8 ms·
China is trying to police what people are saying about it around the world
- adjkant 9y ago> “I personally am not sure what the solution is for these companies,” said Mr. Rosenzweig. “I don’t see a good answer because the Chinese government is really putting them between a rock and a hard place.” I don't think this is that hard of a decision, is it? Just say no and cut ties with efforts for China as a market. Any profits there are not worth jeopardizing all of the privacy and precedents that are being slowly pushed.
- daodedickinson 9y agoI think it's too late. Bill Clinton sold them enough tech in the 90s in exchange for defense contractor kickbacks that now China has passed the US in military technology. China has too much influence and money on too many US campuses and has students demanding repeal of the 1st, 2nd, and 4th amendments, which will help continue the growth of Chinese power. Xi Jinping is explicit in his goal to bring democracy to an end globally, and he now has indirect control of Hollywood to complete this agenda. The big internet controlling companies act like private versions of the Chinese government, and will increasingly be instruments of the Xi Jinping or else be destroyed by richer Chinese competitors. I hope I'm wrong about the boot being already planted on the face of humanity forever.
- droopybuns 9y ago>>1st, 2nd, and 4th amendments I have been befuddled by the behavior of young people on these axis for the last 10 years. This observation you’ve made is super seductive... but I think the more likely reason we are in this mess is that the younger gens are foundationally devoid of skepticism. I applaud your creativity though. It definitely could be a contributing factor.
- Slansitartop 9y agoThe grandparent is probably just mocking satire. I don't think any American, not even the most cartoonish millennial activists, wants to repeal the 4th amendment.
- droopybuns 9y agoThe gun debate over the last few weeks makes me think otherwise. Edit: I don't think they want to repeal it. I think they want to ignore it. In fact- I don't think anyone actually wants to go through the hassle of repeal for any of the previously mentioned amendments, which would be the right approach. They just want some magical executive order that usurps the constitution.
- freedomben 9y agoI don't think we need to repeal anything now that the government just routinely ignores the Constitution when it conflicts with what they want to do.
- UncleEntity 9y agoWell, unless the unreasonable seizures are being committed against "privileged" groups to guarantee equality of outcome (as opposed to equality of opportunity).
- jjeaff 9y agoI knew lots of Chinese students in college. And I can tell you with quite a bit of certainty that most were far too busy studying to go out and organize or participate in political protest.
- tzahola 9y agoAt least they sold us some cheap crap.
- lozaning 9y ago"China has passed the US in military technology" [citation needed]
- adventured 9y ago> now China has passed the US in military technology China hasn't come close to passing the US in military technology in fact. Technologically they're behind the US in: destroyers, submarines, helicopters, drones, laser weapons, satellites, integrated command systems, aircraft carriers, ICBMs and general nuclear weapon technology, tanks, bombers, jet fighters. In several of these categories, China is extremely far behind. The Germans, French, British and Russians also have countless military gear that is still technologically well ahead of China. Overall, Russia's military technology capabilities are well ahead of China. China still struggles with primitives like jet engines, which Russia has long since mastered. China still can't field a single long range aircraft carrier. Currently they're unable to push their military projection much beyond Japan and limited parts of the Indian Ocean. The US has true global force projection to practically every corner of the globe. Will China catch up? Plausibly; it'll take 30 years for them to build all the bases necessary to do it.
- mistermann 9y agoI believe this war will be won economically/politically/socially, not militarily, and China holds most of the cards in those areas if you ask me. EDIT: Hey serial downvoter, do you realize you've missed a few?
- jcranmer 9y agoIf there's one thing history shows starkly, it's that trying to fight a war without getting militarily involved does not end well.
- mistermann 9y agoExcept for the cases where it went well and therefore doesn't register in your consideration.
- biesnecker 9y ago“When we hang the capitalists they will sell us the rope we use.” Because they have a fiduciary duty to, obviously.
- HumanDrivenDev 9y agoQuoting Stalin? Classy. Have any good Hitler quotes you want to share while you're at it?
- bsiemon 9y agoJust because Stalin was a monster doesn't mean that quote is bad.
- lostconfused 9y agoDoes he have any relevant to the topic in the first place?
- oxryly1 9y agoHere's one: "The great strength of the totalitarian state is that it forces those who fear it to imitate it."
