14 ms·
Broadcom Offers $105B for Qualcomm in Landmark Deal
- snarfy 9y agoWhen you look at the iPhone X teardown [1], you can see a number of custom Apple chips. And then you scroll down and see the Broadcom and Qualcomm chips that implement mostly the radio stack. What's to say those won't be Apple chips in the future? [1] - https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/iPhone+X+Teardown/98975#s182886 https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/iPhone+X+Teardown/98975#s182...
- qaq 9y agoBroadcom and Qualcomm own significant patent portfolios covering things Apple would need to produce their own chips
- snarfy 9y agoThis is true today but doesn't have to be in the future. Technologies change. Patents expire. There will be a 6g after 5g. I'm not sure who will own the patents on it. Most likely one of those two companies for sure, but you never know. Apple could invest the R&D and come up with something much better than we have today, and we all end up with Apple radio chips in our phones instead of Qualcomm.
- j605 9y agoQualcom and Broadcom create prototypes even before standards are finalized so it is very difficult for an outsider to get in the game.
- dmitriid 9y agoApple created it's own 64-bit ARM chip before the specification was ready.
- madeofpalk 9y agoTechnologies change by Qualcomm inventing new ones and patenting them.
- philfrasty 9y agoDo they have both exceptional engineers + patent lawyers? Or is their IP stack purely through acquisitions?
- newusertoday 9y agothey definitely had exceptional engineers in the past, irvin jacob and andrew viterbi practically invented cdma while everyone else was going with tdm/fdm based systems.
- dis-sys 9y agopeople used the exact same argument when transitioning to 4G, they hoped that Qualcomm could lose the 4G battle so they could pay less qualcomm tax. what actually happened?
- kalleboo 9y agoFor those interested in the patent landscape around mobile, this blog post has a rundown of the biggest patent holders for 5G-related technologies. The biggest ones are Qualcomm, InterDigital (a NPE), Nokia, Ericsson and Intel. http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2016/03/31/5g-mobile-networks-next-big-battleground/id=67632/ http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2016/03/31/5g-mobile-networks-next...
- dragontamer 9y agoApple can license the patents. But more realistically, Apple can buy Intel modems (as Intel already has a license with Qualcomm for LTE)
- tooltalk 9y agoDoes Intel have a license with Qualcomm? Why did they then go to KFTC and USTFC complaining about Qualcomm not licensing their patents to competing baseband makers?
- le-mark 9y agoSounds like Apple should look at buying Qualcomm then, they could do half the deal in cash if they wanted too.
- mdasen 9y agoFor the standards, the patents would almost assuredly fall under FRAND licensing terms (fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory). Apple would still have to pay the license fees, but they already pay those. As it stands, Apple already pays companies like Nokia and Qualcomm (until they started withholding licensing payments as part of the dispute) for use of their wireless patents. It seems that Apple making their own chips wouldn't change that situation. They license the patents now when using 3rd party chips, they'd license the patents in the future if they made their own chips.
- tooltalk 9y agohate to be a nitpick, but Apple doesn't have a license with Qualcomm. Instead Apple chose to outsource all their manufacturing and licensing to Foxconn whose licensing with Qualcomm predates Apple's iPhone release in 2007. In this particular case, Apple instructed its suppliers to make no further payment to Qualcomm. So I guess so long as Apple iPhone are made in China by those sourcing companies, their (indirect) licensing payment to Qualcomm won't change.
- hourislate 9y agoApple could purchase both companies outright in an all cash deal and still have hundreds of billions in the bank.
- chrisweekly 9y agoEven in the US, I think _that_ would get squashed flat. Antitrust slam-dunk, no?
- mtgx 9y agoAnd most of those patents are under FRAND, hence why Qualcomm is selling itself to Broadcom now...
- jay-saint 9y agoPatents mostly. Even if Apple made the chips themselves they would still be stuck paying royalties to Broadcom and Qualcomm.
