17 ms·
NextDoor Says Users Who Share Posts with Reporters Could Be Kicked Off the Site
- VonGuard 9y agoWha.... what if you ARE a reporter?
- ouid 9y agothen don't report on posts
- ch4s3 9y agoNot to be facetious, but what if it's in the public interest?
- kobeya 9y agoOh you’re free to report on it. You’re just not free to keep using the site afterwards. Their club, their rules.
- RandVal30142 9y ago>You’re just not free to keep using the site afterwards. Bring me to court about that one.
- wyldfire 9y agoI think the court would have to thread the needle on whether: (1) the function of the site is like a private club whose secrets are vital to its continued existence, (1a) the language in the ToS supports (1) (2) the private news items shared there are in the public interest and likely not reported on otherwise (at least the ones that were disclosed publicly). No one likes chilled speech but there's plenty of examples of legitimate agreements for non-disclosure. Those agreements provide mutual benefit and could be threatened by a ruling in favor of a claimant against NextDoor.
- kobeya 9y agoTheir not claiming non disclosure. Just the right to kick you off their service (out of their club) if they don’t like what you do. “We reserve the right to refuse service to anyone.” That is, in fact, a legally protected right in the United States. A constitutional right by some arguments. See, for example, the Boy Scouts vs a long list of gays, atheists, and girls, where this was affirmed numerous times by the Supreme Court.
- DannyBee 9y agoYou interestingly seem to believe your first amendment rights free you from any repercussions. That is ... not supported by law. You have strongly confused prior restraint laws (IE what you'd be punished for publishing and what people can prevent you from publishing) and contract law (IE whether they can legally keep you off the site, enjoin you from doing so further, and receive money damages).
- kobeya 9y ago> Their club, their rules.
- linkregister 9y agoThen accept the consequences of being kicked off of a privately-owned website?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- RandVal30142 9y ago>don't report on posts Make me.
- Dylan16807 9y ago...it's not complicated. You can, but you get banned, and then you can't do it again.
- RandVal30142 9y agoI still feel like people havent figured out this internet thing. If I want to report on a post by say some scrubby Islamic State propagandist I'm going to do it. They can ban me but it will just become part of the reporting. Then give me a few minutes and I'll be back on the site doing my thing again. Terrible terms of service don't make a private garden. Neither does IP/phone number fingerprinting. I agree with you though, it is not that complicated.
- Dylan16807 9y ago> Neither does IP/phone number fingerprinting. It's not that easy to get an unlimited supplies of proxies that are located in a single neighborhood.
- cdibona 9y agoAlso, frankly, what is a reported these days? Anyone with an audience? A popular FB feed? This kind of thing is ignorant of how ...distributed "reporting" has become. This is pretty disappointing, but more than that, pointless to try to police..
- axaxs 9y agoI'm ok with this. Nextdoor is the only social media I use. Regardless of what they do with collected data, I much appreciate posts and profiles being local and reach user determined. I appreciate you can't use it to stalk people ala Facebook. Users should not be sharing posts to a wider audience than the user requested.
- marak830 9y agoSo what denotes a reporter? What if you share with a friend who works for a newspaper? Or someone who works with a blogger. It's a stupid rule, and imho only there to make the users feel like they are in a unique clique. There is no real way to enforce it, nor any penalities. So basically, just PR.
- Dylan16807 9y agoIf you share it, and it shows up in a public article from your sharing, then you broke the rule. It's not that complicated.
- marak830 9y agoSo if you share it to a family member, and someone writes a story similar. . . What is the edge case here. You cannot expect only one person to make a deduction from information points. Edit: or are we talking 'specific headlines'. So if you want to share just alter the headline? Look I can't see any way this could work in reality, it's just PR imho.
- Dylan16807 9y agoAre rules only valid when they consider every edge case? That disqualifies almost every law, among other things. With a little bit of moderator judgment a rule like that can be enforced. It's ridiculous to say that these bans somehow can't be done, that moderators will look at a proof that their system is imperfect and come undone. It won't be perfect, but it's eminently doable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paxy 9y agoIt is ridiculous that they are doubling down on their "private social network" nonsense rather than admitting to users that whatever they post there is ALWAYS going to be public.
