12 ms·
Apple iPhone X Demand Limited, Wall Street Analysts Say
- chewz 9y agoiPhones are technological marvels, masterpieces of engineering. But Apple software is getting worse and worse. I have recently started playing with my Mom’s phone which is some cheap Huawei Android and surprise - I can do the same on this phone as on iPhone - Google Maps, Google Photos, Google Inbox, Google Search, Google Allo, Google Drive, Firefox, bank applications, Spotify, MS Outlook - everything works OK. The feeling is liberating like discovering Linux after years of thinking that Windows is the only choice. I have stoped using Apple Maps, Apple Music, Apple Photos, Apple Mail app, iCloud etc because they are all half-baked and frustrating. At least Google is trying harder with their software. So what is the reason - excluding vanity - to pay 1000$ for a phone when I can have the same functionality for 100 - 200$. I will spend the difference on books, coffee and really good headphones.
- thisacctforreal 9y agoSome areas iPhones excel in: - LTS Updates - HW quality - Relatively consistent UX elements - Foolproof-ish App store - Less features ie no App drawer, just homescreens - Forefront of security & privacy technology The 5s was released Oct 2013, and still received iOS 11. It was also the first(?) phone with a Secure-Enclave device for fingerprint reading. If iOS doesn't limit your glass-brick usage patterns, it's a very simple OS, with features that were thought about and picked for a reason. Or maybe more importantly, left out for a reason. This of course gets frustrating if you disagree with what Apple's designers have prescribed you. But to a lot of people; Android phones these days feel creepy to be around, with the amount of Google-integration that requires much hoop-jumping and ignoring-of-gentle-pushes, just to get peace of mind over your data not being vacuumed from whatever crevices Google can find. And there are a lot of crevices on your personal smart phone. If you're installing + maintaining LineageOS or something then you can get par with iPhones for the features that a lot of people in the HN crowd might care about, especially if you subsect for DDG-users.
- cinquemb 9y ago>But to a lot of people; Android phones these days feel creepy to be around, with the amount of Google-integration that requires much hoop-jumping and ignoring-of-gentle-pushes, just to get peace of mind over your data not being vacuumed from whatever crevices Google can find. And there are a lot of crevices on your personal smart phone. The way some people use their iPhone (my partner included) and all the (cr)Apps they have and what they do, it may as well be an android phoning home to google… also ignoring when its in airplane mode, telecos routinely connect through to the phone via baseband… Even with all the conveniences, sometimes its just better to leave my phone at home… esp with all the times something is just trying to connect to apples servers.
- yladiz 9y ago> The way some people use their iPhone (my partner included) and all the (cr)Apps they have and what they do, it may as well be an android phoning home to google The difference is that with the apps installed on a phone, you can uninstall the app. With Android you can't just "uninstall" the Play Store.
- Yetanfou 9y agoSure you can. You'll need to uninstall Google Play Services as well but it is definitely possible to run Android without the Google-specific bits. It's is the first thing I do when setting up a new Android-device.
- yladiz 9y agoOut of curiosity, how difficult is this to do? Would the average user be able to do this easily?
- Simaramis 9y agoIt is distinctly non-trivial. Likely part of the reason why it remains possible. Chasing down bugs is the unavoidable result, but to a geek it's manageable. MicroG works very well once sorted. It is however astonishing how much processing power Play Services gobbles up. A de-googlefied phone lasts 30-40% longer on a charge. Once done, it works like a breeze. 3-4 year old flagships Androids are titans when de-googled and with custom roms.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- GVIrish 9y agoI have been using Nexus phones for about the last 5 years now, and I would say that a iPhone is clearly a better piece of hardware than a $100-200 Android phone. But for the top tier Android phones I'd agree that the reasons for paying the Apple premium are dwindling. Looking at something like the Essential phone that's retailing for $500, I think the many users would be hard-pressed to find an extra $500 of value out of the iPhone X. Then you look at a Pixel 2 XL, that's about $200 cheaper than the iPhone X while still featuring a very high level of fit, finish, and performance, and it gets to be a good deal harder to make the case for the iPhone X. Android and particularly vanilla Android have really closed the gap on iOS while Apple has gone a bit backwards in some respects.
