25 ms·
With teen mental health deteriorating over five years, there’s a likely culprit
- lazyasciiart 9y agotl:dr correlation between them all getting mobile phones and facebook. Perhaps because of the need to reduce it to six paragraphs, it is a very unconvincing piece.
- lisper 9y agoIt might be an unconvincing piece, but it still seems like a very plausible hypothesis to me.
- lazyasciiart 9y agoI didn't say otherwise. Plausible hypotheses are a dime a dozen.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI've got a plausible (to me) hypothesis of my own - namely, that the "kids these days are getting worse and worse" is something people have been thoughtlessly regurgitating for as long as we have historical written records, and that new customs or technologies are easiest to blame. Today it's Facebook, previously it was TV, earlier still it was walkmans and metal bands. Hell, if I'm to believe random quotes from the Internet, even earlier it was paper/pens and... books. "Facebook is bad for the kids" seems to be the cheapest thing you can write these days while being sure you'll have an audience that agrees with you.
- cwar 9y agoI think a big difference is social media causes people to constantly compare their lives to people's Facebook posts, which are usually people just sharing stuff that makes them look like their life is amazing. I know when I was in high school I compared myself to others and felt inadequate even without Facebook in my pocket. Now kids can just mindlessly scroll through a highlight reel of their peers and feel inadequate wherever they are.
- m4x 9y agoThey are not "thoughtlessly regurgitating" anything. Depression and suicide rates have risen significantly, and they are putting some effort into identifying the cause. This is stated explicitly in the introduction to the article.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoI think there is actually a bigger danger with people summarily dismissing negative consequences of technology, and then just saying "it's no big deal" because it's been going on a long time. Look at TV. Of course TV has many positives, but it's also another factor in people (at least Americans) becoming much more sedentary over the past 6-7 decades, which has been a large factor in the US obesity epidemic. It's a mistake to dismiss the negatives of TV just because we've gotten used to the fact that nearly everyone is so fat. Similarly, with social media, forget about teenagers, as I think many people are able to see the huge negative effect it has on their own lives. The fact that we're becoming a society that constantly compares ourselves to the idealized versions of other people shouldn't allow us to dismiss the obvious negatives of those comparisons.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoNot trying to dismiss all negatives; just biased against this particular flavour (kids getting sad or unruly is surely because of the things they enjoy, as opposed to e.g. broken economy visible every day through their parents). So I'm not dismissing e.g. sedentary lifestyle issues. > The fact that we're becoming a society that constantly compares ourselves to the idealized versions of other people shouldn't allow us to dismiss the obvious negatives of those comparisons I think social media is actually a step up here - the time spent comparing ourselves to idealized versions of our friends is the time not spent comparing ourselves to the apparent presence of all those celebrities and rich people, which was a constant of the previous century. Mass media broke the availability heuristic; the generic dysrationalia it caused in people is clearly visible. Which would be a kind of tech negative I'm not denying.
- wutbrodo 9y agoDid you read the article? Or even the post title? No one is talking about kids getting "worse", they're talking about trying to explain an uptick in things like suicide.
- rdiddly 9y agoWalkmans and metal bands came after TV. In fact so did miniskirts and the Beatles, each of which were also decried as the end of civilization in their turn. Nonetheless, just because people have been saying "the world's going down the shitter" for a long time, doesn't mean it's not.
- rmchugh 9y agoI don't think that's a reasonable summation, there is a correlation between mobile phone use while there are other studies showing teens assigned to use less of Facebook are more happy. The author could not find movement in other variables that could account for this change, although of course that does not prove that they don't exist (she only mentions homework and economic growth). It's obviously not definitive and she acknowledges this, but it is striking nonetheless.
- Al-Khwarizmi 9y agoThanks for saving me a click, the title is clearly clickbait.
- purple-again 9y agoExcept from 2010 - 2015 many teens did feel a crushing sense of economic dread as they dealt with the realities of student loans, an out of reach housing market, devalued college degrees, the gig economy, promises of no retirement, etc. The article just skims over it with a quick this is why economics couldn’t have been the reason.
- cwar 9y agoI don't think many teens (13-18) are doing much deep thinking about those things. I was a teenager about a bit more about than a decade before this time period, so maybe things were just so great then I didn't consider these things. But it seems like a stretch to me that a middle school or high school student is depressed because they are worried about retirement. Things like that were far too abstract to be contributing factors to my mental state at that age.
- dorfsmay 9y agoCurrently a father of teens... That is a huge subject of discussion in high schools. Teens do talk a lot about the economy, ROI of different degrees (nursing being the best, law school and engineering giving less chance of jobs and being much harder, everything else being useless), that their passions don't matter, they have to get a degree that leads to jobs, number of years before they can afford living on their own etc...
