17 ms·
Tesla posts big loss, cuts production of Models X and S to catch up on Model 3
- pwinnski 9y agoThe first two zones of a four-zone process to produce battery packs are being completely reworked, and this is something they only found out about after they were already failing to deliver on promised production goals? I've mis-estimated a lot of things in my career, so I'm trying to be sympathetic, but it seems like someone with production line experience should have been able to test individual parts of the production line before committing to thousands of units per month.
- sixQuarks 9y agoAs much as I'm a fan of Elon, the Model 3 production always had me worried when they kept having to replace senior production and battery executives in the run up. I'm still very bullish on Tesla long-term, but I think the Model 3 will be a fiasco unless some sort of miracle happens, and we haven't even gotten into initial quality problems that may arise once enough units are in customer hands.
- vkou 9y agoInitial quality problems may not arise. They will definitely arise. It's a brand-new model, with brand-new (To TESLA) manufacturing processes - there will always be problems in this situation. What they should hope for is for these problems to arise sooner, rather then later - lessening the cost of recalls.
- aquadrop 9y agoMusk didn't promise those goals, it's what they hoped for. Best case scenario.
- avs733 9y agoSo I apologize that this is basically assertion based and vague but I need to protect friends a little bit. I went to undergrad for mechanical engineering at a university generally known for turning out good auto industry engineers. A few years out of school (maybe 2010-11?) I noticed a lot of my alumni friends were starting to move from places like Honda, Toyota, GM, etc. to Tesla. These were the friends I would generally have considered the most motivated and best engineers I graduated with or new in college. To a man (pardon the gendering) they are not at Tesla anymore. They have all left, most for other startups, and they all left disillusioned with the internal Tesla management. They all left completely burned out. They basically felt that a lot of managers with experience in software were brought in and made very bad assumptions about the translation of software development to mechanical device manufacturing...and wouldn't let go of them. Its not that those assumptions NEVER transfer but they don't ALWAYS transfer. Manufacturing ramp up is really really really really hard. Intel has a 10 billion dollar site in Oregon that does nothing but figure out how to put together a manufacturing process that minimally functions and then figure out how to scale it up. Ramping manufacturing is different than designing the parts. You have layers and layers and layers of design. The big OEM's use suppliers not just to outsource cost and employee management but because they allow those companies to build expertise in a specific area that the OEM then no longer has to maintain. I heard stories from friends there about Tesla managers trying to be "Apple like" and demand tighter tolerances on every dimension of a part, driving up not just cost but lead time as suppliers tried to figure out how to retool their whole process to meet the request. I heard stories of requests to design custom bolts to use throughout the process for no discernible reason. That custom bolt (1) means longer design time, because a part that shouldn't have to be designed has to be designed, (2) means greater cost, (3) and means a supplier has to ramp up their own manufacturing of a new part - but hey blame the supplier. I think the most interesting ones were related to internal culture. Tesla is a car company...I know there are all these cool elements of an office we expect of a startup, but having a beer cart rolling around on Friday's at a car company may not send the best image. I now work at a couple universities (grad student/lecturer) and Tesla is the hot employee all the students want, not unsurprisingly, and they are all about campus recruiting. That can work great, but it relies on having a strong base of experienced engineers to train these people. Tesla has not managed to hold on to that experience from my limited dataset and is instead replacing them with cheap inexperienced labor attracted by the 'aspirational' nature of Tesla as an employee. From the pool of friends I have seen go to SpaceX, I have not heard the same things.
- marvin 9y agoFascinating account. Thanks for sharing.
- chollida1 9y agoSince this came out as part of the Tesla earnings, here's my recap from their earnings release and call.... - Tesla will be late getting up to 5,000 units a week of Model 3. It will happen at the end of Q1 instead of the end of this year. The bottleneck is batteries. - Some lines are at only 500 cars a week. Namely the battery pack assembly, body shop welding and final vehicle assembly. - The $2.92 a share loss was much bigger than the $2.27 analysts expected. - The company burned $1.4 billion and has $3.5 billion in cash. Raising money shouldn't be necessary. - Automotive gross margins fell from 28% to about 18% and will slip to 15% next quarter. - Auto revenue grew 10% to $2.4 billion as sales of Model S and X grew. Revenue is at risk, though. Tesla will divert resources from Model S and X to the Model 3. - Tesla didn't say much about China. The company added a supercharger station with 50 chargers in Shanghai, but no word on a new plant. - Musk expects to spend $1 billion on capital expenditures next quarter. That's consistent with expectations for ramp up for Model 3. - Tesla installed 109 megawatts of ``energy generation systems'' in the third quarter. It acknowledges this is an underwhelming figure: ``the lower deployments are in large part a result of deliberately de-emphasizing commercial and industrial solar energy projects with low profit and limited cash generation.'' As to the battery delay.... Tesla says it's the suppliers fault. "key elements" of the battery module assembly had to be taken over and redesigned, Musk says. EDIT - most importantly, Elon has moved his desk to the giga factory as that is where the largest bottleneck is.
