49 ms·
Facebook Lies
- Artemis2 9y agoQuite looking forward to GDPR forcing Facebook to actually remove all records they have on me. It’s a pain to implement for businesses, but it’s ultimately the right move.
- nathantotten 9y agoAt least for European customers. This won’t help everyone.
- gberger 9y agoHow is "European customer" defined? If someone is not European but resides in Europe, do they have this right? If someone not from Europe travels to Europe and issues the request while inside Europe, do they have this right? (If so, would using a VPN work?)
- nieksand 9y agoI recently went to a GDPR seminar and the presenter claimed that GDPR applies to everybody physically in the EU (even tourists while they are passing through).
- adtac 9y agoIf that's actually the case, I can see a Deletion-as-a-service business. "We thoroughly delete your account for you." The fact that I have to come up such mechanisms is a damning indictment of the way things are.
- AckSyn 9y agoThere used to be a service like this for facebook and twitter, then those two services blocked them from doing so. Which was sad, but it ultimately worked well for everyone who ended up using it before the ban. It would untag you from photos, delete your comments, wall posts, photos, information, change your name, and issue a deletion after changing your password (and emailing that to you).
- davesque 9y agoI really don't get why AckSyn's comment was marked dead.
- eesmith 9y agoGDPR = https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regula... > a regulation by which the European Parliament, the Council of the European Union and the European Commission intend to strengthen and unify data protection for all individuals within the European Union (EU). It also addresses the export of personal data outside the EU. The GDPR aims primarily to give control back to citizens and residents over their personal data and to simplify the regulatory environment for international business by unifying the regulation within the EU. Emphasis mine. Full text at http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32016R0679 http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:320... . > The protection afforded by this Regulation should apply to natural persons, whatever their nationality or place of residence, in relation to the processing of their personal data. This Regulation does not cover the processing of personal data which concerns legal persons and in particular undertakings established as legal persons, including the name and the form of the legal person and the contact details of the legal person. The specific clause concerning customers appears to be: > In order to determine whether such a controller or processor is offering goods or services to data subjects who are in the Union, it should be ascertained whether it is apparent that the controller or processor envisages offering services to data subjects in one or more Member States in the Union. Whereas the mere accessibility of the controller's, processor's or an intermediary's website in the Union, of an email address or of other contact details, or the use of a language generally used in the third country where the controller is established, is insufficient to ascertain such intention, factors such as the use of a language or a currency generally used in one or more Member States with the possibility of ordering goods and services in that other language, or the mentioning of customers or users who are in the Union, may make it apparent that the controller envisages offering goods or services to data subjects in the Union. Regarding non-resident visitors, I can't tell. The directive says "whatever their ... place of residence" so almost certainly yes. It also contains text like "data subjects residing on its territory" so you might have problems lodging a complaint if you aren't a resident.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThe US needs to grow some backbone and pass equivalent privacy (and antitrust, while they're at it) laws. If something is a certain way in both the US and EU, most tech companies won't bother doing any differently worldwide.
- _jal 9y agoIt isn't a matter of backbone. Legislators are simply representing the interests of their customers, such as Experian and Facebook.
- kristianc 9y agoGDPR refers to any business that transacts with the European Union, so businesses outside the EU (and the UK) are included.
- nneonneo 9y agoHave they always had such a 14-day policy? If not, it’s entirely possible that the policy was different when the account was previously deleted, and the account was being retained under that old policy. I’m also surprised that his hacker didn’t bother changing his password - maybe it wasn’t intended to be an account takeover.
- Insanity 9y agoConspiracy theory: It was facebook pretending to hack is account so he would log back in and hopefully stay using the service. But OT: I'm sure that unless they are legally forced to remove the data, they'd rather keep it.
- ydt 9y agoI briefly had a Facebook account years ago before deciding I didn't like it. I deleted/deactivated my account. About 6 months ago I received an email saying that 'someone' had reactivated my account and that if it wasn't me I should log in and visit the help center. My old password still worked and there had been no activity. I strongly suspect this was an attempt by FB to get me back on board.
- imron 9y agoI deleted my Facebook account in 2009 and they had a 14-day policy at the time also.
