19 ms·
How Apple sidestepped a 2013 crackdown on its Irish tax practices
- abalone 9y agoThis is all a bit misleading. The general tone of the article is "Apple's not paying their fair share in Europe." The bigger context here is these are taxes owed mostly to the United States. That's where most of Apple's value-creating work is done and that's traditionally how international tax law works. What's happening is, Apple is parking funds in offshore tax havens while lobbying Congress to lower the tax rate for repatriating funds to the U.S. from ~40%, which they think is too high. So all this talk of "avoiding" taxes is true but it's a temporary avoidance. That matters because it affects what would happen if Europe were to raise taxes. It wouldn't necessarily mean that Europe starts getting Apple's taxes moving forward. It would just eliminate the possibility of parking funds in Europe like this. Maybe it would prompt Apple to look outside Europe for havens. Or perhaps it would impact the stalemate that exists between U.S.-based multinationals and Congress. Ultimately, Congress doesn't want to miss out on those taxes in the long run and Apple doesn't want to get double-taxed when they repatriate. That's why Cook calls it "political crap"... Changes probably wouldn't benefit Europe in the long run.
- joering2 9y agoIts still highly questionable. Try it at home: don't pay taxes for 10 years because YOU decide they are too high and tell Congress you won't pay until Congress will lover your taxes. And make sure you don't have any animals at home and don't forget to turn on your surveillance cameras, because after third visit from IRS, local SWAT team is coming up with flash-grenades and fully automatic ARs.
- charlesdm 9y ago> that's traditionally how international tax law works No, that is how US tax law works. Most jurisdictions traditionally do not tax foreign earnings, but exempt them.
- Cr4shOv3rrid3 9y agoneed another karma point for keybase.io somone wanna help me out with that?
- kbhn 9y agoTry getting someone to help you out by, you know, posting something meaningful.
- Cr4shOv3rrid3 9y agoTest!!!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lucio 9y ago>What could Apple buy with its Offshore cash? Just 1 month of 2017 US Federal Gov outlays. If you make Apple pay all its accumulated cash as taxes, you can run the US Fed Gov from January 1st to January 31 (IF my calculations are correct)
- runesoerensen 9y agoApple has now issued this statement on their tax payments https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2017/11/the-facts-about-apple-tax-payments/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2017/11/the-facts-about-apple...
- csomar 9y agoI think the clash between globalization and countries (sovereign governments) is just being delayed for no good. It is proving more and more that globalization doesn't work with sovereign governments. Case in point: Let's say the US government gets strict with Apple and taxes it heavily. Apple already produces its iPhone hardware in China. Its sales are derived from the whole world and the Chinese market might become bigger than the American one. So Apple could just move to an off-shore jurisdiction that is out of hand of the US government. Boom. Apple escapes the US tax penalty. They might even be able to carry on their US engineer development while being listed as a Hong Kong or Singapore company. The only way to stop that, is for the US to pressure these smaller off-shore city-states. But smaller and other non-major countries can't do that. So big corporations will be able to screw them. In the end, you'll either end up with weak governments which end up breaking down under the negative financial effect; or have the US rule the world "fiscally". It seems that we are going for the latter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Compliance_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Account_Tax_Compliance...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- herodotus 9y agoApple employees earn a lot of money and pay taxes in the jurisdiction in which they live. Companies use their profits either to give dividends to their shareholders (and these are taxed), or to invest in new products or business activities. I think it is counter-productive for governments to go after company taxes.
- rrggrr 9y agoIf passed, and for a brief period of time, Trump's dollar repatriation tax scheme brings home some of the +2 trillion dollars sequestered abroad - including some of the billions Apple has parked offshore. http://www.businessinsider.com/trump-gop-tax-reform-plan-bill-text-details-rate-2017-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/trump-gop-tax-reform-plan-bil... There's something to be said for Apple's efforts to level the playing field against the favorable tax & public policies under which Samsung and Huawei Technologies operate. I'm not crying 'boo hoo' for Apple, but their tax strategies are understandable.
- tooltalk 9y agoCan you elaborate on Samsung and Huawei's favorable tax and public policies under which they operate? Are you saying that their tax rates rates are lower?
- ali_af 9y agoNote that Cook has been vocal about repatriation and has suggested that it be mandatory to all corporations, then taxed specifically for infrastructure development.
- pasbesoin 9y agoThis was offered/done around 2004-2005, with the proviso that it would be a one-time deal. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. Investigate. Confiscate. Incarcerate. I'm done with the "business" line of rhetoric.
