16 ms·
No One Wants Used Clothes Anymore
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoLocal thrift stores still desire these clothes. Having volunteered at a thrift store though, they are not a dumping ground for all of your dead relatives clothes and they are not a trashcan for all the clothes you've put holes in. If you have clothing which you could still wear but don't want/don't fit in anymore then consider donating. Especially consider it if you are a non-standard (American) size ie. not big and tall. Petite/short can be good for kids and adults, slim-fitting clothes are always in want, manual labor has a tendency to eat up shoes so decent shoes are always good and anything which was in fashion just a year or two ago is especially nice.
- neap24 9y agoHaving toured a Goodwill facility once, I was pretty impressed with the process for dealing with "garbage". They seem to have a fantastic process for squeezing every bit of value out of it before sending it to the landfill. Obviously, this won't be the case for smaller thrift stores.
- maxxxxx 9y agoMy girlfriend goes shopping at a thrift store and she finds top-notch women's clothing there which looks it has been used only a few times, if at all. Unfortunately men seem to wear their stuff longer so I have never found anything good in the men's section.
- ghaff 9y agoTo grossly overgeneralize, most men aren't as inclined as many women to get rid of clothing just because they're tired of it after wearing it a few times. Sure, I buy things that I decide aren't as comfortable or look as good as I thought they would be--and I'll donate them. And then there are the copious piles of giveaways I seem to end up with in spite of my best efforts. But by and large, I'm probably fairly typical in that I keep most things until they're stained or worn out. (And sometimes even then if I really like them :-))
- JTon 9y agoIn my part of the world men's clothing always seems to be several times the cost of comparable women's clothing. This may also have something to do with it.
- madengr 9y agoYou can get Kirkland brand men’s khakis at Costco for $20. Decent polos can be had for < $10 from JC Penny. Anyway, that’s what I wear, and they are good until the wife complains about the holes, and then some. I keep telling her I’ll someday fit into that favorite heavy metal T-shirt from high school; don’t throw it out.
- dvanduzer 9y agoSeriously? What part of the world is this? Are you talking about formal wear?
- jopsen 9y agoFashionable looking clothes for men in I would say Northern Europe is relatively expensive... because people buy brand names. Jeans, t-shirts the likes... 200-300 USD for a pair of jeans is quite common (above also exists). You can get dirty cheap, but men are stupid (me included) -- and to be fair the quality is pretty decent. I don't really shop in the US, because quality sucks.
- dvanduzer 9y agoSo what does a pair of high quality women's jeans cost in Northern Europe? I looked very hard for the article I read recently about a woman (in US) who just straight up stopped buying clothes gendered for women because they fell apart immediately. I am extremely curious whether there is a similar cost/construction problem in Europe.
- jopsen 9y agoCan't say I know much about womens clothing, but there a wider selection of less expensive fashionable clothes.. Like H&M, which I'm sure also compromises on quality. Obviously, women can also get highend, quality stuff. But for men it's either highend or the supermarket, there's few things in between. In the US my experience is that high-end stuff is being VERY high-end, and low end is becoming very low end... likely as a result of incoming inequality.
- wcunning 9y agoI've switched to exclusively wearing Brooks Brothers shirts from my local thrift store. They seem to survive to donation, being somewhat higher quality. I also find good winter dress coats and decent suits on a regular basis. It's there, though I'll grant that I might end up digging a little more to find it.
- DoubleCribble 9y agoFor those who question the value of rummaging through the riff raff at their local thrift shop, I refer them to this: https://www.hodinkee.com/articles/found-vintage-lecoultre-deep-sea-alarm-worth-over-35000-for-599-at-phoenix-goodwill https://www.hodinkee.com/articles/found-vintage-lecoultre-de...
- knieveltech 9y agoJeans and shirts are pretty much a lost cause. Every now and again you can get really lucky on formal wear. Example: Last spring I found a ~$1000 cashmere overcoat in my size at one of the local thrift stores for $20.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI don't have the skills to distinguish a 1000 dollar coat form a 20 dollar coat so even if I found one I wouldn't recognize it :(
- knieveltech 9y agoNeither do I. I saw the coat, liked it, confirmed it was my size, and bought it. On a whim I googled the brand when I got home. Point is, you typically have a better chance of scoring dressier stuff at the thrift store because it doesn't get beat to hell.
- Balgair 9y agoI'll second this. If you live next to a 'nice area' like in West LA, the Richmond, Walnut Creek, etc. then the local Good Will is a Goldmine for good quality women's clothes. It will all be a season out of date, but the clothes have been worn maybe once or twice by some super-rich person and they are easily 99.9% off. For best results, go the week after a Fashion Week in Milan or NYC, when 'last season' is now official.
- no_flags 9y agoGood luck finding any men's clothing if you wear size small or even medium. It seems to be 99% L and XL. Same holds true even for stores like TJ Maxx.
