7 ms·
Illinois Ponders Pension-Fund Moonshot: A $107B Bond Sale
- conanbatt 9y agoPublic pensions. And people still argue that we should have those over 401ks.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoBecause investing in education and enacting policies to support raising families and future generations isn't popular for some reason, so we'd rather entrust our retirement funds in the hands of some politicians and fund managers, and if they end up making corrupt and stupid decisions, we can still raise taxes in the future, or divert funds from education and other social welfare to pay for the pensions.
- snarf21 9y agoDon't you think that the people who run the pensions invest that money with those same "fund managers"?
- lotsofpulp 9y agoThey're not, they have different risk profiles. There might be some overlap, but by and large, pension funds (especially taxpayer funded) take many more risks than the usual 401k index and bond funds.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIf I understand correctly, this is because (at least often) the pension funds are underfunded, and have to take risks because they have to have higher rates of return, because with realistic rates of return the contributions aren't enough to reach the specified level of benefits.
- underdown 9y agothe argument is between defined benefit vs defined contribution plans. The former are unsustainable as evidenced by illinois’ ballooning deficit, while the latter are somewhat variable in return.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt's clear enough that many pensions are poorly funded. I don't think it is clear at all that this is inevitable. (It certainly seems likely that they will be underfunded; why not pay for services with promises that someone else has to fulfill)
- lotsofpulp 9y agoUsually, when you're spending someone else's money, there is a moral hazard that you don't quite care about the return. Add to that fact that in the US, taxpayer funded pensions have NO rules (they're specifically exempt from laws regarding defined benefit pension funding), it's quite easy to see politicians giving away deferred benefits to government worker unions in exchange for votes today. The only person this affects (future taxpayers in 20 to 30 years), are mostly not at the table. And not enough people pay attention to local elections or understand the numbers enough to stop this.
- adventured 9y ago> Because investing in education ... isn't popular for some reason That's contradicted by the spending facts of the last several decades. The US invests more per pupil when it comes to primary and secondary education, than any other nations except for Switzerland, Luxembourg, Norway, and Austria. So there's the US - 330 million people - competing with hyper rich, tiny, Luxembourg - 600k people - on education spending per pupil. Our teachers are also among the best paid in the world. We've dramatically over-invested into classical education. Far too many people have run up immense student loan debts, when they should have acquired a trade skill instead at a small fraction of the cost. Germany is the model that the US should be following, rather than just blindly spending more on a traditional education path (which is not working out well). https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/10/why-germany-is-so-much-better-at-training-its-workers/381550/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/10/why-ger... http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/global_learning/2017/05/the_us_education_system_meets_the_german_dual_education_model.html http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/global_learning/2017/05/the_u...
- lotsofpulp 9y agoI should have written investing in education to teach students about their finances. You can go all the way through high school in America and never learn how to calculate interest or amortize or understand how investment returns should be calculated.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoOur teachers are, in many cases, very poorly paid. (Administrators, on the other hand...) If US teachers are paid better than in other countries, that's pretty appalling.
- Godel_unicode 9y agoThe US bureau of labor statistics says that the average teacher salary is $58k/year (with over 2 months of time off) while the average non-teacher salary is $61k/year (average PTO less than two weeks) with at least a bachelor degree.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- davio 9y agoReminds me of this: https://ianayres.yale.edu/sites/default/files/files/Mortgage%20Your%20Retirement(1).pdf https://ianayres.yale.edu/sites/default/files/files/Mortgage... Take out a mortgage in your 20s to finance your retirement so can diversify over a long time period.
- phyller 9y agoTaking out a mortgage and buying stocks on margin are different things. The author is recommending using margin. Taking out a mortgage and having money available to invest requires that you first own an unmortgaged house, or have significant extra equity in a house. And if you have that in your 20s, well, you are already really far ahead.