- eat_veggies 9y agoAm teenager. I'm not too worried about my future because I have some decent development skills. However, a lot of my friends are depressed because a lot of these issues really aren't so far in the future as to be "too abstract." It doesn't take a huge mental leap to realize that the college educations we're about to drop $50k+ on might not help us get jobs in the near future, or that working until we die will sort of suck, or that a pregnancy is an instant game-over (but it's okay, because apparently teens don't have sex anymore), or that most of the jobs we're going to end up getting are meaningless and will soon be automated away, so why not just off ourselves right now? It's scary. I sure as hell hope that tech now is the equivalent of the factory jobs of the 40's, so by the time my skills don't matter, I'll be set or dead.
- umanwizard 9y agodang : can we change the clickbait title?
- adamnemecek 9y agoIm sure smartphones could be a possible factor however one must not forget how depressing the whole high school experience is. I think that the pressure has increased quite a bit. The amount of hw has also increased. I don’t think that this suicide increase has been observed in say Finland.
- Pxtl 9y agoWell, remember that we're talking about an uptick. High school has always been soul-crushing for a certain percentage of the student body. The question isn't just what's wrong, but what's changed to make it worse?
- adamnemecek 9y agoI know we are talking about an uptick. He this been observed outside the us?
- JabavuAdams 9y agoThey address the homework issue in the article. They claim that time spent doing homework has not increased significantly between 2010 and 2015
- MBCook 9y agoI wonder how much of it with smartphones and how much of it was cameraphones (which may or may not be smart). When I was a kid you can make an idiot of yourself and nothing would happen. People would see and they may make fun of you, but that was it. Now if you choose to make a fool of yourself (or do it accidentally) you may get your picture taken/video made and now there’s proof forever to show other people. And it can be posted online. Where people on Reddit or something else will vote it up and share it. I imagine there’s a level of self censorship and self-consciousness the previous generations never had to apply to themselves. Having that kind of low level stress around all the time can’t be great. And that’s not including any pressure to look GOOD on pictures taken of you/taken by you.
- CryoLogic 9y agoHousing market is pretty bad factor. Most generations previous could afford a starter house on two minimum wage or a bit above minimum wage incomes. In many areas today you need two engineering incomes to pay off a 30 yr mortgage.
- bkohlmann 9y agoI'm not sure how many 13-17 year old teenagers were or are concerned with their ability to purchase a home.
- dorfsmay 9y agoMore than you think. They are concerned about being independent, which means affording rent which leads them to think about buy vs rent.
- djrogers 9y agoNo, there are a near-zero number of 13-17 year olds worried about how they’re going to pay their rent when they graduate from college. Those that do generally see things through the optimism of youth and assume everything will work out.
- abusoufiyan 9y agolol if anything teenagers can afford rent anywhere because they have no kids, no spouses and are quite happy eating cheap microwaveable food. They also are the least likely age group to demand lots of cleanliness and personal space, which drive up rents in most places.
- rdiddly 9y agoIt still affects them - what if their parents (or parent, single) can't afford to move them into a decent school district, for example?
- cwar 9y agoThe article says this is not limited to an economic class
- randomname2 9y agoIs it possible this is also in part due to EMFs from their phones (and environment) and circadian rhythm disturbances from screens? Some studies suggest the radiation can be risky to kids: Christ A, Gosselin MC, Christopoulou M, K’uhn S, & Kuster N. (2010 Jan.). Age dependent tissue-specific exposure of cell phone users. Physics in Medicine and Biology, 55: 1767-1783. Retrieved from http://iopscience.iop.org/0031-9155/55/7/001/pdf/0031-9155_55_7_001.pdf http://iopscience.iop.org/0031-9155/55/7/001/pdf/0031-9155_5.... Block, R. (12 July 2012). American Academy of Pediatrics letter to the FCC. Retrieved from http://www.scribd.com/doc/104230961/American-Academy-of-Pediatrics-letter-to-the-FCC http://www.scribd.com/doc/104230961/American-Academy-of-Pedi... Hardell L, Carlberg M, Hansson Mild K. (2009) Epidemiological evidence for an association between use of wireless phones an tumor diseases. Pathophysiology 16 (2-3): 113-122.] Hardell L, Hansson Mild K, Carlberg M, Hallquist A. (2004) Cellular and cordless telephones and the association with brain tumours in different age group. Archives of Environmental Health 59 (3): 132-137. Divan HA, Kheifets L, Obel C, Olsen J. (2008) Prenatal and Postnatal Exposure to Cell Phone Use and Behavioral Problems in Children. Epidemiology 19(4): 523-529. Byun, YH, Ha, M, Kwon, HJ et al (2013 Mar 21). Mobile phone use, blood lead levels, and attention deficit hyperactivity symptoms in children: a longitudinal study. PLoS One. 2013;8(3):e59742. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0059742. Morgan, L, Kesari, S, Davis, D (2014). Why children absorb more microwave radiation than adults: The consequences. Journal of Microscopy and Ultrastructure 2(4): 197-204. doi:10.1016/j.jmau.2014.06.005 Environmental Health Trust (2015). Wireless and Children. Retrieved from: http://ehtrust.org/cell-phones-radiation-3/wireless-and-children-3/ http://ehtrust.org/cell-phones-radiation-3/wireless-and-chil... Exposure to radio-frequency electromagnetic fields and behavioural problems in Bavarian children and adolescents. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19960235 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19960235
- jotm 9y agoAh, whatdya know, I said the same thing a while ago - we don't actually know the effects of long term exposure to so much radiation. But I think it's mostly the Internet - too much information, endless info streams, endless mindless entertainment, endless feeds of successful people (so it seems that everyone is successful, or making 50K/year, or pretty, except you and your family/friends/hometown).
