11 ms·
Do people really believe that infrastructure is not the purview of the government? Roads, water, electrical, internet, etc. should all be built out first on a
by fastball 9y ago
Do people really believe that infrastructure is not the purview of the government?
Roads, water, electrical, internet, etc. should all be built out first on a municipal level, then the state should connect those municipalities, then the federal government should connect those states. The various levels of government do not need to (should not?) be the ones to operate this infrastructure, but I absolutely believe that to foster competition they should build it out and lease it to others (and such an operational lease should never be exclusive / too long-term)
Is there a good argument against this? Who doesn't think the US Highway System has been great for our economy? Who doesn't think a US Internet System would be great for our economy too?
- sitepodmatt 9y agoYes, what you are describing is basically the UK railway. Network rail (government) subcontract out maintainence and build to the private companies (Alstom etc..) and then lease track access to private companies (Virgin trains etc...). The UK has possibly the most overpriced railway in the world, at least in this instance it fair to say 'it didnt work' unless you want to pay 300usd to get from london to glasgow in economy.
- pjc50 9y agoNote that the system was fully private for a while (Railtrack PLC), until they went bankrupt. I think it's going to be expensive whether it's public or private, for complex reasons probably related to "legacy" hardware. If it was fully deregulated then the operators would immediately shut down all the tracks within 100 miles of London to build houses on them. I believe all European countries are required to have separate track and train operators for railways with some structure for competition in rail. It's just that most of them manage it better than the UK. The UK telecoms industry was privatised and has ended up with BT Openreach operating most of the wires, leased out with local loop unbundling (LLU) to a variety of broadband providers. It works OK although not brilliantly.
- RobertoG 9y ago"I believe all European countries are required to have separate track and train operators for railways with some structure for competition in rail." Not really, in some countries the railway and train operators is the same company, strongly controlled by the government and operating without big problems. It's my understanding that the problems in the UK started when they stopped using that model.
- crdoconnor 9y agoIn Japan the railway companies (which are pseudo private in the way a lot of things are in Japan) run the railways effectively at or below cost and the profits are made on property development and leasing on the surrounding land. In the UK the railway companies try to run profits on railway operation while the taxpayer subsidizes them and the surrounding land is owned by property developers who are making profits that are staggering. The Conservative government is also doing stuff like donating 38 million pounds to govia thameslink in profit compensation for a strike they triggered. It's taxpayers and passengers subsidizing property developers' and TOC profits, and the government/TOCs seems to be trying to get the TOC wage bills down so that TOCs and property developers can make even more.
- grahamm 9y agoAnd it went bankrupt at the cost of fixing some fundamental problems that contributed to at least two nasty rail accidents. The government decided it didn't want to continue to be responsible for the maintenance. Would rather feed subsidies to a company that would take the heat for issues.
- walshemj 9y ago100 times better than the states where local monopolies where allowed to remain and you get insane things like receiver plays for mobile.
- jernfrost 9y agoNo, the most sucessful train company in Europe, the swiss doesn’t. And those who have go e for separate companies have just bad experience with it. This separation is mostly ideologially driven with no proven benefits. Right wing parties will push through anything their economic text books say is smart regardless of pracrical results and experiences.
- pas 9y agoAre there non-subsidized railways that break even, what's their quality? The problem with rails is the same with roads. Yes, AnCaps/Libertarians/Voluntarists/goldbugs think that "yeah, if the State weren't meddling in the market, people would form a corporation to build a [toll] road/rail", but of course, the same network effects would lead to very fine roads between major population centers and abso-fucking-lutely nothing else, because why would anyone connect a mining town in Wyoming anywhere? The mining company will use big all-terrain vehicles on dirt roads and that's it. Maybe they'll lay a track for the coal itself. And I'd even argue, that yes, even if rail operates at a net loss according to GAAP, that doesn't mean socially it is a negative. The same applies to broadband. However, maybe ... maaaybe not everyone should live so far from each other, so infrastructure TCO and commute times and energy use (and GHG emissions) would be lower.
- stuaxo 9y agoHave a look at Thailand for the effects of way-less effective regulation. Street furniture and cables all over the pedestrian areas and cars and bikes everywhere else. Huge concrete overpasses, litter and pollution.
