9 ms·
Why Timber Towers Are on the Rise in France
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- oaijdsfoaijsf 9y agoWood is a very cool material! But I would be nervous living in a tall building made out of it, because of its flammability. Maybe if all the wood buildings also have sprinkler systems, that would offset the risks. Our building is a concrete building about fourteen stories tall. The information we received as part of the lease tells us that it's known as a non-flammable building, and supposedly the safest thing to do if there is a fire on another floor is to shelter in place. I doubt the same would be true in any wood building. Oh, and apparently the article also speaks to this: > It’s also this heft that helps make CLT fire-resistant: the outside layers char slowly, protecting the wood inside from burning. (More on that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=UUGNoTP0Nlc1O-EWf3d1m3QQ&time_continue=36&v=hRIPQ_q2iyY https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=UUGNoTP0Nlc1O-EWf3d1m3QQ&...)
- sliverstorm 9y agoNot a fire scientist, but solid blocks of dense dry hardwood are actually comparatively quite resistant to ignition. They are not completely fireproof, but superior to many other modern building materials and furnishings. supposedly the safest thing to do if there is a fire on another floor is to shelter in place Of course, that's what they said about Grenfell.
- notl4wy3r 9y agoFortunately, my building still has the original brick cladding.
- wahern 9y agoDoes it have sprinklers? Lack of sprinklers is what doomed the Marco Polo condominium victims despite all the mitigations. "We've got three commercial fire hoses on every floor," he said. "We've got three CO2 bottles, big ones, on every floor. When we did the building originally, we thought we have enough equipment at the time, so the fire will never transfer to another unit. We have 45-minute fire doors, so if we have a fire, we can keep it to one unit." ... "Solid, concrete and pre-stressed -- it’s the best.” said Schmidt. It was designed to accommodate natural, tradewind ventilation, but he thinks those winds also helped to feed the fire. -- http://www.kitv.com/story/35948583/long-time-marco-polo-resident-shares-building-history-concerns http://www.kitv.com/story/35948583/long-time-marco-polo-resi...
- blattimwind 9y agoA piece of beech firewood lasts about 2-4 hours in a wood stove, which is pretty impressive methinks. (However, construction timber isn't hardwood and never beech).
- peterwwillis 9y agoLarge solid timber beams actually burn incredibly slowly: partly because they're so dense, and because wood is a good insulator. For a similar thickness beam, wood takes much longer to fail than steel when superheated. At 1100F, steel starts turning into spaghetti. But on wood, the layer of carbon created by the char becomes an insulating barrier that reduces heat on the non-charred side by up to 90%. A bigger concern to me is the wood rotting from exposure to water or chemicals. Although reinforced concrete also "rots", but in different ways. Wood at least tends to sag before failing from rotting, unlike concrete. I'm kind of surprised they don't utilize things like steel torsion boxes for the foundations instead of concrete, but perhaps there's cost considerations. They could do a lot of fancy things to extend the size of wooden buildings using steel if they don't mind losing those fire retardant properties. Also, it should be mentioned that wood-based buildings can re-ignite after an initial fire, which doesn't happen with steel or concrete. While you may escape the fire and the fire gets put out, the structure may still not be safe. We may need new fire codes if these buildings become commonplace.
- chrishacken 9y ago"A bigger concern to me is the wood rotting from exposure to water or chemicals. Although reinforced concrete also "rots", but in different ways. Wood at least tends to sag before failing from rotting, unlike concrete." This. We just moved our office into a 100+ year old wood building. We're doing the renovating ourselves. Most of the wood in the building is rotting or uneven. I've spent a week so far leveling the floors. Every old (70+ years old) building I've ever been in is like this; some worse than others. We have our datacenter in a stone/concrete building that was built in 1912. While it has also deteriorated, it's not nearly as bad as the wooden buildings. The floors have cracks in them, but they're still level for the most part, or easily repairable. The building will easily be standing for another 200+ years. I can't say the same for the wood building.
