12 ms·
Video Games Are Destroying the People Who Make Them
- sien 9y agoIs there any part of the entertainment industry that isn't like this? It seems that trying to be a writer, actor, game maker or a musician is incredible amounts of hard work and a small number of people do well and everyone else does badly.
- minimaxir 9y agoThe video game industry is especially bad as it combines the bad aspects of the entertainment industry with the bad aspects of software development. A good story of the combination of overwork and technical mismanagement is the Mass Effect: Andromeda debacle (written by the same author as the NYT article): https://kotaku.com/the-story-behind-mass-effect-andromedas-troubled-five-1795886428 https://kotaku.com/the-story-behind-mass-effect-andromedas-t...
- munificent 9y ago> The video game industry is especially bad as it combines > the bad aspects of the entertainment industry with the > bad aspects of software development. Another corner of the world where those two collide is the visual effects side of film production. What you see there mirrors the game industry to a tee: tons of overtime, high stress, low pay, studios constantly folding, and a never-ending stream of young hungry creative people waiting for their turn.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoThe problems extend to beyond the confines of game developers and publishers. It also doesn't help to have to contend with a deeply critical and particularly cheap audience and overly influential terrible game 'journalists'. Many of the customers, if you've ever played online, are downright abusive actually. The customers, many of whom are young and immature want everything for free. If publishers try to charge for anything at all, it's 'a rip off'. Even though game prices have remained the same for a couple of decades while games become vastly more complex (and hence more expensive to make). Basically games are not valued. The only reason they even get made is because there's enough people who love making them without sweating about not having the best salary, and enough young people who keep coming in to replace the people who've finally decided they've had enough.
- freedomben 9y agoThe problem of people wanting software for free is such a hard thing to combat. There's something psychological about software that people don't realize what it takes to make it. Most people would never expect to obtain a physical item for free, and then get mad when they are charged for it, yet they do this with software.
- spaceseaman 9y ago> and overly influential terrible game 'journalists' I would argue that you're pointing that finger in the severe wrong direction. The young generation of young males who buy video games do not visit the web pages of the enthusiast game press (IGN, Gamespot, Kotaku). Instead, they consume all of their game "reviews" and "criticism" via YouTube - figures like PewDiePie, TotalBiscuit, etc (not exactly a great crowd). The gaming press is actually having a really fascinating resurgence IMO. Websites like GiantBomb and Vice's Waypoint have both found success through cultivating personalities with distinct critical viewpoints. Recently, games criticism has developed into something very unique and enjoyable if you're passionate enough to go looking for it. In this way I disagree with your final point. Games are still immensely valued by [old / women / minority / enthusiast] gamers, but the majority of the market (especially the big $$$ from micro-transations) is thanks to the demographic you describe and (IMO) the media they consume. As a result, large block-buster games will increasingly market themselves to this incredibly lucrative (but not always large) segment of the market and you'll continually see behavior like in the OP as companies like EA try to cut costs and maximize their revenues.
- Pyxl101 9y agoIt unfortunately seems like video game development, and entertainment generally, are very deadline-motivated. You want to release your game at a particular time, so it doesn't coincide with another game's release, or to finish by a particular quarter or holiday / Christmas.
- pfranz 9y agoI think it's actually worse than that. I've seen a couple crunches for games. They're not usually tied to holidays. It usually plays out, "Hey, we're only going to crunch for 3 months." "Oh, well, we've extended the deadline 3 months--so only 3 more months of crunch." Most recently, a game studio a friend works as was supposed to wrap in early October. That's now extended until the end of the year with a ship date around March. If they had any flexibility in the release date, who thought this was a good idea? Of course an October deadline is going to push and now you've ruined the holidays for everyone. A lot of the big game studios put out a game every 4 years or so, but if you're hired for the project they hire you just for the crunch. Then you're on to the next project heading into crunch.
- rodgerd 9y agoCompare with the film industry, which is heavily unionised; there are often dreadful hours for people working on films, but there is generally suitable overtime and so on. None of this exists in videogames.
- pfranz 9y agoMost of film is unionized. The big exception is VFX (computer graphics).
