9 ms·
China’s Economic Growth Looks Strong, Maybe Too Strong
- gthtjtkt 9y agoThere's an economist from Tsinghua University named Patrick Chovanec who used to do an amazing job of documenting China's explosive growth and the many ways in which it might have been artificially inflated (easy credit, shadow banking, fudged numbers, empty skyscrapers, etc.). His blog is still up, but unfortunately he switched from blogging to Tweeting in 2013 and it's been impossible to follow his train of thought since then. It's a pretty fascinating read (assuming you find dry economic posts fascinating) if you start sometime around the 2009 entries and go from there: https://chovanec.wordpress.com/ https://chovanec.wordpress.com/ Some of the ones I found most interesting: Beijing’s Bad Debt Bailout: Problem Solved? https://chovanec.wordpress.com/2011/06/02/beijings-bad-debt-bailout-problem-solved/ https://chovanec.wordpress.com/2011/06/02/beijings-bad-debt-... Big Losses Hidden on China’s Bank Balance Sheets: https://chovanec.wordpress.com/2009/09/23/big-losses-hidden-on-chinas-bank-balance-sheets/ https://chovanec.wordpress.com/2009/09/23/big-losses-hidden-... Even though they're almost a decade old they still give you an interesting look into how things work in China.
- oblio 9y agoMy guess is that China is inflating its numbers, but even so, the growth they've had is impressive and a lot of it is real. And even with further inflation of their numbers, I don't think they will be a paper tiger with nukes, like the USSR was.
- digi_owl 9y agoI can't help wonder if China is what the USSR could have been had not the hardliners come after Gorbachev, leading to turmoil and dissolution of the union.
- gwern 9y agoThey can only systematically inflate a little bit. By the exponential nature of economic growth, if you overestimate the annual 8% by, say, 2% for a decade, by the end that results in a huge absolute gap between the nominal and real GDP. But the estimates from other methods or just going to China show that the official estimate is fairly reasonable, certainly not off by 10x or anything. Which supports the smoothing interpretation: they do fiddle the numbers a lot each year but in different directions and so the net is minimal.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoMuch of it is real, China's growth has been outstanding! Then you encounter the occasional ghost mall or notice that many of the apartments in your complex are empty and wonder a bit about how much of it is real (probably a lot) and how much of it is just a bubble (probably a significant portion also). A lot of China's GDP growth is tied up in asset growth (e.g. appreciated real estate). So if/when that bubble pops, they will take a hit. Accordingly, in the Chinese news, they talk about supporting and nurturing what they call the "real economy" as a counter to that danger.
- IkmoIkmo 9y agoI'm not sure if the ghost stuff is really indicative of a failing economy. I mean, China is about 20% of the world population, you're bound to find emptiness. We're talking about city planning on a massive scale. 220 cities of >1m people are expected by 2025. (SF at 0.8m by comparison). China has multiple cities bigger than countries like the Netherlands, multiple cities 4x bigger than Norway that was recently in the news. It has 280m (rural) internal migrants. Compare it to the US working age population of is just 200m. The numbers are insane. In the US, we move 11x in our lifetimes of ~80y aka 13% of our population moves each year. Apply that average to China and you're looking at 170m migrants annually. And unlike US (a lot of urban to urban), in China there's a gigantic one-way rural->urban traffic, i.e., two people aren't switching urban houses and calling it 'moving', two people are leaving behind a rural home and needing an entirely newly built urban home. How do you accommodate that many people in new homes. Do you start building homes only after they're needed? Or do you build some capacity at a surplus, to cover expected growth? Probably the latter. It isn't much different from any company stocking surplus inventory. That's not an immediate indication of a failure of economics and a bubble. And do you only build in existing popular cities and just try to add to the periphery, or do you build-up new cities? Probably the latter, too. Plenty of other countries do it as well. Incheon developed very much due to overdevelopment in Seoul. Or here in the Netherlands, we now have close 0.8m people living in so called Vinexwijken. They're a development centered on a new ordinance concerning housing development between 1995 and 2005. Since 1995 our population grew by 1.6m or so, apparently half our growth went to these new locations created out of nothing. And we always have discussions about structural emptiness, big malls being built and remaining 75% empty for years. But the scale is smaller, the country is 75x smaller than China. We had issues with structural vacancy rates at a new 100k 'village', scale that up to 75x and you have a similar story. Yet the biggest ghosttown in China ia Ordos, planned for 1 million people, scaled back and built for 'only' 300k, and currently houses more than 100k and climbing. That's what is consistently called the biggest ghost town in China. For Chinese, both the size of the project as well as the timeframe (10 years of vacancy) is a rounding error. Don't get me wrong, there's definitely an asset bubble. But we've also been saying that for who knows how many years and I feel we tend to focus too much on symbolism of the ghost town narrative.