- masklinn 9y agoPatents I'd expect, wireless stacks are patented to the hilt.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ksec 9y agoAs I mentioned in anther post, Apple are already making their WiFi and Bluetooth Chip, W1 ( Bluetooth ) in Airpod, W2 ( 802.11n + Bluetooth 4.2 ) in Apple Watch. So Apple has been testing a lot of things in their smaller volume products. Their next chip W3, will likely catch up to 802.11ac and Bluetooth 5.
- petra 9y agoYes the processor that Apple makes is challenging to build but those other chips, like power management IC or audio codec aren't very challenging, relatively to the difficulty of implementing a good WIFI/LTE chip.
- qaq 9y agoDoes not look good for mobile phone manufacturers if it goes through
- ac29 9y agoI wonder if this would push Google to move into the smartphone SoC business, perhaps in collaboration with Intel, who already makes a NN processor in the new Pixel, an LTE modem for some recent iPhones, and obviously has CPU/GPU experience in x86 (and could probably design and fab a pretty competitive ARM core if they wanted to). Google has the cash to do this, and their recent acquisition of HTC engineering talent suggests they are serious about pushing forwards as a high-end smartphone maker. edit: Given more thought, I wonder if Google was already headed down this track. This mega-merger would only be additional incentive.
- remir 9y agoGoogle buying Qualcomm? That could be interesting for sure, but I don't think that would happen.
- ac29 9y agoIf it wasn't clear, I was suggesting a Google-Intel design collaboration, and Google dropping Qualcomm from future products. I don't think Google has any interest in buying Qualcomm.
- Namidairo 9y agoDepending on how custom the "Pixel Visual Core" is, it appears Google may already have the intention
- TheGrassyKnoll 9y agoHow'd that $13 billion Motorola buy work out for them ?
- skinnymuch 9y ago
- khuey 9y agoThis seems like the sort of thing antitrust regulators should take a long hard look at.
- dis-sys 9y ago"Qualcomm is preparing to fend off the unsolicited offer, arguing it undervalues the company, people familiar with the plans have said. Qualcomm will argue that the proposal is an opportunistic move to buy the chipmaker on the cheap, the people said, and it will likely recommend that shareholders reject it."
- UseStrict 9y agoRarely is it a good thing for the market when two behemoths merge. I hope regulators pay attention and don't just rubber stamp this.
- mtgx 9y agoQualcomm is feeling guilty over its anti-trust violations, just like multiple governments have found it to be. This is why its investors/board members want to get rid of it. I would hope that if Broadcom acquires them it also cleans house of Qualcomm's leaders and board.
- baybal2 9y agoA mouse tries to swallow an elephant
- wiineeth 9y agoGood that samsung started making their own SOC, Mobile manufacturers should shift from qualcomm worldwide. They have almost monopoly in mobile SOC now. US and china are the only markets which require qualcomm patents to work. Mobile operators should move away from cdma. need more competition.
- TorKlingberg 9y agoInteresting. All this consolidation in chip makers is going to hurt downstream device manufacturers. Apple and Samsung must be racing to make all the chips themselves before the Broadcom-Qualcomm giant can put the squeeze on them. By the way, Broadcom's market cap is only $112B, so this must be either a highly leveraged buyout, or more of a merger in practice.
- cmiles74 9y agoFrom the article: "Apple contends Qualcomm is unfairly charging too much and illegally taking advantage of its market position in chips. To heighten pressure on Qualcomm, Apple has stopped paying the licensing fees and is planning to design devices that exclude Qualcomm’s chips, a person familiar with the situation has said."
- tooltalk 9y agoQualcomm's problem is with their patents licensing respect to competing OEM's, not necessarily with chips sales, which is really a side business, IMO. One regulator, KFTC, has found that Qualcomm's "no license, no chip" is a no-no, but why would Qualcomm want to sell chips to customers who have no desire to pay for licenses? Apple has to pay Qualcomm license fee for their patents either way -- whether Apple buys chips from Qualcomm, Intel, or otherwise. Apple is already receiving significant saving -- their royalty is based on the manufacturing cost that Foxconn charges Apple -- or about 1/3 of the retail price. Some of Qualcomm's licensing practices are quite troubling -- no license to competitors, for instance -- but, with respect to Apple's lawsuits, I don't think Qualcomm will have to change their per-device royalty basis.
