8 ms·
Ideas on how to store energy
- chris_va 9y agoThis is basically just a summary of the Wikipedia page: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_energy_storage https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_energy_storage ... And really misses the important aspects, notably round trip efficiency, cost per kWh, and cost per KW capacity.
- enraged_camel 9y agoYeah, Ars Technica used to have great science and technology coverage. For the past few years though, it has just been... sad. Articles either have gross, embarrassing inaccuracies, or are very shallow. They do have decent coverage of the space and telecommunications industries though. So they aren't completely hopeless.
- rurban 9y agoAnd she misses out on the easiest to implement: electric cars loading stations at company or city parkhouses. You can charge them, but mostly take the expensive peeks from them.
- amelius 9y agoIt's missing the supercapacitor.
- jcoffland 9y agoI think you mean Superconducting Magnetic Energy Storage (SMES). Supercapacitors are a different thing. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_magnetic_energy_storage https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_magnetic_ene... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supercapacitor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supercapacitor
- jakeogh 9y agoRather unlikely that parent confused the two. Supercaps are nice if you don't mind trading their ~<1/5 energy density (mass, volume) of batteries for their excellent cycle count. Clearly not grid scale since batteries barely are.
- Dylan16807 9y ago1/5 takes quite a stretch, or comparing to especially low-density batteries. Maybe in a couple decades they'll be there, but my understanding is that high-end supercaps are currently 25x less energy dense than a lithium ion battery.
- jakeogh 9y ago~9Wh/kg for the best supercaps, compared to the old (and still standard) lead-acid maxing out around 42Wh/kg. Li-ion maxes out at amazing 265Wh/kg but they are always? small and scaled up by putting many in parallel... and if you damage one it's emergency fire preparedness time.
- Dylan16807 9y agoBut if you have just about any concern for density, you're not using lead-acid. Not when that's another 5x worse than other batteries. I'm willing to bet that most lead-acid users would happily switch to cheaper supercaps if they existed.
- jakeogh 9y agoAgreed. When supercap J/$ hits lead-acid levels the J/kg difference wont matter and most people using lead-acid will happily trade 1/4th the energy density for near infinite recharges.
- splittingTimes 9y agoI would add gravity storage [1]. "The fundamental principle is based on the hydraulic lifting of a large rock mass. [...] Water is pumped beneath a movable rock piston, thereby lifting the rock mass. [Later] the water which is under high pressure from the rock mass, is routed to a turbine [...] and generates electricity using a generator." "[For certain pistons] the storage capacity increases with the fourth power of the radius, r^4. The construction costs however only increase with the square of the radius, r². [...] Strictly speaking, the price per kilowatt hour of storage capacity decreases with 1/r². This is the outstanding competitive advantage of this storage concept." === [1] http://www.heindl-energy.com/gravity-storage/gravity-storage-overview.html http://www.heindl-energy.com/gravity-storage/gravity-storage...
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoInteresting concept, but lifting rock "only" gives you a ~3x advantage over lifting water, which can be lifted much higher.
- JshWright 9y agoIt can be lifted much higher if you have the right topography. I also wonder about using something much denser, but still reasonably cheap (lead is what, $1/lb?)
- splittingTimes 9y agoI saw a talk of the inventor a couple of years back. The test site they where exploring they wanted to build a rock piston with a diameter of 250 and a height of 500-1000m (cannot remember exactly, but it was in this order). Since they can lift the piston to half its height that would be 250-500m altitude difference. Not sure what the limiting factor of the height of the piston is, so it might be even bigger. For comparison the Three Gorges damn has an altitude difference of ~100m [1]. Also, it is much more compact then a traditional dam [2]. === [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Gorges_Dam#Composition_and_dimensions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Gorges_Dam#Composition_a... [2] For anybody wondering why ~3x: density of water 1 g/cm^3, density of rock ~ 3 g/cm^3
- michaelmwangi 9y agoI am a huge fan of the Donald Sadoway team at Ambri. http://www.ambri.com/technology/ http://www.ambri.com/technology/ Liquid Metal Batteries
- philipkglass 9y agoI'd really like Ambri to succeed. It's not clear if the use of low cost materials for the storage chemistry will produce low system costs. The inexpensive chemistry appears to have led to expensive problems with seals/separators. Similar materials problems have kept sodium-sulfur battery costs high, even though the active storage materials are cheap, abundant, and offer good energy density.
- tfolbrecht 9y agoFirst we need excess energy to have a storage problem. Ignoring that, I think some market based mechanisms on the consumption side could gobble that capacity up. If energy is a big enough input to some process like metallurgy, recycling, computation, etc in times of excess you could drop the price to the base mwh rate minus the cost of a theoretical amortized storage solution + transmission inefficiencies and give incentive to burn that capacity off. Since we've already invented the economy, we can pass around excess money to use for on demand/scaling consumption instead of building big energy network storage and transportation and eating the cost. In theory subsidizing scalable supplies with the fixed supplies.
- llukas 9y agoWe already need to deal with this problem every day as generation sources do not follow daily demand curve.
- robotresearcher 9y agoMoney is not a very efficient way of storing energy.
- baron816 9y agoI'm curious if there could be any advantages/disadvantages to using a different, heavier liquid for pumped storage other than water. My physics knowledge is quite poor, but intuitively, wouldn't using something like mercury or iodine create more pressure going down, thus generating more energy by volume, thus requiring less volume, thus making it more practical to use a tower? Surely someone's looked into this.