- randomdrake 9y agoStudy: Increases in Depressive Symptoms, Suicide-Related Outcomes, and Suicide Rates Among U.S. Adolescents After 2010 and Links to Increased New Media Screen Time Citation: Jean M. Twenge, Thomas E. Joiner, Megan L. Rogers, Gabrielle N. Martin. Clinical Psychological Science Vol 6, Issue 1, pp. 3 - 17. November 14, 2017. Link: https://doi.org/10.1177/2167702617723376 https://doi.org/10.1177/2167702617723376 DOI: 10.1177/2167702617723376 Abstract: In two nationally representative surveys of U.S. adolescents in grades 8 through 12 (N = 506,820) and national statistics on suicide deaths for those ages 13 to 18, adolescents’ depressive symptoms, suicide-related outcomes, and suicide rates increased between 2010 and 2015, especially among females. Adolescents who spent more time on new media (including social media and electronic devices such as smartphones) were more likely to report mental health issues, and adolescents who spent more time on nonscreen activities (in-person social interaction, sports/exercise, homework, print media, and attending religious services) were less likely. Since 2010, iGen adolescents have spent more time on new media screen activities and less time on nonscreen activities, which may account for the increases in depression and suicide. In contrast, cyclical economic factors such as unemployment and the Dow Jones Index were not linked to depressive symptoms or suicide rates when matched by year.
- davito88 9y agocorrelation does not imply causation
- Faaak 9y agoNo, but its a pretty good clue.
- tomp 9y agohuh? It could very well be that teens who are depressed (because of unrelated causes) prefer to spend time on social media, not hanging out with friends...
- spurcell93 9y ago
- deckard1 9y agoThey did a study using Facebook. But I'm more curious about Instagram. "Look at all these rich beautiful people with millions of followers sailing around the world on their yachts." Ten minutes on Instagram is enough to fill any sane person with existential dread and bring about severe depression.
- MIKarlsen 9y agoNot as much as LinkedIn. LinkedIn is a fairytale-land for adults, and it's bizzare (to me) that anyone wants to participate. It's not even humblebragging anymore. It's "Look what I made, and what I achieved" packed into casual "Oh this thing? Yeah it's just my perfect life"-packages...
- wutbrodo 9y agoWhy would anyone browse LinkedIn? This is actually a serious question. I'm pretty good about keeping mine updated, but the only viewers I'm planning on are recruiters, who would be getting the same information regardless.
- MIKarlsen 9y agoIt's a good place to share information I guess. I would've liked it to be a bit more academic if I were to browse it more often. If you work in consulting etc., it's also a nice place to get updates on what people are doing, because everyone (over)shares so much.
- runT1ME 9y agoBecause Facebook/Twitter/Instagram is blocked at a lot of work places, while LinkedIn is not...
- uep 9y agoThat's ironic. To me, the implication of browsing LinkedIn at work is that you're looking for another job. Whereas if you're browsing Facebook or Instagram you're just wasting time.
- tw1010 9y agohttp://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations http://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations
- sigmonsays 9y agocorrelation does not imply causation. ALso, This page is hilarious.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yakitori 9y agoThank god for our daily "social media" is evil propaganda. I hope one day someone looks into who is pushing this and why. It would be very interesting. At this point, all the outrage and propaganda really comes off as manufactured and fake. Maybe it's a generational thing. When I was a child, it was south park, simpsons and gangsta rap that was ruining kids mental health. And video games were responsible for school shootings and all of life's ills. For my parents generation, it was TV, rock and roll and marijuana. Something always has to be wrong in order for the media to sell advertising to us I guess. If anything is leading to our collective mental health deterioration, it's the constant media barrage on tv, newspapers and social media telling us that we are depressed. But fear is what sells.
- vpribish 9y agoit's attention-seekers scaring crotchety, envious, gullible, olds just like it always, always, has been.
- root_axis 9y agoYour comment feels like cynical contrarianism. Just because everyone says social media is bad doesn't mean its not. The observed increase in suicide rates among teens is real and this study presents evidence that social media might explain this rise including careful controls for other factors. Is this study the end of the story on social media? Of course not, but it shows that there is some there there.
