14 ms·
Bitcoin mining heats homes for free in Siberia [video]
- subleq 9y agoHow much are they paying for power?
- criddell 9y agoFor some reason, I never thought of this before, but electricity costs are included in my office lease. I should be mining all the time!
- Zircom 9y agoIn my experience, most leases that include utility costs will often contain language allowing them to charge you for what they consider excessive or unreasonable usage.
- in_hindsight 9y agoIn Siberia power is paying for you! Seriously though in Irkutsk electricity is about 0.017usd per kilowatt/hour
- evgenyq 9y agoit's kilowatt*hour to be correct. btw, a night rate is even less, somewhere around 0.01usd
- in_hindsight 9y agoYes and if it’s countryside, even less I guess
- ComodoHacker 9y agoFree, if you're lucky or inspector is your buddy.
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoFor comparison, PG&E E1 baseline for California is currently $0.19979/kWh. As in, 12x more. God help you if you wander from baseline. https://www.pge.com/tariffs/tm2/pdf/ELEC_SCHEDS_E-1.pdf https://www.pge.com/tariffs/tm2/pdf/ELEC_SCHEDS_E-1.pdf Even using a time-of-use plan like E6 (which they don't allow any more), off-peak is $0.16728/kWh in the summer, and peak summer is $0.35933/kWh. The ETOU-A and ETOU-B plans they're pushing people toward bottom out at $0.17279/kWh winter off-peak, up to $0.36335/kWh. Again, all baseline figures. Electric Vehicles and over-baseline (read: mining) will punish you to death. https://www.pge.com/tariffs/tm2/pdf/ELEC_SCHEDS_E-TOU.pdf https://www.pge.com/tariffs/tm2/pdf/ELEC_SCHEDS_E-TOU.pdf In those rate plans, PG&E apparently spends more on transmission alone than Siberian customers entirely pay for service. Also, good luck explaining the plan structure to someone; it took me 20 minutes of edits just to put this comment together coherently.
- evgenyq 9y agoOh, you have all that med insurance shit for those smarties who can handle electricity rate plans.
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoCARE doesn't help as much as you'd think, but yes.
- smsm42 9y agoThat's why SolarCity PPA is so popular - the whole idea is that they shift most of your electricity consumption back into the 1s tier. Probably still not enough for mining though unless you can make a deal where you get way over regular capacity in solar for the same price.
- sorenjan 9y agoHow is it produced though? I'm guessing in large parts by fossil fuel.
- scarlac 9y agoIn the video they interview the guy who lives next to a hydro plant, so pretty green energy.
- smsm42 9y agoThis one most likely: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irkutsk_Hydroelectric_Power_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irkutsk_Hydroelectric_Power_St... Siberia has huge rivers which are very suitable for building hydroelectric because the accompanying flooding happens in mostly uninhabited areas and thus has relatively little costs.
- smsm42 9y agoHere are the prices: http://energovopros.ru/spravochnik/elektrosnabzhenie/tarify-na-elektroenergiju/2985/40992/ http://energovopros.ru/spravochnik/elektrosnabzhenie/tarify-... (if you read Russian, or use Google translate). Yes, pretty close to 1c/kWh.
- wlesieutre 9y agoDidn't watch the video, but a quick point on how the energy efficiency of this works out: Electric heaters are 100% efficient at turning electrical energy into heat. All the energy they take in, that's where it goes. Bitcoin mining (and computers in general) are basically in the same boat. There's some ancillary energy use for blowing air around or shining lights or making sound waves, but for the most part the electricity turns into heat and does some math along the way. Sounds great! Perfectly efficient! But the important caveat is that heat pumps are (effectively) more than 100% efficient. They can take 100 watt of electricity to transfer 300 watts of heat from outside to inside. It's not technically a measure of "efficiency", we call this the "coefficient of performance" instead. Or we call it the "seasonal energy efficiency ratio", which is the same thing except multiplied by some constant factor because somebody wanted a scale that went up to higher numbers. Or for heating, the heating season performance factor, which I forget the specifics of, but is geared toward how well it works pumping heat in from outdoors when your heat source (outdoors) is very cold. In short, it's just as efficient as any other electric heater, but heat pumps are 3-4x better than that.
