13 ms·
As crime dries up, Japan’s police hunt for things to do
- roryisok 9y agoProbably just me, but economist articles never load properly (windows phone, so there's that). Page keeps popping me back up to the top of the article, happened 4 times and then the text disappeared. Oh well. At least I can infer from the headline that crime is very low in Japan. I wonder what they're doing that the rest of the world aren't
- vim_wannabe 9y agoWhen everyone agrees to a single set of cultural norms you don't need law enforcement to keep them.
- roryisok 9y agoI think there's more to it than that.
- pimmen 9y agoThat doesn’t explain why crime is going down across the US and the EU too. Correlation does not equal causation.
- vim_wannabe 9y agoI was talking more about the philosophical side of things, what with laws often being cultural norms in writing. So when you have multiple different norms things can get ugly and misunderstandings happen. In some countries they are looking into introducing multiple different laws to alleviate this. Obviously a big part of crime comes out of desperation (hunger) which might be going down as you say.
- goldfeld 9y agoAll american-protected. Maybe people are just getting scared shitless with overbearing eyes? Hint: it's not just chilling for crime.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cperciva 9y agoCrime rates are dropping almost everywhere; the exceptions are short term increases during episodes of societal disruption (e.g. wars). One of the reasons Japan's rate is so low is that they're ahead of other countries in the race to grow old; the vast majority of crime, and especially violent crime, is committed by young people.
- pimmen 9y agoYouth activity is probably a factor. Some anecdata is that, in Sweden, January is usually the month when violent crime is at a very low point in the year. Young people don’t have any money to go out after spending it on Christmas and New Year’s, and it’s super cold so running around in town sucks.
- interfixus 9y agoYou do realize who's behind the vast majority of violent crime in Swdeden, right? Hint: Many of them are not particularly known for celebrating Christmas.
- pimmen 9y agoSweden doesn't record religion in the census. I'm very interested in seeing your source for your statements. And "the vast majority of violent crimes" does not mean that one group is more disproportionally represented. Don't throw around words you don't understand, such as "majority".
- ambentzen 9y agoIf you are going to be a racist dick, at least be overt about it...
- interfixus 9y agoOh, but I probably am a racist dick. In this case, however, I don't need to be. A simple look at statistics will do fine. Another hint: It is not native young Swedes who have suddenly gone on a rampage and turned shootings, killings, and the occasional grenade into mundane, everyday background-noise in places like Malmø. Now your turn to be an overt anatomical metafor.
- forgotmypw 9y agoAs crime dries up, Japan’s police hunt for things to do There was just one fatal shooting in the whole of 2015 May 18th 2017 | TOKYO THE stake-out lasted a week, but it paid off in the end. The tireless police of Kagoshima, a sleepy city in the far south of the country, watched the unlocked car day and night. It was parked outside a supermarket, and contained a case of malt beer. Finally, a passing middle-aged man decided to help himself. Five policemen instantly pounced, nabbing one of the city’s few remaining law-breakers. Japan’s cluttered streets are not always pretty but they are remarkably safe. Crime rates have been falling for 13 years. The murder rate of 0.3 per 100,000 people is among the lowest in the world; in America it is almost 4 (see chart). A single gun slaying was recorded for the whole of 2015. Even yakuza gangsters, once a potent criminal force, have been weakened by tougher laws and old age. https://i.imgur.com/QpYCERQ.png https://i.imgur.com/QpYCERQ.png Yet, far from being pensioned off, the police are growing in numbers: beat cops, known colloquially as omawari-san (Mr Walk-around), are a fixture in most neighbourhoods. Japan has over 259,000 uniformed officers—15,000 more than a decade ago, when crime rates were far higher. The ratio of officers to population is very high, especially in Tokyo, home to the world’s biggest metropolitan police force—a quarter bigger than the one protecting New York. This means plenty of attention for crimes that would be considered too petty to investigate elsewhere, such as the theft of a bicycle or the possession of a tiny amount of drugs. One woman describes how five officers crowded into her cramped apartment after she reported her knickers being swiped from a clothesline. A small army of detectives was assigned last year to apprehend a group of 22 people who had been growing marijuana for their personal use only and smoking it in deserted rural spots. In fact, as the police run out of things to do, they are becoming more inventive about what constitutes a crime, says Kanako Takayama of Kyoto University. In one recent case, she says, they arrested a group of people who had shared the cost of renting a car, deeming the arrangement an illegal taxi. Some prefectures have begun prosecuting people who ride their bicycles through red lights. In 2015 a man was arrested for scribbling Adolf Hitler moustaches onto posters of Shinzo Abe, the prime minister. Ms Takayama says detectives have started appearing without permission on university campuses, to monitor “troublesome” students. One reason why police are going