13 ms·
Uber and Lyft drivers' median hourly wage is just $3.37, report finds
- resalisbury 9y agoThe economist behind the study admits this is wrong and has adj the figure to $8.55 from $3.37. Here is the response he posted. https://twitter.com/StephenZoepf/status/970754550968676352/photo/1 https://twitter.com/StephenZoepf/status/970754550968676352/p... He also admits to using "donated" labor from students. $0 is even less than $3.37 ;)
- astrodust 9y agoUber is losing billions and their drivers are making peanuts. That sounds sustainable.
- nraynaud 9y agoI am a bit curious about the dockless bike shares too, I suspect the same thing.
- teeteetech 9y agoI'm not as certain about that. Potentially optimistic, but I could imagine bikes taking on a larger role as we move to self driving cars. If you read threads about biking[0], people seem to be motivated to bike more than they are motivated to drive. Although these same people are stymied by negative conditions. Self driving cars could improve biking conditions by opening up roadways, making them safer, providing better point to point transit. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16420271 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16420271
- gpm 9y agoI think I agree with the biking in general, self driving cars will probably make biking a lot safer both by reducing the chances of an idiot running into you, and reducing the number of parked cars on roads (riding beside parked cars is scary, because you are never sure when a door is going to open into you). I don't think that I necessarily agree that this means bike shares will succeed though, I think private bike ownership has a lot going for it.
- nraynaud 9y agoI have a bike and there are bike shares around me. I am still trying to figure out a policy, but I lean towards bike share for everything short, because it’s like a taxi, you don’t need to go back to your bike. But bike share are crappy, so for longer distance I need bigger wheels and gears.
- nraynaud 9y agoI was skeptical about the business model, the bikes cost a lot, are rented for cheap, and for some reasons the companies go head to head in the same towns instead of covering different areas. And if they kill each other and the winner raises the price, I suspect Detroit wins.
- teeteetech 9y agoYeah, the biking model seems fairly easy to speculate on, but sort of hard to pin down. Here's some speculation from a per bike perspective. Revenue daily rides*365*$1 Costs $250 per bike + $15 per month for maintenance + 20% chance of catastrophe amortized over the fleet = ~$500 + rebalancers + insurance + overhead? So maybe 2 rides per bike per day gets them in the green?
- bfuller 9y agoMy city recently got them, and we currently have more bikes than NYC. It was rough at first but people are taking them a lot now, and its increased bicycling in general even outside of bike shares.
- peterwwillis 9y agoIt was never designed to be sustainable. Why does nobody get that yet? The only reason Uber and Lyft work is that there are a ton of people with limited job skills, who have time on their hands, are short on cash, and need to spend their extra time trying to make money. Sure, there may be "bored people" who do this because they're retired or whatever, but that's a tiny minority. Most people do not become part-time cab drivers because it's more fun than what they would normally do with their free time. A significant amount of our economy is dependent on people having two or three or four jobs, and a lot of those people live in or very near to cities, and have cars. If wages improve across the board, or people move farther away from cities, or people get rid of their cars, ride-sharing is screwed. Much of the "gig economy" is dependent on similar conditions. If we had better access to jobs and a living wage, a lot fewer people would be "gigging" to get by. Another reason (there's probably dozens) why the gig economy is incentivised today are things like rising health care costs, rising cost of housing, rising cost of education, and lack of availability to retirement or pensions. We all know we're supposed to save, but it's harder and harder to save. So people have to pick up gigs. My partner is a teacher and gets paid well for her position, but she still has to Airbnb out a room in her home because the insurance, taxes, and mortgage are absolutely insane. If she makes it to 25 years or whatever it is without killing herself from stress, maybe she can finally retire. Except, oh wait, the state isn't funding the teachers' pensions and will run out of money in eight years! Fun. Point is, the gig economy is here because almost every strata of people below "upper-middle-class" have been getting slowly screwed for decades. It's not designed to give people a working income. It's designed to fit into the cracks in the system - and the cracks keep getting bigger.
- azernik 9y agoBut it's not even sustainable for the big companies. Even with screwing over their please-don't-call-them-employees, they still need constant infusions of investor cash to stay afloat.
