15 ms·
Nobody Wants to Let Google Win the War for Maps All Over Again
- craigyk 9y agoJust last week Google maps directed we take a turn going down the wrong way of a one way street that was already clearly marked as one-way on the map- yeah, I'm not too worried about even Google's dominance in this area. Also, Apple maps in my area has been quietly, but steadily improving. Still not as many POIs as Google, but nicer interface and turn-by-turn (IMO).
- unixhero 9y agoWaze
- gcatalfamo 9y agoGet me a waze _lite_ and I’m sold. But not current waze.
- unixhero 9y agoWade takes me from a to b in any country without effort and faster than any other. Wade it is. Yes the chat function is largely useless the report incident function is cool!
- macintux 9y ago> faster than any other Are you sure? Someone just did an interesting analysis (admittedly, very small data space but a long-term test), found that Waze claims faster routes than they typically achieve. Update: Ah, @dogecoinbase linked to it: https://arturrr.com/2018/02/19/navigation-apps/ https://arturrr.com/2018/02/19/navigation-apps/
- unixhero 9y agoI am here providing an anecdotal story. Zurich Switzerland -> Austrian Alps Heavy traffic, incidents along the road, gridlock ...> Waze got us there FASTEST. "ATTENTION" "WAZE HAS JUST FOUND A FASTER ROUTE". Competed against iPhone & Google Maps. Same way return drive. ... So two data points I guess. Austrian Alps -> Zurich Plus ... I use it daily... So three data points then.
- macintux 9y agoIt's entirely possible you're right, but I don't see how on any individual trip you can assert any solution achieved the best time, unless you have 3 different drivers to take each proposed route (and even then, there's enough variability to make it suspect unless you do it over a long enough period of time).
- dogecoinbase 9y agoWaze: https://arturrr.com/2018/02/19/navigation-apps/ https://arturrr.com/2018/02/19/navigation-apps/ I've experienced something interesting a few times in high-traffic situations (closed highways/etc) where byways produce time estimates which are instantly implausible as many people attempt to take them. It's interesting to think of methods Waze could use to predict optimal paths while accounting for its own effect on traffic.
- Chriky 9y agoWhere did the one way street thing happen exactly? I find it very interesting that it can do that, it implies a disconnect between the rendered data and the data used for routing.
- irrlichthn 9y agoIt could also be a simple routing bug. You cannot know.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jekdoce 9y agoThe thought provoking contrast presented in the article is camera derived sparse maps with lane lines, road edges, signs etc. vs lidar derived dense detailed models of the whole environment. Any thoughts around why the former is not enough? If it is enough it would certainly be preferable, since smaller in size and likely easier to maintain.
- tonygrue 9y agoMy guess is that the more detailed, dense map allows the car to precisely localize itself by using its view of the world to match against the map, yielding a location more precise than GPS (and for when gps doesn’t work); eg ICP point cloud matching/alignment/registration. More sparse maps would give you a less confident match, and you’d have to convert what the car is seeing to the sparse form.
- skgoa 9y agoThe former is enough, but having the latter makes it much easier.
- leoc 9y agoI've been wondering when Google (or someone else) is going to do the same thing for pedestrian routes and locations. There are plenty of highly-trafficked places where GPS is unavailable or not precise enough, and mapping WiFi stations evidently isn't enough to fill the gap. Of course the problem could, and should, be attacked by ground-based radio systems * , but 100% coverage by such systems certainly won't arrive anytime soon, and it wouldn't be like the tech companies to wait for it. You would have to take your phone out to get a location fix ... but that likely won't be the case whenever AR glasses really start to appear in public, and the techcos will also be happy to stick cameras on your clothes and luggage if they and you can get away with it. * Come on Transport for London, it's high time to show some leadership here.
- adventured 9y agoDo you primarily mean high density walking areas, or essentially everywhere that you can freely walk as a pedestrian?
- dannyw 9y agoHigh density, high intersection pedestrian areas. I’ve gotten so lost in Japan metros before, for example.
- leoc 9y agoNaturally you'd prioritise things like all the exits from major metro stations in tier-1 cities. Further down the curve, if it's viable to maintain a map of every public vehicular road in the USA then it would surely be similarly viable to map all the major public streets and squares in the centres of the world's tier-1 cities; likewise the major public interior spaces in their public-transport buildings. So that's your MVP; then obviously you'd go as far further down the long tail as technology and business make viable (and regulation permits). Basically it's just a combination of the SLAM tracking being successfully used already in VR and AR headsets like Windows "MR" and Oculus' Santa Cruz with the usual data-consolidating ways of Larry's Basilisk. I have a suspicion this may be the intended final purpose of all the nice Project Tango research. Obviously you could also use the database for things like photo location-tagging. Similarly, smartphone car navigation apps would want to be able to be able to use the data being collected for self-driving cars, too. You could also imagine self-driving street-sweepers taking advantage of the pedestrian-area data (or indeed helping to harvest it).
