10 ms·
The Ainu, the Indigenous people of Japan
- leroy_masochist 9y agoTwo thoughts on this: 1) Fascinating story. I had no idea the Ainu existed. Their way of life seems very reminiscent of the Haida and other indigenous peoples of the Pacific Northwest. 2) I thought the author's description of the iyomante was precious and patronizing. TLDR: according to the article, the iyomante is the ritualized slaughter of an adult bear that has been taken from its mother as an infant and raised in confined captivity. It's not a quick death, according to the article: > At the start of the ceremony, an elder offered a prayer first to the goddess of the fire and hearth, Fuchi. The elder led the men to the bear cage. They prayed. They released the bear to exercise and play, then shot him with two blunt arrows before strangling and beheading him, freeing the spirit. People feasted, they danced, they sang. They decorated the head and an old woman recited sagas of Ainu Mosir, the floating world that rested on the back of a fish. I get that knowing how this ceremony was carried out is extremely important anthropologically, and there's something to admire in the extent to which the Ainu were connected to the ecosystem in which they lived. That said, I thought the article really went out of its way to romanticize the captivity and torture of a non-domesticated wild animal.
- cabaalis 9y agoIt even describes it as "powerfully seductive" which is not how I felt at all about the description. It's above my paygrade to judge another culture. But I felt sorry for the poor bear.
- jacobush 9y agoThat made me laugh and still feel sorry for the bear. Best put ever... "above my paygrade to judge another culture". :-) Very Star Trek.
- bitwize 9y agoStar Trek doesn't have paygrades because Star Trek doesn't have money. Try the U.S. military, the stereotype of the corrupt commissioned officer saying things like "Askin' questions like that is above your paygrade, son."
- monknomo 9y agoI think that is probably more literal than a person should be with a simile, metaphor or poetical comparison
- flukus 9y agoThe phrase was used in the last episode of The Orville, I think we should accept that into cannon and ignore everything JJ Abrams has done. Aside from that, Star Trek has Latinum bars and Credits as the plot dictates.
- jacobush 9y agoI never heard it from that perspective - only from below, as in "I'm not paid to worry about such things". (And/or implied not qualified, which is how I read my OP-ish.)
- ironic_ali 9y agoWrong place to get a Star trek reference wrong....
- dqpb 9y agoIt's above my paygrade to judge another culture. No it's not. Being attracted or repulsed by other people's behavior is one of the most fundamental aspects of being human. Of course, if you are doing or studying anthropology, you should be as objective as possible. But in the course of just being a person, it's good to be critical, because basically everyone is doing almost everything wrong, and it's good to point that out when you see it.
- rxhernandez 9y agoIt's one of the fundamental aspects of being a toddler. Then your parents teach you to stop gagging when eating foods you find repulsive and you realize there were other qualities to that food that you can appreciate. Then your parents make you do your homework despite you putting up a resistance and you at some point realize how beneficial that homework was. Then you somehow end up in college where hopefully, in the American system at least, they teach you about other cultures and how silly it is to judge other cultures for things you've only taken a cursory glance at. That is, any group can arbitrarily make up rules and belief systems that point in any arbitrary direction. Just because you happen to be apart of a larger group, doesn't mean yours are any better than anyone elses. A simple example can be summed up with the mutilation of genitals. At a first glance an uneducated person would probably say "no, that's completely wrong, I don't care what anyone says, there is something fundamentally crazy about mutilating your genitals." An educated person would have at least taken 10 minutes to hear out that, some people are born believing their sex is incorrect and to help them live a better life they sometimes modify their genitals to match the sex they believe themselves to be.
- z0r 9y agoIs your post satirical? It is easy to over apply abstract ideals if you let yourself. One person's objection to the mistreatment of animals isn't a toddler refusing broccoli, it's a reflection of cultural value. If you weren't blinded by cognitive dissonance you'd at least recognize that feeling of disgust is no better or worse than the mistreatment (or acceptable cultural ritual) of the bear and would abstain from judging the parent posters. Fortunately the kind of apathetic moral relativism you're espousing rings hollow for most.
- dogruck 9y agoReminds me of Hopi rituals involving the capture, raising, and sacrifice of eagles. Even though it's a long tradition that's important to their culture, the reaction is always close to "wait, what, oh no why??"
- irrational 9y ago"the floating world that rested on the back of a fish" I thought it was turtles all the way down. Is the fish on the back of the topmost turtle?
- kazinator 9y agoAll Japanese are "indigenous people" of Japan, just with different amounts of migrant Chinese DNA mixed in (in a nutshell). Both the non-Ainu "regular Japanese" and the modern Ainu have indigenous common ancestors.