- ksec 9y agoApple is already making their own WiFi and Bluetooth Chip. And this will have happen whether these chips maker were consolidating or not. As a matter of fact, arguably it is because Apple making their own chips, the most luxurious piece of market is gone, and they will have to consolidate to survive.
- 9y ago
- shimon_e 9y agoWho thinks Trump knew about this when he announced Broadcom will be relocating back to the USA.
- jakozaur 9y agoAny reasonable antitrust regulation should kill it: https://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/21725552-new-research-suggests-too-little-competition-deters-investment-americas https://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/2172555... Unfortunately they let those mergers happen: https://www.economist.com/news/business/21679810-frenzy-deals-awakening-americas-antitrust-regulators-pushing-limits https://www.economist.com/news/business/21679810-frenzy-deal... Shareholders benefit at the expense of everybody else (customers, employees, ...). Classical capital vs. labour dillema.
- runeks 9y ago> Any reasonable antitrust regulation should kill it: […] Or, alternatively, any reasonable monetary system, under which a $120bn company isn’t able to sell the $60bn[1] of debt required to complete the acquisition. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/06/business/dealbook/broadcom-qualcomm-debt.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/06/business/dealbook/broadco...
- dannyw 9y agoThe debt would then be owned by Broadcom with Qualcomm.
- mudil 9y agoWell, the market believes that the deal will not go through. The Broadcom offer is $70, and today's closing price is $62.
- phkahler 9y ago>> Any reasonable antitrust regulation should kill it Yeah, do you know where we could get some of that?
- xster 9y agoRalph Nader but joining the resistance gets you hunted down by the PR AT-ATs
- 9y ago
- airesQ 9y agoWhat a crazy turn of events. After all this M&A activity, Avago, a virtually unknown company, might end up owning Broadcom, Qualcomm, NXP and Freescale. How is this even possible? Who is financing these guys?
- adventured 9y agoHow is Avago virtually unknown? They derive from HP and Agilent Technologies, along with LSI. Pieced together originally by KKR & Silver Lake. Realistically it's a half century old entity. They then moved the corporation official seat to Singapore for various strategic reasons.
- airesQ 9y agoCalling Avago "virtually unknown" might have been too dismissive from my part. But lets consider 2013. Avago had a revenue of $2.5bn, respectable, but that's not much when compared with Qualcomm's $24.9bn, less than Broadcom's $8.3bn, NXP's $4.8bn, and Freescale's $4.1bn. In fact it seems that at least when it came to revenues, Avago was the smallest company on that list.
- qeternity 9y agoThat's how leveraged buyouts work.
- skinnymuch 9y agoPretty cool to see those revenue numbers. I assumed Avago would have been bigger revenue wise than NXP and Freescale (even with assuming you're using 2016 not 2013 revenue for them)
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoCan't charge taxes if it doesn't have revenue I guess.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoHow is Avago virtually unknown? Unsure who you think should or would know Avago, but I am fairly certain they are far from a household name like HP is.
- LaSombra 9y agoMy pet theory is that Apple is helping Broadcom since they apparently have a better relationship with Broadcom than Qualcomm.
- ksec 9y agoGiven there is Apple's money in both Western Digital and Bain Capital in the bid for Toshiba's NAND business. My guess is this take over will similarly have Apple's money in it as well.
