19 ms·
Try quickly typing 1+ 2 + 3 into the iOS 11 Calculator
- sogen 9y agoAs the thread says, I can confirm this bug, the answer: 24 :( iOS 11 must be the buggiest piece of s I've ever tried. Stuck animations, apps that take ages to load, widgets not working, more stuck animations, text overlapping everywhere. Related: Flat design was supposed to make things leaner... EDIT: Worst of all, every single operation is wrong: 7+8+9 = 96 4+5+6 = 60
- deckarep 9y agoUgh, can also confirm this happens on my phone. This feels like more of UI event/timing issue than a logic issue. Also, if this turns out to be a performance based bug that will be pretty frustrating considering Apple is always bragging about how they build the hardware, the software, have grand-central dispatch, have Metal and have multi-core custom built CPUs...yada, yada. It’s not just that number sequence...it’s any rapid fire typing of numbers that cause these gross miscalculations. Rollback the calculator app, if that doesn’t fix it...rollback the OS. Yes I’m frustrated.
- sogen 9y agobtw, has anyone has tried deleting a note in Reminders?
- bowmessage 9y agoyes it's so broken and if you delete a selected event the app crashes.
- colejohnson66 9y agoI got 24 sometimes and 6 the other times. Possibly a race condition?
- deckarep 9y agoHmmm it could be but who knows? Almost there entire eco-system is closed off so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I guess we’re at the mercy of an update so we can get back to calculating things with at least a few order of magnitudes of accuracy...
- tedunangst 9y agoIt's not hard to know what it is. Watch the screen. You can see the animation.
- deckarep 9y agoThe animation doesn’t mean anything. You should be able to have many animations happening in parallel and their completions should not block keyboard events from being handled...
- systoll 9y agokeyboard events are fine — with a Bluetooth keyboard, you get the right answer no matter how fast you type. The animation shouldn’t prevent the + button from being pressed again, but it does. That’s the bug.
- TrickyRick 9y agoOr try typing it slower and you'll see that the result is correct
- heifer2822 9y agoI think button touches aren't triggered until animations finish so if you do 1 + 2 + 3 real fast, the second "+" won't register.
- 9y ago
- tedunangst 9y agoThe plus animation always takes the same amount of time to complete, so it shouldn't be surprising that every number sequence is affected.
- prawn 9y agoI'm with you. Updated my 6+ and everything is tragically slow. 4-5 seconds just to get the Settings or Messages apps to open. Typing anything is unbearable - every time, the first word capitalises and then botches everything from then on. Basic functions within apps or opening the camera take so long as to render them near-useless. I have switched off any animations and performance tweaks that I thought might help, but no luck. If you have a 6, I'd recommend avoiding iOS 11 as much as you can.
- hedora 9y agoYEp. Thought it was me.
- sah2ed 9y agoI did some research and avoiding iOS 11 is exactly what I've done as there are too many unpleasant changes for me to want to upgrade yet. Besides, there are several apps I use that haven't put out updates to work with iOS 11.
- ak39 9y agoiPhone 6 Plus here. Can confirm exact same issues. I ended up backing up everything and reinstalling from fresh. It's only just bearable now. Still noticeable 2s+ delays to open iMessage & and to get into Settings. Using the device for me has become completely joyless. In fact I have incipient resentment just looking at this p.o.s. It was once a great device. It's now hamstrung with bloat. I have stopped using it much now - I haven't yet installed Twitter & GMail or any of the many apps I had again. An entire 25 GB cache of Music library has yet to be re-installed. The phone sits almost the entire day unused. Battery life at end at night for a recharge? 80%! If Apple doesn't fix these issues quickly and restore confidence in the already dwindling user base, they will suffer greatly at the hands of the Huawei's of the market. You don't need a fascist type of Jobs to get these types of issues fixed. Come on Apple!
- MaxBarraclough 9y agoVageuly related: Menuet ships with a perfectly functional calculator https://youtu.be/fpEwOXzYBi8?t=5m34s https://youtu.be/fpEwOXzYBi8?t=5m34s
- JSONwebtoken 9y ago1+ 23 = 24 7 + 89 = 96 4 + 56 = 60 The second "+" isn't registering because the animation tied to the operator buttons for some reason only blocks other non-numerical inputs for the duration of the animation. I don't even own an iPhone or have experienced the bug, just guessing at the cause.
- sah2ed 9y agoI'm able to reproduce the bug on iOS 10.3.3 on an iPhone 6 so it appears the bug has existed before iOS 11.
- kagamine 9y agoJust tried this on my iPhone 4 (yes 4!, iOS 7.?) and I get 4 when adding 1+2+3 quickly, and sometimes 10 or 11(!?). Looks like this is a feature, not a bug, or else it would have been fixed sometime in the last 8 years! /s
- ship_it 9y agoIs 4 your daily? I miss my 4S and I'd replace current 6S with it but if I could bring performances. Beautiful phone.