- imustbeevil 9y ago> I thought the article really went out of its way to romanticize the captivity and torture of a non-domesticated wild animal. This is how I feel about dog ownership. We take children from their species, sterilize them, and gaslight them into thinking they're part of our family instead. The only reason dogs are domesticated is because we've been inbreeding their species for thousands of years and they literally can no longer live in nature because of how we've bred them. If anything, raising, hunting, and killing an animal is more natural than what we do.
- emodendroket 9y ago> The only reason dogs are domesticated is because we've been inbreeding their species for thousands of years and they literally can no longer live in nature because of how we've bred them. Dogs can't live in nature? I think that needs a citation. Or at least we need some kind of explanation for the apparently impossible phenomenon of stray and feral dogs.
- fhood 9y agoNah, that at least is a fair point. Stray dogs mostly scavenge. They aren't actively hunting for the most part. My cat meanwhile used to catch at least 30% of her diet, something I know because she liked to disembowel small woodland creatures in the bathtub, where they couldn't escape.
- emodendroket 9y agoI guess raccoons and vultures also can't live in the wild, then.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y ago"Dogs" is also a really big category. I think a German Shepard might be infinitely more suited for living the wild, than say a Chihuahua.
- ThinkingGuy 9y agoThis is a pretty good documentary about the Ainu: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Q6cYEQUpBg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Q6cYEQUpBg
- known 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ainu_people https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ainu_people
- edem 9y agoDo they have anything to do with Tolkien's ainus?
- mter 9y agoInteresting article. I didn't know the Ainu still existed as a group. If you're interested in this sort of thing, there has been more written on the okinowan experience which is similar.
- jtraffic 9y agoThis got me into a rabbit hole on Wikipedia about where all the peoples of Japan came from, and what makes the Ainu indigenous. If an indigenous people is the first to settle, not sure the Ainu are clear winners. Lots of dispute about early population dynamics of Japan. It seems the Ainu are considered indigenous because some have maintained their culture instead of assimilating into the larger group, which is unlike the Jomon and Yayoi people who many believe are the ancestors of modern Japanese people.
- masklinn 9y agoThe Ryukyuan people also probably deserve (some of) the title, genetically they are closer to Ainu (and Jomon people) than to "Yamato" japanese.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- panglott 9y agoSurely the Yamato people are indigenous to southern Honshu. And surely the Ainu are indigenous to Hokkaido. Certainly the Ainu are not not indigenous to Japan. "Indigenous" is frequently used in a context where a people's rights to their ancestral lands are threatened. It is an assertion of their claim to places where they are threatened. In the case of the Ainu, much of Japanese colonization and colonialism was justified with the ideology that the Ainu were "dying race" or "disappearing". This was acompanied by the usual policies of social oppression and linguicide—taking them away from their parents to Japanese-only schools and beating or shaming them if they dared to speak the language of their parents.
- Steko 9y ago> Surely the Yamato people are indigenous to southern Honshu Sort of. It's worth clarifying that "indigenous peoples" is a specific legalistic term which connotes more (less?) than just "indigenous". In that context the "Yamato people" as the dominant cultural group in Japan typically do not qualify as an "indigenous people". Confusing matters further, "indigenous" itself is often used in the same, more restrictive context.
- gexla 9y agoAnyone else first hear about the Ainu through arcade games? I didn't remember which one, but a Google search brings up Samurai Shodown, which looks familiar. The character was Nakoruru.
- dragontamer 9y agoI certainly did. I didn't know that the official Japanese Government didn't fully recognize the Ainu until 2000s. Samurai Showdown was straight up a 90s arcade game, which arguably means that Nakoruru's placement as a Ainu character would have been before the official recognition of those people. Nakoruru's moveset revolved around her Bird (either a falcon or an eagle... I forgot exactly), as well as her own dagger style. So it seems like the Ainu are very similar to the Native American tropes (Natural and close to the earth).
- gragas 9y agoIt will be very hard to tear down the walls of peaceful homogeneity, since Japan takes so many steps to preserve its culture. Of the very few people who successfully naturalize as Japanese citizens, all of them have to legally take on a Japanese name. Japanese citizens are proud of their demographic and seek to maintain it. This has worked very well for Japan. In all heterogeneous countries, you see strife for decades at a minimum---see the Irish immigrants in America in the 19th and 20th centuries---and centuries or eternity at a maximum---see African Americans. There is a threshold of difference between ethnic groups where, if you cross this threshold, turmoil and hatred and discrimination will fester, no matter what. This can be seen in America, with its numerous, very distinct ethnic groups, and in Europe, with its massive influx of Middle Eastern and African immigrants. Regardless of how many want to get along, a large portion of both sides will inevitably hate each other, and will vote accordingly. I'm not sure what the solution is to heterogeneous societies. I think it can be worked out. But it is insanity to claim multiculturalism works in its current state and homogeneity does not. All of the most peaceful, successful societies the world has seen so far have been largely homogeneous. Japan is a fantastic modern example.