- aagha 9y agoWhat's the benefit to Apple or anyone else if the money is here in the US?
- canuckintime 9y agoOr the US Congress could just change the law, close the loophole and require corporations to bring the money home anyway without any tax holidays...
- 9y ago
- aaron-lebo 9y agoSteve Jobs: What if the computer was a beautiful object? Something you wanted to look at and have in your home. And what if instead of it being in the right hands, it was in everyone's hands? John Sculley: We'd be talking about the most tectonic shift in the status quo since... Steve Jobs: ...ever. Wonder if Sorkin could make a $1,000 phone and tax avoidance sound good? When did Apple change from being about the average person to being about the ultra rich, or has it always been this way? Maybe it's an unethical company not worth supporting anymore. Way too much of the tech industry has come off as immoral and greedy this past weekend with these revelations. How do we reboot?
- mgkimsal 9y ago> this past weekend Just this past weekend? Really?
- anigbrowl 9y ago'Have you tried turning it off and on again?' Many a true word is said in jest.
- madeofpalk 9y agoWhat's this got to do with the tech industry? Doesnt every industry have this problem. Ikea is particularly well known for their ability to minimise tax. Mining/resources companies are currently under a lot of scrutiny in Australia for the same thing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- komali2 9y agoIf you unplugged Apple's board (or given decision-making apparatus) and plugged in a (currently nonexistent) AI with the parameter "Maximize Profit," would you see a different result? I think not. I think we'd see things far more morally horrifying, in fact, with just enough PR makeup to ensure "maximized profit." Unsure why we laud capitalism and then act horrified at the result. Here in America we've made our decision - profit rules above all else. It is more profitable to lobby congress than it is to upgrade a refinery, it's more profitable to auto-deny every health insurance claim than it is to provide the services your customers think they're paying for, it's more profitable to avoid taxes than not (as long as you can avoid breaking the law TOO hard).
- hashmal 9y agoIt is easy to blame Apple (and other big companies) when the real problem is that governments are incapable of taming these companies.
- AckSyn 9y agoAll Apple is doing is completely legal. Avoiding taxes by using foreign methods isn't unlawful tax evasion, only failing to pay what is owed. The root of the cause is the insane tax requirements governments push onto corporations (people too) for doing national and international business. It's natural for them avoid excessive taxes through whatever methods they can legally do so.
- colemannugent 9y agoI see your point about the bad side of capitalism, but consider that this kind of abuse is only possible because the governments allow it. No economic system can live up to its design when corrupt governments interfere with it.
- aaron-lebo 9y agogovernments allow it corrupt governments interfere with it Are those not in opposition? Another solution is a better breed of business that doesn't see $ as the most important thing in the world, but not sure how you change that. Capitalism can and should be a conduit for innovation without outright greed.
- yawz 9y ago> "...We do not stash money on some Caribbean island." Nope. Just Jersey. Much less exotic!
- mzs 9y agoother details: https://www.icij.org/investigations/paradise-papers/apples-secret-offshore-island-hop-revealed-by-paradise-papers-leak-icij/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/paradise-papers/apples-s...
- nem035 9y ago,,,,
- jakozaur 9y agoMaybe developed countries should agree on minimal profit tax for multinationals? E.g. 10% of profits for companies that have revenue larger than X mln / year? Right now it's race to bottom and there will be another loophole. So much of energy of smart people goes to tax minimization instead of finding a useful way to reinvest those money.
- neil_s 9y ago+1! You can try to apply morals to companies in an internationally competitive environment all you want, but it ain't gonna happen. The only way to ensure they can't play governments against each other is to effectively make a cartel. How you'd get over the collective action problem and prevent countries from defecting is beyond me though, would probably need something like the OECD to pass a resolution. Most current tax havens are UK dependencies, so such an agreement would have a significant impact. Additionally, individual countries could do something like what the US does with its citizens - if you've paid a sensible amount of tax abroad, great; if not, pay the difference here. You can locate wherever you want, but relocating to save on taxes becomes moot.
- hackerboos 9y agoThe UK doesn't benefit from protecting these dependencies and we're a change of government away from seeing them all brought to heel. https://www.theguardian.com/news/2016/apr/05/uk-could-impose-direct-rule-on-tax-havens-says-jeremy-corbyn-panama-papers https://www.theguardian.com/news/2016/apr/05/uk-could-impose...