- BadassFractal 9y agoMaybe similar to the startups world too? Super long hours, not much pay, minimal chance of payoff, infinite supply of people who want to do it. The desired result is financial freedom, whereas perhaps in videogames the desired result is creative freedom. Also yes, anything that seems glamorous has too much supply and not enough demand, so you end up with these skewed power dynamics. Pick a job that maybe pays ok but is super unglamorous, and I doubt you'll see the same practices
- drawkbox 9y agoThe desired result is financial freedom, whereas perhaps in videogames the desired result is creative freedom. Creative freedom is definitely nice and a goal of people in games. Both developers and designers go into it with the goal of making games and eventually making their games. What you find out is, most game companies can only make a few people's games. It is the same in any creative industry. This results in most developers, designers, artists going to work on their own games or at small to medium studios where they can have some input after 3-5+ years. It is the same with entrepreneurs and any work/team really. You will get more shots at implementing things the way you want towards the market you want if you can control it, especially if it is your own or you control the funds. Game studios and agencies are great to learn all the skills you need at a rapid pace and understand the amount of effort it takes, but eventually you will need to break off on your own or small teams to deliver the experience you want. Working at an agency or studio is a bit of an education or hardcore apprenticeship. Most people that get to control creative and design decisions at large game companies had to do just that or make their own (or they put up the money) i.e. John Carmack, Tim Schafer, Tim Sweeney, nearly all mobile studios initially are small teams and either launch their own or subcontract for a label and on and on.
- ryandrake 9y agoDue to the unstoppable force of automation and other productivity multipliers, the situation is creeping into more and more jobs/sectors. The trend is already clear: Increasing numbers of hungry people in line and pushing each other aside for a chance at one of the increasingly fewer jobs. Today it's a few highly desired niches within a few industries. Tomorrow it's the new normal for employment in general.
- waqf 9y agoThere are two, somewhat overlapping, problems here which apply to a lot of parts of the entertainment industry. The first is that supply exceeds demand: "everyone wants to be" an artist. This is basically unfixable. The second is the very skewed distribution of revenue: a few big names get hundreds of millions of people's money, everyone else doesn't come close. This doesn't have to be that way at all (remember the 2000s when everyone was talking about the "long tail"?), but it would be a huge cultural shift and it involves a long discussion about commercialism and entrenched interests.
- fulafel 9y agoIsn't the winner-takes-all phenomenon counteracted by the fact that nobody can predict which games will make it? So studios/publishers/self-publishers finance many times more games than will make money.
- slg 9y agoIt is the failing of the free market. It happens in any industry in which the supply of people who want to work in the industry vastly outpaces the number of jobs available. If you are lucky, the industry might have a union like much of the film, TV, or professional sports industries. If you are unlucky you end up in the video game industry and have this article written about you.
- ekianjo 9y ago> It is the failing of the free market. That's the opposite. It's exactly how a free market is supposed to work. When supply exceeds demand, you can fix any condition you want and you'll still get to fill your seats. If an industry loses attractiveness, they'll have to raise salaries, provide better working hours to retain employees.
- slg 9y agoBy failing of the free market I mean an undesirable flaw in the outcome of the free market. Free markets lead to all sorts of nasty stuff like sweatshops and child labor. We usually create regulations or unions in order to fight back against these flaws. Without one of those, you can get a situation like this.
- ekianjo 9y agoWait. This is not on the same level as child labor at all. This is situation where free, consenting adults, sign a contract to work in a well-known and well-reported industry, forsaking compensation for extra working hours (as specified in their contracts) and knowing very well the crunch phenomenon (it's been reported in numerous publications for at least more than 20 years now) - so what extra protection do you need? They are free to decide what is the best for them, as individuals. And they are free to leave for better jobs, if they are not satisfied with the industry they are in.
- slg 9y agoWhy can't all the above be true for a child if they consent to it or if their parents consent to it? Why can I hire a adult for $3 per hour if we both consent to it?
- ekianjo 9y ago> It seems that trying to be a writer, actor, game maker or a musician is incredible amounts of hard work and a small number of people do well and everyone else does badly. I'm not sure the picture is so bleak financially for game developers. I mean, there's a ton more revenues in the video games industry and it's a growing industry with more and more gamers (mobile, console and PC alike). Then, there's the fame aspect "I worked on X game with this Mr Y superstar game designer" even if they only worked on a very tiny aspect of the said game. And there's the advantage of being IN the industry, the networks, the fact that you are the forehead of what's happening and there's literally tons of ways one can innovate even in "boring" AAA titles.
