9 ms·
I always find it interesting the big companies get the opportunity to make a deal. As a small business you would just go to jail probably. Certainly nobody woul
by maxxxxx 9y ago
I always find it interesting the big companies get the opportunity to make a deal. As a small business you would just go to jail probably. Certainly nobody would negotiate with you.
- aroch 9y agoAt least in the US, the IRS does negotiate with pretty much anyone who owes back taxes: https://www.irs.gov/payments/offer-in-compromise https://www.irs.gov/payments/offer-in-compromise
- maxxxxx 9y agoDo they actually negotiate the amount of tax to pay? I know they will negotiate on payment terms.
- throwaway613834 9y ago> Do they actually negotiate the amount of tax to pay? I know they will negotiate on payment terms. Confused, did you click the link at all? It literally answers your question right there at the beginning: > An offer in compromise allows you to settle your tax debt for less than the full amount you owe. [...] We generally approve an offer in compromise when the amount offered represents the most we can expect to collect within a reasonable period of time.
- maxxxxx 9y ago"We generally approve an offer in compromise when the amount offered represents the most we can expect to collect within a reasonable period of time." I read this and should have phrased more carefully. I think this applies to people who really can't pay whereas Apple just doesn't want to pay.
- collyw 9y agoExactly, Apple has loads of money, there is no reason they can't pay.
- donarb 9y agoDoesn’t matter how much money they have. No corporation will pay more than they are legally required. Apple believes they paid the correct amount (as Ireland never complained).
- valuearb 9y agoThey paid exactly as much as Ireland agreed to have them pay. Those $200B in bank deposits was a huge windfall for the country of Ireland, why would they want to tax it at all?
- gehwartzen 9y agoI think Apple can hire enough lawyers and accountants to drag their feet for the "within a reasonable period of time" portion to come into play regardless of ability to pay.
- charlesdm 9y agoNot based in the US, but due to general tax law complexities, tax authorities definitely negotiate over the specifics and interpretations of laws, as well as the amount payable (source: personal experience). Having a good lawyer from an established firm with an excellent name helps a lot as well. If you're small fish, don't be surprised if civil tax servants try to bullshit you on the law. Be willing to fight (and prove them wrong), or be eaten. On one particular case I'm aware of (friend of a friend), a seven figure tax sum was payable. They eventually settled everything for $25k because they weren't sure of their case.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoYes but pretty much none of the conditions or hardships that they are willing to compromise based on apply to Apple.
- harry8 9y agoJames Brown negotiated his way into jail, I guess. The man who literally stopped riots couldn't negotiate with the IRS his way out of the slammer.
- koliber 9y agoThe IRS does not treat people who willfully break the tax code lightly. This is called tax evasion. They treat situations of evasion differently than they treat differences in tax law interpretation. If you interpret the tax law differently from the IRS and there is an actual ambiguity (no sovereign citizen BS), if you do end up owing the tax you will still need to pay it, plus interest owed. If they prove that you evaded taxes, you need to pay the taxes, interest, and heavy penalties. There is also potential for jail. There are many lines that can be crossed and an accountant will help you navigate them. Tax avoidance is legal and encouraged. The IRS does not want you to pay taxes you do not owe. It may disagree with you at times, and there are avenues for resolving those disagreements. On the other hand, the IRS frowns down upon tax evasion and will hit hard.
- pm90 9y agoI don't think its that simple. If I've learned anything, criminal prosecution for financial crimes is pretty hard unless the crimes are pretty clear cut with convincing evidence. Most of the time, its much better to settle out of court, or negotiate an agreement, avoiding all the unpleasantness of an investigation (a win-win for both).
- maxxxxx 9y agoBut this works only if you can afford a lot of lawyers. Without that you don't get to negotiate much from my experience.
- CalChris 9y agoBeing able to afford an army of lawyers is central to Double Irish With A Dutch Sandwich. Smaller companies then have to compete on even terms with companies which have the resources this tax avoidance allows.
- rayiner 9y agoNo, having business operations and assets that are international in scope is central to such strategies. You can’t shift profits around different jurisdictions if all your revenue and assets are in Oklahoma. It just happens to be correlated with being able to afford an army of lawyers.
- duncanawoods 9y agoHardly. The international operations are often faked to facilitate the dodge e.g. IP licensing of branding from Cayman Island entities.
- pm90 9y agoYou don't need a lot of lawyers, but yeah I do see your point. Usually, if the nature of your crime is big enough to warrant the a federal/state prosecutors attention, you would most likely have the resources. If you're a 5 person company that accidentally committed a crime but they want to make an example out of you... yeah that can be tough.
- pacetherace 9y agoIt's pretty much, if we are persecuted, we will take our business somewhere else.
- AdmiralAsshat 9y agoIndeed, particularly (though not in this case) when the behavior is criminal. I would love to be able to rob a bank and then tell the court, "How about I give back half the money I stole from the bank, in exchange for no admission of guilt?"
- megy 9y agoThat is not true at all, small businesses and even individuals get a chance to negotiate, I have done so myself. You clearly have no experience in this matter, and the IRS may actually deliberately perpetrate that myth.
- agumonkey 9y agoprobably a distortion over legal actions being toyed with by deep pockets when smaller groups or individuals will get crushed
- arikr 9y agoTell us more?