- sitepodmatt 9y agoIn the railway context I believe SRT is government operated including track and trains so they follow a mandate rather then regulation. I took a new train from BKK to Hua Hin a few months ago, quite a pleasant ride to be fair. The cables are a problem, but I suspect it led to faster broadband and FFTH rollout, to give an example I was one of the first True customers and they ran a coaxial cable about 0.25km to the house, it took less than two hours, you couldnt do that if it was underground. Sometimes these things work.
- isostatic 9y ago> The UK has possibly the most overpriced railway in the world The UK railway is still subsidised by the tax payer -- while some routes like Manchester-London make a profit, this profit is reinvested into loss making routes like the Welsh Valleys which help keep communities alive (the operating companies take about 3%, so a £100 ticket without a private company taking money would at cheapest be £97) There is plenty of competition on the Glasgow-London route, including two Coach companies, Plane - multiple companies and routes, driving, two direct train companies (albeit with similar branding) and a third overnight. The $240 peak time one way fare comes out at 58 cents per mile. It's valid on any train, just walk up and go. For almost all trains it's actually $183 return, or 22 cents per mile - valid on any train other than the first arrival into London in the morning and the first couple out of London in the morning. A train from Washington to New York will set you back $1.14 per mile, with less flexibility.
- briandear 9y agoI could fly Glasgow-London for far cheaper than the train ticket. Yet an airplane is far more expensive to operate. I wonder why that is.
- pjc50 9y agoNo, the railway "permanent way" is far more expensive to operate. That's the problem. The UK railway network has rather a lot of 100+ year old bridges in it, along with some less ancient but still pretty old signalling equipment. (extremely high detail PDF on costs: http://orr.gov.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/4933/toc-benchmarking-report-2012.pdf http://orr.gov.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/4933/toc-bench...)
- frereubu 9y agoThat (plane operating costs > rail operating costs) may not be the case when you take into account the cost of maintaining the physical infrastructure (hundreds of miles of railroad) compared to that of airports (a few hundred metres of tarmac).
- 9y ago
- cjrp 9y agoPart of the problem is that you can't have "real" competition, e.g. two train companies can't operate competing franchises on the same line, at the same time. I get terrible service and pay high fares on my Southern Railways route, but I can't opt to use a different carrier without moving house. But if my broadband provider decides to raise their prices by 5% next year, I can move to a different provider with a single phone call and a few minutes of downtime.
- Larrikin 9y agoMost people in the country can not realistically switch internet providers. Even when you have a choice you're often limited to two.
- lhopki01 9y agoWhich country? If you have a phone line to your house you can pick between more than 2. Under what circumstances do most people only have a choice of two.
- Larrikin 9y agoSwitching to DSL is not a realistic option when most of the country has broadband.
- lhopki01 9y agoAgain which country are you talking about? The majority of UK broadband is ADSL2+. There is cable in some areas but not all. In all areas with phone lines there are multiple providers giving around 20Mb/s. They all use the same phone lines because of local loop unbundling. In areas with fibre to the cabinet there are again multiple providers all using the same fibre. The only service in the UK that doesn't have local loop unbundling is cable.
- arethuza 9y ago"In all areas with phone lines there are multiple providers giving around 20Mb/s." I don't know about the rest of the UK but I don't think that is the case in Scotland - once you are any distance from a city or town the speeds can drop dramatically and that's not even in the Highlands or Islands. Certainly when we were looking at houses about a year ago there were quite upmarket new houses in Perthshire that had no broadband at all.
- belorn 9y agoGovernment maintained track system that lease track access to private companies is problematic system because of several points where that relationship breaks. 1: Rail maintenance dictate quality, but is shared between all competitors. 2: Rail is located on ground owned by the government. There is no practical or legal option to operate a private rail network. 3: Lack of distinguishable features to compete, high barrier to entry, and a limited number of companies create an environment thats prime for oligopolies. High price, low service. In contrast to Internet service providers which: 1: Quality of service is generally not dictated by the back bone network. 2: Government tend to grant permission and funding to the first ISP that want to dig into government land to plant cables, but then deny completion afterwards and allow natural monopolies of those that were first. 3: Low barrier to entry could allow for many ISP.