- williamscales 9y ago"key elements" of the battery module assembly had to be taken over and redesigned, Musk says. Tesla seems to be taking the opposite approach to Apple here. In my observation, Apple drives its suppliers extremely hard to achieve the quality it requires. Tesla, on the other hand, is too eager to bring any sundry part in house (e.g. car seats). Apple's approach appears to work in that it pushes suppliers to do what's necessary. I worry that Tesla, having already bitten off a large bite to chew, is inviting too much distraction that will, in the long run, not put Tesla in a stronger position (there is a reason most automobile manufacturers outsource their seats after all).
- btian 9y ago
- dogruck 9y agoAs an engineer who has zero investment in Tesla, I truly hope they overcome this setback. Simultaneously, I know from experience that failure is a real possibility. At this point, it’s nice to have the additional transparancy into the current production bottleneck.
- colordrops 9y agoWhat would failure look like? Worst case outcome to me seems that they would just take longer to get to their goals rather than not achieve them at all. They have enough money in the bank and no unsolved technical issues - it's not black hole physics. I mean they've delivered cars already. They just are slower than expected at scaling up.
- selectodude 9y agoTheir burn rate is incredible. If they run out of money and nobody is there to give them more, they file for bankruptcy.
- aquadrop 9y agoThey burn it that fast because it brings more money in the future and they have funds reserve. Their net loss is getting smaller proportionally to the revenue constantly. They could stop capital investments any moment and be profitable, but that would mean much slower growth later.
- jklp 9y agoNot sure that's the case as looking at this graph from The Verge, their revenues are growing but their losses are also getting larger proportionally to their revenues. https://www.theverge.com/2017/11/1/16593582/tesla-model-3-production-q3-largest-quarterly-loss https://www.theverge.com/2017/11/1/16593582/tesla-model-3-pr...
- prostoalex 9y agoThe burn rate numbers need more scrutiny as they include recurring expenses (salaries and materials) as well as one-time investments into Gigafactory and automated production lines for Model 3.
- sumitgt 9y agoOut of curiosity, has anyone who paid the $1000 to get in line for a Model 3 actually heard back from Tesla? I've never received any communication about timelines at all.
- nik736 9y agoMe neither. Also, I am trying to get my $1000 back for 2 months now since it probably would take around 2 years until I get my Model 3. They are delaying and delaying the payout, so instead of me becoming a Tesla customer I am hating them more from day to day.
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y agoWeird, aren't Tesla selling any more places in that waiting list for the same price? A place better than last would even be worth more, no?
- Avshalom 9y agoIf what you want is a Tesla 3: yes, probably. If what you want is a(n electric) car: no.
- kemiller 9y agoI got mine back fairly quickly, for what it's worth.
- shpx 9y agoI canceled my pre order on June 29 and got the money from paypal on August 18.
- moxious 9y agoThe longer they hold it, the less likely you'll ever get it if things go bad.
- nunez 9y agoChargeback?
- ww520 9y agoTSLA was up 10 points. Now is down 10 points. Interesting time.
- r00fus 9y ago20 point swing? We call that Wednesday.
- SaltySolomon 9y agoNot really all that suprising.
- 0xCMP 9y agoEspecially not with other articles talking about lack of the right production mindset or process[0]. I'm a bit worried these days for Tesla cause these seem like problems stemming from ego of "doing it better through technology" and ignoring wisdom from the rest of the industry that actually works. When major leadership keeps leaving[1] it feels like it's more of an ego, expectations, and political problem than a technical one. [0]: https://mondaynote.com/teslas-new-car-smell-315c72c955d3 https://mondaynote.com/teslas-new-car-smell-315c72c955d3 [1]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-05-04/two-tesla-production-chiefs-to-leave-ahead-of-biggest-challenge-yet https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-05-04/two-tesla...
