21 ms·
The screen that set off the ballistic missile alert on Saturday
- booleandilemma 9y ago“The BMD False Alarm link is the added feature to prevent further mistakes” This is a joke right? It’s only going to make recovering from a mistake easier, it’s not going to prevent anything.
- triangleman 9y agoYES after you get past the mind-blowing photo, the twitter post is also extremely messed up.
- pcunite 9y agoIf you believe this, I have a bridge I want to sell you.
- huffmsa 9y agoLowest bidding contractor wins again.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- whatever_dude 9y agoIt's easy to see how this is bad, and I bet dozens of designers are now creating alternatives for their dribble and Twitter appreciation, but the problem is probably what led to this, not this specifically. I can see it: a contractor started with a link that triggers a push notification, then someone requested another link, then another, then it grew from there, never having the ability to stop and rethink this from a design standpoint since it would require more work, more training, more money. The problem is not knowing (or having someone who knows) how to design something better, it's treating good design as a priority. It rarely happens.
- agumonkey 9y agowhat would you call regular re-evaluation of a system ? hygiene ?
- Joe-Z 9y agoI think we use different words in different contexts: Refactoring, Maintenance come to mind for software engineering. Don't know what the equivalent in the graphics design world would be.
- fredley 9y agoThis is not graphic design, it is UX. Graphic design is a component of UX, sometimes, but not here necessarily. Simply reordering the list, and giving it a hierarchy makes it much easier to see what to do: https://twitter.com/iamlucamilan/status/953201356545974272 https://twitter.com/iamlucamilan/status/953201356545974272
- whatever_dude 9y agoI normally use "code health" or "scout's rule", but it's more about the implementation than the design. "Hygiene" is a great word overall, for both cases.
- fredley 9y agoIf a system has critical safety components (using, or misusing the system could harm or kill people), all parts of it should be treated as such. This applies to hospital equipment, missile warning systems, cars, etc. Things like security and reliability rightly get a lot of attention, but UX is just as critical, as this event shows. There are plenty of case studies of poor UX on hospital equipment killing people[1]. When will people learn? [1]: https://medium.com/tragic-design/how-bad-ux-killed-jenny-ef915419879e https://medium.com/tragic-design/how-bad-ux-killed-jenny-ef9...
- itronitron 9y agoI think a big problem is that people that don't have a lot of experience with design treat design decisions as subjective and arbitrary when in fact there is a lot of science to back up certain design choices (human vision, cognitive psychology, and not A/B testing.) As a result the approval process for any design, whether the initial or a redesign, gets stuck on the desks of various people that either don't feel qualified or don't see the point in the design.
- matt4077 9y agoThis is going to be in every single UI class curriculum, from now until earth‘s destruction in nuclear armageddon.
- zentiggr 9y agoAnd everyone required to sit through the mandatory class will be zoned out and not even absorb the facts that aren't in the 10 question quiz at the end of the section.
- empath75 9y agoWhat kind of ux design is that???
- alex_duf 9y agoIf this is true, It's a miracle mistakes aren't made more often...
- PKop 9y agoProbably the worst UX design (considering the context and the stakes) I've ever seen. How could multiple people accept this as the interface? Put it on a separate page! Have an explicit confirmation dialog, or 3 of them. At the very least maybe it's own section with some padding... Ridiculous.
- empath75 9y agoIt just needs an ‘under construction’ GIF to make it perfect.
- jcranmer 9y agoAn ICBM will land about 30 minutes after it launches. At those kinds of timescales, every delay you put in somebody's path to issue the warning, even a few seconds, is going to be a cost measured in lives. How many people are you willing to kill to reduce the risk of a false alarm?
- ghaff 9y agoThat's true. But somewhere between one click or "Alexa, send the nuclear warning alert" and having multiple people confirm the message with some complex procedure, there's probably a reasonable medium. False alarms also have significant risk, including encouraging people to ignore a real alarm whether for tsunamis or missile attacks.
- misnome 9y agoBy that argument, this is worse because the person might have to hunt around in a pile of similar looking links for the one button, with an increased chance of getting it wrong and issuing the wrong alert. Really, there is no way to justify this as in any way "intentionally designed".
- 24gttghh 9y agoThey could at least make the non-test warnings a Red hyperlink or something, and organize them on a separate part of the page away from the test warnings... If that picture is legit, it's laughably bad. I have a feeling adding a confirmation dialog that takes an extra 200ms to click isn't gonna make much of a difference either when a thermonuclear warhead is heading your way...
- oliv__ 9y agoYikes... is this for real
- robertcope 9y agoThey probably paid a million dollars for that system, too.
- cube00 9y agoThat's just the annual support fee.