after cyclists may be to make up for the steady fall in driving offences. (Both drivers and cyclists can avoid fines by signing up for remedial training at certified driving schools, which are often staffed by retired officers, notes Colin Jones of Doshisha University.) Fifteen years ago police in Hokkaido, in Japan’s sparsely populated north, conspired with yakuza gangsters to smuggle guns into the country so they could meet quotas for finding them. The hunt for things to do may sometimes be beneficial. The number of reported cases of children being abused at home has almost doubled since 2010, despite the declining birth rate. That suggests the police are increasingly intervening in the domestic sphere, which they used to avoid. Even critics of Japan’s justice system accept that it gets a lot right. Rates of recidivism are low and a great deal of effort is made to keep young offenders out of the prison system; police work with parents to keep young people on the straight and narrow. Adults are incarcerated at a far lower rate than in most rich countries: 45 per 100,000, compared with 146 in Britain and 666 in the United States. Yet the police are oddly inefficient. Even though there are so many officers and so few crimes, they solve less than 30% of them. Confessions, often made under duress, form the basis of most criminal prosecutions. The courts dismissed the case of the beer thief in Kagoshima, despite all the work that went into it. Japan is almost crime-free not thanks to the police, says Yoshihiro Yasuda, a campaigning lawyer, but because people police themselves. This article appeared in the Asia section of the print edition under the headline "Petty officers"
- ch4ck 9y agoLoaded properly for me: Edge 40.15063.728.0, mobile version.
- anvandare 9y agoThe most important factors I'd say would be: (1) overall wealthy (compared to the rest of the world) (2) political stability, strong rule of law, low corruption (3) no extreme differences between rich and poor, with the majority being 'middle class' (neither rich, nor poor). (4) social redistribution and welfare system, reinforcing (3) by avoiding poverty traps (health issues, low education, debt spiral). (5) near mono-culture whose norms and values value conformity and avoiding social friction ("the needs of the many ...") (6) relative isolation to the rest of the world, very strict immigration laws, reinforcing (5) I can see the same properties (somewhat differently, of course) and results in Norway or Switzerland. All factors naturally reinforce each other. There's undoubtedly more, but I think those are the most important ones.
- CryptoPunk 9y ago>>social redistribution and welfare system, reinforcing (3) by avoiding poverty traps (health issues, low education, debt spiral). Japan has a Spartan welfare system: http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-knows-it-a-family-affair.html http://www.nytimes.com/1996/09/10/world/welfare-as-japan-kno...
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoI recall a ranking a few years back where Japan was the only country in the industrialized world whose welfare system ranked worse than America's.
- anvandare 9y agoI'm definitely far from knowledgeable on the Japanese welfare system (though that article is from 1996) but at least health care and education seem really cheap (and mandatory). As for the livelihood assistance part of welfare, it seems mostly old people make use of it (since unemployment is so low 2.8% in Japan) - which would link to what glandium said in another post: increase in theft by elders. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2016/06/16/editorials/senior-citizens-welfare/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2016/06/16/editorials/s...
- jchb 9y ago
- crtqt3 9y agoRacial (and therefore cultural) homogeny.
- JKCalhoun 9y agoCommunity policing probably helps. There is a police station every few blocks it seems in Tokyo.
- retox 9y agoSame in the UK, which is why people are being arrested for hurting people's feelings on Twitter.
- gaius 9y agoNo, that's not true. Glos Police for example on their Twitter call for people to report "non-crimes" but their burglary clean-up rate is something like 9%. It's more accurate to say that UK police have given up on "traditional" crime.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI suspect they have given up on crimes where there is little or no evidence and hence not much chance of a conviction.
- vixen99 9y agoIf you don't look for evidence you're unlikely to find it. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/met-police-spending-cuts-400-million-funding-london-crimes-not-investigated-burglary-assault-a8002746.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/met-police-spendi...
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoOfficer warns change could have 'horrendous' impact on victims of offences including burglary and car crime Well I would expect them to say that, turkeys don't vote for Christmas.
- valuearb 9y agoYep, if you make the tiniest possible cuts to our budget we will stop doing our jobs. As if they spent much effort on minor property crimes before.
- walshemj 9y ago
- Houshalter 9y agoThis is 20 years old, but there is something weird about Japanese crime statistics. They might not be as good as much of a low crime society as commonly stated: http://sci-hub.la/10.2307/29766810 http://sci-hub.la/10.2307/29766810 (Is Japan Exceptional? Reconsidering Japanese Crime Rates)
- throwaway613834 9y agoThis is from... 1994? How relevant is it to 2017?