- SaltySolomon 9y agoI feel like they are trying to invent the wheel anew. Yes, electric cars have some differences, but everything besides the drive system has been a ton of times and there are a lot of companies and people who know how to get what you want. Also I agree with you that it feels that they belive that they can do everything better than anybody else and thus try to do everything themselves.
- pmurT 9y agoI've been considering cancelling my preorder. As late as they'll be (assuming they do deliver) and my estimated place in line, the other manufacturers will have competitive offerings
- maxerickson 9y agoHow does the Bolt compare to what you expect to get from Tesla?
- drewg123 9y agoI test drove one. It was fairly ok, but the seats were uncomfortable. The big objective thing that the Bolt is missing is a fast charging network. For now, nothing can touch Tesla's supercharger network in terms of charging speed and locations.
- rootusrootus 9y agoI wonder how valuable that charging network will end up being long-term. With the Bolt delivering 238 miles of range, and that number likely to go up some more in the next few years, it seems like a fairly small niche of people that actually benefit from superchargers. Especially as the number of end-point chargers increases. Which isn't to say that it won't be a valuable marketing tool, however -- range anxiety is definitely going to be a thing for a while.
- prostoalex 9y agoFor one, Tesla superchargers in NorCal and SoCal are insanely busy, with lines and valets during busy hours, so the usage is definitely there. Head over to TeslaMotorsClub forums or Facebook group for owners to witness the mini-dramas playing out regarding hogged supercharger spots. For two, if someone is considering buying a new car, and their daily commute is 3 miles each way, but once a year they take a 200-mile road trip (relatives, beach, mountain vacation), the lack of fast and convenient charging options severely lowers the chance they will consider that 238-mile-range vehicle. Both the number and reliability of public chargers needs to increase drastically - there’s a couple of free Volta chargers by the grocery store I frequent, 70% of the time they’re taken and 20% they’re inoperative. Just a slight bummer for me, as I can charge at home, but a huge bummer for someone who is on a road trip down to their last 20 miles, and was planning to do a major recharge there.
- perseusprime11 9y agoI feel like I should cancel my reservation of Tesla Model 3. Something tells me that subscription-based autonomous cars will be here before my Model 3 and will render purchasing cars useless. Anybody in a similar boat?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rootusrootus 9y agoWhile I agree that the Tesla 3 backorder delay is pretty long, I think you may be underestimating the time it will take before we see any subscription-based autonomous cars by perhaps a factor of 5.
- jfoster 9y agoProbably depends on where you live. It looks like a near-certainty that Waymo (aka Google) will be expanding their Early Rider programme significantly within the next 2 years, but only to particular areas.
- PatientTrades 9y agoTesla best car I ever owned. I will wait 6 months if that what it takes for perfection.
- j7ake 9y agoWhat makes it better than other cars of similar price range in your opinion ?
- StephenMelon 9y agoWhy are you downgrading then? Isn’t that a bit like buying an iPhone X and waiting several years excitedly in line for 5S?
- ericabiz 9y agoSeekingAlpha predicted this a few weeks ago: https://seekingalpha.com/article/4114125-will-tesla-zero-month https://seekingalpha.com/article/4114125-will-tesla-zero-mon... "Leading up to the end of September, we saw new-high Model 3 VIN numbers in the wild almost every other day, culminating in number 521. But since the beginning of October, nothing. I can’t find a single one above 521 with VIN picture evidence on any forum. It’s unlikely to end up this way, but the sole evidence we have to date is this: Tesla is on track to deliver zero Model 3 units in October. Of course, I don’t believe it will be exactly zero. However, it’s no longer an impossibility. It’s looking like my previous estimate of 240 units may be way too high." Tesla says today they produced only 260 vehicles in October--and it's unlikely very many of those got all the way to end users! From SeekingAlpha October 17: "At this stage, I'll continue to roll the dice one more time in favor of betting that for a third full month, the Chevrolet Bolt EV will out-sell the Tesla Model 3 in the U.S. - and probably by a very wide margin, along the lines or 10:1 or more. Maybe even 100:1 or an infinite margin." Even if you consider Elon Musk a sort of demigod (as much of the tech industry seems to), the leap from 260 vehicles a month--which indicates the vehicles are still being made mostly by hand--to 5,000 a week is going to be incredibly difficult to make in just a few short months.
