10 ms·
> Systematic profits are feasible year over year... But only to the select few who are in the right product or looking at the market in the right way. You seem
by ryandrake 9y ago
> Systematic profits are feasible year over year... But only to the select few who are in the right product or looking at the market in the right way.
You seem to be falling for the same myth: That "certain wizards" can get +EV. Every casino on Earth makes money from this myth. I believe that there are no wizards in the stock market (or in business in general), and everyone's gains and losses vs the total market are for the most part random chance.
I'm reminded of the coin flip exercise one of my statistics professors did. Everyone in the class stand up and get a coin. Flip the coin, if it's tails, sit down, and the rest of the class repeats the exercise until only one person remains standing. Then interview that student and ask them how they became such a good heads-flipper, and what great strategy he/she used to flip so many heads in a row. This illustrates the survivorship bias we fall victim to when we look at someone successful and try to determine what wizardry they used to become that way.
- Danihan 9y agoYour comment seems so ignorant to me. Maybe that's true if you are day trading, or picking dozens of short-term holds each year instead of long-term buys. My stock picks have been: * Google in 2003, because I worked in a call center and saw EVERYONE using it all the sudden to find answers on tech support calls. * Chipotle at their IPO because I saw the huge lines at every location in my city. * Amazon in 2008 after the big stock market crash, simply because it just seemed super undervalued considering everyone was still using it / loved it. * Broadcom in 2014 because it was obvious the cellular industry was going to keep growing and they were well-positioned / undervalued at the time. None of that thinking required me being a wizard. Nor was it luck. More just seeing obvious momentum and being willing to act.
- ryandrake 9y agoThat a great example of survivorship bias! Take a successful outcome and look back for decisions that must have led to it. This ignores the people who also "saw the obvious" in 2003, 2008, and 2014 who lost their shirt.
- Danihan 9y agoThe issue with your argument is pretending the stock market is similar to a coin flip. That's a very facile comparison. In reality each company is a very complex black box in which you can only see very limited internals. The examples I listed were not random chance. They are companies that had absolutely dominated their market positioning and were later massively rewarded for doing so. It's fairly easy to see when a company is eating everyone else's lunch. Again, it isn't just random chance. It also isn't rocket science..
- golangnews 9y agoPlease tell us about your big failures as well - statistically you must have had some, and I’m sure you’ve been tracking them with equal rigour?
- Danihan 9y agoI've only invested in five stocks. Four are listed above, the fifth was basically an OTC penny stock in 2009 that eventually went out of business.
- noobhacker 9y agoThe typical argument why traders don't make money is not that the stock market behaves as a coin flip. The argument is that, if you see "obvious momentum," many others in the market are likely to see that too, and the current stock price already factors all of that information in. Of course, it is possible that one beats the market if either 1) one has privileged information, or 2) one has exceptional insight. Both situations are possible, but rather implausible.
- Danihan 9y agoI'd agree with that 100%. The coin flip example is what I was taking issue with. While it's a good illustration of survivorship bias, it does not apply to the stock market as the stock market isn't random.
- 9y ago
- pfarnsworth 9y agoStories about buying stocks is utterly useless. When did you sell? And what is you track record of wins vs losses?
- brianpgordon 9y agoThat kind of stock picking is dangerous. First, it's easy to look around your little bubble and see that people are lining up at your local Chipotle or that people use Google for solving tech support problems, and conclude that Chipotle and Google are taking off. They may be not be doing as well in other locales/sectors. And second, how do you know that these signs of promise aren't already priced in? If you can see signs that Chipotle is doing well, so can everyone else. And they have deeper pockets and better information-gathering capabilities than you do. Nowadays satellite imaging and computer vision are used to count the number of cars in parking lots of retailers to predict earnings! Lastly, there are innumerable complicating factors that the average retail investor has no idea how to account for. Maybe the stock price is low because their EBITDA is barely staying ahead of debt service payments. Did you read the SEC filings? Maybe they're having difficulties scaling their supply chain because they lost a big contract with a major supplier. Do you know enough about the domain to account for how much that should affect the stock price? Who knows, maybe there's even a seasonality factor to the number of people who go to eat spicy food, and your guesstimates will fall apart in 6 months. I wouldn't even bother with this kind of investing. It's just gambling. If you seem to be winning over time it's either because you're lucky or because the markets are going up in general. So just invest in index funds- you'll have lower volatility and you won't be betting against people who have nothing to do but sit around all day thinking about how to beat you.