- Analemma_ 9y agoStalin didn’t say it: https://quoteinvestigator.com/2018/02/22/rope/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2018/02/22/rope/
- mark_edward 9y agoWhen profits come up against morality, profits will win every time. How do you think we even got to this situation in the first place?
- nashashmi 9y agoNot just profits. Also influence. Each company wanted to spread it's products globally. Google tried this. But government kept blocking them causing slow internet. The miserable experience plus targeted hacking destroyed their morale for staying in.
- adventured 9y agoInterestingly for Google, it didn't add up to much in terms of missing out. Much like Russia and Yandex, the odds were slim that Google was going to beat out Baidu on their own turf for various reasons. In the case of Baidu, they ended up being a non-threat outside of China. As China gets a lot more aggressive on censorship and content control in the coming years, Baidu's chances of truly going global will dwindle to zero. Lately Baidu has been looking at search as their past, because they know they've lost and hit a wall there in terms of any global search ambition, so they're burning their resources on trying to play in other categories vs Alibaba and Tencent. Meanwhile since Google was pushed out of China, they have become a near trillion dollar juggernaut. Since fiscal 2009, Google has grown from $23b to $109b in sales. They're about nine to ten times the size of Baidu and growing as fast. That's the cost of being stuck inside of China, while Google is stuck outside of China.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hueving 9y agoThis is not true. There are a bunch of businesses that use there moral positions as advertising to great effect. This is why Apple doesn't sell away your data, why every city is filled with local and organic restaurants, etc. The market does select for moral positions, you just might not like those positions.
- s73v3r_ 9y ago"Any profits there are not worth jeopardizing all of the privacy and precedents that are being slowly pushed." Counterpoint: Scrooge-McDuck-Money-Bin.gif
- Gustomaximus 9y agoAustralia is deeply involved in this. China are actively trying to control conversation with Chinese students and immigrants here. The govt has literally bought all Chinese language press and semi regularly run full page 'articles' in the major press. They have been caught out several time pressuring universities and placing disruptive people in lectures that discuss areas they don't want. I believed agents recently were found to have broken into lectures houses. Its a delicate situation and hopefully the government will not be afraid to deal with it, whilst not turning it into a xenophobic support point.
- robtaylor 9y agoSources?
- John_KZ 9y agoYeah, some of that sounds way too far-fetched.
- fnulnu 9y agoThe various scandals have been reported on quite a bit by Australian news stations
- doctorstupid 9y agohttp://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-04/australian-sovereignty-under-threat-from-chinese-influence/8583832 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-06-04/australian-sovereignty...
- malchow 9y agoSee: https://www.ft.com/content/7ac14e70-ded8-11e7-a8a4-0a1e63a52f9c https://www.ft.com/content/7ac14e70-ded8-11e7-a8a4-0a1e63a52...
- sillysaurus3 9y agoNon-paywalled: http://archive.is/Rq7FP http://archive.is/Rq7FP
- mirimir 9y agoThis is rather biased against China. OK, so Chinese authorities have arrested citizens who have posted "illegal" material. I don't see that they've grabbed citizens of other countries off the streets, which the US and Israel have done. Or pressed other countries to extradite their citizens based on criminal allegations, which the US commonly does. And about takedown requests to Google etc. MPAA and other "rights holders" do this frequently. Indeed, the US government uses DNS poisoning to censor sites that it considers illegal. Or requests that other countries raid hosting services, and impound servers. Has China done that? Anyway, just sayin'. I do believe that everything should be takedown-proof, for what it's worth.
- incompatible 9y agoGui Minhai, citizen of Sweden, was kidnapped in Thailand and secretly imprisoned in China.
- justicezyx 9y agocitation please
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThat one is easy: https://www.google.com/search?q=swedish+citizen+china&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjgrZqH_c7ZAhUOyWMKHRoVBOcQ_AUICigB&biw=1378&bih=758 https://www.google.com/search?q=swedish+citizen+china&source...
- pianoben 9y agoLiterally the first Google search result has it all laid out - well cited, at that. I would hope that you avail yourself of this wonderful resource in the future, saving time both for yourself and for others.