- revelation 9y agoOne or another amateur writer on that site predicts the bankruptcy of Tesla every other week. Even a stopped clock is right once a day.
- galeaspablo 9y agoTwice
- neilalexander 9y agoI can't help but feel that price is an inevitable factor here. Tesla Model S and Model X are expensive! Now that the novelty is wearing off and more EVs are hitting the road from other manufacturers, it strikes me that they just won't remain competitive models. I expect the Model 3 to go some way towards helping this by being much more affordable, but with delayed production on those and an interior design that won't suit everyone, I'm yet to be convinced.
- mmanfrin 9y agoI disagree completely. Tesla has 400k people who put down a grand to 'reserve a spot in line' for a Model 3. The issue is production. Tesla fired off hundreds of workers a month ago, right as they were ramping up Model 3 production. Elon seems an awesome person in terms of what he's doing at a macro level, but he sounds like a horrendous person to work for.
- neilalexander 9y agoLike I said, the Model 3 will go some way to help that by being more affordable, and 400,000 people reserving a Model 3 does not make the Model S or the Model X any less expensive or any more competitive. Of course, the profit margin on the Model 3 stands to be substantially less, too.
- thedrbrian 9y agoHow many of that 400,000 are speculators trying to make a quick buck? Can go wrong for them, see the number of delivery mileage Focus RSs that are selling second hand for less than Ford want for a new one.
- ac29 9y agoIf they can achieve the production goal of 5000/week (an order of magnitude more than they are currently at), it will take nearly 2 years to just fulfill pre-orders. I have to believe a lot of people will be cancelling their pre-orders, and Tesla wont be getting many new pre-orders until production has caught up with demand.
- 9y ago
- mudil 9y agoElon's ROAs (returns on announcements) are getting slimmer.
- jeffdavis 9y agoWhat is the main practical selling point of a model 3 over, say, a leaf? Longer range and that's it? Good thing tesla has a lot of vertical investment in batteries. The market is very competitive.
- sliken 9y agoFun to drive, relatively attractive, better safety features (active and passive), more interior space (nice for 4 adults, tight for 5), and access to the tesla supercharging network.
- vvanders 9y agoSupercharger network is a pretty big difference, ChaDeMo/CCS doesn't touch it in terms of real-world charging rates or deployment.
- sundvor 9y agoIn an EV, longer range is a pretty substantial USP.
- sxates 9y agoAssuming you're talking about the new Leaf which isn't yet available in the US ... * 50-100% greater range * Better acceleration and handling (and RWD/AWD) * Access to the Tesla Supercharger network enabling long-distance travel * Much better UX and constant improvements in OTA software updates. * Buying from a company that is all-in on electrifying and decarbonizing the world, and isn't just dipping in their toes for the granola crowd. * A way more attractive car compared to the Leaf's awkward hatch
- maxerickson 9y agoThe Leaf is even mostly aimed at fleet mileage scoring.
- hackerguy99 9y ago>The Leaf is even mostly aimed at fleet mileage scoring. So it's your contention that 95% of HackerNews can see the future of EVs, but all the major manufacturers have and/or are going to miss it? Shaky bull thesis, my friend.
- glbrew 9y ago"cuts production" I don't follow official statements closely but it sounds like they are using this retooling as an excuse for low demand for the S and X. This way they get to have their cake and eat it too: low S/X numbers justified and re-energized promises for increased 3 production.
- fmihaila 9y agoMusk said on the call that they will produce fewer cars but that they expect increased deliveries, with the difference being covered from their existing inventory.
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoWell, if they have all that existing inventory just sitting around, surely it implies they've built more cars than they've been able to sell, no?
- agumonkey 9y agoI really wonder what kind of hell it is. Supplier issues ? bad management / employee relationships ? Design failures ? ... ps: someone explained to me that Tesla cars are still mostly hand assembled. Explains a lot of things
- ben_jones 9y agoIf Tesla goes under what happens to long term support for their cars? Don't Tesla owners depend on a lot of Tesla services? Subsidized charging stations, sending it in for maintenance, etc.?
- saas_co_de 9y agoYou have a bespoke car that nobody else makes parts for or can repair. it will be a collectors item in another 30 years but in the short term you are pretty screwed.