- lumberjack 9y agoToo quick to blame, "the screen". Is it really just the existence of social media that caused this, or is it maybe a change of culture that emerged with the spread of the Internet and social media? For example, today a child from a religious community might encounter atheism at 12 or 13 whereas previously they would encounter it when they went off to college. Maybe that child happens to be suffering from depression and their faith would have provided them with the hope that they needed to persevere, but having discovered atheism at such a tender age, they are left hopeless and desolate. Not mature enough to deal with their problems on their own and with no reason to believe that things will get any better. I am not saying that the rise of atheism is a factor. It is just one example I came up with, on the spot, to explain how the change of culture due to the Internet might be the actual cause powering this trend, rather than the usage of the social media itself.
- Momquist 9y agoI find your example is extremely odd and disturbing. Facing other mindsets and cultures at a young age as a reason, or at least contributing, to depression? That's really a stretch. Are children also at risk when meeting with other kids of different religions? It could shake their own faith too, by the same logic.
- flukus 9y ago> Facing other mindsets and cultures at a young age as a reason, or at least contributing, to depression? That's really a stretch. I can see it contributing. Humans are tribal animals and teenagers are the extreme of this with all sorts of cliques and clubs that form in high schools. Imagine being a teenager and discovering that your in the wrong tribe, then imagine that the tribe you like is "at war" with your tribe. Even with modern communications it would be easy to feel isolated without that face to face interaction.
- abusoufiyan 9y agoFacing other mindsets and cultures is wholly different in real life versus solely online. Why do you think racism / anti-Semitism / anti-Muslim sentiment is so prominent online and so much less prominent in real life? Why does so much research show that actual, in-person interactions with people of other backgrounds reduces the strength of racist stereotypes in people's minds?
- lsc 9y agoTuesday, this was the theme at my toastmaster's debate club[1] - I got stuck arguing that social media doesn't make you depressed. And... my problem with my argument wasn't that it was untrue, but that it was kinda mean. I don't feel jealous of the lives of almost anyone I went to high school with; quite the opposite. A lot of them post "racist memes with spelling mistakes" - which is sad on many levels; If nothing else, it is a certain indicator that they are not living their best lives... but I have a hard time imagining a world where I could be jealous of someone like that. For that matter, most of the positive social media content I see is baby pictures. I'm one of those people who is glad other people have children; I admire parents, yes, but I certainly wouldn't want to be one myself. I suppose I just don't get it. Do other people carefully curate their social media lists so that they are only following the super-rich, super-successful and super-articulate? because my experience with social media is that I see people closer to 'average' when I log in to facebook, whereas in real life, I live in a world where most people I spend time interacting with are smarter and wealthier and more successful than I am on several other axes. [1]The silicon valley "Agile Articulators" toastmasters debate club - we meet at the Hacker Dojo in Santa Clara. https://www.meetup.com/Agile-Articulators-Toastmasters-Club https://www.meetup.com/Agile-Articulators-Toastmasters-Club
- whatshisface 9y agoIf you really do look down on your old friends and acquaintances like that (so that you see their posts as all about being poorer and less articulate than you), then you're probably the one making posts that depress them. Imagine yourself as if you went to highschool in the society where you now work (so that now, the people you used to know are twice as educated and lots of them are far more wealthy), or perhaps imagine what it would be like to have stayed in your old town while someone else went to SV!
- lsc 9y ago> If you really do look down on your old friends and acquaintances like that (so that you see their posts as all about being poorer and less articulate than you), then you're probably the one making posts that depress them. Sometimes, yes, and that is the cause of some negative self-reflection on my part, but I think that there's another factor at work... I think that especially the "racist memes with spelling mistakes' crowd just values different things from what I value. For many of them, they see education as a negative attribute except to the extent that it intersects with income, (this attitude is creeping into HN, I think) and even then... you have to understand that unlike most of the people I work with now, I went to a school where scholastic aptitude was something you hid, if you were smart. >Imagine yourself as if you went to highschool in the society where you now work (so that now, the people you used to know are twice as educated and lots of them are far more wealthy) I've wondered what this would have been like. I mean, arrogance has always been with me; and I think I am a lot more aware of my own arrogance than other people are? But a big part of that is that for so many of my friends now, I am 'normal' or maybe even below average - just because they went to really exclusive schools then worked at prestigious places. They have a completely different view of what is normal. What if I always existed in a world where I wasn't "special"? I imagine I'd be a better person, socially. But maybe not? I dunno. >or perhaps imagine what it would be like to have stayed in your old town while someone else went to SV! I... did move back to my hometown for a while. It was... not an experience I care to repeat.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoScreen time is a symptom, not a cause. One of the vital drives of adolescents are to gain independence from their parents and figure out their own place in life. To do this, teens need to interact with peers, hang out, make mistakes, and generally be sociable. Our society, largely, does not allow this. Instead, safety fears, need for cars, etc, keep teens at home. So what else is a teen to do to interact socially with their peers? Online is the least-bad remaining outlet for this desire - if they can't hang out in a parking lot or whatever, at least they can take selfies on instagram or whatever.