- adrianratnapala 9y agoWell when I "deleted" my account years ago, Facebook made it absolutely clear that it was really only deactiviating the thing and that it would retain its records. Nonetheless, as far as any of my friends can tell, I am no longer on Facebook at all. So maybe the author of this post removed his account at an earlier period when Facebook didn't make such an honest claim. In that case the title should be "Facebook used to lie."
- mikeash 9y agoThe help page about deactivating or deleting (they are two separate actions) makes it quite clear that your data will be gone, not merely rendered inaccessible, when you delete: https://www.facebook.com/help/250563911970368 https://www.facebook.com/help/250563911970368 That page uses the phrase "permanently delete[d]" multiple times, says there's "no option for recovery," and calls out some information they do keep because it's not actually part of your count, implying that the rest is not kept.
- brownell 9y agoDid you even read the comment you replied to? Years ago they did not delete accounts. They would deactivate it and never delete the data. They do now (apparently), but in the past they were very openly not deleting anything.
- mikeash 9y agoYes, I read it. I took it as meaning that they either read something else which was unclear, or just deactivated the account, or misremember what Facebook said at the time. Do we know that Facebook actually deletes accounts now?
- andrepd 9y agoI'm really really hoping regulators get their act together and come down hard on this sort of things.
- bojan 9y agoIf you live in the EU, do a search on GDPR.
- benevol 9y agoWho expects anything different, really, from companies like Facebook?
- alecco 9y agoMost people don't even think about the consequences until it's too late. It's a new kind of problem.
- fancyfacebook 9y agoThis happened to me as well when I signed up for spotify under the same email I used for facebook, was shocked to see my ~six year old deleted account suddenly become "reactivated" despite them claiming it was "deleted" at the time. Nope, all the stupid stuff that was hilarious to post in 2007 was still there and came right up. Turns out they never delete anything.
- spirit556 9y agoHuh? It's always been this way. Like more than 10 years ago I messed around trying with account deactivation. I've had a fb account since ~2004 it was only avail to certain colleges. This is exactly how it's always been. Am i missing something here? They never actually "delete" anything whatsoever. Isn't this already well known..
- EGreg 9y agoThis reminds me of the hilarious phonecalls trying to cancel accounts at other companies: http://time.com/2985964/comcast-cancel-ryan-block/ http://time.com/2985964/comcast-cancel-ryan-block/
- tomger 9y agohttps://m.facebook.com/help/delete_account https://m.facebook.com/help/delete_account states that it will delete your account permanently. Facebook’s current FAQ notes it’ll take about 90 days for your information to be gone from their system.
- Danihan 9y agoJust reactivated my 8 year old account and deleted it permanently. Long overdue!
- AndrewStephens 9y agoI wrote this several years ago - it is still true: https://sheep.horse/2013/10/the_seven_realities_of_social_networking.html https://sheep.horse/2013/10/the_seven_realities_of_social_ne... You do not have a Facebook page. You never did. Facebook has a page on you.
- mtgx 9y agoA dossier, if you will.
- Raphmedia 9y agoOne could almost call it a book of faces.
- dwringer 9y agoAt the time Facebook was created, there was a lot of talk about how private organizations already had such dossiers on the general public. Facebook is more like the "tip of the iceberg". At least it gives users some control over how they are presented (though less and less every day as they filter timelines and use our names to endorse their ads)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 659087 9y ago> And besides, they take nothing that you don't give them. This isn't true, at all. Facebook collects plenty of data that users and non-users don't directly give them.
- hardwaresofton 9y ago[EDIT] - I missed a key point, the author does say in the article that they deleted their account long ago. While I'm all for bashing Facebook when they do something nefarious, this seems more to do with someone else having the author's password and using their account at an inopportune time (during the FB account deletion process). As a refresher for all: - FB delete != FB deactivate - You can't log in (or let anyone else log in) for 2 weeks post FB delete through https://m.facebook.com/help/delete_account https://m.facebook.com/help/delete_account - The only way you can be sure they delete your info is if you're in the EU, where the government has stepped in appropriately. Facebook will very likely still know who you are, and have tons of information/"shadow profile" on you, because your friends will still post stuff there.