- kagamine 9y agoI have a newer iPhone through work, so my 4 is only used for calls, sms and music. I'm keeping it until it dies and then moving away from Apple. What I really want is a true GNU/Linux phone.
- grzm 9y agoAnother datapoint: iPhone 4, iOS 9.3.5 does not exhibit the bug.
- pilif 9y ago> iOS 11 must be the buggiest piece of s I've ever tried. that might be true in general, but this calculator bug exists since iOS9 and only surfaced now.
- 11thEarlOfMar 9y agoAs soon as I upgraded my 6s to 11, I saw performance seriously degrade. It takes -seconds- to bring up the iMessage editor. My immediate thought was that Apple had liberally sprinkled wait() into the iOS 11 code base so that I'd feel like my ole A9 CPU just wasn't cutting it any more and I'd realize, as they do, it's time to upgrade. Or... maybe they are running every key stroke through the new Azure-enabled Cray computers to better predict what I am going to type so that overall, my typing is more efficient and I'm actually spending less time typing... Yeah. Yeah, that's it!
- icelancer 9y ago>>Or... maybe they are running every key stroke through the new Azure-enabled Cray computers to better predict what I am going to type so that overall, my typing is more efficient and I'm actually spending less time typing... The typing on iOS 11 in all apps is absolutely abysmal. What the hell is going on?
- adventured 9y agoThe giant is pulling apart at the seams. It would take an obsessive, aggressive, near manic product personality to stay on top of something that large and keep it running at an extremely high level of quality. Tim Cook isn't that leader (which pretty much everybody understood on day one). Apple is seeing very serious problems across numerous aspects of their business, from product decisions to supply chain.
- threeseed 9y agoThis is revisionist drivel. Every year it's always "Apple is dying" as they continue to siphon money from every industry they touch. They are about to push a tonne of users into a higher price point with the iPhone X. The Apple Watch is an unquestionable success. We are on the precipice of seeing an ARM based MacBook based on their incredible work with A-series chips. They are also strategically very well placed with their Health and AR initiatives. Anyway look forward to your position in a few weeks when iOS 11.1 is released given the betas are looking pretty good.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- akhatri_aus 9y agoApple has really degraded with regards to the quality of their products with Tim Cook at the helm.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- veidr 9y ago"Jony wants you to take time and appreciate the simplicity of the slowly dimming animations. Or we’re just using it wrong." Apple has lots of issues like this, in iOS and macOS, where they choose visual appeal over functionality, or where animation impedes usability. This is a pretty sad bug, though. My (very expensive, "high-end") Japanese induction stove has a similar issue. Its capacitive touch controls take just an extra beat to register, so you have to turn on the stove, pause 700ms, turn on the burner, pause another 500ms or so, then turn the burner up to max to boil your kettle. I'm totally used to it by now, and never get it wrong any more, but it still bugs me every single fucking morning.
- Nition 9y agoCapacitive buttons are a plague, man. Even the cheap new stoves have them now. Monitors and TVs have had them for a while. Cars are going for touch displays. There's a delay, they don't work every time, and you can't feel them out. Are they cheaper? I don't understand the point of them in the cases where they're literally just replacing a real button. The worst is when they don't even indicate clearly where the buttons actually are.
- shakna 9y ago> Are they cheaper? Not generally, by neither are they more expensive generally. However, there's a large section of consumers that see that sort of thing and somehow assume it means the product is of higher quality, or that's what comes up in the marketing meetings I've had to sit through whilst advocating for mechanical switches.
- Nition 9y agoIt definitely looks more sort of futuristic, I have to concede that. Too bad we have to actually use these devices instead of just admiring them in the shop. Thank you for advocating mechanical buttons.
- stickfigure 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zaroth 9y agoNot a problem in 10.3.1 on a 6S. Is this a joke - it's so lagging it doesn't process the taps in sequence?
- Larrikin 9y agoThis is the first version of iOS I have actually held off on installing on day one, simply because of all the problems Apple has had on macOS and previous versions of iOS. The last update my iPad 3 got basically killed it. Doesn't seem to be getting any better and I plan on holding off on updating for as long as I possibly can.
- ars 9y agoSummary: It animates the + button when you press it, and blocks any further touches till the animation is done. Video: https://streamable.com/4xsh9 https://streamable.com/4xsh9
- teddyh 9y agoCorrection: It doesn’t block any further touches, just operator button touches. So 1+234 won’t miss the 3, but 1+2+3 misses the second +.
- mynameishere 9y agoIs that the actual UI? Oh, man, that is fricking ugly. Biggest computer company in the world, everyone! Famous for their good design! Think how many well-paid people signed off on that dog.
- andrewf 9y agoSimilar issue (seen in iOS 10 as well): when setting an alarm, swipe the am/pm selector and then hit "Done" before the animation completes... Yeah I missed a meeting once.
