28 ms·
Larry Ellison allegedly tried to have a professor fired for benchmarking Oracle
- masklinn 9y agoAnd remember, > Do not fall into the trap of anthropomorphising Larry Ellison. You need to think of Larry Ellison the way you think of a lawnmower. You don't anthropomorphize your lawnmower, the lawnmower just mows the lawn, you stick your hand in there and it'll chop it off, the end. You don't think 'oh, the lawnmower hates me' -- lawnmower doesn't give a shit about you, lawnmower can't hate you. Don't anthropomorphize the lawnmower. Don't fall into that trap about Oracle. — Brian Cantrill (https://youtu.be/-zRN7XLCRhc?t=33m1s https://youtu.be/-zRN7XLCRhc?t=33m1s) And > I actually think that it does a dis-service to not go to Nazi allegory because if I don't use Nazi allegory when referring to Oracle there's some critical understanding that I have left on the table […] in fact as I have said before I emphatically believe that if you have to explain the Nazis to someone who had never heard of World War 2 but was an Oracle customer there's a very good chance that you would explain the Nazis in Oracle allegory. — also Brian Cantrill (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79fvDDPaIoY&t=24m https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79fvDDPaIoY&t=24m)
- bigzen 9y agoWhile I agree with the lawnmower sentiment, should we really write off unethical behavior by comparing humans to machines?
- robert_foss 9y agoI can't tell you if it is right, but it does effectively communicate the lack of decency in anything Oracle does.
- protomyth 9y agoIf you watch the video, Brian Cantrill most certainly does not write off Oracles’s bad behavior, quite the opposite actually.
- derefr 9y agoMachines are one of the only things most people are familiar with that don't hold to all the same values that living beings (humans, other mammals, most vertebrates) usually do. (You might call Ellison a "force of nature", but that might not play well for people who attribute an "eventually-consistent omnibenevolence" to nature.) Really, without the metaphor, what's going on is that Larry Ellison has modified himself to hold the values that a corporation holds, in order to more efficiently drive said corporation toward optimizing on its corporate goals (i.e. increase share value, etc.) Where human values and corporate values are in conflict, Ellison has chosen to forget about his human values and, effectively, become the avatar of the corporation's interests. He's the "ideal CEO", in about the same way as Locutus of Borg is an ideal CEO. A better analogy for this effect, for those who understand it, would be to compare Ellison to a https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Paperclip_maximizer https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Paperclip_maximizer, but that's not really that well-known a meme.
- slavik81 9y agoWhat values are shared by all mammals?
- mmirate 9y ago> Really, without the metaphor, what's going on is that Larry Ellison has modified himself to hold the values that a corporation holds, in order to more efficiently drive said corporation toward optimizing on its corporate goals (i.e. increase share value, etc.) Hmm. I wonder why this augmentation is newsworthy/nontrivial/frightening. Perhaps our human frailty makes this feat truly difficult even for an average CEO?
- krylon 9y agoI kind of feel for Bryan Cantrill and his blood pressure. Getting this worked up cannot be healthy. But damn, few people are that much fun to listen to when ranting.
- theoh 9y agoThere's another aspect, which is that some people find his aggressively dismissive style personally abusive and distressing. I don't know enough to validate this perspective, but it's something for all of us to consider: https://blog.valerieaurora.org/2016/10/22/why-i-wont-be-attending-systems-we-love/ https://blog.valerieaurora.org/2016/10/22/why-i-wont-be-atte...
- throwaway0071 9y agoIt's the first time I read this blog post (thanks for sharing) but it's not surprising to me. I always cringe when I see people quoting Bryan because that's exactly my experience interacting with him on mailing lists or watching him give talks. At this point I don't have the energy to deal with people like him. I just accept him as a natural occurrence in our field. I certainly praise does who do have the energy for fighting that.
- oblio 9y agoI'm also quite combative in discussions. And then someone told me: be careful not to win the battle (current conversation) and lose the war (attention and possibly the respect or friendship of the person you're talking to).
