12 ms·
I've been thinking this over for the past couple months, because I was pretty sure this would be the outcome - that we would lose our net neutrality protection.
by komali2 9y ago
I've been thinking this over for the past couple months, because I was pretty sure this would be the outcome - that we would lose our net neutrality protection.
So let's play out the worse case - Comcast, AT&T etc wait out the shitstorm and then start throttling traffic and packaging the internet, releasing cable-esque "plans."
Is it feasible to just start running our own fiber to hubs? I want to learn more about the internet and what it would take to bypass the ISPs. Can I do this? Do I need to be incorporated to do it? What would it take to start a new ISP with the premise "unthrottled, unmonitored traffic, charged by the gigabyte - an internet utility service"?
As a private citizen, can I purchase a bunch of land between me and, I dunno, a DNS node or whatever and just lay a super long fiber cable straight to it? Who do I have to pay at the node to get to "plug into" it or whatever?
Hmm. I should see if there's some "How the Internet Works: for Dummies" book.
- sliverstorm 9y agoMostly what you need is a lot of money and a legal team. There are some government granted monopolies in certain municipalities, but by and large I understand it's just a money problem. The incumbents have tons of established infrastructure; you're starting from scratch.
- vmarsy 9y ago> As a private citizen, can I purchase a bunch of land between me and, I dunno, a DNS node or whatever and just lay a super long fiber cable straight to it? I'm sure you can, the issue is do you have a couple million $ in your bank account to do this?
- maehwasu 9y agoI do; want to come and hang out on my compound?
- muninn_ 9y agoSure
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ryanisnan 9y agoYou joke but...
- ogsalman 9y agoYeah!
- komali2 9y agoI want half a mil spent on us wearing new socks every day for the rest of our lives, and the other half spent on a pool full of sushi. I understand the pool full of sushi would go bad in about ~8 hours if it is not eaten. I can guarantee you this will not happen.
- jonbronson 9y agoStart a kickstarter/gofundme. I'll contribute.
- komali2 9y agoThis is the route I'm thinking - crowdfunded. Problem is how do you crowdfund "unfettered, utility-style access to the internet" when your funders are spread across the country? It would have to be municipality by municipality. Much harder to get a concentrated volume of funding. Could go the VC route, are there other companies doing this right now? Is the profit model not sellable to a VC yet? It might not be feasible until the actions of other ISPs drive demand high enough for new ones.
- jasonellis 9y agoIf you're looking to actually do this, look into wireless broadband: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_broadband https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_broadband There are currently small operations that offer wireless broadband by putting the receiving equipment on your roof (sometimes they give you a discount if you serve as a repeater) and they purchase wireless data from larger companies' cell towers.
- racer-v 9y agoAsk around for community-friendly ISP's in your area (including Monkeybrains and Sonic in San Francisco). EDIT: OK I suggested sharing a T1 but apparently that hasn't been a good deal since the 90's.
- bwann 9y agoYou realize a T1 is a measly megabit-and-a-half right? Crappy 3G is faster.
- notyourday 9y ago3G may be faster but it is rarely better - with a T1 you are going to get very low latency and very very very low jitter.
- nopzor 9y ago10 friends sharing a t1 falls apart if more than 1 friend wants to stream a movie at the same time. Or if just one friend wants to stream a HD movie. A t1 is 1.54mbit.
- twothamendment 9y agoAh, the good old days - when I had DSL with 1.1 Mbps up AND down, guaranteed. My ISP didn't even have a policy against resale so I shared with 15 units in 6 different buildings - all wired. I was always amazed how much better my dedicated 1.1 felt compared other plans boasting up to 5.
- dreamcompiler 9y agoT1 lines only carry 1.544 Mbps. On the upside, I don't think they cost $1000 nowadays.
- ticklemyelmo 9y agoWhy would they include the T1 option but ignore the nearly equivalent bandwidth of a pair of tin cans connected with string to some acoustic modems?
- JohnTHaller 9y agoNo, it isn't. I live in NYC. I have access to exactly one broadband provider. So, if Spectrum starts blocking Vonage because they want you to pay for their VoIP instead (ISPs in the US have done this in the past), I'll have to drop Vonage and use Spectrum's VoIP. Repeat for blocking P2P, Google Wallet, Facetime, Netflix, etc (all of which have previous incidents in the US).
