21 ms·
There is definitely an education bubble. It's way too easy to get money for college. You hear a lot of stories about the increasing costs of college and crush
by jedberg 9y ago
There is definitely an education bubble. It's way too easy to get money for college. You hear a lot of stories about the increasing costs of college and crushing debt on graduation, but you don't hear a lot of stories of "I wanted to go to college but couldn't get a loan". Almost everyone gets approved, regardless of their future ability to pay it back.
We need a fundamental shift in the way college is paid for. Some (many?) would like to see a government funded system, others would like to see the removal of subsidized loans to bring prices back down (and leaving many unable to afford college in its wake).
Another solution is to let you go to school for free and then pay a percent of all your future earnings back to your college, or at least into a pool that pays for the next generation's college. Of course with that system, colleges would bias towards people who are pursuing profitable majors, so you'd probably see a lot more STEM degrees and a lot fewer of everything else, until it got oversaturated, but there is a very long lead time between "too many degrees" and "no one studies this anymore".
In other words, the fundamental problem is that we tell kids that college is the only path, creating insanely high demand for the product, when in reality there would be plenty of people much better served learning a trade or skill instead of four years doing something hate for a useless degree they'll never use.
- yegle 9y agoI thought the point of student loan is to grant it to anyone regardless of if they can repay? If the loan is granted by looking at the student's future potential to repay, students would prefer majors/colleges with higher chance of getting a student loan.
- jartelt 9y agoIf the word "loan" is in the name of the financial product, you are expected to repay. At some point we need to be upfront with high school graduate and tell them it is a bad idea to go study art history at a $40k a year no-name private college.
- sorrymate 9y agoIf the choice is between not going to college vs. earning a degree, statistically you earn more simply by having a college degree, regardless of the major. Bachelor Degree holders, on average, earn a million dollars more during their life time than those who only have a high school diploma. Even if you are accounting for lost earning potential, cost of tuition, supplies etc... your still talking about hundreds of thousands of dollars more earned than if you were to not achieve a degree. If you are talking in relation to going to university for a STEM degree vs. going to school for art history, you could certainly argue that STEM will will always make more. But I would still recommend young people go to school over not. Even if it is something 'useless'. Either way you slice it, the data indicates that encouraging youth to go to college is still worth it. Even with how expensive college is. Median Lifetime Earnings: https://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2011/collegepayoff.pdf https://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2011/c... Cost of School and Lost Earnings vs High School Grad: https://trends.collegeboard.org/sites/default/files/education-pays-2016-full-report.pdf https://trends.collegeboard.org/sites/default/files/educatio... BLS on Pay by Education https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2015/more-education-still-means-more-pay-in-2014.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2015/more-education-still-means...
- jartelt 9y agoTotally agree. If they want to do so, I would certainly recommend a young person get a degree regardless of whether it is STEM or not. I just wouldn't give someone a huge loan to study a low earning major at a expensive private college. That is just setting them up for a mountain of debt they are unlikely to be able to pay off.
- goialoq 9y agoThat's not true at all. A loan has a priced in risk of default. The National Mortgage Lenders Association defaulted on their mortgage. Many business and corporations, large and small, go bankrupt and discharge debts. Only individual consumers get trapped in non-dischargable debt.
- gozur88 9y ago>I thought the point of student loan is to grant it to anyone regardless of if they can repay? No, the student is supposed to pay back his loan regardless of major. The reason we have student loans is under the traditional credit system someone without a job and a credit history isn't going to get a loan at all.
- umbrellathorn 9y ago> for a useless degree they'll never use I went to school for such a degree. While I don't use it in my day to day now, I still consider it priceless. There's some inherent value added to a person who pursues to study a bit of humanities, history, philosophy and art in college apart from their major. Scholarly work really helps shape the way you look at life for the better. Part of this is that you really understand why you need to trust academic work for general human advancement. We have too many people thinking it's okay to discredit scientists and scholars because they don't understand how research works.
- cloakandswagger 9y ago> We have too many people thinking it's okay to discredit scientists and scholars because they don't understand how research works. And a similar number of people who elevate science to the level of religion, marching in its name and developing a brand of hero worship for scientists when they too know nothing at all about the scientific process. Both are forms of anti-intellectualism that are growing in our polarized political environment.
