10 ms·
California Losing Residents via Domestic Migration
- daxfohl 9y agoLike brexit and the over 70 crowd, how many Californians are voting for laws that they will not be around to see the results of?
- rootw0rm 9y agoTexas and Oregon are starting to look pretty nice. Too bad about the cannabis laws in Texas, though. As soon as I persuade the court to terminate my probation I'll consider selling a few properties and getting out of here, too.
- irrational 9y agoOregon sucks. Don't move here, I mean there. But, Texas is very nice.
- AcerbicZero 9y agoCan confirm. Oregon is terrible, and I've heard it's entirely full now anyway.
- wpasc 9y agoLol, Oregon is full?
- RosanaAnaDana 9y agoFull of hippies. And rain. Unless you are in the east. Then its super-rednecks, dust, and meth.
- HillaryBriss 9y agothere are only about 4 million people in the entire state of Oregon. that's less than half the population of Los Angeles County alone. and Oregon covers an area approximately 25 times as large as Los Angeles County.
- DrScump 9y agoCan confirm. I drove through eastern Oregon last summer. I also got killed. Twice. Then I took the CA plates off the car. It's a horrible place; stay out.
- Casseres 9y agoTexan here. We welcome y'all with open arms, just please don't turn Texas into the places that you left.
- fein 9y agoAustin is already on the path of SV. Perhaps you can keep Austin a containment zone for SF outcasts and the rest of Texas will be left alone. City folk usually aren't fond of sprawling rural areas, so you have that going for you.
- inetknght 9y ago> Perhaps you can keep Austin a containment zone for SF outcasts and the rest of Texas will be left alone. They're definitely more pronounced in Austin. But, (in my opinion: un-)fortunately, both Houston and Dallas are feeling the effects too.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tachyoff 9y agoThat depends on how you figure. Do you mean socially? Legally? Business-wise? There are a lot of complex forces at play to make Silicon Valley the way it is (including history). I don’t think it’s fair to tell any group not to “make” some city like their previous one. Furthermore, one nice thing about the American melting pot is everyone gets a voice. If enough people move to Texas and change its culture, that’s just something you have to deal with (or move, I suppose).
- commandlinefan 9y agoHe mentioned marijuana, though. I can easily see all 49 other states legalizing pot with Texas being the sole remaining hold out. For the next 100 years.
- tachyoff 9y agoThat would make its way to the Supreme Court well before that, don’t worry. Then it’ll either be legal everywhere or illegal everywhere. #federalism
- sremani 9y agoI went to Ft.Worth downtown few years ago, there is this place called.. Hell's Half-acre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hell%27s_Half_Acre_(Fort_Worth) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hell%27s_Half_Acre_(Fort_Worth... I would not be surprised Texas to have legal gambling and liberal MJ laws in the next 20 years.
- triviatise 9y agoJust be aware we are awash in guns. We have open carry, suppressors, full auto, no magazine capacity limits. There are AR15s everywhere. The state has overridden cities' ability to regulate shooting on large properties (over 10 acres). If you are anti gun you definitely wont like it.
- supercanuck 9y ago>Families with kids and those with only a high school education predominate among those moving from California to its top destination states (Texas, Arizona, and Nevada). College-educated 18 to 35 year olds led the way among those moving to California from its top feeder states (New York, Illinois, and New Jersey).
- mullen 9y agoI am loving that. Take all the people who don't have college educations and send them off to Texas, California can take the educated.
- logfromblammo 9y agoA cursory read of the graphics indicates that people with graduate degrees and higher-paying jobs are forcing the people with less money and less education out, and they are moving to states with lower costs of living.
- kenhwang 9y agoI'm not convinced this is a bad thing. What's wrong with having a higher educated, higher income populace?
- inetknght 9y agoWhat's wrong with diversity?
- RosanaAnaDana 9y agoSo imagine being completely unable to live in the place you grew up in once an adult, and forced to emigrate not from choice but financial necessity. Its pretty much a bummer.
- mywittyname 9y agoWe like to forget that much of the early USA was populated for largely this reason. Our ancestors didn't move half-way across the damn world because they wanted to, they were forced out due to circumstances beyond their control, be it oppression, famine, or a general lack of opportunity (no land or jobs).
