18 ms·
Intentional Fire-Spreading by “Firehawk” Raptors in Northern Australia
- saycheese 9y agoStating the obvious, this clearly shows man is not the only animal to use fire as a tool.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- agumonkey 9y agooh god I thought it was a team name not an actual animal.
- jurasource 9y agoReminds me of the fire starting birds in Vernor Vinges "Marooned in Realtime", awesome book.
- viridian 9y agoThis is super cool, if a bit scary. Man Australia has it all though, 8/10 of the deadliest spiders, half the deadliest snakes, crocodiles, rockfish, and now firebirds. Inhabiting Australia is a testament to man's arrogance.
- jacques_chester 9y ago> Inhabiting Australia is a testament to man's arrogance. Given that humans inhabited Australia for at least 40,000 years without the benefits of domesticable crops or herd animals, I'd say it's a testament to incredible perseverance.
- electric_sheep 9y agoHaha, this has been a well-trod rant of mine for years. Don't forget scorpions, vampire bats, great white sharks, and the world's top 4 deadliest jellyfish!
- jacques_chester 9y agoI grew up in Darwin and lived to tell the tale. It's really very simple. Here is a diagram: [place where bad things are] [me] So long as I am not doing something dumb like going near an estuarine river filled with invisible deathbeasts, or getting into an ocean filled with transparently-tentacled murder-squigglies, or stomping through grass near logs with dozing fangjectors, I will be fine. It's just not difficult.
- rplnt 9y agoYour diagram got me a bit confused as the empty space was right over the fold and I was wondering why the comments wouldn't load and what a weird error [place where bad things are] is.
- a3n 9y agoIt's seems likely that people growing up in a place called Darwin would, in time, evolve a particular fitness to thrive.
- jacques_chester 9y agoI love it. Its only rival in my heart is New York.
- taneq 9y agoSo we're not the only: - tool-using animal - fire-using animal - language-using animal - animal which domesticates other animals - animal which builds complex structures Aha! I know! We're the only animal which continually comes up with reasons why we're special.
- nkoren 9y ago> Aha! I know! We're the only animal which continually comes up with reasons why we're special. Nope, that'd be cats.
- drakonka 9y agoCats don't need to come up with reasons why they're special. They just are.
- coldcode 9y agoCats are tool using as well: we are the tool.
- mschuster91 9y agoWe actually live in a symbiotic relationship with cats: we provide them with noms and warmth (and the cleaning of their litterboxes), they reward us with love. And the occasional thrown-off-the-table TV.
- 72deluxe 9y agoI think we are rewarded with "tolerance" which we interpret as love, based on our perception of the cat; if it is our own we see it as love; if it is someone else's, we think it is a friendly cat.
- zopa 9y agoTo be fair, many cats try very hard to reciprocate with food. It's not their fault we don't appreciate a nice fresh mouse.
- duncan_bayne 9y ago"Journal of Ethnobiology" "Though Aboriginal rangers and others who deal with bushfires take into account the risks posed by raptors that cause controlled burns to jump across firebreaks, official skepticism about the reality of avian fire-spreading hampers effective planning for landscape management and restoration. Via ethno-ornithological workshops and controlled field experiments with land managers, our collaborative research aims to situate fire-spreading as an important factor in fire management and fire ecology." I'll believe this when I see video proof, thanks. In the meantime I'm going to mentally file it with UFOs that are alien spacecraft, and reptilian overlords.
- jacques_chester 9y agoBasically, I'd trust Bob Gosford. And the folks out bush tend to have a fairly keen understanding of their local ecosystems.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoThis may be a personal failing on my part - argument from personal incredulity as Dawkins puts it - but the idea of a bird intentionally carrying fire instead of fleeing it seems a bit odd. See also http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-03-03/smart-bushfire-birds/7216934 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-03-03/smart-bushfire-birds/7...: > Mr Gosford said he had never actually seen a bird at a fire front, intentionally spreading the fire. > So he said he decided to appeal to people to come forward if they had seen birds behaving in that way. > Mr Gosford said he received 16 firsthand accounts from people who said they had witnessed birds spreading bushfires to flush out prey. > ... > He said he hoped by filming birds spreading fires, others would see how valuable Aboriginal knowledge could be to the broader community. It seems Mr. Gosford shares my desire to see a video of the birds in action. And hasn't been able to produce one yet.
- jacques_chester 9y ago> the idea of a bird intentionally carrying fire instead of fleeing it seems a bit odd. Fire-stick farming has probably been practiced for tens of thousands of years, which gives a lot of time for birds to evolve in response. Most bushfires in the top end attract raptors as-is (especially Wedge-Tailed Eagles), because there are strong thermals to ride and lots of prey is forced to move, making it easier to hunt. > It seems Mr. Gosford shares my desire to see a video of the birds in action. And hasn't been able to produce one yet. The remote parts of the NT are not a suburban or downtown environment. They are not drenched with folks carrying smart phones who are looking for such behaviour. It's vast, mostly empty and when a bushfire is coming what you're meant to be doing is getting the hell away from it before it catches up and kills you. I appreciate the skepticism, but I wouldn't put bush lore on the same footing as UFOs. One requires a plausible thesis consistent with our knowledge of physics and plausible within the increasingly large scope of observed animal behaviour. The other requires civilisations with FTL travel but no X-ray machines.