- bluedino 9y ago>> then you look at a Pixel 2 XL, that's about $200 cheaper than the iPhone X And that's where the iPhone 8+ comes in.
- GVIrish 9y agoYep. I have to wonder whether the iPhone X is just Apple's way of taking advantage of the customer segment that is price insensitive and actually wants to spend more to get an iPhone that is rarer as sort of a status symbol. The Wall Street Analysts may have just misunderstood what Apple was actually trying to do when they made their first sales estimates.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rubatuga 9y agoApple photos, Apple mail, and Apple Music are amazing in my opinion. Apple maps, disappoints however
- juicy-fruit 9y agoI've been applying to Apple recently and I've submitted well over 20 applications and still no replies. Clearly, they don't think I'm a good fit for whatever they are looking for in a software engineer. I was taking a shower this morning when I realized... Apple doesn't care about software. I realized almost all the software I use on my iPhone or Mac is third party (excluding macOS and iOS). I realized Apple Music is quite possibly the worst piece of music software ever created by man. I realized iOS 11 is buggy as hell. I realized Siri is the worst "assistant" in the market. Apple clearly makes amazing hardware, but they fall behind when it comes to software. Their hardware design is the best in the game, but their software UI/UX is horrible. I know a lot of good designers who work at Apple and I know for a fact that they do amazing work on their own, yet they are unable to show this in the final Apple product. This must imply these designers' talents are wasted at Apple and they are not given a platform to shine. So I'm going stop applying to Apple because clearly we both don't see a good fit for one another.
- mcphage 9y agoIf you're anything like me, losing out on iMessages will be painful. I'm itching to get back to iOS. Also being able to access all of the apps that I've purchased on my phone again will be a very nice plus.
- reaperducer 9y ago>I can have the same functionality for 100 - 200$ Because the $1,000 iPhone and a $100 Android don't have the same functionality. Because you require a very small, Google-centric toolkit means that a $100 phone is a good fit for you. But there's a few billion other people on the planet, and some of them have different needs, wants, and desires. But feel free to continue patting yourself on the back in public for your lifestyle choices, if that makes you feel better. Not everyone finds nobility in frugality.
- batter_eaze 9y agoThe non-metal rear back plate, and the absence of a headphone jack are really stiff turn-offs considering the price. Also, it’s kinda big and heavy in terms of the physical dimensions of the form factor, and besides, I’m just not that into photography. Also, the whole thing with the batteries, and not so much the surreptitious performance throttling, but more the eternally non-swappable battery locked behind delicate ribbon leads inside the pentalobe-secured chasis. So, sorted in preferential order (most desirable first), for an extra special X model, I’d have enjoyed seeing: - the all metal, black gloss finish introduced with the iPhone 7 (yes i’ll be clapping inside some stupid mil-spec plastic envelope because it’s $1,000 but metal doesn’t shatter into a gritty spider web on a bad drop) - normal wired headphones - USB-C replacing the lightning port, because one less dongle for my macbook pro - sane, toolless battery options, ...maybe a universal apple battery format? (yeah right) - maybe smaller and pocket friendly? i dunno... maybe the bigger screen is nice to have... - and whatever other extra crap they bundled in lately Also, a watch without the weird red dot on the dial? Christ, almighty. Why the red dot? Why?
- bob_theslob646 9y agoI think a major mistake Apple made was assuming that it's iPhone base would be willing to accept change so quickly coupled with the fact that they charge 1000 dollars for the phone. I think psychologically , that number bothers people. It would be interesting to see what age most iPhone users are. I know plenty of elderly people in their 70s and early 80s in the U.S., who have an iPhone because it is super simple to use. The iPhone X, with it's gestures, not so much, but what do I know.
- olegkikin 9y agoWhat do people buy $1000 smartphones for? For gaming I can get a pretty good gaming PC for that amount, or Xbox One X with a VR headset. I've never seen anybody do anything really cool with their phone - everyone browses the internet, checks the email, does chats/videochats, maps, take photos, and some silly mobile gaming. I do that all on my sub $200 phone.
