11 ms·
I think a major issue is what happens if Google locks your account for some reason. There have been instances in the past where Google has locked the account of
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
I think a major issue is what happens if Google locks your account for some reason. There have been instances in the past where Google has locked the account of a user for some TOS violations.
http://m.gadgets.ndtv.com/mobiles/news/google-pixel-resellers-see-their-google-accounts-locked-for-violating-terms-of-service-1626948 http://m.gadgets.ndtv.com/mobiles/news/google-pixel-reseller...
http://m.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/aug/1/jordan-b-petersons-youtube-account-locked-during-b/ http://m.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/aug/1/jordan-b-peters...
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-08-21/one-statistics-professor-was-just-banned-google-here-his-story http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-08-21/one-statistics-prof...
Given that Google has a propensity to lock you out of your account completely if they suspect you violating TOS on any of their services, I would be very wary of this device. Do you want this computer and anything you created with it inaccessible because Google didn't like a video or blog post you made?
- shams93 9y agoThat's a good point it's also a risk if you use googles phone service although I haven't run into problems if I did I could only communicate via my thinkpad Linux system, Ubuntu won't lock you out of your machine they don't control your login.
- Scirra_Tom 9y agoIs picking a few cases then concluding it's Google's propensity perhaps a bit hyperbolic?
- raesene9 9y agoI think it's worth illustrating the concept. A device that's heavily reliant on a cloud service (in this case Google's) means you have to worry about the risk of being locked out of that account especially if getting access after that lockout is difficult. These devices are very different to traditional computing devices (e.g. Windows/Linux PCs) which mostly store content locally as there lockout from a single cloud is unlikely to be catastropic. As the major consumer OS makers (Apple/Google/Microsoft) go more in the direction of an integrated experience where cloud storage is key, how they handle possible ToS violation and account lockout/closure will become increasingly important.
- victorhooi 9y agoI actually dissected the authors example above - and they actually don't really help prove his/her point. The first example - was basically fraud, that probably got picked up in hijacking/bot-net detection (based on public statements). The second - I can't comment, as there are no public statements. The third - the author made a public statement, and seems to harbour no ill-will to Google after it was explained to him what actually happened. I can't comment on that conversation, but I will say that in general, Google does a lot to protect its users from all kinds of security issues and attacks.
- raesene9 9y agoAs responded on the third, a process that relies on the subject being well enough known or connected enough to bypass common process isn't a scalable solution. If someone has to know to e-mail you personally to help fix an issue, that concept doesn't scale to x million accounts. I'm not trying to get at Google specifically here, I'm suggesting that as all the tech. companies move more of people's digital lives to the cloud, these accounts become more important and how they deal with ToS violations, reactivations and the like will require a lot of thought.
- victorhooi 9y agoThe third - the author had already kickstarted a normal recovery process by https://accounts.google.com/signin/recovery https://accounts.google.com/signin/recovery. However, these things take a while to process. As I commented elsewhere - if your account got hijacked - the last thing you want is for the hijacked to get back in, via some automated form. I had to deal with exactly this nightmare scenario for a friend a few months back. Two email accounts, one from Gmail, one from another (unnamed) provider. The hijacker tried to get back in, several times (and did on the other one). Knowing that the bar is reasonably high that only you yourself can get back in (even if it may take a few days) is very reassuring. Trust me - if it's between waiting 2-3 days, versus having somebody get back in, pilfer all your email and commit identity fraud, I would pick the former more secure any day of the year.
- sergiotapia 9y agoI uploaded full seasons of a very old 90s cartoon and my account is disabled. I cannot even purchase YouTube TV to try it out. Of course, reaching out to support is moot - their RoboSupport sucks. I will never purchase a Google product if I can help it and will steer clear of them in any team setting where I can affect the decision.
- tmaly 9y ago>support is moot that is how I feel about most of their hardware products. I had a nexus 5 and when ever there was an android release, there were all sorts of problems that filled up the message boards.
- joshuacc 9y ago> I uploaded full seasons of a very old 90s cartoon and my account is disabled. I cannot even purchase YouTube TV to try it out. You violated the law and their (rather reasonable in this case) terms of service and are shocked to find they'd rather not do business with you?