- RingwormOne 9y agoDon't fault corporations for exploiting legal loopholes to save money... They optimize what they must optimize as operating businesses, and if we the citizens want to compel them to do something we must pass the laws necessary to do so... Stop moralizing the behavior of companies. They aren't humans. If you choose not to buy apple products in reaction to their behavior, great. If you want to convince your friends to do the same, great. But legal repercussions are reserved for law breaking entities. Loophole exploitation is not law breaking.
- icc97 9y ago> A corporation is a company or group of people authorized to act as a single entity (legally a person) and recognized as such in law. > Corporations can exercise human rights against real individuals and the state, and they can themselves be responsible for human rights violations. How human do you want them to be? They're a group of humans with human rights. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporation
- maus42 9y ago>Stop moralizing the behavior of companies. They aren't humans. That is true. Companies, however, consist of humans. Make the people making the decisions to be held responsible for those decisions.
- ionised 9y ago> Don't fault corporations for exploiting legal loopholes to save money... No, sorry, I'm going to keep faulting them. > Stop moralizing the behavior of companies. They aren't humans. Repeal Citizen's United then.
- tomxor 9y agoLaw is not just a set of confining rules like a programming language, exploiting loop holes has moral consequences. Corporations are run by humans, some of those humans must ultimately answer for crimes of tax evasion. Just like the VW executive who is currently doing prison time for other corporate crimes (technically their vehicles passed the required tests). Some people would prefer more than this to prevent scapegoating. i.e corporate death penalty... liquidation selling off the assets to the competition, dividing the result between the parties (government, citizens etc) defrauded or harmed. Unfortunately this will never happen with this size of company due to the impact it would have on the economy. The best we can hope for is government intervention, i.e impede company freedoms in proportion to it's crimes, much like a criminal record hurts an individual's job prospects. This would also make strategically immoral profit less attractive (Think of the Fight Club car recall equation).
- DINKDINK 9y agoPoint of debate: Why should Apple have the US government lay claim to the revenue/profits that it generates in non US countries? From the article: "This allowed Apple to funnel all its sales outside of the Americas - currently about 55% of its revenue - through Irish subsidiaries that were effectively stateless for taxation purposes, and so incurred hardly any tax." If you support the taxation, do you also support the IRS taxing the wages of expats living abroad?
- MarkMc 9y agoAlthough most of its sales are outside the US, I believe that in reality Apple generates the vast bulk of its profit in the US - specifically in California. Let's say an iPhone is sold in the UK, generating a $200 profit. How much of that profit was really generated in the UK and how much in the US? The answer is to consider what would happen if Apple's US and UK operations were two distinct, independent companies: Apple in California would determine almost everything about the way iPhones are sold in the UK - where the Apple stores are located, what the stores look like, what their TV and billboard advertising should look like, what happens when a customer returns a product, etc. Apple US would then take this list of requirements and negotiate with a UK business partner. In that negotiation the UK partner has very little leverage - if the UK partner doesn't like terms Apple US is offering, Apple US can just find another partner. The UK partner then sells phones according to Apple's specification. The result is that the UK partner will have thin margins and almost all profit will flow back to the US. Now perhaps I'm being hard on Apple's UK employees - maybe they are doing more than simply working to a specification given to them by their California colleagues. In this case it would be fair to say that a somewhat larger portion of that $200 is actually generated in the UK - so the total tax Apples pays on that $200 profit would be a combination of US and UK tax rates. But there is absolutely no reason why Irish tax rules should apply to the allocation of profit on the sale of an iPhone in the UK.
- lbotos 9y agoDoesn't it already? I've been under the impression that is one of the big "things" about being an American. You will always pay taxes to the US: "If you are a U.S. citizen or resident alien, the rules for filing income, estate, and gift tax returns and paying estimated tax are generally the same whether you are in the United States or abroad. Your worldwide income is subject to U.S. income tax, regardless of where you reside." Per https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/taxpayers-living-abroad https://www.irs.gov/individuals/international-taxpayers/taxp... EDIT: To answer your question, no, I don't like that, but I don't think "companies" should be exempt.
- donutdan4114 9y agoThe issue with all of these major companies will forever be their "product". --- From: Silicon Valley (HBO) Jack: Richard, I don't think you understand what the product is. The product isn't the platform, and the product isn't your algorithm, either. And it's not even the software. Do you know what Pied Piper's product is, Richard? Richard: Is... Is it me? Jack: Oh God! No! No. How could it possibly be you? You got fired. Pied Piper's product is its stock. --- When the only product a company cares about its stock, and they only care about their accountability to the shareholders, we will continue to see mass tax evasion schemes and using any/all methodologies (including illegal/unethical) to maximize profits.