- distances 9y agoNot true in Europe at least, I seem to observe all sizes on racks
- smt88 9y agoIf the clothes are good enough to be used by a for-profit thrift store, they can be used by a non-profit. The problem is the clothes that no one wants and end up in the landfill, and thrift stores don't fix it.
- DrPhish 9y agoThere is always a place that will take old clothes, even if they are worn out. They are "binned" somewhat like CPUs. The ultimate destination for the lowest quality textiles is places that sanitize them and sell them to institutions and such as rags for cleaning.
- ben_bai 9y agoIf all else fails they are shredded and made into painter mats, industrial rags or even sound proofing panels.
- basseq 9y ago> They are not a dumping ground... They kind of are, and it's a role they seem to have embraced. In other words, a good % (50%+?) of the intake volume of clothes is not fit for secondary garment sale, and is instead sold "downstream" (in bulk) to tertiary markets ("poor countries", to use Bloomberg's parlance) and recycles to use as raw material. This is a source of revenue, too. In other words, most thrift stores play an important role in the recycling chain. Otherwise, clothes would go into the garbage. After all, I can't put them in the green recycling bin with my cans, jars, and plastic.
- svachalek 9y agoActually, if they're really ruined, most recyclers will take them with the paper recycling.
- TillE 9y agoReally? Even in Germany where a ton of things go in household recycling bins (including basically all plastics and composites), you'd have to bring ruined clothes to the recycling center separately. Definitely only paper/cardboard in the paper bin.
- dfox 9y agoIn many places in US you don't have separate bins for paper, plastics, glass and what not, but only one (usually green) recycling bin for everything that is somehow recyclable.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI actually got all of my "nice" clothes at thrift stores. Since you can get clothes there for $5-6 from brands that cost... well, drastically more than I'm willing to spend on clothes. The nicest clothes I wear are the cheapest clothes I ever bought.
- basseq 9y agoI agree. I have a few used sportcoats and overcoats from high-end manufacturers that I bought for pennies on the dollar. They are good-to-great quality, and thanks to "timeless" men's fashion, are still in style. You have to wade through a lot of crap to find the good stuff, though. Unless the source is an estate sale, donated pants are almost always at the end-of-life and shoes are always a joke.
- Jill_the_Pill 9y agoHere we have Consignment stores which work a little differently. The "donor" and the shop split the proceeds from the sale. Things start at a higher price that is still a good deal, maybe 1/3 of retail, and then the price falls on a weekly schedule. The shops are picky about what they'll take, but the selection is usually great. Also, it might sound weird, but the clothes tend to be of better quality because they're the ones that stood up to a couple of washings (stuff that just falls apart never makes it there).
- uhhhhhhh 9y agoMyself, and pretty much everyone I know buys rags in bulk from thrift stores. They make money off the crappy worn clothes and I get cheap and plentiful rags. Out of style clothes in good shape seems to be the worst issue for thrift stores. Once the crappy clothes are turned into rags and the modern/stylish good clothes are sold, you're left with racks and racks of out of style/out of date clothes no on wants which is why it was donated in the first place.
- sevensor 9y agoWhat are you doing that eats up so many rags? I have a clothing downgrade cycle that goes from work, to yard work, to rags, and it keeps me adequately supplied, especially when supplemented by occasional worn-out linens.
- mitchty 9y agoWork on old engines, the oil, grease, dust, grime, soot, and the rest of stuff that accumulates means lots of rags.
- megaman22 9y agoI used to work at a power plant, and we would go through a pallet-sized box of rags every week or two. Grease, especially, eats them up
- Spooky23 9y agoCleaning. You can replace most uses of paper towels with rags.
- ultrasaurus 9y agoThere's also an argument to be made that people are over-claiming tax deductions for used clothing that becomes scraps for pennies.
- patja 9y agoPoor people don't itemize. Even fewer with the new tax legislation.
- calvano915 9y agoI'll take people getting a few extra bucks back from taxes for scraps vs. religious donations that offer no benefit to general society. Thrift stores offer employment opportunities to the disabled and ex-convicts, and provide an option for those that can't afford to buy new.
- module0000 9y agoI used to buy my work clothes when I was younger from a local thrift shop called 'Savers'. At the time I was working as a welder in a factory, and being able to get used jeans/work-pants for $2-3 a piece really helped out. I'd wear them out after about a week(lots of hot debris burns holes in them), and couldn't afford to buy new clothes constantly.
- alistproducer2 9y agoHaving worked in a couple thrift stores I concur. Only give clothes in good condition. If it's faded, stained, or holey just throw it out because that's what Goodwill is going to do and instead of helping them, you're costing them money (in labor).
- patja 9y agoYour experience with Goodwill is pretty much the opposite of mine. Goodwill (supposedly) provides important job skills training, including for many immigrants and refugees. In Seattle they specifically instruct everyone to give your worn out holey socks and underwear to Goodwill and DO NOT put them in the garbage.
