14 ms·
I've noticed this many times too, particularly recently, and I call it "Google Alzheimer's" --- what was once a very powerful search engine that could give you
by userbinator 9y ago
I've noticed this many times too, particularly recently, and I call it "Google Alzheimer's" --- what was once a very powerful search engine that could give you thousands (yes, I've tried exhausting its result pages many times, and used to have much success finding the perfect site many dozens of pages deep in the results) of pages containing nothing but the exact words and phrase you search for has seemingly degraded into an approximation of a search engine that has knowledge of only very superficial information, will try to rewrite your queries and omit words (including the very word that makes all the difference --- I didn't put it in the search query for nothing!), and in general is becoming increasingly useless for finding the sort of detailed, specific information that search engines were once ideal for.
To add insult to injury, if you do try to make complex and slightly varying queries and exhaust its result pages in an effort to find something you know exists, very often it will think you're a robot and present you with a CAPTCHA, or just ban you completely (solving the CAPTCHA just gives you another, and no matter how many you solve it keeps refusing to search; but they probably benefit from all the AI help you just gave them, what bastards...) for a few hours.
Google had the biggest most comprehensive index for many years, which is why it was my sole search engine. Now I'm often finding better results with Bing, DuckDuckGo, Yahoo, and even Yandex, but part of me is very worried that large and extremely valuable parts of the Web are, despite still being accessible, simply "falling off the radar".
- copx 9y agoWhat annoys me the most is that Google seemingly no longer allows searching for phrases at all. In the past I could search for a specific phrase like this.. "It never rains on a Wednesday in Rockshire" ..and Google would return websites containing that exact phrase. That no longer works. Nowadays parentheses are largely ignored as far as I can tell. This is super annoying because quite often I am really looking for a website/websites containing a specific phrase. It seems they internally switched to indexing single words only. So if you search for a phrase Google will instead return websites containing (some of) the words in your phrase in no specific order and maybe not even next to each other. I think I understand why: Indexing / searching based on words is massively easier and massively less resource intense than a system which can search for specific phrases. Furthermore the type of searches Google wants/expects you to do e.g. "best hairdryer" work well enough, in fact work better if you only search for single words and then filter / organize the results using AI / using information you have collected about the user. EDIT: I was wrong. It still does work for many phrases, just not the ones I tend to search for. See below. EDIT 2: I actually have no idea what is going on there. I know that searching for exact phrases doesn't work for me like it used to but I have no idea why..
- red75prime 9y ago> Google would return websites containing that exact phrase. That no longer works. Er, what? No search engine finds "It never rains on a Wednesday in Rockshire". Results for "It never rains on a Wednesday" with exact matches Google - 6 pages Bing - 3 pages Yandex - 0 pages Duck Duck Go - 3 pages
- copx 9y agoThat was just a random example of a phrase. I made it up on the fly.
- emmelaich 9y agoNot sure what you expect then.
- mort96 9y agoHe isn't complaining that the specific phrase "It never rains on a Wednesday in Rockshire" to turn up any results. He used it as an example of the kind of phrase which, even though they exist somewhere on the web, won't be found with Google.
- njarboe 9y agoWell now it does. Strangely, for Bing this thread is third on the list but does not show any of the searched for text in the text blurb like the other suggestions.
- sgruetter 9y ago> Er, what? No search engine finds "It never rains on a Wednesday in Rockshire". Now: Google: https://imgur.com/a/tbOzE https://imgur.com/a/tbOzE Yandex: https://imgur.com/a/LB2qx https://imgur.com/a/LB2qx DuckDuckGo: 0 Bing: 0
- kenning 9y agoQuote marks still work. Google tries to find your phrase, and fails, then tries to give you results with some of your words missing without telling you. If you search for "It never rains on a" with quotes it will only show you pages with that exact phrase. If you search for that without quotes it will show you a messy group of results based on what it thought you meant.
