26 ms·
Hyperloop One Becomes ‘Virgin Hyperloop One’
- platz 9y agoI could see investors wanting to fund this simply for the PR benefits; whether or not such a system is actually viable. Or, perhaps they'll spin a few technologies out of it. Or, perhaps they want to grow a network of related companies+technologies that they can re-purpose to another venture in the future.
- sschueller 9y agoWhen are we going to address the elephants in the room? Just the tube alone: - largest pressure vessel in the world. How do you keep it at near vacuum? - Thermal expansion over such a large distance, especially if the top of the tube is warmer than the bottom. - Safety, how does an evacuation look like if the tubes are sealed?. There are many more. Some how I feel like this is a "pipe" dream. Lots of marketing, very little engineering.
- Filligree 9y agoThe pressure tube doesn't need to be at near-vacuum. By the drag equation, air resistance is proportional to pressure; merely cutting pressure by 90% would reduce air resistance by the same amount, and that's trivial with perfectly ordinary pumps. Serious vacuum pumps are not required. This is not to say that keeping it airtight won't still be a major engineering problem, it just isn't as near-impossible as near-vacuum would be. To cope with expansion, you'd need to use sliding plates--which, yes, will make it harder to keep the air out. That's going to be an interesting challenge.
- wlesieutre 9y agoDoesn't the Hyperloop concept rely on not having a perfect vacuum? It's supposed to suck in air on the front and blow it out the bottom as an air cushion. Without the air cushion you just have "maglev in a vacuum" instead. I'm sure that's also a fast mode of travel, but like you said, the vacuum part of it takes a lot of money.
- Robotbeat 9y agoDoes the vacuum part take a lot of money? I would think that if anyone knows, it'd be someone like Elon Musk who has built a spacecraft company from the ground up. For many of Elon Musk's projects, I get the idea that Elon is mostly just bringing broad, multi-domain knowledge to bear on industries that have been siloed for a very long time. So everyone scoffs at a long vacuum tube and using turbomachinery, etc, but for someone with a physics background with extensive knowledge of the spacecraft environment, turbopump rocket engines, and all the subsystems and ground testing systems that enable all this, it really isn't far-fetched at all. Most physicists (of the experimental kind, i.e. those who have to have hands-on knowledge fabricating things in addition to theoretical background) that I've talked to understand his ideas and think they're fairly reasonable. People seem to base most of their criticisms on the fact that it's different than what we already do without a fundamental, first-principles understanding of the system.
- wlesieutre 9y agoA real vacuum (or very close to it) would be expensive, yes. That's what Musk designed the hyperloop to avoid; it works with a "low pressure" tube instead. His original hyperloop proposal paper outlines this in the intro: http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha.pdf Another extreme is the approach, advocated by Rand and ET3, of drawing a hard or near hard vacuum in the tube and then using an electromagnetic suspension. The problem with this approach is that it is incredibly hard to maintain a near vacuum in a room, let alone 700 miles (round trip) of large tube with dozens of station gateways and thousands of pods entering and exiting every day. All it takes is one leaky seal or a small crack somewhere in the hundreds of miles of tube and the whole system stops working. However, a low pressure (vs. almost no pressure) system set to a level where standard commercial pumps could easily overcome an air leak and the transport pods could handle variable air density would be inherently robust. Unfortunately, this means that there is a non-trivial amount of air in the tube and leads us straight into another problem. The "another problem" being that if you just do low pressure, it means your pod has air in front if it and has to pushing that air around (or if that air has nowhere else to go in the forward tubing, trying to compress it, because not enough of the air can squeeze around the pods at the edge of the tube). That's what the hyperloop is getting around by sucking air in the front and blowing it out the bottom. Working as an air cushion is something of a bonus, and if everything works out right it also lets you avoid the expense of maglev.
- Faaak 9y agoThe CERN LHC tube is a 27km circle of vacuum and near-zero temperature, and they don't seem to have a problem with that (granted, they had some but it's solved now). Frankly, yes, there may be issues, but I'm confident that the Human race will be able to overcome those.
- ginko 9y agoThe LHC's vacuum pipes are 6.3 cm in diameter..
- iamgopal 9y agoWhat, really? What's with all those mega photos we see everywhere ?
- Analemma_ 9y agoMost of that is the magnets around the beam tube, with the associated power and refrigeration equipment. The beam tube itself is quite small.