- peterwwillis 9y agoYou really don't know that about concrete buildings without inspection, and possibly core sampling of the concrete. You don't know what the true grade of the concrete is or whether it's thick enough depending on loading. And you need to look for signs of common failure modes such as carbonation, chloride penetration, freeze/thaw cycles, alkali-aggregate reactions, etc. Most concrete failures can penetrate the entire slab before showing outward signs. And concrete slabs have 'exploded' from as little as 200C of heat due to trapped water vapor. This assumes it's earthquake-code concrete construction. A mostly-stone building will be perfectly fine, though :)
- tryingagainbro 9y agoSame here. I am going to offset the carbon thing in other ways, wooden buildings are just too dangerous. A 3 year with "mommy look how cool this is" can burn the house down in 3-4 minutes. Who has the FD right outside the house and ready to go 24/7?. A concrete house on the other hand might need the plaster taken down and you're ready to re-plaster and move in. Or just clean and paint. Plus no squeaky stairs, ever :)
- detaro 9y agoIf that were true, wooden buildings would be more expensive to insure against fire damage than non-wooden ones. Turns out, a (properly designed and built) predominantly wooden building can get the same or (even better, depending on what it is compared against) ratings. EDIT: adjusted wording to clarify re "wood framed"
- tryingagainbro 9y agothey cost the same? https://www.google.com/search?q=fire+insurance+wooden+vs+concrete https://www.google.com/search?q=fire+insurance+wooden+vs+con...
- detaro 9y agoThat's at least figures family friends got for their buildings, not sure about the details. One thing I notice is that the top search results are about "wooden framed" - the house in question was predominantly wooden and thus more massive wood construction than just wood framing is. If I think about it, I suspect this might not apply to larger buildings like those discussed in the article, (unless fixing partially damaged structures is easier? Don't know how the internal details work)
- roel_v 9y agoThis article isn't talking about what American's (and Australians, and Canadians, and Brits) consider 'wood buildings'. Apples and oranges.
- Spooky23 9y agoIt all depends. Personally I don’t believe any claim like that unless the building is like new and above the local fire departments ladder reach. I’ve been personally acquainted with about 10 building emergencies, including minor fires, and in 7/10 cases the facilities management made material errors in response and education that would kill many people in a more serious emergency. You should have zero trust in anything they say. Seemingly innocuous changes to the building can dramatically reduce your chances of survival in a high rise fire. Bug out is always the best strategy, assuming there is adequate egress. If there isn’t adequate egress, don’t live there.
- wongarsu 9y agoSolid wood burns very slowly, your choice of carpet and furniture will make a much bigger impact to making it out than the difference between wood and concrete beams. Of course a wood building is more likely to be a total loss after a fire, so in terms of property damage it's a major consideration. In terms of loss of live, I doubt it makes a major difference as long as all wood has sufficient thickness.
- koliber 9y agoI have lived in the US and in Europe. In the US, house fires are an almost everyday occurrence. In Europe, they happen much more rarely. I would imagine that the interior decor is fairly on par in both places, and contributes similarly to the initial risk of fire. It makes sense that major fires occur more often in the US than Europe, if you think about it. In the US, under the carpet or other flooring material you have wooden floorboards, with air spaces below them. This burns rather well. The structural elements are also made off wood. Once either of these catch on fire, poof. In Europe, the immediate surface of the floor may be made of wood or another flammable material, but it is attached directly to the concrete substrate. This is much more difficult to burn. The article did mention that this is pressed laminate wood which is treated not to burn, but rather char slowly. I hope that this type of construction is going to stand up to fire better than the current American wooden construction methods.
- KaiserPro 9y agoThe vast majority of UK housing stock is also suspended wood flooring. However there are vast differences in fire and electrical safety standards. There has been a concerted effort since the 80s to remove flammable sofas, carpets & mattresses. By luck rockwool was the insulation of choice for many years, unlike the states which either used spray foam or some other PE substance. The standard of electrical safety in the US is comparable to 1960s Britain. (In the UK every plug & every socket _must_ have a fuse. effectively any electrical works demands that RCDs must be installed, which dramatically cut the risk of electrical fires. )
- rsynnott 9y agoNote that fire safety and electrical standards are also very different in the US. My impression has always been that you _can_ make a wood-framed house, at least, as fire safe as a brick or concrete one, but it's considerably easier for fire safety to be screwed up via improper construction or modifications.