- wefarrell 9y ago"they are not a dumping ground for all of your dead relatives clothes" What's so bad about dead peoples clothes? I used to buy lots of clothes at estate sales and I still have a few overcoats from them. I have a barely worn leather jacket and camel skin coat that I bought for a few dollars each, plus maybe 10-20 for dry cleaning. Women would buy clothes at these sales so dresses and women's coats would be more expensive, but for some reason I was the only one purchasing men's clothes. These coats have lasted me much longer than new coats that I buy from stores because fashion today is so disposable.
- anigbrowl 9y agoSome but not all.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoNothing is wrong with some of them. Frequently though we would get donations where someone had stripped everything off hangers and out of dressers, thrown it in trashbags and hauled it all in. Much of the clothing is unusable due to wear, almost zero of it is still in fashion and sometimes you get stuff no one will ever buy - used grandma underwear, stains and all (you'd be surprised how common it was.) The stuff you bought sounds nice and should be donated, I'm just saying that people should use a little of their own discretion.
- mindslight 9y ago"Discretion" is just not going to happen when it comes to estate donations. People are already feeling a huge loss, and the last thing they want is to feel that the decedent's possessions are also now just trash.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoI'm here to make it happen! (if only in a very small way) I'd say that people feeling a huge loss may want to reconsider whether they want volunteering strangers and probationers looking at their relative's undergarments, judging them by how many of their clothes are moth-eaten, how big their pants are, etc. Having done it I can tell you when my parents pass away, I will be donating a few select articles of clothing and trashing the rest.
- blhack 9y agoI haven't worked in a thrift store, so maybe you can fill me in on something: It seems like there are "scalpers" (can't think of another word for them) who semi-professionally go through thrift stores buying up the good things, and then reselling them on ebay. I've definitely seen this with sports equipment. (My fiance and I like going to thrift stores looking for art project supplies, and I always look over the golf clubs seeing if there is anything interesting in there [I am actually a golfer]).
- s0rce 9y agoSame thing with used book stores. Basically just exploiting arbitrage opportunity in the inefficient used clothing market. Unless you pay people to price things more accurately or can identify the resellers reliably this seems difficult to combat.
- philipkglass 9y agoIf you can price things accurately yourself the resellers won't have arbitrage opportunities and you'll make more money. And if you can't price things accurately yourself you'll gain nothing by excluding arbitraging resellers, so I don't see why they're worth trying to exclude.
- icebraining 9y agoAccurately is a misleading word. It depends on what your goals are. Maybe you prefer to make a bit less profit so that people can read more, as a public service. Or maybe you're just using those books to attract people into the store. Finally, the scanners don't know if you can price "accurately", so if you can, they're just occupying space and blocking ways for no benefit to anyone.
- mseebach 9y agoAll thrift stores I know of and have donated to exist to raise money for a charity. They should be thrilled to move stock. But the vast majority of books are next to worthless, so your "read more" crowd will have plenty of options, and won't care that some rare first edition got picked up for premium pricing. If scanners don't find anything to resell (because you've already scanned and correctly priced, or even listed online yourself), they'll leave soon enough.
- cableshaft 9y agoI don't know, good big & tall clothes are hard to come by, especially for a reasonable price. You don't get too many choices locally (JCPenney, Meijer for shirts, and a specialized Big & Tall shop that charges way more than I'd like is all that I know around me). I appreciated that there were actually clothes my size at thrift stores, but even at thrift stores there isn't a huge selection of them. Do they really not sell that much at thrift stores?
- mschuster91 9y ago> If you have clothing which you could still wear but don't want/don't fit in anymore then consider donating. But please only to local homeless shelters/refugee assistance organizations, and only after checking if they actually accept the kind/size of clothes you want to bring, as most of them only have limited space. This is also valid for stuff like sleeping bags or food. The "donation boxes" you see all over the streets in Germany (or those at charity organizations) are in fact often the worst of the worst - the charity organization may get money, yes, but the price of that money is the total and utter destruction of African textile industry. The "creme" aka first-class clothes goes to second-hand stores, the not-so-fine-anymore goes to Eastern Europe and the rest goes to Africa... and for local dealers it's hard to compete. Of course, the trade creates jobs, but the price of the countries not being able to produce anything locally and making them totally dependent on donations is enormous.
- DLwdTxdU6smHQA 9y agoSounds like a relevant piece of information to me. Have you got any pointers/sources for this?
- mschuster91 9y ago> Have you got any pointers/sources for this? For the African exports, sure - "mitumba" is the African word for "donated" clothing. If you speak German, public TV station ARD has a documentation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djXkFedpTrE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djXkFedpTrE (and newspaper Zeit has a short text, based on that documentation: http://web.archive.org/web/20120822083146/www.zeit.de/2011/45/NDR-Reportage-Altkleider-Luege/komplettansicht http://web.archive.org/web/20120822083146/www.zeit.de/2011/4...) For homeless/refugees: at least this is what the Munich organizations regularly state within their calls (and especially during fall of 2015, where people brought in way too much stuff for the refugees and there were severe shortages of space and sorting manpower). Besides, asking someone if he can use donations before getting on the road is always better ;)
- astura 9y agoThe local homeless shelter here doesn't accept coats.