- welterde 9y ago> 1: Quality of service is generally not dictated by the back bone network. If by that you mean that it is not the only thing that matters, then yes. But if the backbone is bottlenecked then of course quality will suffer. > 2: Government tend to grant permission and funding to the first ISP that want to dig into government land to plant cables, but then deny completion afterwards and allow natural monopolies of those that were first. Is that actually the case? Getting a dedicated line between any two buildings tends to be no problem, so why would doing the same on a larger scale be a problem all of a sudden? > 3: Low barrier to entry could allow for many ISP. That's only really possible if the last mile can be leased from either the municipal or some other company (sort of like the government maintained track system). Otherwise the barrier is exactly this last mile, which is the most expensive part of the whole thing (which is also why a lot of small rural ISPs use wireless as last mile access instead of wired connections).
- CaptainZapp 9y agoVirgin Trains at least are nice and if you book well in advance very reasonable deals are to be had. We paid ~42 quid from London to Manchester in first class, one way. Alas we bought the tickets month' in advance and, of course, non-refundable. For shits and giggles I tried to figure out what the same ride costs like when you buy the ticket 30 minutes in advance. And there we come to 280£ each, which is completely ridiculous. It's not that good (2nd ist still ~90quid) Now, don't get me started on Northern. Filthy, Expensive, Clueless and slathered with a heavy dose of disorganisation. I think you can honestly say that privatizing trains in the UK was an experiment going horribly wrong.
- scarface74 9y agoWould your solution be better for most people on average? Probably. Would anyone have unlimited gigabit internet access for $70 a month (like I do)? Probably not. So yeah, I realize the hypocrisy of being willing to pay taxes to help the less fortunate but not being willing to give up my precious gigabit service to help the less connected.
- acover 9y agoMore socialist leaning countries privatize infrastructure. For example Ontario power generation. Is there conclusive evidence that privatization is worse? It seems like an age old question. That there are positives and negatives. It's also politically expedient as it raises money.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 9y agoBig difference between privatising the parts of the system that are a natural monopoly and those that aren't. Privatising the power cables going to people's homes is a dumb move - you won't get the benefits of the free market, as there's no competition between suppliers. But once the cables are in the ground, competition between multiple power suppliers might be possible - so long as customers can compare prices and switch suppliers easily; and the power plants aren't incentivised to cut long-term investments and imperil the country's energy security.
- pjc50 9y agoThis guy gets it. Privatisation on its own does not magically improve services and cut costs. Competition can do so. But privatisation without competition is just a monopoly license to print money.
- crdoconnor 9y agoThere's rarely any political push to privatize things that aren't natural monopolies though, precisely because nobody is going to make bank on that. In practice almost every privatization is simply an exchange where the new owner pays the government $x to help solve its "debt problem" (because the government may one day be rendered insolvent by running out of the cash it it prints). Then, the public gets soaked for $nx where n is usually at least > 2 and the government officials behind the privatization get some really lucrative jobs and speaking engagements after they leave office.
- afpx 9y ago
- andy_ppp 9y agoRich people can't create monopolies and rent seek as easily if government does the basic infrastructure well. Peter Thiel gives the example of not wanting to open a restaurant in San Francisco because there is too much competition for it to be successful and you constantly have to work at it for little reward. Of course the reality is that a successful San Francisco restaurant makes millions of dollars per year. Too little for Peter Thiel to be interested in but for most of us that would be considered extremely successful. The same can be true of websites and the Internet, ala Indie hackers.
- charlesdm 9y agoI think his line of thinking is more like, why spend so much time trying to get X to work, when I can just do Y and make the same amount of money? Unless you really really want to run a successful restaurant, he's not wrong. If it takes 1/10th the effort to run a cleaning business and make $1m a year, vs a tech business, would you do it? Some people would, others won't. Operating in a space with (not just normal but) extreme cut throat competition can get tiring after a while as well.
- rhino369 9y agoAnd even if you really want to run a successful restaurant, capital doesn't give a fuck. Banks won't lend you more money because you have a passion. Investors won't either.