- smallnamespace 9y agoI've seen this form of scientism playing out frequently on Reddit and other Internet forums lately. Discussion will be about some piece of controversial research, e.g. GMOs or vaccines. People who want to discuss the merits of the research are shouted down by what I can only describe as 'science fanbois' -- anything that is 'against science' must be wrong. They're missing the inherent tension in science between a received body of knowledge and the skepticism it takes to produce new knowledge.
- 0xfeba 9y ago> Some piece of controversial research, e.g. GMOs or vaccines Who or what determines what is controversial? To me, vaccines are not controversial at all. You can pick and choose specific ones to argue about, but the concept of vaccines is literally proven, beyond a doubt. As for GMOs, there's a lot more room but even still, the fundamentals are nothing controversial. This is also proven in pretty much anything you can buy in a grocery store today.
- ChuckMcM 9y ago"It's way too easy to get money for college." I would go a bit further and say it is way to easy to get money for bad college. Looking at some of the ways for-profit colleges pitch pretty worthless degrees as a "path to higher pay" and simultaneously lay down the student loan application reminds me of the mortgage refinance market of 2007.
- danaliv 9y ago> Some (many?) would like to see a government funded system Depending on how the debt situation falls out, we might already have that. :-\
- InitialLastName 9y agoYou're being sardonic, but socialism-by-bailout seems like an interesting experiment. Next, we automatically bail out everyone with medical debt -> universal healthcare!
- berbec 9y agoI detected slight sarcasm, but you may be more right than you know. We'll see in 3 years, or less (please)
- InitialLastName 9y agoNo sarcasm. I suspect this kind of bureaucratic sideloading might be the only way to get these changes done. One further: if the Fed starts an index fund and distributes the dividends equally to the American people, do we suddenly have UBI tied to the national GDP? If that index fund gets large enough that it owns a significant portion of the economy, do we have distributed control of the means of production?
- ionised 9y agoWe already had that when the banks were bailed out. Socialise the losses, privatise the profits.
- fredgrott 9y agomy State, Indian does a partial free-2 year degree program in that the AP courses taken in HS qualify as a full 2-year degree if you take enough of them in HS and pass the exams..no college tuition payment required
- jedberg 9y agoThat's an interesting solution to the problem of state funding. I wonder if they've done any studies on the educational effectiveness of the program.
- jobu 9y ago> for a useless degree they'll never use Another part of the problem is that there's really no such thing as a useless degree. A person may never use what they learned from that degree, but the fact that they were able to earn a degree is still used by employers as a bar to judge potential employees.
- heywot 9y agoWhich is a really frustrating thing. I have family members who didn't go to college who could not pursue certain careers (or, struggled to advance their careers) because they don't have piece of paper - even if it had nothing to do with the career itself. In tech it has become less of an issue but I would love to see this go away for everyone. Being able to get a four year degree does not signal that a potential employee is better than someone that doesn't. Especially the way higher education has gone in my lifetime.
- greedo 9y agoNot sure it's less of an issue in tech now. I got into the field when a degree wasn't needed (late 90's), just a pulse. Now it would be hard to get an entry level job without one, at least at my company.
- legitster 9y agoIt's more of a capacity problem. The demand for four year degrees has increased exponentially, but there hasn't really been any increase in accredited colleges. So public money is being sucked up in the bidding war for open seats.
- murph-almighty 9y ago> you'd probably see a lot more STEM degrees and a lot fewer of everything else I honestly think art schools are going to start running into problems convincing people it's a good idea to pay 60k a year for minimal ROI. My cousin wants to go into stage drama, and I don't want to tell her to not pursue her dream, but I think it's a lot to ask her to put herself in debt for years for a piece of paper that says she can act. FWIW I majored in ECE, got a job as a software engineer with 100k salary plus benefits, and I'm ~140k in debt. I definitely overpaid, but my salary gives me a way out. People who came from my alma mater who majored in drama can't say the same.