- stupidcar 9y agoHe explicitly says that he deleted his FB account "long ago". So this isn't about somebody interrupting the deletion process, it's about FB keeping the account around, ready to be "reactivated", even after the 2 weeks.
- nmg 9y agoI deleted (NOT deactivated) my facebook account in August. I received an event invitation three days ago. It's emotionally taxing; it feels vaguely threatening.
- Twisell 9y agoActually I think that an extra step is required to fully "delete" while the standard procedure only "deactivate" accounts. I've permanently delete back in 2014 but actually needed a "ghost account" in 2016 to access some FB walled garden content. I used the same email as my former one and data was gone, no restauration was proposed. (However friend suggestion based on email showed up due to some probable shadow account).
- intoverflow2 9y agoI did similar with a good 6 years between and with two different emails on different domains and it's friends suggestions both in it's own app and Instagram (not linked to FB account but sharing an email) manage to reference people I only ever knew during the time of the first account and never even interacted with on Facebook. e.g a guy I interned for 10 years ago who I never spoke to/added on FB keeps showing up in my Insta suggestions. It's actually a bit unnerving and makes me worry who my account is suggested to.
- bcoates 9y agoThose people probably have your email in an inbox Facebook slurped (possibly as a CC or something)
- trishmapow2 9y agohttps://haveibeenpwned.com https://haveibeenpwned.com Make sure that you don't have any insecure accounts or reuse passwords that have been exposed through breaches.
- IshKebab 9y agoReally annoyingly though they don't provide the hashes. I'd really like to know which passwords have been leaked. Does anyone know of a similar site that provides hashes? I don't need the complete list - just the hashes for my email.
- dublinben 9y agoWhat you're asking for is basically the full details of the data breach, which can be directly used to compromise accounts. You're not going to get that for free anywhere. You can check your own passwords (hashes recommended) through their new Password service. https://haveibeenpwned.com/Passwords https://haveibeenpwned.com/Passwords
- IshKebab 9y agoAh yes, type all my passwords into a third party network. I thought this was a site about good security. Also why wouldn't I get the full details for free anywhere? HIBP obviously has them. Criminals have them. I bet it isn't that hard to find them on bittorrent. In fact, here they are: https://hashes.org/public.php https://hashes.org/public.php Edit: Although that doesn't match them up with usernames, so it's not entirely useful. Edit 2: In fact I just discovered that a long password I used to use is still in the 'not cracked' category of the Last.fm leak (unsurprising since it is 13 random alphanumeric characters). That is useful information.
- Fnoord 9y agoI agree however then I reminded myself I shouldn't reuse passwords and ended up using unique passwords everywhere I remembered I reused passwords. A password manager makes it feasible to do that. Also enabled 2FA as much as I could (pref with an application on phone, otherwise SMS).
- SKYRHO_ 9y agoIt's been a while (6-8months) since I DELETED my account, but I do remember separate options for delete vs deactivation. Out of curiosity I tried logging in again and received "email you have entered does not match any account". While I'm sure the account exists somewhere in the facebook database, it appears to have been successfully deleted. Anyone else have similar results?
- 482794793792894 9y agoHaven't ever had a Facebook account, but I've encountered the deactivation-deletion dark pattern before, most recently on Twitch. I think, it's a matter of them being required by law (won't be the case in all countries) to have true account deletion, but then they try to deflect as many users as possible from actually deleting their accounts by having an account deactivation option and having it in a far more prominent place.
- tjr 9y agoI "deleted" my account in 2013. In 2015, I was working on something that required a Facebook account, and I figured I'd try logging in again to see if it was really gone or not. I got a response similar to yours -- seemed to really be gone.
- bmelton 9y agoI've tried (and failed) to delete my Facebook a couple times in the past, so this most recent go, when I quit using Facebook, I just quit using Facebook -- I uninstalled the apps from my phone, and mapped 'facebook.com' to localhost in my /etc/hosts files. The result was... amusing. Facebook kept emailing me the "Hey, did you see what so and so posted?" emails, knowing full well that I didn't see them. But then, after that, I started getting weekly reminders that "You haven't updated your timeline in a week". Facebook, ever the clingy ex-girlfriend it is, seemed to start amping up the frequency of the emails the more I neglected them, so I started just marking them as spam. Two blissful days went by in which Facebook wasn't a distraction, but then they shifted from email to SMS which, as an Android/Hangouts user, was even more annoying, since now I have to engage in multiple steps to delete. They really, really want me to use their service.