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 9y agoWhat makes you think that USSR was a paper tiger?
- oblio 9y agoThe fact that there were shortage of basic necessities in its last years of its existence. The fact that the majority of its exports were oil and gas based, like those of a petro state. This comic describes it very well: https://goo.gl/GAn5fi https://goo.gl/GAn5fi
- thephyber 9y ago> The fact that the majority of its exports were oil and gas based, like those of a petro state. What has changed?[1] I would argue that this neither confirms nor refutes your defense of the "paper tiger" assertion. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Russia#/media/File:2014_Russia_Products_Exports_Treemap.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Russia#/media/File:...
- oblio 9y agoRussia is still a paper tiger. Its economy is smaller than Spain's. There are two factors keeping it in "the game": - that huge stack of nukes - the ruthlessness of its mostly autocratic leader(s) Neither of those bode well for their future... ("it's the economy, stupid", and all that).
- m0llusk 9y agoNo toilet paper anywhere. Imagine that. Eleven time zones of no toilet paper. International Hotels in the center of Moscow had little stacks of 2 inch square wax paper if you were lucky. This was a completely dysfunctional and failed state.
- ameister14 9y agoNing Zhu has an interesting book on it: https://www.mhprofessional.com/9781259644580-usa-chinas-guaranteed-bubble-group https://www.mhprofessional.com/9781259644580-usa-chinas-guar...
- digi_owl 9y agoAbout those empty skyscrapers i think in part they are a gamble on workers migrating from the interior to the coast. But in recent years their government has started a program aimed at transferring some of the coastal activity inland. How effective that will be is hard to tell, but there are already interesting stories of hotels that have entrances on multiple floors because the city was funded in a valley between multiple hills. End result is that new roads go between the hills on bridges, passing right by the hotel. Sounds like one crazy place to live.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoThat sounds interesting. Are any of these stories available online in English?
- digi_owl 9y agoWell yes, i think the one i read was a blog or travel story from someone that visited the place. BTW, i believe the city in question is Chongqing. But sadly i didn't keep a bookmark of the story itself. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chongqing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chongqing
- goondabba 9y agoInteresting piece on the empty skyscrapers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pbDeS_mXMnM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pbDeS_mXMnM
- baursak 9y agoSeems like an outdated report. https://www.forbes.com/sites/wadeshepard/2017/06/30/ordos-chinas-most-infamous-ex-ghost-city-continues-rising https://www.forbes.com/sites/wadeshepard/2017/06/30/ordos-ch...
- shadowbantruth 9y agoAnother somewhat popular or not so popular opinion is that China reports gdp numbers lower than what they actually have. I don't know what to believe but putting it out there for discussion.
- evbots 9y agoDo you have a source for this?
- Symmetry 9y agoI think the OP might have been misunderstanding a thing that actually happens. Because officials are graded on whether they hit targets or not but they don't get extra points for exceeding them they have an incentive to under-report growth in good years so that a return to accurate reporting in bad years lets them still report growth. So there will be a combination of over and under-reporting of growth at different times, as was show in the graphs in the article. How China Escaped the Poverty Trap goes into more detail for those interested.
- contingencies 9y ago... except top-level officials are constantly shuffled between posts in different cities/provinces they have no family ties to specifically to prevent such corruption.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThat only actually prevents it if: (1) rotations are most often exactly one of the periods on which goals and evaluations occur (that is, understating growth that at least meets the goal never is expected to help you by making it more likely you can plausibly claim to meet a growth goal the next period), and (2) the rotating top-level officials have some other structursl disincentive to form a class identity and class norms (stack ranking where the top slice promotes into a national administration group and the bottom slice is demoted out of regional leadership, while the middle group remains, for instance, would do this, since everyone would have a strong incentive to make everyone else's results relatively worse; OTOH, this incentivizes an opposite kind of misreporting, so it's not really a solution.)
- melling 9y agoBy some measures China has already passed the United States: https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-10-18/who-has-the-world-s-no-1-economy-not-the-u-s https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-10-18/who-has-t... China, and eventually India, matching the United States will hopefully help increase R&D. For example: - Solar energy prices have dropped significantly because of China's investment. - Nuclear energy is dead in the US but lives in China. - AI - China will match the US, accelerating development - Mass Transportation - High-speed rail, maglevs - Electric vehicles - China has large EV quotas and they're the largest car market.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoOnly in PPP, which doesn't mean much because many things are more expensive in China than the USA (housing, cars, high-end goods, schooling, ...). For an equivalent lifestyle, you often need to earn more in China than the USA, so PPP seems to be a weird metric. - Solar is suspected to be heavily subsidized by the government. That isn't so bad for us as long as we don't produce panels, it has led to a solar revolution in the USA as well. - China still hasn't done its own production nuclear plant yet. Citizens are extremely wary of the government to do it right. - The point here is "will" rather than "does". China keeps touting how they will beat the USA in AI by 2020 or 2030 or whatever, but it is still all aspirational. China has a lot of talent and a lot of data work with (privacy isn't much of a concern), but claiming you are going to win a race is much different from winning it.