- RyanZAG 9y agoAs someone from a country without net neutrality, I have to say this hasn't happened. Generally you get very cheap or free plans that are sponsored by Facebook or others that give priority to Facebook, but ISPs are always happy to take a little bit more money for an unlimited plan that gives you full access. And at least in my country, they're not unreasonably priced. Even without net neutrality, your single monopoly ISP could triple their prices and there would be nothing you could do about it. The fact that they haven't seems to show that net neutrality probably isn't going to affect you all that badly. No sane company is going to block Google Wallet or Netflix. Feels like net neutrality isn't the problem - it's Spectrum that is the problem. If repealing net neutrality gets your country to fix your real problem, then I'd say it's going to be a massively good thing in the long run as top parent on this comment chain implied.
- komali2 9y ago>No sane company is going to block Google Wallet Verizon, then, is insane. http://money.cnn.com/2011/12/06/technology/verizon_blocks_google_wallet/index.htm http://money.cnn.com/2011/12/06/technology/verizon_blocks_go...
- RyanZAG 9y agoHow long did it stay blocked? I bet they unblocked it as soon as customers complained. Definitely an interesting example though. Nothing like that has ever happened in my country without net neutrality, but then we have a fairly competitive market where a single carrier trying that would lose their customers very quickly.
- maxsilver 9y ago> As a private citizen, can I (snip) just lay a super long fiber cable straight to (the internet). Yes. I worked on a startup ISP for a few years, which attempted to do this. It's actually really easy to do : 1) Pick a point where you can get connection to the internet. (Backhaul). This is usually a phone companies central office, but it can also be at a data centre or other point of presence. 2) Run fiber cable from there to your customers. (You can also use wireless gear instead for a WISP. I don't like this approach, it's very 1990s despite all the newer better gear, but it's much cheaper than fiber and if your careful it can work out OK) 3) Setup some light network management. Some cities / municipalities have signed agreements for monopoly rights to a telephone or cable provider. Many (but not all) of them can be worked around by simply not selling telephone or TV service. The land between you and your customers is owned. You'll need space in public property (or 'right of way') to connect to them. This also varies based on city/county/state/local laws, but in Michigan there are somewhat decent rules around this. (Set rates for underground conduit access or utility pole access, rules about what can/can't be blocked, etc). The only real roadblock is money. Fiber ISPs are super cheap at scale, but are effectively impossible to bootstrap unless you are already a millionaire. In Michigan, I could easily offer everyone residential 500mbps to the home via fiber for $50/month and cover all costs, no problem. But only after we already had a few thousand customers. The cost for your very first customer is somewhere north of $50k/each, and prices don't become reasonable until your in the thousands. In most areas, the only thing you really need to start an ISP is (1) Lots of money, and (2) perseverance. There's not really any rules that prevent it, and the regulations aren't unreasonable. But the upfront cost is so high, it rules out basically any honest person from having the chance to do it.
- DigitalJack 9y agoI wonder if this would be feasible at the neighborhood level via Home owners association. The neighborhood gets a tower and microwave link to a backhaul station, and provides internet via wifi or wires to the neighborhood. I think our neighboorhood is about 130 houses. probably not enough to make it cost effective. On the flip side, maybe starting a local company to provide LOS microwave hookups to the various neighborhoods in the area could make it work.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- juris 9y agoDepends on where you live. Every city has different laws about how to run cable underneath the ground. The first cost you pay is figuring out where everyone's cables are. The second cost you pay is convincing the city to let you do it. The third cost you pay is doing the digging. If you spin it off as a service to your block, then it might be possible...?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ad_hominem 9y ago> As a private citizen, can I purchase a bunch of land between me and, I dunno, a DNS node or whatever and just lay a super long fiber cable straight to it? Who do I have to pay at the node to get to "plug into" it or whatever? You'll have to buy transit from someone, which will most likely be terminated at a neutral internet exchange / data center. You'll pay the transit provider (e.g. Hurricane Electric) for the bandwidth, and monthly fees to the data center for colocation and the cross-connect. To get that transit back to a point of presence from where you'll branch out service to end users, you'll either have to bury your own fiber (very expensive - tens of thousands of $ per mile even in rural areas not to mention maintenance costs), lease fiber through someone else (e.g. Zayo) (also very expensive), or use wireless backhauls (cheaper but wireless comes with its own set of headaches). Also you'll have to get a CCNA yourself or pay someone to manage your network since a carrier network is nothing like a home network. Now by the time you get service back to your point of presence, you'll have to figure out how to get it to people. Burying fiber is extremely expensive, no way around it. Fixed wireless is a simpler option but getting a line of sight to the customer isn't always feasible, and you'll never have the bandwidth of fiber. That's assuming people even want it. Out in a semi-rural area there may not be much competition, but the population density is so low putting up a tower or burying fiber may not be viable. In any city you're likely to have cable or DSL companies already there, with a price point that may be difficult to convince people to switch. Most people won't care about philosophical arguments about net neutrality, or be willing to pay a lot more for higher speeds. In my opinion your best bet is to rally a coalition of people in your area to petition the municipality to bury the fiber and provide it as a utility. If you're uncomfortable with the gov't being an ISP, there is a very interesting model where the city provides an open access network which lets private ISPs plug in as virtual network layers, letting customers easily switch providers: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/06/what-if-switching-fiber-isps-was-as-easy-as-clicking-a-mouse/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/06/what-...
