably spent an average of $50+/week on Amazon for the past several years and have never once received a counterfeit item. What items are people buying that are so frequently counterfeit?
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI honestly couldn't speak to whether or not many of the items I've bought on Amazon are counterfeit. The example I saw in the article recently was a headphone anchor, and they had copied the packaging. I couldn't tell you, if I bought a headphone anchor, if the packaging looked like crud because it was counterfeit, or because the vendor who made it used cheapy packaging. Could you have bought counterfeit products that work "well enough", and you didn't know it? I do generally just buy whatever's the cheapest price, and rarely look to see if the brand and seller name are the same (or if there's a seller with the same name as the brand). I'm kinda interested in paying more attention going forward though, so we'll see.
- 8note 9y agosomebody from Amazon want to say where the customer obsession is that in blocking product ts that have good reviews?
- hessart 9y agoI wonder how much damage to Amazon’s bottom line Google could do by simply suppressing it from its search results.
- chapium 9y agoThat would be cutting the nose to spite the face.
- kjksf 9y agoI assume he was talking about non-paid search results in which case: how so? It's no like you're going to change your search engine to Bing because Google stopped showing organic search results for Amazon. I just searched for e.g. "Acer Predator Helios 300" and Amazon is second non-paid result. I would imagine that's the case for a lot of searches and not being in search results would hurt them a lot. And to be clear: I think it should be illegal for Google to selectively and anti-competitively tweak search results just as it should be illegal for Amazon to selectively and anti-competitively refuse to sell products.
- dahdum 9y agoThat would be brutal and probably antitrust-y...better to implement some algorithm change for product search that weighs in counterfeit risk. Search for "lightning cable" shows multiple Amazon listings on the first page, similar for batteries and other items that are routinely counterfeited. Google isn't doing the user a favor by routing them to suspect merchandise.
- DrScump 9y agoThe more ruthless strategy would be to continue to sell Nest products but ship only malfunctioning counterfeits.
- Finnucane 9y agoThat’s not what they’re doing now?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- stingrae 9y agoThat is what they do for Chromecast, https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/s/ref=is_s?k=chromecast https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/s/ref=is_s?k=chromecast
- dragonshed 9y agoI've seen this a lot. I use google to search Amazon almost exclusively.
- codq 9y agoWow, that is unbelievable and embarrassing that they allow that. With Prime shipping!
- culot 9y agoThey do manage to keep the counterfeiters off their house brands, so they definitely can control counterfeits if they like. Too bad they do not care.
- solarkraft 9y agoProduct quality is horrible on Amazon. AliExpress seems to be as good, if not better, with more consistent listings and possibly a better search.
- sudouser 9y agoten bucks you will still be able to buy fake nests on amazon and any fake or pirated app on google play
- bitmapbrother 9y agoThe fake Nest will do so much more, though. When it's not being used by a botnet to DDOS sites it's cryptomining Monero in its downtime.
- sudouser 9y agogreat ideas! laughed so hard woke people nearby
- nodesocket 9y agoI have no problem with this. Free market. If you want Nest products buy them from the Google Store (https://store.google.com/category/home_entertainment https://store.google.com/category/home_entertainment). Amazon is not required nor should they be to sell competitors products.
- Eridrus 9y agoJust because something is legal, doesn't mean that we as consumers must like it.
- nodesocket 9y agoI'm a consumer as well. I actually just bought a Nest thermostat and the Google Store experience is just as good as Amazon. Free shipping. I don't get the complaining.
- dpark 9y agoThe big problem is the lack of interoperability that this encourages. No Amazon Prime in Chromecast. No Google Play on Amazon Fire. No integration with Alexa and Nest. The petty squabbles hurt the customers’ experience.
- nodesocket 9y agoI don't think we can call multiple billions of dollars petty squabbles. Both companies view their home automation and smart devices as critical products. You can add Apple HomePod to the mix as well.
- lostmsu 9y agoWait, there was Alexa Nest integration. Was it pulled?
- dpark 9y agoI wasn’t aware there was integration there. I’m probably just wrong about that one.
- mankash666 9y agoSmacks of monopolistic behavior from Amazon
- josteink 9y agoWhen giants create walled gardens, we all lose.