- andrepd 9y agoYikes. Now consider this: this is the design for the missile warning system. It is possible, even likely, that some missile launch system has similar catastrophic UI. How we've not wiped ourselves off by accident so far is a miracle.
- djaychela 9y agoI take it you've read Command and Control [1]? A great, if worrying read on exactly that subject. It's luck, not judgement that something really terrible hasn't happened yet. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Command_and_Control_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Command_and_Control_(book)
- andrepd 9y agoI can't say I have. It seems an interesting read though. Thanks for the suggestion!
- oftenwrong 9y agoAlong the same lines: a whistleblower's account of problems in the UK's "Trident" nuclear defense program from 2015: https://wikileaks.org/trident-safety/ https://wikileaks.org/trident-safety/
- Medox 9y agoanother interesting read regarding this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_close_calls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_close_calls
- 0xTJ 9y agoI'd disagree on the first point, but only because it seems that many launch systems use floppy drives. (The big ones)
- jacobush 9y agoThere is room for error. “This floppy is the drill floppy, I’m sure.” http://nuclearfiles.org/menu/key-issues/nuclear-weapons/issues/accidents/20-mishaps-maybe-caused-nuclear-war.htm http://nuclearfiles.org/menu/key-issues/nuclear-weapons/issu... 1979 Nov 9 Computer Exercise Tape
- megaman22 9y agoHoly hell... I was expecting some old ncurses mainframe design with shitty interface, but if it's just an href... seems like it'd be trivial to hack and cause havoc
- Karunamon 9y agoI really, really hope there’s no JS on that page. Because if there is, given the poor design, it’s probably vulnerable to XSRF. Gives a whole new meaning to critical vulnerabilities. Sheesh.
- astura 9y agoXSRF has nothing to do with JavaScript. A site is vulnerable to XSRF if it doesn't use tokens when performing critical operations, critical operations are (usually) performed using HTTP POST, which can be done via form submission... token generation and validation is done server side... You can perform a successful XSRF attack in a browser with javascript completely disabled.
- goatlover 9y agoJust slap a web interface over everything. I was expecting something old, too. But this is worse, since it's so easy to click the wrong link.
- JdeBP 9y agoAn old ncurses or mainframe design would not have had a shitty interface like that. It would have used more than 2 colours. It would have used consistent capitalization. It would not have underlined everything. It would have divided up menu options into related groups. * http://www.cheapraybansunglassesa.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/as400-computer-system-keyesmail-connecting-to-a-mail-server-of-as400-computer-system.jpg http://www.cheapraybansunglassesa.com/wp-content/uploads/201... * https://i.stack.imgur.com/8LzMo.jpg https://i.stack.imgur.com/8LzMo.jpg * http://thinview.com/images/emulator.gif http://thinview.com/images/emulator.gif * http://hunterstrainingassociates.com/images/ispf1_25.gif http://hunterstrainingassociates.com/images/ispf1_25.gif * https://as400iseries.files.wordpress.com/2013/03/libraries1.png https://as400iseries.files.wordpress.com/2013/03/libraries1.... * https://seasoft.com/assets/seasoft.com/seasoft.com/public/uploads/accordion/226/_1200x/Anti-Virus_Headline_1.JPG https://seasoft.com/assets/seasoft.com/seasoft.com/public/up...
- ghaff 9y agoAnd I would hope that the people (here) who have been calling for the employee who messed up to be drawn and quartered for "pressing the wrong button" might reconsider after seeing this.
- ryandetzel 9y agoI bet it works in ie6. Is this design horrible? yes. Is this out of the ordinary? Absolutely not. This is very common UX for systems designed 5+ years ago and there are still systems designed today that look like this. This is an alert system, now picture your surgeon or air traffic control using something like this...
- olfactory 9y ago> Is this out of the ordinary? Absolutely not. I have not seen UI where there is something that appears to be a link that spans an entire line but it is actually several separate links.
- shuntress 9y agoThere is nothing wrong with the way it _looks_ The problem is that two drastically different interactions are too easy to interchange by mistake. This application could easily look-and-feel the same while having much a better user experience.
- crististm 9y agoIn the defence of those that made the UX, this is version 1. Or prototype. Or something they paid a ten year old with candies to make... Or they don't get it and they are hopeless. No, they do get it. The DRILL link is one row away from non-DRILL link to avoid incorrect dispatching. In the mean time you can ponder if you need to announce a tsunami.
- t3f 9y ago>In the mean time you can ponder if you need to announce a tsunami. I would suggest that recent history [1] has shown we can have a 30m-2h warning, and that isn't good enough. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Indian_Ocean_earthquake_and_tsunami#Signs_and_warnings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Indian_Ocean_earthquake_a...
- senectus1 9y agowow...
