14 ms·
AirBnB units drop by 74% due to SF regulations
- gsich 9y agoNot surprising. Airbnb (and similar services) will lead to such abuse.
- refurb 9y agoI think one the most impactful parts of the regulation is getting your landlord's ok. God knows how many people were doing AirBnB knowing either their landlord would not be ok with it or their lease strictly forbidding it.
- jacquesm 9y agoLandlord or HOA.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoI think this will basically kill AirBnBs for any sizable multi-tenant building, which is basically 90% of the inventory in certain areas of the city. I don't know of any condo associations or professionally-managed apartment buildings that allow short-term rentals. Sure, single family homes or very small condo units (e.g. just a couple units where the owners all know each other) may allow it, but if other cities take this lead it will be a large, significant blow to AirBnB.
- dawnerd 9y agoWell they exist and they list on airbnb. Forget where but I noticed a whole bunch of very similar looking listing and I thought it was spam at first but realized it was just an apartment/condo complex putting their unleased inventory to work. Kinda smart I guess?
- hn_throwaway_99 9y ago> Well they exist and they list on airbnb. My whole point is they won't anymore in SF after this policy goes into full effect. Unless it's something like a hotel or real bed and breakfast (the article explains these exemptions), only primary residents are allowed to list short term rentals (this legislation was put into place to prevent investors from buying up places just to put on AirBnB). It's illegal for the building owner to put up short term (i.e. < 30 days) rentals for multiple units in a building zoned for apartments or condos. My point is that almost all large, multi-tenant buildings prevent their residents from doing short term rentals through subleases (or, if it's a condo building, in their HOA rules).
- URSpider94 9y agoIn many cases, this isn’t people renting out unused inventory. It’s landlords taking their apartments out of circulation for long-term tenants in order to rent to short-term tenants on AirBnB. Think about it - an Airbnb listing has to be furnished, so the landlord has to make a decent investment in order to put such a listing on the market. It’s not like they’re furnishing apartments in between tenants moving in/out to get a few night’s rent. This is also really unfriendly to tenants, you now have a bunch of strangers traipsing through the hallways with no relationship or accountability to the neighbors.
- visarga 9y ago> This is also really unfriendly to tenants, you now have a bunch of strangers traipsing through the hallways with no relationship or accountability to the neighbors. The root of the problem is that tourists have diverging interests compared to locals, because they don't have to share the same building for many years. In situations where agents have to deal again and again, tit-for-tat works. But not where they meet just once. It should be solved by good reputation tracking over rentals, so they don't escape responsibility - maybe reputation tracking should be outside the hands of a private company that has an interest in the game, like an independent organisation.
- TAForObvReasons 9y agoThe most significant points (that weren't discussed ad nauseam in previous discussions over the last few years) from the article: "About 2,000 people listed their homes but never rented to tourists." The percentage is artificially skewed by the effects of eliminating stale listings, and the real effect attributable to regulation is less significant than the headline suggests. "San Francisco charges a $250 registration fee plus a $90 business registration fee for all hosts." This is a scarier prospect for AirBnB and other companies. If $340 is really enough to scare off a significant percentage of people, how much are these hosts making?
- azurezyq 9y ago> Tenants and condo owners who can’t sublet: When renters register as hosts, the city notifies their building owner. “We think a good number of folks might meet city eligibility requirements, but may be renters with ‘no subletting clauses’ in their leases,” Guy said. Similarly, some condo associations bar subletting. I'd suggest this one of the major killing factors. Many sf units are basically condo titles, which cc&r usually forbid Airbnb.
- Bluestrike2 9y agoIt's more that the fees serve as a small barrier to entry for new hosts. While you can likely expect to make that initial cost back up after a few bookings, the fees—along with the paperwork and process associated with them—are a huge change from the earlier status quo. Before, you could have reasonably chosen to list your property on AirBnB on a whim with no financial risk. Now, it's a much more involved decision that requires spending money up front. I'd love to see some numbers on how many hosts de-listed after a short while without any bookings or stopped after one or two at the most. It seems like a given that those kinds of hosts are pretty much gone now.
- arkadiyt 9y ago> along with the paperwork and process associated with them We (airbnb) have integrated with the city for registration requirements so that you can do it from the web UI. Go into the "Manage Your Space" section and click the "Registration" tab. I work on appsec and did the security shepherding for this integration.
- unstatusthequo 9y agoGlad I'm leaving SF. Way too much red tape and too little freedom. One one hand it touts innovation, and with the other it strangles it. Typical government interference for the bad.
- asdjasldkjkljd 9y agoWouldn't blame it all on the government, the current residents are fighting any new housing with reasonable density — it's impossible to do anything about the price of housing when you can't increase the density. Citizens are literally fighting against 2-3 unit buildings which is insane because a 2-3 unit building is still way too small.
- bsder 9y agoMight I suggest Kansas? I hear that they are a utopian dream for lack of government interference. Please take a few people with you as well, if you can, thanks. The nice part about this is that with so many fewer AirBnB things going on, some rental units are likely to come back on the market.
- sergiotapia 9y ago"WARNING: This comment contains ideas known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm."
- adrianratnapala 9y agoI once got a swag-bag at a job interview in Switzerland. It contained a long thin object with just such a Californian warning on it. I was hoping it would be a giant glow stick or a rocket. You something with actual chemicals in it. But it turned out to just be a selfie stick.
- Kalium 9y agoAt this point, we may as well put one of those stickers on the entire State of California. "WARNING: The State of California contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer, birth defects, or other reproductive harm."
- oil7abibi 9y agoI mean not everyone will have a chance right away to register their listings. Give it a month or so, then check back on the numbers.