- coss 9y agoIt's also a tax write off :)
- Accacin 9y agoOne of the things I loved about America (at least Sacramento) was the thrift stores! In the UK we have to go to charity stores if we want second hand stuff (usually), and they're mostly quite small. In American the store was huge and sold so many different things, I spent at least an hour or so wandering around!
- friendly_chap 9y ago> poor countries are turning their backs on the secondhand trade Perhaps those countries are not that poor anymore then?
- robotresearcher 9y agoAs the article says, mass production of new items is now so efficient that they are cheaper than recycled items, which have large handling costs.
- jackhack 9y agoThat's fascinating that it could be profitable, considering that many clothes may make two ocean crossings as they are transformed from raw materials (cotton), weaving into cloth, sewing into garments, and finally, retail sales at the local shopping mall. Surely it would be cheaper to keep it all local, right? Well, I saw a television program about a North Carolina company that is taking local-grown cotton, dying it with Indigo (also grown in NC), weaving it here, cutting and sewing it into a finished pair of blue jeans. Price? More than $200 per pair. That $20 pair of cheap jeans at walmart (there are several brands to choose from) looks a lot more attractive to my budget.
- kaybe 9y agoIf that $200 pair would have perfect fit and last about 5 years of daily wear, I'd be more than happy to buy. Sadly it's more random than that and buying a 30% chance instead of a 20% chance at 10 times the price is just not worth it. added: What works for me is to get the $200 pairs from the local flea market for basically free.
- bluGill 9y agoThat company is going for the premium market. If someone figures out how to automate more it would be cheaper once mass production takes off. But when you have cheap labor and shipping there isn't a lot of profit margin - we would need a much larger world population, or much less poor people who find working for $.50 an hour their best option for life.
- nerdponx 9y agoRecycle them into fashion items and market them as "upcycled". I'm not even being cynical - I'd buy it.
- yawebnw 9y agoThis is pretty common practice. https://commissarystores.com/collections/kostas-seremetis https://commissarystores.com/collections/kostas-seremetis
- freehunter 9y agoI live in a kind of trendy area (compared to some other places in the Midwest) and honestly this is the worst trend in resale. There are tons of resale shops near me that will sell a "naked" 1980s vintage coffee table (complete with coffee stains) for $299... if you get there the same day they take possession of the item. Because when the shop closes for the night they apply a layer of chalk paint (then wipe some of it off to make it look aged, of course) and now the price is $499. It's one of the most amazing rackets I've ever come across, taking $20 items from a yard sale, applying $25 worth of paint and lacquer, and selling it for $500.
- ctdonath 9y ago"A thing is worth what another will give for it."
- nerdponx 9y agoI'm not sure it's such a racket. They put in the time and effort to track down these items, and they also have to keep a storefront open, pay employees, etc. Sure, they make plenty of money, too. I skip the marked-up resale shops and hunt for the stuff myself. It takes forever and a lot of the time the junk you find is truly junk. And that's having it pretty good, with plenty of furniture discarded on the streets of New York City and yard/garage/stoop/estate sales happening constantly.
- mcguire 9y agoGreat! But there article is about the current difficulty of finding someone to take things that can't be upcycled---the specific case are mills in India that can no longer evonomically recycle cloth into emergency blankets.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoIn Ontario (Canada), Value Village[0] has been a staple of the working and lower-middle class for at least 15 to 20 years, and continues to be. I can afford new clothes more than I used to be able to, and I still choose to go there for some items. I regularly donate my old (still wearable) clothing to the CDA[1] or Value Village directly. I wouldn't say no one. [0] https://www.valuevillage.com/ https://www.valuevillage.com/ [1] http://www.diabetes.ca/ http://www.diabetes.ca/ - They're often responsible for the bin placement and even neighbourhood pickup of donated clothing and toys.
- terryjsmith 9y agoPlus kids clothes! My wife and I do about half of our clothes shopping for our 2.5 year old at Value Village and bring stuff there that we or she don't use anymore. She doesn't care about labels, the clothes are cheap, and she'll grow out of them in 6 months (and they may end up donated back again).
- snegu 9y agoEven Value Village sends the stuff they can't sell (which is probably quite a bit) to these recyclers, who it seems now can't really use the materials.
- jonknee 9y agoI don't know why you would donate to a for profit thrift store like Value Village. https://www.seattletimes.com/business/retail/state-ag-sues-value-village-claiming-thrift-shop-chain-isnt-as-charitable-as-it-seems/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/retail/state-ag-sues-v... The owner has a giant estate on Mercer Island near Seattle that's second only to Paul Allen's.