- HenryBemis 9y agoI particularly liked the comment (apologies for the caps) "BAD DESIGN" ad nauseum :)
- joshstrange 9y agoThe thing that annoys me most about this situation is people complaining about how long it took to send out the "Sorry, there was no missile" message. Just as I expected these were hard-coded messages that were sent out by a button (link) click and not a free-form text area. There are many (good) reasons you want your program set up this way (let's ignore the rest of the terrible UI/UX for now). It makes complete sense to me that given a spec of "make a button send this specific text" you would end up with this. So it's very easy to send the initial message but sending a custom follow up requires contacting someone with access to the underlying system who can send a custom message. In the same way that I may give internal users the ability to fire off SPECIFIC (maybe with placeholders) push notifications with the press of a button but not custom messages. Sure my underlying infrastructure can handle custom messages but the UI for such a feature does not exist (or at least is not available to the person who might have the ability to send preset messages). All in all this was terrible for the people in Hawaii, no doubt. That said I WANT my missile alert system to be easy to activate to give people the most time I can to prepare. The best fix for this (yes a new UI/UX would be best but let's be realistic on how much time/energy they are willing to spend on this) would be a scary looking alert confirmation dialog of "Are you sure you want to send this alert to the whole state?" and maybe have to type a confirmation string.
- ceejayoz 9y agoIt'd be nice to have a nice big divider between "live" and "test" messages, and different colors for the two. Small tweaks would go a long way here.
- joshstrange 9y ago100% Agree, there are a million little things that could have been done differently/better. My point really was trying to focus on that the delay in follow-up was completely understandable (also unfortunate) and that there was definitely some low hanging fruit for improvement (your suggestions being chief among them). This is, however, the UI/UX use end up with when you produce a specific spec and farm it out to the lowest bidder.
- ourmandave 9y agoThe scary thing to me is this system probably has full permissions on my phone. =(
- caio1982 9y agoWould this be, you know, by any chance, a Perl or PHP CGI bin triggered by an intranet link?
- icedchai 9y agoHow much do you think the government contractor(s) who built this got paid? My, and possible your, tax dollars at work...
- DanBC 9y agoHuman Factors is becoming more well known, especially in health care. This screen is scary. Now imagine drugs used during surgery that look almost identical. Here are some exampels: https://twitter.com/EzDrugID/status/933871776152543233 https://twitter.com/EzDrugID/status/933871776152543233 https://twitter.com/EzDrugID/status/850259195618131968 https://twitter.com/EzDrugID/status/850259195618131968 It's frustrating that we know this is a source of human error and that we're still doing it.
- fredley 9y agoI wouldn't call it a source of human error, but it's a huge amplifier for it. It adds massively to the cognitive overhead of performing and monitoring tasks.
- rubemazenha 9y agowtf. I hope Trump nuclear bottom is really bigger than that.
- uptown 9y ago"Days after Hawaii alert gaffe, Japan issues false alarm about a missile launch" https://www.reuters.com/article/us-northkorea-missiles-japan/days-after-hawaii-alert-gaffe-japan-issues-false-alarm-about-a-missile-launch-idUSKBN1F514S https://www.reuters.com/article/us-northkorea-missiles-japan...
- jim_dow_jones 9y agoWow, that's a pretty big coincidence. What would be the purpose of both states intentionally setting off false alarms?
- giarc 9y ago>intentionally No one intentionally set off these alarms.
- jim_dow_jones 9y agoYou are correct. There is no current reporting that claims these were set off intentionally. However, I'm curious if there could be a valid motive for both states to purposely set off these false alarms. It does seem like a pretty big coincidence that both states happen to get these false alarms in relatively short time frame. I have already seen conspiracy posts making claims about these alarms being purposely set off, but they never provide a motive. Just curious if anyone can think of a valid one.
- giarc 9y agoI don't want to get into conspiracy type stuff, but I was saying to colleagues yesterday that the bright side of all this is that I imagine there are a lot of Hawaiians building their emergency survival kits right now.
- olfactory 9y agoSome possible motives: - To allow authorities to listen for "chatter" from NK military deployed in Hawaii who might have been ready to carry out some action if an attack were launched, but who would not likely have been told when it would occur. - To watch how NK responds internally to the idea that the US might be launching a counter-strike. Things like escape routes, comms, etc., could be observed via sigint. - To create a "path" for the public to think about this kind of thing. It's been years since anyone in the US (public or media) has had to think about incoming missile attacks. The false alarm gives all the reporters an excuse to read up on the history, to issue warnings about lack of preparedness, etc. This means that in the event of an actual attack the information mechanisms will all work more smoothly. It's a dress rehearsal so that everyone is not stuck like a deer in the headlights if an attack occurs. - The false alarm could have been triggered by someone on the payroll of NK. Note that the main goal of the military is to inspire fear, not to actually kill people.