- tlrobinson 9y ago> But the important caveat is that heat pumps are (effectively) more than 100% efficient. Well, yes, but heat pumps can't mine Bitcoin :)
- mrfusion 9y agoTo be fair a heat pump probably wouldn’t work in Siberia with such low temperatures. Most heat pumps are no good below 20f.
- wlesieutre 9y agoThat's true, I'm speaking more generally about bitcoin mining for heat, but it may make more sense in Siberia if electric heaters are the dominant heating method. There are other reasons electrical heating isn't great, heat pumps aside. An average coal plant (in the US in 2015, I'm using EIA numbers) was about 34% efficient in turning the energy in coal into electricity. Then you lose about 5% of that in transmission, so from the heat released by burning coal you're only getting 32% of that as electricity at your house. Converting 100% of that into heat is pretty unimpressive in the big picture, you'd get 3x more heat by buying some coal and setting it on fire. Obviously you can't do that, but a high efficiency gas-fired furnace will get 90%-98% of the combustion heat into your ducts, with the much smaller remainder going up the chimney. Unless you're on solar power (or some other renewable), burning fossil fuels on-site does better than resistive electric heating. Of course that may also not apply to Siberia. If the ground is frozen all the time it's harder to run gas lines compared to putting in an electric grid. Mostly I'm trying to dissuade anyone in most of the US from stocking up on mining machines thinking it'll be a great heating system.
- andreyf 9y agoTowards the end of the video, the owner makes a point that this democratic distribution of mining power instead of large miners controlling the network is a good idea. Curious to hear more about this -- does anyone know good writing re: Democratic / distributed benefits of mining?
- TD-Linux 9y agoProbably the worst outcome is easier 51% attacks: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Majority_attack https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Majority_attack Note that from this perspective, a mining pool is effectively a single miner - so a Serbian miner might not actually help, depending which pool it's attached to.
- nybble41 9y ago> Note that from this perspective, a mining pool is effectively a single miner.... That isn't really true. A pool operator who tried to abuse their position to carry out a 51% attack against the interests of the pool members wouldn't retain their majority for long. Individual miners would switch to a different pool, or simply shut down their hardware. Conscientious pool participants could also scan the blocks they're asked to work on to detect such attempts before they are carried out, though I don't think any of the standard pool software does that yet. To sustain a 51% attack for a meaningful length of time you would have to own the hardware, not just manage it for others.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- seanalltogether 9y agoThe bitcoin protocol is somewhat at odds with the desired goal of distributed mining. Only 1 entity gets the reward of mining a block, and only 144 blocks are mined per day. You are encouraged to join the strongest pools to have the highest chance of making money. According to blockchain.info, the top 6 mining pools control 75% of the market. https://blockchain.info/pools https://blockchain.info/pools
- hw 9y agoThere are many other cases of people heating homes with mining rigs, especially in places that has a year-round cold climate. Electricity savings in cooling the rigs as well as heating the home + the profit from mining, makes the whole thing worth it... ... IF you can tolerate the noise that the rigs generate
- raihansaputra 9y agoThere are passive cooling rigs for high performance computers (LinusTechTips video). If this is a valid market, one could make prebuilt silent rigs as radiators.
- maaaats 9y agoAs a kid I always tried to convince my mom to let me play computer games to heat our house during winter. She didn't believe me. But it was probably not the efficiency of the heating that stopped her from letting me game all day, though
- ComodoHacker 9y agoDid you tell her that you move you body when you're really engaged and generate additional heat by burning your calories? That might swing the balance to your favor.
- firethief 9y agoBody heat is actually 2-3 orders of magnitude from being cost-effective, unless there's a food source much cheaper than typical lard. Edibility adds quite a premium to calories. In case anyone is wondering.
- acjohnson55 9y agoOf course, it would be cool if Bitcoin didn't require throwaway computation. Then we could use this computation for something that's actually valuable, like protein folding, or something, and still make use of the waste heat.
- virtuexru 9y agoThat "throwaway" computation ensures the integrity & correctness of the blockchain, all while confirming new transactions.