- konschubert 9y agoThose are the detectors. And the magnets around the tubes.
- delecti 9y agoThis picture shows a cross section of part of the LHC. Those two yellow lines sticking out are the actual tubes. Everything else is equipment to manage the particles (detectors, containment, magnetic propulsion). And for a sense of scale, a human can comfortably stand in that tunnel next to it. Image: http://www.tut.fi/cs/groups/public_news/@l102/@news/@p/documents/kuva/x194225.jpg http://www.tut.fi/cs/groups/public_news/@l102/@news/@p/docum... From here: http://www.tut.fi/en/about-tut/news-and-events/tut-and-cern-collaborate-in-development-of-particle-accelerators-of-the-future-x194226c2 http://www.tut.fi/en/about-tut/news-and-events/tut-and-cern-...
- eutropia 9y ago
- The_Double 9y agoI haven't done any work on hyperloops. But expansion seems to be a problem already solved by industry a long time ago: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal_expansion_joint https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal_expansion_joint
- bjl 9y agoMetal expansion joints can't hold a vacuum.
- MrBuddyCasino 9y agoQuick googling says otherwise: http://www.spiroflex.hr/expansion-joints-vacuum-technology http://www.spiroflex.hr/expansion-joints-vacuum-technology
- MrBuddyCasino 9y agoSounds promising: - Resistance to high and very high pressures - Large movement absorption - Early leak indication (in case of damage) via standard check hole - Complete burst resistance - Possibility of permanent leak monitoring in critical media
- dmix 9y ago> Lots of marketing, very little engineering. It started as a technical whitepaper, not a marketing campaign, and multiple companies are building experimental models. I don't think this critique is accurate or fair. There have been far worse vapourware and hype-only concepts that haven't gotten close to hyperloop's tangible progress. No tech can be perfected from the planning stage either, it takes talent, money, and time - and you can't get those things without a bit of hype, the key is keeping it balanced. Regardless the concept seemed feasible enough to some very smart people and people with money to spend, where they see it's worth the R&D. I don't really see what the big risk or downside here of exploring this? Considering the rewards could be very high if it does work and otherwise there has been little innovation in transportation in 50yrs, it's not like there are some obvious alternatives are being neglected.
- TremendousJudge 9y ago>it's not like there are some obvious alternatives are being neglected A high speed train like the ones they've had in Europe for a long time? You know, the ones that regularly reach 300 km/h? If that's not fast or flashy enough for you, what about Maglev? It actually exists, and the tracks are extremely expensive even though they don't even have to maintain low air pressure
- Robotbeat 9y agoWe have natural gas pipelines that have to maintain a far higher pressure difference, and they are in the same order of magnitude in diameter. They're not expensive. Way less than high speed rail lines per mile.
- dmix 9y ago> A high speed train like the ones they've had in Europe for a long time? I don't see what the US political inability to build infrastructure has to do with my comment. Plenty of countries are still building highspeed trains and iterating on that model... and plenty of non-US countries are looking into hyperloop, the first ones to adopt it will likely be outside of the US, as that's where most innovation is these days. And regardless there's always plenty of room for new ideas. Unless you think these billionaires should be backing American transportation mega-projects instead? There's plenty of roadblocks there outside of access to capital, where a highspeed train will likely cost 2-3x the initial projections, even if a private company does it. Not to mention the US is a car-heavy market. It seems like a risky project for any non-government entity to take on as it will be packed full of political risk and direct involvement either way... The US rarely builds major projects anymore except in the defense industry. And almost every major defense project of comparable size ends up being billions over budget or cancelled.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- logicallee 9y agoOut of curiosity, have you ever built anything big? I say this because the tone of your comment is dismissive, however it seems quite low-effort. I can translate your criticisms into criticisms of building subways in 1863: - if you build a subway it will be the biggest underground railway ever built. - Rocks. They could fall in front of a subway car and cause a huge accident. - safety. what if all the lights and power go out? Also how would anyone breathe down there. And my criticisms seem stronger, not weaker, than yours. Today all cities with robust subway systems benefit hugely from them and all of these issues have been resolved. The criticism you've offered seems equally low-effort, so this is why I'm curious if you've ever helped design and build any large-scale project. I don't like gratuitous negativity on HN and it's against the rules here.
- M4v3R 9y agoAlso, planes are a terrible idea. I mean how do you evacuate people from them if something goes wrong? I think this whole airplane thing is just vaporware.
