8 ms·
Some of this is pretty patronising. Amongst the advanced techniques they are surprised Islamic State are able to apply they include 'even affixing written instr
by chrisseaton 9y ago
Some of this is pretty patronising. Amongst the advanced techniques they are surprised Islamic State are able to apply they include 'even affixing written instructions [to weapons]'. It shows you how much people have underestimated them when they are writing articles about how they can write notes and stick them on things.
- azernik 9y agoDoing so consistently for standard weapons indicates a certain level of bureaucratic organization.
- chrisseaton 9y agoWell that's what I mean. People seem absolutely dumfounded that these people are able to form basic bureaucratic organisational structures. They aren't simple people. Many of them have higher education from western countries. They're running their military using the same techniques we do, all the way from similar formal tactics on the ground up to social media PR operations. Them being able to write notes on weapons is the least of our worries.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> People seem absolutely dumfounded that these people are able to form basic bureaucratic organisational structures Lots of people have big ideas. Few can competently execute on them. This is true of commercial entrepreneurship and international terrorism alike. From what I can tell, ISIS is (or was) unusually well run [1]. [1] http://m.spiegel.de/international/world/islamic-state-files-show-structure-of-islamist-terror-group-a-1029274.html http://m.spiegel.de/international/world/islamic-state-files-...
- brazzy 9y agoWhich is likely the reason why they were unusually successful. There are probably dozens of terrorist organizations run by would-be conquerors which never get very far because their leaders are not competent.
- gaius 9y agoThey're running their military using the same techniques we do Well, of course they are. American Green Berets ran an extensive "train the trainer" programme in Afghanistan, bootstrapping the precursors of the Taliban into a military that could take on the Soviets. Then once the Soviets were gone, the factions turned on each other, which meant, they continued to practice and refine what they have learned. An ISIS equivalent of a Drill Sergeant probably isn't too different from his Western counterpart...
- jacobr 9y agoal-Qaida is also present in Syria in the form of Hayat Tahrir al-Sham, previously Nusra Front. They have Afghan veterans in their ranks, but do not have the same level of sofistication and standardization as the Islamic State. It's not obvious exactly why the IS is different, but I doubt it has anything to do with American influence. Other rebel groups in the Syrian civil war has had direct American training but they were highly undisciplined and ineffective.
- varjag 9y agoIf anything they were Iraqi army veterans trained by Soviets. But guess complaining about Russian imperialist overreach is unfashionable.
- azernik 9y agoThe big difference is that ISIS descends from Al-Qaida's Iraqi franchise, which picked up a lot of professionalism from demobilized Iraqi Army officers. ISIS was expelled/quit AQ when it started moving in from Iraq and muscling in on Nusra's turf, but they do have common origins.
- azernik 9y agoThat's the Taliban in Afghanistan. ISIS grew out of the very different Iraqi context. The real origin of ISIS's organizational skill is the disbanding of the Iraqi military in 2003 - a totally unnecessary decision on the part of the US that played a big part in the ensuing chaos in the country. Lots of military officers from the old regime, disproportionately Sunni, out of a job, and none too picky about the specific ideologies of the groups that would advance their sectarian interests, transferred their knowledge to groups like AQI, the ancestor of ISIS.
- Jedd 9y ago> Many of them have higher education from western countries. I think one of the reasons that 'these people' aren't frequently over-estimated (or even accurately estimated) is because almost none of them have higher education from their own countries. Not that many higher education facilities have a specific 'learning from your enemy' track, and it's not as though there are respected rules around not using your enemy's facilities against them ... but you know what I mean.
- grkvlt 9y agoI think the reason people are 'dumbfounded' is that IS are display a level of rationality and critical thinking that seems entirely at odds with their irrational and uncritical cultural-religious-political beliefs.
- krageon 9y agoThe US has a competent military. The country is fundamentally christian - I don't see why the two need to be mutually exclusive.
- gnu8 9y agoI didn't read that much into it. I just attributed it to the racist assumption that all non-white non-US persons live like cave people, which makes it that much more impressive that they use any form of technology, whether it be remote controlled explosives or simply the written word.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>even affixing written instructions [to weapons] Well post 1990 or so you use diagrams on complex weapons because you never know when you'll want to MANPADS (which are fairly complex as weapons systems go) to a bunch of farmers.
- 13of40 9y agoI can't imagine how you'd reliably communicate "and then super-elevate right before you fire" to someone either in prose or glyphs on the side of a stinger. You're probably thinking an AT-4, which did, IIRC, have instructions on the side.
- sitkack 9y agoJust put an OLED reticule in the side of the device with a training video. So simple a child could use it.
- grkvlt 9y agoI dunno. Looking at the 'up-armoured' tanks in some articles, it's clear they have no real idea how slat or spaced armour [0] is actually supposed to work, and are just cargo-culting the improvements based on news broadcast images of US or coalition vehicles i.e. they are welding rebar with the same pattern of bars as MRAPs, but directly onto the underlying armour plates, giving no protection against shaped charge HEAT or RPG rounds...! 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slat_armor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slat_armor and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaced_armor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaced_armor