- jasongill 9y agoThis one gets me all the time - if the system thinks the "wheel" is still moving, it doesn't update the value. So I am always having my alarms go off at the wrong time for the same reason - I set them in a hurry and click Done while the "wheel" is still animating but my selected time is in view, and the time I wanted doesn't register. I'm not sure why it doesn't just set the time to the number that is mostly in the selection box and is being "snapped" to, instead of waiting for the animation to stop
- walterbell 9y agoTry disabling "Smart Invert", then toggling invert mode by triple-clicking the home button .. iOS11 goes back to "Smart" Invert, it cannot be turned off.
- jasonlotito 9y agoThis type of thing isn't new. Even on the latest hardware with up to date software. Countless times I've searched for an app, seen it popup, stop searching, and go to tap and something else comes up and I've now tapped on that.
- inopinatus 9y agoThat problem is frustrating but not unique to Apple. Many asynchronous search interfaces break usability in this fashion. I have never understood how any front-end developer can tolerate this behaviour.
- chrisper 9y agoAndroid is guilty of this too. So annoying. About to take a button and it moves and I press something else. Frustrating.
- uptownfunk 9y agoI really like my iphone because the hardware is so damn reliable. I haven't had my iphone 6 fail on me in over 2 years. It's also pretty tough, I treat it like crap and it still works. The software definitely blows. Does anyone know of another smartphone brand where the hardware is close to being as good as the iphone?
- sogen 9y agotwo years ago I used for a couple months a sony xperia, very nice and solid.
- xcadaverx 9y agoAnimation of the plus button is blocking touch events. What a bad apple example. ... ;)
- epistasis 9y agoAlmost all of the animations on iOS are about 2x-3x as long as they should be. First off, they look terrible, the slooooooow change from one thing to another. Secondly, they severely impede usability because you have to wait wait wait for 1000ms here, 1000ms there, and another 1000ms there after every action. It's enough to make me want to give up privacy and switch to Android. Soooo pissed at slow animations. 500ms, TOPS devs. NO MORE, and ideally something like 200ms. /rant
- trishmapow2 9y agoGive up privacy? I thought it was with Android that I could root and remove all proprietary services (using e.g. F-Droid, LineageOS). Plus, you can set the window/transition animation scale to anything you want. The only thing iOS had for me was reliability and that seems to have gone out the window recently.
- saurik 9y agoBeing able to use an exploit to get root on your Android device is every bit as annoying as being able to use an exploit to get root on an iOS device (particularly as "getting root" isn't even enough on either device: you need to disable a bunch of random OS-level protections with a kernel exploit). There are a small number of Android devices with an unlocked bootloader, but in reality that just means "the Nexus devices from Google that people on Hacker News often complain about the shitty customer service regarding" as the other devices with this property aren't worth buying (and the flagship devices from Samsung--the ones people want to buy with the epic cameras and the great screens--are of course all locked and while they still aren't quite as competent at it they are at least trying hard at their anti-user "security" measures).
- worble 9y agoNearly all the Sony phones have bootloaders to my knowledge, and I have personally always loved their build quality too. Not to mention they're one of the few manufacturers that still allow you to have a microSD instead of paying through your nose for extra onboard storage, so they're my personal recommendation.
- colanderman 9y agoI'd been considering switching to iOS from Android due to Android's horribly laggy UI. Glad to hear it's just as miserable on the other side of the fence.
- VladimirGolovin 9y agoAndroid's horribly laggy UI? Which phone are you using? My Pixel 1 is smooth as silk, no performance degradation at all after one year of use.
- thenickdude 9y agoIn Developer Options, set the animation duration to 0, which kills the animations. It's like having a brand new phone not having to wait for stupid animation fluff to complete. Take care though, because I've used an app in the past which was broken with animations disabled. I can't remember which one it was, but it relied on an animation completing to trigger an event when a soft button was held down for a certain interval.
- colanderman 9y agoGood advice but I did that long ago :)
- plainOldText 9y agoI absolutely abhor the new Calculator app on the iOS 11. The old interface was way more elegant, the buttons were squares (and had a larger touch area), and it worked even when you typed fast. Sometimes I wonder why individuals working for these multibillion dollar companies, who affect the lives of millions of people, decide to change things for the worse. Imagine having spent all those hours overhauling the calculator app, on I don't know, fixing things that actually are broken.
- microcolonel 9y agoI'm perpetually surprised that any competent software developer would go to work for a company that swears them to secrecy about almost everything they do. I can count how many developers employed at Apple I've had any contact with or seen a talk from on one hand. I'm thinking maybe that has something to do with why their system software is riddled with shallow bugs that would be (should have been?) detected by casual at-the-desk testing.