- JonFish85 9y ago> People who came from my alma mater who majored in drama can't say the same. Don't worry, your salary gives them a way out too. And I'm not just saying that to be snarky, I think it's very likely what will end up happening: you'll end up paying for their poor choices one way or another. If it's not directly via taxes to pay off their student loans, it'll fund their retirement.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Don't worry, your salary gives them a way out too. And I'm not just saying that to be snarky, I think it's very likely what will end up happening: you'll end up paying for their poor choices one way or another. If it's not directly via taxes to pay off their student loans, it'll fund their retirement. Social Security benefits, without any other retirement savings, puts you right around poverty level. I would not consider that "retirement". Being a software engineer, who makes more than many other professions, doesn't automatically make you better for doing so. It just means you've optimized for a specific system. Congrats! The world still needs plenty of professions where the pay sucks and college is required (teachers, civil engineers, LPNs), that are arguably far more useful/noble/whatever you want to call real value. Consider that when you're sending your kid(s) off to school, crossing a bridge on your way to work, or are in the hospital being cared for.
- JonFish85 9y ago
- hfourm 9y agoTruthfully, depending on your definition of majority, most college students ARE already pursuing more profitable majors. https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d16/tables/dt16_322.10.asp?current=yes https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d16/tables/dt16_322.10.a... The "underwater basketweaving" so to say, may be at most 10-15% of current college graduates. I think the solution lies more with reducing the cost of college, open source textbooks, more elearning, etc. Regardless of government funding vs subsidized loans, the cat is already out of the hat on a lot of price increases around campuses nation wide. It isn't going to be just as easy to just change the funding source. I also sympathize with the trade school argument, but I don't think everyone going to college is a bad idea by any means.
- jedberg 9y agoYou could do all those cost reduction things, but until you either decrease demand or decrease the supply of money, costs will never go down -- profits will just go up.
- hfourm 9y agoThat is overly generic and not necessarily true.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoUnless the public were given the means to more directly assert control over its public universities.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoPsychology is effectively today's basket weaving. There is an excess number of students receiving those degrees with no intent to work in the field. It's widely perceived as an "easy" degree which makes it worthless unless you continue on and make it into the limited space for a graduate program.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoPsychology is a superb background for both marketing and design. Possibly better than a marketing or design undergrad. It’s also a great lead-in to an MBA. Heck, I think it’s put you in good stead to get finance jobs. Have you studied psych before? I got a minor with my CS undergrad and all my psych classes were invaluable.
- godelski 9y agoThe problem I really see is that we've dug ourselves a big hole. The safety net created for the banks were done to ensure that everyone could get a loan. Banks were "worried" that people would default on their student loans and run away with the money, even though this hasn't happened or is really rare. There was an unfortunate side effect that this incentivized banks to give out riskier loans. Couple that with telling everyone to go to college, kids that don't know what they want to do, and schools that are also seeking a profit, and you get a pretty messed up system. The unfortunate part about this, is that I believe that if you remove the protections on the loans, many students now WILL default, because they have too much debt and are incentivized to do so, if they are one of the larger loan carriers. I'd say "bite the bullet, and that's what banks get for giving out risky loans" but we know that's not going to play out that way, especially since the gov owns a fair portion. Making tuition free is nice, but the generation that took out loans isn't helped AND this does not reduce the college price problem. The price was inflated and there is no reason for them to decrease it. Kind of a parallel to health care here. That's the cost. I like this idea, even if I have to pay back my large loans, but I think the fundamental price issue also needs to be solved. Giving a portion of your earnings is a decent method, but you already bring up the problem with that. And this also doesn't solve the price problem, in fact it encourages the price to keep going up. (We can even tangent into how schools are over charging gov for research, but I'll leave that for another comment) Whatever we do, somebody is going to lose. And that's the problem with bubbles. We need to, as a society and government, decide who is going to lose. Problem is I think the majority of people think the banks [gov] should lose, for giving out such risky loans. But I don't think many politicians would agree. I wonder what the economists say.
- jdmichal 9y ago> I'd say "bite the bullet, and that's what banks get for giving out risky loans" but we know that's not going to play out that way, especially since the gov owns a fair portion. > Making tuition free is nice... I think it's funny that you have these two ideas so close together... The government owning most of the loans provides a very easy path to enabling free college retroactively: extinguish all the loans. The government doesn't have a profit incentive, so there's no reason that such a path should not be reasonable.
- jackweirdy 9y ago> Another solution is to let you go to school for free and then pay a percent of all your future earnings back to your college, or at least into a pool that pays for the next generation's college. We could call it income tax :)
- crocal 9y agoNah, let’s find some flashy Valley name for the concept and disrupt the market.