- barrkel 9y agoPersonally, I have a hard time favouring diversity and safe spaces over good software and solid architecture where the two goals compete. I'm also aware that the competitive streak in me pushes me to excel, and without it - without an element of technological one-upmanship in my personality - I'd be much less ambitious and I'd have achieved far less. So overall I don't think Bryan is wrong, per se, to take the tack he does within the pool he plays in; it's just a pool for type-A personalities (in the system dev domain), and not the right place to play in if you're starting out, or are otherwise fragile. Build up your skin and chops in smaller ponds first. Stay out of them if you don't feel comfortable swimming there, because the discomfort of competition actually serves a purpose for those swimmers. (Yes, some people can pursue and sustain excellence without the heat of competition. But not everyone is like that.)
- userbinator 9y agoThe other memorable quote I've heard is "Oracle is an acronym for One Rich Asshole Called Larry Ellison".
- DonbunEf7 9y ago"Oregon Ripped-off, America's Cup, Larry Ellison."
- lostlogin 9y agoIt probably worked better when Oracle was the race winner.
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y agoOne Relevant Argument Counter Life Eternal
- throwaway6845 9y agoOther RDBMSs Are Clearly Less Egregious
- rhinoceraptor 9y agoI highly recommend his recent talk on technology leadership: https://youtu.be/9QMGAtxUlAc https://youtu.be/9QMGAtxUlAc
- hinkley 9y agoWired did an article about high tech connected homes. The section on Larry Ellison had an anecdote about how Larry got frustrated with his system and threw the remote at a wall, smashing it. He made one of the engineers drive out to his house with a new one on a Saturday night. Now, the fact that this story is true is telling enough, but what sort of experience did the writers have with Larry that inspired them to put in that story that paints him as a petty, tyrannical manchild?
- legohead 9y agoEllison is the kind of guy who lands his private jet late at night, knowing he will have to pay fines for night noise, then sues over it.
- andrewem 9y agoI hadn't heard of this, but it's true: www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Judge-clears-Ellison-for-landing-at-night-2909426.php
- oh_sigh 9y agoEhh...Larry has a point. If you care about noise levels, don't use weight as a proxy - just use noise levels. Why can a big, quiet plane not land at night, but a tiny noisy plane can?
- hawkice 9y agoNoise is ephemeral and therefore harder to prove.
- smitherfield 9y agoAs the other guy says, it's hard to prove in court which noise came from which plane, but besides that, they may have used weight as a proxy for distinguishing between military and civilian aircraft ("tiny noisy planes" tending to be military), and, also, perceived loudness[1] is a function of both decibel level[2] and pitch[3] (that is, a whistle will be at a higher decibel level than a drum we perceive as equally "loud"). It's intuitively plausible that larger planes tend to make lower-pitched sounds. [1] amplitude [2] amplitude * frequency [3] frequency
- rhapsodic 9y agoGetting people fired to suppress speech is a common tactic in 2017. Ellison was ahead of the curve.
- apcragg 9y ago"waaaahh someone said racist things and got fired. 1984 right?"
- jedberg 9y agoI'm more interested in which cloud provider doesn't allow benchmarks.
- username223 9y agoGiven his employment history, I'm guessing MS: https://twitter.com/danluu https://twitter.com/danluu
- sulam 9y agoNot sure that's true, given easy-to-find examples of Azure benchmarks (and it doesn't even do well in this one): http://www.acmebenchmarking.com/2015/11/benchmarking-cloud-provider-performance.html http://www.acmebenchmarking.com/2015/11/benchmarking-cloud-p...
- me_again 9y agoNo, because he says he's supposed to avoid using it. It would be absurd to prevent a Microsoft engineer from using a Microsoft product "to avoid the appearance of impropriety"
- thecompilr 9y agoAre there really no anonymous benchmarks in the wild?
- ghaff 9y agoProbably, but non-trivial comparative benchmarks of many types of commercial software, performed using well thought out methodologies, are neither easy nor cheap to run. Furthermore, an anonymous benchmark (like many other anonymous product comparisons) is going to make many people suspect that it's a fraudulent result. Imagine there's an anonymous benchmark that isn't simple to replicate because of software and/or hardware costs that shows some proprietary software whipping an open source project on some dimensions or other. How many people here are going to immediately jump to the conclusion that it's the proprietary vendor planting false information?