- tlholaday 9y ago> What do people buy $1000 smartphones for? Consider the iPhone X a smartcamera instead of a smartphone. Consider the "portraits in low light" at the end of the side-by-side comparison section that Vanessa Hand Orellana and Lexy Savvides did for CNET here: https://www.cnet.com/news/iphone-x-vs-iphone-8-plus-is-the-camera-worth-the-money/ https://www.cnet.com/news/iphone-x-vs-iphone-8-plus-is-the-c...
- olegkikin 9y agoIf I want a low-light camera, I will buy a DSLR/mirrorless, and no smartphone comes even close to something like Sony A7s (~$1100 used). I used to do commercial portrait photography, so I know. I also dislike the fake background blur / bokeh trend. I understand why the companies are doing it, but it's insanely hard to implement it right, and no phone has achieved it. Every time there's hair involved, they all fail.
- piptastic 9y agoMaybe for a specific event, but carrying around a DSLR everywhere you go is no fun. For candid shots, or traveling without carrying around a backpack everywhere, a phone that can take amazing pictures is awesome.
- valuearb 9y agoMy DSLR is terrible at browsing the web and getting my emails. Don't get me started on trying to play angry birds on it.
- dfabulich 9y ago
- thisisit 9y agoI think Apple might have missed the mark by not adding some kind of incentive for the wireless operators to continue offering subsidized phones. Wireless operators helped create the market when the $500+ iPhone was considered costly: http://fortune.com/2017/01/11/death-of-the-199-iphone-wireless-subsidy/ http://fortune.com/2017/01/11/death-of-the-199-iphone-wirele... Additionally, phone market is reaching maturity slowly. First few generations had real changes in terms of hardware and capability. Sure, there are new capabilities but none of them are in the category of "Must Have".
- at-fates-hands 9y ago> Additionally, phone market is reaching maturity slowly. First few generations had real changes in terms of hardware and capability. Sure, there are new capabilities but none of them are in the category of "Must Have". I've been saying this for years. I'm starting to see family and friends holding onto their phones for two, sometimes three years now. The prime movers to upgrade are slowly disappearing like you said.
- nugi 9y agoYup. I have been elegibe for an upgrade for 3 years, yet no current phone matches the featureset I have currently. - Removable battery (huge deal, i carry 2 spares, often away from chargers for days) - headphone jack (bt quality sucks, a lot, also battery and security issues keeping it on) - Physical function buttons - Waterproof/resistant, semi rugged. (Can I use it ouside in weather? Useless if not.) - Decent camera, and audio. - Gets regular security updates. - Removable mass storage - Makes and recieves phone calls without excessive dropouts. - Internet connectivity with email and very basic browser. Most modern phones dont even check half the boxes. They all seem to be made for people who never leave their car or office.
- kalleboo 9y ago> - Removable battery (huge deal, i carry 2 spares, often away from chargers for days) I thought losing the removable battery would be a huge deal when I switched to the iPhone, but in practice, switching to using USB powerbanks was actually an improvement. Don't have to reboot when you swap out, and you can charge it at the same time as your phone without carrying an extra special charger. And you can get them in massive capacities, and share them with friends who are caught out.
- PacketPaul 9y agoGood. The phone is too damn expensive. My middle school son has a $64 BLU phone. It was subsidized by Amazon in return for ads on the lock screen. Non-subsidized price is around $100. Last week we went to a theme park with a lot of waiting for rides. He played plants vs zombies and YouTube videos non-stop while we waited for rides. I occasionally surfed the web on my $1049 iPhone X. By 3 PM my iPhone battery was dead. His battery ... 64%. I’m hard pressed to justify the $1000 price tag of my phone after seeing his in action. Yea it takes better pictures and the screen it a little better. But is that worth $1000 premium? Oh yea, my Son’s phone is over a year old. So compared to an iPhone 7 the differences are even less.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- no-such-address 9y agoWhy not ask Apple to replace the battery and see if that helps?