- s0rce 9y agoIt is also basically a loan against your car, which you pay back either in reduced value when you sell or increased maintenance.
- procinct 9y agoThey are basically biding their time until driverless cars take off it seems.
- seibelj 9y agoDriverless cars in urban areas are decades away
- acmustudent 9y agoI see a lot of driverless ubers here in pittsburgh
- staticassertion 9y agoI saw one yesterday. There was a driver but like... come one, decades?
- seibelj 9y agoWhen driverless cars are common on midwestern highways every night, they will start moving into complex urban areas. We are very far from cars navigating downtown NYC, Seattle, SF, Boston, etc.
- woah 9y agoDo you live in NYC, Seattle, SF, or Boston?
- seibelj 9y agoYes, Boston, and when can I order my driverless car to pick me up?
- gpm 9y agoA few months ago if you ignore the safety driver [0]. If cars with safety drivers don't count, nearly a year ago if you move to Pheonix and get lucky [1]. They're apparently planning to launch in more cities "soon" (though I can't find a list or date) [2] and they've recently got permission to start charging passengers and intend to by the end of they year [3]. So I think "decades" is an exaggeration. [0] https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/6/16742924/lyft-nutonomy-boston-self-driving-car https://www.theverge.com/2017/12/6/16742924/lyft-nutonomy-bo... [1] https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/25/15415840/waymo-self-driving-minivan-early-rider-phoenix https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/25/15415840/waymo-self-drivi... [2] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/01/waymo-maintains-huge-lead-in-self-driving-car-race/552059/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/01/waymo... [3] https://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/waymo-now-a-full-ride-hailing-service/ https://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/waymo-now-a-full-ride-hai...
- maxharris 9y agoIt's sustainable because we're on the cusp of the autonomous vehicle revolution. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/26/technology/driverless-cars-california-rules.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/26/technology/driverless-car... This is similar to how the huge army of people stuffing DVDs into envelopes at Netflix is going away. It might be slow, but I don't think there will be tons of people watching DVDs from them in 2030... https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/23/netflix-dvd-business-still-alive-what-is-it-like-to-work-there.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/23/netflix-dvd-business-still-a...
- astrodust 9y agoI hope you realize that ripping DVDs and putting them up for streaming is pretty easy, everyone was doing it before Netflix was, compared to having a fleet of autonomous vehicles that can safely operate in a multitude of urban environments, something nobody has ever done before. You have to question the leadership of a company that's willing to throw untold billions and counting on a long-shot bet that they'll eventually have these magical cars and everything will be fine. Once Uber can do it, soon afterwards everyone can, and what makes you think Uber will do it better when they've already had to give up so much to invent their own self-driving car solution? Their business model is completely ridiculous.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- felixk42 9y agoSelf driving cars have nothing to do with what Uber has been up to, and having a lot of cash isn't really a competitive advantage when your competitors are Google, Tesla and other car manufactures.
- astrodust 9y agoUber has a lot of cash by taxi standards, but nothing compared to car manufacturer standards.
- 9y ago
- NotSammyHagar 9y agoeventually they will raise prices, and hope everyone is out of business who competes with them.
- astrodust 9y agoThere's so much irony here. The only way they'll be able to maintain a monopoly is with regulation, and they're the first to ignore regulations. If in the future they get their coveted monopoly, won't it be sweet when someone flouts the rules and undercuts them?
- kawsper 9y agoYour comment made me remember that Richard Stallman calls Uber for Guber (Refering to Goober; another word for a peanut), because they pay peanuts to their drivers.
- SamReidHughes 9y agoAny Uber drivers want to chime in?
- dnautics 9y agoThis seems rather low. Granted it's been almost two years since I drove for (primarily lyft) and I was making 50k/year for about 70h work a week. And also I gave myself about 6 weeks of vacation over that year and half.
- danielvf 9y agoIs that 50k after car depreciation, gas, and maintenance?