- Tarq0n 9y agoFirst website I've seen in a while that disallows viewing it with first-party cookies disabled.
- dp-tyvek 9y agoIt's not that uncommon for scientific journals, sadly.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoFrom http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-03-03/smart-bushfire-birds/7216934 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-03-03/smart-bushfire-birds/7...: > Mr Gosford said he had never actually seen a bird at a fire front, intentionally spreading the fire. > So he said he decided to appeal to people to come forward if they had seen birds behaving in that way. > Mr Gosford said he received 16 firsthand accounts from people who said they had witnessed birds spreading bushfires to flush out prey. > ... > He said he hoped by filming birds spreading fires, others would see how valuable Aboriginal knowledge could be to the broader community. This is a much more speculative thing than a reading of that abstract makes it out to be. It's not impossible, but there's no hard evidence of it as yet. Certainly, there's no video.
- gus_massa 9y agoI think that the abstract is clear, and probably they are using the correct terminology in their field. But the first time I read it I didn't notice that they are documenting first hand stories about the events, but not the events themselves (aka videos). > We document Indigenous Ecological Knowledge and non-Indigenous observations of intentional fire-spreading by the fire-foraging raptors Black Kite, Whistling Kite, and Brown Falcon in tropical Australian savannas. Observers report both solo and cooperative attempts, often successful, to spread wildfires intentionally via single-occasion or repeated transport of burning sticks in talons or beaks.* [..]
- nerdponx 9y agoI don't have full-text access so I can only read the abstract. Why would a bird want to spread a forest fire?
- hordeallergy 9y agoTo get the prey running into the open.
- daemin 9y agoBecause the fire flushes out small prey that the bird can catch and eat. This applies to snakes, small animals, and insects, all of which this species of bird and others can feed upon.
- davidhariri 9y agoI’m in the same boat as you, but in the book Sapiens it’s written that bush fires in Australia are started to force animals out of the forest and to create plains where they can be more effectively hunted in the future. Maybe the birds do this too (or learned it from people?)
- jmts 9y agoYou may have conflated a couple of things here that I think might be worthy of clarification. 1. Fires will force animals out of the forest for hunting. It sounds to me that this is the most likely reason for animals learning to spread fire. 2. While I expect sufficiently fierce fires will create plains, much of Australia's native flora is adapted to bush fires, and use it as an opportunity to regenerate. Many plants have seed pods that will only open after being burned. Thus, while much of Australia's bushland is dry, bushland that has been burned recently tends to be quite green and full of life, and many of the trees remain - however much furrier for their fresh growth of leaves. 3. Australian Aborigines (to my best recollection) were known for cycling parts of their territories as part of their nomadic lifestyle, farming somewhere, burning the land as the left, moving on, then returning again later when the land is restored and more plentiful.
- nithoalif 9y agoWww atau pake oopppoopppopoooppppb vv ujiaaan
- charlottepty 9y agoDo you need a hacker to help you hack any web site, do you ever want a QUICK and the most INTELLIGENT hack service? Then it is your lucky day to meet the most EFFICIENT, RELIABLE, SWIFT and INTELLIGENT hack professional alive…Basic Hacker. The services include the following service: -University grades hack -IPhone Hacking Tricks -YouTube Hacking Tricks -Email Hack -Paypal, MasterCard hack -Facebook Hacking Tricks -Hacking Software -Hacking Tricks -IP Address -Software Hacking -Hack Facebook Password Online -Already hacked online shopping pins for sale at give away price -Windows Hacking Tricks -Control devices remotely hack -Android Hacking Tricks -constantly get Free TalkTime from your network provider -Gmail Hacking Tricks -Twitter Hacking -Hack SECURITY AGENCY WEBSITE and ERASE CRIMINAL RECORDS -Hack any BANK WEBSITE -Hack any Company Website -Hack any government agency websit -Hack into any DATA BASE -Server Crashed hack -Tagged account -Untraceable IP etc…..You can contact davidtimmyhackprof@gmail.com / (818) 527-5489 for a fast work within few hours
- DrBazza 9y agoThe sixth referenced paper: Bird, R. B., D. W. Bird, B. F. Codding, C. H. Parker, and J. H. Jones. 2008. The “Fire Stick Farming” Hypothesis: Australian Aboriginal Foraging Strategies, Biodiversity, and Anthropogenic Fire Mosaics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105:14796–14801. Crossref, PubMed, Google Scholar Not quite an aptronym, but close.
- nakedrobot2 9y agoThe paper was written by two people called "Bird" ?! File under "nominative determinism"! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominative_determinism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominative_determinism
- CiPHPerCoder 9y agoI wonder if they're also self-professed pyromaniacs? :^) Kidding aside, I'd never heard about "nominative determinism" before. That's rather neat.