- sogen 9y agosports too
- SmirkingRevenge 9y agoJust for the heck of it, I signed on to be an extra on a pretty well known tv show that filmed in my area. It was a at least a 12 hour day (but IIRC it was more like 18, but its been while now). As an extra, most of that was spent sitting around and waiting. The crew on the other hand were mostly on their feet the ENTIRE time and were still going even after all the extras were dismissed. Many of them were doing laborious tasks, others like the show runner, are running a million miles a minute the whole time. And from what I gathered, this was basically the norm, while shooting the season which can last for months.
- majormajor 9y agoIt's a lot like being a "startup founder," really. High risk high reward. Game dev and startup founder at least can pay a lot better than actor/writer/musician even before reaching unicorn status.
- jaaron 9y agoA lot of it is, but it doesn't have to be. I'd argue that over at Riot Games, we see crunch as antithetical to what we do. But then we're lucky enough to run a massive online game that needs to be up 24/7 year after year. So our engineering culture is much more like what you'd see at other traditional internet technologies such as Google, Netflix, Amazon, etc. It's just that in our case, our online service is a video game. My girlfriend is at Disney and last year she worked 6 day weeks for much of the time as they led up to a film release. Change would require producers and executives to take a risk (while their competitors continue to crunch). It's going to be very hard to adjust.
- danbolt 9y agoI think your experiences are touching on some really interesting points, as the development environment of a game like League of Legends compared to Halo 5 is very different. I think service-based games aren't just popular because they're profitable, but also that they can be developed more akin to a typical software company.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bagacrap 9y agoHow does one limit bathroom breaks?
- CommentCard 9y agoI believe the answer is in your name.
- chaotic_clanger 9y agothey spy on you. in one studio there was a system that monitored yout kb/mouse inputs and logged an automatic pause into the billing system if there were no activity on your inputs.
- unexistance 9y agosome 'update' since EA Spouse and corresponding lawsuits ~10 years ago http://www.gameqol.org/igda-qol-survey/ http://www.gameqol.org/igda-qol-survey/
- SoulMan 9y agoWell, it's true. I've worked on both gaming and enterprise software companies."Crunch" is everywhere. The only difference Games (especially casual one) has very short lifetime and changes are frequent and sometimes targeting some event or season like Christmas. With this, the work load becomes very uneven throughout the year. There are months teams are waiting for a solid project (otherwise management keeps them busy with some "New IP" experimental work which is destined to fail crossing approval gates ) and there are spikes where they have to work 6 or 7 straight weekends. Some regions where labor laws are not strict (or in culture itself work-life balance is not expected) its for irratic. In one hand the crunch time is extreem where employees are asked to spend very long hours sometimes overnight at work on the other hands they may have to wait for months for a project to be outsourced from the studio that is holding the IP.
- ekianjo 9y agoIt's not like people who work in the video games industry do not have the skills to do something else if they wish to. What the article fails to mention completely is that most people in the VG industry actually want to be there in the first place, despite knowing and experiencing all this.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zer00eyz 9y agoHoliday hell: welcome to e-commerce. Redesign, relaunch, rebuild, replatform, add vendors, remove vendors, deal with poorly built contracts that allow for shenanigans because no one in tech signed off on the deal you just made. I think our whole industry is hell bent on consuming youth and self destruction. No one in tech is immune but some have it worse than others.
- freedomben 9y agoI know a guy in his late 30s that just had a freaking heart attack as a result of chronic stress and overwork. Worst part is his is self-imposed! He is an entrepreneur and does lots of contract work. Sometimes we don't realize what we are doing to our bodies with overwork, stress, poor diets (you know it's true), and insufficient exercise. It's good to get reminded every once in a while.
- baron816 9y agoHaven’t we known for a long time that this kind of stuff is counter productive?
- pfranz 9y agoIt's well known. I think it's hard with creative industries, especially since digital has sped things up and communications has allowed way more people to collaborate. Now you can have many more people making last minute changes...throughout the last 6 months of a project. I've heard lawyers talk about what it was like before fax machines. Turnaround on documents were expected to take a week because they went out through the mail. Now you can get a txt message and expect to turnaround in minutes--no matter where you are. It's just a tempting feedback loop and I feel like as a culture/society we need to set some boundaries.
- ekianjo 9y ago> The average American game developer earned $83,060 in 2013, according to a Gamasutra survey, or less than half the pay of a first-year associate at a New York law firm. What kind of comparison is that? Most people in the world earn less than half of what a first-year associate at a NY Law Firm makes. So what? A proper comparison should be against similar professions, in the entertainment industry. Did the author do any research at all?