- grzm 9y agoI agree that the described bug is a very frustrating bug. As for old squares vs the new circles, that's an aesthetic choice I'm sure some will like and some won't. My impression is that the old UI is more in keeping with the HP calculator it emulated. Personally it's not something I'm overly concerned about but I can understand how some may be. (Don't get me started on the Contacts icon which I can never seem to be able to find.) > "and had a larger touch area" Your comment regarding touch area made me curious. While the button image area is smaller, in my very simple and admittedly limited tests I seem to be able to activate the button with touching the button only tangentially. Even with my pinky I can't not activate a button when attempting to avoid them by pressing in the space between them. This leads me to believe either the active area extends beyond the button image area, or, more pragmatically, fingers are large enough that they're going to end up activating the buttons regardless. Would you mind going into more detail in how you determined that the touch area is reduced in the iOS 11 calculator?
- plainOldText 9y agoHere's how I see it: I look at a button as defined by its shape as "perceived touchable area". A circle enclosed in a square has a smaller area than the square enclosing the circle. You're seeing the new buttons as circles (thus smaller area), even though behind the scenes (as your little experiment has demonstrated) the buttons are still squares (real touchable area) on a grid. I would also argue the eyes have a harder time parsing the layout, as the visual boundaries between the circular buttons have more complex shapes than the old UI, where the boundaries were very thin lines. If you want to run another "experiment" – albeit theoretical – imagine we shrink the "perceived touchable area" of each button even further, say we get rid of the circular background and keep solely the digit displayed on the button. Your eyes will now perceive the visual representation of the button, as only the digit, and I would say our initial impulse is to touch what we see and not some imaginary boundary we know exists.
- IncRnd 9y agoThe software quality of Apple products that I use has fallen significantly in the past few years. Updates slow down my phone, every single update, as well as introducing errors like this or where I double tap home to change applications and instead get a blur on the screen. Desktop OS updates have incrementally slowed down the computers, notably since Mavericks (and even earlier), so ever-slower desktops are actually expected by now. I've used iOS products for years, refusing for example to use Android, but the issues I am encountering on the phone have become ridiculous. It may be time for an old school flip phone with a week long battery.
- vostrocity 9y agoI still use Mavericks for personal stuff. Ditched iOS for MIUI (more polished than iOS these days).
- IncRnd 9y agoI know some people who refuse to go past Mavericks in their business. They perform video processing and streaming. Thanks for letting me know about MIUI.
- kbenson 9y agoI do have to say, it was refreshing that it wasn't what I expected. I expected a floating point bug. This is in some ways worse and in some ways better.
- kirubakaran 9y agoDo people really need that kind of accuracy? Are you launching rockets or something? The answers are close enough for regular people and more importantly, the animation is beautiful. If you want such insane accuracy, perhaps you're not Apple's target market. /s
- lightedman 9y ago"Do people really need that kind of accuracy?" Yes, Steve.
- jordache 9y agoit's within a magnitude.. good enough for most.
- likelynew 9y agoIf you type 1+2+3+4, it comes out to be 470. Still, it is in the range that should not matter to most unless you are launching rockets.
- WA 9y agoRemember: this comes from a company that is obsessed with design and has guidelines how other people must design their apps for their store. Messing up their own apps leaves a bad taste.
- pmalynin 9y agoIf anyone at Apple is reading this, can you please look into the WindowServer memory leak in High Sierra... every 3 days my Mac crashes because WindowServer decides to consume >26 GB of virtual memory.
- kemayo 9y agoPeople are talking about "lag" and performance, as if this was a "the system can't handle it!" issue. This is a misleading description. The actual issue is that some developer at Apple screwed up their animation configuration when implementing the calculator redesign, and nobody tested adding more than two numbers together quickly. Multiple failures, none involving system performance. What's happening is: the operator buttons have an animation on them, and they don't register inputs while the animation is running. The animation is pretty long, so it's quite easy to tap an operator, tap a number, then tap the operator again and have your input be missed. Conveniently, this should be a trivial fix. Just abort the animation when a second input is received while it's still running and register the touch. (Or, lazily, make the animations a lot faster.) Edit: I got operator/operand mixed up while writing this. :P
- bcherny 9y agoDoes iOS runtime not use evented I/O? Coming from web, I would expect tap events to queue up while the thread is busy with an animation.
- tedunangst 9y agoWhile the button is animating, it simply doesn't respond to touches. There's no thread that's stuck. 1 + 2 - 3 consistently produces the correct result because + and - are different buttons.
- gdubs 9y agoIt’s a simpler matter of not passing “allowuserinteraction” to the UIView animation options.
- xenadu02 9y agoCoreAnimation runs animations on a background thread using state snapshots. The event loop is processing events during the animation. It is up to the programmer to decide if events are ignored or processed during animations because what that means depends on what you want to happen: is the animation interactive and reversible? Does tapping reset the animation or does it start animating to the new state from its existing state? CoreAnimation does the work based on the policies you select (eg: interpolating between a half-complete animation and the new desired end state).