- Declanomous 9y ago> has seemingly degraded into an approximation of a search engine that has knowledge of only very superficial information, will try to rewrite your queries and omit words (including the very word that makes all the difference...) I think the biggest irony is that the web allows for more adoption of long-tail movements than ever before, and Google has gotten significantly worse at turning these up. I assume this has something to do with the fact that information from the long tail is substantially less searched for than stuff within the normal bounds. This is a nightmare if you have any hobbies that share a common phrase with a vastly more popular hobby, and is especially common when it comes to tech-related activities. I use Linux at home, and I program VBA at work. At home Linux is crossed out of most of the first few pages, and I just get a ton of results about Windows, and at work VBA is crossed off and I get results about VB6 and .NET. Completely. Useless. I can only imagine this has something to do with their increasing reliance on AI, and the fact that the AI is probably incentivized to give a correct response to as many people'above the fold' as is possible. If 95% of people are served by dropping the specifically-chosen search term, then the AI probably thinks it's doing a great job. It seems like the web is being optimized for casual users, and using the internet is no longer as skill you can improve to create a path towards a more meaningful web experience.
- philipov 9y agoIt doesn't help that it seems every other project out there is trying to name itself after common words in the lexicon. I dare you to try finding information on the Box library.
- Mystrl 9y agohttps://ccse.lbl.gov/BoxLib/ https://ccse.lbl.gov/BoxLib/ Is it this thing at the very top of the search results?
- ReverseCold 9y agoFwiw my first page had nothing to do with anything computer related, except for the last result, which was how to make dialog boxes in Windows. First result: https://littlefreelibrary.org https://littlefreelibrary.org Search: Box library
- dannyw 9y agoI'm glad I'm not alone in thinking this way. I wish I could use the Google of 10 years ago. Pre-personalization, pre-deep-learning RankBrain, just the reliable and consistent search engine where complex queries will return the result I want, if it is there. Today, if I'm searching for something unpopular or specific, I usually get frustrated. You would expect the opposite to happen as the size of the web should increase over time.
- rectang 9y agoI wish I could go back to the Google of 1999. PageRank was magic before people learned to game it. The results were incredibly good.
- userbinator 9y agoPageRank was magic before people learned to game it Even then, before Google started going after them by filtering results, the SEO spam sites were pretty easily recognisable and ignorable as you scrolled through the results. Now, they still show up in droves (try searching for service manual PDFs and you'll instantly see what I mean) but you hit the end of the viewable results far too soon to find the useful stuff buried in later pages. In other words, Google's ranking now seems to be "good SEO'd sites > spammy SEO'd sites > everything else", and cuts off results before getting to that third category, when that third category should ideally switch places with the second and maybe even the first.
- userbinator 9y agoRankBrain Amusingly enough one of the definitions of "rank" is, according to Wiktionary, "having a very strong and bad taste or odor"... as in the smell of a decaying brain. How fitting. I almost wonder if it's deliberate. If they called it BrainRank (like PageRank), the adjectival meaning seems to be emphasised less.
- duggan 9y agoThe emphasis would be incorrect if the term were reversed - RankBrain is a Brain for Ranking like PageRank is a Rank for Pages. No doubt there is someone in Google, however, who has a project for ranking AIs called BrainRank for their own amusement. Anyway, your observation is also an amusing interpretation.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI've noticed the same and if you look across internet and search properties it's trending the same way. I'm not certain yet, but I think it has to do with systems relying more and more on the the system giving a high weighting on popular or frequent searches. In other words, these systems are filtering content by how frequent they are searched and annealing returns which have low frequency. This makes sense from a machine learning perspective. If I want to build a system which returns a search quickly, then it will be biased towards pathways with strong weights. So in the end, systems would be biased against outlier searches and very specific terms which have low or weak search pathways. Effectively the system is getting really fast and good at giving you the most popular return, rather than a precise return. The major problem there is that over time the search space will atrophy, much like memories do, and will kill off pathways which have low frequency. It's unclear if this is good or bad long term for a search engine, because it will remain popular for the majority of users, so long as their search terms and desired results live within the same space. In other words, we're creating a less diverse and more homogenous space by virtue of giving higher weights to more common thoughts/searches/desires.
- fixermark 9y agoI think the interesting question is: if you optimize the design to return rarely-accessed results reliably, what feature that we take for granted does that design sacrifice?
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoTo me it's obviously speed. Reducing the search space or cache or however you want to define it is the best way to increase speed. When milliseconds count that's important.
- Santosh83 9y agoThis is sad because humans are much much slower than computers and even 1 whole second is nothing to us. At least I am quite willing for Google to take a second or more to give me more thorough results. A query that takes 900 milliseconds is better than the same one taking 150 milliseconds but returning poorer results. The additional 750 milliseconds are virtually unnoticeable in human time and a small sacrifice to make for excellent search coverage. The only place where every millisecond may count is the case of automated queries running into the thousands and millions. I'm not aware Google even allows something like that and it's a corner case anyway. Human typed search is the majority use case.