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoIMO the way to go if the ISP monopolies start getting unreasonable is to start single-issue voting for free municipal broadband. Possibly also run a campaign or grassroots organization for it as well. Comcast can't screw with you if nobody is using Comcast.
- oflannabhra 9y agoThis is essentially how cable worked in the beginning[0]. In lots of rural areas, it is still the case that communities band together into co-operatives to provide power, cable, and broadband[1]. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_television#History_in_the_USA_and_Canada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_television#History_in_th... [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility_cooperative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility_cooperative
- twothamendment 9y agoCo-Ops (at least mine) are awesome. I have fiber to my home and I live in the "middle of nowhere". The other two are the power company and the propane company. They act like a company - except they only try to provide a service and provide jobs, not reap huge profits.
- shmerl 9y ago> Is it feasible to just start running our own fiber to hubs? It is, on the city level. Some created municipal broadband, and showed crooked monopolists and their paid shills to the door. To be clear - Comcast and their ilk fear municipal broadband way more than net neutrality rules. So expect fierce opposition, especially attempts to bribe local legislature to write laws forbidding or obstructing municipal networks.
- ethagnawl 9y agoBuilding a mesh network* is a much cheaper, more realistic alternative. Also, with regard to your point about "starting an ISP", I don't know the legalities and IANAL, but NYC Mesh goes out of their way to state that they _are not_ an ISP - there's probably a reason for that. - https://nycmesh.net https://nycmesh.net - https://www.alliedmedia.org/dctp https://www.alliedmedia.org/dctp
- notyourday 9y agoMesh networks do not work at scale.
- ethagnawl 9y agoHow not? I'm not disagreeing, but genuinely curious.
- notyourday 9y agoFundamentally, mesh network is a shared medium. Think of it as ethernet over hubs. As long as there are not lots of talkers it works just fine. The more talkers you get the worse it becomes.
- ethagnawl 9y agoIf those "talkers" all had hubs which were participants in the mesh, would that help the network "scale"? Also, _what is_ the "scale" issue? Network congestion? Latency introduced by the need to relay a message from node A1 to node Zn? Something else entirely?
- notyourday 9y agoNetwork congested which is going to cause latency.
- gtrubetskoy 9y agoBack when the last mile was a real problem, people got pretty inventive with using directional antennas to establish links over vast distances using unlicensed spectrum, which as far as I know is totally legal still. Here's a Cringely blog from 2001-ish: https://web.archive.org/web/20011215000823/http://www.pbs.org/cringely/pulpit/pulpit20010628.html https://web.archive.org/web/20011215000823/http://www.pbs.or...
- topspin 9y agoI did this for a few years in the late 90's, before anything better than POTS was available in my area. Used a 2.4 GHz 24 dBi antenna on my roof to reach an access point on a mountain about 7 miles away. This worked well; the network operators were competent and the service was more reliable than some of the systems I've had since.
- throwaway413 9y agoAlong the same lines, curious, what if it was a WiFi mesh network connected to a gateway node. You could bridge cities/regions by gateway. Inspiration stemming from Havana’s 50mi mesh intranet.
- analogmemory 9y agoIn San Francisco there's local ISP called MonkeyBrains that uses microwave tech to create a wireless network in the city. They put a receiver on top of your apartment/building and then run cat5 or use existing cable. It's pretty awesome and fast. So it can be done. I'm hopeful that people will be inspired to create their own local ISP in light of the new rules.