- arkades 9y agoJapan's homogeneity is also part of a massive racial/cultural superiority complex which fed their imperialistic ambitions and propelled them into ww2. If the international order hadn't chosen to try and avoid the mistakes of ww1, Japan could be the equivalent of east Germany today. Or worse, since I imagine the iron curtain is easier to enforce on an island. As it is, they're having issues with youth marriage and a population pyramid imbalance that's seriously threatening their stability. These are not unrelated to their unwillingness to progress. I don't know how much I'd be willing to hold up Japan's homogeneity as an example of a successful hidebound and insular culture.
- gragas 9y agoI'd much rather live in Japan as a Japanese person or in Switzerland as a "Swiss" than in a country where my demographic is being overrun by another. I truly hope Japan keeps its doors shut to foreigners seeking to move there. Today, you can walk down any of the streets of Tokyo without batting an eyelash. Try doing the same in Chicago.
- sandworm101 9y agoAnimal cruelly plain and simple. This isn't simple killing but torture, the deliberate infliction of unnecessary pain, on an animal. Such rituals are to be studied by academics but not celebrated. What really gets me is the obvious role this ritual plays. It is a baby-killing game. It is meant to harden people against the slaughter of a being raised as a member of the family. It was raised as more than a pet. Women nursed this animal. Then they tortured it to death. How did those women feel? Watching such things, accepting them as normal, makes killing of friends and family that much easier. This is torture being used to enable more torture and is far from unique. Shall we also celebrate how our ancestors trained themselves to be cruel? Should the British Navy celebrating the grand traditions of whipping sailors?
- dang 9y agoWe detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15449966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15449966 and marked it off-topic.
- anigbrowl 9y agoWhile I agree with your analysis of the cultural purpose of this ritual, the lack of condemnation in the article doesn't make it a celebration.
- justwantaccount 9y agoI learned growing up in Japan in the 90's that the Ainu are indigenous people of Hokkaido, the northernmost island in Japan. Okinawa and Hokkaido weren't really Japanese until recently. I think I remember learning that Hokkaido was like Australia, where the mainland sent Japanese prisoners/criminals to or something.
- mcbain 9y agoThe north coast of Hokkaido is home to the Abashiri Prison. The original building was built in the late 1800s by the prisoners, in pretty harsh conditions. We were told being sent there was like being banished to Siberia. It was used for Yakuza and political prisoners. We were recently in Northern Hokkaido, but didn't have enough time in Abashiri to visit the prison museum. That part of the island is nothing like the rest of Japan.
- throwaway47861 9y agoOff-tangent incoming: In my observations (and some bias; I am openly admitting it) which were sometimes reinforced by meeting real Japanese people, most Japanese are xenophobes, racists and very easily collectively agree not to speak about stuff they dislike / feel threatens some imaginary dominance / endanger their prejudices. For all the glorification the country and its people get around the globe, and for all the romantic blemish their fatalistic and stoic philosophy receives, the Japanese I've encountered and observed remotely are pretty ordinary people with a lot of prejudice and hostility towards foreigners attached. Not impressed. And this news comes as no surprise as well. Guess people just love to glorify stuff that's very different from their own, with zero thought if that's actually a good thing?
- icanhackit 9y ago> xenophobes, racists and very easily collectively agree not to speak about stuff they dislike / feel threatens some imaginary dominance / endanger their prejudices You've just described most groups of people, particularly in the older age brackets. People are afraid of what they don't understand and generally dislike change and unpredictability. That's not to say that xenophobes/prejudiced people can't produce anything interesting or worthy of admiration. Isolation in many ways has led to interesting solutions to problems, and the preservation of culture can have benefits just as it has disadvantages.
- throwaway47861 9y agoAgreed with every word. Thank you for the very good comment, much appreciated. Related: have you seen Japanese wood joinery? Gods, that thing is next level!
- corey_moncure 9y agoYou're not wrong. I believe the effect comes from living in a racially and culturally homogeneous society. I lived in Japan for several years on and off. Near the end of one of my longest stretches, I clearly remember walking by the glass window of a storefront in Osaka. I saw someone in the reflection that had an absolutely startling appearance, and gasped aloud. Taller, with different hair, eyes, and skin than anyone I'd seen in months. It was me. The experience of returning to the USA was particularly jarring that time, too. I remember feeling surprised at how fat everyone in the airport was, how there were people with different skin colors everywhere, how loud and lacking in politeness social interactions were. I was born and raised in the USA but there I was, experiencing fight or flight response in completely ordinary situations. I learned to forgive the Japanese after these experiences.
- jokoon 9y agoWeren't Ainu some race thing in the Lord Of The Ring lore? I think they were in Silmarilion...
- r00fus 9y agoI only know of the Ainu from the 1993 fighting game Samurai Shodown character Nakoruru [1]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nakoruru https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nakoruru