- BlueParanoia 9y ago> The average American game developer earned a respectable living wage for the entertainment industry which is likely less than you would make if you were a law, cs, or engineering professional.
- santaclaus 9y ago> if you were a law, cs, or engineering professional Isn't game developer in fact a class of CS professional?
- inamberclad 9y agoMaybe not if they're a designer or artist.
- spaceseaman 9y agoDid you read the enclosing paragraph? "Their income pales in comparison to what’s offered in other fields with reputations for brutal hours, like banking and law. The average American game developer earned $83,060 in 2013, according to a Gamasutra survey, or less than half the pay of a first-year associate at a New York law firm." Your answer is right there for goodness sake! The author compares game developers to a first-year associate because both are "fields with reputations for brutal hours." The author is also Jason Schreier, an editor at Kotaku which has frequently covered these topics. I would argue he's quite aware of the issues developers face, many journalists are close friends with developers in the industry. To echo your demeaning tone: did you do any research at all?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eksemplar 9y agoI never understood why people went into the gaming industry unless it was in a position where they did decision making and got credit. Growing up in the 80/90is I remember thinking a place like Bioware or Black Isle/Troika would've been cool places to work, but as I reached adulthood and understood what went into working those places, the dream quickly faded. Imagine having to work long hours at shit pay, to design/build some loot crate system. Especially when your skill set is in high-demand and you could've gone into something like healthcare IT, where you could be improving people's lives, at 37-45 hours a week at four times the pay. I really don't mean to be rude, I just can't fathom the motivation you would have to work some anonymous job in the video gaming industry.
- georgeecollins 9y agoI can't speak for others, but for me when I started: - It's much more fun to work on something creative and with creative people than not. Yes, people will say there is a creative aspect to almost anything, but I think games (and probably other things like film) are really different. - It is a big deal to work on something that you can identify and people will have heard of or understand. I used to be able to go into a store and point at the boxes that had my name written on them. - When I was younger I really just tended to work a lot anyway.
- smallnamespace 9y agoSome people just love games so much that they're willing to sell their souls and/or health to work on them. That's kind of how I feel about academia right now -- seems highly irrational from a financial or job security standpoint for most people to get a grad degree and aim for tenure, yet there are still droves of people willing to make that trade.
- xfer 9y agoYou are assuming that most grad students aim to be a professor, you have any data to back it up? Since that has not been my experience at all.
- 9y ago
- quizme2000 9y agoThis is ripe in the animation and CGI studios also. ILM/Lucas Arts were notorious meat grinders of young professionals. There must be an upper bound to hours worked in a shift/day/week legally for salaried employees/management/executives. No game or movies is worth working someone to death to keep on budget.
- microcolonel 9y agoThis is what happens when you do something that a lot of other people aspire to do. Growing up, many of the girls in my schools would talk about how they want to go into fashion or interior design (thankfully most them figured out that it would be hard to make ends meet unless they had some particular talent, and the luck and patience for sales and marketing); many of the boys talked about how they wanted to get into game development, many of them acquiring poseur-level knowledge of the field, playing around with development tools. When you have a continuous supply of giddy, overjoyed young applicants who have dreamt since childhood of working a position and want nothing more than to pour their life into what you're making, they will gladly accept pay and working conditions below the general standard for the applicable skills.
- microcolonel 9y agoTo expand a bit, there's a bit of a trap in the truism "you should do what you love". On the surface, it seems to say that you should do the singular thing which you love the most, but you may love more in reality to do something other than that singular thing. I'd say that you should do what you will love the most to have been doing, all things considered. If bathroom in a bag, a 30-70% pay cut, and seasonal firing still leaves game development at the top of that list, then don't sweat it.
- ivm 9y agoIt also got worse after social, mobile, and indie bubbles. Nowadays a small number of companies control most of the market. In 2012 I had more freelance gigs than I could handle, but 3 years later it was impossible to find something decent.
- Jare 9y agoOddly enough, the working conditions at some (many?) of the most successful social/mobile game companies are pretty great.
- ivm 9y agoThey have enough cash to not work on a brink of bankruptcy[0] all the time – Valve has great working conditions too. [0]: http://www.lostgarden.com/2015/04/minimum-sustainable-success.html http://www.lostgarden.com/2015/04/minimum-sustainable-succes...
- shmerl 9y ago> Mr. Iwinski, like many other top video game creators, sees crunch as a necessary evil. Some developers have a lot of critical things to say about working environment in CDPR. Extreme crunch is one of those.