- nostromo 9y agoSearching using “Verbatim” can be helpful. What’s particularly infuriating is when searching with verbatim still ignores keywords.
- colordrops 9y agoI still remember the day that stopped working. I decided that was the day Google died.
- Baeocystin 9y agoIs that when the + command was overridden in search to refer to G+ instead of 'this is a mandatory search item'? I am still shocked they ever thought that was a good idea, or that surrounding quotes was an acceptable replacement.
- cma 9y agoNo, when that was changed you could at that time just quote a single word to get the old +word behavior.
- therein 9y agoYears ago when I interviewed for a Software Engineer position at Google, the person I was matched to eat lunch with between the interviews was from the Search team. I asked him these exact questions. He said, the last time he checked, quoting a single word to mark it mandatory worked for him and that he definitely would know if it didn't. I didn't insist much at the time but I knew he didn't know what he was talking about, and it made me lose hope that this feature would ever come back working like it used to.
- Chriky 9y agoAre you saying the quote-a-single-word thing doesn't work for you?
- fixermark 9y agoI wonder if what you're seeing is a result of the Internet growing, not specifically Google degrading. Which is to say, as the indexable dataset grows, you'd expect the individual indices to turn up more and more heterogeneous results over time.
- dingo_bat 9y agoThe fact that other engines are able to offer up results tells me this is a Google thing, not the size of the internet.
- fixermark 9y ago... unless there's something Google offers up reliably that those other engines miss. Then what you're observing is heterogeneity of returned results due to the dataset being too large for any one index to cover it fully.
- pishpash 9y agoIt could be the internet (content) growing, or it could be the search engine changing, but to me, the most salient change over 20 years is the internet user base changing. At the risk of sounding elitist, the users of the internet have become a lot dumber on average. Search engines therefore grew dumber relative to the one that was tuned to people who were early adopters and used the tool for more productive purposes.
- fixermark 9y agoWith respect: yes, that does sound elitist. I would avoid assuming early use cases were more productive than subsequent average use cases (for one thing, it risks defining "productive" as "stuff I like to do," not via some more objective metric like "revenue generated," "human needs satisfied," or "questions answered").
- pishpash 9y agoOn the objective side, most revenue today is from advertisement and ad-generating content. Search engines make it easy to find ads, essentially. It's not about the content itself any more. So there is that.
- foobarian 9y agoI fear that something like PageRank used to work well just because back then many individuals had personal web pages with well curated links. It seems like this has slowly gone away, and now Google et al. have to resort to increasingly more hand-tuned AI extravaganza to get the search to work decently well at all.
- taneq 9y agoIronically this sort of "links section" probably dropped out of favour in large part because you could find those pages easily through Google, which knew which ones were good because they were linked in a lot of peoples' links sections...
- CurtMonash 9y agoAlso, it gets ever harder to keep up over time, as good links either go away or deteriorate in value. Perhaps not coincidentally, both the Yahoo Directory and DMOZ have been entirely shut down.
- bajsejohannes 9y ago> will try to rewrite your queries and omit words This has been bugging me too the last couple of years. Sometimes I would actually prefer an empty answer to one where various words are missing. Empty can mean an idea is still unexplored. I've started sending feedback to Google every time this happen. Maybe it'll make a difference if more people do it?
- wahnfrieden 9y agoIt’s a bit funny and sad how Google has both managed to seem overly clever to the point of being clumsily useless, and at the same time, continues to offer the original search experience that people pine for but no one knows or can be bothered with: add “intext:” before keywords and it’s the experience you’re wishing for.
- hartator 9y agoNever heard about that before; thanks for sharing.
- userbinator 9y agoI just tried a few of my old "dry" queries (as in, things I've always wanted to look for but can't seem to get good results) and didn't notice much difference... Furthermore, after a total of 3 "Next Page"'s, I got IP-banned with a CAPTCHA. I've had similar experiences recently with "site:" and the other colon-operators, so not entirely unexpected, but still immensely infuriating. It's almost like any real attempt to find what you're looking for, if it's rare, will result in punishment. :-(
- O_H_E 9y agoI start feeling like the web is being de-optimized for nerds & super-users
- FroshKiller 9y agoNothing wrong with that. You generally shouldn't optimize applications for power users. Software should be usable.