- kec 9y agosomeone still has to mop the floors.
- logfromblammo 9y agoMy iRobot Scooba does that--poorly, but it does that. The Roomba handles the initial hard floor cleaning, and also the carpets. I don't have a robot yet to clean the toilets, but I hear they exist in Japan, and my parents have one on their most heavily used commode. Thank goodness California phased out most of its public telephones before sending all their telephone sanitizers on the 'B' Ark to Texas. Whether there is a problem in pushing out all the low-skilled labor depends largely on whether all the work that those people do is automated yet. My concern is that jobs that require some on-site human judgment, but not a lot of skill, will start to go unfilled before robots are ready to step in.
- randyrand 9y agoDemocratic states moving into California and Californians mostly leaving for conservative states. Interesting. There are multiple ways to interpret though.
- pcwalton 9y agoThe data's pretty mixed on that. For outflow states: Texas (#1): Solid R Arizona (#2): R Nevada (#3): Lean D Oregon, Washington (#4, #5): Solid D Colorado (#6): D Utah, Idaho, Oklahoma (#7, #8, #9): Solid R Georgia (#10): R That's 6 R, 4 D.
- ProAm 9y agoColorado is a very conservative democratic state.
- vannevar 9y agoIt might be more accurate to say that Colorado is a very libertarian democratic state.
- ProAm 9y agoFor most of it's history it has voted Republican, with only the last decade or so being Democrat [1]. But the state still holds a lot of very conservative views. It's very down the middle. [1] https://www.270towin.com/states/Colorado https://www.270towin.com/states/Colorado
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DoubleCribble 9y agoOregon is interesting in that it's D because of Portland. The state is mostly conservative small cities or rural and yet the population of the Portland metro area leans so far left and has such a large population relative to the other parts of the state that it changes the entire state. Remove Portland voters from the polls and Oregon would be R.[0] [0]http://pamplinmedia.com/pt/9-news/212726-70134-how-liberal-is-portland http://pamplinmedia.com/pt/9-news/212726-70134-how-liberal-i...
- djrogers 9y agoInteresting data, but: "The graph below shows data from the Internal Revenue Service on the movement of income tax filers in and out of California since 1990. (Data on tax filers does not cover the entire population because some people do not earn enough income to necessitate filing taxes.)" It also doesn't cover populations who don't pay taxes, and who get paid under the table.
- Taniwha 9y agonor does it include people who come to CA from outside the country
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe graph introduced with that paragraph comes from IRS data, the total population estimate (and the other material that is not that graph) is derived from the American Community Survey (which is not restricted to tax filers.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- stevenwoo 9y agoThis chart of U-Haul prices in/out of San Jose (in one form or another) made the news recently. http://www.aei.org/publication/san-francisco-bay-area-experiences-mass-exodus-of-residents-reflected-in-one-way-u-haul-truck-rental-rates/ http://www.aei.org/publication/san-francisco-bay-area-experi...
- tlb 9y agoAlthough, you should expect this with gentrification even when population remains the same, since wealthy people moving in are more likely to use professional movers.
- hirundo 9y agoI vacated California for New Mexico 14 years ago (No regrets). The price of a U-Haul was so high that I was able to buy a used, good condition 12 foot cargo trailer for about 20% more than the price of a same sized rental. I still have it and use it as a big storage locker. When prices get that lopsided it's time to go shopping.
- pascalxus 9y agoThe middle class can no longer afford to remain in CA. A combination of egregious housing policies and other anti-bussines/anti-people regulations stifle the economic well being of it's inhabitants. It's sad to see people having to leave behind their friends and families, for all this. Not only are people leaving, but the birth rate for millineials in CA hasn't been this low since the great depression: http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ln-birth-rate-20161220-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-ln-birth-rate-...
- mehrdadn 9y ago> but the birth rate for millineials in CA hasn't been this low since the great depression I think this might need a rewording to convey whatever idea you were trying to convey, because I have a hunch there weren't many millennials around during the Great Depression. :-)
- dragonwriter 9y agoAnd the birth rate for Millennials has been zero for pretty much all of history, except for a short blip on the late 20th Century. And that's not an effect limited to CA.