- BadassFractal 9y agoSad that The Witcher 3 is such a phenomenal title, yet it caused so much misery in the making. Are there examples of extremely successful games that were made in a boring 9 to 5 fashion?
- tptacek 9y agoSince you have to assume every executive funding or managing a gamedev studio knows that developers grow up dreaming of working on games, it seems like this is a pretty good example of a sector of tech ripe for collective bargaining. Unchecked supply and demand ensures abusive working conditions for entire generations of game developers, unless they can find a way to in some way link the fates of veteran developers with newcomers and allow engineering teams to bargain for some control over and sanity for their shipping schedules. Until that happens, though, the classic tech career advice remains true: don't go into gamedev. There is comparably interesting, creative work elsewhere in tech that is also lucrative and relatively secure.
- valesco 9y agoI am curious as to what those other creative fields are (honest question).
- bsenftner 9y agoI've been in an out of the games industry most my career. I was one of the OS developers for the 3DO, the original PSX, as well as lead or team for 15 years from 1990 on. Years before "EA Spouse" I tried and failed to get some type of collective effort against the rampant, illegal employee abuse. The collective game developer brainwash is thick, and their treatment is 100 times more abusive than the sexual harassment the larger public is currently outraged about. After leaving games, I thought VFX was going to be less abusive. I spent 7 years doing that; artist, programmer & financial analyst. VFX was only better in the respect that the pay and perks were better. Were. Film VFX is mostly overseas or Canada now. I'm in facial recognition now. It is still just exiting the "computer scientist" stage, not at that "Crappy AI College" level yet. Until younger people get some type of collective sense of their abuse, it will continue. Everywhere.
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> their treatment is 100 times more abusive than the sexual harassment the larger public is currently outraged about. Spreading divisiveness between different groups of abused workers helps no one. They're both real, pervasive problems.
- bsenftner 9y agoNot intended to be divisive. Simply pointing out the severity.
- tobr 9y agoIt jumped out at me too as a very unnecessary comparison. It reads like “sexual abuse is an exaggerated problem”, to be honest.
- bsenftner 9y agoSounds like my comparison is being lost here. The abuse is worse in the following manner: game developers were (don't know if currently, but I did over and over) were required to sign 'feature contracts' where we would sign off with risk of financial penalty a feature set to add or modify a game. The game is a known sports or some reoccurring franchise, and this contract is signature required to land the contract, before seeing the code or assets one is modifying. The entire team of one to two dozen developers and artists sign individual contracts, with fantasy milestones crafted sight unseen for the materials we are 'contractually bound' to work with and deliver functioning, bullet proof code. Typically a game would suffer at least one person quitting, one person melting down, and the rest of the team picking up the slack. "Crunch time" was 9 to 12 months of 7 days a week. Literally insane. And meanwhile both the producer from EA/Sony/Satan as well as your in-house producer are pressing everyone daily to stay late, get in early, and deliver, deliver. The only way to describe it is a type of Stockholm Syndrome. So, yes, in my opinion this is worse. This is pure insanity.
- diogenescynic 9y agoAmerican corporations are destroying their workers. Most companies do not care about their employees. There are some that do, many that claim they do, and more that give it lip service. Most Americans are overworked, underpaid, and don’t get enough time off. We need to change the system so it works for us, not the other way around.
- pfranz 9y agoIt's not just America. Heck, the article quotes a co-founder of very well known Polish studio as saying he "sees crunch as a necessary evil." There were a lot of negative articles talking about how brutal The Witcher 3 crunch was. Mass Effect: Andromeda, made by Bioware in Alberta, Canada "ended up building most of the game during the ensuing 18 months."[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_Effect:_Andromeda#Game_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_Effect:_Andromeda#Game_de...
- aaronbrethorst 9y ago"They may gaze with envy at their colleagues in the film industry, where unions help regulate hours and ensure overtime pay." Why gaze with envy when you could organize instead?
