11 ms·
Sudden savant syndrome, in which exceptional abilities emerge after brain injury
- simulate 9y agoThe topic of emergent genius was also covered in a short video about a year ago: https://youtu.be/7H6doOmS-eM https://youtu.be/7H6doOmS-eM
- tw1010 9y agoThe "math genius" Jason Padgett mentioned in the article has drawn a bunch of pretty pictures, but has authored zero research papers. Unless you define genius by how capable you are of impressing non-experts outside the field, how does he in any way apply to the definition?
- Karlozkiller 9y agoSpot on. The article focuses a lot on 'artistic genius'. Actually it jumps a lot between a great deal of things. There's a leap between the photographer who invented new technology, to Jason Padgett who began seeing the world in a weird way, to dementia-patients who begin drawing as parts of their brains decay. There's not much mentioned of geniuses in the meaning of people who further scientific theories like Einstein or whatever example one might give. They only hint that such people might often have autism, and try to explain that with left/right brain development. Which if I recall correctly has been highly disputed since the 1960 Nobel Prize. If nothing else the explanation of autism and savant autism in the article are gross oversimplifications.
- thejacenxpress 9y agoMy favorite example of an 'ordinary' person who gained an extraordinary mental ability is Daniel Tammet. He learned Icelandic in a week. Spent 2 weeks and memorized pi to 22,000+ digits. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AbASOcqc1Ss https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AbASOcqc1Ss
- hyperion2010 9y agoI don't think it is correct to say that he memorized pi, more that he recited pi because his brain simply produced it for him he did not have to look it up.
- ladberg 9y agoExcept that he wasn't actively calculating more digits of pi, some part of his brain had remembered the digits and was playing them back. Maybe some sub-conscious part memorized it, but it was still memorization.
- hyperion2010 9y agoSo just to put my neuroscientist hat on for a moment, memorization is almost always used to mean the use of some mnemonic in order to enable later recall. I'm saying that he never looked at the 137,493rd digit of pi, and that could very well be wrong based on what actually happened, but I think of this more like the other savant in the video who just has the day of the week for a date pop into his head even for dates that have not occurred yet. In those cases 'memorization' is not the word to use.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoThere are many different ways to memorize information, including mnemonics, visualization, auditory recall, conceptualization, and probably a lot of others. Ancient Romans and Greeks used the method of loci[1] to memorize massive amounts of information that used spacial memory to store information in a virtual palace or room in your mind, which doesn't use mnemonics. From the wiki: "In this technique the subject memorizes the layout of some building, or the arrangement of shops on a street, or any geographical entity which is composed of a number of discrete loci. When desiring to remember a set of items the subject 'walks' through these loci in their imagination and commits an item to each one by forming an image between the item and any feature of that locus. Retrieval of items is achieved by 'walking' through the loci, allowing the latter to activate the desired items." Different aphasias like anomic aphasia(the inability or difficulty to retrieving particular verbs or nouns)[1] indicate that the systems used to store and retrieve different forms of memory differ depending on the type of information, or at very least that the concept of a thing is stored differently than its word. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Method_of_loci https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Method_of_loci [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anomic_aphasia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anomic_aphasia
- nopinsight 9y agoThe kind of genius associated with autistic syndrome appears to me that it could be a result of reduced functionality in certain brain regions related to social functions and boredom control. Most people do not enjoy focusing on a single activity for most of their waking hours. Someone who consistently practices a craft for 8 hours a day would accumulate >10,000 hours in just 4 years, sufficient to become an expert in most non-professional activites. Within 15 years, such focus would yield >40,000 hours which is more than the actual practice time most professionals have under their belt. (Most normal professionals do not really get to practice their craft 8 hours a day and they probably take more vacations than these ‘geniuses’ do.) A further boost might come from less distraction and inhibition since their brains might not be influenced as much by the presence and potential judgements of other people. Genius-level work tends to be out of norm and most adults are conditioned to avoid standing out too much. If a potential Einstein were highly sensitive to established scientific worldview at the time, they probably would be discouraged from persisting for 10 years to solve the mystery in their imagination, or at least miss the path that veers off too much from the standard theory. From the article: “Muybridge was no exception. After the bet, he moved to Philadelphia and continued with his passion for capturing motion on film, photographing all kinds of activities such as walking up and down the stairs and, oddly, himself swinging a pickaxe in the nude. Between 1883 and 1886, he took more than 100,000 pictures.”
- geezerjay 9y ago> Someone who consistently practices a craft for 8 hours a day will accumulate >10,000 hours in just 4 years, sufficient to become an expert in most non-professional activites. That assumes that all those hours result in skill impfovemeonts. They do not. Commuters don't become expert drivers just because they get stuck in traffic for hours a day.