- phr4ts 9y agoThis reminds me of Porsche vs. Volkswagen
- PatientTrades 9y agoEven at $105B this would be a bad deal for Qualcomm and its shareholders. Long term Qualcomm will be worth probably double that offer in the next 20-25 years if current trends continue. Cashing out now would be very a short sighted move for shareholders
- skinnymuch 9y agoQualcomm from the article isn't happy with the deal on their own. "Qualcomm is preparing to fend off the unsolicited offer, arguing it undervalues the company, people familiar with the plans have said. Qualcomm will argue that the proposal is an opportunistic move to buy the chipmaker on the cheap, the people said, and it will likely recommend that shareholders reject it"
- yeldarb 9y agoDoubling in 20 years is only a 3.5% rate of return. That’s not great.
- newusertoday 9y agoright now they are also paying dividend worth ~3% assuming they keep on doing this it would be 6.5% not bad..
- nradov 9y agoStock prices already account for expected future growth trends.
- Evansbee 9y agoIs it strange that Broadcom cut a deal to move HQ back the US at the same time it's buying a US-based company that would give it a near monopoly in the industry? https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/926176823117074433 https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/92617682311707443...
- microcolonel 9y agoIt's mighty weird to think of Broadcom as capable of buying Qualcomm. It'll be interesting to see if RISC-V activity increases after a merger like this. NXP has been a member, Qualcomm has been a member.. I don't think this really fundamentally changes the availability devices, or their leverage on the market (aside from Qualcomm's maneuvering becoming part of Broadcom's activities). I don't see why people in here are calling for regulatory involvement. This does not form any more of a monopoly than there already has been (on part of Qualcomm being basically being the sole enabler of LTE).
- phkahler 9y agoI'm glad you mentioned RISC-V. Even if that doesn't displace ARM or x86, it means every company can have their own CPU designs (RISC-V makes CPUs a commodity). That means the only remaining IP blocks of high value are graphics and wireless. Every other part of a SoC is either available or easy enough to develop in-house. Got that? Graphics IP will keep a company profitable for the next 5-10 years, and both these companies have basic graphics capability. Wireless will keep pretty much THESE TWO companies profitable for the next 20 years. Their merger would result in just one company that could build a complete phone on a chip without licensing much - if anything - from outside.
- khuey 9y agoARM basically made CPUs a commodity and Apple is still killing it by designing their own best-in-class version so I wouldn't be so sure about RISC-V.
- phkahler 9y ago>> ARM basically made CPUs a commodity... Definition of commodity: A reasonably interchangeable good or material, bought and sold freely as an article of commerce. That's just one, but none of the other definitions I can find suggest any type of IP ownership or licensing model. Don't get me wrong, what ARM did was a great thing. I just think what's happening around RISC-V is even better.
- 9y ago
- shmerl 9y agoIs Broadcom generally better than Qualcomm? The later is a really nasty company known for patent trolling and attacks on free codecs. While normally this would probably mean less competition, buying out an obnoxious patent troll for patent disarmament can actually be a good thing.
- maze-le 9y agoFor me at least, when it comes to laptops, a Broadcom-WiFi-Chipset is a critical factor in the purchase decision (as a 'DONT BUY!'). In the past Open Source drivers for 'Broadcom' were totally lacking. By now there are the brcm80211[0] drivers, wich kind of work, if you are lucky. With my last 2 laptops I wasnt so lucky, I still encountered constant disconnects and kernel-driver errors when working with them. The alternative was to use the reverse engineered 'b43'-driver wich kind of worked but never to my full satisfaction. I don't really know about 'patent trolling' on Broadcoms side, but these driver issues were enough for me to say: never again broadcom, when you want to use it with linux. [0]: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/broadcom_wireless#brcm80211 https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/broadcom_wireless#brcm8...
- shmerl 9y agoOn Linux, Intel WiFi drivers are by far the best I think. I wouldn't use anything else at least, because of the past experiences.
- jabl 9y agoIf you're satisfied with 802.11n then ath9k is IMHO the best. Only driver that does not require a magic firmware blob, and has all the bufferbloat reduction features.