- pishpash 9y agoAgreed, that's stupid. That's not how digital content works. The only thing that works is anonymity, which social networks of our age have forbidden on principle. That, along with maybe bot-generated fake posts to add deniability.
- Dotnaught 9y agoPeople regularly leak what happens inside companies, where people have signed secrecy agreements and face repercussions far more serious than losing account access to a social network. Nextdoor is fighting a losing battle.
- emerged 9y agoGood. That's sorta the whole point. Not everything should be globalised and ripped apart from any private context. Frankly this is a lesson we collectively need to learn IMO. I get that nothing can anymore completely accomplish a total sort of privacy or other perfect reduction of scope, but that as a theme does have value IMO.
- phrh8 9y agoI think the global reach is the problem here: kind of like how phonebooks, public records intended for the interest of the local population get scraped and sold to ad businesses and credit bureaus. I'm pretty sure that some of the content posted to Nextdoor could be of public interest, and it would make sense that a local newspaper or TV station may wish to report on it, just as they may report on the minutes of city council meetings or organized events. I think the issue here is when you combine a local newspaper with the global reach of the Internet, and something that was meant for a small audience is now being shared way outside of its original target audience. I sure hope people don't go posting the minutia of my local neighborhood to BuzzFeed or reddit. Regardless, this is just for show. This sort of policy isn't going to make any difference. We've seen these sorts of scraping issues in the past with other walled gardens: site owners make a big deal about scraping, shut down their APIs, etc. It hasn't stopped content from being scraped and reported on. Reporters will continue to report; users will continue to make anonymous story tips; and new accounts will sign up after old accounts get locked out.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- legitster 9y agoI know in practice, Nextdoor is kind of a hangout for the worst types of HOA/worry-wort/NIMBY type. But, I kinda get this. The whole point of Nextdoor is privacy. Like, there's a type of socialization that only works based on geography (i.e. - my neighbors get to know my address, my comings and goings, my possessions - stuff that should not be shared widely). If the privacy thing is blown up, then there goes the last actual "social" network. Also, what kind of journalist is going through Nextdoor looking for stories? That's like the laziest, most pedantic muckraking possible. Can you find no one to get a quote from?
- moonka 9y ago>The whole point of Nextdoor is privacy. Like, there's a type of socialization that only works based on geography (i.e. - my neighbors get to know my address, my comings and goings, my possessions - stuff that should not be shared widely). What makes Nextdoor special over something like Facebook? Especially when you consider the origins of Facebook (school networks, etc).
- untog 9y ago> Like, there's a type of socialization that only works based on geography There are also local newspapers. I do understand Nextdoor's motivation here, but it does seem a little odd. Journalists typically get stories by talking to people, and local journalists by talking to local people. Nextdoor is a specific avenue to do exactly that. And half the complaints on Nextdoor are things the author would probably love to have featured in the news (though hopefully they won't be, no-one needs to encourage the NIMBYs), and might be ones that would benefit from a reporter investigating them.
- ghaff 9y agoYeah, on the one hand anything you write, say, or do in public (or even a semi-public forum or a broad company mailing list) is subject to posting on news sites, YouTube, blogs, etc. No privacy. Get over it. On the other hand, I'm not sure that it's actually a good thing to just throw up our hands and say that there's simply no such thing as expectation of privacy and, if it's that important to you, just keep your mouth shut.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chadd 9y agoThis is timely for our community in Topanga, CA (between Malibu and Santa Monica). We've got an ongoing issue with an Internet provider where about 10% of packets are dropped. Nextdoor became a rallying point for hundreds of customers who have been dealing with 'slow web pages' for months. Nextdoor is at its best in these moments! But, we need to be sharing what people are saying with the press as one of our next steps. I noticed this problem with ND so we started blogging about the issues separately and quoting folks without identifying details in Medium, so that the press could quote Medium instead of Nextdoor. (edit: https://twitter.com/topangafrontier https://twitter.com/topangafrontier is the best summary link)
- vinhboy 9y agoThis is an interesting conundrum. On the one hand, I hate the idea of sites like FB using my posts as content for their marketing, but on the other hand, having NextDoor restrict who can see my content is also upsetting. I might even say that NextDoor's restriction on my content is more upsetting because I expect everything I post on social media (which I do on purpose) to be part of the public domain. The idea that I, or reporters, can't use it as such, makes it seem like they are exercising ownership over my content.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoThat's a straw man argument. If you want your content to be free, open a free WordPress account.