- bpicolo 9y agoPeople are using smartphones as a replacement for face-to-face interaction. That's not just symptomatic.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoThe solution isn't to ban or reduce smartphone usage, like you would if smartphone usage itself was causing problems. The solution is to make it easier and more accepted to hang out face-to-face. Ban the phone and keep the isolating culture and you wind up with even more isolated teens.
- bpicolo 9y agoOf course. Banning phones doesn't make any sense and computers are pretty much the same thing in the context of home. Self-moderation is critical here, though hard to do
- jimhefferon 9y agoYes. I teach at a college. Every day I see scenes like a couple walking across campus, obviously walking together, but each on their phone instead of talking to each other.
- freehunter 9y agoAnd 100 years ago, your comment would read "I see a couple walking across campus, obviously walking together, but each staring silently at the sidewalk instead of talking to each other". Not every moment needs to be constantly filled with chatter, and if there's nothing to say, there's nothing to say. Sometimes just the act of physically being near each other is enough.
- greggarious 9y agoThis is anecdotal, but when I was a teen, I was bullied, and online was an escape. The idea of those bullies hitting up a Facebook, Instagram, or even just texting insults 24/7 would probably be jarring and depressing.
- rdiddly 9y agoYeah I was surprised they mentioned bullying in the article as a possible "real life" cause of depression, and not a "smartphone" one. Social media does make it easier for a bully to "connect" with you.
- limeblack 9y agoI find it interesting the article doesn't talk about physical health. Many of the mental health drugs cause extreme weight gain which can lead to depression.
- BenjiWiebe 9y agoWell the one I'm on definitely doesn't. /anecdata
- JSMustDie 9y agoBrowsing using Chrome with JavaScript/WASM disabled. Page loads: yes Images load: yes Texts loads: yes Proper layout: yes Initial scroll position: top CSS effects: yes Visual glitches: no JS disabled warnings: no Functionality disabled: unclear 10/10
- cteague 9y agoMany of you are speaking about the social aspects of smartphones and social media, but I think a big issue is also the cognitive impact of short-term gratification due to internet/tech addiction. Happiness often comes from feeling competent. If teens attention spans are dwindling due to this addiction, they are going to grow up without the grit to persist and develop skills.
- malux85 9y agoI see this in the students I mentor. Every single one of them cannot focus on a single task for longer than 60 seconds, which is severely hampering their ability to think deeply about abstract programming and data science problems. It's very frustrating, but they just cannot stop checking their phones for updates
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoI had this issue. A combination of the pomodoro technique and forced daily reading made a massive difference in my short-term attention span.
- JCharante 9y agoWhat types students are you mentoring? I've observed that groups of the best-performing students look down on those "addicted" to their phones and some have switched to flip phones.
- malux85 9y agoComp-Sci/Electrical Engineers - I've never seen any of them without a smartphone, or even heard them talk about their friends switching. Sounds like a good idea though :)
- matte_black 9y agoI would try switching to a flip phone but the problem is I want a cool modern flip phone not something that looks vintage.
- ouid 9y agoTeenagers get depressed when they are in love, their love is unrequited, and they are constantly reminded of that fact. Facebook facilitates all of these conditions. Why is love never mentioned in these studies as a primary motivator in teen suicide?
- guskel 9y agoOr just rejection and being a social outcast in general.
- sneak 9y agoMaybe phones need IRC clients.
- vlasev 9y agoI'm not sure if it exists, but it would be a good idea to implement something like a temporary "ex block" for a whole device - everything posted by a specific person would be filtered out for you ON ALL platforms. You wouldn't see their facebook, instagram, twitter or any other profiles for a predetermined amount of time. I know it may approach a Black Mirror kind of vibe, but still...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- simplify 9y agoI just read a good article that relates to this. The cause isn't pretty, though (and not related to a screen). https://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/us_5a6a144de4b0ddb658c46a21 https://m.huffpost.com/us/entry/us_5a6a144de4b0ddb658c46a21
- nate_meurer 9y agoThank you for this
- alkonaut 9y agoSo if we find this correlation to be causation, what do we do? Can the genie be put back in the bottle? I’m hoping that giving 12yo kids smartphones in ten years will be seen as giving them cigarettes.
- intrasight 9y agoWe should get some more research results from France now that phones are banned in schools
- xupybd 9y ago> For example, while conducting research for my book on iGen, I found that teens now spend much less time interacting with their friends in person. Interacting with people face to face is one of the deepest wellsprings of human happiness; without it, our moods start to suffer and depression often follows. I think this is really the key. The lack of face time is really hard. Social media is a poor replacement for real interaction. It's kind of like junk food. It makes you feel good for a bit but long term use leaves you sick and fat. You get too much of the stuff you don't need and too little of the stuff you do need.