- user5994461 9y agoAnonymous benchmarks are usually affiliated to at least one of the products being benchmarked. It's usually not hard to figure out which one. Either way I wouldn't expect a real world benchmark to be reproducible, it's too hard to reproduce and takes too much resources.
- NotSammyHagar 9y agoJust post them anonymously. I think if there was enough public shaming against blocking benchmarking, companies would give up on this, just like shaping for sexual harrasment finally accumulated enough weight to knock out harvey weinstein.
- marcoperaza 9y agoThe one time such a clause was challenged in court it was struck down, but on narrower grounds related to the specifics of the particular case. The actual issue of whether such a clause is enforceable was not answered by the court. https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28511/has-the-dewitt-clause-which-prevents-researchers-for-publishing-db-benchmarks-e https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28511/has-the-d...
- madengr 9y agoI guess I have never read the EULA, as I have benchmarked the speed vs accuracy of EM simulators and published the results online.
- moyix 9y agoDeWitt clauses have spread outside of databases too, unfortunately. John Regehr got a nastygram from Coverity/Synopsys when he tried to post static analyzer benchmarks (not even his own; the benchmarks were done by researchers at the Toyota InfoTechnology Center): https://blog.regehr.org/archives/1217 https://blog.regehr.org/archives/1217 This has effectively dissuaded me from trying to perform benchmarks of Coverity and other commercial tools using LAVA [1], so I can attest to its chilling effect. [1] https://seclab.ccs.neu.edu/static/publications/sp2016lava.pdf https://seclab.ccs.neu.edu/static/publications/sp2016lava.pd...
- userbinator 9y agoThat sounds like something SciHub would be very useful for --- "the benchmarks they don't want you to know."
- moyix 9y agoSure, someone could post a paper like this anonymously. But anonymous papers don't benefit from all the incentives of the standard academic publishing system. As a fun aside, here's an example of one of the few fully anonymous papers I know of: http://census2012.sourceforge.net/paper.html http://census2012.sourceforge.net/paper.html
- kirvyteo 9y agoThe EDA (Electronic Design Automation) industry is full of such clauses. Every software in that industry is selling based on its quality of results or faster processing time. Every tool claims 10x improvements but there is no way to verify it. To be fair to them, understandably designs are different and may yield different quality of results.
- trgv 9y agoCan Oracle/Microsoft actually enforce "no benchmark clauses," as in could they take you to court and win?
- adrianN 9y agoDo you want to fight a corporation with endless money for lawyers in court?
- trgv 9y agoNo, of course not. But I'm still interested in what a court would ultimately decide and whether anyone has actually been taken to court over this.
- pimmen 9y agoI suspect not, you should be covered by the first amendment. However, I don't think most people have the money to find out. The ones that do seem keen on following Ellison's example.
- anon62343 9y agoThe first amendment doesn't apply to contracts between private entities. The government cannot forbid you to publish benchmarks. However, it can also not prevent you from signing away your first amendment rights in most circumstances.
- wl 9y agoThe first amendment only protects you against the government. NDA clauses in contracts hold up in court all the time.
- brightball 9y agoThere’s a reddit thread benchmarking SQL Server vs Postgres where the all named references had to be removed IIRC. Edit: here https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2mhpwp/postgresql_vs_ms_sql_server_a_comparison_of_two/ https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2mhpwp/postgre...
- krylon 9y agoSomebody who apparently had to deal with the company once told me that Oracle is really an acronym for "One Rich Asshole Called Larry Ellison".
- titanix2 9y agoHow can database vendors make benchmarking illegal? Saying "we don’t allow benchmarking" in their EULA don’t make it illegal if the clause is abusive. Maybe it can work in some juridictions but I don’t think it is enforceable worldwide.
- markbnj 9y agoI'm not a lawyer so I don't really have any clue :). But I suspect the defense would be that it's an agreement between two parties: you want to use their shit you agree to use it by their terms. The debate around these things has always been more or less centered on what it meant to agree, i.e. did I agree when I opened the shrinkwrap on a box? But with Oracle licenses there is not much doubt about what it means to agree, there being reams of paper evidence that you agreed, and large checks written to make that agreement concrete.