- davidfischer 9y agoFor the record, Atheros is a subsidiary of Qualcomm. Edit: wrong preposition
- abakker 9y agoHow’s this for a new M+A regulation: make it illegal to increase the size of a patent portfolio by m+A. Not to say you couldn’t keep their patents, but that the total number of patents owned by the new company couldn’t be any larger than the larger of the two companies. If the M+A causes the divestiture of even a significant number of low value patents, it could mitigate some harm.
- logfromblammo 9y agoThat would likely have the unintended consequence of spinning off a lot of new non-practicing entities with a large number of low-value patents in their portfolios. Are you sure that's what you want? Those companies are more commonly known as "patent trolls".
- abakker 9y agoThe optimist in me says that if you make the problem bad enough, we might actually get around to fixing it. Or, maybe instead of NPEs, it will be Native American tribes. On second thought, let’s fix antitrust legislation and enforcement.
- jly 9y agoThis is a compromise made to appease antitrust regulators in some situations, already. In a deal of this size, approval would likely require some patent portfolio compromises to get done. Case in point the current Qualcomm acquisition of NXP. In that case, to satisfy EU regulatory officials, Qualcomm has agreed to give up some NXP patents (that must be sold) and agreed to not take legal action on some others, except for defensive purposes.
- Nicholas7900 9y agoCOMPOSITE HACKS • If Truly you Are In Need Of A PROFESSIONAL LEGIT HACKER Who Will Get Your Job Done Efficiently With Swift Response, Congratulations, You Have Met the Right HACKERS We are a group Of Professional HACKERS , a product of the coming together of Legit Hackers from the Dark-Web, (pentaguard ,CyberBerkut , RedHack , Black Hat, Anonymous ) we have been existing for over 12 years, our system is a very loose and decentralized command structure that operates on ideas rather than directives. you can also find us on the dark web at :http://my7cic3ax7oznkvu.onion http://my7cic3ax7oznkvu.onion (Tor Only) Frankly speaking, I always give a 100% guarantee on any job i am been asked to do, because we have always been successful in Almost all our jobs for over 12years and our clients can testify to that . To hack anything needs time though, but we can provide a swift response to your job depending on how fast and urgent you need. Time also depends on what exactly you want to hack and how serious you are. Enough time with social engineering is required for hacking. So if you want to bind us in a short time, then just don't contact us because We can't hack within one hour,sorry. Basically, time depends on your luck. If its good luck, then it is possible to hack within one hour but, if its in the other way round, it would take few hours. I have seen FAKE HACKERS claiming they can hack in 1hr , but there is no REAL HACKER who can say this (AVOID THEM). - Please Note : we have only one contact email : compositehacks@gmail.com we will be happy to have you join over 2000 satisfied clients around the world to use our services. We provide prove of job before payment We offer services like: Hacking Whatsapp account giving you access to the person's whatsapp messages and history . You can check out our Latest Whatsapp Hack video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_LtFUVMcxY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_LtFUVMcxY Initiating Bank Wire Transfers at a resonable fee and completely untracable . Hacking any smart phone giving you access to all activities on the phone like , text messages , call logs , instant messenger chats and other information.(you can use this to spy on your spouse to know if he/she is cheating on you) Hacking Facebook , Instagram , Twitter and every other social network Accounts. Hacking Websites to deface , retrive information, edit information or give you admin access . Hacking into school's websites (server) to change grades without any trace . . Hacking any email service provider like Gmail , Yahoo, Comcast , Aol , Hotmail any others . Location Tracking. Hacking and selling credit cards , amazon , walmart , paypal , bank logs . Selling of untracable phones (even the pentagon can not track our phones). . Selling of Tutorial packs for Beginner Ethical Hackers You can also contact us for other Cyber Attacks And Hijackings, we do almost All. Contact us: compositehacks@gmail.com
- tytso 9y agoIt's funny how people say that Qualcomm was founded by engineers, since given they way they have acted in recent years, I had always assumed that they had been founded by lawyers. I know Broadcom is no prize, but given that Qualcomm has laid off all of their kernel engineers working on the upstream kernel, and given the "quality" of their BSP kernels I have had the displeasure to have to work with (hint: one way to tell that your drivers are not upstreamable is when your BSP kernel doesn't even _build_ on x86), speaking purely personally, it's hard for me to shed a tear for Qualcomm....