- code_duck 9y agoThe WaPo reports it was from an interface with a drop-down menu. “Around 8:05 a.m., the Hawaii emergency employee initiated the internal test, according to a timeline released by the state. From a drop-down menu on a computer program, he saw two options: “Test missile alert” and “Missile alert.” He was supposed to choose the former; as much of the world now knows, he chose the latter, an initiation of a real-life missile alert.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2018/01/14/hawaii-missile-alert-how-one-employee-pushed-the-wrong-button-and-caused-a-wave-of-panic/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2018/01/1...
- MBCook 9y agoI imagine that was a misunderstanding based on initial information. This was tweeted by the official department in Hawaii.
- giarc 9y agoThe tweet linked is by civilbeat.com, not an official account. Correct me if I'm wrong and some official account also sent out this photo.
- MBCook 9y agoOh, no, you’re right. That’s the one I saw but I misremembered. But (looking again) I see in a reply they say the image was provided by the office of the Governer. https://mobile.twitter.com/CivilBeat/status/953270472820457472 https://mobile.twitter.com/CivilBeat/status/9532704728204574...
- jandrese 9y agoRule of thumb with tech reporting is that the reporters always get the details wrong. Nothing shatters the illusion like watching a story where you know the actual facts of the case and seeing just how much they get wrong.
- jacobush 9y ago
- douglasheriot 9y agoIf that’s the user interface, I can hardly imagine what’s underneath. Is this thing actually secure with properly designed two-factor authentication, etc. Or a weak password and a PHP script and some rubbish like that?…
- brewdad 9y agoThat's probably why they released this cropped screenshot. It wouldn't surprise if the site is accessible on the public web and secured with a weak password that must be changed weekly.
- triangleman 9y agoOK great freaking point. Man what a terrible idea, web application for a public alert system.
- huffmsa 9y agoAnd if you think this is bad, just imagine what the Russians are running. Probably a panel of unlabeled buttons
- ryandvm 9y agoI'm looking forward to news stories about the Great Hawaiian Baby Boom in a few months... But seriously, as an occasional government contractor, this does not surprise me at all. This is par for the course on government software projects. Nobody gets fired for adding just one more menu item. Besides, good luck pushing a complete redesign through in a reasonable amount of time/money. With the bloated teams and processes they use, that would take years. Sadly, this is probably the "new" version anyway.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jlebrech 9y agothey use the mouse for something so alarming, also without a confirmation box? a terminal based system would be better than this, how much did this system cost?
- candiodari 9y agoReminds me of this pixar movie: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVLoc6FrLi0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVLoc6FrLi0
- syphilis2 9y agoI think I'm the only person who saw it and thought it was fine. It's a list of clearly labeled text links, very clear very simple. There are some changes that could be made to separate drills/tests from real events (or a different naming convention), but I'm surprised to see many people call a single page text list "terrible UI".
- giarc 9y agoIt's all about context. It might be fine if that's a list of your website bookmarks and if you click the wrong one you just click a different one. But when the consequences of clicking the wrong one are such high magnitude, it's bad design. And I don't even think it's up for debate. If the design of the page just made someone accidentally alert a whole state of an incoming missile, then it's bad.
- syphilis2 9y agoI think someone will always be able to click the wrong link, especially if given the wrong information or confusing information "Give the message for PACOM CDW, ... Oh sorry you did the DRILL PACOM, right?" The larger problem was not having a quick system in place to redact an erroneous message. But I've read a lot of suggestions like spreading items across multiple pages, adding passwords, or big warning colors and lines around the live options that are not just obfuscating/distracting/annoying but are bound to cause errors and open the door for even worse design.
- cmiles74 9y agoAnd remember that when you need to click it, you will be 100% entirely terrified by the incoming missile. Parsing through the list will itself be challenging under those circumstances.
- pure-awesome 9y agoThere are some great comments above on this. Two that stand out: fredley 36 minutes ago If a system has critical safety components (using, or misusing the system could harm or kill people), all parts of it should be treated as such. This applies to hospital equipment, missile warning systems, cars, etc. Things like security and reliability rightly get a lot of attention, but UX is just as critical, as this event shows. There are plenty of case studies of poor UX on hospital equipment killing people[1]. When will people learn? https://medium.com/tragic-design/how-bad-ux-killed-jenny-ef915419879e https://medium.com/tragic-design/how-bad-ux-killed-jenny-ef9... fredley 33 minutes ago This is not graphic design, it is UX. Graphic design is a component of UX, sometimes, but not here necessarily. Simply reordering the list, and giving it a hierarchy makes it much easier to see what to do: https://twitter.com/iamlucamilan/status/953201356545974272 https://twitter.com/iamlucamilan/status/953201356545974272
- jlebrech 9y agoa better terminal app: PLEASE ENTER STATEWIDE WARNING CODE [ ] then the operator types NUKEWARN or whatever in the box. Much less error prone.