- yeukhon 9y agoI would also look at 1. Battery save mode 2. Lower the brightness 3. Disable most, if not all, background refresh. Apple does queey a lot of things in the background itself... but I feel you. Generally these tricks would save you a lot of power and should last an few hours longer for a low-mid usage.
- valuearb 9y agoToo expensive? It’s $10 a month more.
- smnrchrds 9y agoPhone contracts are 2-3 years. $10 a month would mean $240-360 in total. Is that correct? Here is Canada, the price tag from Apple is about $1300 (Canadian dollar is worth less than US dollars). I can buy it from a carrier for $1000 upfront plus $15 a month for 24 month. There are other options to pay less upfront and more each month, but the total is always the same. Can you really buy an iPhone X in the US with less than $400 total?
- dkrich 9y agoI think market analysts continue to miss the mark on this story. What I keep hearing over and over are variations of "people are turned off by the $1,000 price tag." I think this is a complete misread. People don't pay $1k for an iPhone because it's the practical thing to do. If practicality is the #1 priority for phone shoppers, they will simply buy a 7 or 8. I don't think this comprises the top of the market, though, and the top of the market is Apple's wheelhouse. Practicality has nothing to do with why people buy the X. People buy the X because it's a status symbol and they want to be seen with it. With consumer spending up pretty much across the board, I will be very surprised if Apple misses on earnings next month or reduces guidance. I think comparisons to the release of the 6 are misguided as well, since this phone was in shorter supply to begin with, carried a 50% higher price point, and was released alongside two other models.
- aiofgniaotnio 9y ago>People buy the X because it's a status symbol and they want to be seen with it. I find this aspect of the tech industry so gross that I'm considering changing careers. Building a new tool that makes people's lives better is great, but much of the time it just becomes a status symbol. No one should feel bad for owning a machine that's a few years old but does everything they need. I'm not convinced that consumer gadgets fill a real need any more rather than just being new and shiny for the sake of being new and shiny. Unless we as a society can get over showing off by buying things we don't need, I think we're in trouble.
- dkrich 9y agoI don't disagree with you about what people should do, but the reality is that consumers have been this way for a long time, the only thing that changed is that phones shifted from commodities people bought for performance to fashion accessories. People pay more for cars, bags, clothing, etc. to elevate their feeling of status, now we can add phones to that list. Perhaps this has been Apple's greatest contribution to the hardware industry.
- QAPereo 9y ago
- jsjohnst 9y agoI wonder if these analysts actually get out in the world or just sit in cubicles closed off from the real world. Traveling this holiday season, I saw the characteristic notch all over the place. Rural areas of flyover country included, saw them everywhere. In the month prior while in NYC, I saw them being used by folks of virtually every division of socio-economic background. I’ve not traveled internationally yet since it was released, but it seems in the US anyway that the X marks the spot of a home run release for Apple to me.
- andybak 9y agoSurely shipment figures trumps your personal travel observations?
- alyxmxe 9y agoI've been in NYC, Tokyo, Hong Kong, Singapore, SF, Los Angeles over the past few months. Haven't seen a single iPhone X yet.
- jsjohnst 9y agoWell they’ve only been available for a bit over a month now, but either way, if you’ve not seen one, you are simply staring at your phone or have blinders on. Seriously, SF not seeing one!?
- brahj123 9y agoIf you haven't seen one in nyc, then you're either blind or don't know what the iPhone X looks like.
- kalleboo 9y agoPeople still believe the shit "analysts" say?
- pinewurst 9y agoWhy doesn't anyone call out that these are Grade Z analysts? Come on, Sinolink and JL Warren?
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoI agree with this analyst analysis.
- ramshanker 9y agoI swear this post seems to have suddenly dropped out of HN. I saw it on the phone. Than came to laptop only to find it no where. As it can be seen, some many comments were posted in last few minutes of this post. Is there some moderation or something?
- Steko 9y agoIt seems like most articles about Apple are quickly flagged off the front page by a small cadre of haters.
- DSingularity 9y agoGoodness. Everyone is speaking with such authority. I bought my X because I wanted to switch out of Android and because I only buy a phone once every three years it pays to buy the best phone I can buy. Why should I care that it’s 1000$ when I buy a phone once every three years?
