5 ms·
This is a remarkably direct and appropriate apology, along with an appropriate response, a rare thing indeed. If not for their initial response to the first ro
by JoshTriplett 9y ago
This is a remarkably direct and appropriate apology, along with an appropriate response, a rare thing indeed.
If not for their initial response to the first round of feedback, namely to put a "we're still doing it" at the bottom of their original blog post (with completely unreasonable and unjustified explanations for why), I'd give them full credit for responding appropriately. As it is, though, at least they fixed this. They're still going to need to deal with the giant pile of patrons they drove off; many people lost a significant fraction of their support because of this change, and that won't necessarily come back.
Between 1 and 2 years ago, I talked to some folks at Patreon about an unrelated topic (namely, trying to use Patreon for registered charities). They mentioned at that time that they had a change in the works to shift processing fees from creators to patrons, which they said at the time would be "better for creators" for various reasons, but that didn't want to talk about the details yet. (Since the issue is now public, I don't see any issue with saying that now.) That discussion naturally didn't include any information about fee structure or un-aggregation of charges with associated additional fees, e.g. the "$1 costs $1.37" problem, since that wasn't the topic; the impression they gave at the time was that the only change was to pass on the (presumably still aggregated) fees to the patrons, which wouldn't have been as serious a problem, and wouldn't have killed Patreon's suitability as a wildly successful microtransaction platform the way this change did. So, they've been thinking about this for a long time, and yet they sprung it on people without warning and without running the full details by anyone.
Update: there's now a survey from Patreon asking for feedback: https://twitter.com/Patreon/status/941010263385374720 https://twitter.com/Patreon/status/941010263385374720
- runj__ 9y agoYeah, they could have avoided this altogether by checking with their user base but this is a good response, although radio silence for five days is a bit crazy.
- sigzero 9y agoI give them leeway on the 5 days. I guess they could have said something general like "We understand the new payment policies are not what our user base has expected of us. We are formulating an in-depth response and will have it out in the next few days. We appreciate your response and patience."
- JoshTriplett 9y agoIt'd have been dangerous to say even that if they didn't know they could fix the problem in a satisfactory way, or they'd get blasted even more. But yes, they should have handled this far, far better.
- slededit 9y agoIf you ask the user base if they are OK with a price increase you are going to get a big NO every time.
- delecti 9y agoTheir user base includes both patrons and creators. Obviously patrons would say they don't want a price increase, all other things being equal, but they might be okay with it knowing that increase goes to creators. And asking a handful of high earning creators could have given them good feedback on why it's a bad idea.
- slededit 9y agoBut the increase was going to the company Patreon not the creators. That was mostly the point - they need/want to make more money.
- firloop 9y agoIt didn’t really seem like Patreon was making significantly more money from the new model, fees were higher because they chose to no longer batch charges. The fact that this belief is so widespread is a major testament to Patreon’s failed messaging.
- slededit 9y agoNot batching charges would be so needlessly wasteful that I refuse to believe that was really their intent.
- firloop 9y agoFair. It's true that they didn't announce the unbundling until after the initial wave of complaints.
- hutzlibu 9y ago"fees were higher because they chose to no longer batch charges. " Why did they decide that?? (sorry did not read all blogpost in case it is there)
- pdkl95 9y agoShocking you community's members with a sudden change - no matter the size - is almost always seen as hostile and drives members away. I recommend the talk[1] Joe Peacock of fark.com gave about the time they deployed a redesign unannounced and made their infamous "You'll get over it." post in the thread full of confused and angry members. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YnVeysllPDI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YnVeysllPDI
- gozur88 9y ago>Shocking you community's members with a sudden change - no matter the size - is almost always seen as hostile and drives members away. But the size of the change matters. No matter how much warning they gave there's no way I would tolerate a flat $0.35 fee plus a percentage on a dollar donation.
- rhizome 9y agoWhat VC board of directors is going to support that? Are we supposed to believe they didn't game the numbers out on this? That attrition wouldn't hold sway? I don't believe it, and any attempt by them to "I'm just a simple caveman, unfamiliar with your society" an excuse lies in high tension with "$100MM in funding." I think the simplest explanation is that moving to focus on bigger-ticket patrons destroyed their brand.
- minimaxir 9y agoTwitter was filled with screenshots of people removing their $1 pledges. It wouldn’t surprise me if the rollback of the new model was motivated more by economics than PR, where the forecasted revenue under the new model (accounting for loss rate of subscribers) was lower than the forecasted revenue under the old model.
- pjc50 9y agoWell, those things are inseperable in this day and age, especially for a company that depends on internet communities. It's astonishing how a company with one product could misunderstand its own market so badly, but given the troubles of Twitter and to a lesser extent Etsy perhaps it's less surprising.
- sgdread 9y agoI understand why they do it: they trying to bring down transaction costs with payment processors. These fees on small amounts is death by thousand cuts. But, I believe, there is a way: they can introduce wallets for $1-2 patrons: put $10 in a single transaction, then charge the wallet once it is a time to pay to creator. This should aggregate small transactions into larger ones and significantly cut the costs.