- dnautics 9y agoAfter gas and maintenance. Buy Honda. I'm not calculating depreciation, but that's dumb, since I used the car I had (for about 4 years prior), and continued using it about 2 years after.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tachyoff 9y ago$50,000 per year for 70 hour per week works out to $28,571.43 if it were a standard 40-hour work week. Oh, and no benefits and you get to pay for gas and wear-and-tear on your car. So I guess if you're okay spending almost every waking hour working for peanuts and no health insurance, then sure.
- dnautics 9y agoHonestly it was more like 60 h a week and it's not so bad because that "includes commute", and also the schedule is really flexible (includes working around logging off for social events, for example). It was some of the least stressful years in my life, if for no other reason than I got to sleep in every day (not waking to an alarm ever).
- cm2012 9y agoThat seems too low. Most drivers I use have been doing it for years. They wouldn't at those rates.
- jeffmould 9y agoThe number is a bit deceiving. As the article states, that amount is after you account for insurance, gas, wear/tear on the vehicle, maintenance, etc... So really the $3.37 is their "profit" before taxes are taken out. I am actually surprised it is that high. A driver working full-time in a city or area with high demand will put depreciate the value of their vehicle and drive costs up at a much higher rate than the average person.
- UncleEntity 9y agoFor every one who makes it there's probably (wild guess) ten that lose money after working a few shifts and never turn on the app again -- most people are like "I can sit my ass on the couch and not make money plus not waste my gas making billionaires even richer." Like all things there's a learning curve before you can consistently turn a decent profit too.
- bfrog 9y agoYou sure? I personally know people doing it as their primary income in a top 5 us city in pop. It's a grind.
- refulgentis 9y agoDoesn't your question prove the GP's point?
- bfrog 9y agoNot really, they've been trying to get a different job that entire time without success.
- trendia 9y agoThe recent internal Uber study found that long-term drivers learn how to optimize their rides for the highest fares. So there are significant differences between what the median driver makes and what the "pro" Uber drivers make.
- UncleEntity 9y ago> “The companies are losing money. The businesses are being subsidized by [venture capital] money … And the drivers are essentially subsidizing it by working for very low wages.” Last time I pointed that out I was downvoted for some unknown reason. My neighbor was talking about buying a new car to drive for lyft/uber and I was like "the trick is to tear up somebody else's car." We'll see if he heeds my advice though I kind of doubt it since he has an MBA and I'm just the resident slacker who happens to know the business.
- Kluny 9y agoI did the math on working for SkipTheDishes last year (Uber doesn't operate in my city). I really wanted it to be a good idea, but once I calculated gas, insurance and wear and tear on the car, it was an incredibly poor deal. That's with a paid off, cheap, car, too. Not for me.
- jimmywanger 9y agoYeah. Do you think that depreciation shouldn't be 39 cents a mile for an old bucket? Or do they have requirements for the age of your car? If you have like a 2000 camry (which runs forever) depreciation seems to be virtually 0, especially if you buy the car used and only pay like 1 grand. Also, I can imagine if you're just shuttling food around instead of passengers, you can get away with a worse car. Nobody wants to hop in a bucket and go somewhere, but food delivery doesn't matter.
- Kluny 9y agoI use Mr Money Mustache's figuring that each mile costs $1.55, then convert it to Canadian. $1.19 per km. Even a 2000 Camry will depreciate if you put enough mileage on it - if I was shopping for one I'd pay $5000 for under 120,000km, but not even a thousand for over 280,000km. But yes, you can get away with a bucket for food delivery. I'd say the best way to do it is on a scooter, but then you're really putting your life on the line every night.
- 9y ago
- throwawaylyfty 9y agoI ran these numbers when I had access to the data. Varies by region but this number is still much too low. Even if 30c/mile in costs is correct the hourly is still way off
- emmelaich 9y agoI've taken many Lyft and Uber trips in SF recently. It's amazing how many have new, high end cars. One driver was a PYT and recent immigrant driving a luxury Mercedes C class. Wasn't hers. Sugar daddy's? Something else? Doesn't make sense. I feel there's something else going on. Many will have a story about being hired to transfer a bag or a box. Drugs? Money? Guns? Even then there couldn't be enough business to make a good profit.