- ggcdn 9y agoIt would be interesting to visualize and put some numbers to the "cloth cycle". Here in Vancouver, thrift stores are everywhere and quite busy, and it seems like the majority of our used clothes end up in donation bins for them. Some items end up in the garbage, and unknowingly, it seems some make their way to other parts of the world.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Eridrus 9y ago> But longer-term, the industry will have to try to refocus consumers on durability and quality -- and charge accordingly. This seems like wishful thinking. H&M already operates programs where they accept old H&M clothes and give you a discount, working as both a guilt-reduction mechanism for those that want it and a customer retention strategy.
- baursak 9y agoCounterpoint: plenty of clothes shoppers in any local Goodwill.
- jseliger 9y agoTo my mind, this argues for buying a smaller number of very good items rather than a larger number of not-so-good items. I do grant writing for nonprofit and public agencies, and many people misunderstand the extent to which nonprofits want money, not goods—especially used goods—or volunteers: http://seliger.com/2014/04/20/volunteers-nonprofits-really-want-their-money-not-their-bodies/ http://seliger.com/2014/04/20/volunteers-nonprofits-really-w... . It's nice to see a mainstream outlet cover this underappreciated fact.
- cube00 9y agoGood luck trying to find those good items, even the high end brands are starting to slip.
- foobarian 9y agoIt feels like they got good at optimizing for revenue at the cost of quality, and who can blame them? But all I know is an old pair of jeans was made of heavier gauge thread and didn't wear through like today's. The most frustrating thing is the tags are not detailed enough. "Cotton" may describe the material but not the weave or the gauge of the thread.
- swozey 9y agoOutlier is great at this. Pricey and a bit overly technical but very high end. You may be able to find others in the list I posted in my last comment right above this. Example (click details); https://shop.outlier.nyc/shop/retail/nyco-oxford.html https://shop.outlier.nyc/shop/retail/nyco-oxford.html
- swozey 9y agoI like to refer to this list when looking for quality clothing. I've been slowly transitioning my wardrobe to a more lean BIFL high quality closet. It's specific to American brands. I do wish the list gave more details or why they were considered great but I own a lot of items from brands on the list (Redwings, Darn Tough, Pendleton, Alden, Duluth) and have found them all to be fantastic and typically with great lifetime warranties. http://www.acontinuouslean.com/the-american-list/ http://www.acontinuouslean.com/the-american-list/
- cantrip 9y ago"No One Wants Your Used Clothes Anymore" Notice that this is in the Opinion column. None of what's said here is even close to true. Plenty of people shop at their local Goodwill or Salvation Army, where clothes are vastly cheaper than buying them new. Not only are they cheaper, but the clothes are often better quality. Saying used clothes cost as much as new clothes and then citing an Indian blanket mill competing with Chinese manufacturers as evidence of this is disingenuous.
- mc32 9y agoYeah, when i was in college, i went to thrift stores. I'd get decent things on the cheap. By things i mean pants and shirts. No shoes or anything more personal. Today i donate my stuff to them. Even if they have holes, they can be recycled. I recall some guy in college who bought used clothing and shipped it to some guy who sold it somewhere in the Balkans, iirc. Do even if there isn't a local market, there probably is an intl market.
- houseofzeus 9y agoThe global problem is not the stuff that is in a good enough condition for resale. It's the stuff that isn't and still ends up in the donation bins.
- cantrip 9y agoI'm not arguing what the global problem is. Condition of the donated clothing is not referenced anywhere in the article. I'm arguing that what the author is saying is largely false.
- houseofzeus 9y agoWhere do you think the recyclers in the article are getting their raw materials from? Your counterpoint to the authors claim that nobody wants your used clothes anymore seems to be that a handful do, which is great but is a drop in the ocean compared to the amount of new product being churned out, consumed, and ultimately dumped - albeit in some cases via a donation bin or even a cycle of reuse - via the fast fashion chains.
- JeanMarcS 9y agoWhere I live (Caribbean island) you often find in dump place or trash clothes that are still in good condition, sometimes very good. For example last week, I found an almost new suitcase near a trash bin. Out of curiosity I gave it a look. Inside were brand new clothes, new shoes in their box with still the price on it (around 250€). I don’t know what people thinks...
- salpalpable 9y agoSounds like it might have been stolen and discarded.
- bostonpete 9y agoA Caribbean Island where you can find new clothes just left around...? Where do I sign up??
- sehugg 9y agoI see this trend in the U.S. too -- while a used shirt might cost $5 at Goodwill (although it's among the priciest of the thrift stores) a brand-new shirt at Walmart that delints after a few wash cycles might cost $8. OTOH, I have 30-year old Polo shirts that are still in decent shape. (If we didn't machine-dry our clothes they'd last a lot longer, but that's a different story.)