- nsypteras 9y ago"Citizens are extremely wary of the government to do it right." - I don't think citizens have much say in the matter... - it's worth noting that along with data and talent, there is money - China's dedicated 150 billion USD to AI as part of it's 5 year plan. Meanwhile the US is considering cutting scientific research funding by as much as 15% as part of 2018 budget
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago> "Citizens are extremely wary of the government to do it right." - I don't think citizens have much say in the matter... They actually have more say than you think. And also, the government also has a lot of its own introspection about nuclear, especially after Fukushima. Couple with the huge capital costs, and it isn't a sure thing for China. > it's worth noting that along with data and talent, there is money - China's dedicated 150 billion USD to AI as part of it's 5 year plan. Much of the current advances in AI are not coming from federal funding (rather, private companies who are using it). Nor can you expect Chinese academia to soak up that much money and use it efficiently. Again, China has a chance at it, but it is far from inevitable. It is annoying to me when they talk about how their success is a sure thing, the Chinese government used to talk about how they would clean up their pollution problem by 2015 in 2010 because they were going to spend a lot of money on it....
- Apocryphon 9y agoDocumentary on this subject forthcoming - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=55892jT06aI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=55892jT06aI
- fellellor 9y agoThe trailer sounds like typical documentary crap. I'll reserve my opinion for now. PS: This seems to be implying that the Chinese economy is all hot air, but none of the characters in the trailer looked like Chinese. If the banks sold a nonsense China story to "mom" and "pop" investors who know nothing about China, then what makes these guys so much more knowledgeable? Also, one shit company exposes the entire Chinese economy now? Aren't there any mediocre companies in the US? This extrapolation needs a lot more explanation. As someone who know nothing about this, whats likely is that some people in the US have way too much money in their hands and seemingly nowhere to put that. So they looked at China and pumped too much money there following a herd. To call that a conspiracy and a financial crime seems like a huge leap. I mean the same is happening in Indian stocks which are at a stupidly high level. It's more investor stupidity than some grand conspiracy.
- propman 9y agoI read a while back that local governments would significantly artificially inflate their manufacturing, construction, spending, and raw materials numbers. There were dozens that seemed so far fetched they were easily spotted as fake by a professor that did little research. When you have govt officials who are forced to increase growth and you'll look bad/fired if you don't and no authority is safeguarding this, then these actions seem fairly logical. Interesting to see how perception is sometimes as good as reality.
- beat 9y agoThis is, of course, completely different from the performance figures of departments in large corporations, because... um.
- colemannugent 9y agoThe parent never implies that it is. However, at the end of the day large corporations need to keep shareholders pleased to survive. They could lie all they want to themselves, but the shareholders would see through that and remove the bad administrators. China has no such mechanism to ensure accountability.
- beat 9y agoI'd argue there have been plenty of examples of large corporations delivering rosy figures, until they could no longer sustain the lie. Some years ago, I got an investment club to put some of our money in Harley-Davidson, based on numbers that hit our criteria perfectly. Too perfectly. A few months later, the CEO resigned, revised numbers came out, it became clear they'd been more or less cooking the books, and the stock tanked. This happens a lot. Worse, it happens with stock market darlings. Remember Enron?
- carapace 9y agoThe Mandate of Heaven? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandate_of_Heaven https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandate_of_Heaven
- 9y ago
- jbrun 9y agoHaving lived, worked and now running a B2B SaaS company there, the growth is real. Are the numbers exactly right, of course not. China is a massive, complex and not entirely transparent mesh of interests. Long story short though, there is a real middle class in China that is driving real consumer demand. This is starkly different to India, South Africa or Brazil where no real middle class exists. Much longer thoughts on America vs. China http://www.jonathanbrun.com/who-will-lead-the-world/ http://www.jonathanbrun.com/who-will-lead-the-world/
- DSingularity 9y agoThe middle class in America is disappearing I think. Chinese is probably the best language to have as the secondary.
- workthrowaway27 9y agoHow easily can a non-ethnic Chinese person integrate into Chinese society though?
- jbrun 9y agoYou have to marry Chinese.
- ddorian43 9y agoDamn Zuckerberg many steps ahead
- horsecaptin 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2_L71lFItk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2_L71lFItk
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- logfromblammo 9y ago