7 ms·
This is why I don't get why the game industry has such a bad rep for overworking people. It's genuinely hard to do this kind of code so you'd think they take c
by lordnacho 9y ago
This is why I don't get why the game industry has such a bad rep for overworking people.
It's genuinely hard to do this kind of code so you'd think they take care not to scare away the few people who can do it.
I recall at one point Goldmans was bragging to my team about how they'd hired a game dev to do their click-to-trade currency UI. Seemed like the guy found an easier job for more pay.
- mschaef 9y ago> Goldmans ... hired a game dev to do their click-to-trade currency UI. Seemed like the guy found an easier job for more pay. Not necessarily easier... but definitely a different set of difficulties.
- smcl 9y agoI interpreted "easier" as in "I don't have to work 16+ hour days regularly"
- hacker_9 9y agoThis is just capitalism at work; in the game industry there is no guaranteed reward at the end of the development cycle, so you have to keep up the pressure in order to beat out your competitors, and increase your chances of winning. This leads to crunching, 60 hour weeks and mass layoffs when you lose - lookup any of the top AAA game companies on Glassdoor and you will find they are awful places to work (Projekt Red, Rockstar, the now extinct Crytek, EA - consistently voted 'Worst Company', etc).
- staticelf 9y agoLooked up several of the companies you mention and most of them have a pretty high ratings. EA is voted worst company by consumers, not by employees which is pretty misleading. Please stop lying.
- hacker_9 9y agoI'm not lying, read the actual reviews and don't just look at the review score. The good reviews come from people who don't mind working 60 hour weeks, being paid lower salaries, and getting overworked.
- staticelf 9y agoI dont have an account so I can only see 1 review for each company. But it is a bit strange to say that only some reviews count and not the others. Of course most people care if you're being overworked for a small amount of compensation. Your statement is a bit ridicolous.
- hacker_9 9y agoI'm not going to argue as I see you're trolling, but it takes 2 seconds to sign in and read the reviews. Most good reviews from Projekt Red for example are from full time employees who say they love working there, but then list cons such as: 'Economically things can get tough due to lower salaries' and 'I would not recommend this company for those who are not ready to push themselves and those who just want a 9 to 17h without any trouble.' etc.
- staticelf 9y agoI'm not trolling but you cant take 1 company and have their reviews as "this is how it is in the entire industry". I don't want to sign in though, since that service offers nothing for me as a non american.
- fnord123 9y ago>Of course most people care if you're being overworked for a small amount of compensation. Your statement is a bit ridicolous. And yet academia.
- dang 9y ago> Please stop lying. This breaks the HN guidelines. Please post civilly and substantively, or not at all.
- dkersten 9y ago> in the game industry there is no guaranteed reward at the end of the development cycle The same is true for any product industry. There are things you can do (customer development, short iterations that involve your potential customers, etc) to increase the chances, but if you're not doing work for clients directly, then there is no guarantee. Note that the "doing work for clients directly" exists in game development too, there are many freelance or services companies that do work for other companies, and from what I hear about the game industry, these have much more guaranteed pay, just like outside of games. Its the "build the product, when its done, hope someone buys it" type of work that has no guarantees, but that is in no way unique to game development. The difference is, most other industries don't have such crazy crunch times...
- hacker_9 9y agoYeah I agree, the problem applies to most of the entertainment industry. As a result more investment is put into sequels of successful games, artists, TV shows, movies, books etc. Edit: as for crunch times, I expect this is to do with the interactive element of gaming. There is whole lot more work involved when the client has the ability to break your product.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoMy understanding is that crunch time (as well as the release of flagrantly buggy games with patches coming later) is driven primarily by marketing schedules/budgets. Ad buys, press releases, interviews etc. are negotiated and coordinated months in advance, and big releases from any given publisher need to be staggered largely so that they don't all demand marketing money at the same time.
- cma 9y agoPublishers give advances, have milestones, etc. It is uncertain whether a game will make money out in the market, but part of a publisher's role is supposed to be to have a portfolio and be able to spread that risk, funding some of the development of both the losers and the winners.
- Retric 9y ago
- skocznymroczny 9y agoEA isn't voted worst company for their working conditions. They're not even that voted for the quality/popularity of their games (games like Battlefront or Battlefield still sell very well). It's just a recognisable brand that people like to criticise, and that makes it an easy target for organized voting. Ubisoft is also in that category.