- Asooka 9y agoI suppose you could also go at it from the angle that it's an anti-competitive practice and no license should be able to restrict you from publishing truthful benchmarks.
- drb91 9y agoYou could knowingly publish incorrect, fictional, or fabricated results. When they sue, you won’t have violated any license. But at least oracle will look terrible.
- dsacco 9y agoDoes anyone here have direct experience with being sued for releasing a benchmark online? I’m interested in seeing how common (and enforceable) it really is.
- tlogan 9y agoAs far as I know, it is very easily enforceable and quite common for enterprise software. In certain countries that is even illegal to publish "benchmarks" like this one. I remember that there was a law like that in Germany - not sure whether it has changed with EU.
- dsacco 9y agoWow, seriously? That’s unfortunate. I have a significant amount of bare metal storage space and computation resources and would be happy to host benchmarks like these.
- kstrauser 9y ago> In certain countries that is even illegal to publish "benchmarks" like this one. My understanding is that in some places it's illegal for companies to publish benchmarks "proving" that their software is better than their competitors', the idea being that you're unlikely to show a fair comparison. I've not heard of it being illegal for a third party to post such a thing, though. Do you have a link? (I'm genuinely curious.)
- user5994461 9y agoI published one, not on oracle but on other expensive entreprise databases. Never got a complaint. However I received a nice email from one of their sales guy to thank me and say it was great to show to their clients.
- thebeardedone 9y agoI did not know that there is a clause in the license agreement about not being allowed to disclose benchmarks of databases. Recently I came into discussion regarding why someone chose to use Oracle instead of Postgres; the argument that someone brought up was that they did not know how Postgres scaled. After pointing out that the data that will be stored will be most likely be a few hundred GB (in an exaggerated worst case scenario) and that Postgres is said to handle 100's of TB of data, they capitulated and said that customers trust Oracle (even though they never see or touch the database). Personally I would be very interested in seeing comparisons between PG, Oracle and MSSQL as well for different data-sets/use-case scenarios. This would really help as a reference in the future when someone else is making critical decisions which might not appear to make sense. EDIT: This sounds like a very shady clause; anyone with law insights know whether this would be enforceable in the EU?
- DenisM 9y agoThere is a direct comparison, it’s called TPCC TPCD TPCE TPCR family of benchmarks. Each company tries to make themselves look good with those, but they have to follow the rules.
- ghaff 9y agoI haven't dealt with those for a while but, as I recall, all the hardware and software companies in the benchmark (which isn't a comparison except insofar as other companies have also published a benchmark) have to agree to publish. Furthermore, the results are audited and there are various rules about how you can use and talk about the benchmark. (And they cost BIG money to run--into the millions $.)
- user5994461 9y agoPostgre doesn't handle hundreds of TB of data.
- anarazel 9y agoIt's postgres or postgresql, not postgre.
- mcv 9y agoI'm surprised these clauses manage to prevent benchmarks. Surely someone with no Oracle contract can still publish them? Leak a benchmark, benchmark on someone else's system, whatever. It shouldn't be too hard to publish a benchmark for which this clause can't be enforced.
- chubot 9y agoHow would they get the software legally? Oracle would probably sue them for piracy or something. If you bought it, they would probably say you violated the agreement and no longer have a valid license. Not saying it's right, but since it's commercial software, they can probably play some tricks. It's one of among many reasons to use commerical software where possible.
- paulryanrogers 9y agoDid you mean "reasons not to use..."?
- chubot 9y agoOops yes! Unfortunately HN expires the ability to edit the comment after awhile.
- nawitus 9y agodocker pull sath89/oracle-12c? In sane countries licenses don't have magic powers. I'm allowed to publish a benchmark no matter what Oracle things.
- tomjen3 9y agoWhy would you have that clause? If you believe in your product you want me to benchmark it, and if you don't believe in your own product, why should I?
- mmirate 9y agoBecause they don't believe in their own product, but hope that their salespeople convince you otherwise.