- goldenkey 9y agoThat's a false equivalence if there ever was one. When you get stuck in traffic, you aren't choosing conditions of adversity which will guide you towards higher difficulty. One could easily make the comparison between traffic jams and monotony. When one practices a skill, they get to choose the level of difficulty as well as a number of other factors related to the activity. A traffic jam is hardly comparable and it's not surprising that monotony does not really improve anyones' driving skills. However, compare your driving skills to someone from India where there are no traffic lights, and you'll probably go running out of the car. They are able to take higher risks because they deal with it every day.
- magicalist 9y ago> Nobel Prize-winning research from the 1960s shows that the two halves of the brain specialise in different tasks; in general, the right side is home to creativity and the left is the centre of logic and language. This is terrible.
- yesenadam 9y agoCould you give an improved version of the sentence, if able? Thanks. edit: Could the downvoter explain why? Thanks.
- jeron 9y agoIf I recall correctly, that study has since then been proved incorrect - neither halves of the brain specialize clearly in creativity or logic and language
- hacker_9 9y agoIt's an over simplification of the brain, supported by the fact that those that damage their speech centers on one side still end up being able to talk again, as other parts of their brain take on the task instead.
- Karlozkiller 9y agoThe left right hypothesis is wrong. The brain specialization is much more fine grained and much more adaptible to circumstances than described. Yes there are some specialized loci that happen to (most often) be in the left or right hemisphere, but the original hypothesis that logic is in the left hemisphere for example is utterly wrong. An example would be language, researchers started finding language loci in the brain (by showing that if a specific area was damaged, language was damaged) and so on. Based on such evidence the left right hypothesis was formed. What was not taken into account (in my somewhat accurate example) was that there are several other areas one could injure to get language-affecting brain damage. The thing is, such broad things as language, or logic, or art, are not located anywhere in particular in the brain, it is the interaction or many different areas and not necessarily the same areas in every person. There are however several areas that are specialized but on a much lower level than "language" search for Wernicke's area for example. Also note that Wernicke's area is statistically in different hemisphere more probably depending on which is your predominant hand. So no, just no.
- eecc 9y agoNow folks please don’t start smashing your head right wise into the wall, ok?!
- spyder 9y agoSome folks already doing "it": https://www.reddit.com/r/tDCS/ https://www.reddit.com/r/tDCS/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcranial_direct-current_stimulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcranial_direct-current_st... This is the same method as one of the research that's linked in the article has used to "Facilitate Insight by Non-Invasive Brain Stimulation": http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0016655 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....
- JoshMnem 9y agoIt's probably not a good idea. See "Popular electric brain stimulation method used to boost brainpower is detrimental to IQ scores". https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/05/150505152140.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/05/150505152140.h...
- jlarcombe 9y agoLike when Stan Laurel gets hit on the head in "A Chump At Oxford"
- tzahola 9y agoThis is a horrible article. >When you’re bashed on the head, the effects are similar to a dose of LSD Again, this is a horrible article. But I guess the target audience are members of the “i fucking love science” Facebook page.
- jibreel 9y agoin what way could getting bashed in the head have anything to do with LSD?
- tzahola 9y agoIf you're unprepared, you can end up in ER for both of them.
- jibreel 9y agowhats ER ? I did LSD twice, first time was a 100 ug dose, it was pleasant experience. 10 days later i did a 250 ug dose. first 2 hours was the best hallucinations of my life :), then there was an electricity shortage for a few minutes where i live, that darkness scared the hell out of me i panicked and had a strong shortness of breath. needless to say it was a shocking experience. had random panic attacks that persisted for 2 month. LSD is very powerful and surly is no joke.
- astura 9y agoER - emergency room. It's, of course, a misnomer, it's not just one room. ER is common in the US, outside of the US it's also called emergency department (ED), accident & emergency department (A&E), emergency ward (EW)
- sevensor 9y ago> This is a horrible article. > >When you’re bashed on the head, the effects are similar to a dose of LSD Clearly this article was written to appeal to the microdosing crowd. The next status symbol will be a ball-peen hammer for administering microconcussions. You heard it here first.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kleiba 9y ago"He became obsessed with maths and is now renowned for his drawings of formulas such as Pi." Ouch, that hurt.
- PyComfy 9y agoMy dad knew someone who had a reinforcing steel bar stuck into the middle of his head; The bar entered is mouth and exited in the middle of the top of his skill. After that, the guy was noticeably smarter but also more irascible. My dad theory was that the healing of the brain raised the number of synapses and ridges[1] in the damaged part of the brain (which in this case was right between the two cerebral hemispheres). Albert Einstein's brain had four ridges instead of three. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gyrus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gyrus [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_Einstein%27s_brain#Newly_recovered_photographs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albert_Einstein%27s_brain#Newl...
- danschumann 9y agoWe all have greatness within us, but most of us have "too good" of brains. See, the brain is designed to detect risk and avoid it at all costs. It often makes things up. You see a folded up rug in an alley-way, you think "Oh no, is that a person, am I being robbed?" You never see a person and think, "Is that a folded up rug?" The brain always jumps to the worst possibility. It calls Math.ceil() on risky situations. Perhaps these traumatic injuries have changed their thresholds in terms of "what is a risky situation?" Relative to trauma, perhaps things like creativity ( which is risky to your social status ), doesn't seem risky. Risking social status is the mark of any success. Being willing to fail publicly(at least risking it) is required! After trauma, it's probably easier.