- true_religion 9y agoI am not certain how a private, closed, membership-only site with no public accessibility implied"public domain". NextDoor is restrictive by design---having your discussions be private is the entirety of their upsell to use them instead of Facebook groups.
- incongruity 9y agoJournalism has always been hard – most of the things worth reporting on don't welcome the reporters in with open arms, all the time. That having been said, it seems that as more local community interaction becomes digital and starts to fall within walled-gardens, many things, including reporting get a bit trickier. Thus far, we have no legal concept around the notion of a public digital space, if there is such a thing, and what privacy rights do, or explicitly do not exist. I'd argue that things like NextDoor might push us into having to think about the concept of just what is/could be viewed as having a reasonable expectation for privacy. I can't expect that my speech or even image is private if I go outside on the public street, for example... so for sites like NextDoor, is there a threshold where they become so dominant or so a part of our daily lives/community interaction where we should start to see them as public spaces with certain expectations around rights (or lack thereof)? When it's small, the private club idea fits well – but if it becomes dominant and essential to community life – do we need to rethink that idea?
- jimktrains2 9y agoWhy isn't it as simple as "if it's not on a computer you own, don't expect privacy."
- matt4077 9y agoBecause that would preclude the internet from being useful for a rather large portion of people's lives. (Not that I believe you have a right to privacy when you organise as a neighbourhood group and basically act like a tiny, kleptocratic, unelected apartheid regime.)
- jimktrains2 9y agoHow so? The current state is that nothing is private if it's on someone else's server. What I described is the current state. Just because you trust Google not to publish all your email doesn't mean they're private.
- gruez 9y ago>And the site's administrators now warn that users who leak Nextdoor posts to reporters could be kicked off the site. ...and what's preventing the reporters from creating new accounts? journalistic integrity? threat of lawsuit (not sure what standing they have)? also, how do they track down who the source is?
- tspike 9y agoNextdoor mails you a postcard for validation, and your address has to be within the neighborhood.
- gruez 9y agoI'm sure you can convince someone to "lend" their address to you for some $$ so you could create some accounts. Plus if you maintain good opsec with those accounts + compare the posts between the two accounts (to make sure there aren't any "watermarks" in the posts), it would be impossible for them to catch you.
- fma 9y agoYou'd have to find a pretty stupid home owner to agree to let a stranger mail stuff to their address...you know mailing contraband and all that. Better idea is to find a home for sale without a tenant and claim that as your address and hound the mailbox for the next few days. I also don't think Nextdoor carss about duplicate accounts. I kept my account from my old neighborhood and created a new one for my current home using another email address. I don't try to hide it... Same name, I address etc.
- smt88 9y agoThey used to do this. I recently joined with no verification at all somehow. So did my girlfriend.
- nradov 9y agoNextdoor uses a variety of address verification methods including public record checks. Only a subset of users receive mailed postcards.
- acomjean 9y agoSo if the poster doesn't own their posts, does NextDoor? Are they legally responsible for what the poster has said? This will be interesting.
- ryandrake 9y agoThe Internet is a public network. Regardless of any particular site's PR or stated purpose, people need to learn that anything you post to the Internet is public because it's effectively public. The site may say it's private, have terms and conditions that try to pretend it's private, or it might have "privacy controls" that let you/them try to gate access to the content. But once it's posted, the cat is out of the bag, and the content is one scraper or security breach away from being public. Treat it as such.
- ikeboy 9y agoGmail?