- godelski 9y agoCould you please elaborate?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- khedoros1 9y agoI know that there are ads on the radio for law/accounting firms that will negotiate back taxes with the IRS for their customers. The theory being: If you haven't paid taxes in a decade, the IRS would rather have $1000 from you now than $0 from you ever. Someone that I know personally worked with an accountant in the past, who was able to negotiate a similar deal. I haven't ever been involved in it myself, so I'm not familiar with the details.
- markdown 9y agoEven on the principle? I've negotiated successfully to reduce or scrap penalties for things like late return lodgement or late payment, but never had them budge a dime on the tax owed.
- throwaway613834 9y ago
- rayiner 9y agoThe IRS negotiates all the time, as noted below. Moreover, in this case, Apple paid what Ireland asked. The EU came along and said Apple’s tax deal violated EU law. People don’t go to jail for doing what the IRS told them (or indeed, for having a reasonable but ultimately mistaken view of the law). The law has estoppel provisions that protect parties who rely on the IRS’s representations with respect to their taxes. (E.g. where they say a certain thing is okay then hangs their mind.) Plus, the IRS is a litigant like anyone else. If they think they might not win on their legal interpretation in tax court, they’ll settle to mitigate the risk.
- dmach 9y agoI think the EU ruled that Apple's deal violated Irish law, not EU law. The 0.005% effective tax rate should of been a fair bit closer to Ireland’s 12.5% corporate tax rate.
- valuearb 9y agoWhy? If a company has $200B it wants to deposit in your banks, what tax rate should it pay on the interest on that deposit? If Ireland said 12.5% (which is ridiculously high), Apple would have deposited it somewhere else, outside of the EU likely. Accepting bank deposits is a good thing, it didn't create any costs for the government of Ireland. On the contrary, it likely funded lots of economic development. Which is exactly why Ireland did and should have offered a near zero tax rate.
- throwaway2048 9y agoI'm not certain if you are just being obtuse, but the entire arrangement Apple (and other companies) have set up with Ireland, is to avoid taxation inside the EU entirely, that "money deposited" is counted as a loss for other subsidiaries inside the EU and paid as "licensing fees" to Apple Ireland.
- valuearb 9y agoNope, that's not true. Apple pays billions in income taxes in Britain, France and Germany. This is about where they deposit their after tax earnings.
- naturalgradient 9y agoIt's the old adage: "If you owe the bank $1000, you have a problem, if you owe it $1 billion, the bank has a problem".
- Paraesthetic 9y agoWeird someone else also stated this on the same thread and your comment got sunk even though it was the original.
- vecter 9y agoWhy is this still the top voted comment? It's clearly been rebuked as false.
- adrianm 9y agoThis is totally false. Not only can you negotiate with them, but you can also set up very reasonable repayment plans based on your ability to pay. I was surprised how easy it was to do this and how willing they are to work with you to actually resolve everything. It does take a couple of hours to get an agent on the phone, though.
- godelski 9y agoHow does this affect your credit? And can you, like large companies, only pay a portion of the tax you owe?
- adrianm 9y agoMy credit was unaffected. I objected to some of what they claimed I owed, and got them to throw out almost half. No interest and penalities.
- throwaway613834 9y agoBut how do you get them to finally give up? If they say you owe X and you say no, I owe Y, then does one of you have to threaten to go to court before expecting a settlement?
- mlindner 9y agoYour credit is not affected. Large companies do not "only pay a portion of the tax they owe". They are following the law and taking tax exemptions. You can do the same. Disagreements arise in the details of tax law in how various exemptions combine with each other, especially if you itemize deductions. You can't usually just say "I want to pay less", you have to have some reason why you think you owe less.
- Lazare 9y agoThat's totally false. The American IRS, at any rate, is extremely prone to negotiating, cutting deals, and agreeing to payment plans, over disputes large and small.
- mundo 9y ago"If you owe the bank $100 that's your problem. If you owe the bank $100 million, that's the bank's problem." The book "The Cheating of America" goes in to great detail about how this works (for individuals, not corporations) and it is pretty much guaranteed to make your blood boil. It goes through case studies on a number of specific people - how much they owed, what they did, what the government did, and how it all ended up - but the tl;dr is that it's fairly common for very rich people to end up negotiating a settlement for ~20-40% of their tax bill, 2-5 years after it was due. The quote I remember from it was something like "For those who have tax lawyers on retainer, the number at the bottom of a return is less like a final offer than an opening bid." 0: https://www.amazon.com/Cheating-America-Avoidance-Evasion-Billions/dp/038097682X https://www.amazon.com/Cheating-America-Avoidance-Evasion-Bi...
- throwaway613834 9y agoWow, that does make my blood boil. Is there any indication as to whether that assessment is still accurate, given that the book is from 2001? I could see this not being the case, given the digitization of money flow and how much easier it might be for the government to get your money, but then again I could see it still being the case.
- chii 9y agoAnd the sad fact is that the gov't can't hardline the tax code because the world is so connected that a rich person could move away. The World needs to have one unified tax code!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tim333 9y agoWell, the deal negotiated in the article is between Ireland and the EU, not Apple. Ireland had offered Apple a low tax rate to base there and the EU had argued it was illegally undercutting other EU countries.