- raesene9 9y agoI think the problem is where accounts control a large part of someone's digital life. so for example here, it appears that someone breached Youtube ToS and lost their whole Google account. Now imagine you've got all your e-mail/photos/contacts etc in that account and you've just permanently lost them due to that ToS breach. Of course as technical people we can say "ahh you should have had off-cloud backups", but realistically most non-technical people won't do that and likely won't realise the consequences of their actions.
- morganvachon 9y ago"I think the problem is where accounts control a large part of someone's digital life. so for example here, it appears that someone breached Youtube ToS and lost their whole Google account." Exactly. I recall the incident[1] where some Google Pixel phone customers were reselling their phones and making a tiny profit. Google permanently deleted hundreds of accounts and never restored them, for violating a mobile phone TOS. Ban them from the Fi mobile service, sure, but don't delete their entire digital lives! That's like getting a life sentence for shoplifting in the physical world. All your eggs in one basket is never a good strategy, and though I wasn't personally affected by it, the Pixel Phone fiasco opened my eyes to just how much Google and Facebook controlled my own digital persona. I now use neither of their services. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/nov/17/google-suspends-customer-accounts-for-reselling-pixel-phones https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/nov/17/google-su...
- AlexCoventry 9y ago> There have been instances in the past where Google has locked the account of a user This happened to me recently (though I think for security concerns, not TOS violations), and was quite distressing. What steps can be taken to avoid this?
- nickysielicki 9y agophone-based 2FA, physical security tokens, strong passwords, equally secured recovery email address, nontrivial recovery questions. Google accounts have far more security options than most online banking platforms. There's no reason you should lose your google account as long as you listen to the notifications that tell you to review your account security and go through the steps.
- victorhooi 9y agoYes, this is usually the more common story - Google does a lot of things to protect users (from themselves, and from external attack). I suspect a lot of people who get locked out are for fairly pedestrian reasons like password reuse across sites, and they got hijacked. It sucks, but it's better than the alternative (e.g. somebody pilfers all your email and commits identity theft). Trust me, there are a lot of bad actors out there, The other poster had it right - 2FA is really the way to go, ideally with something like Google Authenticator or Yubikeys. If you ever get locked out (e.g. account is suspected as compromised/hijacked), then: https://accounts.google.com/signin/recovery https://accounts.google.com/signin/recovery is your one-stop shop to prove you're really you.
- kuschku 9y ago> It sucks, but it's better than the alternative (e.g. somebody pilfers all your email and commits identity theft). That’s what happened to me. I had a Google account, abandoned since 2012, disabled. A few weeks ago I got an email telling me someone from russia was trying to log in, and this was prevented. The next day, another email – telling me that I successfully logged in from Russia, and had successfully changed the password. Google offered no way to get the account back. I had the creation date, a list of every email in the account, the used phone number (although it had since been shut down and recycled), the old password, and control over backup email. This was not enough, Google left the account in control of the attacker. I requested through a Google employee friend their internal form to handle this. Also, no success. Instead, they talked with the hijacker. In the end, I managed to contact the new owner of the recycled phone number, and together with him, I managed to run the account reset procedure, and regain control. ________________________ Conclusion: Google’s account "security" is useless against hijackers, prevents you from getting your account back, and is just a fucking pain in the ass.
- derekp7 9y agoIf you purchased the device from Google, and they locked you out, couldn't you sue them in small claims court? That would at least force them to respond, and if they don't they would get a default judgement against them. If it is possible / likely that a court would hear the case, would your only option then be to sue for monetary damages, or could you sue for them to perform an action (such as reinstating your account)?
- politician 9y agoThe consumer likely "agreed" to this treatment in the TOS/EULA.
- leggomylibro 9y agoYeah, but EULAs don't supersede actual laws. You can't sign over your firstborn child in a EULA, yet.
- dvt 9y agoWhether or not you agreed to a TOS/EULA is irrelevant. It's for a judge to decide whether or not locking you out of your account (rendering a piece of hardware you purchased nigh worthless) is legal.