- yeukhon 9y agoI don’t see why that isn’t expected. Next time try deactivate it instead of uninstall the app, then there is an option to opt out communication. In your account settings, you can also opt out. I have not received a single email from facebook since then (although I am back on it again).
- bmelton 9y agoI did not expect them to ramp up the amount of notification spam 100-fold as I engage with the service less. I've no intention of logging back in to check my notification settings, but when I was using Facebook, I would get a push notification maybe once or twice every couple of days. Now, I get more than a dozen SMS messages a day. I've built notification systems in the past, and in every instance, respecting the fact that abusing the notification power entrusted to us by our customers was seen as a cardinal sin. Maybe it's the absence of that respect that has catapulted Facebook to where it is, or the presence of it that's held me back in my own endeavors, I don't know, but man, as the recipient of all this spam, it really, really feels unsavory, and further evaporates whatever trust I might have had in the platform.
- 9y ago
- chirau 9y agoThe closest thing you can do to deleting your account is actually manually deleting all your posts and albums first... the using their so called delete/deactivate option.
- nmg 9y agoTry it for yourself. After a number of deletions, response time will slow, an error will occur. You'll reload your page and items you thought were deleted, are not. I've tried many, many times.
- mathgenius 9y agoWow, this is like, part Twilight Zone, part Franz Kafka.
- ape4 9y agoWhat if you fill your Facebook profile with bogus info? Like writing random bytes on a drive to wipe it.
- gruez 9y agoThey probably keep a history on all the changes you made, so I doubt it would help
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 9y agoNo immediate deletion makes sense in that it would encourage hacking. But if they say 2 weeks it should be that. However, as someone else mentioned, the reality is you don't have a FB account, FB has an account on you.
- throwaway198411 9y agothis!
- vcanales 9y agoI'm not trying to defend Facebook, but I used the 14-day deletion and it worked for me. Just saying that there must be more to this story than just "I did it and Facebook lied to me".
- Kequc 9y agoI deleted my account there 10 years ago, about a year ago I needed an account to join a memorial group for someone. Facebook somehow knew that the email address I used to sign up with, which was new, was related to my old email address and tried to link my new account to my old data which was still there. It also still knew a heck of a lot about me including suggestions for people I had just recently met. And some of them I only met once, in passing, never exchanged info with, and never saw again.
- omnimus 9y agoThis is most disturbing. I remember big change in facebook policy on 1.1. 2015 that would mean that deleting your account would not delete data they had on you. Up to that point their policy was that after you delete, data about you is erased (at least in europe). I did delete the account before that date with few other people (mostly because of that policy coming). I never tried coming back but if they still kept all the data, that is pretty substantional. One could sue facebook for that or am i missimg something?
- Kequc 9y agoBefore I left I used a tool that would delete all of my posts and content and stuff like that. Cleaned up the profile as best I could. The type of data they had was more about who they thought I knew, how desperately single I am stuff like that. Given how many privacy related scandals they have had I don't think suing them is going to do anything.
- modeless 9y agoIt's likely that at the time they deleted their account (unspecified "long ago"), Facebook either did not have a guarantee of deletion of all data, or this person did not follow the process that would delete all data and are misremembering how they deleted their account. They are simply looking at the current documentation and thinking "oh yeah, I must have done that, and these guarantees were supposed to apply", when of course that isn't true if those guarantees are new, or if they never followed that procedure in the first place.
- lerie82 9y agoI was always under the impression that Facebook never deleted accounts, just "deactivates" then.
- vcanales 9y agoThe deletion is relatively new.
- skrowl 9y agoI deleted mine over 10 years ago. My wife (who still uses) said that people still click on the "wish happy birthday" shit for me every year.
- Xeoncross 9y ago> If it’s still not gone, I hear you can just post obscene and offensive material until Facebook deletes you. I’d rather not have to take that route though. I honestly never thought about that. Spammer accounts often are cleaned up pretty well.