- s0rce 9y agoI haven't seen many. The few I have been in have been people just doing it for "fun" if they were bored or to keep themselves out of trouble. They never seemed to be the people coming in from Stockton or Reno and needed the money.
- TangoTrotFox 9y agoI find articles like this dubious when they state an outlandish claim, even if supported by a study, and make 0 effort to explain or justify the results. Instead appealing to the implied authority of said study, that the reader is apparently expected to unquestioningly believe. That number is obviously going to be controversial. How was it calculated? What assumptions were made? In their own article every single other source they reference provided higher numbers. How much higher? What were the exact reasons for the discrepancy? They did state that other studies showed higher earnings because "there are numerous ways to report income and to calculate costs and time and miles spent on the job." Why did this study report lower income, more miles, or higher costs? I wish the job of journalism was still to inform people, and not just to get people to click on things.
- throwaway0255 9y agoThis doesn't surprise me at all and it's because of hidden costs incurred by the driver, combined with an implicit bidding system that drives down wages. Hidden costs: 1. Vehicle wear and tear (cars cost you money when you drive them) 2. Vehicle depreciation (cars cost you money even when you aren't driving them) 3. Interest and fees associated with auto loans and leases 4. Insurance premiums 5. Gas 6. Unexpected/unplanned for tax bills But the feedback you're getting about your income is just the dollar figure that shows up in your account, which is vastly higher than the true amount you could reasonably keep as profit. It makes $10 feel like $100. Combine that with the implicit bidding system. And by this I mean, market forces will naturally saturate Uber and Lyft with drivers until the price falls low enough that drivers won't accept it. And because of the factors I listed above, that natural price point is practically guaranteed to be well below minimum wage. The whole setup is just beautifully engineered to trick poor people into thinking this can be a career. I've often thought about which is worse, this or Herbalife. I think Uber and Lyft might impact more people than Herbalife, and generally those people start with less, so I might give it to Uber and Lyft. Actually, it's also a profession that has one of the highest rates of workplace fatalities, so I'd definitely give the title to Uber/Lyft over Herbalife.
- Sam-C 9y agoTo add in to that, Uber itself seems to offer a lot of "helpful" services for their drivers, such as the cellphone they provide that only runs the driver app and nothing else, that uber charges $10 a week to lose.
- aianus 9y agoYeah, nobody does this. You just install the driver app on your personal phone.
- astronautjones 9y agoThe insurance point deserves further discussion - in many states your normal coverage is voided by driving for profit. So if you get into an accident where they can prove you were working, you aren't going to get anything. I know many people who are driving for Uber and Lyft and have no idea about this
- zouhair 9y agoBut hey, they are free to choose their own times and rides. You surely cannot put a price on Freedom. You get screwed a bit, well a lot but it is all for the greater good.
- davebryand 9y agoI question the authenticity of the $3.37 number when I see that the paper this article references was published by an organization funded by these bodies: Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, BP, ClearPath Foundation, Conoco Phillips, Duke Energy, Electricité de France, EnBW, ENGIE, ENI, Eversource, Exelon Corporation, ExxonMobil, Gas Natural Fenosa, GE, Golden Spread Electric Cooperative, Inc., Iberdrola, IHI Corporation, EDPC J-Power, Kiewit Energy Group Inc., National Grid, Norwegian Ministries, PSEG, Southern Company, Swedish Energy Agency, Toyota Motor Corporation, TransCanada Corporation I think Uber/Lyft economics are problematic, but these guys have pretty solid incentives to make Uber/Lyft look unviable. http://ceepr.mit.edu/support/associates http://ceepr.mit.edu/support/associates
- elmar 9y agoThis study only confirms the unspoken word for many years. Looks like these ride-sharing services are a race to the bottom, the only ones that are better off are the users.