- notheguyouthink 9y agoPreviously everything of mine went through Google. Email, phone, phone number, search, etc. I've migrated everything away (except Google Voice) for this very reason. My life would have came to a grinding halt if they banned me, and I couldn't even email them about it.
- busterarm 9y agoWhat was your gmail alternative? I tried to switch everything to Lavabit, but then a month later the Snowden thing happened...that didn't last (and I'm still out all that money)
- jakebasile 9y agoFastmail has been wonderful for me.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoI bought my own domain and have Zoho host my email. I have not had any hiccups at all. They support exchange, so I get push on my phone, which is nice. I set up my gmail to fwd any straggling emails to my new email.
- Zetaphor 9y agoI'm going through the same process, and am currently enjoying ProtonMail.
- notheguyouthink 9y agoAh yes, this is the encrypted email provider I saw on HN a while back (I mentioned in another comment of mine, but at the time forgot the name of ProtonMail). When it's time for email renewal, 1 or 2 yrs down the line, I'll be looking at ProtonMail :)
- narrowrail 9y agoIf most people you email with use Gmail, what's the point of an "encrypted email" provider? Why not just use PGP and stay with your current provider? Thunderbird+enigmail is the way to do meaningful encryption and it is provider agnostic.
- nickysielicki 9y agoNot a concern for 99.999% of people, developer or not.
- jellicle 9y agoDo you mean that people aren't concerned, or shouldn't be concerned?
- nickysielicki 9y agoBoth. I don't think anyone (reasonable) should be concerned and I think most people, developer or not, are not concerned. This is just yet another example of this vocal minority on HN that regularly talks shit about every Google hardware product, where the argument against this specific product actually comes down to a larger argument against Google and how much access and gatekeeping they have with regards to your computer use. What irritates me is that this is Google's core business and if you're not interested in Google products because of that, then who the hell cares what you have to say about this product? It's like if Google launched a volleyball net and the top comment was something like, "Well, I don't have a house or a backyard and so I won't buy this because I won't have space for it!" Well then clearly you weren't going to buy this product in the first place, so what use is your opinion here? Why would Google make a laptop that has nothing to do with the rest of their business? Is the parent comment suggesting that Google should make a general purpose laptop that doesn't integrate with Google accounts? On top of all of this, it's not like the laptop becomes a brick in the event that your account would get locked. You can still use it in incognito mode, albeit without Android apps and such. Furthermore, doesn't this exact same argument apply to Windows 10 with a live.com account login, and Apple with iCloud account logins? Seems to me like the privacy zealots seem to come out stronger against Google.
- daxorid 9y agoI don't think you fully understand the risk model the "vocal minority" is talking about. It's not so much that Google might know about our searches for horse porn, it's that we could lose access to our entire digital life at the whim of an algorithm or a politically motivated employee. As others have pointed out, Google has capriciously cut off account access to numerous people. When they do that, you lose your email account, which is the de-facto access key to a very large number of other accounts. This is to say nothing of the documents, spreadsheets, photos, PURCHASED movies and music associated with that account. Bear in mind the Jordan Peterson case, on which Google has yet to answer, is only one we know about due to its high profile nature. How many other users without access to the ears of the media get rolled over in similar manner? When any other entity chooses not to do business with you, they don't show up to your house and make off with your DVD and CD collection, the home movies of your kids, as well as contents of your filing cabinet and a good number of the backup keys you have for other accounts. The parent is not worried about PRIVACY, they are worried, rightly so, of LOSING THEIR DIGITAL LIFE on a whim of a third party. The probability is low, sure, but the impact is very high. Evaluating risk is not just about likelihood, but also impact. The obvious objection, that one should use G Suite from a domain name they control, and do hour-by-hour snapshot backups of every document and photo they host with Google, is a fair one, but it puts the user in a position in which the very value Google services offers -- convenience -- is no longer there. So what's the point?
- guelo 9y agoThe laptop wouldn't become inaccessible, the account would. You could log in with a different account.
- pwython 9y agoBut all of your data would be inaccessible, as it's associated with the (banned) account...
