6 ms·
The Fermi Paradox is the contradiction between the very reasonable surmise that there must be other forms of technologically advanced life out there somewhere i
by joe_the_user 9y ago
The Fermi Paradox is the contradiction between the very reasonable surmise that there must be other forms of technologically advanced life out there somewhere in our great galaxy and the complete lack of any evidence for it.
But not quite. This paradox assumes that a more technologically advanced society would naturally expand it's energy usage and output to the point that it could be detected by us. That is, expand it's energy output to be much more than our civilization's output since we actually couldn't detect a civilization of our own scale if it was on even the nearest star.
So the paradox is entirely speculative. Alienation civilizations might go in all sorts of ways. They might spend their resources on computation (as suggested by the article), they might consciously create low-energy-usage steady-state utopias, they might eventually destroy themselves, they might just never discover a way to attain such high energy usage, they might become so efficient they don't leak energy into space or something else we haven't thought it.
It's not that Fermi is entirely ridiculous to consider but the way is presented, a lot of people wouldn't know that the universe could full of earth-level societies and we wouldn't know and that's a bit annoying.
- davedx 9y agoBut that’s the thing, if our galaxy had lots of 20-21st century Earth level civilizations, we would be able to detect them with our existing SETI programmes. Personally I like the hypothesis that states eventually all comms will be encrypted and therefore indistinguishable from white noise.
- teekert 9y agoOr simply using tech we haven't discovered yet (i.e. some faster than light method).
- joe_the_user 9y agoWe could not detect civilizations at our level because standard transmissions decay the square of the distance and so such would be quantum noise by the time they got to the nearest start. And less than that by the time they further.
- davedx 9y agoAccording to the SETI FAQ, it would be possible for alien civilizations to detect our higher powered radar systems with SETI setups similar to our own. Do you dispute this claim from SETI? Can you provide a citation?
- quickben 9y agoHe was approaching this from physics and whatever that inverse distance power propagination law is called for 3d space.
- quickben 9y agoI am not at a PC right now, but I can see your point. To counter, Seti should catch anything really high powered. Whether or not a civilization can operate something at that level of power, is a thought experiment. But, still, they sift the skies, at least we are trying right ? :D
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoYou can shine a laser at a place where you expect a planet.
- ajuc 9y agoThere's around 512 G-type stars in 100 light years radius around us. That's not many. Milky Way radius is 100 000 light years. If our galaxy had lots of civilizations that just learned radio in last 100 years - odds are quite high that we wouldn't be able to detect them YET, even if we had the technology to do so.
- davedx 9y agoI understand the probabilities involved. The OP made a rather extreme claim that 'the universe could full of earth-level societies and we wouldn't know'. If all 512 G-type stars in 100 light years had earth-level societies, we would be able to detect their higher powered radio transmissions. Right?
- KineticLensman 9y agoOnly those transmissions that were timed (travelling at the speed of light) to arrive in the small number of decades where we have been listening. Other constraints may also apply
- joe_the_user 9y agoEven Seven light years is a vast, vast distance. The limit isn't 100 light years, it's something like one or less light years. Any ordinary radio transmission dissipates the square of the distance involved. At a certain level, transmissions become so faint they are indistinguishable from quantum noise. You can find the math done on Quora (apologies for semi-walled-garden link). Remember, there's difference between getting a signal whose properties one knows and getting arbitrary signal - if there a strong GPS transmitter or something we knew, we could wait long enough and get micro-data. But arbitrary signal, no, information theory says no. (read all the answers together). https://www.quora.com/How-far-can-radio-transmissions-from-Earth-travel-toward-other-stars-before-they-are-so-weak-as-to-be-practically-undetectable https://www.quora.com/How-far-can-radio-transmissions-from-E...
