29 ms·
Human Beings Almost Vanished from Earth in 70,000 B.C
- kashkhan 9y agocattle biomass is currently twice that of humans. http://www.sciencefocus.com/qa/what-animal-collectively-makes-largest-biomass-earth-0 http://www.sciencefocus.com/qa/what-animal-collectively-make...
- dredmorbius 9y agoHumans alone out-mass all other pre-civilisation terrestrial vertabrates, combined, by about 150% Humans plus livestock are about 99% of all terrestrial vertebrate biomass presently. This is aa new development https://i.redd.it/5h8e3j2tmftz.png https://i.redd.it/5h8e3j2tmftz.png http://peakoilbarrel.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Terrestrial-Vertebrate-Biomass.jpg http://peakoilbarrel.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Terrestr...
- nostrademons 9y agoIt's weird that the abstract of the first scholarly paper linked in this article basically disproves the headline of the article. From the article: "Because once in our history, the world-wide population of human beings skidded so sharply we were down to roughly a thousand reproductive adults." And from the abstract of the paper that that text links to: "Both genetic and anthropological data are incompatible with the hypothesis of a recent population size bottleneck. "
- lokiboy 9y ago"The world-wide population of human beings skidded so sharply we were down to roughly a thousand reproductive adults." This is a completely mind blowing idea that humans were down to a count of about 1000 adults. Look at us now at 7 billion, and we just can't stop warring with our fellow relatives.
- BurningFrog 9y agoA smaller percentage of the world population than ever is fighting or suffering war these days than ever before.
- pizza 9y agoThose who commit war can kill a much higher multiplier of casualties than ever before, however. It would get pretty bad if there were a reason for the percentage who are fighting had a reason to broaden their scope.
- coldtea 9y ago"These days" being the last few decades? No sign that this is not just a temporary stop, in fact the opposite. There were periods of relative peace in world history for longer than that. In the last 100 years we had 2 world wars, 100s of millions killed, and tons of peripheral wars during the "Cold War". Besides for a lot of modern history wars didn't involve much of the citizenry (they had mercenary armies). Now civilians are almost fair game. And where they had arrows, spears and swords for most of history, we now have airforces and atomic bombs.
- RepressedEmu 9y agoYes but in the last 100 years we've also added around 6 BILLION new people. 100 million dead is a drop in the bucket compared to the amount thats been added due to advancing technology and culture.
- mikeash 9y agoThe world wars aren’t the top wars for percentage of living humans killed, and may not even be the top in terms of absolute numbers of humans killed. For example, the An Lushan Rebellion may have killed 10-15% of all humans alive at the time.
- coldtea 9y ago>For example, the An Lushan Rebellion may have killed 10-15% of all humans alive at the time. Those numbers are highly discredited. Historians such as Charles Patrick Fitzgerald argue that a claim of 36 million deaths is incompatible with contemporary accounts of the war. They point out that the numbers recorded on the postwar registers reflect not only population loss, but also a breakdown of the census system as well as the removal from the census figures of various classes of untaxed persons, such as those in religious orders, foreigners and merchants. For these reasons, census numbers for the post-rebellion Tang are considered unreliable. Another consideration is the fact that the territory controlled by Tang central authority was diminished by the equivalent of several of the northern provinces, so that something like a quarter of the surviving population were no longer within the area subject to the imperial revenue system. So, in all, even less that 5%...
- mirimir 9y agoThe article is mixing evidence for bottlenecks at different times. Your quote ... > Because once in our history, the world-wide population of human beings skidded so sharply we were down to roughly a thousand reproductive adults. ... links to Hawks et al. (2000), with this in the abstract ... > It is our conclusion that, at the moment, genetic data cannot disprove a simple model of exponential population growth following a bottleneck 2 MYA at the origin of our lineage and extending through the Pleistocene. Archaeological and paleontological data indicate that this model is too oversimplified to be an accurate reflection of detailed population history, and therefore we find that genetic data lack the resolution to validly reflect many details of Pleistocene human population change. However, there is one detail that these data are sufficient to address. Both genetic and anthropological data are incompatible with the hypothesis of a recent population size bottleneck. Such an event would be expected to leave a significant mark across numerous genetic loci and observable anatomical traits, but while some subsets of data are compatible with a recent population size bottleneck, there is no consistently expressed effect that can be found across the range where it should appear, and this absence disproves the hypothesis. So yes, according to that study, the rest of the article is bullshit. But then, it was published in 2000.
- nl 9y agoI'm not sure that "1000 reproductive adults" disproves the headline at all - that's a barely viable population group. I agree that it is fairly different from the "40 breeding pairs" quoted at times in the article though.
- nostrademons 9y agoIt's not that "1000 reproductive adults" disproves the headline, it's that the paper that that quote links to says there's no evidence for a recent population bottleneck.