- ryanatallah 9y agoIt seems very likely that the change was motivated by payment processor fees. Patreon uses Stripe to process payments, which charges a flat rate of 2.9% + $0.30 per successful charge. Compare that to the proposed fee patron fee structure of 2.9% + $0.35 — where presumably the extra $0.05 per transaction is the cut Patreon takes off the top for themselves.
- conductr 9y agoDon't forget it's now 2.9% of $1.37 instead of $1.00. Reducing their piece by another 1 or 2 cents depending on how Stripe rounds
- ceejayoz 9y agoPatreon does enough volume to qualify for discounts - their Stripe rate is 1.9%, not 2.9%. (This used to be on https://patreon.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/204606125-How-do-you-calculate-fees- https://patreon.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/204606125-How-..., but it's gone now.)
- nojvek 9y agoLooks like they wanna be nice guys running a marketplace at 5% and claiming to be good guys. And then VC dogs biting them to make fatter profits so they find ticket master like shoddy processing fee scams.
- hutzlibu 9y ago
- PandaChi 9y agoI'm just sharing in here b/c I've always appreciated when others "peel back the curtain" to show the thinking behind decisions. At the end of the day, it was obvious that we fucked up from the immediate feedback, but internally there was already a strong camp who felt this change was wrong, which greatly helped our ability to move quickly and plan out how we'd call this off (all the code was already in production behind feature flags). On the data side, our churn ticked up, but was actually lower than we predicted and quickly returned to normal levels https://imgur.com/a/inFOE https://imgur.com/a/inFOE -- so the reversal was largely driven by the complaints of creators and patrons alike, and our own realization of how tone-deaf the decision was to begin with. Speaking of which -- in my mind there are some obvious solutions to alleviating fees that didn't require moving the entire burden onto the goodwill of supporters. We're going to tackle a more comprehensive roadmap in the coming days and weeks (and talk to creators much more during this process), but if anyone is curious or wants to offer feedback, here are my thoughts: * A big problem (that we arguably created ourselves) is a patron could pledge to a creator on the 25th of a month (granting a patron 5-6 days of access), get charged, and then get charged again on the 1st of the next month (granting the patron 30-31 days of patron-access). Pro-rating didn't seem like a right solution for the first charge since becoming a patron unlocked all the content immediately. So imo we should just (like a Netflix or any other subscription) have your first pledge grant you 30 days of access, whenever it was created -- and have this forever be your "anniversary date" of charge -- if you pledge Jan 25th, you'd be charged again Feb 25th. * The question is around how we aggregate pledges if this patron pledges to another creator. If we say the patron pledged $5 to the 1st creator on the 25th of Jan, then pledged $5 to the second creator on the 10th of February, I'd want to charge the patron $10 on Feb 25, and in the receipt call out that you're paying for the 1st creator for the period of Feb 25-March 25, and for the 2nd creator from March 10-April 10 (because you'd have already paid for Feb 10-March 10 when you pledged to the 2nd creator on Feb 10). This way you're ALWAYS getting 30 days of access for every pledge you pay. * Now that we can aggregate payments across multiple creators, I'd want to allow for the purchasing of multiple months/year at a time for a creator or creators, which further reduces fees -- additionally it allows creators to setup rewards (we're building this system out now) for when patrons have pledged a total of X amount or pledged for some time period. * Finally, once we can pledge across multiple time periods, I'd love for cryptocurrency to be able to pay for patronage. Currently it's trivial for us to accept bitcoin via our Stripe integration, but we wouldn't be able to do recurring payments, and the ultimate thing that kills it for me is that creators wouldn't actually get bitcoin, but rather we'd have to convert it to fiat immediately. I'd rather patrons be able to purchase multiple months of patronage and creators have the option to convert to fiat immediately or hold actual bitcoin and participate in the wild ride that is cryptocurrency speculation :) Ok that's all -- ideas are rough above, but that's what's on my mind lately -- happy holidays.
- fusiongyro 9y agoOff topic, but is there a good solution like Patreon for registered charities?
- tristanho 9y agoSuccessful/appropriate company apologies seem so rare these days! Anyone have examples of ones done right?
- grrowl 9y agoI don't understand why this .37 applies to every transaction. Wouldn't it make sense to charge the overhead once a month, with the actual dollar(s) being distributed as the user wishes? They should use the power of their platform (obviously nearing or having passed critical mass) to make it easier for prolific supporters while also maximising their paetron's income. I think they had good intentions, but got greedy and lost sight of their overall goal
- bionoid 9y ago> This is a remarkably direct and appropriate apology [...] many people lost a significant fraction of their support because of this change, and that won't necessarily come back They could have restored all cancelled pledges and covered their costs for a few months. That would give creators money to pay the rent, and probably go a long way towards restoring relationship with patrons. Clearly, they're not that sorry.