- ryandrake 9y agoI think it's wise to treat anything in one's Gmail as "one [however unlikely] breach away from being public info" and use it accordingly.
- prostoalex 9y agoThat was actually my biggest surprise about the DNC hack. People who live by the maxim "don't put anything in writing that you wouldn't want people to see on the front page of the New York Times" apparently decided archiving controversial internal party squabbles was a good idea, and acted surprised when stuff showed up on the front page of the New York Times.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> People who live by the maxim "don't put anything in writing that you wouldn't want people to see on the front page of the New York Times" Almost nobody lives by that maxim; they might have a few decades ago, but the utility of low-latency, asynchronous, low-ambiguity communications channels now available, which inherently involved text or recorded content with the same vulnerability, is so high that people who might have lived by that maximizes when writing meant dead-tree memoranda and files no longer do. But, even when it was more current, I suspect that was, as the saying goes, always observed more in the breach than anything else.
- anonacct37 9y agoI tried to join next door, but my neighborhood has carved my house out of their boundaries. It kinds of sucks being a non-mormon in Utah sometimes.
- finnn 9y agoyou're not missing much.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- praneshp 9y agoDo you have to pay HoA fees, maintain your house per their regulations, etc? I see lot of troll potential here :)
- tyingq 9y agoDid they carve out just your house, or some group of houses?
- WhitneyLand 9y agoI lived in a Utah city with one of the highest concentrations of Mormons and on the whole people were incredibly gracious. Surely not all experiences are equal, but for over three years my wife and I were made to feel welcome in the community. There were little inconveniences like no coffee provided at a lot of workplaces and liquor restrictions, but if you love outdoor stuff that alone can make it a pretty nice place to live.
- anonacct37 9y agoOver three years? I recently started my third decade. I've lived in both Salt Lake as well as in more rural areas. My complaint wasn't prompted by an uninformed view of fellow Utah residents.
- krinchan 9y agoTo be fair, at least in the Southeastern US, NextDoor is more...RacistDoor. I've seen people ask the best way to report black people to the cops so they'll be kept from driving through "our safe neighborhood." It's so full of dog whistles my neighbors dogs bark when I open the app. The only reason NextDoor is freaking out is because they know there's enough of that sort of material to really cause a mass exodus if it ever escaped the neighborhoods it's posted in. That said...it's...a weird issue, to be sure. NextDoor tried to encourage an expectation of privacy but like...who actually expects that? Really. Anyone with a credit card matching the address they key in can get in. It's not the post card only thing any more. I could easily change my billing address on my credit card, sign up for some neighborhood on the west coast, and then change my CC address back. Done. NextDoor has done nothing to actually secure the neighborhood, so it's not like it means anything to say this to the customers. If anything, the neighborhood members could possibly sue NextDoor for overstating the privacy of their posts. I guess the conclusion is: I'm not just throwing my hands up and saying, "Oh well it's online no privacy!" I'm more saying this is probably the absolute worst hill to choose to fight that battle on.
- sliverstorm 9y agoTo me it sounds like an old story; content host doesn't want the obligation to moderate & review the vast quantities of content posted to their site. If the content never makes it to reporters, nobody will be plastering their name on the front of the paper demanding NextDoor hire an army of content moderators.
- eli 9y agoI'm not sure why that deserves a "to be fair." I see blatant racism in my Nextdoor in DC too. There's a problem here, but it's not caused by reporters.
- Fezzik 9y agoI see quite of it here in Portland, Oregon as well. Certianly more “those people” are a problem posts than I would expect. There is definitely a lot more ire directed at the homeless, but the (apparent) insularity of NextDoor appears to encourage people to show their true colors.
- donatj 9y agoInteresting. I am a NextDoor Lead and recently had a user throw a fit over another user who had committed the unforgivable sin of correcting his grammar. He was demanding he be banned. I told him essentially he needed to calm down and avoid conflict (this user is always getting into fights) in addition to that it wasn't in my power as lead to ban people. He said I was being "very unprofessional" and threatened to go to the local newspaper about how we weren't taking his reports seriously - as if they'd care. I explained that I don't work for NextDoor, I'm just one of his neighbors with slightly more power than him. He told me to "never contact him again" lol. OK. Good deal. Anyway, I thought that struck kind of close to this.