- bovermyer 9y agoThis is why things like Code for America are so important.
- sjs382 9y agohttps://blog.codinghorror.com/the-opposite-of-fitts-law/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/the-opposite-of-fitts-law/ In the cockpit of every jet fighter is a brightly painted lever that, when pulled, fires a small rocket engine underneath the pilot's seat, blowing the pilot, still in his seat, out of the aircraft to parachute safely to earth. Ejector seat levers can only be used once, and their consequences are significant and irreversible. Applications must have ejector seat levers so that users can "occasionally" move persistent objects in the interface, or dramatically (sometimes irreversibly) alter the function or behavior of the application. The one thing that must never happen is accidental deployment of the ejector seat. The interface design must assure that a user can never inadvertently fire the ejector seat when all he wants to do is make some minor adjustment to the program.
- hopeless 9y agoThere's a lot we can learn from aviation: accident retrospectives, checklists, master caution alarms, crew relationship management, human factors research, etc. However, my knowledge of these things is a bit piecemeal and anecdotal. Does anyone know a good book on these things?
- fyfy18 9y ago> crew relationship management At least with airlines this seems to be largely abandoned now. My wife worked for a large middle eastern airline for a few years, and the crews were just assigned randomly. Well I guess there is a complicated algorithm that figures it out, but given the company has nearly 15,000 cabin crew it’s unlikely you’ll see someone you flew with again on another flight. Also from the stories I heard people were promoted to managerial roles (on big flights there’s usually a senior for each class, and then a purser who reports to the captain) through seniority, not because they had any specific people skills that made them a good manager.
- dilyevsky 9y agoop probly meant Crew Resource* Management which has nothing to do with crew assigment and is alive and well (on non-shit airlines that is).
- singularity2001 9y agoWait they are starting nuclear war from an IE browser with js enabled?
- joering2 9y agoWhat I want to know, if there is come sort of confirmation window/popup as step 2. That would make a big difference. Was that just plain wrong click, or something more? Btw: any idea what this application is? looks like a HTML page ?
- gveiga 9y agoThis fumble just shows once again how ux design continues to be lacking in 80% of the world apps - the ones used inside companies https://medium.com/@goncaloveiga/what-hawaiis-emergency-alert-reveals-about-enterprise-app-ux-590d33a022e1 https://medium.com/@goncaloveiga/what-hawaiis-emergency-aler...
- rorykoehler 9y agoWhy is the a manual UI to send out an incoming missile alert. Surely the alert should be sent automatically when the anti-missile system is engaged?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Surely the alert should be sent automatically when the anti-missile system is engaged? This is a civilian system. Detection and anti-ballistic missile systems are military, specifically NORAD and the MDA. I agree that NORAD should have an API, though I suspect integrating it with civil defense systems will result in more such mistakes in the short run.
- mulmen 9y agoIf there is no existing integration then how does the civilian system operator know to click this button?
- mannykannot 9y agoWhile we are bikeshedding this, let's give some thought to the possibility of sending a test message when a real one is called for - and in the tsunami warning system as well, as I certainly hope it has more real events than does the nuclear missile one.
- mosselman 9y agoThey should have added the captcha's with the store fronts. That alert would never get triggered unless it were truly needed. It would be 15 minutes late though every time
- jonwachob91 9y agoWhat stands out to me the most is lack of standard naming conventions... > 1. TEST Message >> DRILL - PACOM (CDW) - STATE ONLY >>> Amber Alter DEMO TEST Design aside, a standard naming convention would have gone a long way.
- scrumper 9y agoAnd that's likely one of the only things that could be easily fixed, too. The ordering of those links likely isn't changeable without going into the guts of some upstream monster system (preventing those categorized redesigns that some have suggested). But a simple text label change would seem to be easier.
- peterbraden 9y agoOne problem with interfaces like this is that they are an abjection of ownership. The situation probably doesn't warrant a dedicated designer, and the developer who make it, probably thought 'I'm not a designer, that will do'. The amount of times I've heard 'Just add a button to do it' from 'backend developers'.. The point is, software is there to serve a user, and if you can't envisage the user using the software, then you don't understand the requirements. It's not a design question. Too much responsibility is deferred as 'design' when it's actually a fundamental part of solving the problem at hand. Not that design isn't also important, but the perception that usability == design needs to change.