- jacquesm 9y agoForm over function sucks.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- itbeho 9y agoRemember when Steve Jobs introduced Snow Leopard as a stability/maintenance release without much in the way of new shiny features? Maybe Apple can revisit that idea. Aside from bugs, don't even get me started on the giant fucking labels in the iOS 11 mail app telling me which folder I'm in....
- kalleboo 9y agoThat's what both El Capitan and High Sierra have been sold as on the Mac, so it's not as if Apple has forgotten the tactic. On iOS they have too much competition from Android to take a step back like that.
- Apocryphon 9y agoI always thought that iOS 10 was actually that. One of their high-profile features presented at WWDC 2016 was emoji in Messages. But my hunch was that 10 was a stealth stability release, as well as prepping for APFS in 10.3
- notatoad 9y agoAndroid's last couple releases have been more focused on internals and performance as well - For Android 8 the standout user-facing features are new emoji and they changed the notification shade colour from dark grey to white.
- MarkSweep 9y agoThe calculator in Windows 10 got a similar "upgrade". It now has a loading screen that eats keystrokes. The Windows 7 just launched instantly and took 10% the RAM and threads (seriously, the Win10 calc.exe has 28 threads!) It would be one thing if these companies were making greenfield apps and choose Electron to make their calculator app. But both Apple and Microsoft had perfectly functional calculator apps before, why spend the effort to make them worse?
- kristianp 9y agoBoth the lock screen and the start menu have loading delays that eat keystrokes. It seems to be acceptable to the Windows team that this happens.
- jasomill 9y agoI agree that this behavior is terrible, and arguably even worse when menu animations are disabled, yet the Start menu delay remains more or less the same. What appears to be happening — I have no idea what's actually happening, but my guess as to what the problem may be, is that there's no special handling of Start menu keyboard input, just a set of systemwide shortcuts that tell Explorer to open the Start menu and then to steal keyboard focus. My fear is that the reason that no special effort appears to have been made to fix this is not some significant technical difficulty, but out of some explicit or implicit management decision that time spent fixing a bug that's only visible to the very few users who even realize the Start menu accepts keyboard input in the first place would be better spent on "important stuff", like, um, making the taskbar "more social"[1]. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2016/10/26/windows-10-gets-more-social-with-my-people-a-taskbar-feature-focused-on-sharing-communication/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/10/26/windows-10-gets-more-socia...
- 22c 9y agoI used to be able to unlock my computer before the monitor even finished turning on but now there's an annoying delay where I have to press a button, wait for the screen to turn on, then sometimes press another button to activate the password input box, then type in my password. Also I can't for the life of me get rid of "Schedule a Restart" notifications from appearing (and hijacking focus), despite trying all the group policy/registry edits in the book. Yuck.
- planetjones 9y agoMaybe the iPhone X will have enough power to add three numbers together without lag. Seriously what are Apple doing. The fundamentals are gone. I literally don’t know what day it is anymore in iOS 11. I use google calendar which is stuck on 31 because apple don’t let third party devs have updatable icons. I used to swipe left to find the date, but that no longer works. Now I have to pull down from the top, which I find a rather cumbersome experience. I am not an expert on android but the latest pixel phones promo shots show the date on the home screen (or can be configured to do with widgets I guess). It’s getting tempting to jump ship.
- bobbles 9y agoIf I swipe down from the top of the screen I see the clock and the date, do you get that?
- planetjones 9y agoYes. But it’s cumbersome. With a plus model I can swipe left one handed. I need two hands to swipe down from the top.
- saline 9y agoDo you have the reachability feature enabled? It should allow you to reach the top for gestures while still using the phone one handed. There's also assistive touch, which can help with gestures and other settings.
- NovaS1X 9y ago>the latest pixel phones >It’s getting tempting to jump ship. Well it looks like the new Pixel has much worse issues, so don't jump just yet. Phones in general, from all companies, are in a weird spot right now.
- csomar 9y agoiOS 11 is buggy as hell. I'm quite disappointed that I upgraded. That, and there already was two patches that I went through. That fixed stuff and brought other buggy stuff. This is Apple flagship device and milk cow. This is not what I paid for.
- jijji 9y ago1+2+3=24
- quickthrower2 9y agoIf you redefine juxtaposition as +
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- manigandham 9y agoAnimations are the worst part of every single UI I use. Also constantly hiding basic functions behind more menus and adding way too much white-space.
- leetbulb 9y agoTry 1<<63 on macOS calculator.
- agotterer 9y agoI’ve also been able to reproduce this bug. I found that if you pause and wait for the animation to finish before hitting the next number it will work as expected. iOS usually launches with a bunch of bugs and issues. But this particular release has been one of the buggiest I can remember. There’s so many UI inconsistencies and other issues that feel incredibly rushed. I really hope the next minor patch addresses these, especially the battery issues. I’m charging my iphone7 2-3 times a day.