- bsenftner 9y agoI could argue that - years at EA, and their abuse.
- falcolas 9y agoIndeed. The fact that EA was successfully sued for overtime pay for salaried devs speaks volumes, both about their pay and the working conditions.
- BatFastard 9y agoThat's because game devs don't know what life is like for other programmers. Longer hours and lower pay, but you get to work on what you love (every blue moon or so).
- pjc50 9y agoPeople get into the games industry for the "intrinsic reward" (ie they think it's cool) rather than the money or the working conditions. The games industry exploits this badly.
- pavlov 9y agoGame industry is like Hollywood. There's an endless supply of highly talented hopefuls from all around the world who want to get into the industry more than anything else. The focus of exploitation is just different -- the Harvey Weinsteins of the game industry don't try to sleep with brilliant Romanian programmers, instead they work them to death.
- mariusmg 9y ago"the Harvey Weinsteins of the game industry don't try to sleep with brilliant Romanian programmers, instead they work them to death." As a romanian programmer (although not in the game industry), i must admit this is a very eloquently put. Hats off to you sir.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vvanders 9y agoAs an ex-game dev this is pretty on the mark. They've honed using your "passion" to extract as much work as they can from you for ~2-3 years. After which there's a 50/50 shot that the studio folds/etc. In the AAA space there's also a vicious 90/10 rule where 10% of the games make 90% of the money. With rising costs it becomes increasingly difficult to keep hitting that 10% you need to keep your studio running.
- avar 9y agoThis is a bit like saying "I don't get why web development is overworking people, just look at all this cool stuff Google is doing with the Go runtime!". Most people who work in the game industry are not doing deep game engine hacking, but doing grunt work like scripting/designing some scene in a giant adventure game who's going to have thousands of those, and all of those need to be finished before the release date.
- hyperpallium 9y agoI wonder what the turn-over is for engine programmers? I'd guess very low. I wonder how many commercial engine programmers there actually are, anyway? I'd guess very few.
- peoplewindow 9y agoYeah, "low and falling" for both of them. There are only a handful of major engines today and it's been that way for years. Unreal, Unity, Frostbite .... a few games still roll their own but the costs of keeping up are getting extreme. I really doubt the Unreal Engine developers feel abused. For one thing, the release schedules of engines and games are now to some extent disconnected. Games get whatever the engine can do. Epic isn't going to move mountains to add a feature to UE for a licensee unless they get a TON of money to do it.
- jorvi 9y agoIts kind of amazing how Unity forced change on Epic though. In the X360-PS3 era they absolutely _dominated_ the market, the list of games built on UE during that time is insane. However, after that, Unity started to come up as it had much nicer licensing and as a response to that Epic made UE almost free to use for small studios and more palatable for big ones.
- tapoxi 9y agoI don't think Unity forced change on Epic, Unity targeted the nascent indie market very well and was a great replacement for the deprecated XNA. I can't think of a AAA Unity title aside from Microsoft's Recore - which launched with problems at $40. Epic's AAA market ended up with bigger budgets and a demand for more control, so many of them simply created their own engines. So most UE games seem to be big budget indie titles (Obduction, PUBG, Psychonauts 2) or tight budget AAA titles (Street Fighter V, Shenmue III)
- staticelf 9y agoI think it depends a lot of which company you work for and where in the world you work. For example, there is a lot of game companies in my country and it's illegal to require people to work more than 40 hours a week. I think some may do it anyway by free will or by social pressure, but these people are probably pretty rare. In my country (Sweden) we don't really have a culture where companies pressure people into working more in general so those who do often meet a lot of social uproar and protests.
- goos 9y agoAs a fellow Swede, I think that's slightly disingenuous. Sure, companies can't officially force you to work overtime, but for sure there are many instances where people are encouraged to bring work home or pull some extra hours to make a deadline – especially at smaller companies.
- staticelf 9y agoYeah sure, but it's far from the work environment in the states or even in other countries in europe. Require people to do some extra hours sometimes is often part of every contract but I have never been required to do so. Once I had a boss that wanted me to work overtime "unofficially" but I refused. Needless to say, I left that place pretty quickly. I don't work in the game industry, but I know some people who do and they never work overtime.