9 ms·
How to Read the JFK Assassination Files
- wallace_f 9y agoHypothetically, if a group of people was willing to go to all the trouble of breaking laws to assassinate a President, what's forcing them to be honorable in producing and releasing information implicating themselves? It seems any excitement is contingent on believing not just in the conspiracy, but also in extreme incompetence, no?
- 0xcde4c3db 9y ago> It seems any excitement is contingent on believing no just in the conspiracy, but also in extreme incompetence, no? This kind of belief is more common than you might expect. There's arguably a whole genre of "faceless enemy" in various worldviews that is blatantly corrupt/incompetent/inferior while also being overwhelmingly disciplined and powerful.
- unbridledShrugs 9y agoWell, put it this way... when an outcome is the product of a collective of individuals, some members of the group may be more competant than others, and different tasks might be carried out with varying degrees of success. Taking it a step further, a group comprised of multiple teams might have one very disciplined team for highly demanding critical tasks, surgical strikes, site reliability, and several weak teams for grunt work, digging ditches, scraping logs, whatever. In such scenarios, you might see gaps open up in areas viewed as optional drudgery, or dull thankless conveniences. Consider the Lufthansa heist depicted in the movie Goodfellas. It involved some highly motivated gangsters, who enlisted some sloppy flunkies for assistance. Guys like the getaway driver screwed up and got whacked for failing to dump the getaway car without incident, inviting paranoia that they might arouse suspicion. Then, as paranoia magnified over time, the displined core erased every untrustworthy witness. The principal stakeholders in an operation will often possess power and skill, but their accomplices might not.
- ruricolist 9y agoThey might all be dead by now.
- lstyls 9y ago> Hypothetically, if a group of people was willing to go to all the trouble of breaking laws to assassinate a President, what's forcing them to be honorable in producing and releasing information implicating themselves? This "hypothetically" begs the question and assumes that some three-letter acronym plotted to kill JFK. > but also in extreme incompetence, no? You contradict yourself. If the supposed plotters were so incompetent, how could they have pulled this off and kept the supposed cover-up alive for so long?
- 2845197541 9y agoTheories don't all implicate the US government. There are notions of Russian/Cuban involvement, for example.
- ionised 9y agoWasn't that the theory put forward by the US government? That Oswald was a communist agent?
- zeveb 9y agoNo, the theory put forward by the U.S. government was that he was a lone actor (with Communist sympathies). Had we believed that an agent of a foreign state had assassinated our head of state, we'd have been obliged to go to war.
- mejin 9y agoBased on other comments in HN it appears that a large amount of key documents have been "lost". I've never checked the source, but many threads about the files mention that.
- api 9y agoIt's not the same people? If there was a conspiracy it would have been a small clique (most of whom would now be dead) not the whole government or even official channels thereof. In other words it would have been a crime. These files were slated to be released as ordered by Congress after the JFK film. BTW TIL Trump is trying to claim credit for what is a scheduled release.
- indubitable 9y agoI would be surprised if the releases containing anything especially new, but the government most certainly maintains incriminating information on themselves. For instance we now know that the FBI discovered compromising information on MLK and tried to black mail him into suicide. [1] They also discovered his infidelity through surveillance and contacted his wife again trying to damage his character. This was all well documented and maintained for decades after it had happened. If you want death and murder, there's things like US involvement in Operation Condor [2] which was long speculated but finally fully verified by documents declassified under Clinton. And there are countless other examples. Releases staggered by decades come with great plausible deniability. Is the FBI today responsible for what the FBI of the past did to MLK? If anything relevant was revealed, I'd expect the modern versions of the involved agencies to be the first condemn those actions. Whether that's genuine or not is practically impossible to know. But it's almost certainly sufficient to ensure they'll never face any meaningful consequences for their actions. [1] - https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/fbis-suicide-letter-dr-martin-luther-king-jr-and-dangers-unchecked-surveillance https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/fbis-suicide-letter-dr... [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Condor#U.S._involvement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Condor#U.S._involvem...
- kelukelugames 9y agoIf King's affairs are real then why are they not more widely known? I haven't seen any conclusive evidence other than Hoover's letter.
- indubitable 9y agoI'd imagine mostly because it's not really relevant, and the media at the time wasn't the tabloid circus that it is today. Among King's lovers was Georgia Davis Powers, first black senator of Kentucky, who wrote about their affair. According to her for instance she slept with him the night before he was assassinated at the Lorraine Motel. She was climbing into the ambulance to go with him until another individual reminded her of how inappropriate it would be. These are some pretty specific claims coming from a reputable source with 0 motivation to lie, that could be easily falsified. The letter also mentions another lover by name and implies there was an attached audio recording of King with the classy phrasing, "Lend your sexually psychotic ear to the enclosure..." That audiotape is set to be publicly released in 2027. And then there is the bio of Ralph Abernathy, King's successor at the Southern Christian Leadership Conference and the man King described as "the best friend I have in the world." Within his bio he discussed King's (and his own) regular infidelities.