- nshelly 9y agoRight, but the mantra in the personal finance circles is "Mortgage Your Retirement" because you are borrowing all the money you will need to retire -- say $2m, investing it in the S&P 500 and paying that off over time. If the market goes up than you're that much closer to paying it off and retiring. The authors recommend only 2:1 leverage so only a 50% decline would wipe you out. The problem I personally have with this is the declining marginal utility of money. Losing everything (or a large portion) to squeak out better returns isn't worth it. There was someone on Bogleheads who posted about trying this, exhausting their student loans and credit cards, but unfortunately when they started it was Fall of 2007. The guy had pretty bad luck, but I'm sure it's worked for other people especially those who don't know it (e.g. "I bought options on Google in 2006!") https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5934 https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5934
- phyller 9y agoThis sounds like a horrible idea.
- kasey_junk 9y agoIllinois is well into “all ideas are horrible” territory.
- cobbzilla 9y agoWhat will stop legislators from siphoning off this chunk of cash? How much will be lost in infamous Illinois corruption? The system is already $129B in the hole; this smacks of desperation.
- rayiner 9y agoIs corruption the main problem? When I moved to Illinois in 2009, I was shocked to see it had public services like New York but taxes lower than Virginia or Georgia. State income tax was like 3% until recently. Obviously that wasn’t going to work.
- kasey_junk 9y agoAnd further one side of the equation (benefits) are constitutionally garaunteed but the other side (funding) isn’t. There is t a lot of room for corruption when allocation doesn’t happen. My big question in all of this is why the mid & early career governmental union members keep going along with the strikes. They are out of luck regardless and should be negotiating for fallback positions.
- scott00 9y agoThe unions simply want taxes to be raised to whatever level is necessary to pay them what they want. It's been a while since I did the math, but my recollection is the level of taxation required to balance Illinois' books is not completely insane (though it is high).
- tptacek 9y agoDoesn't that high number presume that businesses won't move over the WI and IN border to avoid the tax increase? Most of the economy of IL is minutes from those borders.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mkempe 9y agoIs there a term for a fund that takes money from people (let's call them "investors"), promises to pay them back that money plus abundant interest in the future, and doesn't actually have enough (or any) money to pay all of these "investors", so it resorts to borrowing money to keep payments going a little longer?
- AnimalMuppet 9y ago"Technically not insolvent"? "Extend and pretend"? "Fool me once, shame on you..."? "Greater fool theory"?
- pg_bot 9y agoIllinois is bankrupt, and the worst thing that you can do when you are bankrupt is pretend that you aren't. If I were a resident of the state I would strongly consider moving somewhere else as your taxes are going to explode, and services will likely be cut. The tax base is already shrinking which will cause a negative feedback loop destroying property values and new business formation.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Illinois is bankrupt No, it's not. Bankruptcy is a legal state, and one which is not open to US states. It's not even insolvent, which “bankrupt” is often incorrectly used as a synonym for. It may have a projected future insolvency, but that's a different issue.
- rayiner 9y agoInsolvency means your liabilities exceed your assets, or you can’t pay your debt as it comes due. If you’re a state like Illinois that has a constitutional restriction on reducing future pension obligations through a change in the law, then you’re cooking the books if you don’t count them as liabilities. And if you do, Illinois is almost certainly insolvent under the first definition. And since it’s not able to pay its bills in due course, it’s probably insolvent under the second definition too.
- tabeth 9y agoOut of curiosity what's the difference between a public pension, where all funds are invested into a 401K like device, vs. each member in the group having their own 401K? I know that's not how Illinois' pension worked, but wouldn't the former be superior as the highest principle results in a proportionally higher (raw) return vs. an individual's?
- Spooky23 9y agoPensions are awesome when funded. Illinois stole from its future by underfunding it.
- tabeth 9y agoSure, but my comment was supposing a hypothetical. Say you're a new state, Zion, and you have the two options available to you: 1) Simply let your employees invest in their own retirement via a 401k. 2) Pool everyone's money together and invest into a super 401k. What I'm asking is if (2) is better than (1), or not. Surely someone has tried a variant of (2) before. I agree though, that funded pensions are awesome. Since some organizations clearly have trouble with that, I was just wondering if there was a simpler way to ensure liquidity in the fund. I'm aware that money is already pulled together with a pension, however my understanding is that pension funds are generally "managed" where most people who use a 401k put it in some sort of index fund where it's pretty passive as it tracks the market in general.
