16 ms·
What If We Put Warnings on IoT Devices?
- DonHopkins 9y agoWARNINGS: WARNING: This product warps space and time in its vicinity. WARNING: This product attracts every other piece of matter in the universe, including the products of other manufacturers, with a force proportional to the product of the masses and inversely proportional to the distance between them. CAUTION: The mass of this product contains the energy equivalent of 85 million tons of TNT per net ounce of weight. HANDLE WITH EXTREME CARE: This product contains minute electrically charged particles moving at velocities in excess of five hundred million miles per hour. CONSUMER NOTICE: Because of the "uncertainty principle," it is impossible for the consumer to find out at the same time both precisely where this product is and how fast it is moving. ADVISORY: There is an extremely small but nonzero chance that, through a process known as "tunneling," this product may spontaneously disappear from its present location and reappear at any random place in the universe, including your neighbor's domicile. The manufacturer will not be responsible for any damages or inconveniences that may result. READ THIS BEFORE OPENING PACKAGE: According to certain suggested versions of the Grand Unified Theory, the primary particles constituting this product may decay to nothingness within the next four hundred million years. THIS IS A 100% MATTER PRODUCT: In the unlikely event that this merchandise should contact antimatter in any form, a catastrophic explosion will result. PUBLIC NOTICE AS REQUIRED BY LAW: Any use of this product, in any manner whatsoever, will increase the amount of disorder in the universe. Although no liability is implied herein, the consumer is warned that this process will ultimately lead to the heat death of the universe. NOTE: The most fundamental particles in this product are held together by a "gluing" force about which little is currently known and whose adhesive power can therefore not be permanently guaranteed. ATTENTION: Despite any other listing of product contents found hereon, the consumer is advised that, in actuality, this product consists of 99.9999999999% empty space. NEW GRAND UNIFIED THEORY DISCLAIMER: The manufacturer may technically be entitled to claim that this product is ten-dimensional. However, the consumer is reminded that this confers no legal rights above and beyond those applicable to three-dimensional objects, since the seven new dimensions are "rolled up" into such a small "area" that they cannot be detected. PLEASE NOTE: Some quantum physics theories suggest that when the consumer is not directly observing this product, it may cease to exist or will exist only in a vague and undetermined state. COMPONENT EQUIVALENCY NOTICE: The subatomic particles (electrons, protons, etc.) comprising this product are exactly the same in every measurable respect as those used in the products of other manufacturers, and no claim to the contrary may legitimately be expressed or implied. HEALTH WARNING: Care should be taken when lifting this product, since its mass, and thus its weight, is dependent on its velocity relative to the user. IMPORTANT NOTICE TO PURCHASERS: The entire physical universe, including this product, may one day collapse back into an infinitesimally small space. Should another universe subsequently re-emerge, the existence of this product in that universe cannot be guaranteed.
- protomyth 9y agoYou forgot “WARNING: This product contains chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer and birth defects or other reproductive harm.”
- rev_null 9y agoDo not taunt happy fun ball.
- tempodox 9y agoCORRIGENDUM: G·m1·m2 / r² isn't inversely proportional to r, but inversely proportional to r².
- lucb1e 9y agoJust a sidenote, this is not original content and no source is mentioned. From a quick ddg search, this seems likely to be the original (1991): https://stuff.mit.edu/people/dpolicar/writing/netsam/warning_labels.html https://stuff.mit.edu/people/dpolicar/writing/netsam/warning...
- DonHopkins 9y agoNOTE: This packet is sold by wait, not by volume. Packed as full as practicable by modern automatic equipment, it was delayed the full net wait indicated. If it does not appear full when opened, it is because contents have been compressed during shipping and handling. http://www.directionsforme.org/item/315569 http://www.directionsforme.org/item/315569
- FabHK 9y agoweight... > This package is sold by weight, not by volume. Packed as full as practicable by modern automatic equipment, it contains full net weight indicated. If it does not appear full when opened, it is because contents have settled during shipping and handling. Not entirely unreasonable note, but nothing to do with IoT
- EvanAnderson 9y agoI'm of the opinion that products which require a separate service to perform their advertised functions (i.e. a "cloud" service-- be it "free" with the product or subscription-based) should be clearly labeled as such. I know that I don't actually own anything that I can't self-host (or pay whoever I want to host it), but it's clear that most people don't. Public education on this front seems valuable to me (but, then, I'm one of those crazy people who believes in standards-based protocols and commodity hosting service).
