7 ms·
When will the world reach 'peak child'?
- nine_k 9y agoA quick preview of the results: - The world has probably not reached 'peak child' yet. However, we are likely very close to a long flat peak; the number of children in the world will not increase much more. We are close to the peak. - A key insight from projections, under different scenarios, is that the number of children in the long-run will depend on how successful the world will be in providing education – in particular to women – in the short-run. This is because women that are better educated tend to have fewer children. If we are successful in providing accessible education for all in the near-term, there will be fewer children – and therefore less demand for education – in the future. - In the last part of this post I will discuss how the size of the population will change in different world regions. Crucial will be the African continent: fast development in Africa will slow down population growth, whereas slow development would leave African countries in an extended period of fast population growth. The latter scenario could see the African population growing 5-fold over the 21st century.
- joe_the_user 9y agoI don't think there's any uncertainty that the rate of child birth is peaking and is going to decline and continue declining. There's really no alternative path I can see. One could put it at urbanized, cosmopolitan women aren't interested in child birth unless there are positive options. I mean, first people thought China's one-child policy was reducing childbirth but a close look and efforts to dial showed the decisions were fairly well set. Brazil didn't have to have an education outreach program. Ordinary TV was enough to reduce the reproduction rate. And a variety of nations are looking at their negative reproduction rates (Japan, Taiwan, Russia, France, China etc) and finding there's no easy reversal. It's more like high reproduction are an exception in society's transitioning out of peasantry but after that, it goes down and doesn't go up again.
- dyarosla 9y agoSee your sibling comment for some uncertainty that still exists.
- zanny 9y ago> it goes down and doesn't go up again. Its almost like making and raising kids is a full time job, and in places where you have better alternatives to making no money and hoping the fruits of your labor support you 30 years down the line people would rather have a career. The day you reverse the reproduction rates in countries where they are negative is the day you recognize parenting as a skill worthy of as much credence as teachers, lawyers, or plumbers.
- nordsieck 9y ago> The world has probably not reached 'peak child' yet. However, we are likely very close to a long flat peak; the number of children in the world will not increase much more. We are close to the peak. I find this highly unlikely. There is huge selection pressure in favor of any population that is resistant to whatever is causing the general decrease in fertility. One example is the Amish. For quite a while, now, their population doubles every 20 years. So far they've managed to maintain their fertility, where other notoriously high fertility populations who are less culturally isolated have not.
- Jedd 9y agoWeird that religion isn't mentioned -- possibly too contentious -- but I thought the correlation within societies of high religiosity and reduced education opportunities for (or just general resistantance to the empowerment of) women was fairly well understood. Tracking changes in religious beliefs in different demographics can give us some good predictive insight.
- kasey_junk 9y agoIn previous studies of this I thought they had shown that when correcting for women’s education levels & wealth religion largely didn’t play much part.
- eximius 9y agoI think his point is that religion can be a causal factor of women education. I.e., suppression of women in extreme sects of Christianity and Islam.
- tim333 9y agoI'm trying to think of any Christian countries where they don't educate women. I don't think it's a statistically significant thing.
- eximius 9y agoMost Christian countries aren't dominated by Christian extremists. Look to cults or isolated sects, though, and you'll find the hallmarks of true patriarchal oppression.
- throwaway080383 9y agoOr perhaps (women's) education leads to abandoning religion.
- 534b44a 9y agoThere are many variables to this. I believe politics/economics, culture and religion do have their fair share of weight. For example communist countries, which have been ideologically opposite to religion, provided higher education to women, compulsory even. On the other hand I've read that in Nazi Germany women were also given quite a lot of rights and work responsibilities. I just yesterday searched github to investigate female employers of the likes of google and microsoft. A significant amount of them were Chinese or Indian. It's really about how much resources a country invests in free (university level) education.
- wyclif 9y agoIn the Philippines, never, given my observations of the culture here.
- xbmcuser 9y agoTHough I agree education will bring down the world population I don't see it happening in Asia or Africa any time soon. One of the major reasons for the change and drop in population growth in the west was not just education but the world wars where large number of male population was either fighting or died and resulted in woman joining the workforce in large numbers. Japan had a similar thing happen after the war. China because of its 1 child policy had a similar effect with more women entering the workforce and being educated.