- erikb 9y agowell all my POIs are in gmaps and I have the app installed everywhere. No idea why I wouldn't want them to stay at the top. Push them please, so they improve their software, but winning they should.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- twic 9y agoI found it mildly amusing to see an article about concerns over data monopoly on a Bloomberg website.
- dx034 9y agoThey don't have monopoly on the data, just on the access. And they start to realise that this can disappear quickly if someone invests enough to provide a competitive interface (e.g. Reuters). Google's in a better position, replicating underlying data is even more expensive.
- dalbasal 9y agoA good example of new vs old generations of data monopolies. But, I think we need to stop thinking of the tech monopoly problem in principled, abstract terms. That's hard because it's how law works, and how our moral instincts genrally work. Bloomberg's data monopoly does/did pay well, give them a nice moat and such. But, it couldn't be leveraged in the same way modern data monopolies can. It didn't permeate into new areas every day. It didn't have all these consequences (eg killing privacy) of scale. They din't lock up a dominant position in categories (eg smartphones, cars) that wouldn't exist for a decade or three. Bloomberg's market position is more conventional. Being a monopoly gives them pricing power, and nicer margins. That is tame by today's standards. Today's monopolies can't even be reasoned about in the language of antitrust. they don't act as trusts, generally. Market share is obscure. How do you determine the effects of reduced price competition for maps? It's free. The whole logic of econometrically calculating the harm to a consumer is irelevant. Yet, the idea that Google owns your phone, browser, search engine, drives your car and controls the ads you see 100 times a day.... That's still a worrying thoguht. Economically, it's easy to see (eg search->maps->phones->cars) how one monopoly leads to another and they strengthen eachother.
- jbverschoor 9y agoNo pois, no maps. Google is unfortunately still the winner here.
- thriftwy 9y agoWe can have a hundred millions of self-driving cars dumping the sub-centimeter LIDAR data of surrounding to OpenStreetMap at any given time. Come to think of it, I see zero reasons why you won't own measurements of your self-driving car, and choose to upload them. Yes corporations may try to pass it as their intellectual property, we should fend them so hard they roll back into XIX century.
- Mediterraneo10 9y agoCars are going to lock down their LIDAR systems, so the best one can hope for is that the companies that control that data are also friends of OpenStreetMap and will pass the data on. I’m not optimistic that the individual owners of cars will be able to read from the LIDAR bus without – at best – voiding their car’s warranty.
- thriftwy 9y ago> I’m not optimistic that the individual owners of cars will be able to read from the LIDAR bus without – at best – voiding their car’s warranty That's one consumer protection law away. And no, I don't believe in "being friends with OSM". I believe in owning your data.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> That's one consumer protection law away “If you buy the car you own the data stream, and must be able to keep it private; read, modify and re-distribute it; and sell it” is a good idea. > I believe in owning your data Gentle political note. This sounds more radical than it is or than your argument needs it to be. The first suggestion stands well enough on its own.
- ximeng 9y agoNot sure open street map really wants to be in that business...
- Harrisonbans 9y agoWell, when this happened than really everyone no need to worried about to lose their home in the world.
- dalbasal 9y agoIt's worth stepping back and considering the landscape of self driving. First, the fact that it's within reach is amazing. It's one of those wierd cases where regular people instinctively put it in the "mars colony" category of futurism while sober insiders had to bring us back to a more optimistic view. Now, there is a lot to worry about in the current landscape of giant tech companies, and this article is another example. But, there are things to awe at too. Having self driving within reach... it's a result of massive effort. Amazing technology, and complexes of technology it is built on. This includes the manufacturing technology producing the cheap components. All of this cam from (1) fairly blue sky intiatives (2) with extremely long and uncertain payback periods and (3) tremendous strategic money-where-your-mouths are foresight. When I realized what G where doing with street-view, I thought it was crazy. More a sign of overexuberance and too much money. Turns out, it was en route to maps dominance which was en route to transportation dominance (and phone dominance). IDK if this is unprecedented, but it's fairly unrivaled in today's world. We don't see IBM or Intel, Toyota or McKesson thinking this big or this far. Definitely not banks or money businesses. Not cities or countries, generally. I mean an equivalent in health/medicine would be taking the ideas from TED talks. A personalized health revolution. Nanobots or curing death like Aubrey de Grey keeps talking about. I'm already hearing the "regulations" explanation. Medicine is restrained by surgeon generals, parliaments and national health setups. I don't think that argument holds at this scale. Self driving cars require re-rwriting our transport rules, and probably massive the physical infrastruucture. The technology will have sucked up billions decades before it makes a penny. The guiding idea is that "if we have a true self driving car, the other stuff will sort." Same applies to medicine. If it's better enough, it'll take. It's hard to peer back and determine of something was inevitable or not, but I suspect self driving wasn't. It could have happened (could will happen? tenses are hard) decades later, if not for the fairly outrageous decisions of a small number of people.