- jimhefferon 9y agoYeah, like if burglars taped a door open and a security guard found it and instead of reporting it he untaped it and then they came back and taped it again. Its not like in books.
- gravy 9y agoUsually I'm opposed to "read these documents the way we tell you to" articles a la CNN but this was a case of judging a book by its cover on my part, with little mention of Trump. Kudos Politico.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sharpercoder 9y agoI saw a documentary which analyzed footage found around 2000 iirc (discovered old footage) of the murder. The conclusion was that due to the wound exit, the shooter could never have been Oswald. It convinced me. Who does the American public currently believe to be the shooter? Is there consensus for some theory?
- lstyls 9y ago> Who does the American public currently believe to be the shooter? What does this have to do with anything? Reality isn't a democracy. It's absolutely possible the shot came from Oswald. Tastelessness aside, try playing JFK Reloaded (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JFK_Reloaded https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JFK_Reloaded). Claiming the ballistics don't make sense is as debunked as claiming jet fuel can't melt steel beams.
- jakeogh 9y agoThey melted. There's no doubt about that. I should note that NIST disagrees with you if you mean they melted before the three buildings were destroyed... or after. http://archive.is/5dz5G http://archive.is/5dz5G more: http://s3.amazonaws.com/nasathermalimages/public/video/Pretext.mov http://s3.amazonaws.com/nasathermalimages/public/video/Prete...
- dragontamer 9y ago> claiming jet fuel can't melt steel beams Just note: Jet Fuel probably can't melt steel beams, because steel has a significantly higher melting point than the temperature of jet fuel. Of course, Steel Beams are about as strong as a wet-noodle at Jet-fuel temperatures: https://youtu.be/FzF1KySHmUA?t=1m55s https://youtu.be/FzF1KySHmUA?t=1m55s Which of course, would cause the towers to collapse. But seriously, Jet Fuel doesn't "melt" steel beams. It just weakens them tot he point where they break easily. You can't make ANY mistakes when talking to a conspiracy theorist. They are right about the melting point of steel, but that doesn't help their argument at all.
- clarkmoody 9y agoOne of the best Radiolab episodes I've heard was Mau Mau[1], which chronicled the uncovering of thousands of documents pertaining to the British Empire in Kenya. The extent to which history must be rewritten is stunning, only to be surpassed by the brutality of the English. Not that releasing the JFK assassination files would rewrite an extensive period of history, but the precedent remains: the grim truth of history often lies forever buried in the archives of state. [1] http://www.radiolab.org/story/mau-mau/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/mau-mau/
- agumonkey 9y agooff-topic opportunity: should history be taught in school ? it's a weird blend of nationalist myth, folklore, ignorant (or not) lies and revisionnism. ps: people I didn't mean to stay ignorant, but hinting at rethinking what we're teaching. History is extremely subtle and trimmed far too much for kids (hence the bad blend I described above).
- alsetmusic 9y agoAbsolutely. It should be taught because knowing history informs our present and future decisions. At the same time, we should educate young people on the realities of one-sided history and the constantly evolving landscape of history. Teach kids to seek more multiple sources and interpretations.
- agumonkey 9y agoThat's the kind of idea I was trying to raise in comments. Criticizing the state of education doesn't mean wishing for no education.
- wallace_f 9y agoJust a thought: growing up I had moved around the country a bit, and perhaps this led me to be introduced to wildly different ideas about history. For example, I was taught both the States Rights and the Slavery motives of the civil war, in both primary school and in Uni! Another: My history texts taught me to be once quite strongly of the belief that the atomic bombings of Japan were necessary, and even saved lives, until a nice old prof in uni showed me that Eisenhower and many military leaders either strongly condemned it, pointing that the Japanese were already negotiating surrender, or said it be at least not dropped on urban population centres, as there was already a complete naval blockade and they had no ability to continue the war.
- jakeogh 9y agoOther thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15564292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15564292
- adventurer 9y ago2,800 of the 3,100 documents have been released. April 26, 2018 is apparently the new date for the remainder of the documents to be reviewed by the President and potentially released.
- lettergram 9y agoGood use of his time clearly...
- phy6 9y agoMaybe he's trying to avoid the same fate as JFK.
- dayaz36 9y agoHaven't they had several decades to review it?...
- stareatgoats 9y ago
- jayess 9y agoHijacking this thread to repeat my comments from another thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15565134 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15565134
- ekianjo 9y ago> The single bullet theory, while almost certainly true, was ridiculed in the film, as was Specter, by name. What about the Zapruder film?
- blowski 9y agoWhat about it? Genuine question, I don’t know what you mean.
- stevewillows 9y agoIt's basically the best footage. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iU83R7rpXQY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iU83R7rpXQY (as expected, its gory) Frame 225 has JFK's throat wound, with the headshot at 313. You've most likely seen this footage many times over the years.
- minademian 9y agoSuch a solid article. Refreshing to read this.
- Yizahi 9y agoI stumbled recently on this improved video of the assassination - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sqk3sdfXFkc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sqk3sdfXFkc