- EADGBE 9y ago> perhaps things like creativity ( which is risky to your social status ) This is absurd.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoIt’s most likely that there was a new impairment in the brain that made them change their behavior and they didn’t know that they would be better at the new task.
- JabavuAdams 9y agoExcept, none of the abilities mentioned are really extreme. More like, you have a personality change, and now spend the time to become as good as other experts.
- JoshMnem 9y agoThat is the most likely explanation. It doesn't produce as many page views though.
- ainiriand 9y agoMight be unrelated but after the doctors extracted a brain tumor from my brain when I was 14 I experienced a sudden burst in creativity that is still here. It was like an explosion.
- csallen 9y agoWould you say that your creativity was repressed beforehand, and removing the tumor brought it to normal levels? Or was it normal beforehand, and now it's even better? If the latter, care to share more details or examples?
- solaxun 9y agoHow the eff would he know that? If you've spent your entire life in one state, and it changes, how can you possibly know what was the normal state?
- csallen 9y agoNormal isn't defined by yourself alone. Rather, it's the average of other people. If you are significantly more creative than the average person, it should be fairly simple to demonstrate that that's the case.
- Doxin 9y agoIt's still somewhat like asking a bornd-blind person what it's like to be blind. To them it is normal, they haven't ever experienced anything else.
- ainiriand 9y agoI think it was normal before and after that it improved considerably. I was unable of stop writing for 3 weeks straight after the intervention (nothing remarkable, I was 14) ,I started drawing and painting. After some months I felt the urge to create programs in my old spectrum, something I never did because I never felt the urge. I had to learn how to focus my attention in something because I left a lot of work unfinished too.
- JoshMnem 9y agoThat isn't a good article. Sudden/acquired savant syndrome isn't a recognized condition, and it probably doesn't exist. The abilities of sudden savants are no higher than what can be achieved by "non-savants" and the abilities can often be explained by other things. I think that it's possible that accidents can give people interests and/or repetitive behaviors that allow them to develop skills, but probably don't give them the skills directly. I am cautious about Treffert's claims in general. I have one of his books where he appears to attribute a few cases of savantism to psychic powers and reincarnation. If you want to see how unscientific some of the claims are, read the article below, including the sidebar. https://www.khaleejtimes.com/business/mind-reading-sharjah-girl-exceedingly-rare-savant https://www.khaleejtimes.com/business/mind-reading-sharjah-g...
- tfuop 9y agoThe writer of the article is an idiot and should volunteer himself for sudden savant experiment run for furthering research on this subject matter
- DaniFong 9y agoIT EXI$T$!
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoI know someone on Treffert’s registry who hit their head in an unfortunate workplace accident, and subsequently emailed him claiming to be a genius. No vetting or testing at all. He now proclaims that he is a sudden savant because he is on Treffert’s list.
- JoshMnem 9y agoI'm not surprised. I recommend being extremely skeptical of all acquired savant claims, and mostly skeptical about other savant claims in general. At least keep in mind that there isn't much real evidence for those claims. Practice and technique can explain just about every case. Even well-known "experts" have many incorrect ideas. The popular media then amplify the incorrect ideas. "The weight of evidence for an extraordinary claim must be proportioned to its strangeness."
- api 9y agoThere's a lot of anecdotal evidence that similar things can happen occasionally and to some people after psychedelic drug exposure. Could the mechanism be similar? Maybe certain drugs and traumas can kick the neural network into another state and maybe that occasionally turns out to be an interesting one. Of course sometimes the neural network lands somewhere less favorable too. Traumatic brain injuries rarely result in savant abilities, and some people "never come back" from too much LSD or other drugs.
- bewatson 9y agoA great book that touches on the subject is "Musicophilia" by the late Oliver Sacks. It goes deep into the neurology of conditions like acquired savant syndrome, though the core of the book is on music-related neurological anomlaies https://www.amazon.com/Musicophilia-Tales-Music-Revised-Expanded/dp/1400033535 https://www.amazon.com/Musicophilia-Tales-Music-Revised-Expa...
- ph4 9y agoReading these comments is a fascinating look into the ontology assumed by militant scientific materialists.
- adam 9y agoReminds me of the Ted Chiang short story "Understand" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Understand_(story) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Understand_(story)
- mattkevan 9y agoBrain injuries are nasty, strange things. I used to work for a charity that ran a programme helping people back into work after getting a brain injury. Each person was affected differently, but as far as I know no-one got a superpower. In general the injury took away any behavioural filters people usually had. So the filters that might stop you from smashing up a room when angry, or taking all your clothes off when stressed, or making everyone you meet sign an NDA in case they stole your ideas (real examples) were just gone. This led to some entertaining stories, but without exception the results of a brain injury were devastating. Don't get a brain injury if you can possibly help it.