- Retric 9y agoThese are the kind of things that don't change quickly. 100 years ago Chicago was a corrupt city, and today it's _.
- taneq 9y agoThis is purely anecdotal but my sister lived in Japan for many years, and she tells me that the policing there is very... uneven, I guess you'd describe it. The police won't get too involved in anything that's not a sure bet to be solved (eg. unexpected deaths are very likely to be written off as suicide) but on the flip side, once they accuse you of something the conviction rate is near 100%. Also if you get a speeding ticket you have to write an apology letter saying how sorry you are, as well as pay the fine.
- sandworm101 9y agoThat isnt much higher than the US conviction rate if 95+. There are a few US counties that havent heard "not guilty" for over a decade.
- stupidcar 9y agoA well-functioning criminal justice system should always have a high conviction rate, because part of the police and state prosecution service's job is to ensure that they only bring charges and fight cases they think they can win. Given they're experts in criminal prosecution, you would expect them to get it right 90-95% of the time. But there's still a lot of variation in how you get to that situation. E.g. how willing are the police to investigate cases that have a low chance of conviction? How willing are they to coerce confessions or fabricate evidence? Is sentencing and plea-bargaining designed to encourage early guilty pleas regardless of innocence? At trial, how willing are judges to lead juries towards a guilty verdict? These kind of issues are at play in every country's criminal justice system, but, for a modern democracy, Japan seems to have a particularly pervasive culture of police intimidation and coercion.
- jsemrau 9y agoWhen I was still living in Tokyo and went shopping for groceries near my house using my Mamachari, I would get stopped at least twice each way.
- donatj 9y agoI was going say, in the two weeks we were in Japan we were randomly stopped to have our passports checked sooo many times. Particularly in Kyoto. The plain clothes cops made me a little uncomfortable. To be fair though in the middle of my trip the Akihabara massacre happened and visible police presence went way up after that. My friend and I spoke the least of anyone in the group, and were actually in Akihabara at the time with no idea at all what was going on. We were there to return a camera, and we noted the place was CRAWLING with news crews. Didn’t figure it out until we got back to our friends who had been watching the news, terrified something had happened. We were randomly passport checked before that happened however.
- ponyous 9y agoJust came back from 3 weeks trip through Japan (mostly Tokyo and Kyoto). Haven't spoke to police even once.
- gwilkes 9y agoThat's weird, I've heard that Tokyo cops do that but I've never been stopped once in eight years of living in Saitama (the prefecture just north of Tokyo). It's certainly not because I blend in, I'm cacausian and 188cm tall.
- jsemrau 9y agoWell it happened to me when living in Tokyo. In other parts it might not be like that.
- kyleblarson 9y agoI often hear stories like this but in roughly 6 months I've spent in Japan the only interaction I've had with police is when I initiate the interaction to ask directions, and they are always super friendly and helpful. (I'm a middle aged white guy)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wordpressdev 9y agoDo these stats cover the Yakuza?
- iliketosleep 9y agoThat's exactly what I was wondering. As far as I know, many streets in Japan are still ruled by the Yakuza.
- donatj 9y agoThey’re supposedly having a heck of a time recruiting the younger generation. There was a pretty good documentary about it on Netflix
- gozur88 9y ago... who keep a lid on the street crime. Your calculations shift when you believe mugging someone might get you thrown off a tall building even if the police don't catch you.
- adventured 9y agoThe Yakuza isn't counted, most of what they do is corruption, blackmail and unofficial / off the books crime. There are a bunch of gangs actively working to take their place as well, none of it is being officially counted: "The Upstart Gangs Filling the Yakuza Power Vacuum" https://www.nippon.com/en/features/c04205/ https://www.nippon.com/en/features/c04205/
- mongol 9y agoCome to Sweden. Police is in crisis.
- adventured 9y agoOr London, where violent crime is skyrocketing and it's commonly thought the lack of enough police is one reason.
- shak77 9y agoYeah... What could be the reason? This one is tough one to crack...
- jinglebells 9y agoAusterity.
- vortico 9y agoYou post is tongue-in-cheek but it brings up an interesting question: Is an experienced foreign policeman a better candidate than an untrained lifelong citizen who is just starting a career? I would guess no, since laws and "the way of doing things" are so different that it would be better for trainee police to start with a clean slate.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoIt's almost certainly a good idea to have a few such people in a reasonably sized group because they will be able to challenge the 'we do it this way because we have always done it this way' mentality that eventually takes over most long lasting groups of any kind.
- vortico 9y ago"The way we do things" is the legal code, and I believe this is better changed in court, not at a police office.
- ubik 9y agoSounds like a bland, racist dystopia to me. You know what Japan really needs? Mass immigration.