- PKop 9y agoFunny you're getting down-voted. This is quite literally a true statement. Then the only point of contention is whether the benefit of this secure network existing and what it gives the world outweighs the cost of the resources consumed. I believe it is, by a large amount.
- eternalban 9y agoIt's not "Funny". This forum's intellectual integrity is declining. OP, of course, made a statement of fact.
- s73ver_ 9y agoThey made a statement of fact, but it wasn't really relevant to the comment it was replying to.
- sliverstorm 9y agoNo, that's not the only one. High on the list is, surely there must be some way to accomplish the same quality of network without requiring so much throwaway work.
- scott_karana 9y agoI suspect you're getting downvoted (though not by me) because the hashing computation doesn't directly provide that. Other proof of work algorithms could concurrently secure the block chain and also provide direct, external benefit. There are some suggestions elsewhere in this thread. :)
- Jhsto 9y agoI used to increase my PC voltages every winter at my parents wooden heated house near the arctic circle. The room temperatures could drop all the way to 16C (60F) during the night. That allowed easy overclocks on my Athlon processor from 3 to 4Ghz. I still had to wear wool socks though, because the air pushing from the central unit would cause an annoying breeze of cold air onto my toes in the always chilly room.
- kiddico 9y agoI always look forward to the overclocking bump I get in the winter :) It's a bit odd having a seasonal clock speed though .
- nerdponx 9y agoThe room temperatures could drop all the way to 16C (60F) during the night That's what you call cold up in the arctic? That's definitely how cold my NYC apartment is every night from November through March. Heat is expensive!
- Jhsto 9y agoInteresting, I didn't know NYC apartments get so cold! But yeah, maybe it's just me, but I prefer sleeping in a warm (or hot) rooms. Also, it's still actually cold outside. Coldest mornings the year I left my parents apartment were around -40C (-40F). I personally withdraw from going outside by choice after it gets below -30C (-22F). Below that point, I start having random nose bleeds of blood. People from the south may pass out.
- wolco 9y agoIn Canada schools are stiil open in -40C weather. We only get a few days like that in the south.
- s0rce 9y agoHah, my place in the SF bay area often gets that cold on cool nights, no insulation, single pane windows and heat is expensive, blankets and thick socks are cheaper.
- _greim_ 9y agoThis reminds me of a story; a buddy of mine during my college days lived in a solitary townhome adjoining a million-watt microwave emitter room. The thing produced enough waste heat to warm the apartment in the dead of winter, even with all the doors and windows open, plus the adjoining warehouse which was several times the volume of the dwelling. I was envious at the time, although now I wonder about the health implications of the setup, and whether it was strictly speaking legal. The guy is alive and well today, fortunately.
- nerdponx 9y agoI wonder what would happen if you heavily shielded the walls, but ran a heat exchanger through. Free baseboard heating?
- _greim_ 9y agoI think that's essentially what they did. I got to go into the transmitter room and see the 1' diameter copper pipe which I was told carried the radiation out and up to the tower, and which not to approach too closely.
- KGIII 9y agoThis whole story sounds horrifically dangerous and unlikely to be approved of with regards to zoning and building inspectors. By that, I mean I'm a tad bit green with envy.
- _greim_ 9y agoMy thoughts exactly. If I ever write a hard sci-fi novel I want to adapt this setting somehow.
- Kelbit 9y agoThat would be a circular waveguide. Very common for radar setups.
- jandrese 9y ago
- kornakiewicz 9y agoBack in these day, you were installing Gentoo.
- Pxtl 9y agoHm, I've politely ignored bitcoin for a long time, but I live in a cold climate and do make some use of electrical heating. Is there a good user-friendly miner setup I could use to supplement a space-heater? I assume a low-power linux box running some bitcoin-oriented package with a bunch of asics shoved into the USB ports?
- fonosip 9y agoTry this linux pendrive for gpu mining https://ba.net/zcash-eth-miner-os/ https://ba.net/zcash-eth-miner-os/
- justinzollars 9y agoEthereum mining put my apartment in SF to about 88 degrees last summer.
