5 ms·
>> Legal and private entities that use the emblem and the name of the City of Sarajevo... With the word "and" in there, I'm thinking this is more about protect
by phkahler 9y ago
>> Legal and private entities that use the emblem and the name of the City of Sarajevo...
With the word "and" in there, I'm thinking this is more about protecting the emblem. Using an emblem (not a flag) of a government entity in certain ways might be construed as conveying something to the content. In other words, putting the emblem along with the name of the city might lead people to think a web page was produced on behalf of the city. I seriously doubt using the name of the city like in the blog is a problem.
I suspect in regard Sarajevo the author is deliberately making the situation sound more absurd than it really is. Having said that, I think his point regarding architectural works is valid. Publishing pictures of publicly visible objects - and buildings in particular - should not have legal hinderances.
- jhanschoo 9y agoIt would have been absurd if not for the cease and desist made to the FB page...
- jasonkostempski 9y agoI'd buy into the FUD a little more if the author had redacted the name for real instead of adding a black background color to black text. Selecting the text reveals the name. Obviously that's not going to fool a crawler.
- JonnyNova 9y agoCheckout the button at the bottom too. It uncensors the whole article.
- r3bl 9y agoAuthor here. As I have said in an other comment on this thread, the idea is that the city's name is easily discoverable. You can discover it by highlighting the text, clicking at the button at the bottom of the article, and by following the Wikipedia links in the first paragraph. I highly doubt that this decision could be upheld in the court. If they want to sue me, I'm ready to "pay for the damage caused" and face legal consequences. Casual Facebook users that are administering Facebook's pages are probably not ready to face the same consequences. And, since this is my blog, the only third party that could remove the mentions of the name without my consent is my hosting provider (arguably better protection than Facebook offers), but if they do so, I will put on a server on the Raspberry Pi and continue with the distribution.
- HenryBemis 9y agoHello Aleksandar, I hope you live somewhere Sarajevo's rule does not apply (e.g. anywhere else on this planet) and that you just happened to write this while just visiting there. Stay safe and well!
- ithkuil 9y agoWhy? A city (or a country for that matter) can be a beautiful place to live despites the brain damaged administration it might have
- j_s 9y agoPhysical safety
- r3bl 9y agoIn the chaos, speaking up is not that hard. I was the first local to talk about certain government entities in Bosnia & Herzegovina buying FinFisher software. I was the first to talk about the government testing Hacking Team software as well. Later on, I've worked on Panama Papers. And now, I wrote this. I am also far from laying low, as I have been a guest in two TV shows talking about my line of interest in the last two years (one for the local TV station in <REDACTED>, one on Al Jazeera Balkans, that aired to the entire country + Serbia and Croatia), and asked some tricky questions to the government representatives multiple times in open panels. The point that I'm trying to make is that I'm pretty sure I've pissed off some part of the country's government multiple (if not dozens of) times. And while I do take a higher level of precaution compared to the average Joe (VPNs, Tor, Signal etc.), I have so far not received any legal complaint, nor have I ever felt threatened.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- NeuroKix 9y agoI am not a lawyer, but I think you are the missing point of Decision about the usage of the emblem, name and the flag of the City of Sarajevo. Article 7 states that "... legal persons may be granted to use the name Sarajevo in a business (company) name or product name, provided their business activity doesn't harm and helps affirm its reputation." You using the name Sarajevo in a blog post or its title clearly doesn't violate this rule. That said, it's beyond me why someone from the city government would decide to enforce this rule on a FB page, unless it's being heavily monetized.
- IncRnd 9y agoHacking is illegal in many jurisdictions.
- IncRnd 9y ago/sarc <--- about what was clearly not hacking.
- TomK32 9y agoHe is making it absurd. In the article the author claims that he cannot name the city of Sarajevo and that view is of course bullshit. You can always write about something. The article's title is plain wrong, as is its introduction. Using the name (in a sense of making it your own or using if for something you sell) is a whole different matter though. The city of Sarajevo might not have a strong obligation to protect its name as say a music label defending their name against a computer company, but still they city has good reason to check on those things. Having said that, the city is of course morally wrong to use this power on a simple facebook page with vintage photos. They probably have a problem with some photos of times they rather want to forget (I see a photo from 1941 and IIRC that was under Nazi-occupation (stupid Italians, why would anyone ever want the balcans?)) If anything, the city should have invited the page's admins to their own tourist bureau, help them and make sure they know some basic rules about copyright (like not using photos with a Getty images watermark. seriously?).
- tgtweak 9y agoSo why is there no clause in the law that states this specifically. Legally, clear as day, it's written. If the city wishes to allow it, they should amend the law to say so. If they don't, that's as good as affirmation of their perogative, especially now with this publicity. Furthermore, the motivation to do that might be helped by the authors exposure of their tactics, justifying any sensationalism. No lies are written in this article. Even if only for pedantic reasons, a law should clearly state it's interpretation. Leaving it up to arbitrary discretion is a slippery slope, and a good way to find yourself in a censorship situation. It's all unreasonable and paranoia until you get a cease-and-decist.
- TomK32 9y agoThe law does specify it when it: "Legal and private entities". A blog post about Sarajevo can mention the city's name without falling under this law. The blogpost's title and introduction are simply wrong. Screaming wolves doesn't help the case of the facebook page, sensationalism cannot be justified here.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThe "and" is probably a large error, "legal and public" would be excluded, meaning public companies - who are probably the target of the law - in theory are not affected. Whether that matters depends on the legal background in B&H, similar errors in UK law have proved costly in the past.
- venning 9y agoI believe that the GP is referring to the other "and", the one here: "the emblem and the name of the City of Sarajevo".
- ValentineC 9y agoIt's possible that "public" could also mean areas controlled by the state [1], in contrast to the "private sector". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_sector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_sector
- IshKebab 9y agoIt's translated so you can't draw that conclusion from the text. But I think it is likely that it only protects the emblem, or the name when used in conjunction with the emblem.