- DenisM 9y agoBenchmarks can be slanted by the person doing them, perhaps they want to present themselves in the better light. There are official benchmarks that are supposedly on even ground,see TPCC, TPCE and so on.
- stonemetal 9y agoThey don't want MS to pay an "independent" 3rd party to poorly configure their database then publish benchmarks that show them in a negative light. Therefor if you want to publish benchmarks you have to (pay to) keep Oracle in the loop so that they make sure you don't screw it up. You see this all the time with Mysql and Postgresql benchmarks. Typically when I see the two compared it is by someone with a decade of experience with one of the systems, and none with the other one. They use a workload that is optimized for their usual system. They also don't have a clue how to create a high performance version for the competitor, nor do they know how to configure it.
- user5994461 9y agoMost of the benchmarks are done by competing companies with competing products, not by a random engineer. They make sure the benchmark put their own products in a good light. It's also true that the testers usually don't configure all the products equivalently. It's usually not (only) incompetence, they are pushing an agenda for their product or consulting services.
- batbomb 9y agoAlright, this isn’t news. It’s pretty well known you can benchmark Oracle, it’s just always referred to as Database X in the literature (Sometimes MSSQL gets this treatment too)
- tlogan 9y agoI was under impression that "no benchmark clauses" is many ToS and license terms. Are there any enterprise software which allows that?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- boodewittclause 9y ago(edit: congress forbid review gag clauses last year) I've pointed this: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/11/congress-passes-law-protecting-right-to-post-negative-online-reviews/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/11/congress-passes-... out to my employer's lawyers, who responded with "well, yes, but we'd still get sued, by Oracle, so... no."
- dwheeler 9y agoThese evil clauses are called Dewitt Clauses, since the original purpose was to attack DeWitt. Unfortunately, the law that protects reviewers does not protect people who publish benchmarks in software. These DeWitt clauses should be illegal in the United States on First Amendment grounds, but the problem is that to get software at all you have to agree to the license, and the licenses often have these nasty things. I think these Clauses should be straight up illegal, but very few people have enough money to pursue this in court.
- anarazel 9y ago> Unfortunately, the law that protects reviewers does not protect people who publish benchmarks in software. I'm not convinced that's generally true. The form contracts language [1] clearly talks about individuals, but at least one of the DB vendor license agreements allows for individuals. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15888236 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15888236 If an individual were to decide to do such a benchmark, I don't immediately see how the DeWitt clause would be still valid. Not many people are going to risk that obviously. > hese DeWitt clauses should be illegal in the United States on First Amendment ground I agree that they shouldn't be allowed, I however fail to see how 1A applies. You willingly enter into a contract with a private entity. That contract has rules, and there are some consequences for breaking them. I think the government has an important, and imo somewhat neglected, role in providing rules around valid contracts, but that's not 1A.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoThe first amendment only applies to government restrictions on speech.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoThis isn't limited to commercial software. Until its recent relicensing, GPL FreeRTOS had this turd: Clause 2: FreeRTOS may not be used for any competitive or comparative purpose, including the publication of any form of run time or compile time metric, without the express permission of Real Time Engineers Ltd. (this is the norm within the industry and is intended to ensure information accuracy).
- CapacitorSet 9y ago>this is the norm within the industry and is intended to ensure information accuracy I like how even they understand that it's a bullshit clause, and try to justify it.
- dangerbird2 9y agoWouldn't a major usage restriction that make it incompatable with other GPL software (and possibly make it tagged as non-free by FSF and OSI)?
- fulafel 9y agoI suspect this makes it incompatible with FreeRTOS itself too, as the GPL allows redistribution only if no additional restrictions are stipulated. So there was legal way to redistribute it.
- yndoendo 9y agoDon' worry, next it will ISPs with a no-benchmark / speed test clause.
- forkerenok 9y agoI can definitely understand their fear of misrepresentation. I wonder if demanding inclusion of their feedback on benchmark into benchmark article (intro or summary) would be more fair than conditionally gagging it..