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoYes. A couple years ago I bought a network-attached hard drive with some kind of cloud backup service bundled (the current marketing-speak seems to be "personal cloud"); fortunately I did a little extra reading before opening it, because it wouldn't even let you set it up for local access without registering an account on the cloud service.
- downer72 9y agoFor sure, that’s what killed the Pebble watch for me. I got it home, opened the box, thinking I had a new watch! Nope. You have to connect it to the internet and let it phone home first. It would not tell time, permit you to manually set the time, or let you explore that watch at all, until it spoke with it’s mothership. I put it back in the box, and tossed it in the closet, and it’s still there, and now it’s completely unusable because the company collapsed.
- 24gttghh 9y agoTechnically it is still usable, with an update that allows the watch to be de-tethered from the old Pebble servers[0], and there is an open-sourced version in active development as of this Spring[1]. [0]https://developer.pebble.com/blog/2017/04/04/transitioning-update/ https://developer.pebble.com/blog/2017/04/04/transitioning-u... [1]https://rebble.io/ https://rebble.io/
- oneweekwonder 9y ago
- NKosmatos 9y agoInteresting idea. I wonder how this would look like on commercial software packages :-) Yeah I'm an oldschooler that remembers buying software and games in actual physical boxes!!!
- npsimons 9y agoNo lie, I still have games in physical boxes, and none of them phone home or require any sort of Internet connection to function. Almost as if they designed for http://offlinefirst.org/ http://offlinefirst.org/ instead of the other way around . . .
- rootlocus 9y agoI sometimes buy hard copies of games simply because I dreamed of having a PlayStation or a gaming PC as a kid, but my parents couldn't afford either, so I never got the chance of collecting anything related to PC games. Unfortunately, most of them only come with a small piece of paper inside with a steam activation code written on it. I remember when games contained entire manuals in the box.
- jaclaz 9y ago>Yeah I'm an oldschooler that remembers buying software and games in actual physical boxes!!! Old enough to remember also printed, well written, exhaustive manuals coming with them? ;-)
- jacquesm 9y agoSimple rule: I buy it, I own it and it should not need an external service to operate. If it does then I'm not buying it. None of those grafted on services for me, I really have yet to see anything that was so compelling that I would give up and consent to essentially renting a device and having an account with some service to make it useful. That way you also don't need to warn anybody about the lousy security, I'm 100% convinced that those companies that are exploited are merely the tip of the iceberg, that for each of these there are a vast multiple that were exploited but never found out and that the remainder also isn't as secure as they should be. Running a secure service with devices in the field is hard, harder than I give most companies credit for and those companies that could pull it off (Amazon, Apple, Google, Microsoft and a couple of others) are usually the ones that I would trust even less with my data because of their ability to add it to the pile they already have.
- krapp 9y ago> Simple rule: I buy it, I own it and it should not need an external service to operate. If it does then I'm not buying it. That's a good rule, but good luck opting out once most manufacturers no longer give you an option.
- JustSomeNobody 9y ago> That's a good rule, but good luck opting out once most manufacturers no longer give you an option. The irony is that this is Hacker News and so many people building those things hang out here. If we want to make a difference, we have to start making a difference.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoWell, I strongly hope those many people involved in these things can feel the peer pressure here, and subsequently push for changes at their workplaces.
- Silhouette 9y agoSurely the idea of overt, explicit labelling about the risks of using these devices is to create the possibility of competing brands using their better security/privacy as an advantage, and thus promote more secure and private products? I've long advocated the basic idea from the article here, but in a much more blunt way, with explicit warnings about the potential consequences: Identity theft is the fastest rising crime in COUNTRY. The average victim loses $X permanently and takes Y months to get their life back. THIS PRODUCT DOES NOT MEET PRIVACY STANDARD Z SO YOU ARE MORE LIKELY TO BECOME A VICTIM IF YOU USE IT. COMPETING PRODUCTS MAY BE AVAILABLE. (Or something along those lines. You get the idea.)
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIn California, there is a law that basically everywhere (e.g. all apartment complexes) must have a sign that specifies that the compounds used on site can cause cancer or birth defects or whatever. But because the signs are pervasive, they are basically useless. This feels kind of like that.
- jorvi 9y agoIt's what I call the WebMD problem, though it's much older. WebMD has to put 'cancer' as possible cause for nearly every symptom because otherwise they risk huge lawsuits. Another shining example is some chainsaws having the warning label 'do not stop saw with hands or genitals'. I've always wondered, to Europeans, sue happy cultures like China or America look absolutely bonkers, but how do these cultures view Europe where it concerns that segment of society.. toothless? Sensible?