- Danihan 9y agoI'm sure you're correct, all stock picking is dangerous though. I'd assert that my style is the least dangerous. > look around your little bubble I didn't (and don't) have a bubble. In fact, I frankly despise the Bay Area and SV because it constantly tries to put you in a liberal / wealthy bubble. >If you can see signs that Chipotle is doing well, so can everyone else. Apparently not, though. They doubled on IPO but most people were still VERY skeptical of them. I could see that they had 100% solved the problem of "fast casual" service. >Nowadays satellite imaging and computer vision are used to count the number of cars in parking lots of retailers to predict earnings! That should make you want to invest in the #1 company that manufactures satellite components.
- 9y ago
- nkrisc 9y agoHow many losers have you picked?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- georgeecollins 9y agoYour last five stock picks were winners. And yet strangely, every academic study done on this indicates that the chances your sixth pick outperforms the market is the same as someone whose last five picks are losers. I know it seems strange, but you are a living example of the lucky coin flipper analogy.
- kcorbitt 9y ago...Google's IPO was late 2004.
- modfodder 9y agoAre those the only stocks you have picked? Have you picked any that didn't do as well? Or any that were losers? What led you to miss on Apple or Priceline?
- Danihan 9y agoI picked one OTC penny stock loser in 2009 that went completely out of business. Something associated with vertical farming. I missed out on Apple because almost NOBODY used Apple in the Midwest in the mid 2000's -- everything was MS. That's a great example of me living in a bubble (which I just said in another comment that I didn't, but there ya go) I missed out on Priceline even though the tech support center I was working in had a whole division dedicated to doing their customer support! Basically, they just never seemed "legit" to me, they seemed like a scam, who the hell wants to "choose your own price" for something important like a flight and then wait and see if it gets accepted? Very weird to me. People also never seemed too excited about them in general... extremely hard to predict they would become the acquisition masters that they did. Both solid examples of blind spots in my strategy.
- donarb 9y ago“Everyone using their tech support” doesn’t appear to be a viable purchasing decision for a company’s stock.
- oaijdsfoaijsf 9y agoThose are all your stock picks in the last fifteen years? No losers at all?
- phlipski 9y agoHow'd you miss on Domino's Pizza? Could have picked it up for about $5/share back in November of 2008. Closed at $178 today. You'd be up about 3460% in 9 years. Google (+574%), Amazon (+2000%), or Chipotle (+350%) can't touch that - assuming you bought all three in November of 2008 and sold today.
- Danihan 9y agoI had no idea Dominos outperformed the rest of the food industry to that extent. Sort of crazy.
- timdierks 9y agoBuying Google pre-IPO is a very clever trade, you must be a market wizard.
- beagle3 9y agoAnd yet, you have rentec medallion, virtu, buffet, gross and quite a few others who have quite consistently beat the market. Each has their own secret sauce, and you won’t get their returns just by sitting at home and picking stocks. But they do prove that the market is far from random.
- zeefoo 9y agoNo, they're the good head flippers in the story; they simply got lucky, someone had to, random doesn't mean no one wins, it means the winner wins by chance.
- ryandrake 9y agoThose would be the few on the right-most side of the distribution who flipped heads 10 times in a row. As soon as they inevitably flip tails, we'll post facto find others who have gotten consistent returns and declare them to be the ones with the secret sauce.
- hidenotslide 9y agoVirtu trades 3 million shares a day, they are way out on the bell curve in terms of statistical significance. There are of course many risks to their business model, e.g. high fixed costs, competition, regulatory risk, technical malfunctions, etc. They are "lucky" to be in a position to capitalize on the opportunity, but investment luck does not play a role on a day to day basis.
- mrchicity 9y agoVirtu trades far more than 3 million shares a day. They may even make 3 million trades a day. If you've seen a system like this in action, it's a beautiful thing to behold and cannot be mere luck. Transactions stream in constantly. It's not just one big, lucky bet, but thousands of tiny bets with a slight edge. A plot of profit & loss with respect to time looks like an almost perfectly smooth upward line. And if you're good, you can do this every single day for years and years. Still, I wouldn't say guys like that have beaten the market in a real way. I've certainly never felt like I did. This style of trading doesn't need outside capital and can't scale. If I gave you $100 and armed you with a scalping bot, I bet you could easily turn it into $200 buying hot tickets on Ticketmaster and reselling them. But would anyone call you a genius trader? Could you do it with a million? A billion? As a business net of all costs like employee compensation and technology, returns to owners are pretty lousy. Compare owning Virtu stock to an index fund since their IPO. Ouch.
- yters 9y agoIf that student flipped 200 heads in a row it isn't survivorship bias. That student has a two headed coin.
- zeefoo 9y agoIt most certainly can be. 200 heads in a row is entirely possible in a random run.