- gone35 9y agoUnsurprising. Krulwich is particularly notorious for sloppy science writing/reporting/whatever he does.
- kobeya 9y agoAlternatively: "how human beings rose from the lesser hominids in 70,000 B.C.E." There's a serious theory it was this bottleneck where humans were confined to environments without natural preditors (seaside cliffs like those near Cape Town) and where social interaction was a necessity. Those with higher intelligence, particularly social intelligence, would scored more mates in that environment. And thus we had a runaway intelligence arms race that separated modern humans from their immediate hominid ancestors.
- bradneuberg 9y agoInteresting theory! Do you have a link or reference where that theory is expanded more?
- canjobear 9y agoWhy would a lack of natural predators make social interaction necessary?
- analog31 9y agoPerhaps the confinement was the part that made social interaction necessary, if humans were stuck sharing a small area rather than expanding into the neighboring territory.
- kobeya 9y agoIt makes evolutionary selection be due to internal social/tribal pressures rather than a predator-prey interspecies relationship.
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoIf you think about it, it doesn't - at least not on an individual level. I suspect it's more likely that the selection happened between tribal groups, not within them. Given independent groups with similar challenges, some would have the intelligence and luck to survive, and some wouldn't. After a challenging event like Toba, tribes/herds with a culture that couldn't adapt or survive would be culled fairly quickly.
- jcranmer 9y agoThe thing about the Toba catastrophe theory is that the best evidence for it is "there was a massive eruption ~73K years ago" (the largest in the past several hundred thousand years). Which is to say, there is no archaeological evidence of depopulation. I don't know the genetic evidence well enough, but Wikipedia's presentation of that evidence is non-sensical, and I don't think there is unambiguous genetic evidence that "humans were relatively inbred ~70kya."
- contingencies 9y agoToday Toba[1] is huge volcanic lake with a central island, and a sort of washed out station on the later hippy trail, but still physically interesting to explore. For anyone considering a visit to Sumatra, do check out the nearby taxidermy museum in Medan[2]. It's absolutely incredible. And for surfers, don't miss the island of Nias[3], but fly instead of getting the boat in bad weather, which amounts to a moving vomitorium. Southeast Sumatra has a huge area of largely unexcavated stone ruins to rival Angkor [4] from an ancient, regionally significant civilization and sea power, Srivijaya[5]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Toba https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Toba [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medan [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nias [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angkor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angkor [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srivijaya https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srivijaya
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoWow, this is a great list. Sure beats the cliche trip to Bali.
- lappet 9y agoI met a driver from Medan in Bali and have been curious to go since. How is Sumatra? Are the people friendly and is it easy to get around?
- sgt 9y agoDid he drive you around on the island?
- chewz 9y agoIt isn’t easy to travel by road but flights are cheap. On the other hand if you go by minivan you will see so much more Sumatra... Sumatra is suprising - mountains, pine forests, mild climate suprisingly for equator it could often get chilly. Lots of agriculture. Vivid nature. But real jungle and primary forrest is mostly gone. People are friendly, smiling, easygoing and welcomming to foreigners. Lots of people speak a little English and bahasa is quite easy to pick up. No grammar, super simple. Indonesia has almost worst education system in the world [1] and forward thinking isn’t part of the culture. Neither is working hard. That can put you through lots of hardship - if you care. People are incredibly social - this is what their life is about. There is a lot of childish fun everywhere - when minivan is passing through the village local people pour buckets of water through open windows. Lots of people sing and play guitar - most badly in my opinion but it is still sweet. People are honest, you can trust strangers, not much of small crime, petty theft is uncommon etc. Everyone smokes cigarettes everywhere also on the bus. Even 4 year old could be already hooked on fags. [2] There is a lot of people, it is quite overpopulated island (not like Bali but close). It means tons of trash everywhere, everywhere, terrible impact on environment. Indonesia is world largest producer of marine pollution (3.2 milion metric tones of plastic per year). [3] If there is trash it is mostly burned on site (including plastic et all) so you get a haze. Cities are polutted, there is too many cars, people and not enough infrastructure. Medan - largest city in Sumatra and 2nd largest in Indonesia is the worst place in SE Asia in my opinion. It is just hudge, poor, dirty and without anything there to compensate. Clean water, sewage’s treatment forget about it. Everything goes into rivers and ocean. There is now wild gold rush which is destroying riverbeds in Sumatra.[5] The food is good but monotonous.[4] The hotels, homestays, peningapans are usually quite dirty. Regarding cleanliness Thailand it is not. Don’t expect clean sheets. Bedbugs are common. There are exceptions. Definitely go to Sumatra. Disclosure: I have spent mist part of last four years here. [1] https://www.oecd.org/pisa/PISA-2015-Indonesia.pdf https://www.oecd.org/pisa/PISA-2015-Indonesia.pdf [2] http://edition.cnn.com/2017/08/30/health/chain-smoking-children-tobacco-indonesia/index.html http://edition.cnn.com/2017/08/30/health/chain-smoking-child... [3] https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/wp-content/uploads/123/4/ehp.123-a90.t001.html https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/wp-content/uploads/123/4/ehp.123-a... [4] There are miracles like organic yogurt, mozarella and mascarpone from Medan or italian restaurant Bixio in Pulau Weh. [5] https://thediplomat.com/2017/10/making-indonesian-rivers-great-again/ https://thediplomat.com/2017/10/making-indonesian-rivers-gre...