- FRex 9y agoMany if not most of 'fire' victims actually die due to burns to respiratory system due to hot smoke inhalation, suffocate via carbon dioxide displacing oxygen, get poisoned by carbon monoxide or cyanide compounds, etc. Dying of burns is so hard that even some people who self immolate 'only' die days after or suffer life long impairment. It doesn't matter if the building doesn't burn because all the furniture in people flats will produce 'enough' heat and smoke in minutes, see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0KSl9s6GjgY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0KSl9s6GjgY
- Swizec 9y agoBloody hell that is terrifying! Short of having a barren apartment, is there anything you can do to guard against this?
- azernik 9y agoA wet cloth over the mouth/nose will catch a lot of the particulates and water-soluble vapors, though it won't help a lot with the heat.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoMaking sure your sprinklers are in working order seems like a good start. Also, based on the video I'd say "don't keep dry Christmas trees around." I dunno how they ignited that tree, but it went from fine to ceiling-high inferno in four seconds flat. I don't think typical furniture will catch nearly that fast in typical home-fire circumstances (overheated electrical devices, dropped cigarettes, etc). I wonder if keeping the tree in a watering stand and topping it up regularly helps.
- wahern 9y agoLooks like it: https://www.fema.gov/media-library/assets/videos/76417 https://www.fema.gov/media-library/assets/videos/76417 Though, not sure what "Needle moisture content > 100%" means. That it's transpiring?
- 9y ago
- SCAQTony 9y agoAfter that terrible fire in England I would recommend getting a 150-meter climbing rope, a harness and an aluminum "figure-eight" and learn how to repel as a means of escape in case the smoke became far too overwhelming. But that's just me. I live in a house.
- EGreg 9y agoI had an invention that could help many people escape from a building: Magnetic strips on the side of the building, and backpacks with metal. You put on the backpack and shimmy down. Just in case, you also strap yourself onto the slide by its sides, so as not to disconnect from it and fall off. This is better than a rope because it can hold many people simultaneously. Do the magnets wear out over time though?
- make3 9y agoor if you've lost too much weight or there is crap on the magnet and less friction, and suddenly your stuck in the air pasted to a burning building xD
- vlehto 9y agoMagnets are probably way too expensive. Especially as you could get same functionality with regular fire ladder.
- EGreg 9y agoHow would you shimmy down the ladder? But yes I suppose technically you can have rollers in vertical struts and have them roll down inside the rails, carrying the person.
- peterwwillis 9y agoNot that I'm telling anyone to rappel down a building, but there are at least four ways to rappel or lower yourself with just a rope and no gear (I highly recommend getting a professional to teach you first). But even so, most new apartments on high floors have aluminum ladders to deploy out a window.
- roel_v 9y agoThis article doesn't mention it, but often when wood is used in 'modern' ways, it's laminated wood, and treated with fire-retardant materials. A contractor proposed a 'wooden' beam to me in one of my buildings a few years ago, in a place where traditionally it would have been steel, and the beam they ended up putting in looked like it was about equal amounts of wood and resin (that's an exaggeration of course - just saying, you could still recognize it as wood, but it's nothing like 'chop the sides off this log to square it and toss it in'; today's construction wood (in big(er) projects) in Europe isn't anything like 'building with wood' in the rest of the world). Plus, a building that is framed with high-density wood beams is different (in terms of fire propagation properties) from an Anglo-Saxon style building of cheap (i.e., low density) timber 2x4's with sheet rock cladding.