- starsinspace 9y agoGood software is when both kinds of users are pleased. As Alan Kay said "Simple things should be simple, complex things should be possible.". But it's probably the hardest thing in UX design to make something that is simple and powerful at the same time - most things sadly end up being only one of the two.
- derefr 9y agoAll this is true, and yet when I use Google Chrome's search autocomplete (which is partly server-side and partly client-side), it will usually fill in exactly the query that will get me what I want (rather than what query I think will get me what I want) before I even start typing it, using some combination of searches I've done before and the indexed text of open Chrome tabs. Google by itself isn't very good, but Googling from the Google Chrome address bar these days is something else.
- ericmcer 9y agoI think part of this has to do with googles actual customer base: Adwords users. The goal of Adwords is to have every single search be worth the maximum possible value in an advertising sense. So if one person a month searches for "Office desk drawer repairman Concord California" they do not want to service that very detailed long tail search, that would minimize value for themselves and maximize it for the advertiser. They want to treat that search in a vague sense so they can display more ads for their customers and charge for each display and click.
- mcguire 9y agoAren't DDG and Yahoo using Bing?
- dx034 9y agoDDG is now also using Yandex. Not sure which one is better though, I find complex queries still better answered at google (luckily that's quick via !g)
- frik 9y ago> Competition · Bing can find it! DuckDuckGo can too! Both of them can find Brent’s London Calling piece, too. Google, Bing, Yandex, Baidu = search engines Yahoo, DuckDuckGo, Startpage, and most other = meta search engine = just display and mix results of one or more third party search engines, because of that they are always slower (high latency) and/or show you cached (=older) results (Yahoo relies on Bing, DuckDuckGo on Bing and Yandex, etc)
- gaius 9y agovery superficial information, will try to rewrite your queries and omit words (including the very word that makes all the difference --- I didn't put it in the search query for nothing!) This is the algorithm deciding that it’s way results in more ad revenue for Google. What do you do? You repeat the query again and they show you a second lot of ads. But let’s be honest if Google could show you as many ads without returning any search results at all, they’d do that in a heartbeat.
- mirimir 9y agoAds? What ads? I see no ads.
- tripzilch 9y agoI actually forgot there's ads in Google's result pages. It's been ages since I've last seen them, uBlock is the first thing extension I install on a fresh Firefox.
- mirimir 9y agoYes, one tends to forget about ads ;)
- tripzilch 9y agoAh yes, forgetting... I feel we should maybe commemorate the atrocities of the past in some way... Like a National Remembrance Day for the Fallen Ads, we could have a moment of two minutes of ... loudly over-compressed slick fast talking sales pitches trying to make you feel bad about your life without their product. Oh, the nostalgia :) Actually thinking about it, I can get nostalgic and enjoy viewing certain ads sometimes, provided that they're over 10 years old. It's that whole icky feeling of being manipulated even while believing you know they do it (except they do it worse) these grabby greasy fingers reaching into my brain. After a about a decade, ads lose that power and they just become quaint. Like the "Jazz Solo Design" from the 90s (image search it and you'll recognize it immediately).
- nbsd4lyfe 9y agoThose captchas are the worst. Google asks me to answer one whenever I make search queries in the middle of the night.
- paulie_a 9y agoThe wierd thing is: Google created two captchas. One to digitize books and a shockingly awful one they use for their own services. Seriously the one they use for their own services is complete garbage and obnoxious to even attempt to deal with
- _pmf_ 9y agoWhat is the modern search engine that represents best what Google did at its functional peak?
- propman 9y agoI'm so glad I'm not the only person thinking that. Last year and a half or so I've started scouring forums and reading studies on google scholar rather than searching the web. And it's gotten worse and worse each year. I've been lazy and so acclimatized to the UI that I haven't changed, but I plan to now. It's especially difficult finding medical information. Mind boggling how 6-7 years ago it used to be so much better.
- paulie_a 9y agoI've also noticed Google omitting the only relevant and crucial keyword in my search over the last year. The First result will consistently show a result that has that keyword crossed out.
- JohnStrange 9y agoYandex is pretty good but I haven't found a use case for DDG yet. Whenever I set it for "privacy" reasons (not that I really believe them), I have to go back to Google to get reasonable results. I can confirm the memory loss, though, ego-surfing confirms it for me. Much of my older stuff is gone and all the top links for my name are related to my current work. (So in my case, it's kind of beneficial.)