- npsimons 9y ago> This feels kind of like that. It might feel like that, but it isn't. Everything[1] causes cancer. Not everything needs to have an Internet connection to a service to function, not essentially at least. It's only these people looking to monetize or "h0ok all teh th7ngs up!!1!eleven!" that are shoveling crap that no one asked for, but everyone is too lazy to object to. I've got a pair of wireless earbuds, completely modern kickstarted project. They function not just without an Internet connection, but even without a paired device. You can load music onto them like an iPod (remember them? they didn't have to be connected to a cloud to have thousands of songs). Good design is possible if you care; bad design is trying to shoehorn required "connectivity" into something that doesn't need it. [1] - For certain values of everything.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoEverything connected to the internet is a potential security and privacy risk. If they had a law requiring warning labels, then all products would just have to have that warning, regardless of whatever good design was applied to it (which is subjective and hard to judge, especially in the legal sense). But ya, take out the internet connection, and no more problems. Take out the battery and the risk of fire/explosion also goes away.
- michaelfeathers 9y agoIt would be interesting to have a word for devices that is sort of like 'organic' for food. It would indicate that the device is self-contained and has no connectivity.
- npsimons 9y ago> It would be interesting to have a word for devices that is sort of like 'organic' for food. > It would indicate that the device is self-contained and has no connectivity. "Well-designed"?
- julianwachholz 9y agoNo "E.T.-Phone-Home".
- jaclaz 9y ago>"Well-designed"? Very good one. A good candidate would have been "smart", but unfortunately it is already taken to mean the opposite.
- fmx 9y agoI use "dumb". Sure, it sounds negative, but when used in context it's easy to understand for anyone that knows about "smart devices".
- rootlocus 9y agoDRM free?
- lucb1e 9y ago"Independent"? I see some suggesting "no connectivity" but that would just sound like a negative thing. Typically you list features, not things it doesn't have. Sure, if you pause to think about it, we (on HN) would all figure out the benefit. But many people might not pause nor figure it out. Independent also doesn't sound exactly right, but perhaps it's just that nobody ever used it to describe this before and I'd need to get used to it. Edit: "Dependency-free" is not as common a word and means the same thing. That might be a little better.
- DarronWyke 9y agoIt wouldn't change a thing, at least not in any meaningful fashion. People want the latest whiz-bang thing and these devices are marketed to those who have the barest understanding of technology.
- murftown 9y agoA little ironic: I tried to share this article on the #offbeat Slack channel at my work, but the automatic preview image Slack generated for it (from the top cover image of the article, which you can't really see most of, unless you view the image separately) is a (pretty NSFW) fake front-of-the-box for a "We-Vibe" IoT vibrator: "We can see how kinky you are". Not what I was planning to share with my coworkers. I'd recommend the author to change the cover image, or at least feature the whole image prominently front-and-center if that's really what they want to do, so people don't accidentally share it inappropriately like I did. Good article though, and I definitely agree that these issues with IoT devices should be made more prominent.
- teekert 9y agoHaha, same on FB, tried to see how to change it, in the end just went for the vibrator image without any text around it (because it is cropped of). Living on the edge.
- Bartweiss 9y agoI sort of wish Slack had a way to disable the preview image feature; I've run into this several times where a reasonable, work-safe article was processed into a picture not-so-suitable for Slack. It mostly seems to be cases like this one, where the first image is concealed or contextualized in the article but treated like a normal header image by Slack. I think one that got me worst was a piece responding to someone else's content. Slack simply pulled the quoted text and picture at the top - which looked like sharing the original article, instead of a response to it.
- scott_karana 9y agoAn X shows up next to the preview/unfold when hovering, and allows you to delete the preview, at least in the full desktop app.
- DonHopkins 9y agoTrump just tweeted that he wants to pass a law that makes it illegal to get brain cancer from your cell phone.
- 0xfffff 9y agoI read about proposal to prominently put expiration dates IoT devices, to show how long it will be servered with security updates. That could be interesting and also raise awareness.
- DarronWyke 9y agoNot really. Don't forget that for the longest time home routers shipped broadcasting the default SSID with no password. Now they come preconfigured with a locked-down SSID and password (though the management interface is still usually behind admin/admin or an equivalent). Security isn't on most people's minds -- it has to be built into the product from the get-go to get the largest reach.
- mtgx 9y agoUgh, hey Troy, thanks for making the post NSFW with that featured vibrator image...was it really necessary to make the point of the article?