- baybal2 9y ago>$460 a month The rig looks kinda tiny even for a pooled mining setup with such output.
- nnfy 9y agoI can attest, I have a 9 card mining setup which pulls around 330w per card 24/7. In the summer when it was 70-80 degrees outside it was enough to keep a large basement in the 90s, plus the rest of the house uncomfortably warm. I had to purchase an AC to keep the place livable. Now that winter is coming around I look forward to the extra heating. There seems to be discussion in these comments about mining for the purpose of heating a home, but the heating is a bonus. You're making money AND saving on energy, that's the important part. Plus, in my opinion, a constant heat source like a mining rig is preferable to an older cycling central system which can be slightly disturbing as it loudly cycles on and off throughout the day...
- top256 9y agoThere is this company too: https://computing.qarnot.com/ https://computing.qarnot.com/ It's built on the same idea but a more mature and more general solution to the same problem.
- aisofteng 9y agoHah! Qarnot is a good name for this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnot_heat_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnot_heat_engine
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jimson3432 9y agoIt's nothing new. Moreover, it's going to be very difficult for individual to mine anything using their PC nowadays.
- jimson3432 9y agoIt's nothing new, it's going to be difficult for individual to mine any BTC anyways.
- senthil_rajasek 9y agoI only turn on the heat when I want heat. Mining bitcoin to heat my home seems backwards.
- jmkni 9y agoMight be different if you live somewhere permanently cold
- senthil_rajasek 9y agoThat's right may be they never leave home or go on a vacation.
- evv 9y agoThis technique could pair nicely with another problem we have- storing solar power. In theory, you could build a system which uses solar power to mine bitcoin during the day, and store that heat somewhere (like an underground tank of water) until you need to warm your house at night. Of course its not a perfect solution because the coldest places are obviously also the places which get the least sunlight.
- kogepathic 9y ago> and store that heat somewhere (like an underground tank of water) until you need to warm your house at night. Just install a solar water system if you want to heat your house, it'll be more efficient at generating heat than solar panels. > This technique could pair nicely with another problem we have- storing solar power. Actually the ability to quickly turn on and off mining operations has other more practical uses for excess energy. Right now there are situations during the day where utilities have to idle base-load plants because renewable energies produce enough to satisfy grid demand, or they even have to pay another utility to take their excess power in case they can't quickly throttle their base load (e.g. with Nuclear). Having a large crypto currency mining pool the utility could use during these times would enable them to use the excess energy and generate a profit from it, instead of paying another utility to take their excess energy.
- jmkni 9y agoDumb question... How much does a Bitcoin mining rig usually last for before it needs replaced?
- Gudin 9y agoSame as any other rig for anything. Higher load usually doesn't make much difference in lifetime. The problem with components is that they can break one day after you bought it, or last 50 years. For example, in CERN they bought 100,000 disk drives for their huge amount of data. Lets say disk lifetime is 1M hours which is 114 years, so sounds pretty good. But that means, on average, every 10 hours one of their drives will fail.
- cgb223 9y agoCan someone talk me out of using this to heat my apartment in San Francisco?
- smsm42 9y agoCheck out electricity prices in SF. Especially the top tier. You probably would be better off burning small-denomination bills for heating. Unless of course you tricked your landlord into covering electricity costs, in which case mine away until police comes to evict you :)
- bkcreate 9y agoYour electricity costs are probably significantly higher and you might lose money overall
- hennsen 9y agoO once had a little freelance gig for a company that did offer computing resources to one part of their customers and heat for houses and water to the other with just that concept. cloud & heat
- rajeshp1986 9y agoEarning $430 for month by bitcoin mining. What about the electricity costs? If you factor in electricity costs and the money they spent on infrastructure(GPU's and high-end machines), it is a dumb idea. They could have spent $30-50 on heating equipment instead.
- nordic 9y ago>it is a dumb idea If you hate money maybe. They get BTC mining fees forever even if they shut it down.