- owly 9y agoI deleted my account years ago. At the time there was a web plugin which could be used to automate the deletion of all posts, pictures, etc. I wonder if there is a tool to do this now as I'm sure FB has cracked down on automated deletion of content.
- megous 9y agoI expected this, so I first deleted all posts, comments, events, whatever could be deleted, unfriended everyone, replaced everything that could not be removed with random strings, including my name and profile url, and then deleted the account. Even if it gets reactivated, it will be useless. It's annoying that this has to be done. There are several other well known companies that make account deletion a stupid hassle. Amazon for example should have already archived my account automatically after not being used for 7 years at all. Apple is another idiotic company that makes it hard to remove stuff from your account (you have to have a mac to disassociate credit card from your account, their web app doesn't allow it for no reason whatsoever (despite being able to add CC info there), only iTunes app on the mac can do it) Companies should think more about account removals.
- seizethecheese 9y agoThis would actually be a cool product. Could call it Facebook Discombobulator.
- megous 9y agoI believe there are some browser extensions to do this. I just wrote a few document.querySelectorAll() based loops in the console that artificially clicked the right elements in the right order with some delay. Fun thing is that while most things are very fats on facebook, deletion is super slow. It takes like 2 seconds to complete. They must have some artificial delay somewhere just to frustrate this kind of scripting.
- ksk 9y agoI think Google does the same with everything (email, web history, searches, ad profile, etc) but I believe their reasoning was that there is no way to guarantee that your data will be deleted from the backups, other redundant caches and whatnot, so they don't claim to be able to.
- kirbypineapple 9y agoI've been locked out of my facebook account for almost a year because they didn't believe I legally changed my name to "Captain Hook Pope Mobile". I sent my revised birth certificate, drivers license, everything. No response on the support ticket for 8 whole months...
- quake 9y agoWait a second. Don't tell me that you're actually the Captain Hook Pope Mobile
- kirbypineapple 9y agoCould there ever be more than one?
- dorfsmay 9y agoEven if you've never used Facebook, you have a "shadow" account, it is a well known fact. Every time somebody you know upload their contacts into FB, they link them with your shadow account, or create it if not already there, as a strong possible match. I have started to use Facebook recently as I needed an account for work so decided to explore a bit, my biggest problem with Facebook is that your "feed" is made up of things that your "friends" liked or posted etc... but in what seems a random order, and not all of them appear. One has to wonder what kind of weighting they apply to each post to decide if it will make it to your feed or not. Twitter has brought something similar recently, but at least you can disable it and get a sane timeline - Just tweeted about this today (check my profile for account).
- ino 9y agoThey also use those means to know your face to scan photos and ask people connected to that contact list to tag you in photos, so they know where you've been, even match them with events. They can fill your shadow profile with photos, location and time data. It's frightening.
- joncrane 9y agoYou can change the sort to most recent first, but the setting isn't sticky and the next day, it's back to the echo chamber, er, I mean, FB curated content.
- dorfsmay 9y agoWhen you set it as most recent then it switches to a very short timeline, and, again incomplete (judging from what you see as default). Indeed, curated content, which is very scary.
- ballenf 9y agoFB should keep a hash of details on people who have deleted their profile and opted out of tracking in order to prevent re-creating shadow profiles.
- alecco 9y ago
- odammit 9y agoI fell into the timeline where it was so easy to log in with Facebook that I auth’d to almost every site with it. Now I’ve got the “Facebook handcuffs”. Stop using Facebook and recreate accounts for everything or keep My account active. I know FB doesn’t care but I have my own little revolt I’ve staged. - unfriended everyone and added random people - swapped out my info (I know they still have it) - post some bs links and nonsense just to dork with any ML running against my account I wish more sites added functionality to sever Facebook auth from your account.