- dweekly 9y agoPersonalized Education ICOs. Everyone gets their own token redeemable for a portion of lifetime earnings and tradable on an exchange. Traders can go long on an investment or short you if they forsee the market digesting an event decreasing your likely lifetime earnings.
- gknoy 9y agoYou might enjoy (or have already read ;)) "The Incorporated Man", a fiction novel which has this basic premise: Everyone's a minority shareholder in their own personal corporation. (except the main character). It's pretty well written, and both the main character and the antagonist have points of view which make sense, IMO.
- FLUX-YOU 9y agoILOs - Initial Life Offerings
- was_boring 9y agoyes, and make sure to include a blockchain.
- julien421 9y agoActually, it is already happening: holberton school, make school, lambda school, etc... :)
- 9y ago
- username223 9y ago> ...four years doing something hate for a useless degree they'll never use. Or 4-5 years getting a piece of paper saying "Computer Science" when they can't do the work, because society says "CS makes money" and the CS department is happy to take it. If people with only a high school degree can't make a living, we need to either make college free, or make companies pay for it.
- jMyles 9y ago> learning a trade or skill instead of four years doing something hate for a useless degree they'll never use. The two aren't mutually exclusive. In a compassionate society, we'll encourage people to pursue art or music or mathematics or dance and plumbing or auto repair. There are enough educational resources to go around; our economy just hasn't found the right shape to make good use of them.
- conductr 9y agoI chose to take 6 years, held a job, paid my own tuition/rent/expenses, graduated with no debt. For me the reduced risk (debt) outweighed the opportunity cost (time). I've always been prideful about money and don't like people paying for my stuff. So I wouldn't ask my parents to pay or co-sign, so I basically couldn't get a loan given those constraints (at the time, late 90s into early 00s).
- martin_bech 9y agoWe have a system like that. Its called taxes and free education. Everyone is offered free college education, including basic living expenses. In return everyone pays a litle more in taxes. And those who choose college, often earn more, and then pay more in taxes. (Im from Denmark)
- dv_dt 9y agoAnd, I would think that running the system that way is actually cheaper and more efficient than the US way where we seem to be moving towards individually accounting for every dollar of education for payback - all while the overall system spirals out of cost controls. It's much simpler to supply gov't budgets direct to public schools with oversight for spending. Vs open loans which little cost accountability. (well accountability via students for which this is the most extensive, longest term, financially complex, with highly variable ROI purchase they will have made in their life so far...)
- martin_bech 9y agoIf you think about it, there is absolutely no reason, for education beeing expensive, if priced by actual cost (books, materiel, professors) instead of beeing priced by perceived value (ie. What will my future earnings be, what will my financing look like, are my parents paying etc.)
- dv_dt 9y agoI've never thought of it exactly that way - but it makes a lot of sense. One way to summarize that idea is "cost-of-goods" public budgeting are much more efficient to run vs "value-of-education" priced student loans.
- sol_remmy 9y agoMaybe you should focus on not falling too far behind Finland, the Netherlands and Sweden first. I don't think I've ever heard of a Danish tech company. Even tiny Iceland has EVE Online.
- learc83 9y ago>Another solution is to let you go to school for free and then pay a percent of all your future earnings back to your college, or at least in to a pool that pays for the next generation's college. We basically already have that system. If you get federal loans (which most people who take out loans do--90% of all loan disbursements) you can sign up for an income based repayment plan. You pay back 10% of your disposable income (income over 1.5x the federal poverty limit), for 20 years. If you make less than 1.5x the poverty limit, you pay nothing.
- mcfunk 9y agoAbsent public service loan forgiveness (which we may very well soon be, if Republicans in Congress get their way), the number is actually 30 years and the forgiven amount is taxable income. Additionally, income-based plans often result in payments that don't even cover interest, so the debt continues to pile up quickly. Meaningfully different from the original suggestion.