- mirimir 9y ago
- ilamont 9y agoFacebook suspended Mr. Guo’s account. In a statement, the company said the account published the personal information of others without their consent, which violated the platform’s policies. Zuckerberg wants to be in China in such a bad way. He's learned Mandarin, plays up his family connections (via his wife's family), and puts on the charm when visiting China. He's created relationships with officials at every level. His representatives have talked with companies which may be partners or acquired at some point. It does not surprise me one bit that Facebook will bend over backwards to accommodate officials on censorship demands. This is the cost of doing business in China for a tech company. Media companies learned this decades ago - read up on how Rupert Murdoch was able to operate there, it's quite fascinating. Now it's Silicon Valley's turn, especially companies that specialize in communication -- social networks, phone manufacturers, companies that sell networking hardware, etc. The Chinese government's survival depends on information control, and if they can't do it themselves, then they force local and foreign companies to do it for them. Don't think that this issue will be limited to human rights activists. It doesn't matter who you are -- your social media comments, family relationships, WeChat and Facebook messages, work connections on LinkedIn, and other digital footprints that reflect your attitude or influence will be used to build a social media score that determines your level of access to the country and ability to do business in China. The scary prospect is that other countries will do the same thing ... if they haven't done so already.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoDid Mr. Guo in fact publish the personal information of others? If so, should Facebook make an exception for him because he's an activist? (If he didn't, then of course Facebook should, first, not suspend his account to appease China, and second, not lie about why they did.)
- incompatible 9y agoI suppose corrupt dealings are personal details, so exposing corrupt dealings (in a credible way, with details) is likely to involve publishing the personal information of others.
- 9y ago
- tombh 9y agoWhilst I think there's some merit in the recent increase in China articles here. The tone of this one seems sensational. What I find most intriguing about discovering China is what it says about me and the so-called West. China's influence is growing you say? My first reaction is concern, but my second is humility, as if looking in a mirror. I can't help but feel a little like this article immaturely criticises a topic that it never has an intention to understand. The entire premise of being able to so easily stir such ominous sentiment betrays the existence of the elephant in the West's room: Western power is so taken for granted we no longer know how to treat it as a privilege. It's embarrassing, in fact I think we have, at the very least, a responsibility to be embarrassed, that unironic, one-sided criticism of China is culturally acceptable. This is not at all to imply that China doesn't represent the absolute worst of human behavior, I'm not naïve. It's to say that the conversation about China is really the stirrings of a new awakening in the West's self-understanding.
- Asooka 9y agoI believe the article is sensationalist precisely because the target audience would generally take western power for granted. It takes strong words to really get across the message that China isn't playing around and has the power to back their ambitions.
- doctorstupid 9y agoThis isn't about western power, it's about western values being protected in the west. I'm sure that people wouldn't be so concerned if China kept its censorship within its borders. As far as I know the west doesn't systematically subvert Chinese values within China.
- whatyoucantsay 9y agoThe US sure tries to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voice_of_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voice_of_America
- blfr 9y agoFacebook suspended Mr. Guo’s account. In a statement, the company said the account published the personal information of others without their consent, which violated the platform’s policies. A spokeswoman declined to comment on whether Beijing’s complaints played a role. Chinese authorities have also successfully persuaded Google to pull down content that had been available around the globe. How do they use those standing desks without a spine?
- kazinator 9y ago+1 for originality: you don't seem to have cribbed the "standing desks without a spine" from any Googleable source.
- forapurpose 9y agoChina has great influence in Hollywood, where major studios edit their films to meet Chinese censorship demands. When Disney made a film about the Dalai Lama, several years later the CEO of Disney traveled to China and apologized in person, saying it would never happen again. The Chinese government is literally censoring political content in the United States and other Western countries. Here's a cite for the Disney story. I've read about Chinese censors reviewing films, and Hollywood self-censoring, but I don't have time to find those cites. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/15/business/international/china-disney.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/15/business/international/ch...
- sehugg 9y agoThere's a bunch: https://screenrant.com/movies-changed-for-china/ https://screenrant.com/movies-changed-for-china/
- megaman22 9y agoThe one that really sticks out is the recent Red Dawn remake. I mean, really, North Korea is going to invade the pacific coast? It was clearly written about Communist China, that's the only way the movie could have made the slightest bit of sense, but they kowtowed and turned it into a dumpster fire, and they still didn't procure release rights there.