- pixl97 9y ago>Of course the reality is that a successful San Francisco restaurant makes millions of dollars per year. Selection bias anyone? Of course a 'successful' $X makes money, it wouldn't be successful otherwise. That tells us nothing on how many restaurants had to fail in relation to the ones that did well. From a hypothetical investor's point of view if 1 out of 10 restaurants does well enough to earn a payback and you would have to put $1 million in each one to get it started, then the one that succeeds has to profit at least $10 million for the investor alone. Yea, seems like a pretty high risk environment.
- mcv 9y ago> Do people really believe that infrastructure is not the purview of the government? Well, the people behind these Koch-funded groups do. They believe that nothing is the purview of government, or at least nothing that can be monopolised and exploited for profit. I think the purview of government is primarily to protect the people against this kind of monopolisation and exploitation. Privatised infrastructure is fine with me as long as it doesn't hurt people's access to it. But in this case, the government is clearly responding to a lack of access.
- tremon 9y agoDo they really believe that, or do they simply need us to believe that so they can keep pillaging the country?
- vorotato 9y agoUpton Sinclair's "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it." still holds true here.
- losteric 9y agoI think they would agree that infrastructure falls to the government... the disagreement arises in what "government" means. Their views seem more aligned with feudalism/monarchism, subjugating the public by convincing citizens to surrender key infrastructure to privatized rule.
- jedberg 9y agoThere was a great Freakonomics podcast[0] where they interviewed a Koch brother. It seems like they truly believe that is what would be best for the country. They are Libertarians and believe in it's tenets to their core. [0] http://freakonomics.com/podcast/why-hate-koch-brothers-part-1/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/why-hate-koch-brothers-part-...
- hodgesrm 9y agoThat's pretty much my take on the Kochs as well. They seem to contribute to things they believe in, which incidentally includes public radio stations and hospitals [0]. You may not like their politics--and many do not--but so far everything I have read or heard about them supports the notion they are sincere in their beliefs. The problem is not so much the Kochs as the fact that we've permitted a political system to arise in the US that allows a disproportionate amount of wealth to flow to a relatively small number of people and to allow those lucky few an outsized influence on the evolution of said system. Those two things are not unconnected. [0] https://www.usnews.com/news/the-report/articles/2015/06/26/the-koch-brothers-gifts-to-society https://www.usnews.com/news/the-report/articles/2015/06/26/t...
- cdoxsey 9y ago> Is there a good argument against this? Yes. The infrastructure in and around NYC. All the bridges need to be replaced (you can literally see the water below through them), the subway system is in tatters, Penn station is a mess of train derailments and constant delays, and the whole thing is unbelievably expensive. It's a textbook case of short-sightedness, mismanagement, and rent seeking from private parties. A govt internet would work ok for a few years until it was driven into the ground by lack of innovation and special interests. With this model we'd all still be connecting to the internet via 56k modems. And because it's a government enforced monopoly, we'd have no choice.
- fred_is_fred 9y agoMunicipal broadband exists because the lack of competition in the private sector has lead to "lack of innovation" and "special interests". The muni broadband projects fill in these gaps since multi-hundred billion dollar companies can't seem to roll out service at greater than 10MBps. Muni broadband is competition to a monopoly, not a monopoly itself.
- jancsika 9y agoI downvoted you because you relied on an analogy to train and subway infrastructure instead of looking at existing municipal broadband plans that have existed for more than "a few years." For example, the municipal broadband in Wilson, NC, was grandfathered in because it existed before the NC state legislature wrote a law to prevent municipal broadband. It's existed for around 10 years. Rather than being stagnant, that plan delivers some of the fastest internet in the country with reportedly easy setup and decent pricing. If you had made your argument citing municipal broadband plans in the U.S. which give worse-than-average speeds and pricing, I wouldn't have downvoted you.