- acobster 9y agoI took a basic falconry lesson with my dad last year. Besides being one of the coolest things I did all year, I got to learn all about the species we worked with: the Harris hawk. Native to the Southwest region of North America, they are of the only (the only?) raptors that strategize together and hunt in packs. Apparently if you introduce two groups who have never interacted before, they will play games and talk to each other for a while, and just a couple hours later go out hunting together (with their human trainers). Also, according to our two instructors, the "universal" (read: they witnessed two Harris hawks do this independently) call for a dog or wolf, their natural predator, sounds like "Dog!"
- joshuaheard 9y agoI witnessed a Harris hawk attack a mockingbird in mid-flight outside my window once. It was brutal, blood and feathers sprayed everywhere, though the mockingbird managed to fly off with the hawk in hot pursuit. At first, I was like WTF!? Then I became curious. I identified the Harris hawk based on my brief sighting, and discovered that they were native to Texas, where I was living, and one of their main sources of prey is the mockingbird.
- tzs 9y agoIt's cheap and easy to encourage birds (and other animals) to come by your window more, if you want to see more of their behavior in person. A coworker has been putting out food for birds for several months, and regularly has something like 20 different species coming by for it, and another 10 or so species that only show up occasionally. It's to the point now that when he puts out food, he regularly has something like a couple dozen birds at once showing up. This includes some hawk species. He's got a camera running and has shown my some impressive footage of the hawks hunting the other birds. After seeing his videos and photos, and hearing his descriptions, I decided to give it a try. For the last few weeks I've been going out and putting unshelled unsalted peanuts on the rails of my deck, which I can watch from the window in front of my computer desk. I've since added black oil sunflower seeds to the mix [1]. I haven't seen nearly the variety of birds he has, and have seen no predator birds. I've mostly got Dark-eyed Juncos, Black-capped and Chestnut-backed Chickadees, Steller's Jays, Spotted Towees, and some kind of Crow (either American or Northwestern). A couple of times I've had some kind of gull, and I've seen one or two things about the size of the crows and jays but did not see it long enough to remember enough to look it up. Besides birds, he's also getting a lot of squirrels, some chipmunks, at least one opossum, and at least one raccoon. His squirrels have gotten to the point that they are not afraid of him. When he goes out to toss peanuts most of them gather at the edge of the bushes and watch him, and then will come get the peanuts while he is there if he doesn't get too close. (I think he also said that the birds have grown much more tolerant of his presence, too, such as eating from a feeder while he is right there filling it). One, though, actually comes up to his window and jumps around until the squirrel sees that it has been seen, and then runs to the door to wait for my coworker to come out. That squirrel will actually come up and take an offered peanut from his hand. He's also had the raccoon approach, but was uncomfortable with that and so tossed some peanuts behind the raccoon to get it to move away. A couple evenings ago he went out, and the raccoon was there. It ran away and he thought he'd scared it off and sat down on the porch. The raccoon had actually just circled around the house to come up from the other side. The coworker tossed the raccoon a peanut. It was a weak toss and only went a couple feet. After a few more tosses, the raccoon would hold out his hands palm up, and wait for a peanut to be handed to him. (He (the human, not the raccoon) was wearing protective gloves just in case). The only thing I've gotten besides birds is squirrels (at least that I've seen). I've seen raccoons in my neighborhood before, but not recently, and a couple of times I put out some seed and peanuts to close too the bird's bedtime, and so there was food on my deck overnight, and it was all undisturbed in the morning. (I'm only putting out food. The coworker has also added some water features to his landscaping that provide good drinking water for animals. From what he told me and what I've read, that makes a place much more attractive to raccoons, which could be why he's getting them. I do not want raccoons, so will not be providing water to the animals). I'm pretty sure a lot of the little birds I see live in the bushes and trees in my front yard, because if I put out food near sunrise, I now get up to a dozen of them quickly coming out of those bushes and trees, taking a seed or peanut, and flying back. If I do the same thing at random times throughout the day, the little birds still mostly come from those trees and bushes, but instead of a dozen or more at once, it is in ones and twos over a longer time. Finally, if I put out food as sunset nears, it is back to a whole bunch showing up at once. Thus, I'm guessing that they live in those trees and bushes, and so near sunrise and sunset that are all home. Hence the crowd. In the middle of the day, they are mostly out roaming around looking for food, and so they only find my food when their roaming brings them back home. I wish I had thought to do some kind of survey of bird population in those trees and bushes before I started putting out food. I'd like to know if they have moved in there because of the regular food, or if they were always there and I just didn't notice them. [1] ...because they are cheap and birds like them. A 10 pound bag is around $9 at Walmart, and will last for me about 45 days. A 40 pound bag is around $20 dollars.
- padobson 9y agoAnyone know if the researchers took any pictures/video of the hawks at work?
- adrianratnapala 9y agoWait, is it the raptors that are intentionally spreading fires by carrying burning sticks around, or is it the local people intentially spreading fires by giving them by burning sticks to carry? And if so, why do the raptors do it?
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoDoes anyone have any idea why the birds do that? Is an attempt made to provide an explanation, in the full article?