- jchavannes 9y agoWikipedia article on this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory#Genetic_bottleneck_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory#Geneti... The Toba supereruption does correlate with a population decline, but evidence beyond that isn't very conclusive.
- xefer 9y ago“Most demographers say we will hit 9 billion before we peak...” I believe this thinking is very out of date at this point. The 2017 UN Population Prospect report has the World population at 11.2 billion and still climbing by 2100. The population of Sub-Saharan Africa alone is projection to be over 4.1 billion which I have to imagine will be nothing short of a cataclysm if it actually gets to that. The data here is stunning: https://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/Graphs/ https://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/Graphs/
- mac01021 9y ago> 11.2 billion and still climbing by 2100. They really don't think any physical constraints are going to get in the way of that? There are only so many fish in the ocean.
- xefer 9y agoThe biggest natural constraint was nitrogen fixation which places a natural limit of around 4 billion people. But artificial fertilizers basically took the lid of that and the population has been exploding since been the process was first industrialized. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/9ef1/254c1b7626ae1c70f0718c0f811d11d990da.pdf https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/9ef1/254c1b7626ae1c70f0718c...
- WalterBright 9y agoBy then people will probably be mostly eating food created by an industrial process.
- nl 9y agoThe short answer is that there are no real physical constraints. BUT there are some fairly important practical issues around unequal access to resources: some places have too much water and some don't have enough. Those kind of problems may lead to war, but probably won't stop population growth (short of it going large-scale nuclear or biological).
- oblio 9y ago
- jaequery 9y agodoes this mean the days of Noah actually did exist?
- dredmorbius 9y agoIf so, almost certainly not this eveent.
- teekno 9y agoMaybe that was our great filter [1] and we’re off to Type III civilization? [1] https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/05/fermi-paradox.html https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/05/fermi-paradox.html
- rf15 9y agoSigns point to a long chain of great filters, as far as I can see: - DNA/cellular Life itself: each is already highly improbable and hard to reproduce, and likely not even possible anymore in our current climate/atmosphere - multicellular life is a lot more likely past step one, but still hard - life that is maintainable and powerful enough to escape the struggle for survival long enough to bother with something like complex social structures and engineering (super unlikely because the more powerful you get, the easier it is for you to accidentally destroy all your food sources and starve to death until the system is balanced again)
- mikeash 9y agoMy pet theory (completely unsubstantiated, of course) is that intelligent life is common but that it rarely develops money. Stuck with barter, most intelligent life never moves beyond low levels of trade and technology. The concept of assigning value to largely useless objects and using them to keep score is extremely powerful, but also highly weird.
- kerbalspacepro 9y agoHave you read Debt: The First 5, 000 Years by David Graeber? While a lot of it is kind of... socialisty, it does a good job at describing how the standard "barter--> money" econ history is anthropologically wrong.
- mikeash 9y agoI haven't, although I've seen it discussed before. I just grabbed a sample of the eBook so I can check it out. Thanks for the mention!
- 9y ago
- Abishek_Muthian 9y ago'Perhaps' this was the trigger for the end of other homo species and the location of certain group of Homo sapiens sapiens (modern humans) helped them survive the consequences of Toba?
- jtth 9y agoFunny how that's around the time of the supposed cognitive revolution.
- gwatch 9y agoIn other news: Twitter buried a significant portions of tweets related to hacked emails from the Democratic National Committee and Clinton campaign chair John Podesta in the last two months of the 2016 presidential campaign. Twitter’s systems hid 48 percent of tweets using the #DNCLeak hashtag and 25 percent of tweets using #PodestaEmails, Twitter general counsel Sean Edgett said in his written testimony to the Senate Judiciary Committee Tuesday.
- gumby 9y agoThese bottlenecks are interesting. The cheetah had an extreme bottleneck — the remaining 20K or so cheetahs are so genetically close that they can take each other. I remember when this was figured out reading that the estimate was that they had gone down below a hundred, a few kiloyears ago. Here’s a brief article from back the (1987) about this: https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1987/02/16/cheetahs-almost-died-out-long-ago/dfe8de44-af4e-4513-81c0-8f62743d8e5c/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1987/02/16/c...