- didibus 9y agoI think this raises many questions that are somewhat similar to raising minimum wage. Can companies survive without this "cheap" accessible labour? Are the game devs being screwed by their employers or the markets? Is it better to regulate for higher salaries, and potentially less total jobs and maybe less games per year? I think the answers to these questions are hard to find, but ultimatly would dictate the pros and cons of the current situation. If execs are just pocketing all the money, ya, that's a problem and maybe unions or regulation is needed. If game development of the current scale just isn't sustainable by the markets given higher salaries, we need to explore what kind of game development scale can? Is it one which reduces the number of jobs? If so, we have the taxi vs uber dilemma... Is it better for fewer people to get good wages, or for more people to get lesser wages? Finally, we must explore the lengthy crunches. Are they truly delivering productive value? Is management in the game industry just poorer? Would reasonable hours impact cost and profits? Maybe it wouldn't, if we believe all the science about how lack of sleep and overwork nullifies productivity. This is all a complex problem.
- pfranz 9y ago> Finally, we must explore the lengthy crunches. Are they truly delivering productive value? They're not. It's a huge waste of money. It's all poor planning. But each company has to learn that individually, over and over, before an industry figures it out. There's some quote about making movies (or art) that the hard part is making the movie the first time. Once they knew what they were making, doing it a second time would cost 1/10th as much. A lot of the leadership at Pixar talk about how difficult Toy Story 2 was on the staff [1]. '"a full third of the staff" ended up with some form of RSI by the time the film was finished.' 'In one instance, an animator had forgotten to drop his child off at daycare one morning and, in a mental haze, forgot the baby in the back seat of his car in the parking lot.' Even though 'Pixar did not encourage long hours, and, in fact, set limits on how many hours employees could work by approving or disapproving overtime.' It created a huge culture shift at Pixar. Luckily, they've in a comfortable enough position to carry out and keep up with those changes. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toy_Story_2#Controversy_and_troubled_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toy_Story_2#Controversy_and_tr...
- shinners 9y agoI'm interested to learn how these gaming companies are able to retain talent with conditions such as this. Perhaps they just churn through entry level Devs who move on to better jobs after gaining some exp.?
- aluhut 9y agoSomeone should talk to Tynan Sylvester from Rimworld. Guy took some months off in the middle of the hype and it didn't hurt the game.
- AdeptusAquinas 9y agoClassic example of supply and demand. More people want to become game devs than there are jobs, and so they can be abused knowing that if they complain, they will be replaced. Tools like Unity, Gamemaker etc are part of the solution : lower the barrier of entry to expand the market, which might even eventually introduce IT level employee competition. Might also be useful if the current generation of game dev 'elites' retire. Props to them for their games, but it often seems their success bias allows them to view crunch and other terrible development practices as normal.
- makecheck 9y agoThese extreme development environments aren’t even creating games that are that fun, certainly compared to some older games. First, there are so many bugs and obviously-unfinished things. “Ship now, pay now, pay again later and maybe it’ll be fixed later” is the new normal. Then there’s the huge production costs. Games suffer and become boring because they take forever to develop these photorealistic scenes and don’t have time to produce a lot of actual game content!! Instead of spending an eternity to create a handful of amazing-looking things, focus on just-OK-looking opponents and make a much bigger and better game.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoWhen you look at what a lot of games end up doing to a lot of gamers, does anyone think there might just be a little bit of karma mixed-in here? Just a little? I've seen so many otherwise well-adjusted people blow their time, health, and sanity on these things rather than deal with their own real-life problems. Then there are the newer ones where they nickel-and-dime people actual money for digital cornfields and lollipops.
- maruhan2 9y agowell, i think that's a conservative point of view. My point of view is different. Video games spur a ton of technological advancements because there's always so much demand from consumers. Technological advancements are always slow and under-funded if it's not backed up by common consumers. There aren't many things that common consumers crave more than entertainment.
- jstewartmobile 9y agoi think that's a grossly sub-optimal arrangement. we got VASTLY more bang for our buck out of the ARPA guys like Minsky, McCarthy, Kay, Sutherland, etc than we ever did out of the gaming and entertainment industries, and we did it without exploiting the competitiveness and compulsiveness of children and children-at-heart edit: to be fair, some games have risen to the level of high-art, but I doubt many artists are going to complain about the pay or the effort when they know that they have accomplished such a thing
- maruhan2 9y agoI wonder how much of this applies to Blizzard who delays products as long as possible or would even cancel big projects that's been long underway
- cjslep 9y agoIt still exists, but I'm unsure to what exact degree as I only know from multiple firsthand sources. If you're on of the old guard you are paid a fair enough wage to live in Irvine, and the job is generally fun. If you're one of the masses of new guard then good luck affording Orange County, have fun chaperoning Blizzcon, etc etc. That's the sensation I got.