- trevyn 9y agoI’m sorry, what? This is great news — clothing is now so cheap that providing it to everyone on Earth is a solved problem. Of course, wealthier individuals will purchase and discard more as a result, and the refuse can simply be thrown into the ground. We are not running out of space to discard things. http://www.waste360.com/operations/regional-landfill-capacity-problems-do-not-equate-national-shortage http://www.waste360.com/operations/regional-landfill-capacit... “Nationally, Staley says he estimates that the U.S. has about 62 years of landfill capacity remaining in its current facilities.” Also, I firmly believe that our future technologically-more-advanced selves will have automated processes for reprocessing landfill waste, so this isn’t even a permanent state of affairs.
- extrapickles 9y agoWe are always ‘running out’ of landfill space. There isn’t much reason to have more than 60-80 years capacity for anything. Technology changes too much to develop more.
- kiliantics 9y agoGreat news. We can go on exploiting sweat shop labour and the environment by producing more and more flimsy garments that disintegrate after a few washes. Just trust future us to deal with the fallout, no need to take any action now. Buy buy buy.
- trevyn 9y agoFor anyone reading this with an open mind -- I believe this style of cynical worldview is typically created by the following process: 1) You have an initial difficulty managing environmental stressors. 2) As a coping mechanism, you vilify individuals who possess things you desire that seem unattainable. 3) You look for broadly-supported arguments supporting this vilification -- e.g., "things aren't made like they used to be" and "I want people to be treated well". 4) You adopt and repeat these broadly-supported arguments -- nobody would give you airtime for the underlying drive of "I want your resources/rewards, give them to me." 5) This repetition leads your mind to emotionally believe isolated arguments as fact, independent of their actual merit or relevance to the situation. 6) You gradually become blind to the underlying unfulfilled desires (including reduction of environmental stressors) that started this whole process, and adjust your identity to include rigid belief in your adopted arguments. 7) You are emotionally compelled to respond to anything that threatens your belief. I'm excited that we're now able to break down the psychological mechanisms for maladaptive behavior, which inspires possible interventions. For example, I'm encouraged by current trends promoting healthy ways of managing stress early in life, and interest in mindsets of loving compassion and open investigation of authentic desires; I suspect that these approaches and similar are likely to increase overall coping skills and self-reflection, which can lead to better outcomes for humanity.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoAround my parts, high quality clothes and goods get donated to the local SPCA, and I shop frequently. Like new $200 pair of leather dress shoes, for $10, was my recent find. However, clearly the article is not about American's buying other American's nice clothes. Its about our bad used clothes still having value overseas.
- juanmirocks 9y agoThis is eye opening. Although an opinion, and likely far from the current situation, it lays out a trend in the making. We will need newer better ways for recycle fabrics.
- lathiat 9y agoI was disheartened to discover that in Australia there is basically no way to recycle clothing that isn’t basically brand new and sale-able at a good will. Just landfill.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoFYI some might be interested in a book called "Clothing Poverty" by Andrew Brooks, about clothes recycling, and how for-profit companies dump a lot of crap on the developing world.
- rdtsc 9y agoCorrupt entities which acquire donated clothes then sell them in bulk still want your clothes. My high school friend's mom had a "business" where she would buy truckloads of used clothes, some donated to go to Eastern Europe, some "diverted" from Africa and she would resell them to smaller distributors, who would setup shops in local markets or just on street corners. Compared to other people I knew they were fairly "successful" based on revenue from that "business". I am sure people in abject poverty could use clothes. The problem is that it's not the lack of clothes, it's corruption why they don't have access to them. Same goes for food as well. One a different note, try going to a local thrift store in a nicer part of town, I had luck finding nice used clothes there.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> One a different note, try going to a local thrift store in a nicer part of town, I had luck finding nice used clothes there. Goodwill does pretty good even in bad parts of town, because unlike independents where the store is also often the sole permanent donation center, Goodwill often operated separate donation centers, generally in more affluent areas, recognizing that supply and demand for used clothes are often not geographically aligned.
- mcguire 9y agoIIUC, all of Goodwill's donations go to regional warehouses for cleaning and sorting.
- cyberpunk0 9y agoPeople praise Goodwill a lot here but I can't really condone their business practices and exploitation of handicapped workers
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoWhy is "business" and "successful" in quotes. It seems like a perfectly valid business operation to me.
- 9y ago
- lazyasciiart 9y agoThis title (which most people appear to be responding to) is over-reaching click-bait bullshit, as one might expect. The piece itself is a much narrower and less excitingly relevant to the everyday consumer topic, could be called "The textile recycling industry is in trouble".