- fsloth 9y agoDude, CLT (cross laminated timber) is so dense it hardly chars. It's not the structure, it's what you hurbish it with that will cause the problems and this is a fact regardless of the material used for the structure (e.g. Grenfell towers disaster)
- goldenkey 9y agoAye that cladding is so important. Really terrible that the older building would have been less flammable before shoddy renovations. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grenfell_Tower_fire https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grenfell_Tower_fire
- thisisit 9y ago"The production of cement, one of the main ingredients in concrete, generates an estimated 5 percent of the world’s carbon emissions. Trees, in contrast, capture CO2, helping offset emissions produced by a typical building process." If I am reading this correctly it's the trees and not timber, laminated or otherwise, which capture CO2. So what kind of advantage does timber offer in form of CO2 emission? Specially considering the tree is now gone and this article doesn't cover if there is re-plantation - something like sow a 5 plants of each tree used for timber.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tree_farm#Tree_farming_and_climate_change https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tree_farm#Tree_farming_and_cli... > Because tree farms are managed to enhance rapid growth, a tree farm tends to sequester carbon more quickly than an unmanaged forest, considering only the sequestration side of the equation and not the carbon release due to rot, fire, or harvest.[10] The fact that managed woodlands tend to be younger and younger trees grow faster and die less contributes to this distinction.[11] > While tree farms absorb large amounts of CO2, the long-term sequestration of this carbon depends on what is done with the harvested materials. Forests continue to absorb atmospheric carbon for centuries if left undisturbed.
- nostoc 9y agoTimber is carbon that a tree has pulled from the atmosphere. As long as it stays in a building, it's not going back in the atmosphere. Planting trees and turning them into timber is a form of carbon sequestration. As long as it doesn't burn or decay...
- sametmax 9y agoAlso France forests are ones of the most well managed in the world. We consistently have more trees growing than being cut.
- hcurtiss 9y agoThat's also true in the US. We have way more trees today than we did 100 years ago. https://www.mnn.com/earth-matters/wilderness-resources/stories/more-trees-than-there-were-100-years-ago-its-true https://www.mnn.com/earth-matters/wilderness-resources/stori...
- robbrown451 9y agoThere is something bothersome to me about using all that wood only to cover it up. Concrete is ugly and wood is beautiful, in my opinion. I hope they leave a lot of the wood visible.
- virmundi 9y agoAs a person replacing a 130 year old sill plate, cover up structural wood. Termites and water can destroy it.
- wahern 9y agoIf it's covered, how can you tell when there's damage? We recently had seismic plywood shear walls installed in our soft story garage, holding up our 2 stories of living space. A previous owner actually had shear walls installed in 1992, after the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake. But the '92 retrofit used the wrong grade of plywood, and used screws instead of nails. Screws have poor shear strength. The panels were basically useless for seismic safety and had to be replaced. The 90-year-old redwood studs looked surprisingly pristine. But one of the studs had some kind of termite or fungal damage. The entire stud, top to bottom, basically disintegrated in your hands; but everything else was in perfect shape, including the sills. There were no outward signs of this at all--neither on the stud itself, on adjacent studs, nor the top or bottom sill plates. It was bizarre. And it would have gone totally unnoticed and maybe even spread, completely undetected, had the old panels not been removed. The shear walls weren't the only things improperly installed. The 1992 foundation bolts didn't use adequately sized washers, so with enough movement the bolt heads would have ripped through the sill plate. Again, this was hidden behind the wall panels. I grew up in Florida trailer parks. To me anything covered is hiding something--cockroaches, termites, substandard construction. Were there no need for the shear walls, I'd much prefer to have exposed studs and a completely exposed sill plate, at least in the garage.
- oasisbob 9y agoWithin a building envelope, if you have water or termite ingress you're already hosed and a layer of paint or gypsum isn't going to save you. The cross-laminated timbers aren't going to be the first thing to rot. In a traditional wood framed building you're looking at the sill plates, the sheathing, perhaps the end of the joists. The high-rise construction shown in the article seems to avoid most of that - the SIPs don't appear to use much wood except the facade.
- EGreg 9y agoWhat about the risk of fire, as they had in Chicago and London etc.
- rsynnott 9y agoAssuming you're talking about Grenfell, that was an old concrete building. The fire was so deadly due to improperly specced and/or installed exterior cladding which had recently been added; nothing to do with wood.