- mempko 9y agoJust tried on my 2011 HP veer which ran webOS. https://twitter.com/mempko/status/922673699752308737 https://twitter.com/mempko/status/922673699752308737 I like to fire up older tech (2011 is not that old) to remind myself all the forks in the roads society had to take that led us to where we are today. RIP webOS.
- chubs 9y agoVery simple fix: all they need to do is pass UIViewAnimationOptions.allowUserInteraction to UIView.animate(...) when animating the flash of the buttons. Simple oversight.
- tzhenghao 9y agoI'm feeling extremely uncomfortable looking at these kinds of regressions. There's probably some Boeing/NASA engineer pulling out his iPhone and making "simple" but potentially dangerous back-of-the-envelope calculations like this. We already solved the calculator many decades ago, then brought it into many portable devices, the first iPhone and now we see a broken version of it on iOS 11.
- badestrand 9y agoThat is what really astonishes me about technology: Stuff can get worse. As you said, it is a solved problem, but unless someone somewhere is pushing hard, it will keep getting worse. People in charge make stupid decisions and the creators probably don't care because calculators are unsexy. Next thing we know, there is a billion dollar startup with a calculator app because the current ones are so shitty.
- geetfun 9y agoI'm a little upset that every one is getting 24, and I only get 23. Am I doing this wrong?
- max23_ 9y agoSame, I am getting 23 too. I think the problem is due to the UI is lagging and thus the second addition click event is not registered. e.g: 4+5+6 will return you 56. Edit: Did it without using the "=" as other has pointed out.
- aparadja 9y agoAre you pressing ”=” to get the actual result?
- tedunangst 9y agoPress equals. You're seeing the 23 you entered, not the sum. If you enter it very slowly, you'll see 3 until you press =.
- dingo_bat 9y agoIsn't it pretty basic to run animations in background, without blocking anything else? Sad that we're going backwards with basic user interface stuff.
- Too 9y agoOld Swedish joke: What's the result of entering 1+2 into a Norweigian calculator? >> "Please wait"
- ACow_Adonis 9y agoNot on apple, but I remember for an old job interview I had to do an online timed basic math proficiency test. You were allowed/expected to use a calculator. Thank god they had practice questions. Because here was silly old me thinking "well I've got a smart phone, I can just use that". One iteration through the practice questions using my smartphone calculator, and off I went to the newsagent to pick up the old version for the real thing... Of course,the rant for why they were testing me on manually-done math for a data analytics job can be saved for another thread :)
- zaf 9y agoWas about to get depressed and write a real nasty, down and dirty sarcastic comment, I mean, 1 + 2 + 3 = 24 , WTF?!?! Woz! What's your thoughts? But then chilled out. I didn't even pay for my shiny new iPhone. Kids, theres plenty of software to be (re)written, be grateful to be employable for a very long time.
- Jzush 9y agoSo, quickly hit 1+2+3 = 24, if I do it slowly, I get 6.
- Jzush 9y agoPressing 1+2+3 quicky = 24, pressing 1+2+3 slowly = 6. Odd.
- gnulinux 9y agoIt is a race condition. Nothing odd, they need to fix it though.
- borski 9y agoEvery time I see a race condition like this the only thing I can think of is the Therac-25: https://blog.bugsnag.com/bug-day-race-condition-therac-25/ https://blog.bugsnag.com/bug-day-race-condition-therac-25/ This isn't that, obviously, but it underscores the importance of testing. This clearly should have been caught in QA.
- jordache 9y ago3.11-3.1 ? LOL Apple.. Get your sh*t together!
- jcims 9y agoI just bought my first iPhone in four years after a run on Android. Obviously neither are perfect but the experience so far has been startlingly underwhelming. I’m chalking it up to new release OS bugs as the hardware (8 plus) doesn’t seem different enough to warrant any issues. This kind of thing just seems like par for the course. I don't get it.
- hedora 9y agoI felt the same way when I switched from Windows Phone to iOS. I’m still bummed they killed it. There are a few IOS apps I use that it was missing, but no dealbreakers. I really wish someone would undercut the big three (on laptops and mobile) with an OS that was bulletproof, covered 90% of use cases well (and is ~10% as complex as the competition), and didn’t rely on ads/telemetry for revenue. Screw platforms + ecosystems; just make it not suck.
- mmorearty 9y agoOriginal source: https://twitter.com/dangerdave/status/921790333905641472 https://twitter.com/dangerdave/status/921790333905641472
- Jtsummers 9y agoGiven that they managed to break volume control for iPhone 7 users like me (other versions too?), this isn't surprising in the least. Volume control mostly works now (11.0.3). However, half the time now it'll show the volume changing, but the actual audio output will be unchanged (may be an app issue, happens mostly with WhatsApp voice calls, but have had it happen some with the built-in Music app, not as reliably flawed there). I'm still rebooting every couple days to keep bluetooth working reliably with my car. Maybe by 11.1 I can tell my sister and parents that it's safe to upgrade.