- razorunreal 9y agoThere are plenty of possible charity improvements, but I think anyone who has accidentally sent an email should understand what this really needs: A countdown timer in the 10-30 second range with a clear, bold description of what it will do, and a cancel button. There should be no way to skip the timer. I'd be amazed if no one said "wait, shit" within 10 seconds of clicking the wrong link.
- tarmstrong 9y agoThis is a great teaching moment for anyone who works in UX or observability, but it's worth keeping in mind that the FCC's Public Safety and Homeland Security Bureau (who operate the Emergency Alert Service (EAS)) has a yearly operating budget of around $17MM this year. The system itself was launched in 1997. This is a legacy software (and hardware!) system with a relatively small budget and number of employees that needs to coordinate with other large organizations (FEMA, HI-EMA, NOAA, etc.). I think the most interesting lessons to learn from this have to do with long term software maintenance. I'm sure folks at the FCC/*EMA knew that this UI was janky but why did they not have the budget/power to fix it? How do we ensure that the public sector can benefit from the technical advances that most people on hacker news take for granted? Curious to hear from folks with experience in relevant parts of the government.
- moojd 9y agoI once got contracted to integrate with a large government web app that was created with some sort of legacy SPA generator. The app was written in .NET and the js on the page would render the views from specs it would get over XHR from the .NET app. It positioned everything on the page absolutely and everything was styled with inline styles. The people who manage it were quoting outrageous numbers to do the simplest style changes because it was so hard to work in. Very few improvements ever got made because the money was just not there in the budget to pay these ridiculous quotes.
- Chaebixi 9y ago> I think the most interesting lessons to learn from this have to do with long term software maintenance. Yes! And with re-engineering too! When you redevelop a system, you need to build up historical knowledge of its antecedents, and teach it to the current operators and maintainers. You shouldn't just start from scratch from the requirements. In this case, there was an even older legacy system that had a similar incident in 1971, which they then mitigated. Apparently that lesson was lost. http://conelrad.blogspot.com/2010/09/code-word-hatefulness-great-ebs-scare.html http://conelrad.blogspot.com/2010/09/code-word-hatefulness-g...: > …In the past three tapes, one for the test and two for actual emergencies, were hanging on three labeled hooks above the transmitter… In the future only the test tape will be left near the transmitter. The two emergency tapes [will be] be sealed in clearly marked envelopes and placed inside a nearby cabinet.
- dictum 9y agoRelated reading list: https://www.amazon.com/Design-Everyday-Things-Revised-Expanded/dp/0465050654 https://www.amazon.com/Design-Everyday-Things-Revised-Expand... https://www.amazon.com/Dont-Make-Think-Revisited-Usability/dp/0321965515 https://www.amazon.com/Dont-Make-Think-Revisited-Usability/d...
- pavement 9y agoHoly shit. That is not even a "pull down menu" as previously reported. Good to know. This means that in Hawaii, you should only think about taking action if the magic FALSE ALARM notice never appears. If the FALSE ALARM notice doesn't appear within an hour, it might just be that the false alarm guy is on lunch break. If it doesn't appear in 8 hours, it might mean that a shift change occurred without proper hand-off. If it fails to appear in 24 hours, a nuclear attack might actually be imminent, and you should check other sources, to determine if the alarm was, in fact, real. This protocol ensures that archaeologists will receive a valid record, omitting the false alarm notice in the rocks on the other side. Eventual consistency ensures that before the archaeological record is written, a false alarm notice will appear, if the alarm was indeed false. In all other cases, the alarm is effectively revealed to history to be a true alert, at some point in the future, as yet to be determined.
- delecti 9y agoI suspect you're joking, but an actual ICBM attack would have likely struck before the false alarm message was issued. There was a 38 minute delay before the false alarm message: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/posteverything/wp/2018/01/16/the-good-news-about-hawaiis-false-alarm https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/posteverything/wp/2018/0... Meanwhile an ICBM would likely impact less than 35 minutes after launch: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intercontinental_ballistic_missile#Flight_phases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intercontinental_ballistic_mis...
- betolink 9y ago- How much for that antimissile program? $100 billion? what? it may not work?!! mmm OK I'll take 2! - How much for a new web interface? 1k?! what?! that's outrageous!! just add another link, it will be fine.
- jwmullally 9y agoFix proposal subthread. Can we harness HN collective intelligence to vote up some good suggestions? Instructions: * Reply with your suggested fix to this comment. (That way we can vote equally between suggestions, instead of having them being scattered throughout the thread). * First line is simple one-line summary, optionally followed by a blank line then some exposition. Example: ---------- Simple fix: Seperate links into 2 color coded sections, TEST and ACTIVE Put each set of links into seperate divs, with different background colors or striped backgrounds.