- sologoub 9y ago> Interacting with people face to face is one of the deepest wellsprings of human happiness; That varies from person to person. There are enough introverts around who are completely drained by excess human interactions and need time to process and recharge. As a blanket statement this is very misleading. For those who tend more extroverted, it’s likely very true, but doesn’t make it true for everyone.
- xupybd 9y agoIntrovert here. It took me a long time to realise the role that face to face interaction had in my emotional well being. I was awkwardly shy and confused by most social interaction. I'd also get down a lot. Over time I learnt that I'd feel better if I made the effort to spend time around people and develop relationships. I'm still not great at this and would like to get better. But it's kind of like exercise yeah some people naturally enjoy it and some hate it but most will feel better for it. Perhaps this is not true of everyone. But I'd be surprised if it wasn't true for a very significant proportion of the population.
- Razengan 9y agoI think the "likely culprit" is, as it has always been, just the "human condition." The coming into an unknown world, ignorant of everything, constantly reconciling conflicting ideas, nagged by a sense of ultimate pointlessness, and the dread of inevitable mortality. However we may try to pooh-pooh these things away, they've been an incurable source of unhappiness since time immemorial. Humans cannot be truly happy unless we keep ourselves seriously deluded or constantly distracted; with biosocial emotions, religion, duty, hope, ambition, goals, pleasure or whatever. Throughout our history the distraction has mostly been provided by daily struggle for survival, but the comforts of civilization and technology, and the increasing knowledge of the species as a whole, have been laying us bare to the above. We probably either have to keep cooking up new distractions, or we'll need to sit down as an species and conduct a no-bullshit review of what it means to be human, and everyone's place, right and requirements in this world, and our combined place in the cosmos.
- abusoufiyan 9y ago>Humans cannot be truly happy unless we keep ourselves seriously deluded or constantly distracted; with biosocial emotions, religion, duty, hope, ambition, goals, pleasure or whatever. Typical internet denizen idea of humanity. Religious people are not all deluding themselves into happiness. Quite a lot of them find religion to be a framework with comes with its own sources of existential dread. Emotions are a delusion to keep us happy? Hope is also a delusion to keep us happy? ...what?
- Razengan 9y agoAlmost all of the things that drive us and govern our lives are based entirely on the approval of other humans or our biological needs; the approval of our parents, peer pressure, love, sex, academic grades, job, income, social/political/professional standing, or religion and the idea of deities, and even the worth/value of our contribution to society.. Would any of these matter at all to a different intelligent species? Say, a hypothetical species without any gender. Poof. More than half of human values and aspirations become meaningless. "Happiness" that is to last for more than a fleeting moment depends entirely on what we choose to believe. That is some pretty flimsy grounds.
- wheresmyusern 9y agoi think the article is correct, but i also think that new perceptions about society are contributing to the problem. kids used to think that they could make ends meet, somehow. as time goes forward, that notion is increasingly replaced by the notion that there is no way to make ends meet or to have a good life besides succeeding in high school and then college and then in a fancy career. anything besides that is not really accepted or respected, from what ive seen. so imagine that you are a kid and you are in fact not up to the gauntlet of challenges associated with making all of that happen -- or imagine that taking on that huge challenge frightens you which causes you to do badly in school which then makes you even more frightened and hopeless. and you need to do all this while attending a public high school in the US, which are some of the most toxic, inhospitable and shortsighted places in the world. the whole thing a stupid cultural artifact that not only makes no sense (the economy will not function if everyone has white-collar jobs), but also completely overlooks the mental health of the people who are subjected to it. and its all made worse by social media, because kids know that if their life and career dont wind up being ideal, their entire social circle is going to be looking at it online. i was in high school when facebook first took off. i suppose im lucky because i got to experience high school before facebook (before modern social media) and i got to experience high school after. such a transition happens once in a lifetime. i immediately had a very bad feeling about facebook and felt really bad whenever i used it. when i was faced with the transition to a facebook world, informed by the memory of how i felt before facebook, i chose not to make an account and effectively opt out of online social interaction. its a decision that i have never regretted and one that seems better and better as the years tick by. i still cant understand why people use facebook. and im not surprised in any way that a world where everyone is on facebook has these kinds of consequences.
- verbify 9y agoTeen suicide isn't going up in Europe generally or specifically in the UK. It seems more likely to me that the uptick is due to a 2004 FDA black-box warning on antidepressants indicating that they were associated with an increased risk of suicidal thinking, feeling, and behavior in young people. It seems likely that prescriptions for antidepressants would go down and people avoiding taking their antidepressants would go up a few years after the warning.