- Clanan 9y agoInstead of giving in to a gut reaction, you should read the paper. All research must get funding in one way or another. If you exclude research due to funding sources and potential conflicts of interest, you wouldn't be left with much.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> If you exclude research due to funding sources and potential conflicts of interest, you wouldn't be left with much. If the majority of research is tainted by conflicts, that doesn't somehow make it any less tainted by conflicts. It's trivially easy to design a study to produce the results you want it to, just by selecting things like accounting methods at the outset. For example, one method of accounting is to allocate costs based on usage. So if you have a car and you drive it 90% for Uber and 10% for your own usage, allocate 90% of all costs to Uber. That makes Uber look really bad. But if you would have bought the car either way and the question is the incremental cost of driving for Uber, that accounting method is the sunk cost fallacy. It allocates large fractions of a bunch of fixed costs to the incremental use, like the original purchase price of the car, even though they're sunk and can't be avoided either way. And the money actually does taint the study, because the funders know the parameters of the study ahead of time and only fund the ones that will produce the results they want, which makes the results tainted by selection bias.
- jrs95 9y agoAs a former pizza delivery guy, this seems odd to me. Before expenses, I’d make between 12 and 20 an hour depending on the night. The car I drove then had a KBB value of less than $3000 and it would have been eligible to use as an Uber. I just don’t see how you could possibly have such high levels of expenses unless you were paying like $600 a month for your car.
- lsc 9y agoAs a passenger, I'm very often in $40K+ vehicles. Even on a 60 month loan, that'd be over your $600 number just on car payments.
- timcederman 9y agoIn 200+ rides, I don't think I've ever once been in a $40k+ Uber vehicle unless I've used Uber Select.
- lsc 9y agohm. It appears I'm off on my car prices. I thought japanese minivans were in that range, and with pool, those are really common. looking, they look closer to $30K than $40K if you don't spring for the extras. doing a survey of car manufacturer websites, my impression of how much vehicles cost appears to be around $10K high across the board. The base model honda accord is only $23K? that is way less than I thought. I use uberx to work, and pool home most days; I've used select once. I think I get a Mercedes C-class at least once a week, some of them looking pretty new. Oddly, I almost never see BMWs. I remember the other night I got in some giant four door American pickup that looked new and very expensive, but I don't know enough about trucks to recognize the model to verify that impression. Still, the standard Prius is gonna be like $400/month on a 60 month loan, and that's just the loan. I imagine that there would be much value in the vehicle after those 60 months, if you drove full time in it, and I imagine the Prius has lower operating costs than most vehicles in it's class. I do occasionally get tiny economy cars... but not very often, which seems weird, as if the major cost was the car, you'd think drivers would optimize for that by buying smaller cars, but that doesn't seem to be the case.
- john_wang_doe 9y agocentury labor exploitation through digital technology and the service economy
- john_wang_doe 9y ago21st century slave labor. Doesn't Uber and Lyft hall in majority of the profit?
- bbd 9y agoBased on the numbers we have, the average earnings per mile is close to $0.545, but the medium profit of $3.37 seems quite off.
- makecheck 9y agoI guess what makes driving different than other low-wage jobs is that it’s a relatively easy job to obtain if you already have the vehicle: you don’t have to do a bunch of interviews, you don’t need a huge amount of ability, you can start making money pretty much immediately. Having a reliable income can be important (as opposed to jobs that limit your hours, etc.). Of course, it’s obviously a terrible wage. Anecdotally, the drivers I’ve encountered were all doing it for extra side income and not as a main job.
- snakeboy 9y agoIn addition, driving in the comfort of your own car with your own music is genuinely more enjoyable than working in a greasy fast food kitchen.
- kerkeslager 9y agoIt seems that yet again, "efficiency" in startup-speak just means "offloading cost onto other people".
- Clanan 9y ago> Drivers earn a median of 59 cents per mile while incurring a median cost of 30 cents per mile, the report said, adding that for nearly a third of drivers, the costs are ultimately higher than the revenue. > The paper reported the average driver profit to be $661 per month. The posted $3.37 number is before taxes!
- BurningFrog 9y agoThe median driver, huh? I'd guess 90% of the Uber/Lyft miles driven are done by 5% of the drivers. The median driver is probably someone halfassing it like I did. Trying it occasionally for an hour or two, without much of a plan. Seeing what it's like.