- Godel_unicode 9y ago2) is how most 401k's work already. e.g. Fidelity has target date funds, and everyone in the 2050 target date funds has their money in one pool which Fidelity manages as a group. There are 401k's that allow investing in individual securities (or so I'm given to understand) but that's not the norm.
- lotsofpulp 9y ago(2) is what is happening now. It just so happens that everyone does it individually in their IRA or 401(k) and then buys mutual funds with it, hence their money is now pooled. Difference is you didn't have to risk a politician or union boss in the middle meddling with the funds, nor are future taxpayers on the hook for when there is a shortfall in the fund (incentivizing diversification by 401k owners).
- logfromblammo 9y agoHa ha ha. Not falling for that one, Illinois. You just want to take my money and find some way to never pay it back. If I really want that bond yield, I could just follow whatever investment strategy you had in mind on my own, thanks. Any tax advantage is more than offset by the additional returns that I'll get to keep for myself instead of handing over to retirees, and my expectation that the fund administrator will be as crooked as the boundary of a Julia set. Suck it up, accept you're "Detroit bankrupt", and amend your constitution now, or wait until after the state is "Puerto Rico bankrupt" and all the responsible parties are collecting their pensions from prison. The smart move here is to not be able to touch Illinois with an eleven-foot pole. Do not buy these bonds. Do not move to Illinois. Do not keep your money where Illinois can get to it. Maybe even get some vaccinations to avoid unnecessary illness.
- chaostheory 9y agoCalifornia's pensions are in trouble as well: http://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/politics-columns-blogs/dan-walters/article148181774.html http://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/politics-colu...
- gwern 9y agoI wonder if you could implement communism/socialism this way. If the supposed immortality of governments/pensions allows one to moneypump financial markets as easily as 'borrow at low interest, buy and hold and reinvest forever', what stops governments from asymptotically approaching 100% ownership of capital?
- milesvp 9y agoMy gut says that eventually prices will reflect a major player like this. Eventually it will get harder and harder for a government to borrow money to pump into other investment systems, or the other investments will get more and more expensive giving a lower yield. Couple this with the fact that the government still needs to deficit spend occasionally (or at least politically it's nearly impossible not to run a deficit) , means that they can't just buy and hold, but will inevitably have to cash out some of their holdings.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoIf done at the central bank level, you can simply print the money necessary to acquire equity investments. Japan’s central bank does this, and is slowly consuming the Nikkei. To answer the original post above, there’s nothing stopping the federal reserve from delivering communism/socialism this way except political will and leanings. The federal reserve mandates are to keep the country at full employment and keep inflation low. What better way to do so besides “seizing the means of production” through printing fiat. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-18/boj-s-etf-buying-is-said-to-raise-concern-among-some-officials https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-18/boj-s-etf...
- cnorgate 9y agoSounds like it's time for a change to the state constitution. Everything is a negotiation: "Because the state’s constitution bans any reduction in worker retirement benefits, the government’s pension costs will continue to rise as it faces pressure to pay down that debt, a squeeze that has pushed Illinois’s bond rating to the precipice of junk."
- jedberg 9y agoWhy would anyone invest in these bonds? By doing so, you're essentially investing in the State of Illinois as your hedge fund/bond manager (depending on the returns promised). Usually with a muni-bond, they are using the money for some sort of public infrastructure and then paying the interest either from fees gained through the use of that infrastructure (like a bridge or power plant) or through taxes. Here though the state is flat out saying, "we're gonna invest in the market, which you can also do, and hope we get better returns than you do so we we can skim some off the top".
- Spooky23 9y agoStates are sovereign and can’t go bankrupt. If they are general obligation bonds, you’ll make money and sell them to the next investor. If they are revenue bonds, you get dibs on the tolls, tax, etc.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> If they are revenue bonds, you get dibs on the tolls, tax, etc. This did not work out for Puerto Rico bond holders.
- RestlessMind 9y agoWe really need to prevent the short-term game played by politicians, where they promise rich pension benefits, do not contribute enough to the pension funds and kick the problem down the road for someone else to solve. The only possible solution I can see is to move from a defined-benefit system (eg. pension) to a defined-contribution one (eg. 401K). Everything else seems it can be gamed.