- randycupertino 9y ago> He was demanding he be banned banned. They are ban happy there! I got banned for calling someone a NIMBY because they were protesting a stop sign at an intersection two separate pedestrians got hit at because "it fostered increased traffic and urbanization."
- zippergz 9y agoCalling people names, even if accurate, is corrosive to civil discussion. IMHO you deserve to be banned for that.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoAnd banning people for minor slights isn't corrosive?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lightedman 9y agoPeople who are that vulnerable to words shouldn't be given the power to ban. What's 'civil' to you is utterly rude to many Asian cultures.
- konceptz 9y agoThe interesting issue I find in this post is that nextdoor stated that this is a “private network”. While probably not using a technical definition, it still seems to overreach quite a bit. I haven’t heard of a forum claiming to be this before. Maybe a strictly vetted user base but never a private network.
- loteck 9y agoIf people are posting on the site under the express agreement that the group is private and posts will not be reproduced in public, then what the reporter did is unethical in the vast majority of cases, including this one. We are on a march to losing our collective faith in journalism and leading the way are careless reporters and editors who fancy themselves public advocates.
- craftyguy 9y agoNah, if you post shit online, it's public. Don't assume otherwise, else you're going to have a bad time.
- loteck 9y agoWhile that may be a valid view from the perspective of a privacy warrior, it does not accurately reflect the ethics of journalism.
- craftyguy 9y agoWait, so the ethics of journalism require accepting TOS/EULAs? If that's the case, then quite a lot of very important investigative journalism in the past few decades is ruled invalid! (despite the touch of sarcasm, I'm also genuinely curious)
- loteck 9y agoJournalism ethics do contemplate situations where otherwise unreportable news of crucial importance to the public should be published. Same for news about things that happen in private but are related to public figures. There can often be very serious consequences for the organization and reporter in these cases. Neither applies here.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoYou're conflating whistleblowing with publishing conversations that are explicitly "off the record".
- ausjke 9y agoNextdoor is quite popular here unless you want to talk about politics, especially if the community LEAD is on the other side. Nextdoor uses real name with real address etc, and it seems to be pretty useful for the neighborhood news and events etc, I don't see other close competitors. But then, I hope there is an alternative. http://fortune.com/2017/05/21/nextdoor-revenue/ http://fortune.com/2017/05/21/nextdoor-revenue/ If very thing goes right, it could be another facebook, I'd be interested in its IPO.
- Readywater 9y agoThere was a recent argument over gun ownership in my neighborhood's nextdoor, which resulted in a bunch of gun owners outing themselves. Unfortunately, this did this alongside their actual addresses, which isn't great for various reasons. Users of Nextdoor seem to struggle more than most services around how they represent their private and public lives on the site: it seems to give many a false sense of anonymity, which is dangerous as hell when performed at the neighborhood layer.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoImagine if the argument was over growing medical marijuana at one's home. A string of burglaries, or worse, would ensue.
- Animats 9y agoNextDoor - like Yik Yak, but for grownups. Same problems.
- intrasight 9y agoNever even heard of NextDoor before reading this. Is it just localized discussion forums?
- smt88 9y agoLocal Facebook
- askafriend 9y agoIt's like Facebook but for your neighborhood, along with verified identities (people verify their addresses through a couple different methods) and groups based on geo-boundaries (which try to reflect the physical real-world neighborhoods). You can communicate with people in your immediate neighborhood or with people in nearby neighborhoods. As you can imagine, what people talk about really depends on the character of your real world neighborhood and the people who live there. That's why I would hesitate to characterize the entire product based on any individual experience with it. It really depends on the neighborhood. I've personally found it to be a mix of extremely useful and meh, depending on the use-case and context. There's definitely immense potential. It's one of the more under the radar billion dollar companies: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/nextdoor https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/nextdoor
- TheAceOfHearts 9y agoI'm a bit surprised by all of this. For starters, I've never even heard of this NextDoor site, but apparently there's plenty of users here. Is it really correct to say NextDoor is a public forum? You can only access the content if you live within the specified area and you agree to their terms of service. What boundaries or factors are used when deciding if something is considered private or public? Why don't companies using online services suffer similar issues? If you leak private company communications, that's usually going to be grounds for termination. But what other legal action can they take against you? Normally you'd sign an NDA to prevent communications from being leaked, however I'm not sure what legal repercussions are available once it's broken. Would it be technically feasible to create a social network that required signing an NDA to join?