- KekDemaga 9y agoThe question isn't "will this ever work?", the question is (while keeping with your airplane analogy) is Elon Musk's design closer to the Wright brothers airplane or Da Vinci's ornithopter. I'd guess the latter personally.
- logicallee 9y agoThe Wright brothers had a bicycle shop, whereas Da Vinci was more of a painter. The main thing Musk has in common with the Wrights is running an electric car transportation company and sending private rockets into space via SpaceX. I think you should revisit whether that makes it more Wright brothers or Da Vinci.
- eradicatethots 9y agoWhat are you arguing? You wouldn’t take the position that it’s guarenteed to succeed, that seems absurd to me. The person you replied to only made the point that it could fail. And in your reply you actually took the opportunity to degrade artists and thinkers, which seems cruel and unnecessary. You’ve found a flaw, I think a pedantic one, in the example they gave. Here’s an example that is less flawed, and I think if you had considered their point rather than sought minute flaws you could see this yourself: the palm note vs the iPhone. Hopefully, even if my analogy is not literally flawless, you can take my point. Also, sorry for spamming you, something you wrote struck me and I wanted to see what else you wrote. Hope you don’t mind this.
- jfindley 9y agoIt's easy to come up with reasons why something won't work. But, usually, it's more productive to start with the understanding that other people are smart too, and that they may have thought of these problems. In this particular case, I believe that the original white paper addresses these points. I'm not a structural engineer, so I've no idea if their solutions are valid and I'm not saying that it's never okay to criticize, but this reads to me as if you may have fallen into the trap of forgetting that the people who designed this are very smart people, and thus likely thought of the obvious problems.
- peter303 9y agoHope it fares better than Virgin Galactic which is at least eight years behind schedule (first commercial flights proposed for 2010).
- jandrese 9y agoDidn't Virgin Galactic go on hiatus after the test pilot died?
- dmix 9y agoDespite the fact there are more billionaires than ever, it's funny how small the group of bold innovators are. It always seems to be the same few people.
- ballooney 9y agoNo, it’s different people doing it, but the same few people funding it. Like VC.
- dx034 9y agoI'd argue that Bill Gate's work has a better return of investment for society.
- larkeith 9y agoIMO, we need both types - Gates' work improves society in our current world, while Musk and Branson's investment kickstart the scientific and technological advances needed to further our civilization.
- kumarski 9y agoSomething I wrote a while ago.... w/ back of the napkin calculations....... Why I wouldn’t invest a money into Hyperloop - Stabilizing a single fault line risk pylon is more than $250K. - How many million are needed for vacuum pumps to evacuate 100+ million cubic feet of of pipe to 100 Pa? - Hot air discharge needs to go somewhere. For every 1 bar pressure, you need ~200 to ~400 cubic meters of volume which is larger - This seems very much like one of those Andy Grove Fallacies. - The hyperloop is a mega engineering project on the ground. Nobody on their team is a civil engineer. Looking at their team objectively, there seems to be a mismatch of competency. - At its core, the science i good, the cost-economics do not work. Das ist nicht gute.
- Analemma_ 9y agoWhen Musk first said that an LA<->SF Hyperloop could be built for 1/8th the cost of the equivalent HSR, I chuckled and then waited for the punchline, which still hasn’t arrived. It’s a cool idea and I do want to see more prototypes and feasibility studies, but people need to get off the hype train (no pun intended) and be realistic about the cost.
- Chathamization 9y ago> When Musk first said that an LA<->SF Hyperloop could be built for 1/8th the cost of the equivalent HSR, I chuckled and then waited for the punchline, which still hasn’t arrived. Yeah, and that proposal was for something with much lower throughput, that didn't have stops along the way, and didn't even reach the same areas (they saved money by stopping outside both cities, which the rail line wouldn't do). It also assumed that the tubes could just be placed along the highway meridians (a lot of the money it was supposed to save was from this).
- warent 9y agoTo be fair, if Elon worked in the project for 40 - 80 hours a week, he probably could get a team to accomplish it at 1/8th the cost or lower. Consider he did this with rockets, getting them to under 1/10th the cost
- lisper 9y agoAll of the Hyperloop development efforts are ignoring the elephant in the room: thermal expansion. If you do the math, the ends of a viable hyperloop track will have to move hundreds of meters [1]. No one has yet advanced even a viable idea for how to deal with that, let alone an actual design. Until that happens, the Hyperloop is vaporware. [1] It's a trivial calculation. The thermal expansion coefficient of steel is about 10^-5. A typical run of, say, SF->LA is 600 km. Temperatures in the central valley range over about 100 degrees. Multiply everything together and the result is 600 meters.