- mikestew 9y agoYou might want ask Fisker Karma owners: https://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/hybrid-support-solutions-to-fisker-owners-join-us-or-kiss-your-100k-bricked-karma-goodbye/ https://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/hybrid-support-solutions-... I imagine the same fate would await Tesla owners. However, there enough Teslas rolling around that someone might find it profitable to pick up support. Multiple vendors still sell, and in some cases manufacture, parts for fifty year old Volkswagens, for instance.
- ghaff 9y agoYeah but 50 year old Volkswagens are a lot simpler, including being almost wholly mechanical. And even today there’s a pretty robust aftermarket parts market for ICEs generally.
- rconti 9y agoI'd be less worried about repairs than about electronics. No more OTA updates, can't track charging status on your phone anymore, etc etc. I wonder if any major functionality/drivability is lost if they totally go dark.
- draw_down 9y agoIt sounds like they are struggling. Hopefully they can pull it together and turn things around.
- crush-n-spread 9y agoThey are not struggling. This Yahoo article is fear mongering. I just listened to the whole earnings call and everything sounded terrific: They pulled their best engineers to Gigafactory to mitigate a supplier misleading them about one of their battery production lines, and so they dropped production of S and X. Apparently as a result of the supplier f* up, they rewrote "20 man years of software in 4 weeks". Which is absolutely incredible. Don't listen to this fear mongering BS. Tesla is the only one in the electric car game. Who else has the charging network, the half-million pre-orders, the 3.5 billion in cash and easy ability to raise more, the Elon shine? Can't stand these articles
- richardknop 9y agoRewriting "20 man years of software in 4 weeks" cannot result in anything else than bug ridden convoluted spaghetti code in my opinion. That is nothing to brag about.
- FireBeyond 9y ago> they rewrote "20 man years of software in 4 weeks". Which is absolutely incredible ... if accurate, if bug-free (for varying reasonable values of same). Otherwise the mythical man-month seems to creep in. That's a project that's complicated enough to require 240 developers (12 months x 20 years, fitted into 1 month), yet somehow was reliably chunked up, retrofitted into their supplier screw up, tested and deployed in 4 weeks?? I'm considering myself skeptical.
- StephenMelon 9y agoSounds a bit like doing the Kessel Run in 12 parsecs? Seriously though, you can probably redo a typical 20 Man Year project in 2, given how much of the development process is usually taken up by missed requirements and re-work, IF you have a bombproof specification and a well-drilled team of stars. The part I’m not quite getting though is how a battery software issue impacted on wider productivity? Couldn’t they get them in-place and then patch the software after the fact?
- S_A_P 9y agoSeeing as how this is an issue in one of their core competencies, this is concerning. Tesla wants to be a battery company(amongst other things). I hope that with this redesign, they're actually fixing problems and working their way to viability. Its easy to doubt Teslas viability(and I think they're overvalued for sure)but Musks teams are solving hard problems at SpaceX so I think they at least have a shot...
- nickik 9y agoElon Musk project not as fast as he claimed, yet still faster then everybody else. That literally every Tesla/SpaceX story in the last 10 years.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gozur88 9y ago"Faster than everybody else"? I guess that depends on exactly what you're looking for. This year's Bolt has a 60kWh battery, which is supposed to give it a 238 mile range - more than the base Model 3. What exactly will the Model 3 bring to the table when I can actually walk into a showroom and buy one?
- nickik 9y agoThinking in a bigger scale then just right now Model 3 will make it clear. The way Tesla has transformed the whole car industry and the scale at which they approach the problem is way beyond anybody else. The Bolt can not be produced in the numbers needed for a revolution. The people who produce it are not interested in a revolution in the first place. The stock might be below peak right now, but the scaling they have achieved since they started is massive, and in the long term they are still on track.
- gozur88 9y ago>The Bolt can not be produced in the numbers needed for a revolution. The people who produce it are not interested in a revolution in the first place. That's an odd argument to be making in favor of a company that's having so much trouble producing cars. Why do you think the Bolt can't be produced in larger numbers? Does Tesla make in a year as many cars as GM makes in a day?
- boznz 9y ago> Why do you think the Bolt can't be produced in larger numbers? Battery Supply I guess.