- Lasher 9y agoAs someone who has been shopping on Amazon since the late 1990s I have recently stopped buying anything branded on there anyway, or at least anything branded where I care about receiving real OEM products. Still a fan overall but one too many knock-off products for me. After a few years of using Amazon pretty much exclusively for everything then going back to other sites for branded items, I have been pleasantly surprised how much better "all the other" online stores have gotten at fast free shipping and reliable service.
- Flavius 9y agoHopefully they will sell knockoffs from China.
- dm319 9y agoHow is this not illegal? If google took amazon off their search engine, what would happen?
- 8note 9y agoit's not illegal for Google to block Amazon's app store from Google play
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoVery few people seem to remember Google started this little war with blocking access to Google Apps on Amazon devices and blocking their app store on Google Play equipped devices. It is weird though because a couple months ago I thought they had announced they had come to some agreement, and now it seems to be escalating again.
- tacomonstrous 9y agoDid Amazon even apply for a MADA with Google to use the Play Store and their apps? They can choose at any time to not make their fork incompatible with mainline Android, and get access to the Play Store just like any other OEM. You seem to blame Google for Amazon wanting to have it both ways.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThe MADA is not a legal document, and it's not really possible for Amazon to comply with it.
- bitmapbrother 9y agoWhy is that? All Amazon has to do is pass the CTS so that all Android apps can run on their devices and not just Amazon Android apps.
- 9y ago
- jwtadvice 9y agoThey also don't/won't sell Chromecast product. This is the danger of vertical integration. Once upon a time the US government did built and used antitrust and antimonopoly legislation.
- tanilama 9y agoIs this legal?
- cronjobma 9y agoThis is usually the beginning of lots of bad things. When a company with such a monopoly starts banning competitors to promote their own products, it’s clear that their customers aren’t at the core of their engine. You should never ‘be evil’ to your own customers for short-term profit gain.
- golem14 9y agoCome on! Trade wars are good. Amazon will win. It's easy!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dade_ 9y agoI don't see why this would make anyone thinks this is illegal as it doesn't stop anyone from buying Google Home products. It isn't as though Best Buy is selling Amazon products and Apple stopped selling nest in their retail stores as well. At this point, Alexa works nicely with my Nest thermostat. If they break that, then I will be mighty annoyed because I will have to reach into my pocket to change the temperature instead of just blurting out the desired temperature of my abode.
- prklmn 9y agoAmazon isn’t a store like the others you’ve mentioned, they claim they are a marketplace
- whoisjuan 9y agoWhere do they claim this?
- pkaye 9y agoWould it be okay for Google to remove Amazon from their search engine given that nothing stops people from trying Amazon.com on their browser?
- ehsankia 9y agoSure, but at the same time, Google ranking shopping comparison sites lower didn't stop anyone from using them either, yet they got hit with $2.7B from the EU.
- tyler_larson 9y agoThe problem here isn't so much that Amazon is going to hurt Google. Google will survive. But we only hear about this story because Google is who Amazon is attacking (today). The bigger problem is that Amazon has set themselves up as the global arbiter of commerce, acting as a relatively neutral marketplace matching buyers to sellers worldwide, replacing many or most of the smaller commerce hubs and marketplaces that used to exist. But once in that position, they exercise control over which products can be sold with the explicit intention of destroying competitors, replacing what would otherwise be a consumer favorite with their own inferior (according to market preference) alternate. Everyone talks about monopolists and moral hazard and market manipulation, but Amazon seems to be the only modern company with the unique combination of dominance, confidence, and poor executive judgment to actually make it a consistent and overt company policy.
- gordon_freeman 9y agoThis is so true! And now as they have bought Whole Foods, they can do the same thing with grocery products by having options such as WF branded ones over the competitors (stocking 365 branded Sugar and dropping Safway Signature branded Sugar) through their Amazon Fresh or Prime NOW service.
- justonepost 9y agoPeople like variety in food. You don’t usually see network effects (ie, recipe only works if you use ingredients from same supplier) Home automation though is a great network effects play which is why amazon is doing this.
- vondur 9y agoIt’s almost like they are asking for government regulation.