- iamgopal 9y agoExpansion joints are available since decades.
- lisper 9y agoNot ones that will hold a vacuum.
- madamelic 9y agoI am not an engineer. Is it impossible to create one? If a tube is a vacuum, then the tube moves, I don't think that negates the vacuum or does expansion and contraction make a vacuum impossible? I wouldn't believe so.
- dx034 9y agoImpossible not. But expensive. And hyperloop is supposed to be cheaper than HSR.
- LeoPanthera 9y agoNot with that attitude.
- dclowd9901 9y agoYour comment may seem flippant, but honestly it seems like people are more eager to be right than aspirational these days.
- batrat 9y agoI see so many negative comments about this, but in my opinion everything has to start somewhere. It doesn't matter how crazy and impossible it looks, it will be done eventually (and we have plenty of examples). Maybe we will not teleport in 2 seconds across the globe or this project will die, who knows if we don't try. A little bit of optimism doesn't hurt. Just saying. And for Virgin, it's not my money, if they want to invest in a black hole sure they can.
- rco8786 9y agoRight. Could you imagine what people thought/said around the advent of commercial airliners or heck, even automobiles?
- TremendousJudge 9y agoOr turbojet trains[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbojet_train https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbojet_train
- pavel_lishin 9y agoOr Ekranoplans[2] [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ekranoplan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ekranoplan
- mrguyorama 9y agoor flying cars, or jetpacks, or a million other ideas that just had "engineering problems" that were supposed to revolutionize transportation.
- wallace_f 9y agoMy favorite historical example of this is that of the nautical screw. Orwell mentions it in one of his lesser-known essays when discussing the problems with arguing about economics(1). >"When the nautical screw was first invented, there was a controversy that lasted for years as to whether screw-steamers or paddle-steamers were better. The paddle-steamers, like all obsolete things, had their champions. Finally, however, a distinguished admiral tied a screw-steamer and a paddle-steamer of equal horsepower stern to stern and set their engines running. That settled the question once and for all. And it was something similar that happened on the fields of Norway and of Flanders [referencing economic questions]." 1 - www.orwell.ru/library/essays/lion/english/e_saw
- uptownfunk 9y agoLots of comments about how this is not feasible, but wasn't spaceX's vision of a reusable rockets similarly not feasible at the outset and they've since been making some quite considerable progress towards this.
- platz 9y agoHN certainly did _not_ take a "not feasable" stance on spaceX's vision of a reusable rockets.
- lmm 9y agoA reusable rocket was not just feasible, it had already been done with the Space Shuttle. "We'll do what the Space Shuttle did but 50x cheaper" is ambitious to be sure, but it's not at the same level as "we'll do this completely new thing that has never been done before".
- excalibur 9y ago....Are they going to rename it in the future based on the number of pods that have gone through its tubes?
- leke 9y agoI see they are using the term "extremely low pressure tubes" instead of vacuum tubes.
- alexozer 9y agoKeeping a plain miles-long tube at at least 90% vacuum seems pretty hard to me, especially when needing to deal with evacuations and possible breakages. Why not divide the tubes into discrete sections gated by movable airtight caps that side away while passing through? If one section repressurizes due to evacuation or some other fault, so be it.
- maxerickson 9y agoIf you have a breakage or stopped capsule you anyway have to shut the whole thing down.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- spacecity1971 9y agoI wonder if the tube could be continuously woven from carbon fiber and given an aerogel insulating wrap, then the interior coated with ceramic? This would perhaps mitigate heat expansion issues.
- arketyp 9y agoI feel that name has got to be a double entendre.
- sova 9y agoSeeing as it'll be the first hyperloop? Or are you talking about the maiden voyage?
- manigandham 9y agoThe engineering has never been a problem, vacuum-tube trains are an idea that's been around for centuries. [1] Removing friction and air resistance is a simple physics problem, and there are already operational maglev [2] trains so putting them in a low-pressure tunnel is not a major revolution. The real issue is the viability of such a transport because of the cost, complexity, and construction effort involved. We (in the USA) can barely build a high-speed rail line effectively so a Hyperloop competing with existing transportation options doesn't make economic sense currently. Take a look at what happened to the Concorde program for a similar example of great technology that just couldn't survive as a commercial service. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vactrain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vactrain 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maglev https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maglev EDIT: Yes, the engineering effort is not easy, but the science is pretty straightforward. We're not discovering new physics here...