- oblio 9y ago> First, the fact that it's within reach is amazing. It's one of those wierd cases where regular people instinctively put it in the "mars colony" category of futurism while sober insiders had to bring us back to a more optimistic view. I think a Mars colony is closer than self driving cars. You need basically strong AI for fully self-driving cars. You just need a ton of money and an incentive for Mars colonies. Most of the science for going to Mars is already there, as well as the tech. I don't think we even truly have the science for wide spread, all-weather, all-terrain self driving cars.
- jpalomaki 9y agoGovernments should open all their mapping data, as some have already done. Probably in quite many countries, there are also entities collecting more detailed data that is used for the maintenance of the roads. All this should be opened up as well. I believe just giving out the data freely will benefit these countries more than trying to extract some small profits by selling it.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoHybrid approach: a compromise like the original public-private copyright deal, might be best. You tender your data to the government. Government publishes it but gives you exclusive rights for N years. In exchange, for the first 2N years, only those who have contributed can access others’ data. Maybe throw in some tax deductibility if the incentives aren’t strong enough.
- roel_v 9y ago"Governments should open all their mapping data" Most don't have a lot of useful data they collect/maintain themselves. It's often easier and cheaper to buy it from some party who gets others to pay for it as well, spreading costs. I used to think like you do, back when I didn't realize just how much work it is to maintain, and then to provide it to all stakeholders in the formats they require. Here in the EU there was a big push 10-ish year ago to make all this information free, at various levels; see e.g. the INSPIRE directive and all work that that caused. Nowadays people have experience with just how much work it is, and have experienced that the promised benefits didn't quite realize (for various reasons). Most enthusiasm is gone, I feel. (as a researcher, all this data becoming free/easy to download has been a huge quality of life improvement for me; but no more than that. I don't feel there is that much new stuff going on that wasn't possible before. Sure, before you had to chase people for weeks and sign all sorts of agreements, but the end results were more or less the same for professionals. Interested amateurs at home would give up in the past, but they didn't/don't produce all that much useful anyway.)
- pier25 9y agoYou can't trust governments to have updated and reliable data.
- crusso 9y agoOn any given day, there could be a half dozen autonomous cars mapping the same street corner in Silicon Valley. It seems kind of tautological that they're using autonomous vehicles to create maps because they need maps for autonomous vehicles. Yeah, I know, specialty equipment... but still. Actually, what seems really odd is that new maps are that big of a deal. The cars need maps for normal navigation, sure, but you wouldn't expect that they would rely on anything too precise for safety reasons alone. The cars need to be able to adapt to possibly changing conditions and can't misbehave (at all) just because a street closed, cones are on the street, etc. Unlike conventional digital maps, self-driving maps require almost-constant updates. The slightest variation on the road—a construction zone that pops up overnight, or a bit of debris—could stop a driverless car in its tracks. “It’s the freak thing that happens that’s going to make autonomous not work,” said McNally, the analyst. I would call an autonomous vehicle that couldn't handle some debris "fundamentally broken". Seriously, this mapping thing smells like a boondoggle.
- jcadam 9y agoAs someone who's old enough to remember road trips armed with nothing more than a Rand McNally road atlas for navigation (really not that long ago - and I do continue to take one along nowadays as a backup), I'll never trust an autonomous vehicle that needs to be fed a constant stream of up-to-the-minute mapping data in order to make decisions.
- rimliu 9y agoI am with you here. Autonomous vehicle may need GPS for navigation, but it should be able to drive down the roads without it.
- jcadam 9y agoGPS is a nice-to-have, but wouldn't be necessary for a true AI, given an autonomous car can have more and better on-board sensors than your basic-issue human (we don't have eyes in the backs of our heads, or LIDAR).
- jacksmith21006 9y agoBumped into this comparison of Google Maps and Apple Maps and it is excellent. https://www.justinobeirne.com/google-maps-moat/ https://www.justinobeirne.com/google-maps-moat/
- GoToRO 9y agoMotivated by a road that was on one map but not the other, I built this: http://comparemaps.drona.ro/ http://comparemaps.drona.ro/
- joshfraser 9y agoIt's not about mapping. It's about collecting data and training their machine learning algorithms.
- losteverything 9y agoNobody wants to let Google win again. I do. Google greatly enhanced my life, esp. Driving and directions. I was an adult BI and speak from experience
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]