- learc83 9y ago>the number is actually 30 years No. It's 20 years. https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/understand/plans/income-driven https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/repay-loans/understand/plans/in... >the forgiven amount is taxable income. It's only taxable up to the point of solvency. If you have a sizeable loan forgiven and you haven't made enough money to pay it over 20 years, you likely won't have enough assets to end up owing very much. Also it's very likely congress will intervene in 10-15 years or so when a huge percentage of voters have this problem. >income-based plans often result in payments that don't even cover interest, so the debt continues to pile up quickly. If that's the case, you will never pay it off and we're back to debt cancellation after 20 years.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Veratyr 9y ago> Another solution is to let you go to school for free and then pay a percent of all your future earnings In Australia we have a system somewhere between this and a loan. You go to (heavily subsidized) university, tuition is paid for by the government with an automatic interest free loan. Once you earn above a particular (somewhat generous) threshold, your employer automatically starts taking a percentage of your income (depends on income) and pays it towards the loan. There's no interest but the loan amount is indexed against inflation. I graduated from one of the country's top universities with $24k AUD (~$18k USD) debt to the government and paid it all off early voluntarily. It used to be that voluntary payments got you a 5% bonus but that's gone now.
- was_boring 9y agoquestion: why would you pay it off early? money (generally) gets cheaper over time and if interest is lower then inflation there is no reason to pay it off early as the debt becomes cheaper every year.
- Veratyr 9y agoI no longer live in Australia and as long as you have this debt, you're required to file an Australian tax return. I paid it off to get rid of that hassle. Also it used to be that voluntary payments got you a discount.
- stephen_g 9y agoMost people don't - they just pay the minimum required out of their pay every year once they've reached the threshold. But getting rid of it does make it easier to borrow more money for a house, etc.
- bobsman123 9y agoWe have that in the US as well. And you do have interest - variable rate tracking inflation. In the US, the minimum payment is $0 and forgiveness happens at 20 or 25 years.
- bradleyjg 9y ago> There is definitely an education bubble. It can't really be a bubble because there are no assets to be bid up in a run away cycle or that can have a sudden collapse. Bloomberg tells you what you need to know in the article but doesn't do it right upfront. The overwhelming majority of this debt is held or guaranteed by the federal government. A bubble is one way to get malinvestment, but it isn't the only one. Here we have malinvestment but no bubble.
- AceJohnny2 9y ago> Almost everyone gets approved, regardless of their future ability to pay it back. Because student loans are the one kind of debt that can stick through bankruptcy, so it's a great investment!
- a2tech 9y agoI wanted to go to college, but couldn't get a loan. Its easy for people who's parents already participate fully in the credit market-but for people like myself who's parents are poor and don't use credit for anything, it wasn't an option.
- treyfitty 9y agoMy parents were poor. I went to school for dirt cheap at a state school. My cousin went to Princeton for free because his parents didn’t make enough income (the income limit was quite generous, at less than $100k per household in NY). Being poor, in hindsight, was a blessing.
- rxhernandez 9y ago>but you don't hear a lot of stories of "I wanted to go to college but couldn't get a loan". I suspect that it's either because you're not listening or people aren't talking about it. I had 3 years of on the job engineering experience and an established, good credit history when I got denied a loan for my last year of undergrad at a state school. Mind you this was fairly recently and my only loan for school I applied for ever. I could be the freak accident but it doesn't seem all that probable.
- muninn_ 9y agoSo did you drop out?
- moultano 9y agoThere's a good midpoint of those two. Cap student loan payments at some fraction of your income for some fraction of your life. Those seem like reasonable restrictions for a loan that isn't dischargeable by bankruptcy.
- jotjotzzz 9y agoMake student loans dischargeable under bankruptcy like any other loans, including corporate loans. Then we'll see big changes. But since we punish the young, by not letting them off the hook, these loan sharks will continue to bite.
- clairity 9y agoyou describe a classic misattribution problem with the demand for higher ed. people use "college" as a synonym for "successful life", but those two things only have a loose correlation, which is only getting weaker with the swell of people getting degrees that they can't wield effectively. we all want a successful life, and being good little free-market capitalists, we eagerly buy into the story that we can achieve success by simply buying a degree (hey, i bought three of 'em!) and letting the rest play out like our wildest dreams. but of course it doesn't work that way because we didn't scrutinize the winding path between degree and successful life, because the shortcut between those two things doesn't actually exist (at least not any more). colleges and universities have done a good job extracting most, if not all, of the value out of the higher education market, with the help of government distortions (guaranteed interest, unbankruptable debt). it's time to put to bed the idea that a degree equals success (it's also time to get rid of those market distortions). a few of us will get lucky of course, but pretty much everyone will need to create success the old-fashioned way: by working hard for it.
