11 ms·
From the article (not all contiguous but related): > A new frontier, uterus transplants are seen as a source of hope for women who cannot give birth because th
by koolba 9y ago
From the article (not all contiguous but related):
> A new frontier, uterus transplants are seen as a source of hope for women who cannot give birth because they were born without a uterus or had to have it removed because of cancer, other illness or complications from childbirth. Researchers estimate that in the United States, 50,000 women might be candidates.
> The transplants are meant to be temporary, left in place just long enough for a woman to have one or two children, and then removed so she can stop taking the immune-suppressing drugs needed to prevent organ rejection.
> The transplants are now experimental, with much of the cost covered by research funds. But they are expensive, and if they become part of medical practice, will probably cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. It is not clear that insurers will pay, and Dr. Testa acknowledged that many women who want the surgery will not be able to afford it.
While the science is amazing, why go this route rather than having a surrogate mother? I've heard the price of a surrogate is $30-50K.
- b4lancesh33t 9y agoMany, many women wish to carry their own children. Some want to do that this badly.
- cutcss 9y ago"Want" as in they are biologically wired to want to do so; hormones/evolution/etc.
- creep 9y agoIt may or may not be simply biological "wiring". Many women are fine with surrogates, and most surrogates are fine with carrying another woman's child without significant emotional attachment. Women who use surrogates want the child, the experience doesn't matter as much as a successful birth by any method. I think a big factor in the cases discussed in the article is that these women were told they would never ever have their own children. Unlike women who are "infertile" (which is usually just a measure of probability, and not a binary diagnosis), women who do not have a uterus obviously understand that there isn't a probability factor for getting pregnant. But then tell a woman with such a diagnosis that there is an experimental procedure that will allow her to fully experience what she had always been told was not possible. It is more for her than just wanting a baby at that point-- the procedure offers her everything she was told she could not have in terms of giving birth to a child.
- danharaj 9y agoLiterally all of your thoughts and feelings are biologically wired.
- solidsnack9000 9y agoSo many wants are biologically wired...
- nostromo123 9y agoBy the same token, you can just lay off having sex, since you are just wired biologically to want it ;-)
- chiefalchemist 9y agoLucky for them there are no enforced prerequisites (i.e., test and/or license) for becoming a parent. I don't doubt some level of that drive exists. What feels questionable is the sanity (?) of going to such extreme lengths to pursue it? As if there is a complete unawareness of the bigger picture.
- dcwca 9y agoIt’s not about sanity. Desire for reproduction is a biological imperative.
- fiblye 9y ago>I don't doubt some level of that drive exists. That's one hell of an understatement. It's only the primary driving force of all successful complex lifeforms. Living things that give preference to offspring other than their own die with zero remaining trace of their existence.
- toasterlovin 9y agoMaybe they meant the specific drive to carry a child, which, in my experience, not all women possess, even if they possess other drives that lead to successfully promulgating the next generation.
- astura 9y agoDrive to go through pregnancy and childbirth, not drive to reproduce.
- notyourwork 9y agoI'll go out on a limb and say if you aren't a female I don't think you are well positioned to judge a woman's judgement towards wanting her "own" baby versus using a surrogate or adopting. (I'm not a female so I have no point of view here.)
- ggg9990 9y agoSure, but I don't think any insurance should ever pay for this.
- b4lancesh33t 9y agoThis is an amazing story of progress, technology, and hope. Do you need to make it about what it costs to you, or can that discussion maybe wait for another context?
- ggg9990 9y agoIt can't really wait, because I bet someone wants this now, and shouldn't get it from public coffers.
- juicyfroot 9y agoAnd they will petition the government to tax you enough to make it happen. They are doing soon.
- nvahalik 9y ago> While the science is amazing, why go this route rather than having a surrogate mother? Or even just adoption. Adoption is far cheaper as well. There are plenty of reasons why people want their own biological children... but this seems like it carries a ton more risk with it. With complications from the transplant and heck even just childbirth.
- koolba 9y agoYes that's what I was trying to get at. The increased cost comes with significantly increased risk yet the same end result (a biological child).
- theli0nheart 9y agoIt's not the same end result. There are huge psychological issues that can come up with being the genetic mother to your child but having someone else carry them for you. Then you also have to figure out how (if?) the surrogate is involved in the child's life at all, how you explain to the child that someone else birthed them, etc. If you ever find yourself favoring one child over another, you'll always wonder if it's because it's not "your" baby. Basically, it's not as simple as just handing off an embryo to another person and 9 months later acting like nothing happened. There are huge ramifications to a decision like this that don't come with being the birth mother.
- thomasfedb 9y agoI’m always struck that people overestimate how difficult it is to explain things to children. I think people often project their own discomfort about talking about something onto the child that is hearing about whatever it is.
- ecopoesis 9y agoAdoptions in the US cost ~$40k, a lot more then the 10-15k for pregnancy.
- deleted 9y ago
- chiefalchemist 9y agoTaken a step further..why not adopt? While impressive it feels too much like a First World Problem. Aren't there any real problems this team could have solved?