- jwmullally 9y agoSimple fix: Seperate links into 2 color coded sections, TEST and ACTIVE Put each set of links into seperate divs, with different background colors or striped backgrounds. As is, these different links are mixed up together making them accident prone. Undoubtedly a mini development boondoggle will result over this incident, in the meantime the above fix is easy and satisifies the real requirement. Already suggested here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16158252 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16158252
- triangleman 9y agoStart a software developer's professional organization akin to the ABET in engineering.
- jv22222 9y agoIt’s just like how in Aliens vs Monsters when they gave the president of the united states two big red buttons right next to each other: 1: Launch nuclear attack 2: Make coffee
- stef25 9y agoPlenty of this type of insanity in "Command and Control"
- fallingfrog 9y agoHopefully the UI for actually launching the nukes is at least a little better...
- zelos 9y agoMore importantly - what about the reverse case? Presumably someone issuing a real ballistic missile warning is doing so while terrified and in a hurry. The consequences of pressing the "This is a drill" button in that case are a lot worse than this.
- abecode 9y agoActually from some of the interviews with Hawaiians on NPR, it seemed like people didn't know what to do when waiting for an incoming ballistic missile. So it seems like even in the case where there is a real threat, the usefulness of the message is questionable if people aren't trained about what to do when waiting for a missile.
- MicroBerto 9y agoFor those of you who don't believe a single thing we're being told about this situation -- including this screenshot -- just know that you're not alone. You don't need to question the narrative publicly like some of us do, but it's always good to keep an open mind about everything we're told, and sadly, that means considering the possibility that there have been more lies than truths told since Saturday. Hopefully someday we'll get the real story, but I have a very hard time believing that this is it.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoAre you suggesting that there may have been a real attack but it's being kept quiet (by idk, the Deep State, lizard people, round-earth conspiracists, etc?)
- Blazespinnaker 9y agoOr that it was done for political purposes.
- MicroBerto 9y agoNot at all, and I take offense to what you are suggesting - that anyone who questions the 'official' story automatically believes in lizard people or whatnot. I find it sad that people have been conditioned to lump anyone who questions such a messed up narrative in with nonsense like that. Let's not act as if we've never been lied to before. We have reached a very low point in both credibility and transparency, and just because I have serious doubts about this story doesn't mean I'm a flat earther or whatever else you're insinuating. Let's be mature here.
- mulmen 9y agoYou offer no reason to doubt the official story though. If you don't present us with new information you're either pointing out the obvious or advocating nonsense.
- tomjen3 9y agoClearly not. He is suggesting that the alert was not send in error, but that requires no more than somebody clicking it and further that he doesn't trust the government (in would call anything else imprudent). I can see a bunch of reasons for clicking that link, from just for fun to wanting more money to fix the UI to the more sinister of wanting to keep the populous scared so that they are more likely to support a war in the future. No reason to bring lizard people into this.
- aviv 9y agoWhat I find interesting is not this screenshot, but the fact that most commenters here don't even question if we are being told the truth as to what happened. Yet here we are talking about UI/UX.
- mulmen 9y agoI don't see why we would doubt it, what do you believe happened? Can you substantiate your belief?
- bogomipz 9y agoWhat is the provenance of this image? How do we know this is real? While UI/UX designers are falling all over themselves with their meme fest I didn't see any reference for the source of this image. If you read the Washington Post account, it says the interface was a drop down menu of which this picture is not of. See: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2018/01/14/hawaii-missile-alert-how-one-employee-pushed-the-wrong-button-and-caused-a-wave-of-panic https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2018/01/1... And perhaps not surprisingly some news outlets are using an unverified image from a tweet as a news story.
- notatoad 9y ago"This is real. provided by the office of the governor in hawaii" https://twitter.com/CivilBeat/status/953270472820457472 https://twitter.com/CivilBeat/status/953270472820457472
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoTo me, the biggest surprise is that this alert system actually worked. Whenever I set up sensing / monitoring systems for my web services, I often wonder if it really will work.
- everdev 9y agoMore spacing. Fixes all UIs.
- Kesty 9y agoNext outrage is when we will find out how much this technological masterpiece actually costed.
- nwhatt 9y agoLots of money to be made in "Enterprise" software, and even bigger amount of impact to be made by having smart developers working in the space. I'm not really sure where the problem lies, partly economics, and part lack of specialized knowledge. In this case that knowledge might be laws around AMBER alerts, how to respond to an RFP for such a system, or even just not knowing that such systems need to built.
- vardump 9y agoUI crudeness is one thing. What I wonder about is whether those links generate HTTP GET-requests. Links do so by default. If so, just need internal web spider or overzealous web browser prefetcher, and one day Hawaii might have a lot of false alerts going on... GET-requests are not supposed to have side effects, like alerting a whole state. When you have side effects, HTTP verb should be something else, like POST. Of course, it's possible there's Javascript handler behind those links that generates a HTTP POST request. Overall appearance of the page does suggest otherwise. I wonder how the confirmation page (if any) behaves and looks like...