- stmfreak 9y agoI had to quit NextDoor after my neighbors demonstrated all the vile hatred we've come to expect from the anonymized Internet, but with the added benefit that people know who you are and where you live.
- beeskneecaps 9y agoDidn’t want to stick around to help solve the problem? It sounds like you could have educated them!
- shifter 9y agoI wonder if that’s possible. Being close minded and vitriolic about political issues is a general personality trait.
- HNSucksAss 9y agoWhoop dee doo. I've been kicked off the site for calling out assholes. NextDoor is a circle-jerk of NIMBYs and shut-ins who like to hear themselves blather.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- alexhektor 9y agoWhy are there two articles from wilamette week on the front page at the same time? Is it just me or does this look suspicious?
- dsr_ 9y agoCommon pattern in HN: somebody finds an article from source X, a few thousand people read the article. Of those, a hundred read linked articles. Pretty soon one of those is submitted, and a thousand people read the article...
- cat199 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect
- OliverJones 9y agoYeah, well, in my northeast MA community, NextDoor is FakeNuzDoor. Wannabe politicians spam it with scurrilous garbage about each other, and the rest of it devolves into arguing about that. I guess it's good having news media pick up this stuff violates the terms of service. It does have a "delete my account" feature. So it has at least one useful feature.
- shifter 9y agoSame thing in Cupertino. There’s even a scandalous blog that someone updates to regularly attack various local politicians and school board members.
- samstave 9y agoHuh... I don't use Nextdoor any longer, but when I used it in Alameda, it was really great. I got someone to loan me a weedwhacker in like five minutes, another gave me a table saw, another loaned me a sander... my experience was pretty good... There were crimes reported, and to be honest the most frequent posts I did see were for moving boxes
- nextdoorsv 9y agoUh oh... Do you folks think I should take down this Twitter tracking some of the weird/racist stuff in my Silicon Valley NextDoor? https://twitter.com/nextdoorsv/status/912353163453153280 https://twitter.com/nextdoorsv/status/912353163453153280
- save_ferris 9y agoJust went to nextdoor.com to see what the app was all about after seeing this and sure enough, there's a full-width banner on their front page of media outlet logos, including NYT and WSJ. Oh the irony. What's funny is that it doesn't explicitly say that they're endorsements from these outlets, they're just there. I was always under the impression that this isn't technically legal, but I'm no legal expert. I know this is off-topic, but can anyone just add a banner of media outlet logos to their site/blog? There's definitely an implied status claim being made here. Why else would one company randomly post other corporate logos that aren't paid for or explicitly endorsed?
- engi_nerd 9y agoSad to hear about racism on Nextdoor, but I am not surprised. I am an admin (Nextdoor calls this a "lead") on my neighborhood's Nextdoor and I have seen and promptly deleted several racist posts over the year that I have been an admin. It is up to the admins to apply the rules for their neighborhoods. If you can prove that your admins are passive and not enforcing Nextdoor's rules, they will act and remove lead privileges from the bad admins.
- hasteur 9y agoPart of my local NextDoor after I got a card in the mail. Lots of "Where was that police car that went down my street headed?", "Escaped Animal", "Flea Market swap", "Promoting my home researched Christian eschatology book published on vanity press". Occastionally there's useful information like City Council issues, major road closures, etc. But As others have said a lot of NIMBYs, armchair patriots, and thinly disguised racisim.