- whack 9y ago> If we look at major commercial databases today, two out of the three big names in commericial databases forbid publishing benchmarks. I see many people bashing Oracle/Ellison, but they are not alone in this. MS does the same thing as well. The really worrying thing is that such practices are deemed to be legal. The entire principle of Free Markets is underpinned by consumers having accurate information about the goods they are purchasing. Having licensing agreements that are expressly designed to prevent the dissemination of product-information, goes against everything that Capitalism and Free-Markets stand for. The fact that there are no government regulations against such behavior, is precisely what leads people to think that we are living in a Corporatocracy, and not a Free Market.
- __s 9y agoIdeally consumers care about access to information enough to produce a negative impact on sales for DB engines which don't allow benchmarking, making regulation unnecessary Ideally, ofc
- TheIronYuppie 9y agoI have no objection to your overall sentiment, but, TBH, much of the reason they do this is it is trivially easy to use very authentic looking benchmarks to effectively lie. The net is that the academic ideal of a free market is effectively unachievable in real life - perfect information does not exist. I don't know how to get around this problem of course.
- whack 9y agoI agree that we can never get to the ideal of a free market, but at the very least, we can ban business practices that are expressly designed to undermine the free market. We already have anti-trust laws that prohibit companies from some practices, such as price-fixing or false-advertising. We really need to strengthen such laws to ban modern practices such as benchmark-bans.
- userbinator 9y agomuch of the reason they do this is it is trivially easy to use very authentic looking benchmarks to effectively lie. ...and that is what the companies themselves do for their own products when they show benchmarks, to make them look better than they really are.
- mgerdts 9y agoI took a databases course under Professor DeWitt - it was one of the most rewarding and memorable classes that I took at UW Madison. Many years later I heard Larry warmly refer to David DeWitt. I forget whether that was at an all-hands meeting or a conference keynote. On an unrelated topic, I was taking the course while US v. Microsoft was proceeding. DeWitt kept getting called as an expert witness. At one point he noticed someone wearing a suit in the classroom. He interrupted the class and asked the guy to hand over the subpoena so that he could continue on without being distracted. It turns out that the overdressed student was just prepared for an interview that was happening after the class.
- thisisit 9y agoFor a time I really idolised Larry Ellison. Then I saw a documentary on Oracle early years and someone said - "There was no Oralce v1, as Ellison, "knew no one would want to buy version 1". This sounded both stupid and an urban legend. Till I checked the Wikipedia entry: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oracle_Database#Releases_and_versions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oracle_Database#Releases_and... It not only changed my perspective of the man but also the company. One can know a lot about a company's practices from the way it was founded. Now there is nothing about Oracle which surprises me any more.
- smitherfield 9y ago>There was no Oralce v1, as Ellison, "knew no one would want to buy version 1" Of the "bad Larry Ellison" anecdotes ITT, most of which do paint him in a very bad light, this one doesn't offend me at all; more like smart marketing advice you can use.
- gkya 9y agoThat's a very bad marketing advice. In case someone finds out what you've done, it's a red cross mark on your brand.
- Dylan16807 9y ago"Version 1 was internal and not good enough, we waited until version 2 to start selling"? I don't see the issue.
- smitherfield 9y agoIt's no different from pricing your product at $9.99/month instead of $10/month, or $9.99/month instead of $119.88/year. Or more pertinent, marketing Java 1.8 as Java 8, selling products with random alphanumeric names like "A-Series 7340X", retroactively renumbering previous software versions, or going straight from Windows 8 to Windows 10. Software version schemes are often started at 0, or other times 1, so why not any other integer? I don't expect software version numbers to mean anything except that higher is (probably) chronologically later. That said I would probably still start numbering internal/beta versions at 1 or 0 and use 2 for the first release. It's not even in the same league of dishonesty as ubiquitous practices by blue-chip tech companies such as using trial pricing in advertisements, selling "new versions" of software with only trivial changes, selling "extended warranties" on hardware that don't cover the most common causes of breakage, or claiming customers have access to "expertise" developing intelligent zero-downtime SaaS solutions on the blockchain with the deep learning algorithms powering our global AR/VR-enabled IoT cloud.
