5 ms·
The difference between this and Windows RT is that this will emulate an x86 chip to allow you to run apps compiled for Intel.
by LeoPanthera 9y ago
The difference between this and Windows RT is that this will emulate an x86 chip to allow you to run apps compiled for Intel.
- asniper 9y agoso I guess AMD compiled apps don't work? :P
- microcolonel 9y agoYeah, AMD64 applications don't yet work on this, only Intel ones. I think the stuff for a standard AMD64 machine isn't quite yet out of patent.
- yuhong 9y agoThe Intel patents for up to SSE2 should expire soon, and hopefully the AMD64 patents should be licenseable from AMD (if they are interested in that). I would not be surprised if this already emulates up to SSE2, given the likely release date and the fact that recent versions of MSVC already enable /arch:SSE2 by default.
- microcolonel 9y ago> I would not be surprised if this already emulates up to SSE2, given the likely release date. Yeah, even if they could be sued, they could settle for a couple years damages max, or quite possibly win, since they're doing DBT (no different from QEMU or loads of other x86 + SSE2 emulators).
- beagle3 9y agothough it's worth remembering that QEMU developers do not have the deep pockets that MS has -- and it is the depth of the pockets, rather than the (alleged) violation that drives law suits and threats.
- e1ven 9y agoSomewhat amusingly, it provides one of the best reasons to continue to provide an x86 version of apps, rather than going 64-bit only.
- jimrandomh 9y agoI don't see any mention of x86_64/AMD64 in the article. I would expect a version of Windows which can't run x86_64 apps to result in a lot of nasty compatibility surprises--it's been awhile since developers had to support 32-bit-only hardware--so I'd expect Microsoft to support it if at all possible.
- yuhong 9y agoOn the other hand, this is mostly for legacy desktop apps, not server apps or the like.
- niftich 9y agoYou're right, the posted Anandtech article does not mention x86_64; however, other prior and recent coverage of this topic does confirm that x86_64 is not supported, such as this Ars Technica article [1] from the same day. [1] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/12/hp-asus-announce-first-windows-10-arm-pcs-20-hour-battery-life-gigabit-lte/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/12/hp-asus-announce-fir...
- microcolonel 9y agoI think most Windows applications which are truly 64-bit only are either too large to run on a machine like this, or likely to be rebuilt for AArch64. For the time being, I think IA-32 support is enough to tide them over, and it has the benefit of being thoroughly out of patent (except some fairly common extensions, like SSE2, which will expire soon).
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoThere's still a lot of Windows devices that run x86 Windows, and new devices still ship with it, mostly low-memory or low-disk-space devices. Thus apps need to support it.
- mrpippy 9y agoThere's no support for x86_64 binaries. Windows 10 is still available in 32-bit editions and almost all apps are still available for 32-bit, so I don't think this is a big issue. I assume any kernel drivers will need to be compiled for ARM64 though. This might not help corporate adoption--VPN client, 3rd party anti-virus/full disk encryption, etc. Also one thing that is x86-64 only is WSL, the Windows Subsystem for Linux.
- adamjcook 9y agoI wonder how Microsoft eventually dealt with this: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/06/intel-fires-warning-shots-at-microsoft-claims-x86-emulation-is-a-patent-minefield/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/06/intel... Intel seemed to indicate at the time that it was really interested in any licensing around the x86 ISA.
- rbanffy 9y ago"It's a nice market you have with high-margin enthusiast desktop CPU's, Intel. It'd be a shame if Windows stopped supporting them"
- loeg 9y agoWindows cannot possibly cut support for x86.
- londons_explore 9y agoIt could cut support for the highest end x86 CPU's in desktop machines (ie. non-server). That would then make those CPU's un-sellable, since they're pretty much all used for gaming. Obviously, they wouldn't say that - the way to market that is to release 'Windows Gamers edition', which costs way more and 'unlocks' the power in the latest CPU's. When in fact, non 'game edition' windows versions simply leave some cores disabled or sleep some of the time when they detect a 'too fast' CPU and a fullscreen game running...
- godzillabrennus 9y agoAt some point I'd like to believe people would just stop paying Microsoft tax to play computer games... Then I remember people pay tons of cash for their rigs that are obsolete within two years anyway. Seems like a lucrative practice for Microsoft and one they should embrace, extend and extinguish.
- 9y ago
- alkonaut 9y agoIs it a "full" windows, or a "modern windows" like RT was? I.e. does it run Win32/x86 apps or just the UWP/Store ones?
- noveltyaccount 9y agoBoth. Comes with "S," which only runs store apps, but can be upgraded to Pro, which runs everything.
- ramijames 9y agoI guess the question I have is: how fast can it run everything?
- bduerst 9y agoIs there a performance hit because you're emulating x86? If so, has anyone measured it?
- MBCook 9y agoAlmost certainly. There may be small corner cases where the translated code is faster but I’m sure they’re the exception. That said, people may not care. ARM can be very fast. My iPad is faster than many low end laptops. So you get in the situation where a low cost laptop with ARM may be as fast or faster going through emulation than a low end Intel chip from 4-6 years ago while providing WAY more battery life. People may be willing to make that trade. I’m guessing it’s not 20% speed on most tasks. Probably 80%+, depending on the age and power of the Intel chip.
- beagle3 9y agoI think 20% is more likely than 80% for raw compute tasks - ARMs are competitive with intel in performance/watt, but are not much better at it (and definitely are not competitive yet in absolute performance). People are going to buy it for the 20-hour battery, and then run the CPU at 100% to run emulation which will eat the battery in 3 hours. However, most people run a small selection of programs most of the time (web browser, word, excel, outlook), which will likely have an ARM native version sooner than later, and the long tail of programs they must have are often not compute intensive, and spend 85% of their time in the OS doing graphics/io which are native. So overall, even if the CPU emulation is 20% speed, the overall feel is likely going to be 80% or better for most people. Gamers shouldn't hold their breath though.
- djsumdog 9y agoEventually you'll see most people just release ARM versions. Look at Apple/Rosetta.
- katastic 9y agoMy most important difference is whether Microsoft is going to stop supporting it a couple years after selling it like they did with Windows RT--leaving their customers with thousands of dollars of useless, unsupported machines. I still can't believe they did that. Discontinuing software is one thing--you can find replacements. But discontinuing Surface RT tablets OS right after selling them is insulting and I will not be recommending them to my clients until Microsoft proves it will actually provide a long-term platform.