- mattmcknight 9y agoHere's a more complete, if a bit dated, analysis. https://www.law.upenn.edu/live/files/6611-report-municipal-fiber-in-the-united-states-an https://www.law.upenn.edu/live/files/6611-report-municipal-f... I would say that Greenlight in Wilson is still fast because of the relatively recent infrastructure build out. The question of whether they are stagnant are not won't be answered until the next build out is required. The project was financed by bonds with the infrastructure as collateral. Since Wilson's bond has a balloon payment due in 2033, any new infrastructure would probably require rolling over that debt in addition to the new infrastructure costs. Given the low positive cash flow, it remains to be seen whether they will be able to keep up with future infrastructure demands, whether driven by streaming VR or other services. They are also deriving significant revenue from cable television and landline phone services, both of which are potentially negative growth service areas over the next 15 years. The peculiar advantage of municipal broadband is that municipalities are usually not rural, they can take advantage of the higher density installation locations which most providers want. Many of the monopoly contracts issued by various localities to providers came with the caveat that everyone in the county needed to get access to the service. To be fair, the higher costs for more rural installations should translate into higher prices for rural customers, but that would reduce demand. So, it is certainly worth trying more of these muni-broadband projects, as this obviously is not yet a solved problem. My only plea would be that we don't give anyone a monopoly on putting wires in the ground, whether a private company or a government entity, whoever wants to safely lay cable should be given a permit.
- dominotw 9y agoI lived in chicago, they did some maintenance work on the street in front of my house but improperly installed the manhole cover. Now evertime a car passed over the manhole cover it made a loud thud. This is moderately busy street and there would be lound noise all day long, I was jolted out of sleep several times because of this. I called 311 who said they will look it into it. I called them again couple of weeks after that, some person rudely asked me to call local alderman instead. I called alderman who said they noted down the complaint, called them many times in the following months. After a while a they said its comed( electric company) fault and I should call them. I called comed, they asked me to call local city office. I took time off from work and went upto local city office and they said I should call 311 for complaints of this nature. Sorry, I don't want govt anything. If something goes wrong you are at mercy of some govt employees who have no motivation or sympathy towards your problems. People who know govt officials like alderman ect get things done but everyone else is out of luck, just roll the dice and hope it fixed. Edit: why the downvotes? I think this is a on topic response to parents comment about how well govt maintains roads. You should come to chicago and look at the roads in working class neighborhoods. People are ok with poorer people getting horrible internet cos they can't raise enough taxes to fix their internet infrastructure. Its horrible, if you take CTA in chicago underground in winter, you'll see drops of water ( is it water?) drip on your head from leaky ceilings.
- gech 9y agoPeople run into the same wall dealing with support for any company.
- dominotw 9y agoI get good customer service from comcast, amazon, costco ect. Are you seriously saying thats typical of any company and that you have to personally know some exec in that company to get things done?
- pjc50 9y ago> I get good customer service from comcast There's an entire subreddit out there who would like to hear from you on this subject...
- JonFish85 9y ago"Do people really believe that infrastructure is not the purview of the government?" I don't think anyone is arguing that the government shouldn't be responsible for certain infrastructure, it's the degree to which the government should be involved, and what its role should be. If I put on my more conservative hat for a minute to make an argument, I think the idea is that the government should be somewhat of a last resort for things, and that less is more when it comes to government involvement. Part of the reason for that is that once the government is involved, it changes the incentive structure quite a bit. Using other infrastructure projects (e.g. roads, bridges, etc) for examples that others have pointed out, they're a great way to raise taxes earmarked for those projects, but then that's when politicians start to play games and move money around to their own projects, and now the roads are falling apart, so we need to raise taxes to pay for the roads! It's also somewhat tricky because once something is a government project, it's basically that forever. It's fairly rare for something to go back to the private sector once it has become a government program. What is more likely is that the solution is more government involvement, and that's something that conservatives tend to view as a bad thing. Obviously I'm not speaking for all conservatives, and this isn't even necessarily my own viewpoint, but I wanted to push back against the idea that "conservatives just want what's worst".