- misterHN 9y agoLarry Ellison is Jewish; I don't doubt the bit about retaliating by not hiring grads, and I suspect he would retaliate against benchmarks using other modes and channels as well, even today. Nevertheless, this is chilling speech, and Ellison should probably be told by a judge that when he issues legal threats against benchmark publishers, he is a gangster who is committing the crime of racketeering. On Ellison's grave it will be written: HERE LIES A DIRTY JEWISH GANGSTER
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoCan someone explain how this agreement can be binding? For instance, if I buy their DB, then publish benchmarks, at best they can deactivate my license or something right? So if I am willing to forego the cost of the license, I can do whatever benchmarking I want, publish it, and say goodbye to the DB?
- user5994461 9y agoIf you publish a benchmark, you risk a lawsuit. That will be time consuming and expensive. It may result in fines and having to take off the benchmark from the internet.
- michaelbuckbee 9y agoBuried quite a ways down in the article is an interesting concept of using semi anonymous markets to distribute and pay for benchmarking.
- nicodjimenez 9y agoMaybe it's time to start shorting Oracle stock. In the age of AWS and Azure, I don't see their 10 year prospects as being very good.
- scarmig 9y agoOracle Cloud! It's not in the Azure/GCP tier, but they're investing a ton in it (seven figure offers) to pull in engineering talent from AWS/Azure/GCP. And Oracle does have some definite ... "structural" advantages.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoOracle has been in the death throes for decades. There's loads of money on keeping the existing Oracle shops hostage for decades of betting the farm on Oracle-specific tech. Unless you won the Powerball and want to live on Ramen for the rest of your life, don't do this.
- billmalarky 9y agoYou know it's called shorting for a reason. You can't just short a stock for as long as you want before covering at some arbitrary point in the distant future.
- drawkbox 9y agoLarry Ellison long ago was an engineer, he turned to the dark side a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away. There are reasons for companies not wanting benchmarks public i.e. unequal or fixed results. But ultimately one can no longer be an engineer if you are excluding metrics from software for business/legal reasons. I have had to run many systems on Oracle and the developer is not their customer, it is a painful experience in Oracle enterprise. The extent of it is they have Ask Tom fill in the gaps. Luckily most of the Oracle work was moving systems from massive Oracle setups to swifter (and hundreds of thousands of dollars cheaper) architecture on MSSQL, PostgreSQL and MySQL (until Oracle bought them) now MariaDB. I like platforms that put the developer and their workflow as a top priority, not how many rounds of golf you play with the C level execs. Oracle would be the latter type of "enterprise" company.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoStandard "enterprise software" company operating procedure. I think VMware is equally jealous of their benchmarks. It could be worse though. Cisco pressed criminal charges against this guy[0] for wanting to 3rd-party-service their equipment. Happy 2017, peasants! [0-0] http://www.vancouversun.com/news/Cisco+deceived+Canadian+courts+audacious+ploy+jail+executive+judge+finds/4884794/story.html http://www.vancouversun.com/news/Cisco+deceived+Canadian+cou... [0-1] https://www.computerworld.com/article/2507735/cybercrime-hacking/former-engineer-who-sued-cisco-now-faces-criminal-charges.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/2507735/cybercrime-hac...
- paultopia 9y agoLaw professor here again. For those who are interested in the legal and policy aspects of this, I highly recommend a book called Boilerplate by Margaret Radin. This is just one of many examples of comically abusive and bizarre contract terms that companies impose by imaginary consent.
- scarlac 9y agoHow are clauses like this even legal? One could argue they limit people's personal freedom and is essentially an anti-competition clause without an upside. Legitimate question, as I am finding it hard that a court would allow this.
- paultopia 9y agoI haven't looked into the enforceability of this kind of contract in particular. That being said, there are arguments in the abstract that I'd apply---essentially, the argument that this kind of contract is against public policy because of those kinds of anti-competitive effects. Without doing the research, it wouldn't surprise me if the extent to which these clauses were enforceable varied state-by-state. States tend to diverge a lot on these kinds of "unenforceable because against public policy" arguments.
- DesiLurker 9y agowhenever I encounter a deep gray area contract like this my first thought is that its a play on cost of discovery. so long as it is ambiguous enough it just boils down to who can afford how much legal expense. when comparing deep pockets like oracle and some random reviewer/blogger its a done deal.