- samsari 9y agoI think that would work, but the challenge would be in finding a denser liquid than water in quantities that would make it useful - and cost effective.
- thmsths 9y agoAnd safe. Imagine the disaster if that mercury tower started leaking.
- fny 9y agoWater is freely available. In the examples mentioned, there's typically a natural reservoir (a lake) or man-made reservoir (a retention pond) that's used. You might get a slight boost from using sea water (density of 1027 vs 1000), but I feel like the salinity might wear your equipment faster. Also, heavy metals like mercury and iodine very are expensive compared to water. And once you start talking about using metals for storage, it might be worth exploiting state changes instead.[0] [0]: http://www.ambri.com/ http://www.ambri.com/
- grondilu 9y ago> using something like mercury you really don't want to do that.
- Tossrock 9y agoI hadn't heard of / thought of the thermal storage idea (freezing ice at night - when it's more efficient both cost wise due to cheaper power, and thermodynamically due to lower outside temperature - and then using that to reduce the need for daytime cooling), and it's so obvious in retrospect that it seems like it should be everywhere. Given what a huge amount of electricity is used on air conditioning (~6% of all electricity generated in the US, apparently), this seems like it could be pretty big.
- microcolonel 9y agoThermal is also useful at the utility level, if you're trying to make concentrated solar work (though it can only really work okay, ultimately). The usual medium is molten salt.
- dhimes 9y agopaging dani fong to weigh in on this....
- jjcm 9y agoThe flywheels are interesting to me, especially for their use in vehicles. I wonder what the tests for catastrophic failure looked like though, especially since that Volvo engine spun theirs at 60,000rpm max. That is a lot of energy in a small package.
- jaggederest 9y agoInterestingly, most of the energy in a moving automobile is actually stored as angular momentum in the drivetrain components, rather than what you might intuitively expect as linear kinetic energy in the mass of the frame, for example.
- tfolbrecht 9y agoThat is extremely weird considering the frame etc has so much more mass. Do you have some math on that?
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoI would expect this to be true only below a certain speed given a certain vehicle mass. It's obviously incorrect at 100 mile an hour with the engine idling and in neutral.
- robotresearcher 9y agoYou seem to be ignoring the wheels. Lots of angular momentum there.
- jaggederest 9y agoI just know the math indirectly, from observing that stopping distances scale linearly with rolling component mass but by the square root of the total mass of the vehicle. Relevant to modifying vehicles - if you put larger, heavier rims on your car, you must also upgrade the braking system or you're rendering it unsafe to drive by possibly doubling the stopping distances.
- nradov 9y agoIs there any prospect of making superconducting magnetic energy storage more cost effective? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_magnetic_energy_storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconducting_magnetic_energ...
- goldenkey 9y agoThe main point of these systems is to store energy for months without much loss. Considering the cooling costs of the mechanism you mentioned, it only seems viable for more rapid usage situations ie. the middle ground between fast discharging batteries and slow discharging hydro gravity storage. The beautiful thing about gravitational storage is that it is reversable. So the same pump that used energy to pump the water into a tank 20 stories up can also spin down as water pours through the turbines, acting as a hydroelectric generator as the water is released. Having a single reversable mechanism makes these systems pretty easy to maintain and the only places energy is lost is through friction during conversion and through leaks. They are pretty hard to beat. The idea of deep ocean pods is similar in execution but instead of working solely against and with gravitys energy potential, the water pressure is used as well...its just more compact..but the orbs will need to be well built to withstand insane pressures.
- anotheryou 9y agoI really like this idea: http://www.heindl-energy.com/media-and-newsletter/videos.html http://www.heindl-energy.com/media-and-newsletter/videos.htm... A gravity storage in form of a piston carved from rock. It's lifted with water that's pumped underneath. The seal is a rolling "sleeve": http://www.heindl-energy.com/gravity-storage/idea-function/sealing-the-rock-piston.html http://www.heindl-energy.com/gravity-storage/idea-function/s...
- jaggederest 9y agoI always thought it was interesting that more of these systems didn't exploit phase changes and the cold side of the Carnot cycle. For example, instead of compressing air, you can liquify it, and then when you want to recover the energy you use it as a heat sink for a heat engine (for example, solar thermal) - in theory, this is just as efficient as adding energy to the 'hot' side of the cycle, and you can expand it out through an engine as well.
- timb07 9y agoAluminum has also been considered as an energy storage material, specifically one that is easily transported: http://evworld.com/article.cfm?storyid=765 http://evworld.com/article.cfm?storyid=765
- randyrand 9y agoWhat about storing it in fat cells? Bio chemistry storage. Is this possible/advantageous?
- andrewflnr 9y agoNot sure about fat cells, but IIRC there has been some work in using algae to generate hydrocarbons from the air. I can't really see "fat in fat cells" being better than alternatives that skip some steps, though.
- m3kw9 9y agoHow about a system that loads springs as mechanical energy, do that have those?
- agumonkey 9y agopractical engineering youtube channels talked about swell pressure under buildings, I find this kind of "osmotic" work interesting. Extremely interesting.
- jakeogh 9y agoThe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trompe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trompe is an interesting device for the compressed air category.