- blackrock 9y agoTrue, they requested that Red Dawn be re-edited, so that China was not the bad guy. I have not seen the movie, nor do I care to. However, let's think about this situation for a moment, as rational adults. And if you can, then try to think about this from the other side. There is a lot of bad blood coming out of American media about China. It's in the news, the movies, the TV shows, the literature, it's everywhere. Unless you are dense, then I think this can be established as a fact. China is continually being painted as the big bad scary commie, that's out to eat your children (or something like that), or at least, they're taking your iPhone assembling slavery jobs. A movie like this, would add more fuel to the fire. You, as an intelligent individual may be able to distinguish that Red Dawn is a fictional movie, with good and bad guys. And this sells tickets. And Americans love this! They want a big bad evil enemy, that their country can destroy. And right now, China is it! However, can you guarantee that another American, of lesser educational intelligence than yourself, can distinguish such a thing? That this is pure fiction, and not a proxy of reality. Nobody wants to be painted as the bad guy. Americans movies will certainly never paint America as the bad guy, despite the fact that millions have died at the receiving end of American weapons. In fact, I can't recall any media where America is painted as the bad guy. The Chinese people certainly don't want to see themselves as the bad guys. Especially not when it's a historical fact, that they have been severely dominated by Western nations. And hundreds of millions of their people have suffered and died. And to this day, there are certain white people, that are proud of what their race did to China in the 1800s. And if you find this shocking, please let me know. You can find this perception all over the internet, and you can poll your close friends, and ask them what they truly think. Anyways, movies are political statements. When you make it too real, then it hits too close to home. And there are certain dangers with that kind of propaganda. And it will certainly upset the people on the receiving end of it. Stick to making movies about aliens and their probing devices, zombies, and superheros in tights. Or killing the evil German Nazis. Nobody will question these kinds of movies.
- EggsOnToast 9y agoThis is just me soapboxing, but I would argue that situations like this illustrate a need for online social platforms run by the state. I realize the obvious vulnerabilities of such a setup, but if we believe free speech to be an essential element of our societies then we need social platforms beholden only to our own laws even if they simply exist in parallel to private platforms. The internet, and social media in this context, have become just as fundamentally important to discussions and grassroots politics as the street corner once was.
- malloryerik 9y agoYou'd then have different social platforms for different countries. Instead of run by the state, governments could choose to give out vouchers redeemable only at social platforms that charge users directly for their services instead of relying on the advertising and data-sales game.
- EggsOnToast 9y agoI think your criticism is valid but I don't see it as unsolvable. Interconnectivity and decisions around how to facilitate it can be added later. While they are important elements for global dialogue, the first and foremost goal should be cultivating a domestic product that is suffiently feature rich to be a valid alternative to the current offerings. Interconnectivity with other social networks is a secondary goal that can be pursued as things progress.
- ethiclub 9y agoSuch a platform is desperately hard to argue for, but I suspect that a trusted, basic platform provided by governments will become defacto in many nations within our lifetimes. We do have component precedent cases to build upon in Estonia, with the (failed) British ID cards etc, but I do wish a nation somewhere was further along. Perhaps small countries Luxembourg, Belgium, principities and Estonia are the places to keep an eye on rather than China, USA et al? I also believe that such a platform is the quickest path towards incorruptible technocracies, slowly but surely through referendums being opened up through the platform (small, local decisions at first). If this does not occur in the public sector, then I view governments as the taxi industry to capitalism's uber, and it will be the free market (controlled by increasingly intelligent public demand more than lagging legsislation) that starts to provide more 'pure democracy' behaviors. (As an aside, I wonder whether we shall start to see more interestingly structured IPOs) The cynic in me sadly suspects that socialism just isn't fast enough, and that the free market will be the dominant tool for change - But that slowly but surely, public voice will become a more ethical one - In this era we are in which is surely a second age of enlightenment. Hopefully this will sculpt the free market to be more aligned with the commons, and less brutally and bluntly aimed at collecting $.