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agohttps://www.thedailybeast.com/does-japan-ever-convict-men-for-rape https://www.thedailybeast.com/does-japan-ever-convict-men-fo... they could work on this. It seems all crime isn't drying up, just the things the government wants to call a crime.
- will4274 9y agoWarning: site has malicious ads which navigate you away on mobile
- smegel 9y agoNot if you browse with javascript disabled by default.
- zpr 9y agoThese days, that might also be a crime.
- linkregister 9y agoFirst they came for the Ad Blockers, but I did not speak out — because I wasn't one. Then they came for the VPN Users, but I did not speak out — because I wasn't one. Then they came for the JavaScript Disablers, — and there was no one left to speak for me. ;)
- Parcissons 9y agoYou can opt out, in the third menue, down a flight of stairs, behind the door with "Living Tiger" sign on it. You will be reopted in, on the next update. Sorry, we cant save your privacy and security settings.
- azinman2 9y agoWhich would be what percentage of internet users? 0.00001%?
- jhiska 9y agoIn other words, the police are trying to create crime so they can justify their investigations.
- stephengillie 9y agoA group is formed to handle a perceived type of problem - a committee or task force. They triage and rank these problems, then deal with them in decreasing order of determined importance. Solving each problem has costs, such as disruption to other people's lives - both involved parties and bystanders, but this disruption is seen as a necessary evil. Below a certain threshold of problem, solving problems becomes too expensive, and the cost is greater than the problem-removal benefit. These groups rarely dissolve when they are past this point, due in most cases to the ego of an individual human or small group. This is a generalization of many concepts, but I've never been sure what to call it.
- conanbatt 9y agoGovernment.
- hateduser2 9y agoWhy ego? This is just as easily explained by habit/routine/dependence on the group by its members
- tankenmate 9y ago“It’s hard to make a man understand something when his livelihood depends on him not understanding it” -- Upton Sinclair It's rare for a open ended committee or organisation without founding scope to vote for its own dissolution.
- QAPereo 9y ago“Turkeys don’t vote for Christmas.” Just to bookend your excellent quote.
- hateduser2 9y agoI think actually that’s what I meant by dependence on the group for money or wellbeing (livelihood?). Separating those things from ego (pride)
- ThrustVectoring 9y ago
- NedIsakoff 9y agoHow about working on the groping issue?
- superquest 9y agoReminds me how Roman soldiers built roads throughout the empire during the Pax Romana, when they had no wars to fight.
- javajosh 9y agoIndeed! However, asking modern police to do infrastructure work of that sort might be too much. However, what police officer would turn down an opportunity to get trained as a programmer, and then put to work in forensics, workflow, or national cyber defense?
- sliverstorm 9y agoFirefighters in America are doing the same thing, as buildings become more fireproof & smoking declines.
- Noos 9y agoIf I were to speculate, I think, no, there's still plenty of crime, but like a lot of Japanese culture, it's dealt with informally by the group. To actually go to the police is an admission your local culture or group can't harmonize what happened, so you need to have harmony forced on you. That doesn't mean actual innocent or guilt; just that harmony is maintained. If it ever has to escalate to the police in that kind of culture, it's something really serious that the normal means of informal dealing and restitution won't work at all. And the mindset when that happens is dangerous, because the objective can be more "quickly restore harmony by any means necessary" than "find the guilty." Like the old chinese kung-fu movies where they would grab someone, torture him, then make him sign a confession. It's more important to resolve the situation to restore balance than disrupt that to right wrongs. Again, this is real speculation, but Japanese are people too; they don't somehow possess a special human nature that removes all the nasty emotional impetus behind crime.
- larkeith 9y agoI wouldn't be surprised if this is partially the case, but the homicide rate suggests to me that there is also a significantly lower amount of (serious) crime - it seems difficult and unlikely that murder would or could be handled without involving authorities.
- Nexxxeh 9y agoDuring the recent gun crime argument in the wake of the Vegas shooting in the US, someone pointed to Japan as an example of strict gun laws. Japan has more than double the suicide rate than the UK, and noticeably higher than the US. I wonder if some murders in Japan are written up as suicides in order to close the case quickly? Plus I would would guess Japanese people are more likely to kill themselves than go on a murder spree of family members or coworkers, but that's just based on what I've seen as an outsider.
- jopsen 9y agoJapan is notorious for extreme work ethics.. so a high suicide rate is not surprising. I'm don't think it's fair to make wild speculation like that without sources. It not like they haven't investigated the high (but also falling) suicide rate: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_in_Japan https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_in_Japan
- fishmeat 9y agoBeware the crappy link laced with popup ads and trackers.
- Giorgi 9y agoDon't they have full-scale mafia operations? Ya, fight that