- malandrew 9y agoPart-time drivers are also likely to already own their own car so factoring in 100% of vehicle depreciation is disingenuous. It only makes sense to father most if not all of vehicle depreciation for those drivers that are working full time.
- jonmc12 9y agoThis article is not informative. It leans on an MIT Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research study, with no publicly described methodology and a hidden "full" report. Its a waste of time for everyone imo. This type of "science" journalism is everything that is wrong with the intersection of media and research. Funding aside, the researchers are isolating a non-transparent, non-reproducible data finding, out of context, and feeding it to the press. On the other hand, the press is reporting this finding, and weighting believability upon credential, instead of reasoning. The head researcher of the article even lists his key credentials as follows: "..His work has been covered in numerous popular press articles..". Good, informative, transparent research? who cares, credentials are accumulating. The output is statistical nonsense. Its a complete waste of time for anyone looking for real information, because the findings are not contextualized in any meaningful way. The article does not come close to offering apples-apples comparisons of other surveys that would give the reader a working understanding of the economic dynamic it talks about. I'm so confident that the findings are meaningless because I used to own several businesses where I hired 100s of professional drivers. It would be easy to manufacture results like this $3.37 "median" finding. Many drivers in any given year start and quit with no idea of what the job entails or the economics, yes, even when you tell them explicitly up front. I've seen first-time drivers that want to use vehicles that get 12 mpg. Some drivers just shouldn't be drivers; they can't navigate, avoid traffic, or follow basic instructions. Many drivers aren't ready to treat the situation as a business with a profit and cost center - it's not trivial to quantify costs, and many people don't think that way at all. Also, some new drivers that might make good drivers, take some time to learn. They can take a while to work into a rotation and earn more lucrative rides. Also, many drivers take time to understand the principle that some times of day are busier and they will make more money during that time. Context matters, a lot. Also, I frequently ask Lyft / Uber drivers what they make. In many different cities. Its all about the same as I used to see in my businesses. It's not magic, the drivers who stick with it understand the system and make anywhere from nominally above minimum wage to maybe 3X minimum wage for the most capable and most opportunistic drivers. The basic economics of professional contract drivers has been about the same for dozens of years. I'd speculate what might have changed, if anything, is that Lyft / Uber have normalized driving as a profession, and have strong brands that attract more people. Maybe that results in higher churn rates than the industry has ever seen. That would actually be really interesting if a university researched that trend and explained it through quality scientific journalism. I feel journalists who are serious about presenting research findings will provide: 1) a complete and transparent understanding of the methodology of the findings, 2) impartial reviews from believable research peers, 3) a concrete and thorough description of the context of the finding. This seems like a minimum journalistic standard. It shouldn't be good enough to point to a dude associated with MIT and say "this dude says this thing so <press narrative>". If journalists rely upon credential, without reasoning, to assert truth, its just manipulation hiding behind assumed pedigree.
- felixk42 9y agohttps://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-deliver-part-one-understanding-ubers-bleak-operating-economics.html https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-delive... I have always thought Uber drivers are either mispricing their vehicle cost, or doing some sort of tax optimisation. If you have a nice car that you only drive a little bit on the weekend, so that most of the cost is in the fixed stuff (age based depreciation (a 5 years old Porsche with 0 mile is still 5 years old), insurance, parking etc), and the tax man let you allocate cost based on miles driven (I am not based in the US), then Uberring where you "try to get business" by driving up and down a highway would be great.
- msoad 9y agoLyft rents out cars on a weekly basis. If a driver completes enough rides they don't have to pay a rental fee. Rental includes maintenance and driver only pays for gas. That is much simpler to calculate. Someone should do the math on that.
- oh_sigh 9y agoThis headline is a confusing a statement based on what the paper says. The paper[1] claims "Results show that per hour worked, median profit from driving is $3.37/hour before taxes". The profit has subtracted from it amortized losses associated with vehicle wear and tear/deprecation. This makes sense knowing the nature of the business, but if a Domino's delivery driver, who similarly uses his own car for the job, says to you that is hourly wage is $9, would you assume that he was subtracting out vehicle deprecation? [1] PDF: http://ceepr.mit.edu/files/papers/2018-005-Brief.pdf http://ceepr.mit.edu/files/papers/2018-005-Brief.pdf
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoHysterical laughing... What was it Travis K said about people making shitty life choices?