- jahnu 9y ago"The engineering has never been a problem, vacuum-tube trains are an idea that's been around for centuries. [1] Removing friction and air resistance is a simple physics problem" "simple" Getting to Mars is a simple delta-v engineering problem. Nuclear fusion is a simple magnetic field engineering problem. Self driving cars are a simple programming problem. Don't ever change, Hacker News.
- manigandham 9y agoOk, we did get rovers to Mars decades ago so I'm sure you know what I mean here, but you seem to be making my point that it's not worth it. Simple isn't the same as easy, but an evacuated train tunnel with air or magnetic tracks does not require new science. The physics are well understood and simple. The hard part is evolving the tech to be reliable and cheap so that people will use it and pay for it - but that doesn't seem to be within economic reach, and that's before factoring in construction and upkeep.
- sigmar 9y ago>so putting them in a low-pressure tunnel is not a major revolution. >evacuated train tunnel with air or magnetic tracks does not require new science. The hard part is evolving the tech to be reliable and cheap so that people will use it and pay for it - but that doesn't seem to be within economic reach, and that's before factoring in construction and upkeep. You seem to be suggesting that a) we could have done this before because the tech has always been there. b) we can't do this now because the tech is not reliable or cheap. I'm not sure how you can rectify these two arguments since this tech is more reliable and cheaper now than it ever has been.
- saosebastiao 9y agoEverybody talks about the engineering challenges, which have been beaten to death. Elon Musk has a pretty respectable track record of making things that seem technologically infeasible and making them happen. He's not in charge anymore, but I trust that he wouldn't put his name on something that's not possible. Even if it wasn't possible, I'm not the person to make that critique. The bigger challenge, IMO, is economic. High speed trains make a lot of money, but their revenue has little to do with competing with airlines over significant distances between large cities, which is what the Hyperloop is attempting to supersede. The financial success of high speed trains has much more to do with their ability to rapidly start and stop in lots of intermediate urban areas within a corridor. I know this goes against the popular narrative about why high speed trains are popular (OMG they can compete with air travel!!!), but the narrative is wrong. The revenue of HSR has a lot more to do with the number of cities that it services than the end to end speed. If you look at ticket revenues on successful HSR lines, terminus to terminus tickets typically make up <15% of total revenues. The rest is made up by the remaining cartesian set of city pairs. Even if you could add up all possible market share (trains, planes, cars) between terminus cities, it would still be less than the total revenue for that line, due to the additional cities it serves. Even with the gradual growth in power levels for high speed trains, with some now capable of 360kph, end to end speeds have basically gone unchanged. What has changed with more powerful trains? The lines have more stops now...they serve more cities, with the higher power levels used for faster acceleration and deceleration. More cities means more revenue, whereas higher speeds have already hit strongly diminished returns. Maybe with Hyperloop being really fast could grow the market and monopolize market share between Alpha cities, but that would still be a stretch if the goal is economic viability. People see hyperloop, they crave its speed, but the costs are too high and revenues are too low to just serve the endpoints. But if you decide to serve intermediate cities, you slow it down, and it no longer becomes the object of technological lust, and nobody will want anything to do with it. Among economic historians and really nerdy train enthusiasts like me, this isn't a contentious point. The same economic delusions were a primary causative factor in the overhyping of railways during railway mania, best exemplified in chapters 16-20 of Collective Hallucinations and Inefficient Markets: The British Railway Mania of the 1840s [0], which is a masterpiece of economic history IMO. Anybody in charge of building out some version of hyperloop should do themselves a favor and read it, and then work on not repeating history. [0] http://www.dtc.umn.edu/~odlyzko/doc/hallucinations.pdf http://www.dtc.umn.edu/~odlyzko/doc/hallucinations.pdf
- biznickman 9y agoThe viability of Hyperloop One should not be the focus in the context of this article. That's not what this is about at all. It's that Hyperloop One needed Richard Branson on board because Elon Musk is creating his own competitor now. This is an incredibly smart move to ensure the survivability of the business from a publicity perspective. Branson has a history of doing things that people thought impossible or just a bad decision (like creating an airline company). Public perception is the name of the game at this stage, not just feasibility. From that perspective, Hyperloop One has effectively done one of the only strategic moves remaining at this point that ensures it has any chance of persuading a government to select them as a preferred vendor (or continue doing so).
