9 ms·
Silicon Valley homes now out of reach even for big spenders
- ilaksh 9y agoThere should be another option besides McMansion, townhouse, condo or condo hi-rise. That is small two-story homes. I say split the lots up into two or three pieces.
- harryh 9y agoIn many cases this idea is illegal under local zoning laws which is....unfortunate.
- joering2 9y agosame goes with going underground. Nothing stops us from having -100 stores underground in NYC or LA or SF. We know how to lay water pipes, AC, deliver air, supplies, create emergency plans, etc... the only problem --- zoning laws :( edit: was referring to places where you cannot build up anymore, such as sky scrapers in NYC
- ufo 9y agoBuilding underground is much more expensive than building up.
- harryh 9y agoI lived in NYC until very recently and was kinda sorta apartment shopping. One place I looked at had the common areas on the ground floor, the bedrooms on floor -1 (with small windows that looked up to grates through holes in the ground) and then a windowless basement on floor -2. It was kind of neat actually and pretty cheap (relative to similarly sized places in the neighborhood) due to being on the ground floor and below.
- cgb223 9y agoIsn't there some kind of law against a living space without access to windows? I'm all for the idea, but I don't get claustrophobic very easy
- icebraining 9y agoYes, in the NYC administrative code: Lighting Requirements: All bedrooms must have at least one window that opens to a street, yard, or court on the same lot. The window may also open to a balcony that opens on a street, yard, or court. The total area of the windows in the room must at least be one-tenth the floor area of the room. All required windows must be at least twelve square feet in area.
- icebraining 9y agoSo, making underground excavations in one of the most built up pieces of land on Earth. Doing that safely would cost a pretty good penny, so you'd have to sell them as "luxury" condos, but who in their right mind would spend that kind of money on a windowless hole, rather than living a bit further on a regular condo? I'd bet zoning is not the only thing keeping that from happening.
- cc439 9y agoThe water table is a pretty obvious barrier to that in all 3 cities you mentioned.
- smsm42 9y ago> -100 stores underground in NYC or LA or SF I don't know about NYC but California is an earthquake-prone area. Making underground housing that can withstand a serious quake would be quite a challenge. And imagine trying to rescue people from -100th floor after one...
- junkscience2017 9y ago"In-law" units are now being fast-tracked in many communities, which is a variant of this.
- rat_1234 9y agoThe share of the wealth creation in Silicon Valley that has been captured by property owners is outrageous.
- anubisresources 9y agoHow much of the gains from the computing revolution have been captured by a few thousand Bay Area Landlord’s?
- harryh 9y agoI think the vast majority of the gains from the computing revolution have been captured in consumer surplus. Billions of people get to use all kinds of online software for free. Certainly hard to estimate but this is likely worth trillions alone?
- SapphireSun 9y agoYou can probably measure some of that in terms of how people would have done these tasks previously. Some of those tasks are trivial, like keeping a paper calendar instead of a digital one. You can also interpret it in terms of jobs eliminated.
- iansimon 9y agoYou still have to pay to access the Internet. Comcast/AT&T aren't free.
- goialoq 9y agoIt's still cheap as free compared to the cost of accessing the same information/media pre-Internet. Google used to brag about how using Google was more energy-efficient than going to the local library.
- junkscience2017 9y agoDisagree. Maybe one day all of these homes will be owned by a giant corporation, but for now, they are typically owned by individuals. Not everyone who has benefited is a robber baron.
- junkscience2017 9y agomany homeowners are electing to retain ownership of their home but rent it out. this has reduced the inventory available for purchase. many homes on my street in Los Gatos have become rentals. when my new neighbors (renters) tell me their monthly rent, my jaw drops.
- wavefunction 9y agoI would expect this trend to accelerate as the new GOP tax plan greatly reduces the taxes paid on income earned by landlords letting out a property.
- koverda 9y agoCitation?
- wavefunction 9y agoThe bill, go read it.
- njarboe 9y agoProp 13 highly encourages this behavior. If one is leaving the Bay Area and ever wishes to return, keeping ownership of a property with a low assessed value could save one or two thousand dollars a month in property tax when you return.
- gnicholas 9y agoWe have a neighbor who rented out her house to 5-6 groups of people (some individuals, some couples). Based on the type of cars her tenants drive — newer German sports cars — I'm guessing she pulls in around 10k per month in total. She cashes the checks from South America, where she now lives.
- fossuser 9y agoIf you follow homes on Zillow you'll see small two bedroom houses get bought for 1.2-1.5 million and then immediately show up as rentable for $5500/month. If you actually live here and want to buy it's very difficult and extremely risky. I don't mind living with roommates, but if you're someone who wants to have a family it's probably not worth it. I share a 3 bedroom with three other roommates (four total since there's one couple) and the total rent is $6150 (which is a pretty good deal). I wish there was some hefty tax on people buying houses just to rent them that don't actually live here.
