11 ms·
Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area after new construction
- weeksie 9y agoHoly shit, supply and demand is still a thing! Last year I was in Seattle and all I heard was complaints about all of the highrises going up as if that was what was causing the high rents. headdesk
- timr 9y ago"Last year I was in Seattle and all I heard was complaints about all of the highrises going up as if that was what was causing the high rents." Well, no. People are complaining about the change in their neighborhoods, of which high rents and new construction are both observable qualities. But not to worry...if rents are truly declining, the new construction will rather quickly stop. Real estate investors are smart enough not to build into falling markets for long. They will leave holes in the ground before they complete a project that won't pencil out on financing -- just as they did in Seattle and San Francisco during the last bust. (Edit: you guys...really. The article itself says that construction has already slowed down: "Developers and banks that lend money for new construction have taken notice of the market cooling. While tons of new buildings are already approved or under construction now, the pipeline for future projects that exist only on paper is shrinking." If rents decline from new construction, it happens over years of economic shifts, not because developers rush headlong over the cliff like a bunch of lemmings.)
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoSigh, not sure why I feel the need to respond to posts like these, but this pattern, where a poster expresses haughty distain that others dare downvote them, then posts "evidence" that likely misses the point of the downvotes in the first place, is annoying. I don't think anyone who understands supply and demand thinks that new construction won't slow - it's pretty self evident that if demand slows that people will stop adding supply. If anything, I think folks are objecting to the tone of your post that makes it sound like declining rents will leave a wake of "holes in the ground" instead of a normal and healthy adjustment.
- timr 9y ago"not sure why I feel the need to respond to posts like these, but this pattern, where a poster expresses haughty distain that others dare downvote them, then posts "evidence" that likely misses the point of the downvotes in the first place, is annoying." I didn't post "evidence" (scare quotes yours). The quote is right there, in the article. It's something that's actually happening, and I quoted it because of the irony. Likewise, I lived in SF during the last crash. I saw the holes in the ground, with my own eyes -- developers pulled construction equipment out of foundations, and left them there, at mid-Market, in downtown San Francisco. I lived near two of them. Nothing I'm saying here is even remotely theoretical. The real issue is that there's a certain popular narrative here, and any facts that disagree with that narrative are immediately ejected from the conversation. It isn't "haughty disdain" to observe that people are rejecting facts that don't fit their biases.
- lsc 9y agoYou're not wrong, people are just objecting to your bombast. Also note, 2008 was unusually dramatic; one of the big projects in downtown sunnyvale went bankrupt and changed hands several times before completion. Yes, declining home prices do sometimes leave long term holes in the ground, but mostly only when prices decline a lot more quickly than expected, as they did in 2008. I was here in 2001, too, though (or a little up the peninsula) and there was a bigger drop in rent (though not sale prices) then than in 2008. In 2001, sure, you saw 'for rent' signs, but as far as I remember, the 'holes in the ground' as you put it, of buildings who's builders had gone bankrupt partway through were rare.
- timr 9y agoNah, people are objecting because they don't want to hear facts that contradict their preferred narrative. They want to believe that construction instantly lowers prices, and any information that contradicts this narrative is voted into the dirt on HN. I grant you that 2008 was exceptional, as recessions go...but it's not rare to see projects abandoned. I saw it in Seattle in 2001 as well. It just depends on the state of the projects when the recession hits -- you might not get "holes in the ground" unless the decline hits quite suddenly (as in 2008), but you definitely see projects abandoned. That's universal.
- c3534l 9y agoCertainly here in Portland that's what people complain about. The rent here isn't as bad as, say, New York City or San Francisco. But it does mean that over time people can no longer afford to live in the neighborhood they grew up in, and it means change that the existing residents don't want.