- corpMaverick 9y agoDon't forget the other blip on the late 10th Century.
- kridsdale1 9y agoWilliam the Conqueror’s father was a millennial.
- mehrdadn 9y agoAnd Jesus was born just a little too late to be a millenial. :(
- Casseres 9y agoNative Texan here. I and many other Texans I know welcome newcomers with open arms. We all just have one message though: Please do not turn Texas into the places y'all are leaving. There's a reason y'all are leaving after all. EDIT: Newcomers: We generally don't care what anyone does or thinks, we only care when people try to force us to conform to their beliefs, including what to do with our money, eg) raising taxes. Wow, the back-and-forth on upvotes/downvotes is crazy. Sorry, didn't mean for this to be controverisal.
- antimatter 9y agoThis is my fear as well. As a Californian who's looking to move to Texas at some point in the future, I really hope the people leaving aren't taking "California values" to Texas with them.
- whatshisface 9y agoOne of the greatest strengths of the Texas legislature is that almost everything is written in to the constitution, thereby being almost impossible to change. So for this reason the (proven disastrous) legal and business theories that have messed up housing costs in California would have a very hard time taking root here.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoOf course when the bad ideas bear their dark fruit, they will be hard to change too. But more seriously can you expand more on this "almost everything is written into the constitution"? Is this a back-door way of getting Swiss-style direct democracy. Skimming wikipedia it seems that amedments are passed by a referendum approving a legislative proposal (and this processes has happened hundreds of times). if this is the only practical way of creating legislation, then you basically have the people as a third house of the legislature.
- whatshisface 9y agoAmendments must win two-thirds of the legislature and a simple majority of the public. In some sense, it's a swiss-style democracy and-ed to one of the most conservatively designed legislatures ever implemented. Regular laws don't have to pass the same gauntlet, but because the constitution is so expansive nearly every new law has to get it amended to prevent a contradiction. https://www.laits.utexas.edu/txp_media/html/cons/0405.html https://www.laits.utexas.edu/txp_media/html/cons/0405.html
- krausejj 9y agothis is related to an article i just submitted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16478780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16478780 it costs too much to live here because of zoning. zoning is largely driven by local governments, dominated by homeowners who benefit when prices rise. but california might fix it with sb-827, which would prevent local governments from banning density near transit hubs. california builds <100k units per year. McKinsey did a deep dive that shows that sb-827 could unlock 3 million units—this would be transformational. https://standupcalifornia.com https://standupcalifornia.com (this is my site supporting sb-827) please, if you care about california, learn about these issues and support sb-827!!!
- nosuchthing 9y agoNote that upvotes should come from https://news.ycombinator.com/newest https://news.ycombinator.com/newest it appears to penalize the submission for voting directly on your linked HN page
- davidw 9y agoIt'd help fix it, but California's dug itself into such a deep hole that it'll take a while to fix it even with good measures like that one. The statistic that always amazes me is how Tokyo built more housing than the entire state of California in 2014. https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-costs-tokyo https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-... If you (as in the generic you, not the comment I'm responding to) live in CA, and care about this stuff, you should get involved with the YIMBY folks there. They're doing great work, and achieving real results.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoTokyo is huge though, it's population is about 1/3 that of the whole of California. So we are talking about a ratio of only 3+ in housing built per capita. Significant for sure, but hardly bizzare.
- davidw 9y ago
- joelrunyon 9y agoSan Diego is bleeding people to Austin. I wish San Diego would just make it's own state, adopt Texas' taxes and it'd be hands-down the best place to be in the US.
- cycrutchfield 9y agoYou want 2% property taxes at San Diego property values? Without Prop 13?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sk5t 9y agoIs there a place where owners of $1MM properties expect to pay less than $20K in property tax?
- air_ml 9y agoSan Diego? If you bought you house 20 years ago and it is worth $1M now, you probably pay $2k to $3k in taxes.
- mullen 9y agoI don't think this is true. My parents own a house near a $1M and they much more than $3K an year in taxes.
- air_ml 9y agoDepends on how long they owned they house. For example: https://www.redfin.com/CA/San-Diego/2443-Curlew-St-92101/home/5748778#public-records https://www.redfin.com/CA/San-Diego/2443-Curlew-St-92101/hom...
