6 ms·
Can Nashville Pull Off a $5.2B Transit Makeover?
- aurizon 9y agoMake it fully automated, self driving, on controlled trackways with entry and exit on the opposite sides of cars. Why? They do it with elevators don't they? I recall when all elevators had operators - yes a person in the car to push the floor button. This evolved from old systems with a hand operated cable line with a window the operator put his hand into to pull up/down and to level the car. This led to elevator operator unions, and strikes - which led to fully automated push button elevators when the unions got whiney and greedy. Operators were getting $50,000+ for riding and pushing buttons. . So the were all left out in the cold and courts supported automated elevators. Then there were the movie projector operators, relics of the carbon arc in the old days. Now fully automated digital projection rules this work place,
- PakG1 9y agoFor working example, see Singapore. That being said automated systems still require maintenance and maintenance engineers could get unionized and still have similar impacts.
- dnautics 9y agoSingapore is also lucky in that the planners matched the routes with actual transit demand (not hard when it's a small island). I think the only realistic way that the US is going to have good public transit is when city operators allow privatized public transit. Singapore's lines, for example, until this year were privatized companies competing for contracts - one of the companies was nationalized, so who knows moving forward... But in any case, Singapore is the cleanest, fastest public transport system in the world, and is considerably cheaper than any in the US.
- Spooky23 9y agoMass transit is just like any other capital intensive fixed industry — they tend to go out of business a lot without implicit or explicit subsidy. Most of the New York City MTA system was built out of the ashes of defunct rail and bus companies that were devastated by inflation, bad business decisions, inability to handle maintenance costs or inability to raise capital. Today most US mass transit is controlled by public authorities which are like a .gov/corporate hybrid. Telecom has similar problems, but went a different route, where AT&T was able to secure a monopoly to build out the network in exchange for public utility status and some regulatory strings. Since privatization, telecom has gone back to that model to deliver long-term profit, gobbling up cable and media. Except this time they are dumping the public utility part.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lfam 9y agoI do deliveries to some buildings that still have freight elevator operators, in a USA city. I don't know what they are paid, but it is worth every penny for them to manage the elevators. There is not enough "supply" of freight elevator in most tall buildings, so these operators distribute the capacity to the dozens / hundreds of people needing to use the elevator each day. $50k per year is a bargain for all the time they save for the thousands of deliveries and other uses each year. If you have experience in this area, then I should not say this: it's easy to criticize some work as useless when one is totally ignorant of the problem space. But buildings don't hire these operators as a charity.
- lfam 9y agoAnd I'd like to add that I am really skeptical of replacing this job with software, considering that facilities management in these buildings always seems to be barely holding it together. I think a $50k employee can be more responsive / adaptable than a computer program whose administrative credentials are misplaced 2 weeks after installation. And probably cheaper, too.
- aurizon 9y agoYes, I agree, freight management differs greatly from people walking in and pushing buttons for their floor. We now have a new system where you go in and push what floor on an external pad and the system tells you what car to go to.
- jdavis703 9y agoThe BART system is designed to be fully automatic. However each train still has drivers. The reason is because of of other people. Here are a few instances where a human operator has been able to do things an automated system would struggle with. Able bodied individuals weren't leaving the priority seating to make room for a disabled person. So the operator first reminded people to make room. After that failed he threatened to leave his cab and make someone leave their seat. A computer couldn't do that. At worst it could halt the train until the cops showed up, which would probably be a sub-optimal way to handle asshole passengers. There was police activity causing a halt to all train service. As a result the operator manually connected their train with one that was already in the station so the passengers could leave. Another situation involved a sick passenger. The paramedics forgot to alert the operator they had picked up the passenger, so the operator had to verify everything was taken care of before departing. In an emergency the paramedics may not have the time or ability to coordinate with central control or whoever oversees the system.
- Trill-I-Am 9y ago$10 billion of urban transit spending won’t fundamentally fix the problem in Nashville because so, so many people commute in from out of the county because of white flight. We need regional transit solutions but they won’t happen because 1.) The suburban counties currently reap all the economic benefits with none of the costs (transit) 2.) The wealthier suburban counties (Williamson) don’t want people (read: anyone that isn’t rich and white) from Davidson County coming into their county. 3.) The extremely republican dominated state government isn’t going to spend any money on infrastructure for the main democratic stronghold of the state.
- martinald 9y agoSo what will? $10bn of freeway widening and maintenance?
- Trill-I-Am 9y agoOnly thing that I would imagine would fix it would be 1.) An expansive light rail and BRT network going out to several of the suburban counties 2.) Congestion charges 3.) fixing the damn schools so people want to live in this county and don’t commute 4.) fix the horrible urban bus system so you don’t have to go downtown first before you can go anywhere else
- bryanlarsen 9y agoAnd the way to get all that is amalgamation so that the suburban counties who benefit from an urban core without paying for it actually start paying for it...
- horv 9y agoFor what it's worth, I think attributing it to white flight is a little misleading. Davidson County is certainly more diverse than the other counties in the metro region, but most of the people I know who live outside of Davidson County do so because of the schools. I'm close friends with a few Nashville Metro teachers, and I think that issues within Metro stem mostly from lack of funding. As for the support from outside Nashville proper, I think that all of my friends and coworkers who live outside the city have much more to gain from a transit system that extends outside the county. My commute is pretty reasonable, a consistent 15-20 minutes. My coworkers in Williamson, Rutherford, or Cheatham Counties all have significantly longer commutes. I'm not saying support is a given, but for all the people who talk about Nashville turning into Atlanta, it's not those of us who live inside Davidson County that have the most to lose.