- victorhooi 9y agoThanks for bringing that up. However, te truth is often a bit more nuanced (although it doesn't make for as good headlines). Dissecting your three examples. In the first case, (and based on their own statements) those people were buying up phones by the hundreds, shipping them to a single physical address and then scalping over the internet. It's basically fraud. So yes, they probably got picked up by an automated algorithm that looks for hijacking/CC fraud or bot-nets. From public statements though, I believe most of them got their accounts back when they reached out to confirm they were real people and not some fraud bot-net. It's still technically violation of their ToS, but I won't comment on that part. The second case I'm not directly familiar with, and there's no public statements so I won't say anything further. In the third case, the affected customer made a public statement afterwards: https://twitter.com/salilstatistics/status/899863971817238528?lang=en https://twitter.com/salilstatistics/status/89986397181723852... I can't comment any further than what's been said publicly except on general principles 1. Google does a lot of things to protect users from external attacks, everything I've seen seems to indicate they really do care about users, and 2. There are pretty clear ways to get back into your account should anything happen (https://accounts.google.com/signin/recovery https://accounts.google.com/signin/recovery is your one-stop shop), and 3. The user doesn't carry any ill-will towards Google once he realised what actually happened. (Disclaimer: I work for Google, but the above statements are my own and do not reflect those of my employees).
- tehwebguy 9y agoPerhaps there was something specific about that specific instance that made it fraud, but reselling a phone isn't fraud by default. Not interested in needing to beg a horrible algorithm or become internet famous just to get ahold of a human that might turn my digital life back on.
- victorhooi 9y agoI'm only speaking in general terms here, not specifics. However, reselling phones is usually against the ToS of pretty much every retailer. This isn't unique to Google. Here are our ToS - https://store.google.com/intl/en-US_us/about/device-terms.ht.. https://store.google.com/intl/en-US_us/about/device-terms.ht.... > You may only purchase Devices for your personal use. You may not commercially resell any Device, but you may give the Device as a gift. Recipients of gifts may need to open and maintain a Google Payments account in order to receive any support offered by Google. These Terms apply to any gift recipient. I'd like to see you walk into an Apple store, and buy 10 iPhones. Or say, 100? In fact - Apple even introduced controls to stop scalping of Genius Bar appointments: http://www.idownloadblog.com/2013/09/12/apple-store-genius-b.. http://www.idownloadblog.com/2013/09/12/apple-store-genius-b.... Or say you create 100 email accounts - john001@gmail.com, john002@gmail.com, john003@gmail.com etc. - and have them each buy a phone, and ship them to a single physical address. It's certainly possible to see how this would come across as hijacking or botnet fraud.
- gressquel 9y agoBy using chromebook, you are almost giving away your entire digital life. Such data will be abused by Google to sell ads, as it has happened many times before. What a horrible piece of privacy abusing junk this Chromebook is.
- ballenf 9y agoA lot of these will be used by businesses on paid GSuite accounts where the monetization of user data doesn't happen: https://gsuite.google.com/security/ https://gsuite.google.com/security/ I think $5/mo per person in exchange for some degree of privacy and being the customer instead of the product is a reasonable deal. $10 for unlimited storage. In addition that price gets you 24/7 live support from a real person. I'm not suggesting this answers the general privacy concerns and other issues presented here.
- kuschku 9y ago> A lot of these will be used by businesses on paid GSuite accounts where the monetization of user data doesn't happen: YET. GMail also launched without ads and datamining. Google retroactively added it, without opt-in, and mined all your data later anyway. If Google can physically access something, you have to assume they will data mine and publish it at some point.
- daxorid 9y agoThe real utility in this device is to flash with coreboot and install Linux, not to run client endpoints of Google's horrible services.
- earlybike 9y agoWhat’s the solution? 1. Spread all activity on multiple mail accounts? 2. Get a G-Suite account + own domain, so in a case of a lock out you just change the MX records? Option 2 is expensive for a lifelong private account and 1 is cumbersome. Any other ideas?
- jlarocco 9y agoI'd consider buying one, but first thing I'd do is wipe it and install a regular Linux.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoReplace ChromeOS with a free Linux distro!