- Celarnor 9y ago> ... but you don't hear a lot of stories of "I wanted to go to college but couldn't get a loan". Almost everyone gets approved, regardless of their future ability to pay it back. This is absolutely not the case. Student loans have caps and they're incredibly easy to hit, especially if you go to a 5-year school where you're expected to pay tuition while doing 6-month internship blocks. Lots of people I knew in college (myself included) had to drop out in the first 2 quarters of year 5 because they couldn't get enough money to finish. Edit: Just checked to see what the cap was at these days. Back when I was in school, the unsubsidized loan max was 27k. Now its 31k. https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/types/loans/subsidized-unsubsidized#how-much https://studentaid.ed.gov/sa/types/loans/subsidized-unsubsid...
- etskinner 9y agoI think the point of the parent comment was to say that people never get denied because of credit history, choice of major, etc. in the way that they might be denied for a credit card.
- Florin_Andrei 9y ago> There is definitely an education bubble. Right, and people in poor countries stealing money to feed themselves is a "food bubble", with the solution being a reduction in food consumption. How come there is no "education bubble" in countries where college is essentially free? That would be guaranteed to create the biggest bubble of all.
- jpao79 9y ago>> Another solution is to let you go to school for free and then pay a percent of all your future earnings back to your college, or at least into a pool that pays for the next generation's college. PBSNewsHour did a piece on this concept: Purdue invests in students’ futures with new model of financing https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/purdue-invests-students-futures-new-model-financing https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/purdue-invests-students-fu... "Unlike student debt, it shifts the burden — or the risk, I should say — entirely from the student to the investor." "That’s because the terms of the agreement, called an ISA, are made well before students launch their careers. So, even if a student ends up in a low-paying job, the pay-back percentage stays the same."
- muraiki 9y agoYou said: "...profitable majors, so you'd probably see a lot more STEM degrees and a lot fewer of everything else...". In terms of lifetime earnings, STEM is not necessarily a sure fire route: "'Students and parents have a pretty good idea of what majors pay the most, but they have a poor sense of the magnitude of the differences within the major,' said Douglas A. Webber, an associate professor of economics at Temple University who studies earnings by academic field. He points to one example: The top quarter of earners who majored in English make more over their lifetimes than the bottom quarter of chemical engineers. But what if you never make it to the top of the pay scale? Even English or history graduates who make just above the median lifetime earnings for their major do pretty well when compared to typical graduates in business or a STEM field." See https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/03/education/edlife/choosing-a-college-major.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/03/education/edlife/choosing...
- mywittyname 9y agoThat article seems to contradict itself. They claim the pay difference is not big between STEM and liberal arts, then goes on to present data that clearly shows there's a big pay difference. But then goes onto say the reason for the gender wage gap is not enough women choose STEM majors.
- wang_li 9y ago> It's way too easy to get money for college. It'd be more correct to say that it's way too easy to get money while at college. An awful lot of college students believe that being in college means that they have a middle class lifestyle. It is cliche, but in my day (1989-1993) students were poor. You lived in a dormitory and ate in a cafeteria. Maybe you'd go to a bar once a month. And 99% of the time you walked everywhere. I think easy of approvals for student loans combined with the 2008 recession and slow recovery led to a lot of people finding that student loans were a source of income rather than a way to pay for college.
- goialoq 9y agoAffordable education is easy to get: state and local public college. The only problem is young people making poor choices (which is partially the fault of elders and predators) and taking out large loans to attend overpriced (for the value) schools/programs.
- sempron64 9y agoHave you read The Unincorporated Man? It's a sci-fi novel about a society like the one you're suggesting, where "investors" in humans such as parents and educators own shares in the person's future earnings. The novel/series casts this in various lights, mostly negative but with undeniable fairness and benefits. One question is where these shareholder cross the line into slaveowners. What is a reasonable rate of taxation? What can be reasonably demanded from the indebted?
- joshshifman 9y agoI would disagree that it is way too easy to get money for college. I co-founded a company that is aimed at giving loans to students who are often denied credit in the traditional market, primarily because they lack credit worthy cosigners. This amounts to about 2m students every year.