- tschwimmer 9y agoSomething I'm surprised that nobody's mentioned yet are the acoustics of a wooden building. Wood is less dense when compared to concrete and (at least in older buildings) there are significant air gaps between ceiling and floorboards of the floor above it. As anyone who's lived in an SF Victorian will tell you even regular walking can be perceived as loud by the person below. Before I'd consider living in a wooden building, I'd have to be convinced that the noise isolation would be sufficient. I wonder if it's been accounted for properly in these new buildings.
- cm2187 9y agoBy the way, is it the same with high rise, glass towers? I live in a mid size (20 floors) modern-ish building (1999) with excellent acoustic insulation (as in spotless, never heard a whisper from a neighbor). But the building is made of concrete with some windows. I am comparing that to high rise towers (50-60 floors) where you only have a thin layer of concrete between floors but no concrete between apartments (probably to keep the weight down). Wouldn't you expect these towers to have structurally poor acoustic insulation?
- cstuder 9y agoAs someone living in a modern wood building I can tell you that this is really not a problem anymore. Our floors are filled with anhydrite, they are solid. Only when the kids upstairs are _really_ wild you can hear their steps.
- boobsbr 9y agoAs someone living in a wooden house, I can say it's still problem. Even walking barefooted upstairs can be heard from downstairs. Floorboards creak and make noise. Only places that don't make this noise are the bathroom and kitchen, which have tiled concrete floors.
- throwanem 9y agoHow old a house?
- ApplePrincess 9y ago"The production of cement, one of the main ingredients in concrete, generates an estimated 5 percent of the world’s carbon emissions. Trees, in contrast, capture CO2, helping offset emissions produced by a typical building process."
- humanARO 9y agoThe production of cement, one of the main ingredients in concrete, generates an estimated 5 percent of the world’s carbon emissions
- bcn 9y agoHere are a few renderings of the "Arboretum" project that was mentioned in the article- http://www.laisneroussel.com/fr/projects/55 http://www.laisneroussel.com/fr/projects/55
- Animats 9y agoThis trend towards large multi-story timber apartment buildings is worrying. That used to be prohibited in many US jurisdictions. Now I see San Jose and Redwood City putting up lots of these things. "Luxury apartments" made of chipboard. The fire protection people aren't happy about this.[1] There's a fad for "podium buildings". The first two floors are steel and concrete, and then there are a few floors of wood. These appear in areas where you're not allowed wood construction for commercial buildings. The bottom floors are commercial; the upper floors are residential. [1] https://community.nfpa.org/community/nfpa-today/blog/2017/03/21/recent-fires-in-apartment-buildings-under-construction-highlight-the-importance-of-developing-a-fire-safety-program-and-designating-a-fire-prevention-manager-during-construction https://community.nfpa.org/community/nfpa-today/blog/2017/03...
- jkaljundi 9y agoModern wood is much more fire resistant than concrete or steel https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-3oEb8KUiQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-3oEb8KUiQ - it's an imaginary myth, that wood is dangerous.
- scythe 9y agoWood constructed buildings are fire resistant. The article he linked discusses fires in buildings under construction recently. All wood is flammable, but insulation goes a long way.
- KaiserPro 9y agoIts not the wood thats the fire hazard, its the plastic isolation, or terrible electrical standards
- sjg007 9y agoI saw these two all up and down El Camino along the train. Even saw a new hotel being built the same way (San Carlos new Marriot)..
- bastijn 9y agoSo how much of earth do we need to cover with forest to have a sustainable production for our buildings at a level that it actually matters? One building works, sure enough. But is it scalable to a level that it actually helps? I have my doubts. Bringing awareness is still a good thing of course. Which is how I tend to see most of these projects.