- chiph 9y agoBack during the .com era, I got bored one day and looked up the cheapest house for sale in Cupertino. $300k got you what would have been a crack house in the RTP area - run down, no lot, chain-link fence to keep people out. I just repeated this experiment - $500k for a 1-acre lot with a shack on it, or $925k for a 2 bedroom condo. Those prices are insane. Yet every time I think they're unsupportable - they go higher.
- nojvek 9y agoAlso don't discount the fact the USD went through some serious deflation. In the name of jump starting the economy, our govt literally made money out of thin air and made it rain.
- simonbyrne 9y agoWouldn't that be inflationary?
- bad_hairpiece 9y agoPrinting more money is inflation
- dmoy 9y agoWait when did the USD go through deflation?
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoWell, don't forget that the reason the economy needed jump starting is that $4 trillion evaporated in the crisis of 2008.
- jonknee 9y agoYou mean inflation (well really, quantitative easing, we actually have been below target inflation for years), but that would mean housing everywhere has spiked in price. That's not the case, housing in a few markets has far outpaced anything else.
- 9y ago
- kcorbitt 9y agoIn a sane world, the Bay Area would have the highest new-construction numbers of any metro area in the USA, and probably the developed world. Unfortunately, the market is so distorted that I'm only aware of one potential large-scale buildout in the area (the Brisbane Baylands development -- and even that has a 50/50 shot of being successfully blocked). Such pointlessly wasted potential. :(
- gehwartzen 9y agoOr some of the tech companies could be distributed over a larger number of cities. It seems ironic to me that tech companies, of all industries, are placing such a huge premium on physical proximity.
- nielsbot 9y agoSometimes "good, old fashioned" collaboration is best.
- robbyking 9y agoI'm a longtime Bay Area software engineer, and the problem is it's scary to move to a town that only has a couple tech companies. I'd love to live someplace smaller, but if I find -- and lose -- a job in a small town, I'm out of other options. Here I have recruiters knocking down my door.
- xienze 9y agoSo move to a town that has a lot more than a couple tech companies like Austin or Raleigh. It’s not all SV and wastelands in this country.
- pwinnski 9y agoI don't live in SV, but I've worked remotely for SV companies, and have spent some time there. I think you're underestimating the gap. I wouldn't call every other city a wasteland, but it can sometimes feel like it's hard not to have a tech job in the Bay Area. It's also possible that people in SV are over-estimating the gap, but I think the reality is closer to the extreme they imagine.
- sputknick 9y agoI know there is a class of people in SV unaffected by this directly, but eventually it MUST start to affect them in that they will be unable to get employees to come to the area? I guess this is probably a self correcting problem with more people/companies going to Seattle, RTP, Austin, Boston and elsewhere.
- refurb 9y agoThat's been happening for a while. I was involved with recruiting for my employer and HR mentioned the COL in the Bay Area is a major barrier to hiring. People love the company, love the area, but just can't afford to move here. In fact, my employer just open a site in Portland, OR to address a major hiring need. The fact that the lower COL was a major deciding factor was clearly stated.
- sidlls 9y agoMy view on that is: good. Stay away. Go elsewhere. Whatever. That's less competition with the same demand for my skills here. I haven't found a single job in Seattle, Austin, Boston, or elsewhere willing to offer the salary I earn, benefits, and equity that isn't also with a company that has a presence in the Bay Area.
- sytelus 9y agoThe best way to cut success probability of your startup in to half is by basing it in SV. Startups don’t have truckload money to pay for COL in SV. They can’t attract talent other than big shots who are already multi-millionaires (and likely won’t code). People from other place would not move to join them because base salary won’t even pay for their rent (and stock options stays paper money for long time). It’s utterly foolish to base your startup in SV. Come here for hiring but keep your base out of SV, probably in Austin, Seattle, Florida or may be Southern CA.
- cgb223 9y agoWhat are the factors preventing real estate developers from buying up land and building larger complexes to meet the demand? Seems like an opportunity to make a lot of money
- deadmetheny 9y agoZoning laws that make it illegal to build tall buildings and insane NIMBYism from property owners who benefited from Prop 13.
- santaclaus 9y ago> What are the factors preventing real estate developers from buying up land and building larger complexes to meet the demand? Local property who oppose new development in order to restrict supply, primarily.
- johan_larson 9y agoHere's a good summary: https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ Basically, there are a lot of regulations governing what you can build and where. And those regulations have a constituency that benefits from them, namely everyone who already owns a home in the Bay area. If you bought a nice single-family home twenty years ago, you're sitting pretty. You live in a nice area that probably isn't going to change very much (thanks to the regulations), and the steeply rising value of your real estate (thanks to the regulations) is going to fund your retirement very nicely.