- drawkbox 9y agoAmazon is a very smart company that invests heavily in research and development to stay ahead and loved by people. Amazon will continue to stay ahead of monopoly calls as long as they don't make moves like this. Monopolies can benefit for some time such as AT&T with software/labs/modern applications (C++) wiring for telecom, Microsoft with Windows desktop and getting people on the internet, Apple with the smart phone, Amazon with online purchasing, Google with search, cable/telco providers and broadband access etc. But once these companies start pushing too hard on the monopoly levers, blocking competitors, actively breaking competitors products/software/standards, blocking out fair markets, then they start to have problems and maybe will get broken up. AT&T was broken up, Microsoft got slowed considerably resulting in Apple/Google rising, Amazon and Google need to keep it fair or else it will get more and more heated. Moves like blocking competitors or competing products, rather than just making better products, are troubling and signs that the some people in charge there are taking cheap ways out to gain short term advantage. Capitalism only works well when there are fair markets and competition, otherwise it is big fish oligarchies of companies that works for noone controlling everything.
- kerng 9y agoThe problem is that these players are just so big, that's why we read about. The poor little shop down the street that is bullied by Amazon has no way of voicing their problems. Maybe it's just me, but I have been avoiding making Amazon the first stop when I buy something, and it's difficult because they are so omnipresent. But once I bought a painting from China which never arrived, probably counterfeit and Amazon never reimbursed me. Since then I am not a big Amazon fan anymore and stories like this make me wonder what options there are to bring a bit more diversity into this market?
- nextstepguy 9y agoRead the story about Amazon authorizing fake Chromecast devices to be sold, while blocking the real ones. Mind you the devices look exactly the same (minus better bandwidth.) Read some of the reviews from folks buying the imitation, knowing it wasn't the real deal, but nevertheless bought them because "where else could they buy from?". Those comments and now this make me wonder how strong Amazon has become to decide what consumers can buy or not.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- freech 9y agoI wonder whether Amazon accounts for this properly. If someone asked them to remove a competitors products, how much money would they demand? They'd have to calculate the damage this does their brand. Do they calculate in this case?
- gsich 9y agoNo big loss, as those devices aren't smart to begin with.
- blaisio 9y agoOn the bright side, for people worried about monopolies and corporations having too much power, this severely hurts Amazon's brand. They really are a much less useful site when instead of being "the place where you can buy anything" they are "the place where you can buy Amazon products, and a few other things too".
- ggg9990 9y agoThe US needs laws and a DOJ that can put an end to this kind of market power abuse. What Google and Amazon do to each other publicly they do daily to millions of individuals and small businesses that are too weak to retaliate.
- jimjimjim 9y agowell done everyone. we have made amazon the gatekeeper of the consumer market. don't make Baron Amazon angry or he will have you run out of town.
- knodi 9y agoThis is because Google removing youtube app from Fire devices.
- Molaxx 9y agoHow is that legal? Microsoft took on antitrust lawsuits for bundling its browser with its OS. This seems much worse.
- moomin 9y agoIt’s almost as if when you get companies as large as countries, they start having trade wars.
- ausjke 9y agoMr. Anti-trust has been waiting for Amazon I believe. These childish moves will just speed that up.
- ggm 9y agoI'm going to repeat the sentiment of a post I made in another place (about websites sharing PII) -What aspect of trade and commerce regulation is not being applied here, that we have a tool in the armory for, in the body of the regulator? What would you like a competent trade regulator to do here? I'm naive, but I'd like them to tell amazon to fk off out of this behaviour and penalise them significantly. I think either a shop has a giant sign on the door "we don't sell NEST" or not. Simply not providing it, when in other ways its in competition with the suppliers of NEST feels like trade discrimination for predatory outcomes. Supplying competitive items, including forged items puts you in a very strange place. Apple stores don't sell windows PCs, this is understood. If Apple established a general purpose computing outlet, supplied PCs but decided not to stock Dell or HP (note, not that Dell or HP refused to supply: Apple decided not to stock) then I'd say the same thing. If Dell or HP didn't stock to Apple stores, and if Google refuses to stock to Amazon, then the beef is with the supply side, not the distribution side. Same logic, different direction.
- americanhead 9y agoYour move, Google