- BurningFrog 9y agoStatistics is tricky. Remember that the median driver drives very few rides. The median ride is driven by someone who does it more or less for a living, and who makes a lot more money than this. Also remember that this single fact was cherry picked from the report to make a good headline, not to give the best understanding of the situation as w hole.
- vlovich123 9y agoIf people truly were making $3.37/hour full-time I think you would see very few drivers; it's grossly misleading to assume so many people aren't capable of managing finances. It looks like the full paper itself is currently embargoed so it's hard to examine the methodology. However, just looking at the math (assuming I did it right) it seems the conclusion are misleading (the numbers themselves indicate they probably just sampled all ride-share drivers throughout the US rather than full-time ones): revenue: $0.59/mile cost: $0.3/mile monthly profit: $661 Average fuel consumption is ~26.4 mpg so let's round to 25mpg Average fuel cost: $2.5/gallon Average number of working days/month: 21.75 Average number of weekend days/month: 8.65 0.59 * x - 0.3 * x = 661 0.29 * x = 661 x = 2279 miles 2279 miles/22 days = 103 miles. 2279 miles/8.65 days = 263 miles 2279 miles * 0.59 = $1344/month in income or $16128/year. 2279 miles * 0.3 = $683/month in expenses ($273/month in insurance, maintenance & repairs, $273/month in fuel, & $136/month in depreciation). . Average fuel price is $2.5. 2279 miles/25mpg = ~91 gallons. 91 gallons * 2.5 = 227/month in fuel. Where it gets tricky is we don't have data on the average speed of an Uber driver & whether the 103 miles includes driving around waiting for rides. Let's assume a conservative average speed of 40mph. 103 miles/day / 40 mph = 2.5 hours/working day/month. 263 miles/day / 40 mph = 6.575 hours/weekend/month. The faster you drive the less you work so if my average speed of 40mph is too conservative, then the average driver drives even less. It seems like this builds an average profile of a driver is one who picks up a rider or 2 on their way to/from their main job & then picks up some extra cash driving a bit on the weekend. The average driver probably doesn't consider Uber as their sole source of income but rather as extra income their making when they otherwise wouldn't be doing anything. Now of course that's probably less money per hour than they could pick up from picking up additional hours somewhere or even something like Task Rabbit. However the average Uber driver probably sees it as more reliable in terms of total revenue than Task Rabbit, it requires minimal effort, & it has extreme time flexibility that a second job wouldn't (just turn on the app whenever you want to make money). Anecdotally the full time drivers I've asked in LA & the Bay Area told me they're pulling in 60-120k depending on how many hours they put in & the area they drive in. I didn't know this but apparently Uber & Lyft offer a lot of incentive programs that only the most active drivers can t take advantage of that significantly bumps your income (trips/day, trips/week, miles driven, etc). If you're not doing it full time then you're not getting these bonuses which is going to further impact your $/mile (of course I suspect the fares & costs are higher in these areas too). Since 40% of your cost is fuel consumption, drivers doing this full-time are going to prefer fuel-efficient, cheap cars than the average driver doing this on the side. This is obviously a more complete picture than the misleading news reporting might indicate. *EDIT: As another comment pointed out, the cost numbers are artificially inflated. They're attributing to the entire cost of insurance to driving whereas from the model above the average driver already has a car. Thus they need to actually use the fractional increase in the more expensive insurance they need for the ride share vs what they would get otherwise. I suspect the same problem applies for depreciation where they're not using the fractional increase of depreciation cost due to driving more but just the overall vehicle depreciation which was going to happen anyway. Even the full time drivers probably would have bought vehicles anyway so the depreciation & insurance cost isn't reflective of that anyway. TLDR: The main problem of the "study" can be summed up as follows: they take income from those who do it occasionally & subtract the costs of the ones who do it full time. Given the threat ride sharing poses to personal car ownership, it's not surprising such a misleading study is sponsored by people who would be impacted by reduced car ownership.