- grepthisab 9y agoBecause $1000 is a lot of money to most people.
- jakebasile 9y agoThat's true, but why should that color someone's decision on what they buy?
- grepthisab 9y agoBecause people who budget responsibly live within the constraints of that budget.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoThis is not surprising. Like PC sales a decade ago phone replacements were going to slow.
- Joeri 9y agoThe iphone X is very overpriced when viewed as a utility object, because it doesn’t provide 4x the utility of a $250 phone. But it is very reasonable when viewed as a fashion accessory. A $1000 phone to go inside a $2000 purse is not crazy at all. People keep looking at apple as a tech company and struggling to understand them, but if you view them as a luxury/fashion company who happens to specialize in technology they make a lot of sense. Nobody complains ferraris are overpriced for the mileage they get and the amount of trunk space, because utility is not the point of a ferrari. I expect the iphone X to sell really well, to the crowd that buys luxury. The question is whether that is a big enough market to sustain the volume.
- scarface74 9y agoSustain the volume at what level? All indications are that Apple makes less profit on the iPhone X than the other phones. Apple would be quite happy if someone bought any iPhone that they sell from the 6s to the 8s Plus 256GB. I'm purposefully excluding the SE. I think that probably has a lower profit margin. And how is it overpriced? There is no such thing as an overpriced item in a free market as long as the quantity that Apple can make in a given time period matches the quantity people are willing to buy.
- EpicEng 9y ago>There is no such thing as an overpriced item in a free market as long as the quantity that Apple can make in a given time period matches the quantity people are willing to buy. That's the market perspective, but there's a value perspective as well. For example, my kid loves blind bags (no more youtube I think...) These companies want to sell him $0.05 plastic dolls for $5 and they prey on his gambling response to do so. These things are not worth anywhere near $5 except from the perspective that commercials can make my kid want them.
- scarface74 9y agoIn the aggregate, "the value perspective", is how many people value the product enough to pay Apple's asking price. If the value perspective isn't enough to sell the number of phones Apple can make, then Apple would lower the price.
- nugi 9y agoIts a luxury, disposable income signalling device. I don't know many tech savvy people with iphones of any kind anymore. Its clearly image and exclusivity driving sales, not features. I think many people see apple as a luxury brand more than a technology company now. Which might be better than the alternative. 'Anyone' can create tech, it takes years and billions to create a valuable brand.
- CharlesW 9y ago> I don't know many tech savvy people with iphones of any kind anymore. To present alternate anecdata, nearly every tech savvy person I know uses an iPhone, especially those who understand the privacy differences between the Apple and Google ecosystems.
- jrs95 9y agoThis is bullshit. I just switched back from Android to an iPhone X and I'm loving it. More than half of the software engineers I work with have iPhones. None of us seem to be particularly interested in 'image and exclusivity'.
- sajithdilshan 9y agoI have been using a Xaiomi Mi4i for a couple of months and at the beginning it was great. The camera was awesome and it was worth the 200$ I paid for it. But after few months it became slow and the storage became a bottleneck. After that I've switch to an iPhone SE and never looked back. I've been using if for almost a year and it is smooth and perfect for my day-to-day work and not to mention it is worth every penny I've paid for it. I think I'm gonna stick with it for a couple of years.
- scarface74 9y agoWho am I suppose to believe "analysts" or Apple who gave revenue estimates that if they met, would be a record breaking quarter for them? By the time they gave those estimates, they were already about a month in the first calendar quarter.
- pfranz 9y agoGood? I feel like these "analyst" reports are often completely wrong and generally not useful. Who knows what Apple's goal with the iPhone X is, but as an observer I see it as a low volume, premium product, that allows them to innovate. If you have a crazy high volume product you can't do anything risky...even if you could you'd run into volume issues (acquiring parts) and any bad choice would affect a majority of your profits for the year.
- JohnTHaller 9y agoThe couple folks I know of who got the iPhone X were really keen on animojis, so Apple artificially limiting animojis to the X seems to be driving a few sales. There's no technical reason you can't do them on a regular old iPhone 8 since they only use the regular camera. It's purely a marketing limitation.