- jtolmar 9y agoIf I did all my math/googling right, one acre of managed forest can produce about thirty square meters of the 20-inch-thick panels mentioned in the article per year. (A typical wood weighing 0.4 tons per square meter and a managed forest producing about 6 tons per acre per year.) I'll guess it takes around four of those acre-year units to build one person's worth of an apartment building. (Thirty square meters is on the small side for an apartment, and apartments need walls, but they're also not going to be entirely constructed of the thickest panels.) My home city of Seattle is growing at about 20k people per year, which (if we try to fit them all in wooden highrises) works out to 80k acres, which is roughly the size of the city itself. I feel like that'd be entirely reasonable. It's also worth noting that this sequesters a rather appreciable amount of carbon (trees are half carbon, so about 240 kilotons per year).
- mseebach 9y agoAlso, if we're considering ecological foot print, structural use of wood is near-permanent sequestering (ie. carbon-negative) which is better than most other uses of wood such as burning for fuel which is "only" carbon-neutral.
- pyrale 9y ago> one acre of managed forest can produce about thirty square meters of the 20-inch-thick panels mentioned in the article per year. > I'll guess it takes around four of those acre-year units to build one person's worth of an apartment building. France has about 30 million acres of privately held forest. Let's assume that half of this surface produces at your estimated rate, and 20% of that production goes to building: that would be about 3 million acres or 750.000 new individual units per year. With about 775-800k births in recent years, this would be fine.
- frik 9y ago"Timber Towers" work for up to about 10-story building (depending on architecture, building technique). It's similar to brick and mortar buildings, only with the introduction of cement and steel we got the first high rise skyscrapers (1890s-1930s). Also fire-safety (30+ min fire resistance) is a problem with wood based buildings, the photos shows that at least the elevator and staircase shaft is made out of steel reinforced concrete. That said wood based buildings have a warmer in-house climate and other positive aspects.
- teekert 9y agoPerhaps it's difficult to convey but I redid a lot of the interior of my current (brick and mortar) home from the 1930's myself and it really made me appreciate wood as a building material. Strong, very easily made into the required shape, easy to attach to each other, easy to attach other things to... I always felt wood was "how we used to do it"... not anymore. Guess this place is a good as any to express my found love for the material.
- rsync 9y ago"Guess this place is a good as any to express my found love for the material." I agree with you but I would point out that the buildings and their "wood" materials that the article discusses are really not anything like what you worked with. The article speaks about wood and trees and "timbers" but these building materials are engineered panels and timbers that, while in many cases actually stronger than their "real wood" counterparts, do not have the aesthetics you remember. I would go so far as to suggest that they are moving not from concrete to wood construction, but from concrete to glue construction.
- teekert 9y agoAh, good clarification, indeed I mostly used pinewood for inside and Azobe and Meranti for outside (though some composite for the parts we walk on). But The pleasure was mostly from being able to drills holes and put screws in with a light cordless drill and saw it in the right shape either by hand or a light jig saw. It's carry-able and still very strong. I guess this also applies to the used composite materials your describe?
- yoyohoneysingh 9y agoGuess this place is a good as any to express my found love for the material.
- sigu1 9y agoI am reading this correctly it's the trees and not timber, laminated or otherwise, which capture CO2.
- Iv 9y agoTrees capture CO2, timber stores it. Trees only capture CO2 while they grow. If you cut down mature tree and let another tree grow, while you store its carbon in constructions, you are effectively creating a carbon capture process.
- eksemplar 9y agoIs the clue and fire resistance safe to breathe though?
- anovikov 9y agoIt's rather stupid to worry about global warming here, as concrete use in France is less than 1% of what it is in China anyway.
- sailorman 9y agoIt's strange when I hear about fires.
- MrFantastic 9y agoConcrete buildings can last for centuries. There are few wood buildings that last that long. I would think something like aerocrete would also provide superior insulation.
- jasonmaydie 9y agoHow is cutting down trees better for climate change? Don't we need more trees?
- pirocks 9y agoTrees will be planted to replace these trees assuming the timber is sourced correctly; also the carbon bound up on the wood is staying in the wood.
- johngalt 9y agoThink of trees as co2 batteries. They take in co2 to create wood then release it back when they burn or decay. If you plant a tree farm and use the wood to create buildings you are effectively doing carbon sequestration.