- Giorgi 9y agoOn the side note - good time to buy Tesla Stock
- mattbierner 9y agoOnly around a 10% drop from the start of trading today. Some nice opportunities short term but I don't see that changing anyone's longer term outlook. At $300, the stock is still either a great value given the company's potential or terribly overvalued
- antiviral 9y agoSo this is the real reason that they had those 'performance-based' layoffs. If you need to fire a certain number of employees, just give bad performance evaluations to those people and fire 'for cause.' As a company, Tesla can use whatever nonsensical management techniques they want. But firing people 'for cause' will unreasonably hurt otherwise productive people in their future careers. And it will make future candidates far more wary to ever want to work there.
- crush-n-spread 9y agoI listened to the whole earnings call that just happened, Elon said they had laid of 2% of their work force which is much low than industry standard for yearly layoffs. Elon quoted GE which lays of the bottom 10% of their staff every year. It's not that bad.
- zzzzzzzza 9y agoGE had that policy for management (not the whole company), for a limited time.
- moduspol 9y agoOr maybe they could normally keep lower performing employees around, but cash is getting tighter so they decided to let some of them (less than 4%) go. "Cash being tight" and "firing some employees for performance reasons" are not mutually exclusive.
- vkou 9y agoAre they replacing them, or are they just making everyone else work more for the same pay? How much ramp-up will replacing them require? How will that impact their production rate?
- moduspol 9y agoLow performers (and especially the bottom 2%) can often provide negative value to the company. It's quite possible there is no net additional work to distribute, or if there was, that they had additional capacity in the rest of the workforce for the same tasks. They may not need to be replaced. If they do, we can safely presume they determined those resources (cost / time) involved in doing so were less than what it takes to replace them. It may not negatively impact their production rate. They may be able to improve their production rate by spending that money in a more targeted way now.
- penglish1 9y agoThe great thing about corporate missions & goals is that they are written so broadly: "Our goal when we created Tesla a decade ago was the same as it is today: to accelerate the advent of sustainable transport by bringing compelling mass market electric cars to market as soon as possible. " (https://www.tesla.com/blog/mission-tesla https://www.tesla.com/blog/mission-tesla). Thanks to Tesla - seriously(!! COULD not and WOULD not have happened without them), we now have a compelling mass market electric car on the market. The Chevrolet Bolt.
- rootusrootus 9y agoHa! In any case I'm not sure I'd give credit to Tesla on that. The Bolt seems more like a response to the Leaf and friends than it is to anything like a Model S.
- penglish1 9y agoMaybe. Without a broad consensus from all the involved individuals at Chevy, we'll never know. Were they looking more at the (first edition at the time?) Leaf or the hypothetical and probably unnamed at the time "Tesla mass market model with X miles range and $Y price tag?" If they were aiming for the Leaf, it appears they got to market faster and better (specs) than the 2018 Leaf. A little surprising from Chevy (when compared to Nissan), particularly since they didn't really have a first edition to build on themselves. If they were aiming for the Model 3 - they got to market faster and "at least in the ballpark" spec-wise, AND at much much higher volumes than Tesla. To me this is less surprising. A mass-market car producer could get to market with a high-volume car faster than Tesla? And in higher volumes? That isn't so surprising. It would have surprised me _even less_ if Toyota had done it, though they clearly weren't trying. It does surprise me a little that Nissan hasn't, though it is fairly clear that they aren't trying _hard_.
- Avshalom 9y agoWell no, companies have been trying on EV every decade since the invention of the car. The Prius normalizing an electric drive train pushed full electric further into the mainstream then Tesla has. Granted Tesla's investment into batteries bumped Panasonics time line up a bit and bumped full BEV up a bit but a compelling mass market electric car on the market has been clearly inevitable since 2000. Edit: I changed it from "Tesla ... may have". To "Granted Tesla " to more accurately reflect my evaluation of Tesla's contribution to the time line.
- babesh 9y agoDisclaimer: I own Tesla shares. Tesla has a long history of taking far longer and far more money to achieve a goal than they forecast. They don't show signs of adjusting their forecasts based on previous misses. For the last couple of years the market has given them a pass for that when the market has punished other companies for far less. Tesla has gone to the well again and again to raise money. One concern is that if market support drops, they may not be able to go to the well again. And history suggests that they will need to and will miss their revised goal as well.