- johnvega 9y agoSubtle accumulative micro attention brain hijacking that turns into detrimental habits. Overtime, it can be catastrophic. Perhaps it's less than 50 percent, but it's happening in a massive scale, so the actual number can be staggering. http://www.timewellspent.io/problem http://www.timewellspent.io/problem Our society is being hijacked by technology https://youtu.be/C74amJRp730 https://youtu.be/C74amJRp730 ... tech companies control billions of minds ... https://youtu.be/nay5w-FC08Q?t=5m https://youtu.be/nay5w-FC08Q?t=5m ... how we're steering 2 billion people's thought ...
- psb31 9y agoThis research is highly debated and is by no means a sure thing. The research so far has been correlational, inconsistent, and weak. Twenge hugely overstates the confidence we should have in the findings. See https://medium.com/@OrbenAmy/social-media-and-suicide-a-critical-appraisal-f95e0bbd4660 https://medium.com/@OrbenAmy/social-media-and-suicide-a-crit... and https://twitter.com/shuhbillskee/status/955070356091555840 https://twitter.com/shuhbillskee/status/955070356091555840 for some critiques of the work.
- autokad 9y agoWhen I worked for a research lab for a university attached to a hospital, facebook usage was highly correlated with diagnosed depression. it was unclear whether depressed people used facebook more, or using facebook more caused depression. the correlations with facebook usage and other illnesses was weak, but depression was not.
- abritinthebay 9y agoSpeaking from experience - the former.
- patientplatypus 9y agoMorons - "It can't be the economy because unemployment is low and the economy is booming." Except of course that rents are far outpacing wages and most people are getting by with make work. Almost all the US jobs created since 2005 are temporary https://qz.com/851066/almost-all-the-10-million-jobs-created-since-2005-are-temporary/ https://qz.com/851066/almost-all-the-10-million-jobs-created... I mean good lord, if I were 17 right now and knew it were only going to get worse as I got older I would be down right morose. I wonder how these authors could be so obtuse and out of touch. Author: Jean Twenge Professor of Psychology, San Diego State University Oh I get it. The authors are rich and far removed from the actual conditions of the job market. "Fooled by numbers" indeed.
- jacobolus 9y agoWhy do you think Cal State psychology professors are “rich”? Twenge has a salary of about $100,000/year. https://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/2016/california-state-university/jean-m-twenge/ https://transparentcalifornia.com/salaries/2016/california-s... Plus whatever she brings in by writing non-fiction books, delivering paid speeches, doing market research consulting, and maybe some summer job. That’s probably quite a bit lower than the average reader of this forum.
- patientplatypus 9y agoAccording to this she's at least in the 8th percentile (http://graphics.wsj.com/what-percent/ http://graphics.wsj.com/what-percent/). Meaning she doesn't have to worry about keeping a roof over her head or how to feed herself (that's 1 in 6 btw https://www.dosomething.org/facts/11-facts-about-hunger-us https://www.dosomething.org/facts/11-facts-about-hunger-us). So yeah, she's safely rich enough to be insulated from being wrong about poverty. And people will listen to her because she has a title (ie rich enough to pay for one) and so therefore they assume she is right. A complete dumpster fire the whole way down.
- jacobolus 9y ago>35% of all households in San Diego make at least that much (something like 180,000 people), and the percentage is significantly higher if you only look at mid-career professionals.
- mirimir 9y agoThe existential challenge for most teens is "Do I belong with peers?" I had a hard enough time with that, with only a few hundred schoolmates. I can't quite imagine how tough that must be on social media today. Bullying and mobbing are just so much more efficient. I suppose that one could argue that's it's just stronger selective pressure for toughness. "Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me." But now, words can hurt. Can destroy your life. Or so it seems. And what about the ones who survive? What sort of society will they create? I have no clue. Maybe we should manage social media like psychoactive drugs.
- cornholio 9y ago> Bullying and mobbing are just so much more efficient. That's a deeply insightful observation that should be centerpiece in this conversation. As others have pointed out it's clearly not "screen time", and if the effect is real, it's related to social media, not screens. My happiest days were spending 10+ hours on my Sinclair Spectrum clone, the screen certainly made me feel more capable and confident in my abilities than school work or social interaction. Yet, my social interactions were moderated by the constraints of real life, that strongly dampen agresive tendencies. I can imagine in terror what it means to be a withdrawn teenager now: technology permits cutthroat exclusion of the undesirables while ridicule is instantaneous and viral.
- cyphunk 9y agothat is a cheap shot. while it could be screens, it could also be the polarization of society. and while the polarization may also relate to the decentralizatoin of media and it's arbitration (enabled by screens), this too is more complex that just the screen.
- mordymoop 9y agoWeird that they so often write "screen" when they mean "social media". My eyes were glued to screens growing up. TV, PC, GameBoy, consoles. But his is only happening now.