- bfrydl 9y agoYou're assuming a lot here. This might not even be an HTML page. It used to be fairly common in Windows UIs to have underlined blue clickable text in native applications.
- vardump 9y agoWell, all I know it looks like an unstyled web page. We can just guess indeed. Oh, and their display mode is set incorrectly. It's clearly non-native resolution (blurry text, bilinear "zooming" performed by the display, while individual pixels are in sharp focus) and wrong aspect ratio (the font appears too wide). Perhaps 1024x768 on a display with 1920x1080 native resolution. Or something similar.
- ChiliConKanye 9y agoIf you're referring to "HTMLHelp" help applications they actually were HTML pages, under native chrome. If you can think of any other usages in non-browser UIs where links where used to navigate would love to see them for nostalgia's sake.
- timdeneau 9y agoDisturbing to see the control system for their emergency alert system is this careless. This was human error? No shit.
- Analemma_ 9y agoRoman Mars at least must be psyched. Next week’s 99PI episode is practically writing itself.
- foobaw 9y agoThis is crazy. I used to work on the engineering-side of this on phones (CMAS). The amount of requirements from the government and the carriers for the UI/UX were ridiculous (how the messages are precisely displayed to the users, requirements regarding data scenarios). To give an example, it took about 300 hours to verify each release. How is it possible that they don't have standards while the OEMs do?
- avenoir 9y agoThis is just my observation, but this is what you get when software is used in such critical situations and yet the entire software engineering/development field is completely non-standardized and practically the wild west. Again, this is my opinion, which I know a lot of people disagree with, but we're going to keep coming up against this kind of stuff until software developers become licensed and accountable for their designs.
- triangleman 9y agoYES once again we learn the hard way that this is the only "engineering" field in which its practitioners are not licensed, certified, belong to a professional organization with safe harbor protections, and so on.
- jeffdavis 9y agohttps://xkcd.com/970/ https://xkcd.com/970/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lowbloodsugar 9y agoAlternatively, a foreign adversary is taking its hacking to the next level, and this is damage control pretending that it's not. Advanced warships that "accidentally" run into other ships. Paralyzing remote islands with missile warnings. This is like the beginning of a Tom Clancy novel, and our cool, calm, collected President with his military and CIA experience will see us through.
- bactrian 9y agoIt’s almost so bad (even for gov work) that one wonders if it wasn’t designed like this recently as an excuse to run this “false alarm” exercise. This is the kind of thing we would want the gov to do and lie to us about because most people can’t handle the truth. “Put the links really close to tether so we can use that as an excuse.”
- anigbrowl 9y agoIt's nice to be validated.
- drake01 9y agoFound this on twitter: If @Github would have built the Hawaii text alert service: https://twitter.com/mattiasgeniar/status/952929404925202432 https://twitter.com/mattiasgeniar/status/952929404925202432
- mindcrash 9y agoAs a designer 2 things going through my mind since the moment the story broke the EMS system fired a statewide alert due to a wrongly clicked HI element: 1) How in the name of everything holy did this monstrosity of an interface for such an important system get approved in the first place? 2) Given a monstrosity of a interface: Why are there, apparently, ZERO safeguards in place to make sure the human error rate at least has a HUGE chance to get close to zero?
- wambotron 9y agoI've worked at quite a few companies in my time, and almost all of them have complete garbage for their internal tools. It's always perceived as "something we need, but it doesn't matter what it looks like" -- but this shows exactly why it _does_ matter. I actually prefer working on internal tools if given the opportunity, because I get to talk directly with most of, if not all, of the users and get real, continuous feedback.
- kvhdude 9y agoI remember while rooting my samsung phone, i had to 'reset all settings'. Settings to me means configuration options. Found out for the designer that settings meant _all_ data!. Lost some family photos that were not backed up.
- hartator 9y agoI kind of agree that’s ugly and can be way better, but I don’t see how you can make the confusion. One says drill, the other doesn’t. The guy should just get fired.
- krapp 9y agoI remember when former threads about this came up, some people were certain that it was impossible that a mistake like this could come down to "pushing the wrong button," because surely there would be safeguards and sanity checks in place. Ironically, moving the ballistic missile alert to an actual physical button separate from everything else would have been better than... this. This looks like it's literally just an HTML page on an internal network. Do they send the alert command through the query string or something?
- m3kw9 9y agoLooks like someone’s homepage on Angelfire 25 years ago lol
- freeelncer 9y agoJust redesigned that screen: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16164497 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16164497