- Chathamization 9y ago> But that’s the thing, if our galaxy had lots of 20-21st century Earth level civilizations, we would be able to detect them with our existing SETI programmes. But we couldn't. In general, SETI couldn't even detect such a civilization even if it was in the star system closest to earth: > If an extraterrestrial civilization has a SETI project similar to our own, could they detect signals from Earth? > In general, no. Most earthly transmissions are too weak to be found by equipment similar to ours at the distance of even the nearest star. But there are some important exceptions. High-powered radars and the Arecibo broadcast of 1974 (which lasted for only three minutes) could be detected at distances of tens to hundreds of light-years with a setup similar to our best SETI experiments. The OP is right, in order for their to be a paradox we have to assume that civilizations much more advanced than ours are using a particular type of tech (the kind we're looking for, like radio broadcasts), that their using much stronger signals that we have ever used, and that the time period they used these hypothetical super powerful radio signals happens to be at the right time for us to encounter them. IE, let's say they used them for 2,000 years before moving on to other tech, but the signals only reached earth between 1,548,000-1,546,000 BC, or 450,000-458,000 BC, etc. People are making a set of very, very specific assumptions based on little evidence. Then they see that the evidence that is available suggests that it's unlikely that every single one of their assumptions is correct, and they respond by calling it a paradox. [1] https://www.seti.org/faq https://www.seti.org/faq
- davedx 9y agoOP said: 'the universe could full of earth-level societies and we wouldn't know'. It's a very extreme claim and the SETI FAQ answer directly contradicts it.
- mannykannot 9y agoThe SETI FAQ says that in the right circumstances, we might detect some of the closest ones, so the OP's statement is not contradicted.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> But we couldn't. In general, SETI couldn't even detect such a civilization even if it was in the star system closest to earth. Your quote relies on us detecting re-runs of "I Love Lzcwwdrrr", but our telescopes can reliably do spectrographic analysis of faraway stars and planets these days. We'd likely be able to detect things like unnaturally high levels of hydrocarbons in otherwise oxygen-full atmospheres, and other industrial by-products. If Alpha Centauri had a planet with an industrial civilization, we might be able to spot city lights.
- indubitable 9y agoThe paradox itself makes no such assumptions or speculation. It simply says that everything we know indicates that life and presumably technologically advanced life should be everywhere, yet we see it nowhere. There's an absolutely phenomenal article on the Fermi Paradox at WaitButWhy [1]. Your objections are mostly just scratching the surface of the wide array of possible explanations for it. [1] - https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/05/fermi-paradox.html https://waitbutwhy.com/2014/05/fermi-paradox.html
- joe_the_user 9y agoYou are simply mistaken. The article you link to filled with speculation concerning "type II" and "type III" civilizations. If you assume earth-level civilizations as advanced, "where is everyone?" has a simple answer - "I don't know because we couldn't see them anyway". If you assume some other civilization as advanced, you are speculating. That's what speculation means.
- sametmax 9y agoI would upvote you so much more if I could. So many issues I see in reasonings are a direct cause of lack of imagination. What we know is limited. Speculating is interesting. But it's critical to identify it as speculation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- doktrin 9y agoYou're also speculating. Your original post is quite literally a list of 'what if' scenarios.
- indubitable 9y agoAgain the paradox has nothing to do with that. The paradox is simply in the discrepancy in what we see versus what our current state of knowledge leads us to expect we ought see. The article covers a wide array of possible reasons for this, including the possibility of advanced civilizations not existing which seems to be your focus.
- rwnspace 9y agoThe notion in the article is great fodder for a novel, but I think this perspective is sound. You've said almost as much, but I think there's a good argument to be made that societies which undergo an industrial revolution either collapse the ecology that supports them, or survive it by maturing and expending energy on QoL for the whole biosphere. In either case the window of time for making a cosmic racket is fairly small. It could just be that interstellar networking is generally quite rare. Personally I think the same tendency which makes us so enterprising and leads to thinking up 'paradoxes' like this, is the same thinking that makes us not-so-certain to pass the ecological test.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoThe argument I've heard most is that a civilization only has a short time where it's blasting broadcasts into space willy-nilly, before improving their tech and making it more efficient, thus dramatically lowering its potential to be discovered by its stray broadcasts.