- pjc50 9y ago> once something is a government project, it's basically that forever Hardly. In my lifetime the UK government has privatised electricity, water, gas, telephones, British Aerospace, British Steel, British Petroleum, Rolls Royce, Rover, British Airways, railways, coal mining, and Royal Mail. Experiments have been made with roads, bridges, schools and hospitals. Success of these has varied. The utilities make a big profit while people struggle to pay utility bills: https://www.ft.com/content/ef488dc0-9168-11e7-a9e6-11d2f0ebb7f0 https://www.ft.com/content/ef488dc0-9168-11e7-a9e6-11d2f0ebb... BAe and BA are still in business. British Steel were owned by Tata for years and the few remaining sites are now spun off and trading under the original name. BP are making a profit except when they spill in the Gulf of Mexico. The railways are a mess. Rover were looted by their directors who narrowly escaped jail.
- 9y ago
- at-fates-hands 9y ago> Is there a good argument against this? I think one of the main issues is having a company that has spent millions, sometimes billions of dollars building out their infrastructure. Then you have the government come in, build out a competing infrastructure with tax payers money. As a business, you're now having to compete with an entity that has unlimited budget resources, can build out wherever they want, grant contracts and favorable leasing options to whichever businesses they want to and quite easily put you out of business. When you have to compete with a government entity as a business, you will always be at a disadvantage. In essence, governments don't foster competition, they basically do away with it, pick the winners they want to and then monopolize it and push other companies out.
- haltingthoughts 9y ago>Who doesn't think the US Highway System has been great for our economy? When one considers the hidden costs of increased urban sprawl, reliance on automobiles, and the associated increase in pollution, it isn't so clear. If roads were privatized then the true costs would be more clear.
- ouid 9y agoAre you arguing that privatization of an industry is likely to result in better management of its externalities?
- rayiner 9y ago> Do people really believe that infrastructure is not the purview of the government? Sure. Lots of people do. Japan’s railroads, subways, and many highways, are private. Water utilities in France are mostly private, as are most of its highways. Almost all electrical systems in the US and Europe were privatized in the 1980s and 1990s. Would public internet infrastructure have been better in the US? Our internet speeds in the US are faster than our big EU competitors: UK, Germany, France, Spain, and Italy. That’s pretty much the only piece of infrastructure you can say that for. Our subways aren’t better. Our roads aren’t better. Our regional trains aren’t better. But our internet service is better. It’s not a philosophical question, but an economic one. How do you ensure adequate spending on very expensive infrastructure. Japan does it for rail by making rail companies private and allowing them to use land grants to enter retail leasing markets. (Japanese railways own lots of the land around stations and are the landlord for the associated retail establishments.) Many European countries have the political discipline to ensure adequate funding for public infrastructure. Both models can work. But we already know that in the US we don’t have the political discipline to properly fund infrastructure. Infrastructure gets attacked from the right, who don’t want to pay taxes. But it also from the left, who want to use infrastructure as leverage for social issues. For example, in Stockholm, the publicly owned (but completely privately funded) dark fiber utility took 16-17 years to cover 90% of the city. There was no mandate to build in historically disadvantaged neighborhoods or anything like that—build out was based on demand. That approach is completely illegal in most US cities.
- hodgesrm 9y agoDo you have a source on the US vs. the rest Internet speeds? That's not my impression from end user experience in those countries.
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoOur max may be higher but I too would like to see that our average is higher because I rarely get the speeds I pay for.
- rayiner 9y agoSee: https://www.akamai.com/fr/fr/multimedia/documents/state-of-the-internet/q1-2017-state-of-the-internet-connectivity-report.pdf https://www.akamai.com/fr/fr/multimedia/documents/state-of-t.... To use a concrete example, 500/200 fiber through Orange in France is about $63/month after the one-year promo period: https://boutique.orange.fr/internet/offres-fibre/jet https://boutique.orange.fr/internet/offres-fibre/jet. The closest FiOS plan is ~$80/month after the promo period for symmetric gigabit. So we're somewhat more expensive, for somewhat faster speeds. Affordability-wise, it's about the same, considering the much higher household income in the U.S. But if you visited say Baltimore and Paris, you wouldn't realize that. "France has fiber and Maryland doesn't," you'd conclude. Population distribution in the two places is very different: most people in the U.S., especially the folks who can afford higher tiers of internet service, live outside the core cities. While Baltimore has crappy internet choices, most of Maryland lives outside Baltimore, and has fiber. Indeed, Maryland is in the top-5, just behind Sweden and way ahead of France in Akamai's tests.