- yters 9y agoIf you think 200 heads in a row is practically possible on a random flip, I have a bet to make with you.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoFlipping heads 200 Times is definitely possible, I can do the math to prove that. It is just greatly improbable to happen in the space or lifetime of the universe.
- yters 9y agoProbabilities can be so small they are only possible in a mathematical sense, but impossible practically speaking. When faced with such small probabilities we can use Bayes theorem to infer a better explanation than chance, such as a two headed coin.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agolol @ u spouting nonsense. i think your trying to say you can use bayes to adjust for small sample sizes, like with beta-binomial models, or comparing posterior distributions for different models and params.
- yters 9y agoTwo sequences of coin flips: HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH THTHTHHTHTHHHHHHHTTTHTHHHTHHTT Which was generated by fair coin, which by 2 headed? How did you decide?
- anonu 9y agoYeah, I hear ya. My "systematic profits" comments was in reference to a few firms and individuals I've observed over time. These people have some sort of structural or informational edge in the markets. There are commodity trading firms that are such substantial players in the markets they trade that they control that market. Certain High Frequency firms have scale and breadth of resources to get higher quality data, faster connections and hire guys that rewrite Linux process schedulers in assembly. Warren Buffet's secret weapon is that he never sells (so you never realize a loss!). The point being - anything else is gambling. And these guys - who look at a market structurally instead of some sort of casino - will eat your lunch in the long run. Their "edge" is actually orthogonal to price fluctuations. Just my 2 cents.
- notyourday 9y ago> Warren Buffet's secret weapon is that he never sells (so you never realize a loss!). That's not how mark-to-market accounting works.
- anonu 9y agoRoughly speaking - if you mark an asset lower than its purchase price you have an unrealized loss. You still hold the asset and - if you're taking the super long-term investment horizon view as Buffet does - eventually your asset will go up. In addition, Buffett gets into investments that probably wont have their business models disrupted anytime soon - and are tied to the success of the USA as a country: railroads, insurance, housing.If he does his stock picking right, he doesn't need to sell...
- notyourday 9y agoThat's not correct for public companies - the unrealized mark to market losses will be reported as losses via correctly (mark-to-market) valuing the asset on the balance sheet.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pfisch 9y agoThe stock market is not random though. If you have a person who previously worked at the fda specializing in kidneys for example, having that person analyze which kidney drugs/devices they think will get approved is not luck. People can have an informational advantage and use it to make intelligent trades.
- beiller 9y agoYou would be right if the stock prices actually 1:1 tracked business success. The reality is that they do not. The are an approximation of future growth, and that adds a great deal of uncertainty, sometimes enough to even make your anecdote moot.
- johnvonneumann 9y agoSo he is falling for a myth, yet what you're referring to is the Efficient Market Hypothesis, does the word "hypothesis" ring any bells for you? Even more so, does the fact that a theory that originated in the 1960's, still bares the name EMH. Almost 60 years on and it still hasn't been proven. Your thought process seems incredibly flawed, the idea you have about coin flipping being at all similar to stock picking is laughable. And this to me would indicate that whilst you may believe that your analogy is a good indication of survivorship bias, it is clear to me that you are suffering from confirmation bias. You're looking for examples that suit your belief, and ignoring some basic elements. Let's look at this one seriously, coin-flipping is an statistically independent event, whilst if we apply even some fundamentals of finance and EMH (which I don't agree with, btw), we will quickly find ourselves in the realm of correlation. I never stuck around Uni long enough to get deep into this stuff, but you could do with some reading on the CAPM model. To quote from wikipedia on the CAPM model: "Financial correlations play a key role in modern finance." You only have to look at the fact that many companies have been put out of business by companies like Amazon, which means that at the very minimum, you have at least ONE external factor that has an influence on the performance and price of other securities. And this is all without even starting on the even more hilarious notion that information across the market is symmetrical, that's right, I as a lowly consumer exchange peasant, have the exact same information available to me as Jim Simons and the team at RenTec. Who's Medallion Fund, by the way, returned a 35% CAR over a 20 year period. You have to be mental to believe the shit they teach in undergraduate Finance.
- csomar 9y agoYou got a nice story out there. Random, bla bla bla... How instead you come up with real numbers? Like you pick a stock or say an index like the Nasdaq and analyse if its movements are truly random or not? Also you are aware that true random might mean perfect distribution? You don't know whether the tick is up or down but you know you'll have a distribution that is 50/50 up or down. So you can market make based on it (buy and sell on the same time). There are more to trading than day trading: Collecting premium on futures or options, arbitrage, collecting interest on bonds, etc...