- ianai 9y agoI wonder if all habitable planets with simple life would have the conditions necessary to create oil and coal. Love them or hate them, they still power most of our civilization. Imagine if we did not have a gas/coal readily available? We refined nuclear as a weapon first. The need for a nuclear bomb might not arise in a power constrained civilization and thus go much long before being discovered (if ever)
- dx034 9y agoI'm sure someone has simulated that but it appears highly likely that a planet with plants (or any carbon based life) will at some point "generate" fossil fuels. And maybe, if we hadn't found oil, we would've come up with more efficient ways to use electricity generated from renewable sources. Would've taken longer but we could've made up for that later in the process. Batteries were known at the time of the oil revolution and electricity from hydro & wind were also known.
- nerfhammer 9y agoOr they might realize the universe is just inherently a dangerous place and design their own little universe to go inhabit. Peacefully exiting the universe.
- ioulian 9y agoWhat I've always thought about is if all life eventually struggles for power and destroys itself? Imaging what would happen if the whole world just worked together! Is this something that is in our DNA, to be on top of everyone? 1% controlling the whole world, limiting their potential... Can we someday put aside our differences and work towards the same goal? Life on earth (humans and animals) don't really work together on a global scale. Is this only because of our nature, here on earth, that we need to destroy thing to live well (coal, forests, animals as food, ...) Maybe there there are planets that have excess minerals, resources to build starships without killing their environment, without the need of wars (for oil for example). Haven't we just had bad luck, being evolved on a planet with limiting resources, or just bad luck that we chose to use limited resources for our civilisation, or just bad luck that we need limited resources to survive? Are there a lot of civilisations struggling with the same problems? Or maybe there are aliens that can just drink water to survive and fly to other suns with just oxygen (just to make a silly example)? This was kind of a response to "Can a civilisation really peacefully exist without destroying itself or the rest of the universe". On the other note, imagination is such a big advantage of humans, we can achieve so much just by using our imagination. Also the whole topic of "Are we alone and where is the rest" is so interesting!
- kiliantics 9y agoGoogle Murray Bookchin
- Terr_ 9y agoI'm sure a civilization can exist without destroying the rest of the universe -- but it will rely on the rest of the universe pushing back a bit.
- soylentcola 9y ago
- skgoa 9y agoThat's how I have always viewed this. There is no reason why a civilization would blast out EM waves in a 360°*360° sphere at incredibly high energy levels indiscriminately forever and ever. Instead what we have seen right here on Earth over the last 100 years is that technological progress lets us do ever more with ever less energy. Unless we are talking about detection from a relatively low range, a range where the square-cube law hasn't reduced the energy we would receive by too much, I would not expect us to ever receive random radio transmissions from other civilizations. Which, ultimately, turns the Fermi paradox on its head: it would be incredibly unlikely for another civilization like ours to develop at exactly the same time as us and so close to us.
- amelius 9y agoI suspect that some thermodynamics law says that if you burn an amount of energy, you inevitably emit IR radiation. More energy means more radiation.
- mannykannot 9y agoYes, but every star emits IR.
- marcosdumay 9y agoNot many things emit a huge amount of IR and nearly nothing more energetic than it. Anything like that would be easily detected with our current tech.
- mannykannot 9y agoGood point - even protostars have distinctive spectra, I think.
- dwaltrip 9y agoThe Fermi paradox isn't only talking about detecting alien civilizations via radio emissions and the like. More likely would be the detection of a civilization that is harvesting a respectable portion of their star's energy. Energy is power, and stars absolutely dwarf any other accessible source. Once basic space construction is mastered (which we are very close to), large scale solar collection seems a likely path that many civilizations would take. A Dyson swarm would probably be the first step, which would be detectable from very large distances.
- jules 9y agoOr civilisations that reach a certain level go into a slow dysgenic decline because civilisation eliminates natural selection.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoOh, yes natural selection, that mechanism that mindlessly produced creatures adapted to the Loopdeformation (Regrow->Overpopulate->War->Regrow) and pushing for expansion of there speciality in the LD. Totally something we should bring back. If evolution as a process could be stuck in local minima, then we would think otherwise - but that is heresy.
- Zarath 9y agoIt's also plausible that such societies are non-physical, meaning the content of the society is less about the physical substrate and more about the properties of the system itself
- oAlbe 9y agoCare to elaborate please?
- IgnoresCodeTalk 9y ago> they might consciously create low-energy-usage steady-state dystopias is just as likely