- 45h34jh53k4j 9y agoYes. Yes it was. Its a piece of plastic, how is this NSFW? Grow up.
- mtgx 9y agoSo you're allowed for browse for vibrators at your work place? Interesting. He could've used any other image from the post as the featured one.
- rootlocus 9y agoI shared it on #general and nobody complained.
- mar77i 9y agoUrm, you know, people got used to IoS. Telling other people how to make their choices is telling other people what to do. It's not always nice, and frankly, never actually works.
- nashashmi 9y agoI know this is sarcasm!
- DannyB2 9y ago> It's not always nice, and frankly, never actually works. It works and is profitable. Just ask any advertiser. And it is nice. It increases corporate profits. What could be nicer than that? /s
- zokier 9y agoPeople also got used to smoking. Telling people not to smoke might not have been nice, but it definitely has been working.
- guest 9y agoThis rant about societal evolution is mostly based on grounded political science and governance. tldr: Regulation drives technological evolution, access to information drives product requirements when physical regulation is not there. Without information the free market stagnates (read; fails over time as an efficient tool to drive society forwards). If the world will be reigned by fascism, the increase in technological requirements (increasing requirements on efficiency, availability, longetivety etc) will solely be on the consumer (read more; the enlightened consumer) - without as much, precise and accessible information as possible that system will fall. Those who favours less information are the same with one or more tied interests to upkeeping status quo. Regressives (majority of the conservatives) are not for meritocracy as the context change pushing meritocracy is upsetting status quo by default. If you like to be cynic the "war" to be allowed to know (the age of missinformation) is allready here with manipulated narratives and fake mainstream news. Regulation is an easier way to sustain a minimum of increasing requirements and when that is not there (inter)nets (read; communication/access to information) will play a key role to technological evolution. Hopefully this means someone has gotten a little better insight into correlation and causation.
- koverda 9y agoIf we follow Troy's line of reasoning, then we would need to add these warnings to phones, tv's, websites, credit cards -- just about anything that contains data about you. I guess the main point the author is trying to make is that data can get compromised, and some people might not be aware of that. Nothing new or groundbreaking.
- npsimons 9y ago> If we follow Troy's line of reasoning, then we would need to add these warnings to phones, tv's, websites, credit cards -- just about anything that contains data about you. I honestly don't see a problem with requiring this and enforcing it with the corporate death penalty. Need I mention Equifax?
- vannevar 9y agoIf there is such a warning, it should be along the lines of: "This device is inherently insecure and could be remotely operated by persons unknown anywhere in the world."
- TeMPOraL 9y agoAlso: "This device collects data to be processed by the vendor and possibly resold to third parties." Also maybe they should be honest and just write: "This device will stop working at any time the company behind it gets bought and/or decides to abandon the product line."
- rasz 9y agoSure, but Microsoft starts first with same label on Windows 10.
- trimtab 9y agoZ-wave and encrypted ZigBee controlled products work pretty well for in-home automation. Communication is encrypted between devices. The problem can be the Z-wave/ZigBee controller which may very well require Internet and Cloud access to "phone home." I avoid using IoT devices that I can't re-program or if nothing is available except some proprietary/cloud driven device I isolate them into their own little network space, so they can't attack the rest of the network or "phone home" unless I let them. Sometimes, that isn't possible and that's when 30 day return privileges come in real handy. The ability to trace the packets coming off of most IoT devices is fascinating and sometimes scary. A lot of devices are like the recent OnePlus smartphones that record and send most everything to their "true master" the manufacturer of the device. At least, with a Oneplus you can fix that, by reflashing the phone.... which is not true of most IoT devices being sold today. Have you noticed that BestBuy seems to only sell IoT devices that will "phone home?"
- firefoxd 9y agoYou gotta have a link for what you said about the OnePlus.
- alexland 9y agoThere was a post on /r/Android about it [1], but it seems like you can toggle this off by disabling device analytics in the settings. [1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/75ev0z/oxygenos_is_collecting_a_lot_of_personal_info/?utm_content=comments&utm_medium=browse&utm_source=reddit&utm_name=Android https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/75ev0z/oxygenos_is...
- ksk 9y agoI get the humor value, but isn't this just elitism from the software folks? Should we add similar warnings to websites of startup companies? Or during the installation of pretty much every single OS? I saw some folks recommending punitive damages against IoT companies that ship this insecure junk. Well how about prosecuting software devs who introduce security vulnerabilities?
- ericb 9y agoWe need UL listing for security on IoT devices.