- aidenn0 9y agoMy house is worth almost double what I paid for it and yet I would vote against prop 13 in a heartbeat. Even if it were repealed today, it will take at least a decade to recover from the harm it has done to the municipalities.
- dragonwriter 9y agoFar less than it was between 1990-2006, as the source notes; the geographic and income distribution is interesting.
- higginsc 9y agoI appreciate the effort that went into making this, but I get really annoyed with analyses like this that show heatmaps comparing highly heterogeneous groups (in this case, states, income groups, age groups, and education groups) that use an absolute scale. Of course absolute migration looks extreme in NY and Texas compared to, say Missouri or Iowa. This would be a much more interesting story if they used a lift metric that controlled for state/group size and/or state/group migration volume.
- DoctorBit 9y agoInteresting that three of the top five destination states (Texas, Nevada and Washington) have no state income tax.
- walrus01 9y agoSeattle is full and the weather is dreadful. It rains 364 days a year and the other day of the year is full of smoke from forest fires. Please consider Portland instead.
- politician 9y agoSeattle has plenty of room, and the weather is beautiful during the spring and summer. We had one smoky period last year due to a freak fire in BC. It's a great place to raise a family, and make a killing in tech. (I'm not currently selling real estate.)
- walrus01 9y agoSeattle is a hell on earth of rain, Amazon, heroin addicts and smoked salmon. Be quiet or the californians will hear you!
- chrisseaton 9y agoSome people quite like a rainy climate, and Amazon creates a whole tech scene of its own around it.
- walrus01 9y agoI'm guessing sarcasm doesn't translate well into text. Should have added more hyperbole.
- anthonyleecook 9y agoIt's no wonder that high-earning individuals are moving into California. A few numbers I ran across on the web: - Bay Area economy is growing 3X (!!!) faster than average in US. - Santa Clara region has an income average of $98,000, top 5 amonst the nation - Average salary for Software Engineers for San Francisco is $210,000 This of course doesn't bode well for mid to lower income citizens, who now have to move out as far as antioch or stockton to afford a home. Bad for a family of 4, still doable for singles that can room with roommates near work. We really do need to have more housing in regions that are underdeveloped and soon will be served by the BART extension, google's building foray in downtown san jose, buildout in the caltrain stops between Redwood City and South San Francisco, etc.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thereare5lights 9y ago> - Average salary for Software Engineers for San Francisco is $210,000 Where did you get that figure?
- derwiki 9y ago> - Average salary for Software Engineers for San Francisco is $210,000 Curious where you got that? I looked at the Hired salary info yesterday, and it was far shy of that.
- anthonyleecook 9y agoI saw it here: https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-average-starting-salary-for-a-software-engineer-with-a-BS-degree-in-San-Francisco-Bay-Area https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-average-starting-salary-fo... On second thought, this might not be accurate as there's no direct references. Indeed says senior software engineers is around $187,000 https://www.indeed.com/salaries/Computer+Programmer-Salaries,-San+Francisco+Bay+Area%2C+CA https://www.indeed.com/salaries/Computer+Programmer-Salaries...
- Dowwie 9y agoPortland Uber drivers complained about this phenomenon when I visited a while ago. Bay area transplants were buying into Portland through new high rise developments that locals detest.
- taborj 9y agoThis has been the attitude for years in Oregon. It's not just in the cities through new high rise developments; in the rural areas, they buy out the properties for cash -- generally above asking price -- which jacks up the prices out of reach for the locals. Frankly, it happens everywhere that the cost of living is lower.
- meddlepal 9y agoI'm sure there is a $$$ number that would convince me to move to California, but I'm not sure there are many companies willing to pay it and I would be super worried the entire time I was there about possible unemployment. I feel like there is going to be a blood bath in the Bay Area if we're actually in a bubble and it bursts. The next five to ten years should be an interesting ride.
- drdeadringer 9y agoLet's say we're in a bubble and it bursts. How would it be different from The Great Recession?
- hkmurakami 9y agoOne difference is that with a industry/geography isolated crash, we are unlikely to get the kind of federal stimulus support that we saw in response to the Great Recession.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoFrom a near-miss in my own life: A bubble that bursts may look a lot like The Great Recession. A bubble that bursts just after you move to a new city, where you don't have any professional track record? That's worse. A bubble that bursts harder in the new city than in the one you came from? I'd think hard before I signed up for that...