- swman 9y agodownside: less air bnb upside: maybe more housing available
- axau 9y agoAlmost certainly not. Many people in SF avoid long term rentals very much on purpose, because of the city’s comical tenant protection laws.
- ttul 9y agoVancouver is about to do the same with a new bylaw governing short term rentals. The cause is an unbelievable shortage of actual long term rentals for people who live in the city. But the cause of THAT shortage is not AirBnB. It’s rampant speculation by both locals and foreign investors. Rather than fix the tricky speculation issue, government focused on Airbnb. IMHO this will hurt both cities by making it more expensive to visit.
- mjfern 9y agoIf you own a property, why not just rent it for cash flow? What's the benefit of letting a property sit vacant? So the property owner doesn't have to deal with finding tenants and property wear and tear?
- karthikb 9y agoIf property value appreciation is significant (in SF, about 12% in 2017) the benefit of renting out (AirBnB or otherwise) may actually be minimal - as you said, the overhead of finding and managing the rental. $3k/month on a rental makes you far less than just 12% appreciation on a $1.5M place.
- maxxxxx 9y agoAnd renting out is a lot more work than keeping something empty.
- usaar333 9y agoWhere are you getting 12% appreciation from? Paragon (https://www.paragon-re.com/trend/san-francisco-home-prices-market-trends-news https://www.paragon-re.com/trend/san-francisco-home-prices-m...) shows it at 7% for houses and 5% for condos. That's ~6% after property taxes (assuming recently set cost basis) or $90k/year. Maintenance, HOA fees (if any) further drop this return. (Besides future appreciation isn't something you can bank on..) A $1.5M home should rent for at least $4.2k (P/R ratio of 30). That's $50k a year, smaller than the appreciation of $90k but still very significant. The only reason I see to not at least hire a rental management company to do the renting for you is if you are subject to rent control and fear not being able to evict the tenant/raise their rents.
- olfactory 9y agoI'd argue that none of the "desirable" outcomes are actually in the best interest of SF. They are, however, a huge boon for the remaining smaller number of hosts and of course for hotels. But all in all this will significantly increase the price of visiting SF and likely result in a significant decline in tourism revenue.
- beatpanda 9y agoG O O D
- zbentley 9y agoWould it be possible to clarify the title as currently posted? It's ambiguous whether the price or quantity of units dropped by 74%.
- dharness 9y agoI'm actually not sure I saw anything in the article that actually provides that figure - but it looks like it is meant to be the quantity.
- bkohlmann 9y agoI'd be interested to understand two things: 1) How has the average price for similar priced airbnb offerings changed pre and post regulations 2) How do vacancy rates for airbnb offerings in SF change following the purge? I can see trends in both directions. Would be an interesting empirical analysis of how supply changes outcomes.
- cozzyd 9y agoChicago has hard a hard time enforcing its ordinance: http://www.chicagobusiness.com/realestate/20171218/CRED03/171219896/airbnb-scofflaws-evade-chicago-officials http://www.chicagobusiness.com/realestate/20171218/CRED03/17... Hopefully SF's measure has more teeth.
- esturk 9y ago"HOW DO THEY SLIP THROUGH? - The problem: The city has yet to rule on about 1,300 applications that are missing a unit number or specific address. Until the new ordinance required that Airbnb collect that information, most hosts would list their home without an address or specific location, one way to avoid detection if the unit was in a building that prohibited vacation rentals. It's possible that some hosts deliberately filed an application without an address, hoping it would allow them to stay one step ahead of city regulators." Interesting you brought this up. Unless the listing is unbelievably attractive, a listing without a number or address just seems sketchy to me. Makes me think its the analog of a hourly rented motel.
- dmurray 9y agoAirbnb usually doesn't show the exact address to the customer before you've rented it, or at least it doesn't make it easy to find. I've always assumed this was to make it a little harder for landlords, neighbours or regulators to see that a property was being listed without their permission. If you're visiting an unfamiliar city and the place has good reviews, I don't see anything sketchy about only being able to narrow down the location to within a few hundred metres.
- cgmg 9y ago>Hopefully SF's measure has more teeth. Why?
- cozzyd 9y agoBecause an ordinance meant to achieve X should achieve X?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- intrasight 9y agoThese are not burdensome regulations. And, as was mentioned in this discussion, Airbnb makes the registration easy. So clearly the reduction is from (a) illegals getting out of the act, and (b) activation energy barrier of that registration fee.
- jokoon 9y agoInternet technologies have been constantly disrupting the rule of law for individual interests. I have no political statement to make about it, but there are so many issues between the internet and the law: content copyright, airbnb, uber, money laundering with bitcoin... If you're a technologist, I can clearly see how a libertarian agenda fits perfectly. Governments are not following on technologies to take advantage of them, or at least not quickly enough...
- visarga 9y agoHmm... so it used to be just 8453 rentals for a large city. It was a drop in the bucket.
- eggie5 9y agoI just read in Amsterdam they are introducing regulation that limits airbnb rentals to max 30 days/year.
- cbcoutinho 9y agoA friend of mine rents out her apartment using Airbnb and I remember it was a max of 60 days p/y. Are they reducing it? EDIT: Yea it looks like the city is reducing the legal number of days someone can rent out something via Airbnb [0,1] [0] https://techcrunch.com/2018/01/10/amsterdam-to-halve-airbnb-style-tourist-rentals-to-30-nights-a-year-per-host/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/01/10/amsterdam-to-halve-airbnb-... [1] https://www.engadget.com/2018/01/10/amsterdam-airbnb-rental-30-day-limit/ https://www.engadget.com/2018/01/10/amsterdam-airbnb-rental-...