- faceboksukha 9y agoI deleted my account long time ago from facebook. Liars, cheaters, fake news and privacy violations you will found only from facebook. I really questioning whole company morals
- proofofstake 9y agoI am in this Kafka-esque situation where I try to get an account deleted that is not even mine. I don't have and want a Facebook account, but Facebook does not agree. I few years back I started receiving mail for an account that I never created. The name is not close to mine, but a silly sexual pun. I have mailed security and account support multiple times, asking for the account to be deleted, or decoupled from my email address, because I keep getting login attempt notifications and even friend suggestions. Just checking, and coincidentally the very last email is one for the Facebook account. "Hey, it seems you are having trouble logging in! Click here to sign in.". Yes, Facebook, someone, for whatever reason, is trying to log in to a Facebook account for 4 years now, and won't take no for an answer... "If this wasn't you, please let us know by clicking here". Ok, Facebook, this is not me, and it was not me the last 10 times I clicked that button. (I now assume, that this account is somehow being used to mine my social connections. Something like a public ghost account.) Timeline: 2013: Hi Fuck, you got more friends on Facebook than you realize! List of 6 people I know IRL. 2013: Hi Fuck, you have 1 friendship request. Log in to accept. 2013: Do you know [3 people I know]? 2013: Hi Fuck, Fuck placed something on your timeline and is waiting to see it. 2013: Do you know [9 people I know]? 2014: We've updated our Terms of Service 2015: Someone asked a new password for your account. 2017: Hey Fuck, it seems you are having trouble logging in. 2017: Hey Fuck, it seems someone tried logging into your account from a new location. 2017: Hey Fuck, we received your request to reset your account password. XXXXX is your reset code. 2017: Fuck, go back to Facebook in just one click. 2017: Hey Fuck, it seems you are having trouble logging in.
- uniformlyrandom 9y agoI have the same thing, but with PayPal. My full namesake has created another account, and used my email there - so I guess he is not getting any notifications. I am afraid to contact PayPal support, since they might just go ahead and block the wrong account, or both of them, so I just ignore these emails from parallel universe. I was able to shut down a couple of Instagram accounts that were using my email though. Instagram does not verify emails, but fully trusts them to reset your password.
- tomsthumb 9y agoIf corporations are people why not file a restraining order?
- redbeard0x0a 9y agoYou gotta work within the system, I like the idea...
- thebigspacefuck 9y agoI'll have to try this. One of my biggest regrets was deleting my Facebook account sophomore year of college when I moved schools. A lot of pictures and memories erased. I moved away so a huge part of my connection with my old life was gone. It would be amazing to get them back.
- lazzlazzlazz 9y agoThis person deactivated their account but didn't delete it. That's all there is to it. How is it possible this reaches so high up Hacker News? None of you have seen users (or yourselves) make similar mistakes?
- mrlyc 9y agoI kept getting email messages from Facebook after I deleted my account. They stopped after I lodged a complaint with the Australian Communications and Media Authority. It enforces the Spam Act (2003) which prohibits the sending of unsolicited commercial electronic messages with an Australian link, i.e. if it originates or was commissioned in Australia or originates overseas but was sent to an address accessed in Australia.
- thetoddfather 9y agoThis near exact scenario happened to me today. I had disabled Facebook about 3 weeks ago. For good measure, I went ahead and deleted all apps, history, or any method by which I might wander back. Needless to say I was a bit thrown off this morning by the slew of “welcome back to Facebook” texts from my friends. I assured them somebody had created a false account, but sure enough there I was seemingly alive and well with an active profile. The only explanation I can think of is that an application or service attempted to authenticate via Facebook connect- if this is enough to reactive an account, it damn well shouldn’t be. Given that social media has overtaken reality for most, it feels a lot like a company unknowingly took my life and ran with it. It’s a bit eerie to scroll through a feed of your friends trying to reach you, and living your life without you. For a few days, Facebook was a more believable authority on my life than I was.
- AmrEldib 9y agoNetflix also does this. I unsubscribed and many months later subscribed again only to find that all my everything was exactly the same. They never deleted my account. With regard to Facebook, not exactly the same thing, but in August, I tweeted that I haven't logged in to Facebook in over a month. The next day, I got an email from Facebook asking if I'm having trouble logging in to Facebook. I never gave Facebook my Twitter account. https://twitter.com/AmrEldib/status/899423898139148289 https://twitter.com/AmrEldib/status/899423898139148289