- Panino 9y agoRegarding the disingenuous headline, it was likely chosen by an editor to get clicks. There are problems with the article itself though: > new clothes are becoming as cheap as used ones You can find $30 - $40 t-shirts from the GAP, and $3 - $4 t-shirts from Goodwill. The Goodwill shirts also have more cotton in them and so will probably last longer. Most of my t-shirts are hand-me-downs or old t-shirts from Goodwill, and several are over 10 years old and among my favs. (Back then I only paid $1 to $1.50 each for them!) There are cheap new t-shirts though: I once bought some at Wal-Mart and regretted it. They came in a bag so I couldn't try them on or get a good look at sizing, and lo and behold they were weirdly shaped around the shoulders and I couldn't really wear them. Just a waste of cotton. Hell, Goodwill even has a fitting room. Side note: it's fascinating how Goodwill manages to improve the community while having low prices, whereas Wal-Mart appears to impoverish it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mcguire 9y agoI wonder what happens to clothes donated to Goodwill that aren't fit to be resold in their stores. You've got to figure they have to do something with that leftover 5 or 6%. /s
- basseq 9y agoYou have to split these into two markets: 1. Secondary Clothes Market - As trends move faster and clothes get cheaper, used clothes a) aren't as much of a deal and b) aren't what you want anyway. Moreover, as new clothing prices drop, quality drops as well. That means that fewer used clothes are fit for the secondary market in the first place—as they're less able to stand up to wear and tear. 2. Recycling Market - It appears we're in a glut right now, so "new" material can be manufactured almost as cheaply as "recycled" material. The cost savings with recycled material are offset by slower supply chains, lower relative quality, and fewer options. So why recycle, other than social good? (Which, it's worth noting, is an increasing buyer value.) I expect the market may correct, likely in rising costs of new materials. In the interim, it's a race to the bottom for recycled material.
- edkennedy 9y agoThere are sites like grailed.com which have been taking advantage of the used clothing market for higher end fashion wear.
- lancefisher 9y agoI used to drop my used clothes off at Goodwill, but my wife started selling them on ebay. It’s really surprising to see some shirts and pants sell for up to $20 or $30. And they’re easy to ship.
- GFischer 9y agoFor example: Levi´s jeans sell for 100 dollars here in Uruguay (incredibly high import taxes). A lot of people make a living smuggling clothes. I couldn't believe the prices in the U.S. when I visited, I knew it was cheap intellectually, but seeing it in person was something else. And I don´t mind at all wearing an in-store return or using an open box or whatever gets me a cheaper price :) ... a lot of refurbished items make their way to Uruguay where they're sold at an U.S. new price...
- foxhop 9y agoWe try to keep our old clothing local. We donate our children's clothes to friends (even if 30% is used by them its worth it). Also children grow so fast! If we decide to discard them ourselves we do the following, in order. * we each keep 1-4 sets of "paint" or "work" clothing * long sleeve button down shirts are worn backwards as children art smocks * a single t-shirt cut apart becomes 4 rags for cleaning, working * a single t-shirt cut into about 20 strips becomes perfect in the garden to hold tomato plants to stakes, etc * a whole bunch of old clothes gets vacuum sealed and stuck between studs in the shed to act as a great insulator (I dust borax on the layers of clothes to act as a flame retardant).
- astura 9y agoI didn't go shopping for clothes in the store ever until 7th grade. Everything I owned was from bags and bags of hand-me-downs from various places.
- foxhop 9y agoTL;DR keep the 2nd life of your old clothes local to increase their chance of reuse and value.
- gumby 9y agoAs an aside it always grates on me that the marketing meaning of “fleece” as “plastic foam fabric” has wiped out the normal meaning
- a_t48 9y agoThe secondhand shops in Tokyo were glorious for me. Everything was in good shape and in styles that I like. As a slimmer guy, I found better fits too. Only issue was that things were quite a bit pricier (but the cheap food made up for it). San Francisco thrift shops have also treated me fairly well, but it's harder to find stuff I like\fit.
- tapatio 9y agoI'm having a real tough time giving away my "lightly used" Patagonia and North Face clothing said no one ever.
- shadyrudy 9y agoTell that to my wife! She is dealing my daughters 1T-6T outfits from Well Dressed Wolf, Sweet Honey, etc. on an app called Mercari. It's a little cash on the side for her, and her friends.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Zigurd 9y agoTrue for many kinds of clothes but thrifting for vintage items still has value, especially if you are a bit off-center as a thrifter. For example, men can find nice, high-end blazers and tweed jackets in thrift shops because they haven't caught on in the vintage eBay seller marketplace. High-end consignment sellers have mostly moved to the internet, but you can get real couture for off-the-rack prices. Which is to say: Not cheap, but not astronomical, either.
- daodedickinson 9y agoI do.
- tmaly 9y agoRelated, my wife and I wanted to ship some used by like new baby clothes to Canada a couple of years back. Her sister had a new baby girl, and she could have used them. I visited the local Kinkos to try to Fedex them, and I was told that Canada does not allow used clothes.
- GFischer 9y agoMany countries don't :( including mine. Stupid protectionism.
- objcts 9y agoDiscarded knitwear is especially valuable: a single, fully-fashioned knit sweater can contain up to 2 miles of yarn. My wife has devoted herself to making use of this abundant resource for people who are looking for high-quality yarn for knitting. https://www.unraveling.club https://www.unraveling.club
- blotsky 9y agoI'd have to disagree--certainly a percentage of these clothes are shit and end up in the trash. However, many of those of lesser means depend on the used clothes 'channel'.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoSo these are the guys responsible for the cruddy fleece blankets that loose 10% of their fibers the first time you wash them and make a persistent mess thereafter.