- vadimberman 9y agoIn Asia, it has likely happened already. In the poster boy of overpopulation, Bangladesh, the fertility rate dropped from 6.2 children to 2.1 children per mother (https://www.ft.com/content/f60e2ddc-0bbc-11e1-9861-00144feabdc0 https://www.ft.com/content/f60e2ddc-0bbc-11e1-9861-00144feab...). No Asian country today has fertility rate above 2.5 AFAIK (except maybe the Philippines).
- harryf 9y agoYou might find it interesting to read up on other things by the late Hans Rosling e.g. https://www.google.ch/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/amp/world-39211144 https://www.google.ch/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/amp/world-39211... - one of his key arguments is the Wests beliefs about 3rd world population growth are largely outdated and lack awareness of how much progress has been made.
- lugg 9y agoHe has a lot of good videos out there but this is the one specifically covering Africa / population predictions and the misconceptions / dated knowledge. https://youtu.be/FACK2knC08E https://youtu.be/FACK2knC08E
- tropo 9y agoIn the long term, this can only happen when mortality is very high. There are lots of things that seem to reduce the rate. We can consider education, birth control, taxes, child support, alimony, custody laws, religion, heathcare costs, daycare costs, education costs... and in the end it doesn't matter one bit. None of that can possibly matter in the long run because the chance of having more offspring than normal is inheritable. You might point at birth control and ask how that fits in, but your ability and willingness/desire to use it is a mental trait that is at least partially inheritable. There is no escape from evolution.
- dnautics 9y agoYou don't see how a child born to a lower class family of 7 might not be less reproductively fit than. A single child from the the same class? Think of it this way, given what you know of class dynamics and sexual selection in humans, if your child had the choice of selecting between one in a random assortation, without knowing which was which, which one would be advantaged and why?
- tropo 9y agoLet's work that through. We'll do a few generations, starting with 8 families of each type, with each type on their own separate isolated island to keep things simple. We start with 16 people on each island, half male and half female. Going generation by generation: First: 56 kids, or 8 kids Second: 196 kids, or 4 kids Third: 686 kids, or 2 kids Fourth: 2401 kids, or 1 kid Fifth: 8403 kids, or extinction Now, your idea that a child of a large family of 7 is less reproductively fit isn't going to help the low-reproduction families at all. They go extinct; they are thus clearly unfit. Unless the high reproduction families are losing about 5 of every 7 to early death, their population grows exponentially. In reality, there are not separate islands. The resource exhaustion caused by the high-rate families will not just affect them. Everybody is effected. Even if the high-rate families are more affected, it isn't likely to stop them and anyway there is no saving the low-rate families from extinction.
- Franciscouzo 9y agoI don't share GP's view, but is a child of a family of 7 siblings 7 times less reproductively fit than a single child?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nimbius 9y agoIf you ask millennials, Peak child is already here. total fertility rates for the group are in decline. http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/millennials-say-no-to-kids-population-replacement-level-turns-negative/article/2640743 http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/millennials-say-no-to-kids...