- Insanity 9y agoI wonder what the point is of these crazy hours. We are encouraged at work to not make overtime too often because it decreases code quality. More of a "go home, come back fresh" tomorrow. As a consumer I also rather have games delayed than delivered in the EA style, full of bugs. But I might be a more understanding consumer as I work in IT. I really do doubt these hours have a positive impact on code quality though.
- __bjoernd 9y agoIf you skim the common gaming websites and their comment sections you will see that your sentiment is not shared across the audience. Lots of people like to make a fuzz about delays and 'those stupid people not getting their shit together in time.' These people might be the vocal minority, but they are getting heard by management + developers alike.
- Insanity 9y agoUnfortunately that is probably true. Another good reason to not skim those comment sections!
- steeleduncan 9y agoDoes code quality matter as much for games? Automated testing is rare and much of the heavy lifting is handled by libraries such as Unreal Engine and Havok, leaving one-off glue code. The majority of sales happen in week 1, and the DLC is usually shipped within a year. Unless the game attains classic status and requires porting to new platforms one day, it is unlikely you will need to work on that code in the future even. Don't misunderstand, I rarely even play a AAA release until a few months in when the bugs are quashed because they irritate me so much. However I suspect EA et al optimise for release frequency rather than code quality. Presumably the affect of the latter on the profit & loss is dwarfed by the affect of the former.
- Insanity 9y agoYou're probably right there. There is pressure to release because of competitors (like BF, and CoD used to do) and because customers start to expect it. But better code quality can also mean losing less time fixing bugs that could have been prevented in the first place. Thus, actually reaching the expected release date, but attention focussed elsewhere. I'm not familiar enough with that world though to really understand how complex their code is. As you said, I assume libraries such as UE, CryEngine, .. take care of the truly hard bits.
- oelmekki 9y agoAnd on top of that, your users will probably hate you. Complaining is a thing on the whole internet, but I'm always shocked by how common it is for gamers to trash those who basically make their leisure possible. Indeed, this industry seems to be the most toxic one for developers. Among all recruitment mails I receive, gaming industry ones always stand out. They're basically always in the line of "want to work in your dream industry?" and make me feel like they actually are doing me a favor by sending me a recruitment mail. "lol" is my usual thought while closing the mail. By the way, to game developers : don't feel too bad. Once MR will be a thing, you'll be kings of the world, just like webdev from 2000'.
- Noos 9y agoIt doesn't surprise me. Video Games tend to rely on stressors to provide eustress and a pleasurable experience. This is okay with single player games, but multiplayer games wind up adding a ridiculous amount of additional stressors that developers can't compensate for and often can even make it worse. you're often invoking fight/flight responses and potent stress reactions; why is it so odd that players over time start to turn on people who do this to them?
- oelmekki 9y agoI see your point, but you make it sound like they have no choice but play games :) Ultimately, they do that to themselves and they want it (because they want to beat it). It's like watching an horror movie and insulting actors for being scared.
- jon_richards 9y agoI've heard similar things about places like SpaceX. So many people want to work on something cool that the companies can afford to not be the best places to work.
- jbb67 9y agoI went for an interview at a game company before I got my current job. As well as the technical questions, a large part of my interview seemed to be indirectly about my attitude to working many extra hours and days. I explained that surely in a properly managed company, with proper planning such things would rarely or never be necessary. Surprisingly I got asked back for a second interview (which I declined because I'd been offered a much more suitable job elsewhere)
- chaotic_clanger 9y ago10+ years, working in 3rd or 4th game studio. no issues, but with certain employers the crunches can be quite intensive. escpecially when promised 'relief after crunch' never really comes. with decent employer and if you like math and coding as such, it's an amaze-balls (i believe is the expression) job to have: very broad spectrum of problems that the coding of the games involve and almost free hand in realization and the best part is that performance and memory really matters, and there's no way around it. what i like the most is lower level (sometimes significantly) of corporate bullshit, and that's true even for bigger studios. it's a bit like in quantum physics: "shut up and calculate!" except we code.
- garfieldnate 9y agoI've thought for a long time that public school should include material on understanding and preventing abuse to yourself and others. I had a parent that was emotionally manipulative and grew up accepting it. When I went out into the world I put up with a lot of emotional abuse and let myself get whipped by jerks because I wanted to avoid confrontation at all costs. My wife deals with poisonous people much better than me, and I regularly use her as the voice of reason when I have trouble with some people.