- djsumdog 9y agoBefore I even started reading, I knew it was going to be an attack at the phone. A few centuries ago, they'd attack books. Look back at videos from the 1950s and people didn't talk to each other on the train back then either, their noses were in books, magazines and newspapers. By the 80s, the nerdy kids had headphones and cassette players. By the 90s, people had discmans. The trouble with articles like this is they don't explore the other factors. Maybe the simply access to information makes kids more nihilistic. And nihilism isn't a bad thing. The universe is absurd, we have no meaning except what we give to ourselves (through religion or belief of whatever). Maybe kids are just realizing this, and it has nothing to do with technology? Maybe they're realizing that because of technology. Maybe they see a wold that's yelling at them, calling them entitled, where they know they'll be in more debt and less paid than any other generation before them. Maybe it's just the pure knowledge of our place as cogs in the gears. There are tons of factors for where we are today. The income gap is getting wider, parents are struggling to give their kids a good standard of living. Many parents can't pay for their kids educations like the previous generation could because it's getting too expensive. The article says "every region in the country." Are they just looking at the US? If you didn't find similar numbers in Europe, where they have the same access to cellphones and technology, they you have to address the other issues such as health care, better pubic welfare, freedom of transportation and high standards of living.
- luckydude 9y agoI like the point of looking at Europe, that's a good idea. Anyone have any stats for Europe?
- jp555 9y ago“And nihilism isn't a bad thing.“ Becoming unwilling to manifest any faith in anything at all is absolutely a bad thing.
- abritinthebay 9y agoThat... is not what Nihilism is though? I mean someone who is a nihilist might think that but it’s not a logical consequence of, or foundational feature of, nihilism.
- redleggedfrog 9y agoIt's very interesting to me to see the attack on the article/research and the defense of the screen here. Reminds me very much of client change deniers.
- earenndil 9y agoObviously just a sample size of 1, but I -- a teenager -- am the only one out of all my friends that isn't depressed, and I'm fairly sure I spend more time on the computer/phone than all of them. Not to imply that the conclusion is wrong, I could just be an outlier, but it's likely just a rule of thumb when attempting to diagnose/identify potential causes of a problem.
- ineedasername 9y agoThey took the results of a survey administered 6 years apart and applied their pet theory to interpret the differences. The survey is done every 2 years by the CDC, so their findings have a prima facie lack if rigorous credibiltlity by ignoring the 2 administrations in 2011 and 2013.
- jrs95 9y agoThere's a lot of discussion with social media in regards to the impact of mobile devices on children, but I think the easy access to internet porn is arguably just as harmful. There are teen boys with erectile dysfunction because of this. I wouldn't be surprised if it had broader negative psychological and social effects as well. At the same time, I don't think we really have enough information about what the impacts of this really are. I hope some more research is done on this topic.
- comatose 9y agoWhile the unemployment rate may have "improved" it doesn't track people "leaving the workforce " due to giving up or running out of benefits. It was a considered a somewhat jobless recovery actually. With regards to smartphones "correlation does not imply causation." Needless to say I only read the first few paragraphs before determining this wasn't a well reasoned article.
- snegu 9y agoI am curious whether there was an equal effect for boys and girls. Most of the men I know are a lot less active on social media than women, but I'm not sure if this is also true for teenagers.
- cwyers 9y agoLet's look at the OECD stats for teenage suicide worldwide: > Teenage suicides rates have, on average, declined slightly over the past two decades or so (Chart CO4.4.A). While in 1990 there were, on average across the OECD, 8.5 suicides per 100 000 teenagers (15-19), by 2015 this rate had fallen to 7.4. Much of this decline occurred during the 2000s. Between 1990 and 1999 the OECD average teenage suicide remained fairly stable at around 8.4 suicides per 100,000, but this average fell across the 2000s before reaching a low of 6.3 per 100,000 in 2007. With the exception of 2008, the average rate remained lower than 7.0 until 2014, although it increased slightly in 2014 and 2015. https://www.oecd.org/els/family/CO_4_4_Teenage-Suicide.pdf https://www.oecd.org/els/family/CO_4_4_Teenage-Suicide.pdf
- djrogers 9y agoHow can the author look at something as broad as ‘access to a smartphone’ and not dive deeper? What are these kids doing on that phone that’s making them miserable? I have my suspicions, and it’s not candy crush...
- m3kw9 9y agoIs the faux social networks that sells vanity and likes over real substance and relationships
- saucymew 9y agoWould anyone with actual children who are living in the smartphone era care to comment? Blanketing "access to information leads to nihilism" removes social exclusion, FOMO, cyber-bullying, etc. from the conversation, imo.
- tritium 9y agoProtip: It’s not the individual’s mobile device usage patterns that are the problem. It’s the usage patterns of everyone else that turns out to be distressing.
- Kenji 9y agoI love how people blame anyone but themselves. What about family structure, hostile environment in kindergartens and schools, too much homework, lack of freedom to roam freely outside, etc. No, it's the screen. It's social media.