- paultopia 9y agoYes. This is often true of all kinds of legally shady behavior, not just contracts. This is why things like class action litigation can be important, and other aggregation mechanisms. (There might be something to crowdfunding challenges in cases like this)
- jpalomaki 9y agoCould it be that these provisions are there mainly to prevent other companies from publishing misleading benchmarks? Instead of fighting in the court if the benchmarks are done properly and give correct picture, maybe it is just easier to outright ban them.
- atesti 9y agoSo how good does Oracle perform im comparison to mssql and postgres? For example with just INSERTs and SELECTs?
- jondubois 9y agoEveryone knows that Oracle products are poor quality. They were never about the product... Always about sales and litigation. Oracle has firmly established its reputation and I'm confident that someday they'll pay for it.
- JetSpiegel 9y ago> someday they'll pay for it I'm not holding my breath though. Maybe my grandchildren will live to see Oracle bought as a Kickstarter project started by Postgres devs.
- cpitman 9y agoThis has often been abused by these companies to attack open source software that allows benchmarking (because what kind of open source license would ban that?). The company can perform a "benchmark" of their product and the open source product. They'll then release the results as a whitepaper. Even if they perform the benchmark correctly, they can always choose which results to actually publish. But since the proprietary software has a "no benchmarking" clause, open source projects cannot respond to the whitepaper by performing their own benchmarking. They would need the permission of the proprietary vendor! For example, here is an IBM blog post comparing the performance of IBM MQ and Apache ActiveMQ (https://webspherecompetition.wordpress.com/2015/03/12/ibm-mq-vs-apache-activemq-performance-comparison-update/ https://webspherecompetition.wordpress.com/2015/03/12/ibm-mq...). I've tried to find a copy of the IBM MQ EULA to link, but cannot find one anywhere. But last time I reviewed it (several years ago) I believe it also had a "no benchmark" clause.
- yuhong 9y agoThe blog post says in the end that IBM does allow benchmarks.
- cpitman 9y agoI don't see that. It has tools for running the benchmarks yourself, but that doesn't give you permission to publish benchmark results. And even if it did, a blog post from an employee cannot give you permission to do something that the EULA takes away.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rasz 9y agoEulas are toiled paper in EU, so just benchmark here. You can even buy the software second hand and avoid touching EULA completely. Oracle learned this the hard way, losing the lawsuit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UsedSoft#ECJ_ruling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UsedSoft#ECJ_ruling
- harry8 9y agoWhy don't the competing proprietary databases go right at Oracle in their ads to business class at airports. "Oracle won't let you read or publish benchmarks, maybe too many of their customers would get fired if they did...?" Or variants on the "why do they need to hide?" Haven't seen a case where going with postgres up front on pure prejudice has backfired. Maybe there are times, it would be interesting to know what and when.
- mnemotronic 9y agoWe don't do benchmarks. Our network security team verifies VPN transaction performance and ensures packet security using general purpose scripts that, strangely, look like they're doing basic db operations on different servers and systems. The unfortunate side effect are numbers related to network latency and, I suppose, system performance. But of course we don't care about that.
- metaphor 9y agoThis should be marked (2014).
- askvictor 9y agoWouldn't it be relatively trivial to create a set of data and code, plus a deployment script to spin up some DBs on a cloud service and compare the results? If you're doing it in house without publishing the results so that you can determine the best db for your needs, would it run foul of the TOC? Would the vendors even know you're doing it?
- aloknnikhil 9y agoMeanwhile, Aurora on AWS has an explicit performance assessment guide https://d0.awsstatic.com/product-marketing/Aurora/RDS_Aurora_Performance_Assessment_Benchmarking_v1-2.pdf https://d0.awsstatic.com/product-marketing/Aurora/RDS_Aurora... With Oracle going all in on cloud, this mindset of Larry surely doesn't bode well?
- znpy 9y agoI hadn't a chance to read Oracle's or SQL Server's license, but one thing is not clear to me: is the used forbidden from performing benchmarks or from publishing them?