- justinph 9y agoOld clothes that are made from natural materials like wool, cotton, and linen can be composted. The trouble is that many times the thread and accessories (buttons, zippers) in the clothes are not natural and the compost needs to be sifted to remove these. Thread is particularly difficult to remove.
- bluewater 9y agoFor upscale brands (vineyard vines, polo, etc) used but excellent condition men’s and women’s clothing is selling online at places like poshmark. I haven’t been a seller but I’ve bought several pieces in the $20-30 range that retail for well over $100. Style Encore is a chain retail store that sells used high end women’s clothing, shoes and handbags.
- KittiHawk 9y agoThe thrift stores in my area are as busy as ever, and the online market for used clothing is huge. I get most of my clothes used on eBay or Poshmark. (Aside from swag shirts and underwear, which I buy new.) Sounds like a lot of the people chiming in in this thread are in the same boat. The article isn't really talking about that market though, it's talking about the market for recycled textiles. If it's as cheap to manufacture new textiles as it is to use recycled material, then it's harder for recyclers to compete. If those recyclers go out of business, then rubbish clothing has nowhere to go but the landfill.
- d0100 9y agoI do, and I'm not even that poor.
- retromario 9y agoMaybe in the US. In Germany I've been stunned at how thriving the flea market is for used clothes, especially baby and toddler clothing. In my town, there are two major flea markets on a weekly basis. Every neighborhood in town will have at least one yearly "Hofflohmarkt" (courtyard flea markets) and there are countless smaller and specialized flea markets organized by local kindergardens and churches. The amount of high-quality pieces of clothings bought and sold is staggering. For baby clothes, in particular, pieces that have been worn once or twice, easily worth 15-20 euros selling for 50c a pop. I compare this to the experience of my siblings raising their kids in the US and the general difference in mentality to second-hand clothes is shocking. I'll admit to being (culturally) shocked when my partner first suggested buying "used" clothes on our newborn but we've must of easily saved 1000s of Euros on children clothing, without sacrificing quality. It blows my mind. This mass flea-market system should be much more prevalent imo.
- stickfigure 9y agoUsed clothing stores are very common in the US, especially for the baby and toddler category (which has its own dedicated stores). For baby clothes, a rough fit will do and they're generally only good for a couple months anyways. That said, a lot of baby clothes is given as gifts, and there's a minor social taboo against giving used gifts. I doubt the US is very different from most Western European countries in this regard.
- zodPod 9y agoI don't think it's that we don't want used clothes anymore. It's that the thrift stores are so greedy that we would barely save any money shopping there. It used to be every shirt that came through was $3 which should've been fine because the stuff is literally handed to places like GoodWill. THEN someone decided they could make more money if they marked up name brand stuff. Now they want $20 for an American Eagle t-shirt when I could go to American eagle and buy it for $25. Screw that. That's the problem it has nothing to do with us not wanting it. I shop there all of the time and I am constantly turning down stuff because it's too expensive now.
- rokhayakebe 9y agoI do. I actually decided this year would be my year of used clothes.
- p2t2p 9y agoI’m writing this while wearing used t-shirt from local charity store. Boy, is it awesome t-shirt with awesome design. I started to call those charity shops a “museum of human consciousness”. Usually they have awesome stuff which I reckon to be thanks to crowdsourcing nature of their offerings.
- mcv 9y agoThere's always a market for second hand clothes in good condition. My wife buys and sells a significant chunk of her wardrobe online, primarily through marktplaats.nl ("marketplace", a leading Dutch second-hand stuff site acquired by eBay). Or kid's clothes go either to friends or family with younger kids, or we give them to our cleaner who takes them to an orphanage in Ghana. But with low manufacturing costs (no doubt driven by sweatshops and child labour), it's possible that recycling has become a lot less relevant than reuse. (Also: don't give away clothes with holes for reuse. Nobody wants that.)
- jingjingjanet 9y agoThe best way to solve this issue at scale is to alter the way people relate to shopping. As a woman, there is a lot of social pressure to show up in new outfits constantly, demand for new styles/designs will remain, and even increase. Millennials these days value access over ownership. We can recirculate high quality fashion with each other, i.e. share our closets at scale, this way, there won't be a need to constantly buy new things from cheap fast fashion stores, as we can simply reuse each others. Awesome new services such as: https://silkroll.com/ https://silkroll.com/ is taking a giant leap forward with this emerging and fast growing trend of closet sharing.
- jingjingjanet 9y agoThe best way to solve this issue at scale is to alter the way people relate to shopping. As a woman, there is a lot of social pressure to show up in new outfits constantly, demand for new styles/designs will remain, and even increase. Millennials these days value access over ownership. We can recirculate high quality fashion with each other, i.e. share our closets at scale, this way, there won't be a need to constantly buy new things from cheap fast fashion stores, as we can simply reuse each others.