- detritus 9y agoBranson's missing a d from his almost nominatively-determining name — the guy's got a talent for self publicity over challenging the incumbency, which for the most part he hasn't since launching Virgin Airlines and Megastores, which were both back in the 80s.
- nsxwolf 9y ago"Branson's missing a d from his almost nominatively-determining name" Wat? Edit: This has been a fun puzzle. I read the Wikipedia article for "Nominative determinism" and I've been swapping the letter "d" into various positions of his first and last name trying to figure it out. No luck yet!
- eradicatethots 9y agoI also was confused, but they probably mean “Brandson”
- detritus 9y agoYes, there we go. I'm genuinely surprised it was anything other than fairly obvious. Perhaps his reputation's different away from the UK?
- _zachs 9y agoImagine if half of these commenters were around when the Wright brothers were pioneering aviation?
- mrguyorama 9y agoThis kind of skepticism would have been perfectly acceptable had the Wright Brothers wrote three pages of guesswork and napkin math instead of actually building a plane.
- kowdermeister 9y ago> instead of actually building a plane https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjv7bB9hy0k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjv7bB9hy0k
- delecti 9y agoI have no doubt that there was just as skepticism about the invention of aviation.
- daemin 9y agoJust as a thought experiment, could the promotion of these "hyperloop" projects be a clever political ploy to misdirect/divert attention and prevent a viable high speed rail network from being built? Elon's main business is electric cars and (one of) Branson's is airlines. So a reasonable competitor to both is fast and cheap(er) public transport along a major travel corridor in the USA. This means that by promoting this alternative to high speed rail as faster, cheaper, better, they are undermining public support for a real project, which could mean its end.
- 0898 9y agoBranson's also in railways – Virgin Trains.
- daemin 9y agoI think Branson gets into almost everything, like a bigger form of an Angel investor. In that regard it makes sense to use the brand and money to make many small seed stage investments.
- trose 9y agoInteresting idea. In Denver, they're partnering with our regional transportation district to evaluate a hyperloop system here. Unfortunately RTD has been completely incompetent with existing rail programs to date so there isn't much confidence in their ability to pull this off. Could potentially be designed to fail.
- monocasa 9y agoYeah, Denver being chosen just convinced me that this whole thing is pump and dump cash grab. CDOT has this thing for "public/private partnerships" which are just thinly veiled schemes siphoning off taxpayer money. The whole US36 debacle proved to me that they aren't capable of negotiating a good deal on the part of the taxpayers.
- icebraining 9y ago
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoThe original Hyperloop paper quotes its design pressure as “about 1/6 the pressure of the atmosphere on Mars” [1]. Martian atmospheric pressure is “about 0.6% of Earth's mean sea level pressure” [2]. So 0.1% of Earth’s surface pressure, or a 1,000:1 pressure change. To put that in perspective, the Boeing 787’s GEnx-2B67, the most powerful GEnx engine variant, generates a 43:1 pressure ratio [3]. To get a sense of the engineering differences between 6:1 and 1,000:1, look at NASA’s Space Power Facility [4]. The Hyperloop’s thermal issues are a hard enough problem that they alone put this in the domain of materials science. That’s the same category of problems separating us from a space elevator. The Hyperloop always seemed like a transportation system not for this planet. The thermal issues, too, become trivial to solve on Mars: bury the tube. Mars does not appear to be too seismically active [5] and has no existing property rights to take into account [citation needed]. (The lack of water also makes steel more viable.) [1] http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-20130812.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-201... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Mars https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Mars [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Electric_GEnx https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Electric_GEnx [4] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Power_Facility https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Power_Facility [5] https://www.space.com/418-marsquakes-red-planet-rumble.html https://www.space.com/418-marsquakes-red-planet-rumble.html