- tripzilch 9y agoThat's because you're not using DDG's !bang syntax to its full power. I have it as my default address bar search engine so I can redirect straight to Wikipedia (using !w), Discogs or whatever of the 1000s of !bang abbreviations are defined. Just the amount of times where you know the most useful (and probably top) result on Google will be Wikipedia makes DDG worth it. Saves a click. But for me it saves a click very often. If I need Google occasionally I just append !g, but it's just one of the many other places I use !bangs for finding stuff.
- detaro 9y agoBut browsers already have that functionality built in, why go through DDG for that? (well, Chrome and Firefox do, not sure about others)
- tripzilch 9y agoIf others = Opera, then yes, they came up with that first :) I've been using those kinds of keyword search shortcuts for years before switching to DDG by default. The realisation was that having 100s (maybe 1000s already) of easily-guessable search shortcuts pre-programmed with DDG's !bang syntax is way more useful than having top configure 10-20 of them by yourself (and forgetting most of them when you reinstall a browser). Definitely worth the extra "!" keystroke and redirect :) [especially given DDG doesn't track you via that redirect].
- Daycrawler 9y agoThe worse is when it gives you results containing synonyms of your query words (and even highlights them in the little description under the link). Like, dude, I used this word for a reason
- dillweed 9y agoI concur - and then to run across a google aficionado who alerted us to a policy change where now paying to move up the charts was cutting them out and the paid for results not labeled as ads. The ultimate result of all good things when they get too big? Corporatize? I fear more that the people who should be creating the next google have been numbed and hypnotized into a state of flux, where everything is acceptable.
- beefhash 9y ago> solving the CAPTCHA just gives you another, and no matter how many you solve it keeps refusing to search They even have a patent on that: https://www.google.com/patents/US9407661 https://www.google.com/patents/US9407661
- naasking 9y ago> will try to rewrite your queries and omit words (including the very word that makes all the difference --- I didn't put it in the search query for nothing!) I've always double quoted the specific term I'm looking for. That usually bypasses this, ie. searching for "foo" will look specifically for foo and not food or what have you.
- londons_explore 9y agoThe timing of this correlates with the sharp rise and unavailability of DDR4 memory...? Coincidence? No...
- terminalcommand 9y agoI also get very angry at Google trying to stop me from making advanced queries. Even if I only chain a couple of Google's very limited operators together it shows me captchas and after a while the captchas do not stop. I keep solving them and it just wants more. Lately I've also been noticing that the behaviour of some google search operators are broken. " something " "otherthing" is not considered as an AND " something " OR "otherthing" is not considered as an OR. Google shows me the results it wants. I recently tried to research FreeBSD and Meltdown (I tried many times: "FreeBSD" "Meltdown", "FreeBSD" AND "Meltdown" etc.) and almost no result involved the terms both FreeBSD and Meltdown. The interesting thing was, Google did not say there was no results matching my criteria, it kept showing me popular IT news, linux news etc. It was extremely frustrating. The only operators that work are site, date and filetype. The logical operators do not work reliably or do not work at all. If you're searching for something popular google finds it best, but if your search patterns are deviant google ignores you and even thinks you're a bot and refuses to service you.
- Bartweiss 9y agoI'm enormously frustrated that Google has been killing off advanced-search tools. The loss of '+' is annoying, particularly since quoted and non-quoted mixtures are unreliable. Searching on "freebsd" "meltdown" might have solved your problem, but it's too unpredictable to be sure. My experience suggests that Google is doing something with site-level search, such that a site with only 'freebsd' won't appear but a site with 'freebsd' and 'meltdown' on different pages still might. '-', meanwhile, seems to simply be disabled some of the time.
- Cyberdog 9y agoI'm primarily a DDG user, and I get annoyed that it often drops terms from my query as well. However, if you prefix the term with a +, such as `+freebsd +meltdown`, it will reliably keep that term in my query and show me what I want. So my queries often get overwritten, but at least I can reliably override it.
- nezzle 9y agoYou fail CAPTCHAs and get flagged as a robot. Are you sure you're not a robot? I have the same problem. To pass Google CAPTCHA you have to perform like an average human. This is different from getting it right. Once I started being lazier, (e.g. back of a sign isn't a sign, picture that contains a storefront but in the distance doesn't contain a storefront), I have had greater success rates. It's like Google is training me to be dumber.
- JCzynski 9y agoAn image containing the back of the sign doesn't contain a sign. A sign is the front. The back is just a flat surface, not a sign.