- gok 9y ago$5.2 billion for around 25 miles of light rail? Honestly by American standards that’s pretty affordable. Denver spent a similar amount for much more rail but in the process got a commuter rail line where the grade crossings don’t work.
- jaxn 9y agoBut it is 25 miles of light rail to get you to a city with a VERY inefficient bus system that has historically struggled to gain riders. I suspect there are more people in Nashville using ride-share than are using public transit.
- dionidium 9y agoIt really depends. St. Louis has built light rail along existing rail ROWs in rural areas, inside existing Downtown tunnels, and through new urban tunnels built specifically for light rail. The costs vary wildly along each of those segments. $5 billion to build new tunnels? That's a bargain. Along rural ROWs? That's a boondoggle.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoAside from the dense and compact NYC subway, is there any transit system in the USA that people would say is a great example to follow?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoChicago’s rail system (“The L” elevated line + Metra hub and spoke to the suburbs) as well as the CTA bus system are very good. My suggestions to improve would be better funding for light rail, dedicated lanes for buses that other vehicles can’t enter, priority access at intersections, and a congestion charge to enter the core (“The Loop”). EDIT: Dropped "light" from "light rail system".
- dzhiurgis 9y agoToo bad they rejected bus-rapid system. They seem to be cheap, effective and actually working really well. We have few lines here in Auckland and they are about 2-3x faster than taking a car at peak times.
- sliverstorm 9y agoThere's one in our town- the one pitfall I've come to feel is placement of the crossings. Close but not part of existing intersections means another traffic light whose timing you can now bungle.
- thesmallestcat 9y agoMinor quibble but Chicago's elevated and commuter rail systems are all heavy rail, not light rail.
- brianwawok 9y agoWhats the difference? Heavy is the same stuff as freight trains, and light is smaller?
- 9y ago
- jaxn 9y agoThis seems like a puff piece that does nothing to capture the debate around this proposal that is taking place in Nashville. Yes, there are state-level politics involved, but there are a LOT of Nashville residents that are strongly against this plan on the grounds that it will be outdated and under-utilized before it is ever completed. The Mayor's PR machine and the local Chamber are working hard to create support for this proposal, but it will be an uphill battle and will likely fail with the voters.
- jdavis703 9y agoHow can it be outdated? Do residents think self-driving cars will take over by the time the system is ready?
- SwellJoe 9y agoI don't know anything about Nashville, but one of the common complaints about a recent rail proposal in Austin was that it served the areas least likely to use mass transit. And, it traveled within the wealthy and slow-growing (in terms of population) west and northwest parts of central Austin, even though the east and southeast sides use mass transit more, once you remove the university population, which is already reasonably well-served by the bus system and wouldn't have been served directly by the proposed train, anyway. One could make the argument that the proposal, in that case, was outdated because it didn't recognize that much of the growth in Austin is in the east and southeast of the city. It was based on assumptions about where people live and work that aren't current. And, many made the case that it was based on serving the wealthy, mostly white, population of Austin, especially a few real estate developers, while the poorer, mostly latinx, population would continue to be poorly served by Cap Metro buses and would likely see fare increases because of the new construction. So, even if one believes a particular transit technology, whatever it is, is technically sound and will last decades (e.g. the NY subway, which has likely paid for itself many times over since its construction and continues to serve the city, despite being very old and in need of updates and new construction), it may not be forward-looking on logistical matters. If you build a train, bus, light rail, nuclear submarine, hyperloop, whatever, that nobody rides, you haven't solved any problems for the city, you've just incurred debt. I'm in favor of mass transit, of course. The more, the better. But, I surprisingly found myself on the opposite side of the recent Austin rail measure because of the reasons mentioned among others. Again, I have no idea what's going on with Nashville. I've only visited. Just sharing how one might oppose a transit initiative without believing self-driving cars will solve everything in five years.
- nodesocket 9y agoI'm moving from San Francisco to Nashville in December for a plethora of reasons, but I can tell you that Nashville is growing and expanding like crazy. I believe it is in the top 10 fastest growing US cities and it is VERY business friendly (no state income tax) and has favorable small business conditions. While Nashville is certainly a music city, the business environment continues to improve. Even with a 1% increase in sale tax to support Let’s Move Nashville, I think this has a great chance of passing. I'm very bullish on the Nashville economy :-).
- Xcelerate 9y ago> I'm moving from San Francisco to Nashville As a Tennessean who wouldn’t mind moving to San Francisco, I’m curious if you can share any of your reasons? I haven’t noticed many tech benefits in Tennessee over SF beyond lower cost of living.
- nodesocket 9y agoWell, if I share my opinions of why I want to move out of downtown SF I'm sure I will just get downvoted here on HN, so instead I'm just looking for a change. Ready to settle and slow life down. I absolutely love music (played drums and piano) and really enjoy the amazing live music scene in Nashville. I also found that people are super friendly, charming, and ultra polite in Nashville.
- paul7986 9y agoWhat You don’t like the blight of the homeless smacking you in the face in San Fran? I guess it’s in Nashville (I never saw it while living there for 3 years from Baltimore) too but it’s not a lifestyle there or a city other cities dump their homeless problem on. I loved San Fran on my first visit then I stayed at a hotel on Market st and visited Haight Ashbury..omg!
- nradov 9y agoPresence or absence of a state income tax doesn't imply anything about the business climate. States without income tax typically have higher sales and/or property tax, which aren't necessarily better.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]