- thearn4 9y agoSome colleagues of mine also did a short feasibility assessment of the original white paper, and came to some similar conclusions. The propulsion system also made some assumptions about compressor performance that seemed too optimistic compared to existing turbomachinery. That said, I have not followed closely enough to know if the hyperloop startups out there are following the original conception or if it has significantly evolved or not. I hear that they've ditched the compressor altogether, but that's got to have a pretty big impact on expected speeds.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Some colleagues of mine also did a short feasibility assessment of the original white paper, and came to some similar conclusions Likewise. It sounds like above-surface (on Earth) is probably unfeasible given (a) security and (b) thermal concerns. For security, we just contemplated debris from the track (or a bullet from an errant rifle) puncturing the tube. Hyperloop One is testing an 3.3m diameter and 500m long track [1]. That's 4,276 cubic meters [a]. "At sea level and at 15 °C air has a density of approximately 1.225 kg/m3" [2]. The air in the Hyperloop One test track thus weighs about 5,200 kg. If we use the Hyperloop's original design spec [3], a puncture means air on one side at 1 atm expanding into the space on the other at 1/1,000 atm. This simplifies to a wall of air moving at just below the speed of sound. Since the speed of sound is about 330 m/s [4], the end of the tunnel will could hit with a pulse with about 140 megajoules of energy [b]. That's the energy in about 30 kg of TNT [5][c]. > I hear that they've ditched the compressor altogether, but that's got to have a pretty big impact on expected speeds It currently sounds like a vactrain [1] with magnetic levitation [2]. [1] https://arstechnica.com/cars/2017/03/hyperloop-one-shows-photos-of-its-test-track-being-built-in-nevada/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2017/03/hyperloop-one-shows-pho... [a] pi * (3.3 / 2) ^ 2 * 500 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Density_of_air https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Density_of_air [3] http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-20130812.pdf http://www.spacex.com/sites/spacex/files/hyperloop_alpha-201... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_sound https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_sound [b] (1/2) * (5200 / 2) * 330 ^ 2 [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TNT_equivalent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TNT_equivalent [c] (140 * 10^6 / 4.184 * 10^9) * 10^3 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vactrain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vactrain [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maglev https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maglev
- mtgx 9y agoHow safe would the hyperloop be from tube implosion? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T9bpUfWy8Wg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T9bpUfWy8Wg I guess it would depend on how well they engineer the whole system, but who's going to watch over the hyperloop building companies to do that right?
- SubiculumCode 9y agoI know there are feasibility questions, but have you thought about how such travel could affect the course of U.S. politics? One could feasibly live in Utah where land is cheaper, but still commute to California for work. This would both lead to a purpling of many red states, as well a providing a path for interior state natives to find good jobs in coastal city centers. Knowing the status of American politics where highly populated coastal states are overpowered in the Senate by the seats of the near empty states in the interior, one can see that if the potential for hyperloops is realized, there will could very well be a massive shift of power back to the populace with more equally distributed representation.
- ada1981 9y agoDidn't expect to see Dick putting his name on this one...
- a-b 9y agoI’ve been curious for a while if hyperloop and boring company are complimenting each other.
- Animats 9y agoWhen does Hyperloop One get a go on the Dubai - Abu Dhabi line?[1] That's quite feasible. Straight route across flat, open desert. Hyperloop One is a maglev vactrain. It doesn't "fly" aerodynamically, like Musk's original plan. This means a more expensive track in the tube, but higher riding height. Musk's original plan required a ride height of 0.3mm to 1.3mm, which means a really smooth tube. Maglev clearances are typically 1-2 cm, which is much easier to maintain over many kilometers of tube. Also, only the track has to be flat; the tube can have seams and expansion joints, so it can be fabricated by standard piping techniques. Vehicles can draw power from the track; Musk's original design was battery powered. Maglev track is expensive, though. That's why maglevs are rare. If somebody in Dubai has the money, there's no reason it shouldn't work. Japan already has 42km of maglev running, part of the Tokyo-Osaka maglev route under construction, with full-sized trains. That's mostly in tubular tunnels. Hyperloop One is easier than that. Hyperloop One's test track uses a 3.4 meter tube, instead of Musk's original 2.4m tube. Maybe larger in the production version. Musk's very optimistic cost proposals are based on his undersized tube. Hyperloop One will work, but it may not be all that cheap. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fu-6IDp3Fo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fu-6IDp3Fo
- glbrew 9y agoGreat youtube video that presents huge barriers to the hyperloop: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNFesa01llk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNFesa01llk
- hwillis 9y agoThat video is awful and masturbatory. https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSPi1JFx4_-Gz0Fm0qq2KUz4c22UbZCco https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSPi1JFx4_-Gz0Fm0qq2K...
- yahna 9y agoI wonder where this company would be if the original paper was written by pretty much anyone other than Musk.