- timr 9y agoIt's also worth noting that rents have been declining in hot US markets since (at least) Q3 of 2016. The trend is nationwide, and owes more to macroeconomics than to construction in a particular market: https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-cities-see-apartment-rents-fall-for-first-time-in-years-1475614808 https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-cities-see-apartment-rents-... http://www.businessinsider.com/rents-are-plunging-in-the-most-expensive-us-cities-2017-12 http://www.businessinsider.com/rents-are-plunging-in-the-mos... https://www.cnbc.com/2016/12/03/rent-prices-show-signs-of-calming-down-with-nyc-san-francisco-and-dc-sliding.html https://www.cnbc.com/2016/12/03/rent-prices-show-signs-of-ca...
- stock_toaster 9y agoHasn't the Chinese government been clamping down more and more on "capital flight"? I read articles a few years ago how that [capital flight] was driving up rents in some markets. However, I imagine that would only have some impact in the so called "hot investment cities", but not /nationwide/. Any idea what the macroeconomic causes are?
- timr 9y agoInterest rates. The reversal of quantitative easing. Both have been propping up asset bubbles across the US (including, you guessed it: tech investment) -- which are now beginning to slowly deflate.
- weeksie 9y agoI think that's a fine point! Interest rates going up is def going to cool off investment. However, there can be more than one cause for an economic effect. Seattle had very low inventory and I'd be surprised if hundreds of new units coming online didn't put downward pressure on prices. But yeah, I haven't done the digging to attempt to quantify that effect. My second point remains, however. Building more housing does not inflate prices. (and yes, I know it's not quite as simple as econ 101 supply and demand, but)
- lsc 9y ago
- jxramos 9y agoyou mean trees don't grow to the stratosphere?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mandliya 9y agochuckle.
- ghein 9y agoInstead of rent control we need nationwide minimum rent increase. 5% annual minimum increase and a max 5 year tenancy. ( if the feds can ban drugs they can do this...) Encourages construction of rental housing, disarms communist terror groups like acorn, and breaks up Stalinist renters groups like most HN posters.
- smelendez 9y agoIt is complicated, though. Rich people moving in to a working class neighborhood makes the neighborhood more attractive to other rich people, both directly and by bringing in rich people amenities. So building high end housing can ultimately cause more demand and higher bids for the existing housing in the neighborhood.
- djsumdog 9y ago..and create whole areas like Capitol Hill which are mostly tech people moving in, pushing out others .. or what's going on in Freemont where homes that people bought for $120k now go for $800k (and you see low-to-middle income workers like cashiers, nurses, hair-stylists, cash out on their houses and move way out). This is a good start, but I hope they don't stop building and complete all the existing projects. The prices are still high. ST3 will help make it easier to live where you want, with a lower income, and still be able to commute reasonably, by train, to work.
- weeksie 9y agoWhile that's intuitive, that's not an argument against building high end housing. I do agree that it's complicated, though! As someone who lives in New York, I can attest that affluent people will just rent the apartments that already exist in the neighborhood and drive the prices up for everyone. The difference is that the shitty tenement one bedroom gets bumped to 3k/month because the affluent will displace the current occupants. If you build luxury buildings, the affluent will move into those. Sure, that will have a second order effect on the desirability of the neighborhood (which is what I believe you are arguing), but I am of the belief that that is a separate issue. Gentrification is its own bag of worms. A while back someone said "Luxury Housing is future middle class housing" and that rings pretty true. The economic incentives are to build nice properties and over time those properties get old. A good percentage of them get divided up into smaller places or simply rented for less as new inventory comes on line.
- fulafel 9y agoAlternative conclusion: So building high end housing can ultimately cause the rich people move to the high end housing away from the working class neighbourhood, making room for lower income people.
- kodablah 9y agoI worked on some pricing recommendation/forecasting software for apartments. Many things come into play, but yes the general multifamily goal is to sustain ~95% occupancy. That, along with competitor info, is primarily what drives the prices. Anything that increases vacancy or makes the competitors cheaper drops prices...kind of obvious of course.
- rorykoehler 9y agoShould have banned airbnb instead of having a sensible housing policy.