- sogen 9y agoI'm on 11.1, still sucks
- tdrnd 9y agoFor anyone that want to see this in action, but doesn't have immediate access to an iOS 11 device, here is an quick video that shows what happens: https://twitter.com/yarnichat/status/922051344185348096 https://twitter.com/yarnichat/status/922051344185348096
- makecheck 9y agoMaybe product regressions are inevitable at highly successful conpanies, becoming victims of their own success. Important people leave companies sometimes, which can be a real pain but probably not a disaster. On the other hand, this company overworks people, and the stock that employees have is probably worth a small fortune. They may have lost lots of good people, and cracks are starting to show.
- mzzter 9y agoTry evaluating 2^3^4 on some native Android calculators ;)
- alextooter 9y agoIt's not just about animates, Apple's software quality is getting worse those days. Not only the iOS,macOS is getting worse too. Seems they fired all software QA engineers, and hire more ppt engineer, stop saying awesome and check your code.
- partycoder 9y agohttps://xkcd.com/937/ https://xkcd.com/937/
- ancarda 9y agoWhy is there no way on iOS to disable all animations? It isn’t just the calculator, usually when an animation is playing, there’s no input. My phone feels so slow all the time, I hate it. Reduce Motion helps a bit, but honestly I’d disable all animations that aren’t absolutely non-blocking.
- United857 9y agoI've not worked at Apple before, but it wouldn't surprise me that a lot of these quality issues come from their supposed culture of secrecy and compartmentalization where no one knows what anyone else is doing for the most part. This makes it hard to test things end-to-end as an integrated whole before things get released. At my employer, our culture is almost the polar opposite -- everything is open unless there's a need not to. Every employee dogfoods the latest builds of our apps/website/hardware before it goes out to the public, and culturally, internal feedback is encouraged. This is invaluable QA signal (in addition to automated testing and traditional manual testing) and a key part of why we can release as fast as we can.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoThey did just fine while Steve Jobs was around. It's not the secrecy (although it does help to have transparency), it's complacency.
- laichzeit0 9y agoLet's just be frank: If Jobs was in charge, everyone that remotely touched that app would pulled into a room, berated and told how fucking dumb they are, and told to pack their shit and find another job. Remember, he was obsessive about the first calculator app and hand-tuned it to his liking, so it's not hyperbole to suggest that he would be fucking livvid. [1] Asshole, but perfection requires assholes. Apple is regressing. Their products are too expensive to tolerate regression. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/macintosh-calculator-2011-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/macintosh-calculator-2011-10
- rodgerd 9y agoOr he might berate the users, like he did with the antenna.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoSteve left Forstall in place to fill that role. Guess he made the wrong people cry. Maybe he’ll make a grand return someday.
- teddyh 9y agoThat link is an incomplete version of the the original story here: https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&story=Calculator_Construction_Set.txt https://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?project=Macintosh&stor...
- ship_it 9y ago> perfection requires assholes? Wait, wat? How?
- justinjlynn 9y agoDude, it's Apple. Hold your tongue. ;)
- justinjlynn 9y agoDoes nobody have a sense of humour or the ability to literally hold their tongue and say Apple?
- wruza 9y agoI know I’m pretty late on this, but can I have my iOS 6 back? You know, it still fits all my needs the same way buttoned phones did (except the internet, which is a distinct program) and looks not like modern crap.
- deathanatos 9y agoThere was — and I think it's still present — a similar bug in OS X's WM. ^→ and ^← switch spaces; the active (keyboard focused) window is not switched until the end of the animation, and subsequent keyboard input isn't withheld in the meantime. Meaning that if you type: 123 ^→ abc Which window gets "abc" is entirely dependent on how fast you type it. (If you wait long enough, the top window in the destination workspace gets it. If you don't, the top window in the source workspace.) This gets doubly fun when both windows are terminals with ssh to production machines open…
- banned1 9y agoApple is now Microsoft.
- 5_minutes 9y agoI dont understand why there’s no calculator on the iPad included....
- sunpazed 9y agoFor the record, I’ve never touched the native calculator. I’ve been using an RPN tool called CALX. It’s great. I’d more than happily pay to use it, but it’s free!