- jroseattle 9y ago> While impressive it feels too much like a First World Problem. Aren't there any real problems this team could have solved? Talk to any couple who has had difficulty conceiving, and the humanity of this "first world problem" gets brought into perspective.
- mberning 9y agoExactly. How can you not understand a person’s desire to have a child of their own flesh and blood? That instinct and desire is such a deep part of our biology. The people asking must be very young or have some strang sociopathy.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoIntelligence and empathy may be inversely correlated. Diversity is helpful here
- MBCook 9y agoName a society on earth were people would prefer to adopt rather than go to this option if it was available to them. I don’t think this is an issue of the “American“ perspective or something like that.
- pessimizer 9y agoI'd bet most of them. People don't adopt because it is extremely difficult for some reason. Adopting probably costs more than an artificial uterus.
- 9y ago
- xenadu02 9y agoLet’s say you lost your testicles due to cancer, but there’s a new procedure that can grow new ones from your stem cells. It’s experimental and will cost $150,000. Before having your cancerous testes removed you stored sperm. Are you really surprised that some men who want to be fathers would choose to have the procedure rather than using their own previously stored sperm?
- robbrown451 9y agoYes I'm surprised. I'd want my testicles back for other reasons maybe, but if I had stored sperm I don't see why to have an expensive operation.
- icebraining 9y agoYes. In fact, much more surprised than in this case - I can at least see why would you want to have your baby grow inside you. Doing experimental surgery just so you can have fresh sperm seems absurd to me.
- justinjlynn 9y agoShit, I'd just want my balls back so I didn't have to take shots every few weeks.
- jschwartzi 9y agoAnd they'd be brand new, with none of the reduced output that comes from aging.
- kurthr 9y agoWell, yes I'm shocked that someone would go to great expense, risk their life, and use scarce research resources in a completely unnatural effort to do something "naturally"... but I shouldn't be. Because rule 34... someone will get off on it.
- tonyhb 9y ago
- anonymfus 9y agoSurrogate motherhood is a very traumatising experience.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoWhile the science is amazing, why go this route rather than having a surrogate mother? I've heard the price of a surrogate is $30-50K. That sounds rhetorical, but I'll bite anyway. Some women really long for the experience of childbirth. This may not be entirely psychological. Giving birth has significant impact on a woman's physiology. In addition to changing the shape of the hips and often other details like that, it leaves a woman a chimera for many years. Because her blood and the blood of the baby mix, she carries cells from the baby for many years afterwards. I have a genetic disorder. I have two biological sons. I was not diagnosed until they were about 12 and 14 years old, so I didn't (consciously) know about my condition at the time that I was making reproductive choices (though I did know I was always "sickly"). My first pregnancy significantly impacted how I eat. I removed a number of things from my diet to cope with my difficult pregnancy and many were never added back into my diet. I have reason to believe this did my health a lot of good. For example, it cured the chronic, sever vaginal yeast infections I had for more than two years prior that pregnancy. I never again had chronic, severe yeast infections. I have read up a bit on pregnancy-induced chimerism and talked a bit with people online about it and talked a fair amount with my sons. I have come to think that some women long for a baby because it can have a profound impact on a woman's body in ways we don't fully understand and perhaps sometimes that longing is rooted in some subconscious awareness that going through the process of carrying a child to term may alter their body in ways that are potentially for the best. This would be really hard to prove. We have no means to see what the biological outcome would be for the same woman with and without the pregnancy experience. But I am in remarkably good health for someone with my genetic disorder and I credit my two pregnancies with some portion of that fact.
- hiram112 9y agoThat is quite interesting to hear from a woman. Artificial wombs are coming. I was under the impression that women considered pregnancy as a burden which carries risks, is painful, causes all sorts of negative hormonal / physiological effects, etc. I think that artificial wombs will initially be challenged by feminist and conservative groups, but will end up being accepted, first with wealthy Western women, but eventually by everyone else. I have never considered that women might choose to carry a child, if they weren't required due to technological and scientific advances.
- blitmap 9y agoI think it is incredibly cool that we can essentially move a uterus from one woman to several others. Startup idea: Uterent™
- intopieces 9y agoCountries such as France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Portugal and Bulgaria prohibit all forms of surrogacy. So, this gives women in those countries the option of having a child legally.
- oh_sigh 9y agoWhat effect do immunosuppressors have on the fetus?
- sjg007 9y agoProbably well studied in pregnant moms with cancer or transplants. I would guess not a big impact as far as we know today. First there are cases where the maternal immune system attacks the fetus. Second the placenta generates immunosuppressants to prevent that, third, the fetus itself and the baby at birth does not have any innate immunity. In fact the baby relies on the moms immunity after birth.
- astura 9y agoCan you harvest(1) eggs from a woman without a uterus? I don't see how you would. To get to the ovaries of a woman without a uterus you'd need to cut her open. (1) is that the correct terminology?