- bobsman123 9y agoWe already have this system. There are income based repayment plans that cap and hire forgiveness at 20 years for undergrad or 25 for graduate. It’s 10% of AGI annually for Revised pay as you earn. Please don’t call for more government when we already have those solutions.
- drngdds 9y agoCollege demand is insanely high because of education inflation. Employers require a college degree for most white-collar jobs. I think a better solution would be to rework college. It doesn't make sense that you need a four-year degree including a bunch of irrelevant classes to get your foot in the door at any white collar job. The standard for higher education should be probably leaner and more focused on useful skills for a particular area. And if hiring was based more on objective tests of knowledge and ability, you wouldn't have as many people spending lots of money to go to prestigious universities. (I don't know how or if any of this could be accomplished.)
- ReinholdNiebuhr 9y agoI tend to lean libertarian, so that's my bias. I'll be upfront with that. That said, I'd be okay eliminating student loans both in government and even in private markets. Like private personal loans take over. I think it would work out over time. I can't speak for the overall society, but I know personally I noticed locally amongst friends and family that when student loans became more widespread under Obama local private companies stopped paying for their employers to get nursing degrees, or other degrees. My sister got her RN and Masters degree through a program at the hospital she worked at, starting as a receptionist when 16. I knew someone who was a dishwasher at a michelin star restaurant and they paid for his culinary degree and worked to develop him. He's running his own joint now. It seems now not many employers are willing to pay the bill for education as the government is there to do that for them. I can't say this is perfect.. it seems any way you cut it people are going to get thrown under the bus. Personally I paid upfront for college after years of working various jobs, I cherished every class a whole lot more I feel. Sure it's history and political science that I majored in, degrees many would view as useless. I think said studies are more vaulable when you're older, after you start building a life/career as they can certainly add compliment to one's understanding of reality. That said, I'm not advocating people not go into said fields at a younger age, it's a tricky issue. I know I would have hated studying STEM related stuff when younger and even when I went to college at an older age. Now I'm working on aquaculture stuff.. go figure.
- aplummer 9y agoThis would exclude so many smart kids from college. People who work a ton of jobs but support disabled family members for example. > “it seems any way you cut it people are going to get thrown under the bus.” Incorrect, every other western country at least has a pretty workable system.
- ReinholdNiebuhr 9y ago"people are going to get thrown under the bus", can include rich being over taxed to pay for free college for the masses. My statement was meant to be broad in that someone is going to get screwed, rich or poor.
- QML 9y ago> instead of four years doing something hate for a useless degree they'll never use I think this comment here points to the issue of colleges -- most people have no clue what major they want to be or what type of career they want to pursue. The result is that if they are pushed into a corner they do not want to be in, money would be spent and nothing of value would be gained. What should be happening before college or at the earlier levels is people taking classes that allow them to explore but also teach them transferable skills. Ideally, this is where G.E.'s should've worked. However, at the current state, they're just useless extra units that seemed be layed onto college students in order to keep them in school longer, and thus pay more tuition. In addition, most of the things they teach are not transferable - they're too specific / boring and after a semester, it's all forgotten. Instead, the G.E. curriculum should focus on knowledge shared by every field, or that could be used in any career -- logic, data science, ethics, etc. An improvement like this could justify the high-cost of a college education.
- blang 9y agoSome left leaning think tanks have tried to get this passed under the name "Pay it forward". I think Vermont got the furthest along, but does not seem like it has gotten much traction recently. One of the problems with this legislation (this is now totally my opinion), is that it only addressed the funding side of things and not the spending side.
- anthmcc 9y ago> Another solution is to let you go to school for free and then pay a percent of all your future earnings back to your college That sounds horrendously expensive and unfair. Your major is in yarn and you don't make any money? oh well that's fine. You CS major, pay through the nose.
- atom-morgan 9y ago> Another solution is to let you go to school for free and then pay a percent of all your future earnings back to your college This is just another way of wording how you're paying your debt and who you're paying it to.
- akhilcacharya 9y agoI'm still not convinced of the efficacy of the federal government guaranteeing loans to expensive private institutions (especially for-profit schools that prey on returning veterans and the poor). Instead, I think that they should only guarantee loans for cheaper public schools or for a specific dollar amount.