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoI probably own more Apple devices than most people here (even considering this is HN we're talking about) because I do a lot of iOS programming and I have to use them as test devices. I also own the latest devices. But this problem is not some stupid complaint coming from uninformed people. This calculator thing was a perfect symbolism for all this bullshit that's been going on since iOS 11 release because the bug is so easy to replicate, but there's much more going on than just this calculator bug. Before I go on, note that I have the latest iOS installed, and I do iOS development. I'm not a clueless newbie. Anyway here are some examples: 1. my iPhone apps crash 50% of the times when I bring them back from sleep. 2. Even the ones that DO load, takes around 8 seconds on average to start up. This includes Email and iMessage. Yes, I have to wait 8 seconds for my mail app and messages app to "boot up" before being able to check a message I just received. This is ridiculous. I have talked to several of my friends who have been experiencing the same thing. 3. I had to turn off animations. Otherwise I couldn't my screen will freeze when i try to type into imessage, etc. Remember, all of the above are happening WITHOUT the animation turned on. 4. I started getting emails from "No Sender" with empty content, couple of times a day. I'm just assuming this has something to do with some fucked internal clock (I have double checked and my iCal and preferences are correctly set) but who knows. 5. Yesterday I was trying to take a picture and opened the camera. And YES, I mean the native camera app that ships with iOS. I saw the camera UI launch, but there was no "camera". It was just a black screen. I've become accustomed to this type of lag in app loading so i waited for my camera to "boot up". It never did. The camera app was open and there were all the UI components, but it wasn't capturing anything. I have never seen anything like this before. Please stop saying "haha it's funny how these idiots think some calculator problem means Apple's future is doomed" because last time something like this happened was when I switched from Windows to Mac.
- dvt 9y agoWas going to upgrade to an iPhone X. After this iOS 11 nonsense, I'm honestly considering going back to Android. It's absolutely unforgivable how terrible my iPhone 6S has been running since the update. Same as you: constant crashes, random freezes and reboots, abysmal battery life, not to mention an insane bug where when someone calls you (or you call them), they can't hear you and you can't hear them. This bug persists until you reboot your phone. Like, wtf? This feels like Apple has crossed the Rubicon. The Steve Jobs era is officially over.
- xxxxxxxx 9y agoIt's not only Apple that is regressing. calc.exe crashes at startup my Win 10 machine 50% of the time. It needs a remote procedure call to work now. Activation of application Microsoft.WindowsCalculator_8wekyb3d8bbwe!App failed with error: The remote procedure call failed. See the Microsoft-Windows-TWinUI/Operational log for additional information.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoThank you ! I have been getting really annoyed with the ios 11 UI. podcast feels like molasses - click the play button on a downloaded podcast - literally count 3 seconds before the UI responds and another before I hear anything I just assumed it was my phone. The excellent Working Copy is now non-functional for me.
- patwolf 9y agoAnother UX issue I've seen with the iPhone calculator: My wife is a nurse and uses the iPhone calculator to calculate doses. She performed a calculation like 2.25 / 1.5 = It did give the correct answer of 1.5. However, there was no animation or blanking out of the display to easily distinguish between the operand of 1.5 and the result of 1.5. She thought it was a bug and wasn't giving her an answer. I always thought it was a little scary that such a horribly designed calculator was being used by so many medical professionals.
- jonandersense 9y agoI just tested this and it does animate (a brief flash). This is on iOS 11, so maybe you have a different version?
- patwolf 9y agoyes, this was iOS 9 or 10
- j605 9y agoI am more scared of professionals using a phone calculator instead of a dumb calculator that should work all the time. I always carry around my scientific calculator not because my phone can't do it but because it is more reliable.
- mrfusion 9y agoI seem to get 23 when I try this.
- aj7 9y agoUse Wolfram Alpha.
- temp8748 9y agoIt does this in iOS 10 too (just tested)
- Aardappel 9y agoThis very problem is also an eternal struggle in game development when it comes to player character animation. There's some people who wish to start blending into the next animation the moment a new player input comes in. This is great for responsive gameplay, but causes wonkey looking animations, feet sliding etc. Then there's the people that simply want to always let an animation complete. It looks great, but obviously is very frustrating as your inputs get ignored and you can't react to things when you want to. Buffering inputs is not viable either. Sadly, it seems in modern games the latter group is winning more and more. For example, in the Witcher 3 (which is otherwise an amazing game) orienting your character such that it is looking at (and the right distance from) a pickup is almost a minigame, since every time you tap a directional key to move in the a direction, an animation plays, which inevitably moves you too far. I can't really resist playing games like The Witcher 3 anyway, but if I could I would "vote with my wallet" and not play any games that prefer animation fidelity over good player controls. Sigh.
- sashk 9y agoJust tested out on iOS 10.3.2 with iPhone SE and it has exactly same bug. Trying to add 1+4+7 will result in answer being 48. So it's more than a year-old bug.
- ratiofarming 9y agoI see so many people here saying that their performance in older iPhones has declined with iOS 11. I would like to point out that most (if not all) the lag issues and other performance related issues can be reproduced on a current iPhone 8. I have one. The flashlight has a noticeable delay when turning it on, the calculator is broken as described, the UI gets stuck a lot, apps crash a lot etc. This is not a money grabbing scheme by apple. iOS 11 is just really bad software. Not the calculator though, this problem is older and has been there in iOS 10 aswell.