- brianyu8 9y agoVery interesting, I had no idea that Cheetahs had such an insane bottleneck. One question though, what do you mean by "they are so genetically close that they can take each other"?
- icegreentea2 9y agoThink gumby is talking about studies from the 80s which showed that captive unrelated cheetahs can accept skin grafts from each other. More detail (and later developments!) here: https://chickenoreggblog.wordpress.com/2011/02/04/cheetah-genetic-diversity-revisited/ https://chickenoreggblog.wordpress.com/2011/02/04/cheetah-ge...
- gumby 9y agoYes, that was it
- gumby 9y agoI’m sorry, keyboard problem with this $#@ iPad. They can take skin grafts from each other.
- ratacat 9y agoAnd we can accept skin grafts from sus scrofa (but many people don't believe Gene McCarthys theory that we're descendant from pig / monkey hybrids)
- c517402 9y agoxkcd of land mammal biomass https://xkcd.com/1338/ https://xkcd.com/1338/
- dredmorbius 9y agoHuman biomass growth 1900 - 2015: http://peakoilbarrel.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Terrestrial-Vertebrate-Biomass.jpg http://peakoilbarrel.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Terrestr...
- EGreg 9y agoDoes anyone see parallels between the flood stories and Toba?
- Quarrelsome 9y agoToba is possibly more fire and brimstone and hell on earth. Think about it, the sun would be blotted out, famine, war, destruction, ash everywhere. Its possibly the root source of our depictions of hell. I think the flood is more likely to be related to our exit of the ice age and the resulting catastrophic flooding from the ice melt. All speculative of course but its fun to speculate.
- arethuza 9y agoThere were also events like Storegga Slide that caused a tsunami in the North Sea - it might have inundated Doggerland. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Storegga_Slide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Storegga_Slide
- varjag 9y agoThe 40 couples left must been really celebrating the narrow escape in 69,999 BC.
- dharma1 9y agoParty like it's 69,999
- grondilu 9y ago> But our looming weight makes us vulnerable, vulnerable to viruses that were once isolated deep in forests and mountains, but are now bumping into humans, vulnerable to climate change, vulnerable to armies fighting over scarce resources. The lesson of Toba the Supervolcano is that there is nothing inevitable about our domination of the world. With a little bad luck, we can go too. I'm personally more inclined to think we are less vulnerable than ever before. I doubt any virus would wipe out an entire population. An infectious agent spreads better among a numerous population, but as it kills its hosts, the population becomes smaller, which slows the infection rate. So there is negative feedback here, and I doubt that can lead to a total extinction of the host species. Not to mention that we have modern medicine now, and that we understand how viruses work. Climate change is an issue, but I have hard times imagining how it could wipe out all human beings. Worse case scenario, I guess, would be a sharp decline in agricultural production. So hunger riots and stuff. But even that would at worse reduce the population until a new equilibrium is reached. And I don't see that equilibrium to be at 0. Nuclear war is a serious threat. But it's not like it would destroy the surface of the Earth or anything. It would provoke a nuclear winter though. I suppose a nuclear winter is about as bad as a volcanic winter is, or worse. Again, the main difficulty would be a sharp decline in food production. And that also would require a new population equilibrium to be reached. IMHO human beings, nowadays, can deal with an awful lot of contingencies. We can predict them, we can store resources, we can plan ahead... There really is a case to make about the idea that humans will survive a mass extinction. Annalee Newitz wrote a book about it[1] 1. https://www.amazon.com/Scatter-Adapt-Remember-Survive-Extinction/dp/0307949427 https://www.amazon.com/Scatter-Adapt-Remember-Survive-Extinc...
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoCanticle for Liebowitz is a novel on that topic. I'm not sure "humans will not go totally extinct" is any more comforting than the cliche of "We'll not destroy the earth, it'll be fine, it's human's that'll be wiped out" there's definately the opportunity for a lot of people to have a very bad time. Even worse than the bad times that large segments of the planet are experiencing right now.
- 9y ago
- saladeen 9y agoWhile everyone is focusing on the bottlenecks and such that this might have caused in homo sapiens, the main thing for me is the relation between Toba catastrophe and the main human migration out of Africa, which came 60kya. My theory is that Toba killed off or severely weakened populations of other human species (Neanderthals primarily) that were claiming the areas in Middle East and thus blocking our expansion. So instead of (or along with) having being a major threat for us, I think it's what enabled us to become the global species we are today.
- CodeSheikh 9y agoIt is appalling to think most of us could be descendants of those 40 something odd pairs of survived Homo Sapiens.