- zombieprocesses 9y agoIsn't everyone trying to police what people say online now? Least of all the nytimes and the rest of the media? Europe does it. We do it. The media advocates for it. Is it just bad when the chinese do it? 90% of the time everyone here seems to support censorship and control over social media. Then the story is about china and everyone is against it.
- anthonyleecook 9y agoThere's censorship, and there's kidnapping/threats against citizens in other countries "After U.S.-Based Reporters Exposed Abuses, China Seized Their Relatives" https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/01/world/asia/china-xinjiang-rfa.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/01/world/asia/china-xinjiang... "Chinese Police Are Demanding Personal Information From Uighurs in France. Officials have threatened to detain relatives of those who don’t comply." http://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/02/chinese-police-are-secretly-demanding-personal-information-from-french-citizens-uighurs-xinjiang/ http://foreignpolicy.com/2018/03/02/chinese-police-are-secre...
- norikki 9y agoBut the people most censored on social media in the West are alt-right. Are you saying that white people wanting their own communities and countries is a legitimate interest on par with the Tibetans wanting their own communities and country?
- forapurpose 9y ago(Pardon the bit of philosophy, but I think it's on-topic, well-grounded, and substantially novel (at least to me!):) The myriad of issues of the present era seem chaotic, but I'm starting to believe I see the defining theme, the one that will characterize it in history books, and I see the story in the article as merely a part of it: The contest between democracy and liberty on one hand, and wealth and power for an elite on the other. People like Thiel say "freedom and democracy" are not "compatible" with "capitalism".[0] Similarly, the Chinese government (and Russian, and others) is a wealthy elite that keeps the power from its citizens and the bulk of the wealth to itself. It's aristocracy: The belief that power should be controlled by the elite and inherited, not delegated by a vote of universal peers with equal rights. It's not really "capitalism" that that Thiel advocates, but economic power for the currently wealthy unrestricted by the democratic wishes of other citizens (i.e. simply more power for himself, the oldest, most base political instinct - again, see China). He has fellow advocates in the current US government: For example, the Secretary of State (another business elite) and others have openly said the US shouldn't sacrifice making money for human rights, and openly support brutal, oppressive dictatorships. In the US courts, conservatives have given corporations and wealthy far more power over the democratic will of the people - corporations have gained Constitutional rights of real humans; they and the wealthy have gained unlimited, anonymous financial influence in politics and elections; and they've gained protections from the courts themselves (class-action restrictions, arbitration requirements, etc.). Another example is one vein of extreme anti-regulation dogma that says, on principle, economic powers should not be limited by the will of the majority (I'm not saying all arguments against regulation are problematic, only the principle that the issues shouldn't be decided democratically). At times there truly is an immediate tradeoff. Daimler-Benz, Google, Hollywood, and others have to deal with this real problem in China and it will affect their bottom lines. But from an historical perspective it's nothing new and is a minor sacrifice. Few of those companies would exist in their current state or enjoy their wealth if not for the massive sacrifices of life and wealth made by prior generations; there are 18-year-olds still at the bottom of the English Channel who never even set foot in France or fired a weapon. What are the corporations and we doing for the next generation? Will we be merely parasites that consume the benefits bestowed on us and pass on less, rather than invest in and expand freedom as our ancestors did? The U.S. Declaration of Independence ends "we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our Fortunes, and our sacred Honor" for liberty. It wasn't the opposite: they didn't pledge to give up their liberty for greater fortunes - but that's what Thiel, et al want. In the long run, it's not a tradeoff. Giving freedom and opportunity to more people makes them more productive; it's a wonderful, mutually-reinforcing phenomenon between democracy and freedom on one hand and prosperity on the other. It has made the democracies the wealthiest, most free countries in the history of the world. It has given hope and liberty to more than a billion people; today's wealthy were yesterday's poor. It's worked throughout the world, from Japan to Latin America to Taiwan to Europe and the US to many more places. But at times there are immediate tradeoffs and sacrifices that we must decide to make: Will we give up wealth for democracy and freedom? Do we want democracy and freedom (and long-term prosperity), or unbridled economic wealth and power for a nascent aristocracy? It seems like an easy choice to me once you think about it that way.[1] [0] https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/education-libertarian https://www.cato-unbound.org/2009/04/13/peter-thiel/educatio... [1] Of course, it's even easier when I frame the question that I answer!