- azernik 9y agoNot sure how much of this primer on Bay Area politics you need, but here we go: Mostly local governmental opposition. Local towns want businesses (tax revenue!) but not residential development (costly services!). Local homeowners who vote for said town governments also have an interest in higher home prices. What makes this possible for them is the lengthy public hearing process involved, allowing local activists to delay construction for years for BS reasons; and the discretion given to elected officials not just to make policy, but also to override it. In recent years, Bay Area activists (under the slogan of YIMBY - "Yes In My Backyard") have been successful in both pushing housing development through direct local advocacy (especially effective in places with lots of voting renters, like SF proper), and in getting the state to exert its power more over local government. The background to this being that the state has since 1982 had a law trying to combat this phenomenon - the Housing Accountability Act. It requires cities to publish city development plans for public inspection, requires those zoning policies to meet certain requirements in terms of housing quantity, and then to actually make zoning decisions that comply with those policies. However, private individuals or organizations need to bring suits against cities to make it effective, because the US is crazy and prefers lawsuits to actually hiring professional regulators. So activists have funded lawsuits (see the more recent entries at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Housing_Accountability_Act#Litigation_involving_the_HAA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Housing_Accountabil...) against cities that have obstructed development. They also got the CA state legislature to strengthen the HAA this year, putting more of the burden of proof on the cities to show their justification for development denials, making cities pay attorney's fees when they lose a case, and allowing judges to fine cities for violations.
- gnicholas 9y agoI wonder how the self-driving car trend will change things in the Bay Area. Right now, there's a tradeoff between paying $2M+ for a house and having a 2 hr+ commute. When your car can drive you to work, the commute becomes much less annoying. If people can save $1.3M on a house in exchange for a long, but self-driven, commute, the allure of living right in SV will be significantly lower.
- smsm42 9y agoCommute is a pretty big thing. If SV had proper public transportation (which is virtually non-existent) it's be much easier to live a bit further. But I don't think it's feasible - maybe with self-driving cars it would be? But then, for 90% of tech jobs, you don't do anything that needs you to be physically present in the office anyway. We should just learn to work remotely better.
- goialoq 9y agoReally, you'd enjoy sitting in your car for 2+ hours every weekday? That's incredibly unhealthy.
- gnicholas 9y agoHow is this any different from a 2 hr train commute, which many people endure? Not saying it's great, but if it saves over $1M in purchase price (plus another $10k/yr in property tax), I think some people would take the bargain.
- smsm42 9y agoIf I wouldn't have to drive, I'd probably be fine with it, maybe not 2+ hours, but an hour or so definitely wouldn't be a huge deal. You could read, sleep, work, listen to podcasts/music, watch movies, relax, etc.
- legulere 9y ago“The biggest single factor that determines pricing or value of a home is supply and demand,” It's a bit different from the traditional supply and demand: There are two kinds of demand: One is the demand for actually using housing, which is not affected by supply and price. The other is the demand as a financial instrument, which even increases with rising prices.
- PopsiclePete 9y agoFuck the Bay Area. Just...fuck it. There are other well-paying jobs in nice parts of the country where you can still live like a human being and not spend 4/5 of your income on rent or 2 hours a day in traffic. Just boycott the whole damn mess and let the companies figure out that they have to stop hiring and expand to other parts in the country. America cannot do city planning to save its life. Hasn't been able to since the 1920's. It's all single-story homes and strip malls and highways and that shit doesn't scale past a point that most other industrialized societies laugh at, but we just suck at it here and quality of life goes to shit immediately. Just accept it, there's no easy solution, and move somewhere else. Even NYC is better at this point. DC are has a shit-ton of jobs, so does Texas, so does Washington, so does Colorado.
- johan_larson 9y agoI'm a developer well away from Silicon Valley, so when I saw this story I laughed. Then I remembered my most recent paycheck, and I cried.
- sloxy 9y agoI find it beyond belief that local homeowners are being so short sighted. Do they not worry what their children/grandchildren are going to do for accommodation when they are property hunting? Or is their assumption that screw them, that's their problem?
- pwinnski 9y agoAs with most issues, what does the future have to do with today? Most people don't want to take the risk of a huge hit on their property value today in exchange for a chance at avoiding crisis some day in the future. Ideally, some other chumps would take a huge hit on their property values for the future, and mine would remain high. I don't actually live in SV, but that sort of thinking is everywhere.
- bobosha 9y agowhat is the situation in east bay Oakland or thereabouts? or perhaps Marin county? are they just as insane?
- stmfreak 9y agoYes. But proportionately less as the commute worsens.