- Tiktaalik 9y agoThe significant takeaway for me as a Vancouverite is that these are apartments and they're reaching renters and rental vacancy is increasing. In contrast Vancouver is also building more substantially more multi-unit residences than ever before, but somehow Vancouver's vacancy rate remains sub 1%. In a reverse from Seattle, Vancouver predominantly builds condos, and this could be a factor. Vancouver, likely needing the assistance of the provincial and federal government for legislative changes, needs to start doing things differently, and Canadian governments need to find a way to incentivize developers to build rental apartments instead of condos.
- zbobet2012 9y agoMore likely they simply need to authorize them to do so...
- goodcanadian 9y agoThe condos usually end up on the rental market assuming they are not sitting vacant simply as a place for rich foreigners to stash their money.
- wvenable 9y agoCondo's also sit empty in Vancouver because they appreciate fast enough that it simply isn't worth the hassle to have renters.
- nikanj 9y agoVancouver likes to talk a lot about 10-20% of new condos sitting empty. For some reason, they completely ignore the 80-90% that do get tenants.
- baybal2 9y agoAs a former Vancouverite myself, I want to bring to attention of people that there are a lot of cities in the world with both very high vacancy rates, and high housing price, despite progressively growing housing stock. You can say that a lot of those cities fall under the category of "fancy towns" where people come not to earn money, but to spend them. There, markets can remain irrational for a loooong time: Sydney, Dubai city, Hongkong, Shenzhen On my memory, Shenzhen had an astronomic ~20% vacancy rate 5 to 6 years ago while already being the most expensive city in China. Rentier and property investors decided to wait out, expecting prices to go up even further, and they did!
- seltzered_ 9y agoSome things to note as a seattleite: Just because rent is decreasing on the high end doesnt mean it’s decreasing on the low end apartments. Apartments are built to a less restrictive code than condos. There aren’t many condos being built in seattle from reading other articles. Similarly there’s much debate about building more homes / townhomes / improving transit. Amazon supposedly had a hiring freeze recently, and close by (in SLU) I’ve seen folks dancing with “now leasing” signs.
- refurb 9y agoJust because rent is decreasing on the high end doesnt mean it’s decreasing on the low end apartments. There is a knock-on effect although depending on the spread it might be small. Ontario (Canada) just raised minimum wage by 20%+ in one shot to $15/hr. Lots of drama happening now as business owners try to adjust. What I found interesting is that workers who were making $15/hr before the increase are now asking for a raise. It was a restaurant where the front-end made $15 and the dish washers $12. Now the front end says "I should be making more than the dish washers" and it goes all the way up the chain.
- DaiPlusPlus 9y agoBut can those restaurant workers now comfortably (<33% of take-home) afford their rent?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dvanduzer 9y agoThe psychology of relative status garners a lot of attention to understand inequality. Of course there is backlash to front-of-house folks seeing their relative status decrease, despite the fact that nothing has changed for them. A difficult, but crucial adaptation needs to happen in a wide variety of industries: The people working the less glamorous, less visible, but equally crucial roles in operating these businesses should have been treated as peers / relative equals all along. The converse is also true in software engineering. Questions like whether programming is "more difficult" than graphic design are largely irrelevant. Humans will always be playing status games, but denigrating labor based on some perceived skill level is a habit we should actively be trying to get rid of. Meanwhile... > There is a knock-on effect although depending on the spread it might be small. Can you provide more specific detail where knock-on effects like this have been observed? It's nearly guaranteed that a decrease on low end rents will be vanishingly small. Margins can only go so low, which is why developers are attracted to luxury projects in the first place. (Likewise, a million dollar paycut from a CEO can only raise 480 person-hour-dollars in wages. But those margins matter a hell of a lot more for the line worker's lifestyle than upper management's.)
- gumby 9y agoOMFG the market works the way you'd expect. Actually, I shouldn't be so sarcastic: the news in this article is that Seattle let the market work. If only we could get this message through the Bay Area NIMBY's numb skulls.