- martin1975 9y agoYes, it was. If you're talking about Irwin Jacobs, Andrew Viterbi, Franklin Antonio - yes, these were/are true, hardcore engineers at heart.... that was the impetus and backbone of Qualcomm. Everything that follows is the effects, which are far less interesting than its beginnings.
- tytso 9y agoAt many companies, the Founders push their biases into company culture so strongly that it stays for a long time. For example, my sister (who is an accountant, although now she's a director in the Finance and Auditing department) works at a company in the insurance industry that was founded by folks in Sales --- and it shows. Previously, she worked at Motorola, and that was clearly run by engineers. HP and Digital Equipment Corporation are also companies which have their engineering founders bias engrained into corporate culture for a long time. Although HP's more recent CEO's have not been engineers (for example Fiorina was a salesperson, and look what she did to that company). But Qualcomm certainly seems to behave as if the Lawyers dictate all of their decisions, which has made me wonder if at least one of their founders was a lawyer.
- psykotic 9y agoRegarding the lack of upstream work, a former Qualcomm VP told me that the major reason they minimize any open source work is that their lawyers are paranoid that any accidental IP leak might endanger their patent-related revenue streams (80% of their pre-tax profits are from patent licensing). Given that patents are public information, I'm not sure I understand the exact logic there, but I've seen this general kind of legal paranoia play out before. Their non-Android Linux BSPs are especially bad since they're frankensteined together from a subset of their AOSP tree with their only concern being to meet the minimal requirements of some high-volume customer contract.
- jhallenworld 9y agoAvago is acting like some kind of corporate raider: the only reason they had the money to buy Broadcom was huge bank loans: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-avago-acquisition/avago-taps-five-banks-for-broadcom-acquisition-loan-idUSKBN0OL1HR20150605 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-avago-acquisition/avago-t...
- wyldfire 9y agoReturn of the LBO?
- baybal2 9y agoIn much more crude form. What Hock Tan does is he gets ridiculous leverage, find near monopolist companies to buy, buys them, then quickly pays off debts by selling off almost everything from acquisition targets except for things needed to maintain that monopoly status. Nothing smart in this scheme
- r00fus 9y agoLBOs never left. That you're hearing about them now is simply because it's on HN. Oracle bought Peoplesoft using an LBO for example. Dell is another high profile LBO/MBO.
- awill 9y agoThe only reason Qualcomm is cheap enough for Broadcom to purchase is because of Qualcomm's disastrous SD810 chips that ruined many flagship devices in 2015. And that's all because they had to rush to the 64-bit market to chase Apple. So really, Apple is the cause of this (j/k)
- pfooti 9y agoi only hope they end up named comcomm
- ckcameron 9y agoBroadcom's previous aquisitions have not greatly benefited the hardware market. As a company they seem to be purchasing hardware manufacturers and the pace of advancement and quality of support then drops off a cliff for the acquired products. A good example of this is the LSI/Avago aquisition. Innovation in storage controllers had showered, the new Broadcom NVMe RAiD and HBA controllers offer very little change, and are more just a representation of existing technologies in combination. Qualcomm had been fairly aggressive in it's developments and the overall quality of hardware in the mobile market has improved greatly because of it. Arguably, the ability of ARM to potentially unseat x86 as the supreme architecture is because of Apple and Broadcom's and rapid advancement of their chips. I don't Broadcom would offer us the same.
- sliverstorm 9y agojust a representation of existing technologies in combination I don't shop in those markets, but combining existing technologies into one product can be a step in the march forward. See the integration of the memory controller, northbridge, video codecs, and so forth into the CPU SoC. No one integration blew the doors of, but helped pave the way to the fast, low-power chips we have today.
- josteink 9y agoSo even less competition in this space? Sounds great!