- notyourday 9y agoWireless won't solve this problem.
- johncolanduoni 9y agoHow is the latency?
- analogmemory 9y ago5-15ms
- anigbrowl 9y agoBesides the costs, getting all those easements takes a lot of time, and often legal work. This is why crowdsourcing fiber hasn't taken off, it's a nice idea but you'll go through a ton of money on permits and legal filings before you buy a single spool of cable.
- martin1975 9y agoI sent a message to our mayor, to which he responded, regarding muni fiber... It seems the best way to approach it is via a public-private partnership - meaning, we (the residents of our 50,000+ city in SoCal) pay for the buildout, own the fiber infrastructure that should be good for at least 3-5 decades, while someone like Cox, GFiber or whomever provides billing/maintenance/operations.... that way it's a win win and the city doesn't have to get involved in becoming a full blown ISP. In his response he said the topic's been brought up before. If I get his and the council's blessing, the next thing is to hit the ground and get probably 3000-5000 signatures and put this up on a ballot in 2018 November to see how the city feels. I'm optimistic however cause I've been hearing multiple complaints, on-goingly about bad service from ISPs (and we have Cox here, and I don't think they're that bad as opposed to Comcast) and probably a pet peeve is data caps... Sure, we've 1TB caps which is plenty, but w/advent of 4k TV and IPTV ... that may be very low. Here's to hope that in a few years we all have FTTH where I live (crossing my fingers!)
- rmason 9y agoIt's quite expensive to start a fiber network. You might want to consider using wireless with a mesh network. In Detroit there's an organization that has become the leader: https://www.alliedmedia.org/dctp https://www.alliedmedia.org/dctp In Detroit it's not real high speed because they're using foundation money to provide basic access, but there's no reason I know of that it couldn't be. Here's more information on the mesh network in Detroit: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/kz3xyz/detroit-mesh-network https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/kz3xyz/detroit-me...
- orblivion 9y agoA relevant story many will recognize: https://www.thelocal.de/20140601/german-villagers-build-own-broadband-network https://www.thelocal.de/20140601/german-villagers-build-own-... As best I can tell they are not even municipal. Merely a cooperative owned by a big chunk of the town. At least last I heard.
- patcon 9y ago> I want to learn more about the internet and what it would take to bypass the ISPs. Can I do this? Fwiw, a group called Toronto Meshnet [1] was investigating the opportunity for a community mesh project (which lacks incorporation and know-how of how to run an ISP) to partner with a non-profit ISP [2] (that lacks capacity, constantly gets shut out of the last-mile to new condo developments, but understands the ISP side) to have mesh accommodate the last-mile into homes.[3] I think they're in a slow-down phase right now as they didn't get funding, but I imagine there's legs in this approach, and they'll ramp up again :) [1] https://tomesh.net/ https://tomesh.net/ [2] http://www.torfree.net/ http://www.torfree.net/ [3] https://github.com/tomeshnet/documents/tree/master/meeting_notes/20160809_meeting-notes.md#next-steps-with-free-net-collaboration https://github.com/tomeshnet/documents/tree/master/meeting_n... -
- username223 9y ago> As a private citizen, can I ... just lay a super long fiber cable straight to it? The other responses offer far more technical details than I can, and probably also a better long-term strategy, but here's a small thing you can do right now: knock on your neighbor's door, and offer a six-pack of good beer and half his internet bill in exchange for his WiFi password. If he says yes, cancel your service. Say you are moving to Bhutan and becoming a monk to make their "customer retention specialists" go away. From my apartment in a fairly spread-out "city," I can see about ten wireless networks, half with a pretty good signal. I can only imagine what things are like in SF/NY, where techies are stacked on top of each other like dogs in a no-kill shelter.
- letsbehonest 9y agoThe more likely next step is not cable-esque plans. It is ISPs shaking down Internet companies to try to get huge sums of money at the source. As such, what you'll see as a consumer is just higher prices from _other_ companies, as they're forced to pay for access to bandwidth which you paid for. This also means that most people won't understand the problem, and won't get upset with the correct people. This is a travesty, akin to if every appliance manufacturer had to pay a recurring tribute to the electric company. But hey... at least the Libertarians are all quite excited.
- hyperpallium 9y agoAlso a possibility of ad hoc suburban networks, where each phone becomes a cell tower. User ISP.