- djsumdog 9y agoThe market didn't "Just work," in Seattle. There is a long history of things not going right. The city had to do a lot to get this current housing boom to get going, including a lot of subsidization. They also got a lot wrong (no where near enough low-income housing .. and a lot of the decent low income housing requiring you to be below the poverty line -- leaving the middle class in really tough spots paying Amazon employ rent while barely making enough to pay it.) It's still not really working. The homeless problem is still insane. There are still a ton of one unit dwellings that no one is bringing up to code; the ones that use to house the very low income around places like Belltown. Another thing that didn't "just work" was Amazon giving new employees discounts in certain condos. Turns out someone in HR didn't realize these types of deals were illegal, since private groups can't offer housing discounts or subsidizes or it violates various Fair Housing laws.
- TulliusCicero 9y ago> The market didn't "Just work," in Seattle. It is literally illegal to add to the housing supply in most of the city; a majority of Seattle land is zoned exclusively for detached single-family hones.
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoI wonder, if you count agents in a market economy as having not just money to spend making rational purchases, but also political power as a sort of alternate currency (represented by a vote each), is NIMBY really a rational market reaction. If you start in a fully free market state, and enough actors combine their political power to limit the market, then that results seems just as important, if not more important, than one where there is a limit placed on the system to prevent such actions. Even the US Constitution, which could be considered a very strong limiter in what combined political power can do on a city, state, or even federal level, can be modified by enough people combining their political power.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoarent a ton of people gonna move here when ali babba opens in that building downtown? (assuming the person telling me that wasnt full of shit) seems like 10k more tech workers could probably have a pretty big effect on the rental market
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoAlibaba isn’t going to employ 10k in Seattle, and probably not enough to move the needle on housing. They have about 40 (in Bellevue no less).
- djsumdog 9y agoI thought the poster was saying "Alibaba" to make fun of Amazon. Also I like calling those new buildings The Amazon Testicles.
- keyboardhitter 9y agoSame. Bezos' Balls of fury.
- senatorobama 9y agoOTOH, Baidu has a successful DL group.
- baybal2 9y agoAlibaba used to own a quite huge office in DT LA, but people in Alibaba I knew said that they never had more than ~40 full-timers and contractors in USA. They came to US for the talent, haven't found it, and mostly bailed the idea.
- HNSucksAss 9y agoIt's time for morons to stop overpaying and screwing everyone.
- junkscience2017 9y agoAssuming this construction has also not resulted in reduction of quality-of-life for the community, then this is a good for homeowners as well; it is introducing more potential buyers. My big concern with the Bay Area is the market for my house getting asphyxiated by a complete lack of liquidity in entry-level accommodation. There are a bunch of new rental/lease projects happening in the Bay Area, I see them in some phase of construction everywhere.
- keyboardhitter 9y agoAfter apartment hunting for months last year, I came to the conclusion that... a lot of the new apartments being built are tragically boring. Many units are alike -- cave-like, and give the impression that construction was rushed while passing off the design as "urban". So I found "fancier" places alluring, but in reality they are just apartments with a bit more than the bare minimum design. I sometimes wonder if there is a business scheme behind this contrast but I try not to feed into my paranoia.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thinkythought 9y agoAnecdotal, but in my building and several of my friends the landlords are just letting units sit open for months, as they flat out refuse to lower rents. They're actually remodeling one of them in an attempt to justify the(really, honestly ridiculously high) rents. So they may be dropping on the high end, but across a lot of people i've talked to the low to mid end is stubbornly holding strong and refusing to see the writing on the wall that a beat up older apartment building just... isn't worth this much. I have seen rents overall dropping on craigslist, especially for larger harder to rent units. They're down quite a bit from this summer if you're willing to split a 3+ bedroom apartment or house, when they were absolutely stratospheric before(often close to the same as just renting multiple cheap studios)