- junkscience2017 9y ago> Disclaimer: I own Tesla shares why do people do this? it is not relevant, helpful or required in order to comment. Anyone with a NASDAQ index fund in their portfolio or 401k has at least one share of Tesla...which is basically everyone here
- jonahrd 9y agoI'm just taking a wild guess that this person isn't being technical and talking about an index fund, but is disclaiming that he or she purposefully purchased shares of Tesla stock
- probe 9y agoIt's just to be honest that you're not hyping up a stock for a pump and dump scheme (see some cryptos). But you're right it doesn't really matter for such a big/liquid stock like TSLA For what it's worth, Disclaimer: I own Tesla Shares :)
- nhebb 9y agoFWIW, I think you all mean disclosure, not disclaimer.
- m3kw9 9y agoIt feels like all of musks other business could align and take over everything, sort of like Go strategy
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoThere will be Tesla defenders right till the end.
- bufferout 9y agoI guess some people like companies that produce great products?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThey have earned that. There aren't many companies who care about anything other than making money.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoI have a bridge to sell ... So Tesla is good ("anything other than making money"), and Nissan with doing more good by selling more Leafs is not? If Nissan is good, which electic car producer is bad? I would agree on SpaceX - though a cynic might say it's Musks way out of the earth catastrophe[1] - but with many more companies selling electric cars the argument falls flat for me. Especially if one looks at all the allegations by employees - if they are employees at all or sub-contractors without rights. Either Tesla has bad press or there are much more than with other car companies. [1] Because you can be sure you're not the one on the last ship out
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> So Tesla is good ("anything other than making money"), and Nissan with doing more good by selling more Leafs is not? Not saying that. But where were the other automakers when Tesla was single-handedly pushing against the market to make EVs viable? I get people are cynical, but come on. Musk has been actually proving for years that he cares, and the goals for Tesla and SpaceX were idealistic for as long as he was involved, did not change, and the companies did nothing to suggest they're not what he says they are.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y ago
- smallhands 9y ago<shout>most importantly, Elon has moved his desk to the giga factory as that is where the largest bottleneck is.</shout> wow elon musk must be something out of a movie! daniel (aka me) WHAT HAVE YOU BEEN DOING WITH YOUR LIFE
- rsynnott 9y ago> But a problem with a subcontractor, compounded with other issues, forced Tesla to start over in certain areas, delaying production. > “We had to rewrite all of the software from scratch,” Musk said, adding that they’d redone “about 20 to 30 man years of software in four weeks” for the battery module. Maybe I'm just overcautious, but I would prefer not to be anywhere in the vicinity of a high-discharge actively cooled 100kWh battery whose control system was written, presumably as a rush job, in four weeks.
- j7ake 9y agoYeah doing 30 man years of software in 4 weeks is nothing to brag about. It's like assuming putting 9 women together can output a baby in a single month.
- varjag 9y agoSo your opinion is parallelizing software development is impossible? Interesting.
- sushibowl 9y agoThis is not an unorthodox or unreasonable position. The Mythical Man-Month is a classic text in software engineering and project management and essentially argues this very point. The analogy to child birth is actually also a classic one made originally by the author. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks%27s_law
- varjag 9y agoOf course just like everyone on HN am aware of the book and heard this quote a billion+ times. And of course I know it's badly misused in this particular case (as it often is).
- mrguyorama 9y agosoftware development parallelization works about as well as it does for actual software, ie non-linearly at best. Add to that overhead/mistakes/difficulties caused by "synchronization" and you come to the conclusion that a significant amount of that "30 man years" of software had to be just discarded when rebuilt
- debpoulami_123 9y agoThe solution to that is to structure the project into independent parts that can be done in parallel by smaller amount of people, thus vastly reducing communication waste.
- avs733 9y agoAnd now other media outlets are reporting that Musk shouted "SHAME" at a reporter on the earnings call. All in all, not Tesla's finest hour https://jalopnik.com/elon-musk-just-yelled-shame-at-a-bunch-of-journalists-1820059349 https://jalopnik.com/elon-musk-just-yelled-shame-at-a-bunch-...
- xHopen 9y agoMy shares!!!!
- Animats 9y agoThere's good information at the Daily Kanban.[1] They describe what corners Tesla cut, and why it backfired. "Tesla has not yet built a Model 3 using the automated tooling", says one of the people from the company that builds the automated tooling. Normal testing and tweaking time for a new body assembly line is 6 months to a year, and before that, sections of the line are run in test at the supplier's factory. Tesla skipped all that. It didn't work out well. [1] https://dailykanban.com/2017/10/source-tesla-responsible-model-3-production-hell https://dailykanban.com/2017/10/source-tesla-responsible-mod...