- gumby 9y agoIts funny that people fixate on tax when discussing this issue yet if you look at the numbers its high earners who move into the state.
- all_blue_chucks 9y agoCalifornia is also losing residents by discouraging migration via high taxes. For example, I had two job offers: one in California and one in Washington. Since this was a $200k+ job, that income tax in CA would have cost me $40 grand per year. Suffice it to say I now live in Washington.
- adamrezich 9y agoWA finds plenty of other ways to tax the hell out of you instead though :P
- dragonwriter 9y ago> California is also losing residents by discouraging migration via high taxes. California, despite high and progressive income taxation, has net in-migration at high income levels. If high taxes are keeping people out, it's things like gas taxes, road tolls, and sales taxes, that are regeressive relative to income.
- sureshv 9y agoCA State income tax on $200k is around $15k - not sure where the other $25k went unless you mean cost of living.
- gamblor956 9y agoYou appear to be quite bad at math, as other comments have demonstrated, so it's probably better for California that you now live in Washington. Snark aside, CA taxes do pay for a significant amount of government services. It may not always seem like it, but CA is the third largest state by area and the largest by population.
- wetpaws 9y agoUnfortunate reality of CA is that or every resident that's moving out there are two people going to take their place.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Unfortunate reality of CA is that or every resident that's moving out there are two people going to take their place. Actually, for every 6 moving out, 5 are going to take their place, per the article. But I suspect that a lot of the out migration isn't from the urban economic powerhouses and most of the in migration goes to them, so that for urban California, your statement may be closer to true, though exaggerated.
- tomkarlo 9y agoThe article seems to ignore a big group: California nets about 100K or more immigrants from outside the US each year, which would cover the gap in recent year. http://www.ppic.org/publication/immigrants-in-california/ http://www.ppic.org/publication/immigrants-in-california/
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The article seems to ignore a big group: California nets about 100K or more immigrants from outside the US each year, which would cover the gap in recent year. Yes, the article specifically about internal migration doesn't address external migration. > California nets about 100K or more immigrants from outside the US each year, which would cover the gap in recent year. Sure, but it doesn't change it from near balance to anything but even nearer balance; it's nothing like 2 in for 1 out on a statewide basis.
- tomkarlo 9y agoThe article's clear, but the headline is misleading, since it's not actually true that "California is losing residents" as an broad statement - it's more narrowly true that CA is seeing more people move to other US states than from other states, but I guess that's less compelling as a headline. California's population has grown every year since at least 1960, but the headline and article would make you think otherwise.
- cody3222 9y agoIt would be really interesting to see the difference in trends between the Bay Area, LA, and the more rural areas. Seems the housing price issue is much more of a problem in the Bay Area.
- chipotle_coyote 9y agoAccording to Trulia's market trend reports, both LA and Sacramento's median housing prices have increased faster in the last five years than San Jose's: LA went from $400K to $779K, a 94% increase, while Sacramento went from $143K to $305K, a 113% increase. San Jose went from $490K to $865K, a "mere" 77% increase. Stockton also more than doubled in the same period. Obviously one could argue San Jose was already overpriced, but in terms of trends, California's housing prices are kind of on fire -- you don't have to be in the SF Bay area for costs to be rising much faster than the national trend. (Which is still higher than I would have guessed: the median price over that five-year period across the entire country rose from $154K to $205K.)
- marcell 9y agoDoesn't the chart in TFA directly directly contradict the point of TFA? From TFA: http://lao.ca.gov/Blog/Media/Image/957 http://lao.ca.gov/Blog/Media/Image/957 Net out migration is at a fairly low level compared to other times since 1990.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Doesn't the chart in TFA directly directly contradict the point of TFA? No. Though it might contradict an incorrect inference about the point, which is not “this effect is getting worse” but “this effect exists, and here is a detailed breakdown”.
- vasilipupkin 9y agoIt's also noteworthy that a lot of people from Illinois are moving to California even though California income taxes are higher. It seems to me that the California outmigration is mostly from economically depressed parts of California, not from LA or Bay Area.