- poniatowski 9y agoAfrica is going to be crucial What we have seen in the different projections of future global population is that Africa is the most influential and contentious. What happens in Africa now and in the coming decades will determine what size and structure the global population will have at the end of the century.18 It seems less certain what the future for Africa will look like; there is considerable disagreement between UN and WC-IIASA projections. Even the medium projections vary significantly between the two institutions: The UN projects a population of 4.5 billion while WC-IIASA projects a population of only 2.6 billion. This difference of 2 billion is just as large as the difference between the projection for the global population by the UN (11.2 billion in 2100) and WC-IIASA (8.9 billion in 2100). Whether the world population increases to more than 10 billion will be decided by the speed with which Africa develops – especially how quickly women get access to better education, women's opportunities within the job market, and how rapidly the improvements in child health continue. It's really quite astounding. If the UN's predictions are accurate, Africa's population will soar to 4.5 billion, with the Sub-Saharan part alone accounting for 4 of that 4.5 billion. Which means tens or even hundreds of millions of migrants flooding Western nations, making the current crisis seem like a drizzle when compared with this storm looming off in the distance. You would think this would be major news, discussed openly and often by the talking heads on cable news networks and given front page billing by major newspapers. Instead, you hear virtually nothing about it, unlike (for example) Peak Oil. Though not as famous as other dystopian novels like 1984 or Brave New World, this might yet prove to be the most prophetic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camp_of_the_Saints https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camp_of_the_Saints
- mc32 9y agoThe thing is we know how to contain pop growth and it does not have to be drastic like China's. India is trying to implement novel kinds of birth control[1] and in addition, we know educating women [and following into the workforce] helps bring down pop growth in a generation. So we know the solution, whether the world or locals are willing to implement them are another question. I don't think there is any way the world remains livable with 12 billion aspirational consumers. [1]https://www.wired.com/2011/04/ff_vasectomy/ https://www.wired.com/2011/04/ff_vasectomy/
- lalaland1125 9y agoI think all of these analyses contain a critical flaw in that they ignore the effect of evolution. Any characteristic that increases reproduction rates that is passed down to the next generation, whether that characteristic is cultural, location-specific, or genetic, will eventually become the majority. (And yes, cultural beliefs and location can be "passed down" to some degree.) This will result in eventual birth increases as pro-fertility adaptations build up. You can't assume that the system is static and that trends will continue when the math of evolution inherently promotes a pro-reproduction bias.
- llukas 9y agoUntil extinction event of course as environment is not infinite ;)
- vtange 9y agoSo you're saying this whole world is a game where if a species is not intelligent enough to know when to stop reproducing in order to save the environment, it's an inevitable game over? :)
- llukas 9y agoNot necessarily. (similar but not 100% same) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotka%E2%80%93Volterra_equations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotka%E2%80%93Volterra_equatio... Predators don't know hwne
- lacker 9y agoI do not believe the world will hit peak child, unless there is a catastrophe. Looking at overall birth rates might make it seem that way. But logically, in order to hit peak child, every subgroup will also have to hit peak child. Will every single country hit peak child? Will every religious group hit peak child? All it takes is one of those groups to keep expanding, and the world will not hit peak child. There are so many subgroups with drastically different birth rates and retention rates, I don't believe we will hit peak child. There will just be a transition period as the world starts to contain fewer Italians and more Mormons. For an interesting take on a single subgroup's demographics, the Amish, check out this article: https://medium.com/migration-issues/how-long-until-were-all-amish-268e3d0de87 https://medium.com/migration-issues/how-long-until-were-all-...
- jake-low 9y ago> In order to hit peak child, every subgroup will also have to hit peak child. This is an interesting argument; thanks for sharing it. I didn't understand it right away and my intuition was that you must be incorrect. But after playing with some actual numbers I've come to understand. In an attempt to restate your claim in a way that's more intuitive to me: If a group is reproducing above the replacement ratio, then they haven't hit peak child yet. So if only one subgroup remains that hasn't hit peak child, then that subgroup is also the only one that's growing (all others are shrinking). Assuming that trend continues (read: assuming subgroups have birth rates that reflect their culture, and that culture will be preserved in the next generation), this subgroup will grow without bound. The pressure-release on a system like this (one which the article you linked points out in its conclusion) is that birthrate within a subgroup isn't fixed. The birthrate among the Amish appears to be declining slightly, perhaps influenced by economic forces in the US. In your example, while it's true that _tommorow_ there will be more Mormons and fewer Italians than today, that doesn't guarantee that eventually the world will be populated entirely by Mormons, because the birthrate in that subgroup isn't wholly 'inherited' (in the cultural sense) -- it may change in ways that we can't forecast today.
- grondilu 9y ago> But logically, in order to hit peak child, every subgroup will also have to hit peak child. All it takes is one of those groups to keep expanding, and the world will not hit peak child No, it just has to make less children than it did eighteen years before.
- tritium 9y agoWhen space releases the pressure valve, and space-faring society represents a compelling alternative.