- make3 9y agowtf does this even mean. companies will always care about profitability for their owners. that's the whole point of starting and having a business
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Xylakant 9y agoHow is this the whole point of starting a business? Elon Musk is often quoted as using Tesla as a mean to promote electric transportation. Corporate structures that may never pay dividends to the owners such as gGmbH (gemeinnützige GmbH) exist and get used in practice. There’s a ton of reasons to start a business, shaving off the absolute maximum in profits is just one.
- imaginenore 9y agoMusk said multiple times that all his non-SpaceX businesses are just means of getting humans to Mars. The electric transport and solar energy / storage indeed have nice side effects, but they are not his final goal.
- kungito 9y agoWhat Elon Musk is doing is called amazing PR and guerilla marketing. I wish it wasn't so but I'm eagerly waiting to be corrected
- tryingagainbro 9y agoI'm with Apple on this one. The government can make it illegal if they wanted to. But it's not so Apple of John Doe should not be bothered for doing legal things when it comes to taxes. If what they're doing is illegal, slap them with a fine too (like EU did...it's currently on appeal i think)
- nautilus12 9y agoUnpopular opinion: Since did "technically" following the law matter more than a companies reputation, both with the public and with the government and society in which it resides. If my neighbor built a giant flashing neon sign facing my bedroom window and it was somehow "technically" within the bounds of the law I would still be ticked off, even if my neighbor provided me with iCloud sync. The problem is that Apple avoiding taxes isn't as blatant and irritating as a neon sign in our window, but it SHOULD be when we go to pay our taxes. We should feel immediate outrage at anyone that isn't pulling their weight, especially when there are individuals in government trying to get us to pay even more in our taxes to make up the difference. Get apple to pay their damn taxes first. ONLY then you can talk to me about upping my taxes to fund something like universal free college education.
- wukerplank 9y ago> What could Apple buy with its offshore cash The examples are ridiculous. How many teachers, nurses, doctors could you employ with that money, had it been properly taxed?
- tareqak 9y agoTechmeme summary: BBC: Paradise Papers: Apple shifted to new tax haven of Jersey, after crackdown by European regulators of its Irish tax arrangement, sought to keep move secret
- patresh 9y agoWhy is it that criminal laws are judged on a case by case basis and tax code is so inflexible? For instance, in states that allow shooting trespassers, you could buy a patch of sidewalk and shoot anyone that walks into it. I doubt that you would get off scot-free since in criminal law you always consider context. Why is that notion of context impossible to include in the tax code and leave some interpretability to the judge? This would make these loopholes more risky and therefore less attractive.
- x220 9y agoCriminal cases in nearly all jurisdictions in the United States are not judged on a case-by-case basis. They are judged on precedent.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zeristor 9y agoMaybe Britain should invade Jersey?
- microcolonel 9y agoWhen talking about "tax avoidance", it is important to be fair. There is only one question, "Is this illegal?", and that question has only two answers. Either it's not illegal, and the onus is on you to lobby for and define laws which achieve your goals, or to simply accept things as they are; or it is illegal, and the onus is on your prosecutors to prosecute. Avoiding taxes is the rational, moral, and fair thing to do. People should not be punished for playing by the rules, because then it becomes arbitrary.
- anigbrowl 9y agoWhen talking about "tax avoidance", it is important to be fair. There is only one question, "Is this illegal?", and that question has only two answers. Wait a minute....so it's important to be fair, but not to examine whether the behavior in question is fair? I get that you want to shift consideration to the rules, but as we all know the rules are up for auction by those willing to spend money on lobbying and financing campaigns. If we're going 'to be fair' - the standard you're asking for - then I think we need to include that factor in our assessment. Otherwise, it seems like you're appealing to people's instinct to support fairness as a diversion from the rather blatant rigging of the rules, and that doesn't seem fair at all. There's something disturbing about the prevalence of this rhetorical technique by so many posters whenever this subject comes up. Whether it's cynical or reflexive I don't know, but it is misdirection. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hlkQPiiLs6U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hlkQPiiLs6U
- _rpd 9y agoI think the EU knows very well that it needs a uniform tax code. This faux outrage - "I am shocked—shocked—to find a tax haven in the channel islands!" - is just laying the political groundwork for the project.
- argo_ 9y agoanybody seeing a message asking for a flash update in the first video? https://i.imgur.com/mIQIKLx.jpg https://i.imgur.com/mIQIKLx.jpg possibly a Bad Rabbit injection? -_-
- polskibus 9y agoI wonder who else uses those tax tricks. Why isn't there somekind of SaaS that enables tax avoidance for everyone ?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]