- kegan_myers_asy 9y agoVH1 rises again.
- Animats 9y agoMaglev in a tube is a proven technology at full train scale. Here's the Chuo Maglev from the inside.[1] 500KPH in tunnels. They're not pumping down the tunnels, just plowing through on sheer power and money. The Chuo Maglev makes the Hyperloop One look like a toy project. Watch the video. They have a production-quality train, with tourists and whiny kids riding it, going 500km/h. They've hit 603km/h in tests, but don't run it that hard normally. This is the first section of track between Tokyo and Osaka via Nagoya. Planned opening to Nagoya is 2027. Japan's Alps are in the way. They're tunneling straight through. Longest tunnel segment is 25km and it's being drilled now. 90% of the Tokyo-Nagoya segment will be in tunnel. Stations in Tokyo and Nagoya are under construction. The line will probably run 3-4 trains an hour each way, like the existing Shinkansen. Hyperloop potentially has a higher speed to 900-1200km/h, but that may not be achieved in practice. The Chuo Shinkansen has a turn radius of 8km, and passengers don't have to be strapped in. Hyperloop would need 4x the radius to go twice as fast with the same ride quality. Laying out a route with a 24km turn radius severely limits where track can go. Strapping everybody in and pulling 0.5G sustained is not going to go over with customers. Commercial aircraft usually stay within +-0.25G. Maybe 0.5G in mild turbulence, and customers don't like it. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HZ6dYhHIol8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HZ6dYhHIol8
- nihonde 9y agoAmen. If you want a fast train in 2017, hire the people who have been winning in that department since 1964.
- nihonde 9y agoAlso, the リニア will cut travel time between Tokyo and Nagoya from about 100 minutes to 40 minutes, which is a big difference for people who do business between those two regions.
- skinnymuch 9y agoThat's insane. If you didn't have to switch trains for Philly (30th St) to NYC, an avg ride could take a bit than 100 min if there are only around 7 stops the entire way (normal stops would make the ride like 2 hours). Reducing those numbers by more than half would be incredible. Even if this is just a pipe dream and there isn't a direct train between the two cities right now anyway.
- Robotbeat 9y agoThe biggest problem people have with Hyperloop is because it certainly seems like Elon Musk just waltzed into the high speed rail debate and Dunning-Krugered some crazy scheme that doesn't look anything at all like conventional approaches to the problem and thus doesn't jive with any common sense we might have built up around different transport methods. But that's kind of what Elon Musk does: he Dunning-Krugers himself into a new industry every couple of years, using a simplified, undergraduate physics level of analysis to find something that (to an optimistic non-field-expert) looks like a better solution to the problem. And the most annoying thing of all is that he usually succeeds. Often in spite of his original idea being technically wrong. For instance, Falcon 9 was supposed to be recovered with parachutes... that didn't work, and people who were working on vertical landing rockets told them that, but at the time Elon just rolled his eyes and said "just use parachutes." But SpaceX/Elon found out the idea didn't work and switched to the "correct" solution and got it to work operationally (and with paying customers) much faster than people who had been working on the problem for years before. The moral of the story is that it's often better to be able to execute fast even if you start out wrong than to take your time with the right answer.
- evanlivingston 9y agoThe moral might be that hubris along with billions in cash can accomplish the things the person with hubris set out to do.
- Robotbeat 9y agoElon Musk didn't start out with billions of dollars, and he has almost no liquid assets (he borrows against his stock when he needs cash). But this is a good point. Lots of talented people have good ideas that end up going nowhere because of lack of capital for implementation.
- skinnymuch 9y agoHe spent all his money on his trio of companies by 2008. He could've relatively speaking for people worth a hundred million to billions, be worth very little today. I don't think he has ever in his life had a billion in liquid assets. You could argue I guess, but he likely wants to keep a majority stake in SpaceX, and likely doesn't want to go below 20% stake in Tesla.
- Apocryphon 9y agoI guess one of the silver linings of living in a "cyberpunk neo-Gilded Age but with better UX than '80s cyberpunk" world is that dueling tech magnates might accidentally craft something that could help society.
- ovrdrv3 9y agoAnyone else see Branson on Shark Tank the other night?
- mannanali413 9y agoI bet with Hyperloop One becoming `Virgin Hyperloop One`, the hospitality and the customer care experience will surely be awesome, thanks to the Virgin Group :D :D