- smsm42 9y agoElectricity costs are probably subsidized (since otherwise in places where it gets super-cold it wouldn't look nice if people froze to death for inability to pay their power bill). Electricity costs in Irkutsk (place where the place that the video is describing is located) are 0.7 RUR per 1 kWh for rural areas. That's about 1 cent per kWh. For comparison, California's lowest tariff in about 20c per kWh and if you are consuming a lot (which you'd do if you mine) you'll get over 35c/kWh. If you qualify for low income subsidy, though, you might get it for significantly cheaper :)
- where_do_i_live 9y agoSo - I actually physically run 2 mining rigs - each with 6 Nvidia GTX 1070s - pulling 1020 Watts each. They each heat a room fairly nicely and I make around maybe $300 in profit from just selling coins per month. This is AFTER I subtract my electricity costs which for these 2 rigs is about $160 per month. I have not quantified the heating benefits but I'd estimate it at maybe $20 a month. I built them back in March/April for $6k total, and I've made twice that so far - paying for itself already and extra $$$ - plus I still have the hardware going or I can resell it at a profit even thanks to the shortage of high end video cards due to all these crypto miners like myself. In the summer, I had the rigs in 1 room air cooled with just the windows open - no problems with 90 degree F days at all. Fun project, and so far quite successful.
- himlion 9y agoBut if you'd bought $6k worth of ethereum outright in march it would be worth $90k now. That's why I haven't started mining, it only seems profitable in a sideways market.
- tylerhou 9y agoBut that’s also survivorship bias. If you buy a rig, you can always have the flexibility of mining whatever’s profitable, and even potentially not mining when there’s no profit to be made.
- where_do_i_live 9y agoThat has a different risk profile entirely. I could always resell the video cards I bought at near cost. Buying speculative coins is another matter entirely. Further, I'm not mining ETH - if I took your advice on the coin I am mining I would have a net LOSS not gain. You should take another look at the economics of mining, I think you have a few aspects misunderstood.
- sliverstorm 9y agoI could always resell the video cards I bought at near cost You sure about that? There are so many miners these days, if the mining market tanks, the used graphics card market will be flooded and prices will likely plummet.
- nordic 9y agoThey should be mining Bitcoin Cash instead.
- zeep 9y agoMany miners switch back and forth... To get the best returns.
- asavinov 9y agoThere is a startup which installs their servers in private homes and other buildings where they are used for heating. They essentially connect the market of server computing and heat. [1] https://cloudandheat.com https://cloudandheat.com [2] https://www.informationweek.com/cloud/heating-your-house-with-cloud-computing/d/d-id/1317475 https://www.informationweek.com/cloud/heating-your-house-wit...
- SonicSoul 9y agohmm.. Airbnb for bitcoin miners as space heaters?
- vden 9y agoSeems to be quite popular solution when Russian winter is coming. Couple of weeks ago there was an ethereum-mining heater Comino https://comino.io https://comino.io These guys say they use optimized liquid cooling to transfer heat from GPUs to the room effectively (and earning like $10-$15 a day).
- jimnotgym 9y agoIs there a way into mining that is scalable? I mean some way where you don't have to shell out $8k up front and can build-as-you-save? There are lots of ways to save money on heating for people with $8k to spare
- sergeyfilippov 9y agoHow to measure the clickbait coefficient of the headline: A: imagine the situation the headline literally describes ( Bitcoin mining heats homes for free in Siberia) B: read what the article describes (A cottage that’s heated for free with bitcoin mining) clickbait_coefficient = the distance between A and B
- mark-r 9y agoThere's nothing new about this. I remember a story from the days of mainframes, where a data center had to be redesigned - they had built it without heating, expecting the mainframe to provide all the heat the building needed in the winter. By the time they got around to buying a machine to put in it the technology had progressed and it was much more power efficient than they had planned.
- aisofteng 9y ago>the days of mainframes Those days aren't over. Mainframes are still in serious use, at least in banks, and (I didn't know this until going to find the following link) apparently also have Blockchain support: https://www.ibm.com/us-en/marketplace/z14 https://www.ibm.com/us-en/marketplace/z14
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoASPLOS 2008 conference on Wild and Crazy Ideas already suggest the more general version of this: "Computation: A Byproduct of Home Water Heaters" http://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~swanson/WACI-VI/ http://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~swanson/WACI-VI/